MURDERED: Jessica Chambers

Transcript

Speaker 1 Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One Bank guy.

Speaker 1 It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast, too.
Oh, really? Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply.

Speaker 1 See capital One.com/slash bank. Capital One NA member FDIC.

Speaker 3 20th Century Studios presents the upcoming comedy, Ella McKay, from Academy Award-winning writer-director James L.

Speaker 4 Brooks.

Speaker 7 Emma Mackey plays Ella McKay, an idealistic young woman who juggles her family and work life in a story about the people you love and how to survive them.

Speaker 9 Featuring an all-star cast, including Emma Mackey, Jamie Lee Curtis, Jack Loudon, Kumale Ninjani, Iowa Deborey, Julie Kavner, with Albert Brooks and Woody Harrelson.

Speaker 5 Ella McKay.

Speaker 6 In theaters December 12th.

Speaker 1 The holidays are the most wonderful time of the year. To save with Racketon, use Racketon to get cash back on gifts for everyone on your list.

Speaker 1 From toys to kitchen gear to electronics, cash back is automatically added to your account and you can get paid with gift cards, PayPal, or check.

Speaker 1 Join for free today and get a new member bonus after minimum qualifying purchases. Go to racketon.com, download the app, or install the browser extension.
That's R-A-K-U-T-E-N.

Speaker 1 Terms and conditions apply. Hi, Crime Junkies.
I'm your host, Ashley Flowers.

Speaker 10 And I'm Britt.

Speaker 1 And the story I have for you today is is of a young woman whose life was not only taken too soon, but in a way that can only be described as cruel and truly downright evil.

Speaker 1 In a small town in Mississippi where everyone knows each other, it is a mystery how no one knows a thing about this girl's murder.

Speaker 1 Or maybe the real mystery is why no one is coming forward with what they know.

Speaker 1 This is the story of Jessica Chambers.

Speaker 1 At 8 p.m. in December, Heron Road in Cortland, Mississippi is dark and desolate.
There aren't any other cars coming or going.

Speaker 1 So when two guys in the lone car on that stretch of road drive up to the scene of a fire on the side of the road, they know it's up to them to tell someone. And this isn't just like a little thing.

Speaker 1 They could see flames from far off. And when they get closer, they understand why.

Speaker 1 There is an entire car just straight up engulfed in flames. Now, luckily for them, this story takes place in 2014, so they can just call 911 on their cell phones.

Speaker 1 And a few minutes later, the Cortland Volunteer Fire Department arrives on the scene. Now they get to work putting out the fire, trying to get it out quickly so it doesn't spread to the nearby woods.

Speaker 1 The car is kind of up this like small embankment and it is, like I said, blazing. But that is not what the craziest part is.
All of a sudden, a woman comes walking out of the woods on fire.

Speaker 1 Or at least that's what some of the reporting claimed. I mean, some later suggests that she's just badly burned.
And when I say badly burned, I mean like fully charred.

Speaker 1 But either way, she is in a bad state. She looks like she's naked except for a pair of underwear.
Her hair is singed and she is like walking towards first responders with her arms stretched out front.

Speaker 1 But they can tell every move is a struggle for her as she calls out what sounds like help me, help me. I mean, it is an an awful sight.

Speaker 10 And something that's going to haunt them forever, I'm sure.

Speaker 1 100%.

Speaker 1 But what's even more shocking is that some of these first responders know who this girl is. I mean, they don't recognize her, obviously.

Speaker 1 I mean, truly, she is so bad that they wouldn't have known if they were related to this victim. But once they get to her and they ask her her name, she says what sounds like Jessica Tambers.

Speaker 1 And immediately first responders know that they're talking to 19-year-old Jessica Chambers. How though? Cortland, Mississippi is like, when I say small, 500 people small.

Speaker 1 Plus she'd recently graduated from high school and she was known as a former popular cheerleader.

Speaker 1 So reporting by Teresse Apel, who extensively covered Jessica's case, says that they are like, they're with her. They know who she is now.
They're trying to keep her awake.

Speaker 1 They're like rubbing her sternum. They're like trying to keep her talking.
even though it's hard to hear what she's saying, not only from her extensive burns.

Speaker 1 I mean, like literally flesh has been burnt away, but also because of the noises that are being made trying to put out the car fire around them. I mean, there's equipment, there's hoses.

Speaker 10 Right.

Speaker 1 But the one thing they ask her is probably the most important question, like, who did this to you? And she is able to give a single first name, Eric. Or maybe it was Derek.

Speaker 1 But many of the first responders who were around her are so convinced that what they heard her say was the name. Eric.
Again, it's hard to hear. So they go get her a pen and a paper.

Speaker 1 They're like, hey, can you write this down so we can be sure? Only she can't write. Her skin is so badly burned, she can't even move it.

Speaker 1 I mean, forget holding a pencil, like she can't move her hands or arms at all. At this point, Jessica is losing consciousness and they can only press so much.

Speaker 1 Their main focus has to be like keeping her alive until this helicopter gets there to airlift her to a hospital that has a burn unit.

Speaker 1 And it is then in the middle of this chaotic scene that a man walks up.

Speaker 10 Aren't they in like the middle of nowhere?

Speaker 1 Yeah, this is a very rural road. So I can't imagine first responders are like expecting foot traffic.
Now, apparently, this guy that walks up doesn't say a word.

Speaker 1 He's just like staring in the direction of Jessica's car and the woods. And first responders ask this guy to leave because they're obviously like, this is an active crime scene.

Speaker 1 Like, please get the heck out of here. And he can even see Jessica nearby, like on the ground.
And so then the man just kind of like walks off.

Speaker 10 Did they bother to ask him if his name rhymed with Eric before they sent him off?

Speaker 1 No, and this is just like a blip in the reporting, but people bring it up. And I thought that crime junkies would want to know about it.

Speaker 1 Because to me, it's just so weird that he walked up on this row. Yeah.

Speaker 1 But, you know, the fire, the scene around, it's causing a scene. Maybe that's why.
But they send him off.

Speaker 1 Things are moving so fast that first responders don't really have the time to worry about this guy, much less his name.

Speaker 1 Like they're probably just thinking like he's some nosy passerby trying to get a better look at the scene.

Speaker 1 And to your point about asking him his name, I don't know like who heard her say the name versus who sent this guy packing.

Speaker 10 Right. There's a bunch of people on the scene.

Speaker 1 Right. I mean, in fact, source material doesn't even say if he walks down the dark road.
I don't know if he gets in a car. Like they don't make mention of a car, which is why I'm saying he walked up.

Speaker 1 But it doesn't matter. Everyone's preoccupied.
I think the only thing first responders can focus on is Jessica herself in that moment.

Speaker 1 Now she holds on long enough to be flown to the hospital and for her family to come see her. But early the next day, which would have been Sunday, December 7th, 2014, Jessica passes away.

Speaker 1 Now, in the fresh throes of grief, Jessica's mom, Lisa, still has to go talk to police as a witness to help them try and piece together Jessica's whereabouts the day before.

Speaker 1 And what she ends up telling detectives is that yesterday, this would have been Saturday, Jessica got a call or a text sometime between like 5 or 5.30.

Speaker 1 She got up and told her mom that she was going to go grab some food, clean out her car, and she left.

Speaker 1 And when she wasn't back after a little while, Lisa texted her asking her, you know, where did you go? Like, did you go, where did you go wash your car?

Speaker 1 Because like it was taking longer than she expected. But she doesn't get a response.
So Lisa calls her. And then Jessica doesn't pick up.

Speaker 1 But a little before seven, Lisa finally does get a call back from Jessica. And it's kind of strange.
Like Jessica says she'll be home soon.

Speaker 1 And she's like, I promise I'm going to clean my room, which is something she said she was going to do for a while. But Lisa couldn't shake the feeling that something was wrong.

Speaker 1 Like something was off about the call. It had been super almost eerily quiet when she was on the phone.
Like there's no road noise.

Speaker 1 There's no one in the background, no music, nothing, which was very out of the ordinary for Jessica. She always had something going on in the background.

