MURDERED: Kala Williams & Heather Higgins

Speaker 1 Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One Bank guy.

Speaker 1 It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast, too.
Oh, really? Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply.

Speaker 1 See capital1.com/slash bank, capital One N-A-member FDIC.

Speaker 1 This message is brought to you by the Capital One VentureX X card. VentureX offers the premium benefits you expect, like a $300 annual Capital One travel credit, for less than you expect.

Speaker 1 Elevate your earn with unlimited double miles on every purchase, bringing you one step closer to your next dream destination. Plus, enjoy access to over 1,000 airport lounges worldwide.

Speaker 1 The Capital One Venture X card. What's in your wallet? Terms apply.
Lounge access is subject to change. See capital1.com for details.

Speaker 2 This is an ad by BetterHelp. I've come to realize that when it comes to reaching out to a friend who has been on my mind, right now is always the right time.

Speaker 2 As the days get shorter, BetterHelp encourages you to check on friends and yourself. With over 30,000 therapists worldwide, BetterHelp is one of the leading online therapy platforms.

Speaker 2 This month, don't wait to reach out. Whether you're checking in on a friend or reaching out to a therapist, BetterHelp makes it easier to take the first step.

Speaker 2 Our listeners get 10% off their first month at betterhelp.com/slash crimejunkie. That's betterh-e-l-p.com/slash slash crime junkie.

Speaker 1 Hi, crime junkies. I'm your host, Ashley Flowers.

Speaker 2 And I'm Britt.

Speaker 1 And the story I have for you today is one of the ones that will leave you furious because there should be a conclusion.

Speaker 1 Police think that they know who did it, but because of a technicality, prosecutors won't prosecute.

Speaker 1 So two families are left wondering what to do when the people in charge throw their hands up and say there's nothing they can do.

Speaker 1 And be sure to listen all the way to the end because the cracks in the system have left a predator out there walking free among us.

Speaker 1 This is the story of Kayla Williams and Heather Higgins.

Speaker 1 There are plenty of things that parenting books just can't prepare you for.

Speaker 2 I have literal classes as an adult, like to be a foster parent.

Speaker 1 Nothing actually ever truly prepares you. 100%.
And I guarantee you, what's not in the book is is how to talk to your 12-year-old after they discover human remains in the woods. Oh.

Speaker 1 That is exactly the scenario one father found himself in on Mother's Day, 2012, after his son came running home, telling him that he and his two friends found something in the woods by their house in Spokane, Washington.

Speaker 1 Now, what dad and later the police that he calls in find in that wooded area, just off of a narrow walking path in a small ditch, is the upper part of a body peeking peeking out from between torn black trash bags.

Speaker 1 Soon, the area is swarming with officers. Investigators are there, crime scene technicians, you name it.

Speaker 1 And one officer, as he is standing over the remains, spots another bundle of trash bags haphazardly hidden underneath a pile of sticks and branches about four to five feet away.

Speaker 1 And although he can't see what's inside, It's the right size to be the other half of their victim.

Speaker 1 Now, there isn't any blood anywhere around, around, which tells them that whatever happened to this poor person, it probably didn't happen here. This is just a dump site.

Speaker 1 But there's more to collect than just the bags that the victim was found in. Investigators also find a bloody hand towel, a blanket, a black camera strap with teeth marks on it.

Speaker 1 But according to police documents, those teeth marks look to just be from animals. But the whole thing is that it smells heavily of decomposition.

Speaker 1 So while they meticulously collect evidence from the forest floor, their victim is sent off piece by piece for an autopsy.

Speaker 1 And at the examiner's office, the remains are carefully unwrapped layer by layer. They realize that the victim is young.
It's a female in her like early adulthood.

Speaker 1 She's white with long blonde hair and her body has been cut in half at the waist.

Speaker 1 Now, starting with her upper body, they find a towel knotted around her neck, covering her lower face with strands of black electrical tape like entangled in it.

Speaker 1 And her clothing, a sweater, t-shirt, and camouselet have been cut vertically from the bottom up and shoved around her shoulders beneath her body.

Speaker 1 Her bra, which was also cut in between the cups, is beneath her. Then found in the layers of plastic is her underwear, also cut.
And her clothing is discolored. Not from the blood, though.

Speaker 1 It looks like her clothing is discolored from bleach. Like that's what the stains look like.
Oh, that's not good news.

Speaker 2 They're going to be screwed getting any sort of evidence or samples off of her body then.

Speaker 1 I know. And it's not much better for her lower body.

Speaker 1 So her lower body, which was in that second bundle, is wrapped not just in plastic bags and the tape, but also an orange sleeping bag with a plaid interior.

Speaker 1 Now, it is zipped closed with more of that black electrical tape wrapped around it.

Speaker 1 And in between all of the bags layers are more towels, a pair of boxer boxer shorts, and some sort of black strap material.

Speaker 1 And then they find a pair of men's size 36 jeans with a black synthetic belt.

Speaker 1 Now, whereas her top half was still clothed, even though it was cut, her lower half is completely nude, save for the socks still on her feet. It's not...

Speaker 1 immediately apparent how long she's been out in the woods or even when she died. I mean, it's been pretty cool in Spokane as winter turns to spring.

Speaker 1 So despite some decomp and some animal activity, she is relatively well preserved.

Speaker 1 And it's because of that preservation that they're able to quickly identify her via fingerprints as 20-year-old Kayla Williams. Kayla's not completely unknown to police in Spokane.

Speaker 1 She'd been arrested before, although I can't really find out exactly what for.

Speaker 1 And I know at one time she had been reported missing by her brother, which is like a little over a month ago. He reported her missing on April 2nd.

Speaker 1 But they think that she might have actually been missing for a little while by that point.

Speaker 1 You see, her family had gotten worried when she didn't meet her mom, Martine, for church a few weeks in a row. Like the two of them had this routine.

Speaker 1 Kayla didn't live at home, but she and her mom always made sure to attend church twice a week with one another.

Speaker 1 Like this was the thing that provided stability in what was otherwise a pretty turbulent time for Kayla because she'd been struggling with substance use disorder.

Speaker 1 So, you know, when they finally realize she's gone to report her missing, there had been a little bit of a police search for her, which didn't result in much of anything.

