MISSING: Jennifer, Sidney, & Monique

Speaker 1 Appliances and home systems all tend to break down at some point, but with an American Home Shield warranty, you're covered.

Speaker 1 When your fridge is on the fritz or the faucet won't stop leaking, AHS will fix or replace covered parts of home systems and appliances no matter how old they are.

Speaker 1 Not to mention, as a benefit with select plans, you can video chat with live repair experts to help assess or fix the issue on the spot. American Home Shield.
Don't worry, be warranty.

Speaker 1 Get 20% off any plan at ahs.com/slash crime junkie. See ahs.com slash contracts for coverage details, including service fees, limitations, and exclusions.

Speaker 2 Saks Fifth Avenue makes it easy to holiday your way. Saks is where you can find everything from the perfect Chloe bag for your hard-to-shop for sister to a Prada jacket for a fancy holiday dinner.

Speaker 2 And if you don't know where to start, Sachs.com is customized to your personal style so you can save time shopping and spend more time just enjoying the holidays.

Speaker 2 Make shopping fun and easy this season and find gifts and inspiration to suit your holiday style at Saks Fifth Avenue.

Speaker 1 This is an ad by BetterHelp. I've come to realize that when it comes to reaching out to a friend who has been on my mind, right now is always the right time.

Speaker 1 As the days get shorter, BetterHelp encourages you to check on friends and yourself. With over 30,000 therapists worldwide, BetterHelp is one of the leading online therapy platforms.

Speaker 1 This month, don't wait to reach out. Whether you're checking in on a friend or reaching out to a therapist, BetterHelp makes it it easier to take the first step.

Speaker 1 Our listeners get 10% off their first month at betterhelp.com slash crime junkie. That's betterh.com slash crime junkie.

Speaker 2 Hi, crime junkies. I'm your host, Ashley Flowers.

Speaker 1 And I'm Britt.

Speaker 2 And the story I have for you today is the 25-year-old mystery of a young woman who walked out of her mom's house with her two young children, never to be seen again.

Speaker 2 But after decades of silence and literally during our reporting, the family got their first real tip in a long time, sparking new hope for answers to what happened to the trio all those years ago.

Speaker 2 This is the story of Jennifer Lancaster and her daughters, Sidney and Monique Smith.

Speaker 2 It's around noon on May 13th, 2000, when Vicki Lancaster starts thinking that something might be wrong.

Speaker 2 Her 20-year-old daughter, Jennifer, and her two little girls, Sidney and Monique, didn't come home last night. Jennifer's a single mom.
The three of them live with Vicki.

Speaker 2 And Jennifer relies on her mom for help, especially at night because Sidney is only 14 months old and Monique is a newborn. Like Jennifer gave birth to her just five weeks ago.

Speaker 2 In those five weeks, she has never gone MIA. So like I said, by noon, she knows something is up.
So she has Jennifer's younger sister, Jessica, call the father of her girls.

Speaker 2 He and Jennifer are no longer together, but they all live in Topeka, Kansas.

Speaker 2 And while he's not super involved in their lives, Jennifer's family thinks that, I mean, it's worth giving him a call anyway, right?

Speaker 2 But Monique and Sidney's dad says that he hasn't seen or heard from Jennifer, doesn't know where she is, doesn't know where the girls are. And the family does believe him.

Speaker 2 Vicki told our reporter, at this point, she starts thinking back to her last interaction with Jennifer the night before.

Speaker 2 And she remembers that she had one of the girls' quilts in a bag when they walked out of the door at 8 p.m.

Speaker 2 Like they'd all just gotten back home from dinner with Vicki's parents and Jennifer was headed out again.

Speaker 2 Vicki even asked her what she was doing with the quilt and Jennifer told her that she needed to take it to the cleaners, which was odd because they had a washer and dryer in the house, but at the time she didn't really question it.

Speaker 2 She's only questioning it now.

Speaker 2 So Vicki tries calling Jennifer's cell phone, but she doesn't answer. And as she's looking around for any clue as to where she might be, Vicki actually finds Jennifer's phone in the house.

Speaker 2 So she left it either accidentally or on purpose. But while the phone is there, she starts noticing a lot of other things that belong to Jennifer and the girls are not.

Speaker 2 The family had recently moved into that house. So a lot of the stuff that they had was still in boxes.
So Vicki hadn't really noticed before.

Speaker 2 It's one of those things you have to kind of like get into the details of.

Speaker 1 But she didn't see her moving like boxes in and out of the house, like just this quilt.

Speaker 2 No, no, no. Like if this stuff got moved out, it would have had to have happened earlier.
She doesn't know when and she doesn't know what it means, but it probably scares her a little to realize this.

Speaker 2 So she calls the Topeka Police Department at around 6 p.m. to report Jennifer missing.
And the police obviously have questions, right? Like they want to know what is missing?

Speaker 2 What is going on with her? What could have led to this disappearance? Vicki says Jennifer and her children and their belongings are all missing, like just like she'd found.

Speaker 2 But she tells police that she doesn't feel like Jennifer would just run off with the girls. Like the girls were so little and Jennifer had never been able to handle them on her own.

Speaker 2 I I mean, Vicki and Jessica were always helping her out with them, which makes sense to me. Like two kids under two at 20? Like, are you kidding me? I couldn't handle a newborn by myself at 33.

Speaker 2 So it does seem off that one day she would suddenly just run off alone with the girls. Now, Vicki says Jennifer is a bit rebellious and she has been mixed up with the wrong crowd for a while now.

Speaker 2 But she's not involved in drugs or anything like that, at least as far as they know. Only they do know that she does drink a lot sometimes.

Speaker 2 And the police basically tell her that while it looks more like she left on her own accord than not, they will still take a missing persons report for her and her daughters.