Speaker 1 But this call she has, it lasts a little over a minute. And by 8.07, that's when detectives know 911 got the call about the car fire.

Speaker 10 Could they tell when the car had been set on fire? Like, was it right before the 911 call or?

Speaker 1 I mean, at this point, they're not sure. It's looking like it was pretty close to when the call was made.
So obviously there is this gap. There's more to fill in.

Speaker 1 Like, well, first of all, who texted her? Like, who did she encounter? Where did she go? Right.

Speaker 1 And because evidence was probably contaminated or even fully destroyed in the fire, local police know that they're gonna need all the help they can get.

Speaker 1 So while they start pulling records, they're sending off what little evidence they can pull from her car. They decide to also call in the big guns.

Speaker 1 By Monday, a full task force is set up to investigate Jessica's murder. The FBI is there, ATF, the Mississippi Bureau of Investigation, along with the U.S.
Attorney's Office.

Speaker 1 They're all helping Panola County Sheriff's Office. And on the same day, there is a new discovery in the case.
Jessica's car keys have been found on the side of the road.

Speaker 1 Now, they're found in a yard a little ways down the road from Jessica's car, which is great news because it means that they aren't totally burnt to a crisp.

Speaker 1 And if someone touched those keys, they might be able to get DNA off of them. So they send those off to be analyzed with the rest of the stuff.

Speaker 10 What is the rest of the stuff? What all did they initially find, send off?

Speaker 1 Not much. No.
So they had Jessica's phone in like pieces near her car. I think they're hoping to get like some data, maybe a better read on her exact movements from nearby cell towers.

Speaker 1 I think they had some charred clothing that they sent off for analysis. Maybe like a piece of a bra, but they can't even say for certain.

Speaker 1 Like, again, they're just like collecting maybe things and sending them off. Right.
Anyways, this DNA stuff is going to take a minute.

Speaker 1 So So in the meantime, detectives go look through surveillance footage from the gas station that Jessica's mom said she went to after leaving her house.

Speaker 1 And she did go there just like she said she was going to. I have seen the footage online.
And this seems like a small little setup. We're talking like just a couple of little pumps.

Speaker 1 I'm actually going to send you the video so you can see what I'm talking about as I kind of walk you through it. I've got mine too.
So.

Speaker 1 So if you see, she like pulls up and she starts walking towards the door to go inside of the store.

Speaker 1 But then before she even gets to the door, all of a sudden she turns to the side, like something or someone caught her attention.

Speaker 1 Like, I don't know if you can see, it's a little fuzzy, but it looks like maybe she like waves to some, she puts her arm up. I don't know if she's waving.

Speaker 10 Yeah, I don't know if I'm like actually seeing this or if my mind's just kind of like putting it there, but it almost looks like she smiles too.

Speaker 1 I know it's hard to tell. And there's no sound on these.
So we're missing that piece.

Speaker 1 But right after she, you know, puts her hand up, waves, maybe smiles, whatever, she walks out of frame in the direction of the person or whatever caught her attention.

Speaker 1 She's off camera for a few minutes before she comes back in from the same way. And then she goes inside to the store to pay for gas.
And luckily, there's a camera in there too.

Speaker 1 And there are a couple of guys that we see inside, but they don't really even interact with her, like much less even like talk to her. They don't seem to even be looking in her direction.

Speaker 1 She pays, no biggie. Then she goes back to her car alone and then drives off.

Speaker 10 And I assume we have no other cameras that pick up that area that had the person she was waving to.

Speaker 1 Of course not. I mean, there are actually other cameras.
There's another one outside and another one inside from what I gather, but we don't have the actual area that she walked to.

Speaker 10 So lucky or intentional?

Speaker 1 That's the right question. And they won't know until they find the person that she talked to that night, which should be easy, right? In a town of 500 people, it wouldn't be hard to get word out.

Speaker 1 Like, hey, were you the one she chatted with come forward help us fill in the gaps so what detectives do next is they literally start tracking down every eric and or derek in panola county oh yeah and they even the surrounding counties they're trying to build a database of people who have those names And they do find two Erics that are directly connected to Jessica through her Facebook page.

Speaker 1 But just as quickly as they find them, they say neither guy is the one that they're looking for. Like one they rule out, but don't specify how.

Speaker 1 The other they rule out by looking at, I guess, his cell phone records. I don't know what exactly they're looking at.

Speaker 1 I'm hoping it's location data, stuff like that, saying like, you know, all it says is using cell data. They can't connect him to Jessica on the night of the murder.

Speaker 1 I'm hoping they're not like, he just didn't call her, but, you know, whatever. Right.

Speaker 1 But either way, ruling these two out doesn't deter detectives because shortly after, a Derek pops up on their radar and he has an interesting connection to Jessica.

Speaker 1 You know those gifts that make everyone go, wait, where did you get this? Well, those gifts come from JCPenney. Yes, JCPenney.

Speaker 1 JCPenney has gifts for that person in your life who is impossible to shop for. You know the one, the friend who buys themselves everything, or the family member who swears they don't need anything.

Speaker 1 Sorry, not this year. From diamond jewelry to the newest gadgets, JCPenney has gifts that look expensive at a fraction of the price.

Speaker 1 I did all of my holiday shopping for my daughter through JCPenney Online. I got the exact things I was looking for at stellar prices.

Speaker 1 And she is going to lose her little mind when she realizes I found the perfect frozen sneaker to replace the ones that she grew out of.

Speaker 1 We have been looking everywhere for them, and I had no idea they were just waiting for me at JCPenney.

Speaker 1 With prices up to 60% off during JCPenney's Black Friday sales, it is the perfect time to fill your cart and throw in a little something for yourself too.

Speaker 1 It's guilt-free, the way holiday shopping should be. Shopjcp.com.
Yes, JCPenney.

Speaker 10 Hi crime junkies. Whether we're piecing together clues or creating episodes, Ashley and I make important connections thanks to another partner in solving crime, T-Mobile 5G Home Internet.

Speaker 10 With T-Mobile Home Internet, getting set up and online is never a mystery. Plug in, power up, and in 15 minutes, you're connected.

Speaker 10 With their fast feeds, we can deep dive for answers and stay in the know. And don't worry about surprise endings.
Your great price won't change for five years, guaranteed.

Speaker 10 I rely on T-Mobile 5G home internet every day, but especially first thing in the morning when I go to check my email and inevitably find an email from Ashley with a brand new exciting case she's discovered and already started totally deep diving on.

Speaker 10 With T-Mobile 5G home internet, I know I can open a new search tab and start digging in right away too. Visit t-mobile.com slash home internet to check availability.

Speaker 10 Guarantees monthly price of fixed wireless 5G internet data. Exclusions like taxes and fees apply.
Service Service delivered via 5G network speeds vary due to factor affecting cellular networks.

Speaker 10 Guarantee exclusions and details at t-mobile.com slash home internet.

Speaker 1 Derek Holmes is a 22-year-old man from Cortland who was first brought to their attention by one of the initial people they interviewed.

Speaker 1 Now, this person says that Derek was acting strange with Jessica, always trying to contact her, almost like saying they were harassing her and just overall doesn't seem like a good dude.

Speaker 1 And when detectives look him up, they see he's been to prison for exploitation of a minor and is a registered sex offender in Cortland.

Speaker 10 So this guy's checking all the boxes.

Speaker 1 So they bring Derek in for an interview. And when they ask him where he was and what he was doing Saturday night, December 6th, he tells them he was at home rubbing his mom's feet.

Speaker 10 Yeah, like we all do on Saturday night, Ashley.

Speaker 1 And listen, he says his mom has a diabetic condition that requires him to rub her feet every night. He's actually maybe being a good son.
And when detectives go talk to his family, they vouch for him.

Speaker 1 Of course. And there were apparently some other people around the house that day to confirm that he never left the house.

Speaker 10 Okay, cool. So show me the cell data.
Right.

Speaker 1 So they go, they do. They pull his cell phone data from that night.