Speaker 1 And the TLDR of all of it is basically that she had been living with a few people in an apartment. One of those people was including her, like maybe current, maybe ex-boyfriend, this guy named Matt.

Speaker 1 And he was obviously one of the first people that they wanted to talk to.

Speaker 1 But one of the guys that they were living with said that Matt had moved out of state right around the same time that Kayla went missing.

Speaker 1 Now, you'll see that if you go out and read about this, but that turned out actually not to be true. They ended up tracking Matt down at the apartment that they all shared just a few days later.

Speaker 1 So Matt said that he hadn't seen Kayla since around the end of March, but he made it clear that he wasn't interested in having her in his life anymore.

Speaker 1 He allegedly also struggled with substance use disorder. And the last time that he'd seen her, he had been trying to avoid anything or anyone triggering.
And Kayla was still using at the time.

Speaker 1 So I guess he told her to leave the apartment. And that, he says, is the last time he saw her.
So because they didn't really get anywhere, the search for Kayla ultimately stalled.

Speaker 1 But her family never stopped looking for her. So on May 13th, that same family is watching the news.
Kayla's mom has it on as her husband is getting ready for work.

Speaker 1 And when she sees a news segment about the body of a young woman being found, she says she like knows instinctively that it's her daughter.

Speaker 1 And later that day, in another moment that no parenting book can ever prepare you for, she opens the door to investigators there to give her the worst news of her life.

Speaker 1 And they have so many questions like when, why, who. I mean, it's something Martine can't stop thinking about as they're finishing her daughter's autopsy.

Speaker 1 She and investigators are hoping that the results will answer at least some of the questions, but ultimately it doesn't.

Speaker 1 In fact, it only results in more questions because despite police telling the public that Kayla had signs of significant trauma, despite the fact that she was dismembered, despite noting cut-like defects on her hands and a stab wound on her thigh, despite looking as though she had what looks like bleach poured on her, Dr.

Speaker 1 John Howard can't determine exactly how she died. So he rules her cause and her manner of death as undetermined.
What? I get cause if you can't determine the cause of death.

Speaker 2 But manner.

Speaker 1 I know.

Speaker 2 Okay, my mind is reeling, but does he at least determine if it's actually bleach on her?

Speaker 1 So as far as the bleach, so not early on, according to the documents we have. I know testing does happen later.
Okay.

Speaker 1 But in that moment, I don't know how much they're even taking the bleach into account, which is like a bananas thing to say. Yeah.

Speaker 1 And basically, at first, I guess this guy is like, well, she might have overdosed. And maybe someone she was with might have disposed of her body, which is still a crime, by the way.

Speaker 1 It is not a homicide, though. And also not even like something worth picking apart in my mind, because like, hi, you can test for drugs.
So like, let's just do that. Let's stop guessing.

Speaker 1 So fast forward to when the talk screen comes back, it shows that while she did have meth in her system, there wasn't nearly enough to have killed her.

Speaker 1 Yet, for some reason, this isn't enough to change anything for the ME.

Speaker 1 Okay, no overdose, but he still doesn't know the cause. So he doesn't think he can rule on manner, which I have seen trip up so many cases.

Speaker 1 A lot of times it becomes this like finger-pointing game where investigators will kind of wash their hands of it. They're like, well, there's no crime, like we can't investigate.
Right.

Speaker 1 But at least this time around, no one in charge of the investigation, like, or at least on that side of things, has any doubt about what this is.

Speaker 1 According to an episode of the show Still a Mystery titled Depths of Depravity, to them, this is a homicide. And thankfully, at the autopsy, swabs were taken, as well as fingernail clippings.

Speaker 1 So they asked for those to be sent off for DNA testing, along with all those other items from the scene. And while they wait for results, the investigation keeps moving forward, albeit slowly.

Speaker 1 They did some initial canvassing around where Kayla's body was found. I don't know what you were picturing initially, but this wooded area isn't remote.

Speaker 1 We're talking about like a pretty residential area. So there were some initial hopes that maybe someone witnessed a person disposing of two large trash bags.

Speaker 1 But unfortunately, whoever brought Kayla there got lucky.

Speaker 1 The only thing they took away from their door knocking was the knowledge that this is a pretty quiet spot with the occasional disturbance from teenagers partying in the area.

Speaker 1 Although, for the last couple of months, the usual gaggle of teens haven't been coming around.

Speaker 1 Some neighbors also mention this older man who they say they've seen before, and he likes to make some people in the area uncomfortable.

Speaker 1 But spoiler alert, they end up finding the guy and end up ruling him out. So they decide to focus on the people they know who were connected to Kayla.
Starting with Matt.

Speaker 1 You know, those gifts that make everyone go, Wait, where did you get this? Well, those gifts come from JCPenney. Yes, JCPenney.

Speaker 1 JCPenney has gifts for that person in your life who is impossible to shop for. You know the one, the friend who buys themselves everything or the family member who swears they don't need anything.

Speaker 1 Sorry, not this year. From diamond jewelry to the newest gadgets, JCPenney has gifts that look expensive at a fraction of the price.

Speaker 1 I did all of my holiday shopping for my daughter through JCPenney online. I got the exact things I was looking for at stellar prices.

Speaker 1 And she is gonna lose her little mind when she realizes I found the perfect frozen sneaker to replace the ones that she grew out of.

Speaker 1 We have been looking everywhere for them, and I had no idea they were just waiting for me at JCPenney.

Speaker 1 With prices up to 60% off during JCPenney's Black Friday sales, it is the perfect time to fill your cart and throw in a little something for yourself, too.

Speaker 1 It's guilt-free, the way holiday shopping should be. Shop jcp.com.
Yes, JCPenney.

Speaker 1 Groons are a convenient, comprehensive formula packed into a daily snack pack of gummies that tastes great. This isn't a multivitamin, a greens gummy, or a prebiotic.

Speaker 1 It is all of those things and then some.

Speaker 1 Generic multivitamins only contain around seven to nine vitamins, while groons have 20 plus vitamins and minerals and 60 ingredients, which include nutrient-dense and whole foods.

Speaker 1 They're vegan, nut-free, gluten-free, dairy-free, have no artificial colors or flavors, and are available in low-sugar or sugar-free.