Speaker 2 But it's really here that Vicki and Jessica realize that for police, like taking the report and actually like doing the things they need to do to find her are very different things. Right.

Speaker 2 So Vicki and Jessica start a search for Jennifer themselves. They get flyers printed with a picture of Jennifer and the girls.
They start posting them all over.

Speaker 2 They even get people to help post them at truck stops across the U.S. I mean, it's 2000.
There is no Facebook. I don't even think I had a mice face then.

Speaker 2 Like, this is just the two of them trying their hardest to get the word out, hoping that someone, anyone, anywhere will come forward with a tip or a sighting.

Speaker 2 And in all this time too, Jessica had started calling other friends, right? She and Jennifer are pretty close in age. They know a lot of the same people.

Speaker 2 And for much of their lives, they did everything together. But everyone she is calling hasn't heard a thing.

Speaker 2 Now, it's important to note that Jessica says she and Jennifer were super close most of their lives, like I said, but Jennifer at times struggled with her mental health and she would distance herself.

Speaker 2 Vicki tried for years to convince Jennifer to get help, but she was never receptive to it. And her mental health declined even more when she got pregnant with Sydney.

Speaker 2 And then by the time she had Monique, again, five weeks before this, she was really struggling. So after Monique was born, Jessica said that Jennifer wasn't even showing interest in the girls.

Speaker 1 Which sounds a lot like postpartum depression. Right.

Speaker 2 I mean, the family doesn't know that for sure.

Speaker 2 But the fact that she was struggling like this, and now that all three of them are missing, it makes Vicki feel certain that something terrible is happening. She just has this dread sitting with her.

Speaker 1 Yeah, but one thing that doesn't really add up to me within the thinking that maybe she did something to herself and the girls is taking their stuff.

Speaker 1 Like, to me, that says that you're going going to live somewhere else, like, where you're going to need your things.

Speaker 2 Same. Like, again, I don't know what it means.
Like, there are contradictory things here, but all in all, people are just worried.

Speaker 2 And when weeks go by and they don't hear anything, they don't know what to think.

Speaker 2 So one day, like two weeks out, Jessica decides to head out with a friend to just drive around Topeka looking for any sign of Jennifer.

Speaker 2 I mean, I mean, this is literally a long shot, like needle in a haystack kind of thing, but like, what are you going to do at this point?

Speaker 2 But they actually do find something on this drive, and it's something big. As they're driving by this apartment complex, about 10 minutes from home, they spot Jennifer's car.

Speaker 2 Looking to grow, learn, or simply get inspired, with Masterclass, anyone can learn from the best to become their best.

Speaker 2 For as low as $10 a month, get unlimited access to over 200 classes taught by world-class business leaders, writers, chefs, and more. Each lesson fits into your schedule.

Speaker 2 You can watch it anytime on your phone or your laptop or TV or switch to audio mode to learn on the go. You can even download classes to watch offline.
And the impact is real.

Speaker 2 88% of members say masterclass has made a positive difference in their lives. Personally, I've been trying to redecorate my house.
It is just out of my wheelhouse. I can do a lot of things.

Speaker 2 I'm not good at this. So I did a masterclass from Kelly Wurstler on interior design, and it was so helpful.

Speaker 2 Masterclass always has great offerings during the holidays, sometimes up to as much as 50% off. Head over to masterclass.com slash crime junkie for the current offer.

Speaker 2 That's up to 50% off at masterclass.com slash crimejunkie. Masterclass.com slash crime junkie.

Speaker 1 Tis the season, cold and flu season that is. But this year, find symptom relief for less on GoodRX.

Speaker 1 With GoodRX, you could save an average of $53 on flu treatments and get discounts on cold medications, decongestants, and more. GoodRX is free and easy to use.

Speaker 1 Just search for your prescription on the website or the app, compare prices, and get a free coupon to show your pharmacist.

Speaker 1 Check GoodRX to save at over 70,000 local pharmacies nationwide, including Walmart, Walgreens, CVS, Publix, Kroger, and many more. Or get prescriptions delivered right to your front door.

Speaker 1 GoodRX is not insurance, but works whether you have insurance or not. And if you do have insurance, it could even beat your copay price.

Speaker 1 For savings on cold and flu medications or any other prescriptions, check goodrx. Go to goodrx.com/slash crime junkie.
That's goodrx.com/slash crime junkie.

Speaker 2 Jennifer's Jeep Cherokee is sitting in this parking lot of the complex. Jessica walks up to it to look inside and it's empty.
Now, Jennifer's car is typically pretty messy.

Speaker 2 Like Jessica told us it usually looks like a trash can.

Speaker 1 Her words, not mine. Okay, as someone with a trash can car, we do not take offense.

Speaker 2 Right. But the weird part is here.
So again, like she's got kids, whatever. Normally it's a hot mess.
But when she looks inside, it's clean and not just like tidy. It looks like it's been cleaned out.

Speaker 2 I mean, even the girls' car seats aren't there. And that stands out to her as super odd.

Speaker 1 Yeah, does this apartment complex mean anything to them? Like, did she know somebody who lived there?

Speaker 2 Not that Jessica knows of, or they probably would have checked it earlier, right?

Speaker 2 But she does plan on finding out for sure because she goes around the complex asking people if they have seen anyone resembling jennifer or sydney or monique but no one has which like none of this is making sense like we said why take your stuff unless you're planning to start over or go somewhere but you can't go somewhere without your vehicle right and like You're clearly still going somewhere, right?

Speaker 2 Or you wouldn't need the car seats.

Speaker 1 Right. Unless you had another car.

Speaker 2 Whose, though? Because Jennifer didn't have a second car. Hers was in fine working condition.
So there's no reason to like go buy a different car.

