Mystery in Orange County: Behind the Scenes

Speaker 1 Grand Canyon University is one of the largest universities in the country.

Speaker 1 Praised for its community and impact, GCU integrates a welcoming Christian worldview and open discourse into over 300 online programs.

Speaker 1 Redefine your online education through GCU's industry-driven, academically rigorous programs. In 2024, online students received over $161 million in institutional scholarships.
Find your purpose.

Speaker 1 Private, Christian, affordable. Discover available scholarships at gcu.edu/slash slash myoffer.

Speaker 3 It's time for Black Friday, Dell Technologies' biggest sale of the year.

Speaker 3 Enjoy huge savings on select PCs like the Dell 16 Plus, featuring Intel Core ultra-processors and with built-in advanced features. It's the PC that helps you do more faster.

Speaker 3 Plus, earn Dell rewards and enjoy many other benefits like free shipping, price match guarantee, and expert support.

Speaker 3 They also have huge deals on accessories that pair perfectly with your Dell PC and make perfect gifts for everyone on your list. Shop now at dell.com/slash deals.

Speaker 2 I'm Lester Holt. Tonight on Dateline, something new.
This summer, we asked our correspondents to look back on their most memorable stories. Tonight, it's Josh Mankiewicz's turn.
Josh?

Speaker 4 Lester, this is a case that stayed with me for years.

Speaker 4 The case of Maribel Ramos.

Speaker 5 You said your sister didn't come home.

Speaker 4 She just vanished. Yes.

Speaker 6 I was worried.

Speaker 4 Did you think they'd find her? Yes, I did. This was something I had never seen before.
A person who was missing, making sure they were recorded in their own words.

Speaker 7 I always played.

Speaker 7 Why are you crying?

Speaker 8 Because I'm afraid.

Speaker 4 Something had happened to make her pretty scared.

Speaker 5 Yes. She was in danger.

Speaker 4 What was she so afraid of? Or who? You got a roommate who maybe has a crush on her. You got a boyfriend.
You got an ex-boyfriend who's suddenly back in her life.

Speaker 9 There were a number of potential suspects. Absolutely.

Speaker 4 The way the suspect was finally caught, very smart detective work.

Speaker 10 He knew a lot more than he was telling us.

Speaker 4 Tonight, a new look. Mystery in Orange County.

Speaker 4 Orange County, California. On TV, it's a place of sun, fun,

Speaker 4 and privilege. It's where the real housewives first aired their dirty laundry.

Speaker 4 Around here, you get the sense that everyone's rich and white and lives in a mansion with a view of the Pacific.

Speaker 4 But step back from the coast, and you'll see the Orange County that isn't on TV. Not as wealthy, not as white.

Speaker 4 Full of those who came here from somewhere else, chasing a better life and finding it in places like Santa Ana, a mostly working-class immigrant community in the shadow of Disneyland.

Speaker 4 It's the part of the OC where people know that to survive, they'll have to work hard.

Speaker 4 There are a couple of things that made me want to return to this story. First, exactly what happened here was something investigators had to work at.

Speaker 4 And second, the way the suspect was caught was something I'd never seen before or since.

Speaker 4 Maribel Ramos arrived here as a baby leaving Mexico behind. She would not only survive here, but thrive.

Speaker 4 To tell you the truth, this should be the story of a woman who worked hard to change her life and in doing so carved a path for others to follow.

Speaker 7 Hello, I Arnold Boyce.

Speaker 4 But this story is going to end differently.

Speaker 4 Why are you crying?

Speaker 8 Because I'm afraid.

Speaker 4 There are some parts of life that hard work just can't fix.

Speaker 8 I'm just scared.

Speaker 8 I'm just like calling to let you guys know that if something happens, I did it because I was trying to defend myself.

Speaker 4 Some things that are beyond our control.

Speaker 8 All I'm trying to say is that I'm warning.

Speaker 8 Honestly, I will fight for my life, and I swear I will kill him.

Speaker 4 All of this should have never reached that point of no return. So maybe it's a story of simple bad luck, of two lives lives that should never have come together

Speaker 4 tell me about growing up with maribel

Speaker 4 what was she like troublemaker mom wanted her to stay in home and she wanted to go play baseball and tomboy yes yes her sister lucy says tomboy maribel ramos also had a spark I mean she'd come in and immediately what introduce herself to everybody and make friends and people were drawn to to her.

Speaker 5 She's easy to talk to.

Speaker 4 Yet even as a child, Maribel figured out that a different world existed and she wanted to live there.

Speaker 5 Oh, she knew at a young age that there was a lot more to life than what we had around us. There's things you can do and go to school and have opportunities and live in a nicer house.

Speaker 4 She saw all of that.

Speaker 5 Yeah, yeah, definitely.

Speaker 4 Maribel Ramos knew she'd have to work hard to get what and where she wanted. After high school, she worked in security at Kmart and hatched a long-term plan to become a cop.

Speaker 4 But she'd need a college degree, and that meant money.