Speaker 1 Plus, they contain six grams of prebiotic fiber, which is three times the amount of dietary fiber compared to the leading greens powders and more than two cups of broccoli.

Speaker 1 You guys, these are so good. I pack a bunch in my purse or my backpack because I am notoriously bad about forgetting to take supplements, vitamins, all of that.
And when I remember, boom, right there.

Speaker 1 So use code crimejunkie at groons.co to save up to 52% off your first order. That's crimejunkie at gr-u-n-s.co for up to 52% off.

Speaker 1 Matt mostly repeats what he said when Kayla first came up missing, that he hadn't seen her since like late March. But he clarifies that it wasn't that uncommon for her to leave for days at a time.

Speaker 1 So not seeing her for a few weeks didn't raise too many red flags for him at first. Even though, by the way, it might might be worth mentioning, I have her cell phone.
That's what he tells police.

Speaker 1 According to an article in the Spokesman Review, he tells the police that she had left it at the apartment, likely because she had run out of minutes and they just didn't take it with her.

Speaker 1 A search warrant allows investigators to take a look at her calls and text messages, and they read that one of the last messages she sent was on March 18th to a friend and mentor.

Speaker 1 This friend says that she last saw Kayla on March 18th as well, and she had been living on the streets after a fight with Matt.

Speaker 1 The friend told police that Kayla hadn't been doing well, but she was going to try to patch things up with Matt.

Speaker 2 And did she?

Speaker 1 Well, that's unclear because I don't know the exact date Matt last saw her. He just says late March.
And we tried to talk to him for this episode, but...

Speaker 1 all of our attempts to reach out to him have been unsuccessful.

Speaker 2 And was her phone really like out of minutes or disconnected or whatever?

Speaker 1 Oh girl, I wish I had more details around her phone. I just don't have anything.
Like nothing nothing beyond the information I just gave you has been reported.

Speaker 1 And anyone we spoke to for this episode couldn't tell us if there was anything else of interest on the phone, if they looked, if they did like a full forensic sweep, like I got nothing.

Speaker 1 Where we do find something of interest is in all those results that come back from the lab. Now, not everything they sent in for testing resulted in something usable.

Speaker 1 Like, none of the swabs gave them anything that they could work with at the time. The boxer shorts found at the scene, however, are a different story.

Speaker 1 They come back with a full DNA profile that is a match to a 42-year-old man named Robert Davis. And Robert is a bad dude.

Speaker 1 He has a string of past convictions and allegations behind him, including a really violent sexual assault from 2007. Apparently, that April, 2007, he had gone into the apartment of a woman named Dawn.

Speaker 1 and she reported that he choked her into unconsciousness and sexually assaulted her.

Speaker 1 According to Thomas Klaus's reporting for the spokesman review, she survived and a sexual assault kit proved his DNA was all over her.

Speaker 1 But for some reason, he was never officially charged with anything.

Speaker 2 How is that even possible?

Speaker 1 I don't know because some of the reporting on this is like conflicting. Like I've seen some reports saying that Don didn't want to push forward.

Speaker 1 And then I've seen others where the investigators and the prosecutors just dropped the ball.

Speaker 2 Okay, but now they've got his full DNA profile on these boxers in Kayla's case.

Speaker 1 Yeah, and not just the boxers. So here's the other thing.
They found two major DNA profiles under Kayla's nails, too. And a direct comparison proves that one of those is this Robert guy's.

Speaker 2 Okay, but then who's the other?

Speaker 1 Well, the other profile belongs to Matt, which might not be all that surprising. I mean, remember, she'd been talking about patching things up with him to her friend.

Speaker 1 Like we know they have a relationship or had and we still don't know when she died so if it was right after she saw him that might explain it i mean having robert's dna under her nails and his boxers and knowing his history like they're much more interested in him even more so when a bunch more from the scene gets tested and it all keeps coming back as a match to him the black electrical tape around her neck those jeans that camera strap found near her body it all has his DNA on it.

Speaker 1 Now, I do need to mention that there is one other profile found on the fly of the boxers. That profile does get matched to a guy named David.

Speaker 1 But as far as I can see, his DNA isn't anywhere else on her body or the other pieces of evidence.

Speaker 1 And based on the police docs that we have access to and the interviews that our team conducted for this case, it seems like he's never been considered a person of interest in Kayla's death.

Speaker 2 He's just like a blip in the DNA evidence.

Speaker 1 Yeah, it is all about Robert Davis. So on July 25th, this is more than two months after Kayla's body was found, they track him down and speak with him.

Speaker 1 Robert explains that he does know Kayla, but not very closely. He says that he only knows her through Matt.
He would purchase drugs from Matt and the few times that he did so, Kayla was there too.

Speaker 1 But that was it. He says they never hung out.
They never had sex. Although he does admit that he probably wouldn't tell police if they had had sex.
So cool, cool, yeah.

Speaker 1 I mean, it's honest, but like, here's where it gets weird. If investigators confronted him about his DNA being freaking everywhere, it is not in the documentation I've seen.
And so he's not arrested.

Speaker 1 What? Because, and this is where we get our hiccup that comes back to bite us, even though they have investigated it.

Speaker 1 And even though they have linked all this stuff in and around the bags with her dismembered body to a very bad guy known for very bad stuff, it's not a homicide.

Speaker 1 Technically, there isn't a murder, right?

Speaker 1 Which makes no sense to me. Like,

Speaker 1 we can put you with her before she died when you're saying you weren't. Like, we got you.
Yeah. But apparently it's not enough for them.
Though they aren't totally walking away either.

Speaker 1 At one point, I guess they go talk with Robert's mother, Raynelle. He had like lived with her off and on.

Speaker 1 But according to a timeline published by the Spokesman Review, she claims she doesn't know anything either.

Speaker 1 So like, I think they're at least trying to dig and like build something, but they don't get anywhere like at first.

Speaker 1 But it was worth going to talk to her because a few days later on August 1st, she contacts police like out of the blue. And she says, listen, I don't know anything about Kayla's murder, but.

Speaker 1 A couple of years ago, my son came home and he confessed to disposing of a different body. So maybe I should tell you about that.
Yeah. You think?

Speaker 1 She says that two years ago, which would have been in 2010, Robert came home acting really anxious.

Speaker 1 And eventually he told his mom that these two guys had killed a woman named Heather Higgins and forced him to help dispose of her body. So he put her body in a sleeping bag.