Speaker 2 And whoever left this car there took the keys with them, clearly, because none were left behind.

Speaker 2 So I don't know. At this moment, they're thinking maybe someone picked her and the girls up.
They left together. And Jennifer just left her car there,

Speaker 2 maybe temporarily. Like maybe she planned to return.
That's why she took the keys. But there's really no way of knowing.
At this point, Jessica knows she needs to call police.

Speaker 2 Like maybe they'll know what to do. So they show up, they check the car out, but that's like the extent of their investigation.
They don't process the car.

Speaker 2 They don't collect any fingerprints on the car. Nothing.

Speaker 1 I mean, it's kind of hard to stick with the theory that she like left on her own free will when her car is left behind and totally cleaned out.

Speaker 2 Yet they seem to. Like we FOIA the records for the police investigation so we could get details about how they were thinking about this, what happened, but that request was denied.

Speaker 2 Police wouldn't speak to us either because they said this is still an open case. So we really only know what Vicki and Jessica discovered on their own search for Jennifer and the kids.

Speaker 2 So because the police aren't taking the car, now the family has this to deal with. And because there are no car keys, Vicki has to go to the dealership.

Speaker 2 She has to get a new key made to move the car and she takes it back to Jennifer's grandfather's place where they just kind of leave it because i mean they don't know what to do with it and police are just like here you take it So, I mean, best they do is they just like hold on to it, hoping that Jennifer is going to come back and need that car one day.

Speaker 2 Now, at this point, Vicki decides that the best thing she can do to figure out Jennifer's movements or what's going on is to get Jennifer's phone bill because Jennifer is still on her plan.

Speaker 2 But what she sees is a little scary because she finds out that there have been no calls outside of calls to her.

Speaker 2 and Jennifer's grandfather that had been made from her phone in the entire week leading up to her disappearance. So this isn't really helpful.

Speaker 2 And whether or not it was intentional, TBD, we know the phone clearly wasn't used after she goes missing, right? Because the phone was still in the house.

Speaker 1 Yeah, but if she did mean to go off grid, she could have gotten like a burner or a prepaid phone to use. Like, not only like when she left, but even to plan her leaving.

Speaker 2 Totally. And I mean, it's 2000.
Cell phones aren't glued to everyone's hand like they are today. Like, forgetting it also seems totally possible.
But I mean, you're right.

Speaker 2 Like, it would have been easy to go buy a prepaid cell phone still, even in 2000.

Speaker 2 And it's maybe even what is most probable. Because at this point, even Vicki starts thinking that, okay, maybe Jennifer was planning on leaving, right?

Speaker 2 We're not seeing any sign of her communicating with someone else. Like she's leaving with the quill.
Some of her stuff is missing that she had to have siphoned out of the house at some point.

Speaker 2 Like maybe she really did just decide to go because the longer Jennifer has been missing, the more time she's had to just go over and over and over in her head, like what has happened before she left the house that night and though at the time she told police that jennifer wasn't really acting differently like she's realizing now that she kind of was acting a bit odd in the week leading up to her disappearance she told us that that whole week jennifer brought the girls to have breakfast with vicki at the hospital that vicky worked at which was out of the ordinary for sure, but like at the time, Vicki was just grateful for that time with them, right?

Speaker 2 Like she said, in that, those breakfasts, whatever, Jennifer was acting

Speaker 2 like like fine, but it was almost like she didn't want those meetups to end. And now looking back, she's like, that's super strange.

Speaker 2 Like, was this, I don't know if she was thinking, was this some kind of goodbye or, or whatever, but she starts thinking about what else was going on that week. What was different?

Speaker 2 And that was the week that Jennifer had gone back to work as a dancer at a popular gentleman's club in Topeka called Baby Dolls.

Speaker 1 And who was watching the girls?

Speaker 2 Jessica did that week. Okay.
Now, pre-baby, pre-Monique, she worked the night shift at Baby Dolls, but coming back, she was on days. So her mom's thinking, okay, maybe something happened there.

Speaker 2 And so she turns to Baby Dolls, which reportedly was known to be a little bit shady.

Speaker 2 Our reporting team actually got in touch with Jennifer's manager from Baby Dolls back in 2000. His name's Rich Christie, and he gave us more insight into like the vibe of the place.

Speaker 2 He called Baby Dolls a reputable establishment with a lot of high-end clientele.

Speaker 2 According to Rich, by the end of a good day shift, Jennifer could walk away with between like $250 to $300, which today has the buying power of about twice that much.

Speaker 2 So like not a small amount of money.

Speaker 1 But also not enough to start a whole new life with.

Speaker 2 Very true. But in talking to Rich, he wasn't giving any goods, just like, you know, yeah, weird she went missing.
Work was work.

Speaker 2 But then our reporter like really was like drilling in and asked the exact right question.

Speaker 2 Was there anyone at the club that week that Jennifer returned to work that stood out? And he says, you know what? Come to think of it, yes, there was this one man that he remembers.

Speaker 2 Rich said that the guy he was thinking of was maybe an attorney, maybe a doctor. Like he couldn't quite remember.
He just knows that this guy was, or at least seemed really successful, pretty wealthy.

Speaker 2 What he knew for sure was that this guy was from Florida and he was there getting treatment at a place called Menningers, which is this renowned mental health facility that used to be located in Topeka.

Speaker 2 Rich didn't remember the specifics of what the treatment was all these years later.

Speaker 1 How does that even come up in conversation at a gentleman's club? And bigger question, why is this man who's there for what I assume is like inpatient treatment even at a gentleman's club?

Speaker 2 How it came up, it seems like maybe he was spending a lot of time there. Again, I don't, I don't know.
And that's what I was going to say.