Speaker 1 And he might be telling the truth because there is nothing that can connect Jessica and Derek to the same place and the same time of her murder. So.

Speaker 1 While a promising leader first, for the time being, Derek is off their potential suspects list.

Speaker 10 And if they're doing all this comparison, they have her records back by now, right?

Speaker 1 Yeah, it's fuzzy. I don't know exactly when the cell phone records come back, but at this point, detectives have interviewed a ton of people and gotten reports.

Speaker 1 And so here's what they're piecing together. So it turns out that Jessica had spent some of the morning with her friend Keisha and a guy named Quentin.

Speaker 1 And they just kind of like rode around together doing, I don't know what, until about noon when the two girls drop Quentin off at his house. At some point, they split up.

Speaker 1 Jessica goes back home where she spends the afternoon napping, hanging out until she gets that call. Remember her mom said between 5 and 5.30? Yeah.
Well, it's actually at 5.20 from Quentin.

Speaker 1 Now she doesn't answer, but she calls him back, which is when she leaves for the gas station.

Speaker 1 She apparently tried calling and texting Keisha, presumably to meet Becca, but Keisha's phone had run out of minutes, so she couldn't get a hold of her. Ah, the good old days.
I know.

Speaker 1 So at 5.24, investigators say Jessica shows up on the surveillance footage at the gas station where I already kind of walked through. She walks off screen, she buys her gas.

Speaker 1 And just like a quick aside, I kind of caught this when I was looking at it. If you actually watch the surveillance footage, you can see the time stamp of 624.

Speaker 1 So like I got like deep in the weeds questioning the entire timeline, but the more I actually looked into it, the more I think it could have just been a daylight savings thing because everyone was supposed to set their clocks back an hour just the month before and maybe this one just hadn't happened.

Speaker 1 And everything I've seen in the court records, everyone says that happened at 524. So I have to to think that's what's up.
And I know that they observed daylight savings there.

Speaker 1 So anyways, we see her pump her gas. And by 5.29 p.m., she's leaving the gas station and calling Quentin again, which I don't think he answers because then he calls her back at 5.34.

Speaker 1 Now, her phone pings near a home in Cortland right before 6 p.m.

Speaker 1 Whose house?

Speaker 1 It's more of like an approximate area. I don't know that they can.
like pinpoint it to a specific house and they're still working on narrowing it down.

Speaker 1 But after that, she goes to Batesville, which is like five miles north of Cortland. And she was only at that place for about 10 to 15 minutes.

Speaker 1 Now, detectives know this is more of a business area that she's at, but they don't go into detail about where she might have gone, nor do they share if she was with anyone during this time.

Speaker 1 And in an article for the Clarion Ledger, detectives somehow get access to a, quote, privately owned video source.

Speaker 10 So like a ring camera type thing?

Speaker 1 Maybe, but wherever this is, or whatever this video is and wherever it's from, it shows Jessica in her car driving back to Cortland shortly before 6.30.

Speaker 1 Now, this is when we're getting closer to like her calling her mom. So her phone records show that she's still trying to get a hold of Keisha during this time.
Obviously, it's not working.

Speaker 1 Shortly after 6.30, her phone pings back in the area close to the gas station that she was at before. And it seems to just be like sitting in this spot.

Speaker 1 She tries one more time to get a hold of Keisha. And when she couldn't, that's when she calls her mom, Lisa.
That's exactly at 6.48 p.m.

Speaker 1 And that is the last call or text that went through on her phone because a little after 7.30, her phone pings from the location that she was found at by first responders on Heron Road.

Speaker 1 And her phone officially turned off when investigators believe it got too hot from the fire. And that would have been at 8.04.

Speaker 10 And I'm assuming detectives have already talked to and cleared Keisha and Quentin?

Speaker 1 Essentially. So according to ID's murder mystery episode, Keisha and Quentin were interviewed by investigators and even then by the FBI.
The FBI at least talked to Quentin at his house.

Speaker 1 And it basically seems like they aren't too concerned that they were some of the last people to hang out with her. I mean, Keisha was interviewed first.

Speaker 1 She pointed to Quentin being around too, and he was the one who told detectives that they should look at that Derrick Holmes guy.

Speaker 10 And during all this, have they gotten the forensic stuff back yet?

Speaker 1 Or are they still waiting on all that? Well, her autopsy is complete, which shows her cause of death was thermal injuries and soot and smoke inhalation.

Speaker 1 It's also determined that her burns had a splash pattern to them. Oh.

Speaker 1 Which indicates that she was, I guess the way they like could see everything, she was sitting in her car when someone poured some type of accelerant over her body and then set her on fire.

Speaker 1 Now, they're also able to find out what kind of accelerant was used thanks to the piece of what actually was bra or clothing that was collected.

Speaker 1 So that has come back and they determine that it was gasoline.

Speaker 10 And can they tell if she was naked before she was set on fire or did her clothes burn away? Leaving just like her underwear?

Speaker 1 Yeah, they don't explicitly say. And I don't know if that's because they don't know

Speaker 1 or if there's certain things they just don't talk about. And I don't know if this is related, but they also don't do a sexual assault kit during her autopsy.

Speaker 1 I don't know if physically like it was impossible or wouldn't have shown anything because of how badly she was burned.

Speaker 1 But to me, the way that she came walking out of the woods completely nude, except for having underwear, I feel like it's an immediate red flag. Yeah.

Speaker 1 Like, why would everything else burn away except for underwear? Exactly. Yeah.

Speaker 1 So there's this theory that starts to form among law enforcement at this point. They feel very confident that whoever did this worked alone.
Or if they had help, it was just from one other person.

Speaker 10 How do they know that?

Speaker 1 I'm not sure, but they believe this person is local and they don't think it was someone random or like just some kind of random thing.

Speaker 1 And considering how small this town is, it would make sense that it wasn't some random person just driving through town lighting girls on fire.

Speaker 1 Like the whole thing feels super personal and super thought out.

Speaker 1 Plus, in another article in the Clarion Ledger, something her family said that they heard around town was that someone was in the car with Jessica.

Speaker 10 And wait, with her like the whole time at the gas station too, or just later?

Speaker 1 No, after she left the gas station. So they say that they think whoever this person is was the one that poured gas on her.
And they even say down her throat and nose and then set her on fire.

Speaker 1 And And they also heard that she may have fought back before being knocked out because she had this huge cut on her head.

Speaker 10 Was that in the autopsy?

Speaker 1 Well, not that I saw. Like, take it with a grain of salt because this is what I'm saying.
It's like, this is what they're hearing. These are the rumors going around.

Speaker 1 And I never saw it brought up in any of the other reporting. So I don't know, but it's what they're hearing.

Speaker 1 So while detectives don't get any reliable forensic evidence from the autopsy, they do get some DNA back from the keys.

Speaker 1 Most of it's female, belonging most likely to Jessica, but there was some male DNA and actually more than one profile. The problem is they just don't know who it belongs to.

Speaker 10 Okay, but the natural person would be someone close to Jessica. Did she have a boyfriend?

Speaker 1 That depends on who you ask. So her family says no, and they don't know who would be holding her keys.
Now, is it possible that someone else would have?

Speaker 1 Like, sure, but there's no name that they're bringing up to them.

Speaker 10 Which makes the DNA more promising.

Speaker 1 Yeah, if they can find out who it belongs to.

Speaker 10 I mean, can they do a direct comparison?

Speaker 1 This is the problem. So the sample is so small.
We are definitely not talking about CODIS. I don't even know if it's big enough to do direct comparison.

Speaker 1 From what I can tell, they can compare in a way that they can rule people out, but they're going to have a harder time proving that someone is a match, if that makes sense with how little that they have.

Speaker 1 Got it.

Speaker 1 Which means that they're going to have to solve this the old-fashioned way by hitting the streets, talking to people, and keeping an ear to the ground, trying to figure out if any of the rumors floating around the small town have any merit to them.

Speaker 1 And this is when they start hearing some interesting things. Because even though her family said that she didn't have a boyfriend, word on the street is that she did.