Speaker 1 and dumped her down a steep hill somewhere north of Spokane.

Speaker 2 And a sleeping bag feels like a really important detail.

Speaker 1 That's what Kayla's found in too, right? Her lower half.

Speaker 1 Now, Raynelle tells police that she didn't come forward then because she, frankly, just didn't believe him at the time.

Speaker 1 Like because of his substance abuse, like she didn't trust a lot of what he said. And she kind of just chalked it up to him being worked up over nothing.

Speaker 1 But the thing is, 39-year-old Heather Higgins really did go missing back in 2010. And she still hadn't been found by the time they're talking to this woman.

Speaker 1 By this point, the news that parts of Kayla's body had been placed in a sleeping bag wasn't known to the public either.

Speaker 1 And investigators don't think it's a coincidence. Yeah.

Speaker 1 And that's not the only similarity between Heather and Kayla either. The investigation into Heather's disappearance was just as lackluster as the police search for Kayla had been, if not more so.

Speaker 1 Just like Kayla's mom had realized something was wrong, it was Heather's mom, Jackie, who first sounded the alarm.

Speaker 2 Black Friday is here, and Pandora Jewelry is offering up to 40% off store-wide and site-wide now through December 2nd.

Speaker 2 Explore jewelry designed to last beyond the season, from classic charms to modern rings, bracelets, earrings, and more.

Speaker 2 Whether you're holiday shopping or treating yourself, now's the perfect time to find something special. Save up to 40% on the jewelry you love.
Shop at Pandora.net or your local Pandora store.

Speaker 2 Exclusion Supply.

Speaker 2 Tis the season, cold and flu season that is. But this year, find symptom relief for less on GoodRX.

Speaker 2 With GoodRX, you could save an average of $53 on flu treatments and get discounts on cold medications, decongestants, and more. GoodRX is free and easy to use.

Speaker 2 Just search for your prescription on the website or the app, compare prices, and get a free coupon to show your pharmacist.

Speaker 2 Check GoodRX to save at over 70,000 local pharmacies nationwide, including Walmart, Walgreens, CVS, Publix, Kroger, and many more. Or get prescriptions delivered right to your front front door.

Speaker 2 GoodRX is not insurance, but works whether you have insurance or not. And if you do have insurance, it could even beat your copay price.

Speaker 2 For savings on cold and flu medications or any other prescriptions, check GoodRX. Go to goodrx.com/slash crime junkie.
That's goodrx.com/slash crime junkie.

Speaker 1 Heather was also going through some turbulence in life when she vanished.

Speaker 1 She'd recently been hospitalized and returned home to find that the money that she was going to use to get a new apartment had been stolen.

Speaker 1 So she had been working on getting alone when she just vanished like into thin air.

Speaker 1 And when her mom realized that she hadn't heard from Heather in a few days, she went over to find her cats alone in the apartment. So on September 27th, 2010, Jackie reported her daughter missing.

Speaker 1 But the response made her feel like police just didn't care.

Speaker 1 According to her mom, they looked at her recent hospitalization for bipolar disorder and a a previous DWI that she'd gotten and basically said that Heather could just leave if she wanted to.

Speaker 1 And in a public statement about her disappearance, one detective said that she was an alcoholic, which just, by the way, wasn't even true, at least according to her mom.

Speaker 1 And this is like this little stuff that bothers me.

Speaker 1 Instead of using her nice college ID photo, which was recent because she was currently in school for journalism, The photo that police decided to use for her missing persons flyer was a mugshot from a prior arrest.

Speaker 1 which pretty much tells you everything you need to know about how the police viewed her like yeah as the person that they were looking for exactly i mean it all made jackie feel like police were saying that her daughter wasn't worth finding yeah so she started looking for heather herself and jackie spent years doing what police should have even putting her and her loved ones in dangerous situations to try and track her daughter down.

Speaker 1 A daughter that she believed was still alive. But almost from the beginning, according to her mom, police didn't actually share that belief.

Speaker 1 In fact, they were confident early on that she'd been killed, possibly by Robert Davis, whose name came up early on. The thing is, they didn't share any of that with Jackie.

Speaker 1 They kind of allowed her to go on believing that Heather might just come home. Like, they'd let her believe this for years.
Wait, how early on are we talking here?

Speaker 1 Like within like a few months, possibly even the first few weeks. So you see, they learned that the day she went missing, the loan that Heather had been trying to get fell through.

Speaker 1 So she decided to go into town and pawn some rings. Now, she couldn't drive at that moment.

Speaker 1 So she went across the street to her neighbor, Dawn's apartment, to see if she knew of anyone who could give her a ride. Now, if the name Dawn feels familiar, that's because...

Speaker 1 The Dawn that lived across from Heather was the same Dawn that said she had been assaulted by Robert Davis back in 2007. Oh my God.
I know, and I don't know why,

Speaker 1 but Dawn gave Heather Robert Davis' phone number. And the last anybody saw of Heather, she was getting into Robert's minivan.

Speaker 1 Now, I don't know why Dawn still had Robert's number after what he did to her or why she felt okay giving it like that contact info to someone else.

Speaker 1 But Dawn has since passed away, so we couldn't ask her. And no one our team talked to could explain it.
It sounds like the nature of their their relationship was complicated, obviously.

Speaker 1 Like that's probably a massive understatement.

Speaker 1 But regardless, when Robert was eventually interviewed by police, he admitted to giving Heather a ride that day, but he claimed that she got angry with him.

Speaker 1 So he left her on the side of the road in town. The end.
So, okay, I'm kind of getting a little twisted on this.

Speaker 2 In this time when they find this stuff out about Robert being with Heather, are they still holding the position with her mom that she just walked off on her own?

Speaker 1 Yeah, this is what's so weird.

Speaker 1 So this is early on, but they don't give Jackie any updates about this. So like, I think they probably told her early on that they thought she was a runaway.

Speaker 1 Jackie is like on her own to do her own thing. They learned this stuff about Robert Davis, but they don't tell her mom this or that they've like, if they're thinking has changed, they don't tell her.

Speaker 1 They just let her. keep on believing that her daughter might still be out there.
And it's not like they aren't in contact with her.

Speaker 1 She told our team that she called investigators every single day because she was investigating on her own.