Speaker 2 Like, I don't know if he even would have told them exactly what the treatment was or whatever, but I know it was like an outpatient situation where he was free to kind of come and go during the treatment.

Speaker 2 But Rich said, like, dude was there a lot, even during the day shift when Jennifer was performing that week. And he would drop hundreds of dollars on the dancers.

Speaker 2 He made it apparent that he had a lot to offer. Rich says that after Jennifer disappeared, he came back to the club, this guy, a few more times, but far less frequently.

Speaker 2 And about a month or so after Jennifer had vanished, he also stopped dropping by the club altogether.

Speaker 1 And how long had he been going there before she went missing?

Speaker 2 He had been coming there for about like five or six months, according to Rich.

Speaker 2 Now, obviously, nothing ties Jennifer directly to this man. I mean, Rich doesn't remember him like singling Jennifer out or anything.

Speaker 2 He doesn't even remember him being creepy or off, just not part of like the usual crowd that you got. You know what I mean? So this guy involved or not.

Speaker 2 What this guy represents to Jennifer's family is the sort of people that she might be coming into contact with and that could have led to her disappearance.

Speaker 2 Because her family thinks that maybe Jennifer met someone in the club that promised her and her daughters a better life.

Speaker 2 Like the more time that goes by, the version that they hope played out was that Jennifer got her happily ever after, that she just wanted to stay off the grid ever since and the end.

Speaker 1 But why wouldn't she have just told them that?

Speaker 2 I don't know. Like maybe it goes back to the way her headspace was in that time, like her being distant.

Speaker 2 Also, even though Rich told us that Jennifer was a dancer, her mom said that she always thought that Jennifer was a waitress and that if she was a dancer, she could see that being something that Jennifer wouldn't have told her.

Speaker 2 So maybe Jennifer, if this is what happened, felt like her family wouldn't understand.

Speaker 2 Or if she wanted to get them to understand her leaving, she would have to tell them all this other stuff that she had never talked about before. Maybe she wasn't ready to open up that can of worms.

Speaker 2 But honestly, now, like that is best case scenario to her mom, that she started a new life. She's just out there with her girls, happy.

Speaker 2 Worst case scenario is that she was promised something great, but was met with foul play instead.

Speaker 2 So you can imagine how excited Jennifer's family is when a month or so after she and the girls vanish, this man.

Speaker 2 calls Vicki's home in the middle of the night and says that Jennifer was in Lawrence, Kansas, like 25 miles east of Topeka.

Speaker 2 This sighting of Jennifer was at a different gentleman's club, though it's unclear who actually saw Jennifer there.

Speaker 2 And Vicki didn't know the man that was calling or how he even got her number to tell her about the sighting, which is a little odd to me.

Speaker 2 And ultimately, it doesn't end up leading anywhere because when whoever like looks at this club, there's no sign of Jennifer there. at least when they go to look, if it was her at all, right?

Speaker 2 Like, so either she left or it never was. I don't know.
And we don't know who this guy was or how he got her number.

Speaker 2 So, without anything solid for the family to go off of, again, they're kind of just left with zero answers, zero leads, and just hope that Jennifer is out there somewhere.

Speaker 2 Then, a few months after that, Vicki gets another, I don't even know if tip's the right word, something

Speaker 2 happens that

Speaker 2 almost keeps this spark of hope going that Jennifer is out there. But what she gets that gives her that hope is super weird.

Speaker 1 Ever notice how convenience always wins? That quick coffee run turns into a $10 spina drop that's more disappointment than nutrition. Sound familiar? That's where cachava comes in.

Speaker 1 It's a whole body meal packed with everything the mind and body crave, without the guilt or the greasy bag.

Speaker 1 Each serving delivers 25 grams of 100% plant-based protein and comes in six flavors like chocolate, vanilla, chai, matcha, coconut acai, and strawberry.

Speaker 1 With every two scoops of cachava, you get 85 plus superfoods, nutrients, and plant-based ingredients.

Speaker 1 No artificial flavors, colors, or sweeteners, just clean, delicious fuel that fits a busy schedule.

Speaker 1 Cachava makes it easy to stop sacrificing quality for convenience and start feeling good about what's in the cup. It's fall, it's cooling down, it's the perfect time for my favorite cachava mix.

Speaker 1 A couple scoops of chai and some almond milk, and if you're feeling crazy, a splash of apple cider at the very end. In my opinion, it's pretty much the best thing ever.

Speaker 1 Your future self will thank you. Go to cachava.com and use code Crime Junkie for 15% off your next order.
That's cachava. K-A-C-H-A-V-A.com code crime junkie for 15% off.

Speaker 1 As the air turns crisp and the holidays draw near, comfort becomes the best gift of all.

Speaker 1 Quince delivers layers that last, sweaters, outerwear, and everyday essentials that feel luxurious, look timeless, and make holiday dressing and gifting effortless.

Speaker 1 By working directly with ethical top-tier factories, Quince skips the middlemen and offers prices 50% less than similar brands.

Speaker 1 I just got the coolest, sleekest, oversized blazer from Quince, and it has absolutely become my cold weather style staple.

Speaker 1 It goes with everything and truly is just the perfect piece to class up jeans in a t-shirt or add a cozy twist to a little black dress.

Speaker 1 And I swear, every piece I get from Quince is just as high quality and versatile. Step into the holiday season with layers made to feel good, look polished, and last from Quince.

Speaker 1 Perfect for gifting or keeping for yourself. Go to quince.com/slash crimejunkie for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns.
Now available in Canada too.

Speaker 1 That's q-u-in-ce-e.com slash crime junkie to get free shipping and 365-day returns. Quince.com slash crime junkie.