Speaker 4 Brooks.

Speaker 7 Featuring an all-star cast, including Emma Mackey, Jamie Lee Curtis, Jack Loudon, Kumale Ninjani, Iowa Deborey, Julie Kavner, with Albert Brooks and Woody Harrelson.

Speaker 6 In theaters, December 12th.

Speaker 11 Planning a trip this year? Travel smarter and connect deeper by learning the local language with Rosetta Stone.

Speaker 11 With over 30 years of experience, Rosetta Stone's immersive intuitive method helps you live the language, not just memorize it.

Speaker 11 Choose from over 25 languages, including Spanish, French, Japanese, and more. Their true accent speech recognition technology gives real-time feedback to help perfect your pronunciation.

Speaker 11 No translations, just natural learning that builds from words to phrases to full conversations. Whether you have five minutes or an hour, you can learn anytime on desktop or mobile.

Speaker 11 Get a lifetime membership and unlock all 25 languages. Learn as much as you want, whenever you want.
Rosetta Stone, learn confidently, connect authentically. Don't wait.

Speaker 11 Unlock your language learning potential now. Listeners can grab Rosetta Stone's lifetime membership for 50% off.
That's unlimited access to 25 language courses for life.

Speaker 11 Visit RosettaStotcom slash pod50 to get started and claim your 50% off today. Don't miss out.
Go to Rosettastone.com slash pod50 and start learning today.

Speaker 1 Supposedly, Jessica was dating a guy named Travis Sanford at the time of her murder. Travis is actually serving time behind bars for burglary charges at the time.

Speaker 1 But it's apparently known around certain circles that Travis and Jessica didn't always have the best relationship.

Speaker 1 Even though he was incarcerated, he and Jessica would still talk on the phone and he was a very jealous guy.

Speaker 1 And it's never mentioned which gang he's connected to, but detectives hear that he is affiliated with one of the gangs in town.

Speaker 10 But just to be clear, he was in prison when she was killed.

Speaker 1 Yes, which is why they know it can't be him, or at least he could not have done it himself, which doesn't mean that he didn't have someone else do it. And detectives even go talk to him about that.

Speaker 1 But they say when they get there, he's like visibly upset when they tell him not only that Jessica had been murdered, but like how she'd been murdered.

Speaker 1 And based on his reaction and their conversation with him, he gets ruled out as a potential suspect.

Speaker 1 But even when confronted with this, Jessica's family still denies that she had a boyfriend or was ever in a relationship with this Travis guy. They say that.

Speaker 1 Even though she made some bad decisions, like it doesn't mean she's involved with any gang, which like seems to be what people are implying.

Speaker 10 What kind of bad decisions were they aware of?

Speaker 1 Well, I mean, it's no secret, I guess, within the community that Jessica struggled with substance use.

Speaker 1 Like she'd actually just gotten out of a recovery center designed to help her get her life back on track.

Speaker 1 But what her family didn't know was that, at least according to her friends, Jessica was selling drugs.

Speaker 1 In reporting by Sarah Fowler and Ron Maxi, it's Jessica's friend Keisha actually who claims that Jessica regularly sold marijuana like almost every day for the last six months leading up to her death.

Speaker 1 I don't know if that's real. I don't know.
I don't know what's real. I don't know what's rumor.
Like her family feels like the rumors about her kind of spiraled out of control after she died.

Speaker 1 And maybe they did, because I see places where Keisha alleges that she and Jessica often drove around and smoked marijuana. But that is a far cry from being a dealer.
Right.

Speaker 1 And apparently, like when they tried to push her, she wouldn't name names. She wouldn't say where Jessica got her supply.
So is she not wanting to like. snitch on people

Speaker 1 up the chain or is there nothing to back it up? You know what I mean? Right. But clearly the rumor mill is spinning, especially since Jessica's murder took place during peak Facebook.

Speaker 1 I mean, there's a large number of people online commenting, speculating,

Speaker 1 basically like virtual detectives trying to solve this crime.

Speaker 1 Reporting by Terrestrial says that hacktivist group Anonymous actually takes note of Jessica's death and starts digging up information on people they think are related to her murder.

Speaker 1 And the consensus kind of becomes that Jessica could have been a victim of domestic violence or maybe even something gang related.

Speaker 1 And Anonymous claims to learn this from hacking into different people's social media accounts, one being a former boyfriend of Jessica's and some of his associates.

Speaker 1 But detectives do their due diligence and check into these theories and basically say that there's nothing to prove any of these rumors to be true.

Speaker 1 But what's interesting about these rumors is that for Cortland being such a small town, there is actually a lot of gang activity.

Speaker 1 One gang that the internet sleuths believe is connected to Jessica's murder at the time is the Black Squad gang.

Speaker 1 After surveillance footage was released from the convenience store, people online started targeting the store owner's son, Ali Alsinaim.

Speaker 1 And they were saying that he was the leader of the Black Squad and that he used his dad's store to sell drugs.

Speaker 1 And they say that since he knows Jessica and he was one of the last people to speak to her, like he's got to be connected. All kinds of ridiculous claims that aren't backed by any factual evidence.

Speaker 1 Ali says in a documentary for Investigation Discovery about this case that it's just wild because he willingly gave police the surveillance footage from his store in hopes that it would help them track Jessica's killer down.

Speaker 1 But it almost just like backfired on him because he's trying to be helpful. And then all of a sudden he starts receiving death threats online.
People are avoiding coming to his store.

Speaker 1 And this prompts detectives to speak out again and let the public know that like, by the way, guys, Ali is clear. He's not even like a suspect at all in this case.

Speaker 1 Now, other rumors are floating around that Jessica could have been an informant, mostly because she hung out with people affiliated to certain gangs, but her father was a mechanic for the Panola County Sheriff's Department, which I think made some people uneasy, especially those who were leery around police officers.

Speaker 1 So they worried that somehow Jessica's dad maybe got her involved with the sheriff's department, which is why people around town started saying that Jessica was, you know, on the verge of outing some like big-time gang members.

Speaker 1 And to back that up, what I'll say is more reporting by Teresse Teresse Apel says that Jessica even told her mom, this is just a few weeks before her death, that here, I have a quote, hang on just a second.

Speaker 1 It says, quote, these bitches think I'm snitching and I'm not. And I guess when Lisa asked her, like, you know, what are you talking about? Who are you talking about?

Speaker 1 She just said, quote, nobody, mama, you don't need to know. So I don't know.

Speaker 1 what she was talking about, but the important thing to note is even that statement does not prove she was involved in anything or had anything to snitch about.

Speaker 1 So with no solid leads to follow, detectives watch as days pass and no new information comes to light.

Speaker 1 The next big hit that they get doesn't come until the fall of 2015 when detectives get more cell phone data that they start to analyze and like really start digging in.

Speaker 1 They're like hoping to pin down if Jessica was alone or with someone in those few hours. that she's really unaccounted for on December 6th.

Speaker 1 And what they get back doesn't give them any new names, but it does point them back to someone they've already talked to.

Speaker 1 So in the records that detectives get back, they're able to show that her friend Quentin, remember, the guy that she had hung out with, they're like calling each other on the day of the fire.

Speaker 1 So he was actually with Jessica at the exact same time she was murdered, which is not, yeah, not the story he told before when they wrote him off, before he says he was just with her in the morning.

Speaker 1 Now, this took so stinking long to get. I assume maybe what they did was like a cell phone dump or they were like tracking location data, not obviously not back and forth text.

Speaker 1 Like that was simple small potato stuff that they did in the early days. And we're almost a year out now, but they have something that they basically think proves he lied to them.

Speaker 1 So in November 2015, detectives go and they question 27 year old Quentin Tellis to see what his story is now. Problem is he's not in town anymore.

Speaker 1 He's actually in jail now in Monroe, Louisiana for debit card theft. So they have to go there.
And when they meet with him, they are really upfront with him.

Speaker 1 They tell him that, you know, while they know his original story was that he saw Jessica the morning of the day she was murdered, they now have cell phone data putting him and Jessica together on December 6th later than what he initially told them.