Speaker 1 So they could have told her, I mean, countless number of times that they didn't believe Heather was still out there. But for some unknown reason, they didn't.

Speaker 1 Now, by the time they got around to talk to Robert, it was months after Heather went missing. And by then, he'd conveniently sold his minivan and had it straight up crushed.

Speaker 2 Oh, so not just like sold it to someone.

Speaker 1 There's no getting in that minivan. Got it.

Speaker 1 But the thing is, if they had done just a little more digging, they would have found that the rings that she was going to sell that day, those had in fact been pawned, except they weren't pawned by Heather.

Speaker 1 They were pawned by Robert. But that link wouldn't be connected for years.
At the time, police didn't even check the pawn shops. They just let Heather fade.

Speaker 1 Even when her student ID and a butcher knife were found submerged in a river three and a half blocks from where Robert was living at the time, they still did nothing.

Speaker 1 And they still, even then, didn't tell Jackie anything. And now there are two women, one still missing, one murdered, directly tied to Robert Davis.
But there is no arrest.

Speaker 1 And both Kayla and Heather's families are left to try and fit together the pieces. By now, according to Kayla's mom, Martine, they're at least aware of each other, but they never really connect.

Speaker 1 They're trying to navigate their grief and a system that feels like it's not on their side. That is until early 2013, when a new detective is assigned to Kayla's case.

Speaker 1 His name is Mark Burbridge, and as he's reviewing her autopsy, he can't believe what he sees.

Speaker 1 The autopsy report is sparse, and as Detective Burbridge is comparing the report to the photos that he is seeing of Kayla's body, he can't make sense of it because the original report doesn't contain any mention of the dozens of sharp force wounds that he is seeing.

Speaker 1 Or, by the way, the shoe prints on her chest and leg. or the defensive wounds or the bruising around her wrist like she had been restrained.
So he's confused, to say the least, and frustrated.

Speaker 1 So according to police docs, he tries to go to Dr. Howard, like wanting clarification.
I mean, probably really an explanation, but it takes months before Dr. Howard will even speak with him.

Speaker 1 And when they're finally face to face, Dr. Howard is super defensive.
He even says that Detective Burbridge is being rude and goes so far as to ban him from the medical examiner's office. What?

Speaker 1 Yeah, which is not the reaction Burbridge was expecting, but he's not going to give up. Something isn't right here.

Speaker 1 So he meets with the Spokane County prosecutor, this guy named Jack Driscoll. But Jack isn't much help either.
He basically says that he's not going to go against what Dr.

Speaker 1 Howard ruled, because if he goes on to say that Dr. Howard druling on Kayla's case was wrong, like that's going to call into question all of his other rulings and like open up this can of worms.

Speaker 2 Am I the only one who thinks that's maybe like a good thing?

Speaker 1 Yeah. I mean, if only if it were that straightforward, right? Like, so to me and you, yes, this is a good thing.

Speaker 2 Because making mistakes or doing things in error, like we should correct those things.

Speaker 1 Yeah. I mean, if you're missing stab wounds, like you would think Spokane County would want to, I don't know, take care of that.
Yeah.

Speaker 1 But doing that unravels God knows how many convictions, which again, they might be convictions that are actually like needed. No one's like, Like, and it's going to take a lot of work.

Speaker 1 I mean, no one's saying this is going to be easy to do. But to Detective Burbridge, like, it needs to be done.
Yeah.

Speaker 1 And he thinks that all of this, like, they're just more interested in protecting their people, securing their convictions, their image, whatever, than actually protecting the general public.

Speaker 1 Doing their job. So he decides to pay a doctor from Seattle to review the autopsy results.
And in the meantime, on July 8th of 2013, he conducts a follow-up interview with Robert Davis.

Speaker 1 At this point, Robert has moved to Court d'Alene, Idaho. and he says pretty much the exact same thing.
He never had sex with Kayla, he didn't kill her, and he did not dispose of her body.

Speaker 1 He's still saying this, even when he's finally confronted with all of the DNA. Still denies killing her, still denies disposing of her body, even denies being at the crime scene.

Speaker 1 Like, this dude doesn't give an inch. So they let him go.

Speaker 1 Now, on December 31st, 2013, the autopsy results from Seattle come back, and this one could not be more different. We actually got our hands on both Dr.

Speaker 1 Howard's original autopsy and the new report, which was done by a guy named Dr. Carl Wiggin.
And Britt, comparing these two reports, it's like they're not even talking about the same body.

Speaker 1 On her upper body alone, Dr. Wiggin notes four abrasions, including what looks like a shoe print on her chest and parallel marks consistent with bindings.

Speaker 1 There are 18 sharp force wounds, 16 of which are concentrated on her hands and lower arms, as if she was trying to like defend herself.

Speaker 1 And there are 50 contusions also consistent with defensive wounds, including a black eye.

Speaker 1 And on her lower half, he notes six abrasions, including a shoe print on her left thigh, nine sharp force wounds, and 48 contusions consistent with defensive wounds, which is like wild to me that we're still saying undetermined.

Speaker 2 Undetermined manner of death. It like defies logic.

Speaker 1 I know.

Speaker 1 And like, listen, Dr. Howard's report talked about like some defects like on her hands and fingers.
Like he points out some like cut like defects on her left hand and thumb, like four of those.

Speaker 1 And then obviously he like notes the wound where she's cut in half. And he makes a note of a stab wound on her thigh, which appears in both reports.

Speaker 2 But there's like shoe prints on her thigh, shoe prints on her chest.

Speaker 1 Dude, he had nothing about her having a black eye. He had nothing about her, like the injuries on her lower arms or her legs.

Speaker 1 And what sticks out to me is like the sheer enormity of the wounds in this second autopsy compared to the first. Like, again, it feels like you're looking at reports for two different victims.
Yeah.

Speaker 1 And this second doctor, he also notes that he sees no documentation showing. like internal exams to like fully rule out sexual assault.

Speaker 1 Oh, and by the way, they did eventually do like some testing to see if the stuff that the staining was actually bleach, but ultimately that came back inconclusive.

Speaker 1 Like it doesn't really fall into these reports, but it's worth noting.

Speaker 1 And the second doctor, he couldn't, he, he, like the first, he couldn't determine a specific cause of death. But based on everything he's seeing, the second doctor, this Dr.