Speaker 2 So Vicki is checking her mail one day and she gets this thank you card and coupons in the mail from Steak and Shake.

Speaker 1 Midwest Classic.

Speaker 2 Listen, no one's complaining when you get Steak and Shake coupons. But here's the rub.

Speaker 2 Where she's getting it from, this steak and shake, she's never been to this steak and shake that is all the way out in St. Louis, Missouri.
This is like four and a half hours from Topeka to the east.

Speaker 2 And the letter was addressed to Jennifer, thanking her for the comment card that she left after dining there.

Speaker 2 So you better believe Vicki like runs to the phone, calls that steak and shake, asking if they still have that comment card that Jennifer allegedly wrote.

Speaker 2 They tell her no, like the way their system works is that once the card information goes into the database, the card is destroyed.

Speaker 2 And this breaks Vicki's heart because her one hope was getting her hands on that card to see the handwriting because she knows she would have been able to tell if it was truly Jennifer's or if it was like someone else and this was some kind of hoax.

Speaker 2 And they just like addressed it to Jennifer at Vicki's house.

Speaker 1 But that would be such a weird hoax. I know.
We've seen a lot, but I don't understand this one. And more than that, like if it is a hoax, it would have had to have been someone that the family knew.

Speaker 1 Like, how would they have her address?

Speaker 2 Her address.

Speaker 1 I know. Like, her name.

Speaker 2 I could, I could spiral. I have spiraled.
So she lived with her mom, right? Like, does someone have her driver's license?

Speaker 2 Is it someone that knew her? I mean, I know back in the day, papers would often print home addresses, but I don't think the papers were even picking up this case, really.

Speaker 1 Well, and like, who is in St. Louis getting a Topeka newspaper?

Speaker 2 You know, I keep coming back to a couple of scenarios when it comes to this comment card.

Speaker 2 So one, it was the person who did something to Jennifer, And this was like a sick way to drop a line that wouldn't be traced back. Is this the same person that called? I don't know.

Speaker 2 I just don't think a stranger gets anything from a hoax like this.

Speaker 1 Right, because you can't even like follow it through. And like strangers who do hoaxes usually like want to see something.
Yeah, like get something out of it.

Speaker 1 And they don't get anything out of this one.

Speaker 2 That's not to say people aren't sick and wouldn't, but unlikely to be.

Speaker 2 Or two, it was Jennifer filling out the card. Now, I wonder if that is maybe the last permanent address that she had and maybe the last one that she remembered.

Speaker 2 And so she just like wrote that down, never thinking that they would send a thank you card for a comment card. Like, I don't know who does that.

Speaker 2 People from the Midwest, but they don't call it who's your hospitality for nothing, even though it is St. Louis, whatever.
But like, you get me.

Speaker 2 The problem with this scenario, though, is she's alive and well. She left on her own.

Speaker 2 But what I know is that in all this time since, Jennifer and the girls, their social security numbers have never gotten any hit since they disappeared, which feels like it wouldn't be the case if they were out there just like freely living their lives and just didn't want to be contacted.

Speaker 2 And like, that's what makes her family the most nervous.

Speaker 1 What if it's both, but like not in the way you've laid out? Like, what if foul play is involved?

Speaker 1 So there is someone else, but Jennifer really did write the card and say she's with someone, like a trafficker or...

Speaker 1 a kidnapper and she can't write like help me so she writes this comment card with her old address to like signal to her mom that she's still out there.

Speaker 2 So this is like an option three that I keep like playing with in my mind. And actually that option that you laid out is one that I think Vicki, her mom, like believes most to be true.

Speaker 2 Because a huge fear for her and for her whole family is that Jennifer could have been trafficked.

Speaker 1 And if that's what actually happened, there's a huge possibility that the girls, I mean, they could have been taken away from Jennifer, given new names, different fake socials, ended up somewhere else, no one even knowing who they are.

Speaker 1 They were so tiny when they disappeared. They were literally babies.
I mean, my mind honestly even goes to like adoption fraud situation.

Speaker 1 Like, has anyone looked at what the motive would be if it were foul play? Like, who is the intended target?

Speaker 1 We keep talking about Jennifer because she's the one who had time to have a story around her, but maybe the target was actually

Speaker 2 the kids. It's totally possible.

Speaker 2 And like you said, I mean, the wild part is they're so young that they would have absolutely no memory of where they they came from other than like what they were told by someone.

Speaker 2 Like the problem we have here is I don't think anyone has enough information to say what the motive is because I don't think you can talk motive without knowing what really happened. Right.

Speaker 2 But I will say, I mean, there's been some online chatter.

Speaker 2 Like one of the things I came across that I found really interesting is this kind of fringe theory that maybe this serial killer, a guy named John Robinson, could have something to do with Jennifer's disappearance.

Speaker 2 So according to something I read on Investigation Discovery, John was a serial killer that operated in the Midwest, but specifically the Kansas and Missouri areas around the time of Jennifer's disappearance.

Speaker 2 And I mean, listen, I would love to know if John was a patron of baby dolls, but like everything I found about him online is that like he tried to maintain this facade of this super upstanding citizen.

Speaker 2 I mean, he was a Sunday school teacher. Doesn't mean he didn't, but like doesn't fit the like persona he was trying to put off.

Speaker 2 But he ultimately got arrested on a sexual battery complaint in June of 2000. This is just a month after Jennifer and the girls vanished.

Speaker 2 And from there, detectives discovered human remains on his property. The thing that's wild is he was known, forget this, allegedly promising women a new life before murdering them.

Speaker 2 And he wasn't above selling their children in the process. which he did in at least one case that he is tied to, like a murder conviction.

Speaker 2 And law enforcement has said they do think he has more victims that just haven't been ID'd.