Speaker 1 And this time he's like, oh, you know, Yeah, I was with my buddy Big Mike. We rode up to Batesville together to meet Jessica.
We had to give her some marijuana, but like, that's really it.

Speaker 1 I really didn't see her after that.

Speaker 10 Never good when the story starts changing.

Speaker 1 No. And in the moment, I guess that explanation's good enough for detectives because the cell phone pings, they're not exact, right? So it is kind of plausible.
This is a small area.

Speaker 1 Maybe he's like meeting up with her, but not in her car. You know, maybe they'd be in the same area, whatever.

Speaker 1 So detectives decide what they have to do is they're going to go check this out with Big Mike.

Speaker 1 And when they bring him in for questioning, he says that he and Quentin weren't together on December 6th and they never drove to Batesville together.

Speaker 1 Yeah, he's actually got his own solid alibi to prove it. There was cell phone data putting him in Nashville at the time, and a friend of his claims to have been with Big Mike in Nashville.

Speaker 1 I guess they were watching like the Titans play the Giants or something.

Speaker 10 Which, to be fair, is a better alibi than being at home rubbing your mom's feet.

Speaker 1 Seriously, yes. So after checking out the alibis, at the end of January 2016, detectives head back to Louisiana to question Quentin again.
And what do you know? His story changes again.

Speaker 1 Of Of course it does. This time he tells detectives, like, okay, oh, wait, I must have misremembered.
I actually did ride with Jessica to Batesville sometime after 5.30 p.m.

Speaker 1 I was with her afterwards at my house, just not for long.

Speaker 1 And what detectives need to account for is the fact that Quentin was actually seen on security footage after Jessica's murder at this dollar store back in Batesville around 8.30 p.m.

Speaker 1 And so they ask him about this. And he says that he went back to buy a cash card for his girlfriend in Louisiana.

Speaker 10 Or he's trying to establish an alibi.

Speaker 1 Maybe that too. But as they keep talking, I think Quentin is getting paranoid because he just like blurts out that he and Jessica had sex just once, about a week before her murder, but not that night.

Speaker 1 Like for sure, not that night. Even though, by the way, like apparently when he blurts this out, like no one asked.

Speaker 1 And then he divulges some unique details about how they did it in her car, and they had to like lean the seat all the way back.

Speaker 10 And out of curiosity, what position was Jessica's seat in when they found her car?

Speaker 1 Nail on the head. Her passenger seat in her car was found laid all the way back.

Speaker 1 So that and the fact that she was only wearing underwear when first responders found her, they're thinking that maybe they did have sex, something went wrong, and then she was set on fire.

Speaker 10 But then where did the gasoline come from?

Speaker 1 They actually have a theory about this.

Speaker 1 So at some point, detectives learned that around 7.46 p.m., like very specific, Quentin made a call to his girlfriend in Louisiana and told her that he was going to walk to his sister's house to borrow her car.

Speaker 1 And detectives already know that there's a shortcut from Heron Road. This is where Jessica's car was found.
There's a shortcut that leads to his sister's neighborhood.

Speaker 1 And wouldn't you know it, it's along that route that someone had found Jessica's keys way back in the beginning. So they're thinking he went that way.

Speaker 1 got his sister's vehicle and then used that to drive to his own place where he kept a gas can in the shed.

Speaker 1 And because this is such a small town, you can't make this up. Like only in this story could this happen.

Speaker 1 But apparently the security footage from the gas station from earlier, not only is it capturing like the stuff with Jessica or whatever, but it actually points to Quentin's house of all places. What?

Speaker 1 I know. And you can pretty much see the like just the beginning of his driveway, not everything.

Speaker 1 And what they see is that around 7.50-ish, you can kind of make out a vehicle pulling into Quentin's driveway up to the storage shed near the front of the driveway.

Speaker 1 The car's there for like two minutes before it drives off.

Speaker 1 Now, you can't make out the driver or the tag from this footage, but they say that it's him and that he's going back to get the gas can because apparently he told them that he had that gas can way early when they like first talked to him and they weren't even interested in him.

Speaker 1 So because they learned about this forever ago and they weren't interested in that, obviously they didn't collect that gas can or check out this like super well back then when they could have.

Speaker 1 And now it's a little late. But this is their theory now.

Speaker 10 But if the video quality sucks so bad, how do they know it's Quinton in his sister's car?

Speaker 1 Apparently there's another camera at the gas station. I told you it had more than the one that we saw.

Speaker 1 And I guess that one had a better shot of the make and model of this car, which they say matches Quentin's sister's.

Speaker 1 So at 8 p.m., the video captures the car speeding past, I guess this like other one that they say they can see him in, speeding past, heading to Batesville, where detectives know now that Quinton was to buy that cash card for his girlfriend out of state.

Speaker 1 Right. So what detectives really want to get into next with Quentin are the string of text messages between him and Jessica.

Speaker 1 They had gotten access to their entire texting conversation so they can try and figure out why Quinton would even want to hurt Jessica.

Speaker 1 And they see that for four days leading up to her death, Quentin kept texting Jessica, basically asking her for sex.

Speaker 1 And every time she would let him down easy with some kind of like throwaway comment.

Speaker 1 And on the night of the crime at 7.42 p.m., which is likely right around or even right after the time Jessica was set on fire, Quentin's phone, they say it like wakes up. Was it turned off?

Speaker 1 That's not super clear. It just says it wakes up.
So I don't know if it was like in sleep mode or if it was off, but it wakes up. Okay.

Speaker 1 He calls and texts her and his messages aren't being returned, obviously. But then his text says, oh, hang on, let me read it to you exactly because I think it's important for stuff like this.

Speaker 1 It says, quote, Bae, my friend is coming over tonight. I'll call you tomorrow.
Good night. Sweet dreams.

Speaker 10 Is his phone pinging near where Jessica is?

Speaker 1 It's not. I'll get to that in just a second.
Okay. But what detectives can't get past is Quentin's lack of texts or calls to check on Jessica after word gets out that she's been seriously hurt.

Speaker 1 Now, I don't know that anyone knew she'd been fully set on fire at that point. People had just started to hear that she was severely injured.

Speaker 1 And what they're saying is that instead of of reaching out to her, it's just like radio silence.

Speaker 1 And then what really doesn't do him any favors is that once word got out that Jessica had died, and that happens on Sunday morning, you know what he does?

Speaker 1 He deleted all of the calls, all of the texts, everything

Speaker 1 between them. And he deletes her entire contact from his phone.
And when police are like, why would you do that? If you had nothing to do with this, he's like, well, she's not around anymore.

Speaker 1 Why would I keep a dead girl on my phone?

Speaker 1 Uh, okay.

Speaker 10 Did the police not know all of this when they first talked to him?

Speaker 1 So it turns out that they did know all of this early on. According to the limited series Unspeakable Crime, he had told the FBI about deleting everything, but I guess the agent never asked why or

Speaker 1 deemed it suspicious.

Speaker 10 Yeah, like, hey, like little red flag over here.

Speaker 1 I know, it wasn't until detectives were like actually talking to him in Louisiana that they wanted to know more about his logic behind it.

Speaker 1 And to be fair, I mean, everything is in a new light now, especially because when they go talk to him in prison, not only is he there for debit card fraud or whatever, the thing I didn't tell you is that the debit card theft is actually connected to a young woman named Ming Chen Shao who went by Mandy.

Speaker 1 And Mandy had been murdered. So Quentin had become a suspect in her case because of a weird string of events.
So I need you to back up with me a little bit.

Speaker 1 Mandy was an exchange student at the University of Louisiana Monroe from Taiwan. And on July 29th, 2015, she was stabbed 34 times in her own apartment.

Speaker 1 According to reporting by Sarah Fowler, a warrant filed said that she was stabbed by someone trying to get the pin to her debit card. And after her death, her card was used three times.

Speaker 1 Surveillance footage from the ATM used to take the money out of her account shows Quinton using her card.