Speaker 1 Wiggren, says there's no way this isn't a murder. Right.
So armed with this new report, Detective Burbridge goes to the deputy prosecutor, who in turn brings the findings to Dr. Howard, the first ME.

Speaker 1 But Dr. Howard refuses to change the ruling.
And his reasoning is that he can't rule out an overdose as her cause of death. Hold up.

Speaker 2 He's legit still holding on to that? Yes. He did the tox screen.
There wasn't a lethal amount of drugs in her system.

Speaker 1 Yes.

Speaker 2 actually can't be an overdose.

Speaker 1 I know. And like literally this makes no sense to anyone in the police department.
Like, for Detective Burbridge, this should be an open and shut case. Yeah.

Speaker 1 And in 2014, his supervisor agrees and he gives him permission to write up charging documents for Robert Davis for murder.

Speaker 2 Which, quick question, did they ever go looking for Heather's body after Robert's mom talked to them?

Speaker 1 Um, okay, so there were a few searches done by her family. Um, and like the area that Robert alluded to, I guess, is super difficult to search.
Like it's all these really steep cliffs.

Speaker 1 So there were some searches done. Again, like most by her family, nothing was ever found.
So even now,

Speaker 1 but still, even without Heather's body or confession, the escalation of Robert's alleged crimes feels super clear to Detective Burbridge.

Speaker 1 So like, even if they can't get Heather, like they know what they're dealing with in Kayla's case. Like, let's at least get him for that.
But here's what's wild.

Speaker 1 Still, with everything they have, and no matter how clear it feels to the detectives, to the people in the police department, you, me, our listeners, prosecutors refuse to press charges.

Speaker 2 What else do they want? What else could they possibly need, Ashley?

Speaker 1 Like, the word frustrating, like, doesn't even cover it. Like, it doesn't cover it for how I feel, certainly not for how Detective Burbridge is left feeling.
Like, he is straight up angry.

Speaker 1 Kayla's family is angry. And that anger only intensifies when on June 21st, 2014, another woman comes forward saying that she has been attacked by Robert.

Speaker 1 On the evening of the 21st, a woman we'll be calling Sasha was alone in her trailer in Cordeline, Idaho when Robert entered unexpectedly. Now, she knew who he was.

Speaker 1 He had been hanging out with a friend of hers. But him showing up unannounced without her friend was strange.
Sasha said Robert proceeded to attack her, choking her until she passed out several times.

Speaker 1 And each time she woke up, Robert was sexually assaulting her. And in her gut, she knew that Robert was going to kill her if no one stopped him.

Speaker 1 Now, thankfully, true hero of the story, her dog was there with her. And this dog began attacking Robert, which is what Sasha believes made him stop.

Speaker 1 And when she woke up again, according to the court docs, he was running out the door.

Speaker 1 Now, thankfully, she didn't suffer any serious physical injuries and she was easily able to identify Robert as her attacker.

Speaker 1 So he gets arrested and originally charged with first-degree attempted murder and burglary, though he pled down to burglary and battery with attempt to commit rape.

Speaker 1 And he ended up getting a sentence of 15 years with the option of parole much sooner.

Speaker 1 Now, it's not much time, but while he's in prison, Detective Burbridge has a little more breathing room to like get this right.

Speaker 1 And he gets an early win when the deputy prosecutor tells Detective Burbridge that they're finally going to consider getting another opinion about Kayla's autopsy.

Speaker 2 Wait, why can't they use Dr. Wiggren's?

Speaker 1 Because they say because Dr. Wiggren wasn't an official ME, like he runs a private practice called Wigren Forensic.

Speaker 2 So he like can do autopsies.

Speaker 1 And he had, like, he served as the associate medical examiner for Snohomish County for like a couple of years. It's not like he's just like making up his certification.

Speaker 2 But they want someone with like the actual legit title

Speaker 2 medical examiner to give their official stamped opinion.

Speaker 1 Yeah, bingo. Which sounds fine, but great, whatever.

Speaker 1 Until three days later. That's when the deputy prosecutor says, you know what? Actually, never mind, that's not happening.

Speaker 1 Oh, and don't even bother asking why, because the deputy prosecutor doesn't give a reason. Cool.
Yeah. So, in a last-ditch effort to try and get something,

Speaker 1 investigators try to interview Robert Davis again. However, he asks for a lawyer and refuses to talk.
And that ends up being Detective Burbridge's last attempt to get answers.

Speaker 1 Because in 2015, he's taken off the case and moved from major crimes to the Special Investigations Unit, which primarily manages drug investigations. Why he's removed? Unclear.

Speaker 1 There's speculation and rumor, mostly stemming from his unyielding pressure on the prosecutor's office. But as with any change of like leadership in a case, momentum gets lost when he gets moved.

Speaker 1 Knowledge gets lost. Kayla and Heather's cases have both had numerous lead investigators assigned to them over the years, each having varying levels of success getting new information.

Speaker 1 And by this point, Jackie, who's Heather's mom, does know that police believe her daughter was killed. Again, I don't know when it happens or how it happens, but by this point, she knows.

Speaker 1 And even though charging documents are again brought to the prosecutor's office for Kayla's homicide on February 9th, 2017, those charges, again, do not get approved.

Speaker 1 And the reason is that the prosecutor's office cites is a need for more evidence.

Speaker 1 But all the shadiness, all the dodging of charges, all the protection of the ME's office, That gets challenged in April of 2017, because that's when the Washington Department of Health launches an investigation into the medical examiner's office.

Speaker 1 You see, they'd received complaints from numerous families who claimed that Dr. Howard and his co-me, Dr.
Sally Aiken, have a history of incorrect rulings when it comes to cause and manner of death.

Speaker 1 You see, according to more of Thomas Klaus's reporting, Kayla's case is one of several that are brought up in the complaint.

Speaker 1 Others include Brenda Thurman, who was shot by her husband in what was initially ruled an accident. And then there's Dr.

Speaker 1 John Marshall, who was found in the Spokane River with what looks like bruising from being beaten. His death originally ruled an accident too.

Speaker 1 Sarah Schmidt was also found in the Spokane River with bruising on her ankles that looked a lot like ligature marks. Her death is ruled a suicide.