Speaker 1 Okay, have they looked into him specifically for Jennifer's case?

Speaker 2 I couldn't tell you because police stonewalled us. I mean, he's certainly someone I find very interesting.

Speaker 1 Well, yeah, it literally fits square into one of the first theories the family brought up, like offered a new life intake set.

Speaker 2 And like to me, it's like the Kansas and Missouri connection. But again, I don't know like when he was like locked up.
Is it, is the postcard come after he's already in jail?

Speaker 2 Like I'm still like looking into this guy. I don't know.
And listen, those two places are right next to each other. Like it's not a one in a zillion coincidence, but she goes missing in Kansas.

Speaker 2 The comment card comes to Missouri. I don't know.
What I know is that sadly, that comment card was the last tangible lead the family had in over a decade.

Speaker 2 And I don't even know how seriously police took this or if they even looked into it at all.

Speaker 2 I mean, they definitely didn't collect the card as evidence or anything because Vicki still has that card today. Not that it would be evidence, right? Like I know

Speaker 2 she didn't write it, but they didn't copy it, keep it in the file, whatever.

Speaker 2 Now, throughout this time, the original detective assigned to this case, Detective Terry Harris, would check in with Vicki every so often.

Speaker 2 It'd be the usual no updates, but she felt like he was putting in real effort into looking for her daughter and grandchildren.

Speaker 2 So at some point, it kind of felt like this turned into an investigation, right?

Speaker 1 Yeah, but did they ever check the car for evidence then? Like go back and do that?

Speaker 2 I didn't say a good investigation. No.

Speaker 2 So according to Vicki, the car, you know, she tried to keep it as long as she could in case Jennifer came back, but it got repossessed at some point, though she can't remember exactly when.

Speaker 2 So whatever happened inside that car, if anything,

Speaker 2 whoever was in it, or if it held any clues as to where to look for Jennifer and the girls, that remains a mystery.

Speaker 2 Even in spite of that, Vicki had at least an ounce of confidence in Topeka PD until 2011. That's when she gets a call from from a new investigator in charge of the case asking her to submit DNA.

Speaker 2 The investigator won't give a reason why. And Vicki is living in Houston at the time.
So she's like, sure, you know, the next time I'm passing through Topeka, I'll give you guys my DNA.

Speaker 2 But the detective is like, no, you need to go to the nearest police station as soon as possible and give them your DNA. Like, please hang up now.

Speaker 1 What do the police know that we don't know?

Speaker 2 Well, what do they know that even Vicki doesn't know? Because they won't even tell her why.

Speaker 2 So she goes to the Houston Police Department to give her DNA and she asks the detective there, like, do you know what's going on? Yeah.

Speaker 2 And he tells her what police in Kansas wouldn't, that police found female remains in Illinois that they think might be Jennifer.

Speaker 2 This fall, Acorn TV has an autumn to die for, three full months of killer whodunits.

Speaker 2 With a brilliant mystery every Monday and a new crime drama every week, all for less than the cost of a pumpkin spice latte.

Speaker 2 So cozy up for an autumn to die for on Acorn TV, the home of thrilling crime drama and brilliant mystery. Visit Acorn TV and use promo code Crime Junkie for a 30-day free trial.

Speaker 1 The thought of getting a degree can be straight up terrifying. We get it.
But Southern New Hampshire University makes it easier than you'd think.

Speaker 1 They have over 200 degrees you can earn online, no set class times so your social life stays alive and well, and low online tuition that won't scare your bank account.

Speaker 1 College doesn't have to be a horror story. Visit snhu.edu slash crime junkie to get started.
That's snhu.edu slash crime junkie.

Speaker 2 Immediately, Vicki goes home and googles female remains in Illinois.

Speaker 2 But what she finds, like she's not seeing any connection to the details, like on Jennifer's case, like she doesn't see whatever it is police see.

Speaker 2 But you know, like, is there something police know that we don't know? Right. So she tries going to the police to see how they're tying them together.

Speaker 2 She calls Topeka Petey back, basically everyone's saying like no one has the details except for this one new investigator and she isn't sharing.

Speaker 2 So Vicki just gets left in the dark waiting to see if her DNA is a match to this dough.

Speaker 2 When the results finally come back, it turns out not to be Jennifer. And Vicki is relieved, but also upset by how detectives handled the whole situation.

Speaker 2 Because listen, it doesn't matter if it's been 25 years or 25 days, the pain of a missing child never goes away. So like a bit more empathy from police would have gone a long way with her.

Speaker 2 And when Vicki shares her anger with the detective's boss, she believes that may have been the catalyst for what happens next, or rather what doesn't happen.

Speaker 2 Because after the DNA results are in, Vicki says she never gets an update on Jennifer's case ever again.

Speaker 1 My hopeful little butt thought the boss was going to be upset with how the detective handled it, but no.

Speaker 2 The blue wall is firm. Like, stand by your own.
This is like so disheartening. I mean, like, I've seen this over and over.

Speaker 2 Like, the more cases we've done, the more families I've worked with, families really have no rights when it comes to like how they're treated or what they have access to information-wise.

Speaker 2 But listen, if law enforcement is going to protect their own, we can do the same, right? And people do show up for Vicki and really show up for Jennifer.

Speaker 2 In 2015, Rich, the club manager, takes it upon himself to start asking around to see if anyone knew anything about Jennifer's disappearance or if they'd heard any updates.

Speaker 2 And his interest in Jennifer's case rubs some people the wrong way. I mean, police perk up when they hear that he's asking around because they immediately call him in and start questioning him.

Speaker 2 Almost like he has something to do with that. And he's like, listen, I didn't have anything to do with this.
I just feel like it's wrong. There wasn't a bigger investigation.