Speaker 1 And apparently he'd used his own phone to call her bank and entered her debit card number and pin in. And after he was arrested, he admitted to using the debit card.

Speaker 1 Now, the whole reason they got to him was actually not by using the ATM footage and working backwards, my friend. No, no, no, no.

Speaker 1 So there is a guy that had come forward and said that someone he knew confessed to Mandy's murder. Again, this is like a totally different jurisdiction.
Yeah.

Speaker 1 He's like, this person knows the details about stabbing her and torturing her until she gave up her debit card pin. That's how they got to the affidavit.

Speaker 1 So everything we have in the affidavit comes from this guy.

Speaker 1 Well, according to Law and Crime, the man who came forward said that this person showed him the ID of the woman and then said, quote, that stupid motherfucker, Quentin, got caught using her debit card, end quote.

Speaker 1 And the guy this man is first pinning for Mandy's murder is not Quentin. Right.
It is a different guy. So detectives went, checked out that lead, found out it was a total lie.

Speaker 1 The guy he's pointing to couldn't have done it. So they go back and confront this original witness about it.
And he's like, yeah, I actually just want to frame that guy. Like, bad day.
Sorry, not him.

Speaker 1 Like, okay.

Speaker 1 Britt, this is the weird part. Guess what this guy's name is? Like, this witness.
Guess what his name is?

Speaker 10 Does it end with a rook?

Speaker 1 Frickin' Eric. Oh my God.
Let me introduce you to Eric Hill. And if things can't get more small town, Eric is a former boyfriend of Quentin's sister.
Oh.

Speaker 1 And she actually still has his name tattooed on her, by the way.

Speaker 10 So he's like solidly like within the circle.

Speaker 1 Yeah. And he is apparently key to giving law enforcement in Louisiana information about Mandy's death.
Because even though Eric and Quentin's sister aren't dating anymore, Eric is actually, you know.

Speaker 1 If

Speaker 1 you're still in the family? Yeah, if that line hasn't been covered. Yes, Eric.
Okay, so he is related to Quentin through marriage now.

Speaker 1 So in 2015, Quentin and Eric's cousin, Chiquita Jackson, they married actually on the same day Mandy's body was found. Oh.

Speaker 1 So, and I know that's a lot of names and you don't have to keep track of them all. Just know that Eric Hill has a lot of ties to Quentin.
That's the moral of the story.

Speaker 10 Again, firmly in the circle.

Speaker 1 Firmly in the circle. So.
After Eric flip-flops his story, detectives tell him they know he's related to Quentin's wife, spent a lot of time with Quentin.

Speaker 1 And weird, you know a lot of things about her murder that if this guy didn't tell you, question mark, how do you know? Right. And that's when Eric's story changes.

Speaker 1 He then says that he learned all of those details about Mandy from Quentin when they were trading their like quote-unquote war stories.

Speaker 1 But here's the thing about all those details he shared with detectives, like none of that stuff was public knowledge. And they know what he said about torturing her.

Speaker 1 And like, specifically, he talked about like small cuts that would inflict pain. They're like, that's something that only the killer would know.

Speaker 10 Which my question is, he knows all this because Quentin told him or he knows because

Speaker 10 he knows. Exactly.

Speaker 1 Except they don't seem to press on that. They're like,

Speaker 1 they basically like on a silver potter's like, here's your chance to connect the crime to Quentin. Would you like to? And he totally does.

Speaker 1 Even though there's no evidence from Mandy's case that connects Quentin to it. Just the calls to her bank and the ATM footage incriminates Quentin.
So for sure, he was using her cards.

Speaker 1 And there's also no forensic help in Mandy's case. But in Jessica's, they are able to develop four male profiles from the DNA found on her keys as things are getting better.
Okay.

Speaker 1 Again, it seems like it's still just exclusionary, and Quentin's DNA cannot be excluded from those.

Speaker 10 What about Eric's?

Speaker 1 This is the crazy part. They don't even seem to entertain that idea.
Like, I don't see anything about them looking at his.

Speaker 1 So when detectives, though, they go back to Quentin, they're like, why would your DNA be on her keys? And he's like, I've driven her car before, but I don't know if that helps anyone.

Speaker 1 Because, like I said, the sample is super small. So it's not like a definitive win for detectives.

Speaker 1 But with Quentin's changing story, he has actually provided them a more rounded look at the events of that night. And detectives are confident that they have a motive.
Quentin wanted sex.

Speaker 1 Jessica refused and things got out of hand.

Speaker 1 They theorize that he either knocked her out or thought he killed her, then left the scene, borrowed his sister's car, got the gas can from his shed, drove back, doused Jessica in her car and gasoline, then set her on fire.

Speaker 1 But here's the kicker. Detectives believe that Quentin didn't know Jessica was still alive when he set her on fire.

Speaker 1 He thought he was just going to get rid of the evidence. He didn't anticipate her being alive when first responders showed up.

Speaker 1 So they're saying he sent her that text about a friend coming over, like, I'll call you tomorrow, and then goes to establish an alibi in Batesville by buying that like cash card for his girlfriend or whatever.

Speaker 1 So detectives think they have a home run, but Quentin denies all of it. He says he was with her that night, yeah, but he wasn't with her around the time she was killed.

Speaker 1 But detectives just don't believe him. And in February 2016, he is indicted on capital murder charges by a special grand jury in Panola County.
And by July, he pleads not guilty.

Speaker 1 But it's not until October 2017, after some delays, that Quentin's trial begins.

Speaker 4 Brooks.

Speaker 7 Featuring an all-star cast including Emma Mackey, Jamie Lee Curtis, Jack Louden, Kumale Ninjani, Iowa Deborey, Julie Kavner, with Albert Brooks and Woody Harrelson.

Speaker 6 In theaters December 12th.

Speaker 11 Planning a trip this year? Travel smarter and connect deeper by learning the local language with Rosetta Stone.

Speaker 11 With over 30 years of experience, Rosetta Stone's immersive intuitive method helps you live the language, not just memorize it.

Speaker 11 Choose from over 25 languages, including Spanish, French, Japanese, and more. Their true accent speech recognition technology gives real-time feedback to help perfect your pronunciation.

Speaker 11 No translations, just natural learning that builds from words to phrases to full conversations. Whether you have five minutes or an hour, you can learn anytime on desktop or mobile.

Speaker 11 Get a lifetime membership and unlock all 25 languages. Learn as much as you want, whenever you want.
Rosetta Stone, learn confidently, connect authentically. Don't wait.

Speaker 11 Unlock your language learning potential now. Listeners can grab Rosetta Stone's lifetime membership for 50% off.
That's unlimited access to 25 language courses for life.

Speaker 11 Visit RosettaStone.com/slash pod50 to get started and claim your 50% off today. Don't miss out.
Go to rosettastone.com slash pod50 and start learning today.

Speaker 1 A lot of the prosecution's argument revolves around the cell phone data that's been at the forefront of this investigation and how they say it basically proves Quentin was lying about his whereabouts and all the time that he spent with Jessica on her last day.

Speaker 1 I'm going to be honest, I kind of lost the thread at this part. I think the jury did too, which is like an important piece if you're going to be a prosecutor or defense attorney.

Speaker 10 Right.

Speaker 1 Because the prosecution, they spend so much time getting into the details of the cell phone data using language like RTTs and Nilos to describe the system that they use to determine where a cell phone is located within the network, like what tower you're getting pinged off of when you use your phone.

Speaker 10 Lost in the weeds.

Speaker 1 I know, but here, here's the big issue that I was able to actually like glean from all this. Jessica had Verizon and Quentin had AT ⁇ T.

Speaker 1 So their phones were using two different systems to ping their locations. And while Jessica's location was pretty well tracked, Quinton's actually wasn't.

Speaker 1 His was more of a guesstimate that they used to basically place him with Jessica on the sixth.

Speaker 10 Wait, that's their smoking gun? That Quentin is kind of sort of in the same area as Jessica?

Speaker 1 Yeah. So it's not rock solid.
No. And another thing the prosecution has to overcome is Jessica's final statement that Eric did this to her.