Speaker 1 And then there's Cindy Lou Zeppenfeld-Bergen, whose body was found wrapped in plastic on the side of the road in Idaho after she filed for a protection order order to escape domestic violence.

Speaker 1 Spokane ME did the autopsy and ruled her cause of death as a heart attack and therefore ruled her manner of death as natural.

Speaker 2 Just to be clear, she was found wrapped in plastic. You got it.

Speaker 1 Now, of course, the county commissioner makes a statement saying that the county stands behind its MEs. Even before the investigation gets underway, which is like a little wild to me.

Speaker 1 Like, let's let the process do its thing.

Speaker 1 But the thing about this investigation is that even if it reveals that there was something wrong with the rulings, apparently there's no way to get them changed because it's up to the medical examiners to change the rulings, which at least for Kayla's case, we know they've refused to do.

Speaker 2 Wait, how does that make any sense?

Speaker 1 It doesn't. Like the power is still sitting with the ME's office to make the change.
And even if somehow they could have changed the rulings, we know they wouldn't have.

Speaker 1 Because by the end of the investigation in 2017, Department of Health ultimately finds that doctors Howard and Aiken, quote, met the standard of care, which if you ask me, is a pretty

Speaker 1 low standard. And it is a slap in the face on top of every other gut punch that these families have experienced.
But Kayla's family's fight and Heather's family's fight. It isn't over yet.

Speaker 1 Because come 2019, Robert Davis is up for parole and they're ready to do everything in their power to make sure he stays in prison. Kayla's mom and one of her brothers go to the hearing.

Speaker 1 Jackie, Heather's mom, can't go because she's sick, but she told us that she is so glad both her family and Kayla's family were ready to fight his release.

Speaker 1 Because according to Jackie, the parole board in Idaho wasn't even aware of Kayla or Heather's cases until their families made them aware. Now, how they didn't know this is beyond me.

Speaker 1 I don't know if it's because he wasn't convicted of it, But once the board finds out, the board asks Robert about Kayla, like in his review.

Speaker 1 And according to Martine, Robert got mad when they asked. She told our team that his face like got bright red.
Veins were like popping out of his neck.

Speaker 1 He swore up and down that he didn't know who she was, which... By the way, is a brand new story.
Yeah. Because he admitted to knowing her back in 2012.
Right.

Speaker 1 Ultimately, he gets denied parole, which is a huge win.

Speaker 1 And Jackie told us that a woman on the parole board promises her and Kayla's family that they will be notified next time he's up for parole, which they're all for, right?

Speaker 1 Like they're gonna fight this. They wanna keep him in prison for as long as possible to keep him off the streets and to give investigators more time to build their cases.

Speaker 1 And hopefully they can get him once and for all. If they're working the cases, that is.
Right. Because the families don't know.

Speaker 1 By this point, the investigations into both cases have changed hands so many times, it's difficult for them to keep track of who's in charge and what they're doing.

Speaker 1 Still, though, this was one of the first wins they've had in a long time. And then another one comes in 2021 when both Dr.
Howard and Dr. Aiken retire.
So a new medical examiner, Dr.

Speaker 1 Veena Singh, is appointed. And she begins revisiting several of the previous ME's rulings, including Kayla's.

Speaker 2 Looking for a TV service that puts you in charge? Sling is the live TV option that gives you total flexibility.

Speaker 2 Only pay for channels you actually watch, so you don't have to wonder why you're stuck paying for stuff you don't want. With Sling, you can also come and go as you please.

Speaker 2 Pause your subscription at any time and you'll still have access to more than 600 free channels.

Speaker 2 And with their new passes, you decide when you want to watch, whether it's for a week, a weekend, or even just a single day.

Speaker 2 It's getting to be peak sports season, and I'm definitely ready to get in and watch every game game my schedule allows.

Speaker 2 With Sling, I'm able to pick a package that gets me all the channels I would need to watch my NFL and NBA games. And I love the convenience of the Sling passes.

Speaker 2 I can start my subscription for the season and pause it once the season wraps up. It's truly so convenient and easy to have the TV channels I want when I need them.

Speaker 2 Choose and customize your channel lineup or pause and watch for free. Sling lets you do that.
Visit sling.com to learn more.

Speaker 1 Looking to grow, learn, or simply get inspired? With Masterclass, anyone can learn from the best to become their best.

Speaker 1 For as low as $10 a month, get unlimited access to over 200 classes taught by world-class business leaders, writers, chefs, and more. Each lesson fits into your schedule.

Speaker 1 You can watch it anytime on your phone or your laptop or TV or switch to audio mode to learn on the go. You can even download classes to watch offline.
And the impact is real.

Speaker 1 88% of members say Masterclass has made a positive difference in their lives. Personally, I've been trying to redecorate my house.
It is just out of my wheelhouse. I can do a lot of things.

Speaker 1 I'm not good at this. So I did a masterclass from Kelly Wurstler on interior design, and it was so helpful.

Speaker 1 Masterclass always has great offerings during the holidays, sometimes up to as much as 50% off. Head over to masterclass.com/slash crime junkie for the current offer.

Speaker 1 That's up to 50% off at masterclass.com/slash crime junkie. Masterclass.com slash crime junkie.

Speaker 1 In possibly the biggest victory her family has gotten, Dr. Singh changes Kayla's manner of death from undetermined to homicide.
Finally. And Kayla's isn't the only case that's amended either.

Speaker 1 According to Haley Gunther's reporting for KQH, Dr. Singh has changed the ruling on four of Dr.
Howard's cases, which, by the way, like huge shout out to Haley.

Speaker 1 She was a huge help in setting us up for success on this story. Like, she made a lot of connections for us.

Speaker 1 Anyway, it's difficult to describe the feeling of relief that washes over the family when they hear this news.

Speaker 1 Like, it is the first step in a long journey ahead of them, but it is the step that they've been fighting for, like, for years. And maybe now, finally, things will start falling into place.

Speaker 1 Except, it's never that easy, is it?

Speaker 1 Because when charging documents are again brought forward to the prosecutor's office in 2022,

Speaker 1 they get denied. And in mid-2024, the family's worst fears come true.
Robert Davis is let out on parole. By the way, they got no warning about that.

Speaker 1 No chance to stand before the parole board and fight to keep him off the streets.