Speaker 2 And you guys seem to have no interest. So I'm just asking questions because no one else is.
But all the questions he was asking, it didn't go anywhere.

Speaker 2 Rich says that no one at his club was ever interviewed.

Speaker 1 The club, which is like the one place that could have held so many answers in this case.

Speaker 2 Exactly. I mean, it shows you what he's talking about, like the lack of investigation, of not even like trying to get to the people who might have answers.

Speaker 2 Even Even after Rich left baby dolls, he could never shake that sad feeling he'd get for her mom who had to go all those years with no answers. And the fact that two little girls just vanished too.

Speaker 2 It just doesn't make sense to him. But despite even his asking, him hitting the pavement, nobody knows anything.

Speaker 2 Now in 2021, a cold case investigator for the Shawnee County DA's office takes over the case. And a local reporter, Tim Renscher, reports again on Jennifer's disappearance.

Speaker 2 He had done some in the past. It's in his update article that Vicki sees this line that doesn't make sense to her, right?

Speaker 2 Like she's like reading about her own daughter's case, like, but it says that the family didn't want to be contacted.

Speaker 1 And she's the family. Yeah.

Speaker 2 She's like, well, I know that's not true. Nobody called to ask me.
So she calls up the investigator and asks where that statement came from.

Speaker 2 And they tell her that no one has reached out to her for the past decade because of a note in her file.

Speaker 1 I'm sorry, what note?

Speaker 2 A note that says the family doesn't want to be contacted about Jennifer's case. What?

Speaker 2 Vicki says that the detective who kept her in the dark about the Illinois remains is the one who put that note in there.

Speaker 2 And she doesn't know exactly why, but Vicki thinks the detective may have done it out of spite after she called the detective's boss and complained.

Speaker 1 So she was like punishing her.

Speaker 2 So she has been been in the dark, not knowing anything for years because of this little note sitting in Jennifer's case file, which to her is heartbreaking. For me is rage inducing.
Yeah.

Speaker 2 And I would like to remind everyone again that we tried to reach out to police for records and for an interview and records, which by the way, it seems like they gave other journalists, but they would not talk to us.

Speaker 2 So I can't tell you why that note was put there at the detriment of Jennifer, of her girls, and of their family.

Speaker 2 Add to that heartbreak are the tips that come in that the family has little way of verifying, but only adds to their terror.

Speaker 2 Jessica told us that sometime in 2022, a friend of a friend told her there was a man who was known to traffic women out of baby dolls specifically, and he operated, wait for this, between Topeka, and St.

Speaker 2 Louis. This man allegedly spent time in prison for trafficking women.

Speaker 2 And the tipster who shared this information with Jessica was so scared that she wouldn't tell her what the man's name actually was.

Speaker 2 So, without more information to go off of, I can't really say if this is a theory that could be checked out, that was checked out.

Speaker 2 And we couldn't confirm if Jessica ever shared this information with police. So, we don't know if it's something that they've looked into.

Speaker 2 And it's not like they're sharing anything with the family either. At the end of the day, Vicki and Jessica just want answers.
It has been 25 years and there has been very little,

Speaker 2 only a few blips of hope, including one that came as we were writing this episode, April 2025. Jessica reached out to us after we had interviewed her to tell us that someone had contacted them.

Speaker 2 And this woman who contacted them believes she's Monique. Jennifer's youngest daughter who disappeared when she was just five weeks old.
Oh my God. And listen, her story is harrowing.

Speaker 2 This woman, who I'm going to call Nora, is living in Ontario, Canada.

Speaker 2 Now, Nora heard some rumors around town that her parents may not be who she thinks they are, and that maybe she should look into it.

Speaker 2 And after some of her own research, she somehow came across this missing person's case from Kansas.

Speaker 2 Now, Even after our team talked to Nora ourselves, it's not super clear how she specifically came across Jennifer's case. But it could all be about timing.

Speaker 2 You see, her date of of birth is the same as Monique's, at least what she told, April 6th, 2000.

Speaker 1 Which is bananas.

Speaker 2 I know, especially because Jennifer's family says that they have never had anyone reach out claiming to be one of the girls before in 25 years.

Speaker 2 So when this was going on, I mean, Jessica and Vicki are feeling all of the emotions. They are nervous.
They are, of course, hopeful that this could be the thing they have waited decades for.

Speaker 2 And Nora's got her own story to tell. She says that she had been trafficked by the man she believed to be her father.
And so even she wants answers.

Speaker 2 And when Jessica sees what Nora looks like, she says it looks a lot like her own daughter. So there could be something there.

Speaker 1 So what now? Like DNA testing? Are you looking into her parents?

Speaker 2 Okay, well, so Jessica went to the Topeka PD to try and get Nora set up for a DNA test. You're never going to believe this.
They weren't super helpful. So

Speaker 2 her next step was to call the FBI, hoping that they could get something going. And listen, they didn't have anything more than recommendations to offer, like there's nothing they can do.

Speaker 2 But Jessica was determined.

Speaker 2 So she suggests that Nora go ahead, submit her DNA to the nearest police station, which we were able to confirm with Canadian police that they received her sample and are preparing to send it to Topeka PD.

Speaker 2 But that's where their involvement ends and it becomes up to law enforcement in Kansas to do something with it. And we have no idea how long that will take.

Speaker 2 Topeka PD told Jessica initially that once the DNA comes through, it'll likely have to be sent over to the Kansas Bureau of Investigation. They'll be charged with the actual DNA testing.

Speaker 2 And that could take weeks, it could take longer. And you have to imagine trust between Jennifer's family and Topeka PD is like virtually non-existent by this point.