Speaker 1 They bring a burn doctor that treated Jessica that night, and he says that her mouth and airways were so charred that there's no way she would have been able to speak like normal.

Speaker 1 They say it's highly unlikely that she said Eric or Derek with much clarity. But the thing I'll say.

Speaker 10 But she said her name almost right.

Speaker 1 Yeah, that was, yeah.

Speaker 10 I can't get past that. Like, I can't buy that she couldn't have said Eric.
There, if she said Jessica Tambers versus Jessica Chambers.

Speaker 1 I know. This all gets like kind of muddy.
And one of the first responders on the stand says that what they heard was more of like a e we, like, so a little muddier.

Speaker 1 Some say they didn't hear her say anything at all. But again, others are actually pretty adamant.

Speaker 1 But after adding doubt to the prosecution's cell phone data argument and then the fact that Quentin's name is nowhere close to sounding like Eric or Derek, the defense goes after the fact that Quinton was on camera back in Batesville buying that cash card when Jessica was set on fire.

Speaker 1 Even though the prosecution argues that he went to the store right after to basically set up his alibi. I mean, they're both using the same evidence to like argue different things.

Speaker 1 When the trial concludes, Teresse Apel reports that the jury deliberates for eight hours over the course of two days.

Speaker 1 And when they reconvene, their verdict is not what anyone in the courtroom expects. Now, in the state of Mississippi, the jury's verdict has to be unanimous.
There is no majority rules here.

Speaker 1 So what happens next stuns everyone. Apparently, the jury got confused by the instructions and they thought that if they were going to choose guilty, the vote had to be unanimous.

Speaker 1 But if they all couldn't agree that Quentin was guilty or not guilty, then it automatically meant that they had to go with a not guilty verdict. But that's not how it works in Mississippi.

Speaker 1 The jury's vote has to be unanimous one way or the other.

Speaker 1 So oh. Yeah, it's not a, it's not like, like, I think, I don't, I don't know.
Like, I think it actually would have been a mistrial.

Speaker 1 And in their mind, they're just like not guilty because they didn't understand.

Speaker 10 Because they didn't get the instructions. Yeah.
Just because you couldn't all agree on guilty, you still had to agree on not guilty, essentially.

Speaker 1 Yeah, which is like so wild, especially coming off of like the Karen Reed stuff with like, with the juries and the forms.

Speaker 1 Like it's wild to me that you could go through a whole trial like that and then say not guilty. And then if they're like, hey, we didn't understand.

Speaker 10 Like fumble the instructions and not be like, hey, why don't you just go back into that room and talk it out again?

Speaker 1 Yeah. But and luckily that's like kind of what they do here.

Speaker 1 Like before everyone leaves like again in karen reads everyone like left the courtroom and then they found out that there was confusion in this case it seems to happen they're in the courtroom so the judge like sends the jury back they're like you know you need to come to some kind of agreement just kidding verdicts not in yeah and not long after that they're back and they're like okay all right we have a unanimous decision this time all in agreement and our verdict is not guilty which is obviously not what the prosecution wants.

Speaker 1 So they ask for the jury to be polled in case there is still any kind of confusion. And it turns out they're still split.

Speaker 1 The jury still can't come to a unanimous decision if he's guilty or not guilty, which again, so freaking concerning that, like, you just got it explained to you. Did you not know?

Speaker 1 Are you just trying to go home? Yeah.

Speaker 10 How did, like, oh, so many questions.

Speaker 1 So the judge declares a mistrial on October 16th, 2017.

Speaker 10 Honestly, appropriate.

Speaker 1 And this split ultimately comes down, the split and the jury, to a few different things. One of them was her saying Eric.
Like the jury just could not get past that.

Speaker 1 But also, there is a racial component to this entire trial. Jessica was a young blonde white girl.
Quentin was in his late 20s and black. And Cortland, Mississippi has its own racial tensions.

Speaker 1 Even though the town is pretty split population-wise with black and white residents, there is still a racial divide within the community.

Speaker 1 And many individuals in the black community feel that the prosecution or like the whole system really was was just trying to pin Jessica's murder on a black man with a criminal history.

Speaker 1 Because like you said earlier, there is no smoking gun in this case. And just like the racial makeup of the town, the selected jury was also pretty split in half.

Speaker 1 Like the five not guilty votes were all from the black jurors. And the seven guilty verdicts came from every white juror plus two black jurors.

Speaker 1 But what I will say is this mistrial isn't the end for Quentin. He's still serving that five-year sentence for burglary.
So he is still kind of put away.

Speaker 1 And the prosecution has time to like put their case back together again. They gear up right away for a second trial.
And the second time around, the prosecution tries to learn from their past errors.

Speaker 1 They tried to keep the new jury from getting hung up on the Eric Derrick of it all, but the defense won't let them. They want them to not forget that the last thing she said is Eric did this.

Speaker 1 And they bring in their own experts who say that she could totally have said Eric. Basically, you don't need your lips for that.

Speaker 1 Like if you actually, I'm going to look like a fool, but if you're like,

Speaker 1 yeah, her lips burnt off, but they're like, she could have done it. So according to the defense, there is a chance she did mean to say exactly what she did.
Eric may be Derek.

Speaker 1 Now, their most valuable tactic at this trial for the prosecution is a brand new witness, this woman named Sherry Flowers, who says that she picked up a guy that was flagging her down on December 6th along Main Street.

Speaker 1 And this area is near where Jessica's keys had been found. And at first, she says she stopped because she thought the guy was like family, she knew him.

Speaker 1 She pulls over, realized she didn't actually know him. And this guy apparently never identified himself.
But detectives presume that this man is Quinton.

Speaker 1 And the long of the short of it is, like, I don't really understand why they bring her because they have her basically tell the same story.

Speaker 1 Like, she drops him off at the sisters, and their story is still the same. Sisters, like, he gets her car, goes to his house.
Right. I think they do this because

Speaker 1 maybe the timeline of having him walk to his sister's, yeah, was like too tight.

Speaker 1 So they fixed that, like bada bing, bada boom, with this. He hitches a ride, same old story, gets the gas can, you know, the rest.

Speaker 1 Now, at the second trial, the defense also questions the interview tactics used on Quentin, insinuating that he was likely coerced into changing his story because of the detectives' lies about cell phone data pinning him to Jessica's location and her murder that night.

Speaker 1 And what I'll say is, I watched some of the interrogation and

Speaker 1 he either, I don't know, he sounds so scared like an innocent man, or this man deserves an Oscar. And I don't, I don't know which it is.

Speaker 1 But the last thing that the defense really does is that they go after the fact that Jessica was involved in drugs in some way or another.

Speaker 1 And they say that that could have put her in danger with people other than Quentin. So I don't think they did that the first time around.
And I think they saw that as a mistake.

Speaker 1 Like clearly we need to, if not him, then who? You don't have to do that. But like clearly a jury wants that, they think.

Speaker 1 According to the Clarion Ledger, to back up the defense's claims and thanks to Jessica's phone data, the federal anti-gang operation was able to charge 17 people with different drug and gang related offenses, though none were ever suspected of her murder.

Speaker 1 So like that was going on, yes. But like, was it connected? I don't know.
Right. So now that they've got all the information laid out, they send the jury back to deliberate.

Speaker 1 And again, it takes a long time. 12 hours until they come back claiming that they do have an answer.
And their answer is that they are split.

Speaker 1 Six guilty and six not guilty.

Speaker 10 So the answer is another hung jury. Yeah.

Speaker 1 There's simply, they say, enough reasonable doubt that they cannot come to a unanimous conclusion. And so the judge has to declare another mistrial.
What does this mean for Quentin?

Speaker 1 Well, I mean, nothing in relation to Jessica's case, but he is still serving time for the previous charges, and he still has Mandy's case kind of looming over him in Louisiana.

Speaker 1 So in 2019, a grand jury actually indicts him on second-degree murder charges in connection with Mandy's death.