Speaker 1 Since 2024, their cases have again been reassigned. as the most recent investigator retired.

Speaker 1 And both families continue to try and fight for justice, although the fight is getting harder the longer it goes on.

Speaker 1 Heather's mom, Jackie, described living with the pain and the unknowns as a life sentence. Like instead of the person responsible for her daughter's disappearance serving time, she feels like she is.

Speaker 1 And Kayla's family worries that they'll never get to see the day when justice is served for everyone who might be involved with Kayla's murder.

Speaker 1 Kayla's mom, Martine, believes Robert was one of the ones responsible, but she can't help but wonder if someone closer to Kayla may have known what happened and maybe won't come forward for some reason.

Speaker 1 Like, it's a question that has haunted her for years.

Speaker 2 Well, and Robert's mom's story, like, mentions two other guys. Like, is it possible that he's like working with other people or other people know more about this?

Speaker 1 I don't know. I don't know like if there are other people involved.
Again, Kayla's mom seems to think so.

Speaker 1 I think the way that like police view, at least what I picked up, is like they think that he did something to Heather. I don't think they like think he was just there when a body was disposed of.

Speaker 1 That doesn't mean that no one else was involved, but they just think he's far more culpable than just being like a bystander. Now, there have been no more official searches to find Heather's body.

Speaker 1 Like I said, it's difficult terrain where he said she was. So it's going to be difficult to search.

Speaker 1 And like, that's part of the reason that Jackie and her family would be out there doing more, but they literally can't. And without concrete answers, she's left in limbo or that prison, as she says.

Speaker 1 Both moms are. Answers and justice feel so close, but still out of reach.

Speaker 1 And they have to live with the knowledge that their daughters were killed, but the system that is supposed to get them justice has just refused to do so.

Speaker 1 But that grief and frustration is not how either mom wants to remember their girls. Jackie called Heather the defender of the defenseless.

Speaker 1 She had a heart of pure gold, going out of her way to help those experiencing homelessness. Like I said earlier, she was in school for journalism.
She wanted to tell people's stories.

Speaker 1 And I can't help but wonder where that career would have taken her.

Speaker 1 And Martine wants Kayla to be remembered as the vivacious, strong-willed young woman with an infectious laugh who dreamed of a career where she could just help people.

Speaker 1 When she went missing, Kayla was working on getting her GED with dreams of going to nursing school. And there was so much she wanted to give of herself, but she never got the chance to.

Speaker 1 One thing is clear, something needs to change. In the family's opinion, it's the prosecutor.
Today, that prosecutor is a man named Larry Haskell.

Speaker 1 Now, we tried to get in touch with his office, but since it's an open case, they said they wouldn't comment.

Speaker 1 Just about everyone we spoke to for this episode feels that the prosecutor's office won't take this case because it would mean admitting that the original autopsy report from Dr.

Speaker 1 Howard was incorrect, which would call into question hundreds of other rulings. It would likely cost the city millions, but in my opinion, that's a small price to pay.

Speaker 1 How many more cases are there like Kayla's where the ruling was wrong? How many dangerous people are still out causing harm? And on the flip side, there could be innocent people sitting in prison.

Speaker 1 Like the problem goes both ways. Totally.
This case is solvable. I said it at the beginning.

Speaker 1 And enough time has passed that maybe people who didn't feel like they could come forward in 2010 or 2012 might feel safe to do so today.

Speaker 1 So we're going to have contact information for the Spokane PD in our show notes if anyone out there knows something about the disappearance of Heather Higgins or the murder of Kayla Williams.

Speaker 1 And here is my warning to everyone. Robert Davis is still out there.
He is living in Iowa while he's on parole with an ankle monitor, according to Kayla's family.

Speaker 1 An ankle monitor that they say they had to ask for, by the way. They live in fear that he will strike again and they pray that the right person will do the right thing to get him off the streets.

Speaker 1 But in the meantime, crime junkies, this is where you come in. Kayla and Heather's families have been fighting for over a decade for justice.

Speaker 1 They've lost trust in the people that are supposed to fight for them.

Speaker 1 So if you want to join in on that fight, my recommendation is to contact the Washington State Attorney General and ask for a review of Kayla and Heather's cases.

Speaker 1 Nick Brown in his office oversees all of the prosecutors in the state of Washington. And if there is one person who can get things moving in the right direction, it would be him.

Speaker 1 So, we're going to have that contact information in the show notes as well.

Speaker 1 You can find all the source material for this episode on our website, CrimeJunkiePodcast.com.

Speaker 2 And you can follow us on Instagram at Crime Junkie Podcast.

Speaker 1 We'll be back next week with a brand new episode.

Speaker 1 Crime Junkie is an audio Chuck production. So, what do you think, Chuck? Do you approve?

Speaker 3 For adults with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms, every choice matters.

Speaker 3 Trimphaya offers self-injection or intravenous infusion from the start.

Speaker 3 Trimphaya is administered as injections under the skin or infusions through a vein every four weeks, followed by injections under the skin every four or eight weeks.

Speaker 3 If your doctor decides that you can self-inject Trimphaya, proper training is required.

Speaker 3 Tremphaya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis.

Speaker 3 Serious allergic reactions and increased risk of infections and liver problems may occur. Before treatment, your doctor should check you for infections and tuberculosis.

Speaker 3 Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or if you need a vaccine. Explore what's possible.
Ask your doctor about tremphaya today.

Speaker 3 Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more or visit tremphayaradio.com.

Speaker 4 Have you ever experienced something truly unexplainable?

Speaker 4 A moment that felt almost like a vivid dream, leaving you with a lingering sense of wonder, leaving you questioning everything you thought you knew?

Speaker 5 Perhaps it was a fleeting glimpse of something extraordinary, a chilling whisper in the dead of night, or an undeniable premonition that comes to life.

Speaker 5 I'm Yvette Gentile, and I'm her sister, Rasha Pecarrero.

Speaker 4 Each week on our podcast, So Supernatural, we partner with the one and only Ashley Flowers, host of the number one true crime podcast, Crime Junkie, to take you on a journey of the world's most mystical mysteries.

Speaker 5 Ready to explore the unknown?

Speaker 1 Join us every Friday for a new episode of So Supernatural, available wherever you listen to podcasts.