Speaker 2 Like if it gets tested, they don't even feel confident that they're going to like get updates on the results. But then we had an idea.
We know the wheels of justice move slow. I I hate moving slow.

Speaker 2 I don't know if you've met me.

Speaker 2 Understatement. We're not looking to test evidence here, right? Like when I started thinking about it, I want to know if person A is related to person B.

Speaker 1 That's actually pretty easy.

Speaker 2 If both people are, you know, readily willing to give their DNA, you just got to go to a lab. Private labs do this all the time.
All you need is a home kit. So we had kits sent to Canada.

Speaker 2 and to Kansas. Vicki got the kit, sent back her sample, and we got confirmation from Nora that she received her kit.
But then a few days passed and it was radio silence.

Speaker 2 We tried contacting her multiple times and she just went dark on us. And Jessica hasn't heard from her since either.

Speaker 2 So now Jennifer's family is left with more questions than answers and processing that what reignited a bit of hope in the case is now shattered.

Speaker 1 I'm like floored by this story.

Speaker 2 I know.

Speaker 1 So was all of it, any of it real? Like the trafficking, her parents?

Speaker 2 I don't know, man. Like

Speaker 2 she, she submitted the DNA to Canadian authorities, right? It's like, it's not like she backed out then. Like why

Speaker 2 now?

Speaker 2 It's the timing that I think is so weird. Like I said, not to get a single call resembling this in 25 years.
And then we show up and all of a sudden this.

Speaker 2 I mean, I could get real conspiratorial, right? Like we're asking around, we're submitting requests, we're ruffling feathers, but like, what if it was just some cosmic blessing, maybe, right?

Speaker 2 Like that we're at the right place at the right time, not to take away any pain that this caused, maybe just help expedite the truth, weed out any lies.

Speaker 2 I don't know, because I don't know what is truth and what is lies still.

Speaker 2 Hey guys, I am jumping in here real quick because there has been an update.

Speaker 2 Right after we dropped this episode in the Crime Junkie fan club in June, Nora had reached back out to us and said that she had to leave where she'd been staying before the DNA kit that we sent arrived.

Speaker 2 And so we ended up having to send her a new test. Well, that testing was done.
Those results came back. The entire team was waiting on edge for them.
And thankfully, we didn't have to wait long.

Speaker 2 On July 24th, 2025, the DNA results concluded that Nora was not Monique. There was a 99.81% probability that Nora was not related to Vicki.

Speaker 2 Now, I know this isn't the update we wanted to share, but I am glad that we were able to close this chapter for the Lancasters.

Speaker 2 They're now left to wait on the police for anything new in this case, but we did what we could to get them answers. And for that, Vicki told us she is immensely grateful.

Speaker 2 All right, now back to the original story.

Speaker 2 Vicki says that she wishes she would have shared a little bit less about Jennifer and her behavior with police when she first reported her daughter and granddaughters missing.

Speaker 2 Like maybe they would have taken it all the more seriously from the beginning.

Speaker 2 But hindsight is 2020 and she still holds out hope that her granddaughters are out there somewhere, whether they know who they are or not.

Speaker 2 So she has submitted her DNA to law enforcement and her granddaughter, Jessica's child, has submitted her DNA to ancestry.com.

Speaker 2 They're waiting for the day that a match pops up and leads them to some answers once and for all.

Speaker 2 Vicki has a message for Jennifer herself if she's still out there.

Speaker 3 I would just like to say to Jennifer that, you know, I hope they are and I pray that they are safe.

Speaker 3 I really wish that someday I would be able to hear from Jennifer and know that they're okay.

Speaker 3 I'm not upset. I understand that things happen sometimes and you just have to get away.

Speaker 3 I just hope and pray that day, that she and the girls are happy and healthy and together and they have a support system together.

Speaker 2 Jennifer would be 45 today. She had blonde hair and blue eyes.

Speaker 2 She had multiple piercings on her eyebrow, tongue, and ears, plus a tattoo of Lowrider on her left upper arm in green and black and another green and black tattoo on her lower back.

Speaker 2 Sidney would be 26 years old. She had black hair and brown eyes.
Her sister, Monique, was only a month old, and she'd be 25 today. She also had black hair and brown eyes.

Speaker 2 We're gonna include their photos, including age-progressed ones for the girls in the show notes.

Speaker 2 And if you're listening to this episode and you have any information on what happened to Jennifer or her daughters, please reach out to Topeka PD at 785-368-9551.

Speaker 2 You can also submit a tip to KBI directly online or by calling 1-800-572-7463.

Speaker 2 And if you wanna reach out to us, you can email tips at audiochuck.com.

Speaker 2 You can find all the source material for this episode on our website, crimejunkiepodcast.com.

Speaker 1 And you can follow us on Instagram at Crime Junkie Podcast.

Speaker 2 We'll be back next week with a brand new story.

Speaker 2 Crime Junkie is an audio Chuck production. So, what do you think, Chuck? Do you approve?

Speaker 4 20th Century Studios presents the upcoming comedy, Ella McKay, from Academy Award-winning writer-director James L. Brooks.

Speaker 4 Emma Mackey plays Ella McKay, an idealistic young woman who juggles her family and work life in a story about the people you love and how to survive them.

Speaker 4 Featuring an all-star cast including Emma Mackey, Jamie Lee Curtis, Jack Loudon, Kumal Ninjani, Iowa Deborey, Julie Kavner, with Albert Brooks and Woody Harrelson. Ella McKay.

Speaker 4 In theaters, December 12th.

Speaker 2 Hey, neighbor, celebrate the holidays with Birch Lane. Our timeless furniture and decor are delivered for free in days, not weeks.
It's classic style for joyful living.

Speaker 2 Shop Birch Lane, a Wayfair specialty brand at BirchLane.com.