Speaker 1 And according to reporting by Ashley Mott, there is GPS info that they say puts Quinton's phone within 60 meters of Mandy's apartment on the day that she was murdered because of the calls that he made to her bank.

Speaker 10 Do detectives question Eric Hill about either case? I kind of feel like he's the biggest loose end here.

Speaker 1 I couldn't find anything in like any of the source material I have that talks about them talking to him, even though I personally think he should have been questioned.

Speaker 1 And like, okay, if we're gonna, if we're gonna use all this cell phone data to say that Quentin was around, like,

Speaker 1 yeah, what's his cell phone data look like? But they don't. Like, I think they just think of him as a witness.

Speaker 1 Except even that changes in 2020 when Eric Hill writes a handwritten affidavit recanting his testimony. And Brett, I'm actually going to have you read this.

Speaker 1 So this letter was published in the News Star.

Speaker 10 It says, quote, my name is Eric Hill Jr.

Speaker 10 I'm writing and filing this affidavit on my own free will to state on about May 11th, 2016, I, Eric Hill Jr., was pressured by Monroe Police to take the stand to make a false statement against Quinton Telles.

Speaker 10 Quentin Tellis never told me anything about a crime, and I I don't know anything other than what was put on TV.

Speaker 10 I, Eric Hill Jr., was charged with accessory to murder and was forced to falsely testify on stand against Quinton Telles by Monroe police or be convicted of murder, a crime I had no knowledge of that supposedly happened if I didn't take the stand against Quinton Tellis.

Speaker 10 End quote.

Speaker 1 So, I mean, this dude fully recants on some pretty serious details. Yeah.
And like I said, only the killer would know. Though, right?

Speaker 1 Like if we're saying, Quentin is saying his, his confession was coerced. We know how things can accidentally, intentionally get like fed.

Speaker 1 I don't know, but he's saying he actually didn't have any knowledge of what happened. He was just forced to take the stand in Quentin's debit card theft trial.

Speaker 1 But here's the thing about the affidavit that's really confusing to me. Reporting by Ashley Mott claims that the detectives do a handwriting analysis on this letter.

Speaker 1 And allegedly, it was written by both Eric and Quentin.

Speaker 10 What?

Speaker 10 I'm so confused. I was too.

Speaker 1 There's actually pictures of the affidavit. Sorry, the letter and the affidavit, there's pictures of this for like analysis.

Speaker 1 And so there's apparently like sections written by Quentin where it says like my name is, and then like I declare under penalty.

Speaker 1 But then Eric wrote out the actual part of him saying his testimony was false. And I have a picture of it.
If you want to see it, I can send it to you. Yeah.

Speaker 1 Oh,

Speaker 10 yeah. There's like two different kinds of handwriting.
There's almost like a fill-in-the-blank, my name is Eric Hill before all of this. Yeah.

Speaker 1 So I don't know if this makes it weirder or not, but apparently Quentin and Eric are both in custody at the same time and place.

Speaker 1 Like, I guess Eric had, by this point, he robbed a convenience store on Christmas Day in like 2019, and he'd been in prison since February of 2020.

Speaker 1 So I don't know what their end game is or if they're finally just like he's or Quentin's able to confront him and if he really was was lying, Quentin's like, listen, like, I penned this, like, you fill it out and like, you have to tell the truth.

Speaker 1 I don't know. I don't know.
But over the next few years, Quinton remains behind bars, waiting for updates on Mandy's case until November 2022.

Speaker 1 That's when a Louisiana judge actually dismisses the indictment, claiming that after much delay, Quentin's right to a speedy trial for Mandy's murder was violated.

Speaker 1 And under Louisiana law, if that happens, the defendant is to be released without bail.

Speaker 1 However, when Mississippi hears about his imminent release, they request a transfer to get him to serve out some outstanding sentences there.

Speaker 1 I don't really know what it's for, but Quentin gets transferred.

Speaker 1 And because he's now in Mississippi, his trial is removed, or his Louisiana trial for Manny's case is like just removed from the docket. Right.
And that's where Quinton is now.

Speaker 1 According to the Mississippi Department of Corrections website, he is anticipated to be released October 16th, 2027.

Speaker 10 I just can't get past the Eric of it all. Like, how are they going to have an Eric that's so closely tied to this person they're trying to pin this entire thing on and just not look into him?

Speaker 10 I mean, I need to know Eric's location on December 6th, 2014.

Speaker 1 I mean, I feel like if this case is done right, there's a lot more people we need to know about.

Speaker 10 Like, there are just like these offhand mentions of the guy she waves to, the guy who walks up during the scene. I mean, yeah.

Speaker 1 So, like, I know that they, like, the guy who walks up during the scene they basically kind of like just wave him off like rule him out the guy

Speaker 1 that she like waved at or whoever she like saw at the gas station they do identify that person also another like they say not involved but like again show me the self you did all this work on Quentin show me the other data I need more than they say he's not involved right right and what I really want so I mean I think there's plenty of other work that can be done to either prove Quentin did it or prove someone else could have done it or prove Quentin didn't do it.

Speaker 1 I honestly don't know.

Speaker 1 But the other question I have is like, I always want to know that the thing I couldn't find is like, what is Quentin's excuse about having the debit card? Right.

Speaker 10 Yeah. If he's not involved with Mandy's murder.

Speaker 1 Because, yeah, I mean, I will, I will admit. How did he get the card? Right.
That makes him look so guilty.

Speaker 10 Well, yeah, when you said all they have him on is using the card and selling the card.

Speaker 1 I'm like,

Speaker 1 all is

Speaker 1 kind of a lot. Don't get me wrong.
But like, in my mind, I'm like, like, if he were to say, like, someone who I might know or who's in my circle gave it to me, that's a whole different thing.

Speaker 1 But, but as far as I know, he hasn't said that. And, like, wouldn't wouldn't that have come up by now? I don't, but maybe not because it hasn't gone to trial.
I don't know.

Speaker 1 I think there's still so much, like I said, that can be done for this case. But the lack of forensic evidence is limiting, to say the least.

Speaker 1 Now, there's obviously one or more people out there who I believe know what happened. And so if that is you or someone you think you know, please come forward for Jessica's family, for Mandy's family.

Speaker 1 They deserve justice. So if you have information regarding Jessica's murder, you can contact the Panola County Sheriff's Department at 662-563-6230.

Speaker 1 Or if you want to be anonymous, you can call Crimestoppers, 1-800-729-2169.

Speaker 1 And if you have any information about Mandy's murder, you can contact the Monroe Police Department at 318-329-2600.

Speaker 1 And lastly, if you or a loved one wants to explore treatment for substance use, you can seek help by calling 211 or we'll link to their website in the show notes.

Speaker 1 You can find all the source material for this episode on our website, CrimeJunkiePodcast.com.

Speaker 10 And be sure to follow us on Instagram at Crime Junkie Podcast.

Speaker 1 We'll be back next week with a brand new episode.

Speaker 1 Crime Junkie is an audio chuck production. So, what do you think, Chuck? Do you approve?

Speaker 1 Hey, neighbor, celebrate the holidays with Birch Lane. Our timeless furniture and decor are delivered for free in days, not weeks.
It's classic style for joyful living.

Speaker 1 Shop Birch Lane, a Wayfair specialty brand at birchlane.com.

Speaker 12 Have you ever experienced something truly unexplainable?

Speaker 12 A moment that felt almost like a vivid dream, leaving you with a lingering sense of wonder, leaving you questioning everything you thought you knew?

Speaker 1 Perhaps it was a fleeting glimpse of something extraordinary, a chilling whisper in the dead of night, or an undeniable premonition that comes to life.

Speaker 1 I'm Yvette Gintile, and I'm her sister, Rasha Pecarrero.

Speaker 12 Each week on our podcast, So Supernatural, we partner with the one and only Ashley Flowers, host of the number one true crime podcast, Crime Junkie, to take you on a journey of the world's most mystical mysteries.

Speaker 1 Ready to explore the unknown? Join us every Friday for a new episode of So Supernatural, available wherever you listen to podcasts.