Speaker 4 So Marabel Ramos became private first-class Ramos. She joined the Army hoping to use the GI Bill.
Her first day was August 8th, 2001. And just 34 days later, the whole world changed.

Speaker 4 I turn on the TV and the towers are crumbling.

Speaker 5 The first thing I thought was, oh my gosh, my sister's going to war. How do you wrap your mind around that?

Speaker 4 Lucy worried. Their mother worried.
But Maribel was like a rock. What did Maribel say about going overseas?

Speaker 5 She didn't express her feelings about it.

Speaker 4 She just

Speaker 5 said, well, this is what's happening, sister. We need to talk to mom.

Speaker 4 Maribel went to war in Iraq. What was it like to see her in uniform?

Speaker 6 It was pretty amazing.

Speaker 4 Giselle Sendejas is Lucy's daughter, Maribel's niece.

Speaker 6 I saw her as like a really brave, strong soldier. Sometimes I wouldn't even see her as my aunt.
I was just like, whoa, you're going out there like to save everybody.

Speaker 4 You were proud of her? Yeah. Maribel learned to jump out of airplanes and she manned the guns for armed convoys.
She also made sergeant. She seemed fearless.

Speaker 4 I'm sorry I never met the most important person in this story because it was difficult not to be impressed with Maribel Ramos and what a star she'd become.

Speaker 4 She set very high standards for herself and others and she had a really clear plan for the rest of her life and all of it was admirable.

Speaker 4 In 2009, after two tours in Iraq, Maribel left the Army and set part two of her plan into action, enrolling in college. But adjusting back to civilian life wasn't as easy as Maribel had expected.

Speaker 4 Like a lot of war veterans, she suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder, or PTSD.

Speaker 4 She'd seen some terrible things. Did she ever talk about that?

Speaker 5 Not with me.

Speaker 4 Instead, she focused on school, work, and family, especially her niece Giselle. She kind of adopted you as this project.

Speaker 4 Yeah. Now, why did she do that?

Speaker 6 I think it was because

Speaker 6 she wanted me to have the best.

Speaker 4 As Giselle grew older, the self-improvement message sometimes came complete with push-ups. After all, Maribel was all army.

Speaker 6 When I would get in trouble, she would make me do exercise in order to like work off the punishment.

Speaker 4 And all this time, Maribel was hammering away at Giselle. You're going to finish school.
Oh, yes.

Speaker 5 This is what you're going to do, Miha. And she would tell him, okay, Giselle? Yes, Dia.

Speaker 4 Maribel got a dog and rented a two-bedroom apartment in the city of Orange, which she shared with a roommate, a quiet chemist named Casey Joy, who also had a dog.

Speaker 5 I thought it was a perfect match. I'm like, he has a dog.
She has a dog. He seems quiet.
You know, he's not going to have all these people coming over.

Speaker 4 By May 2013, everything seemed great. Maribel was leading by example, finishing up her degree in criminal justice at Cal State Fullerton.
Giselle was following in her strong footsteps.

Speaker 6 And she was dropping off money at my house because I had gotten good grades. And she had just got her hair done, dyed, and styled because for her graduation.

Speaker 4 She looked great. Yeah.

Speaker 4 And she was happy.

Speaker 6 Yeah, she was.

Speaker 4 And that's why it made no sense when just days later, Maribel Maribel Ramos, soldier, student, loving Anne,

Speaker 4 simply disappeared.

Speaker 2 What had happened to Marabel Ramos when we come back?

Speaker 5 I'm freaking out. Her door is open, her lights are on, her bed's undone.
Everything was horrible, and I felt it.

Speaker 2 The mystery was about to deepen.

Speaker 10 Nobody'd heard from her. Nobody.

Speaker 4 May 3rd, 2013 was a Friday, a day that should have been an easy day for Maribel Ramos. School was nearly over.
Graduation was so close.

Speaker 4 But that morning, things weren't right.

Speaker 5 I got a text from Casey at 10 a.m., and he said your sister didn't come home.

Speaker 4 They'd been roommates for more than a year now. Casey felt protective of Maribel.
He told Lucy he'd already called police to report her missing.

Speaker 11 Orange Lee's dispatcher wrote, Oh, this is not an emergency. And I have a rume, she's 36 years old, and she didn't come home last night.

Speaker 5 So what I did is I texted her at 11, and I said, happy Friday, because we usually text each other anyways. That was my way of connecting.
And she didn't text me back.

Speaker 4 Unusual? Yes. Lucy still wasn't worried.
She knew her combat-hardened sister could take care of herself.

Speaker 4 But then evening came. And for Maribel, Friday night was softball night.
She loved to play and never missed a game. But this Friday night, she didn't show.
Now Lucy's phone was ringing.

Speaker 4 Maribel's teammates on the line.

Speaker 5 They told me, go to the house. The police are there.
Do not take Giselle.

Speaker 5 I'm freaking out. And I walk in, and my sister's not there.
Her door is open, her lights are on, her bed's undone.

Speaker 5 My head started spinning. Everything was horrible and I felt it.

Speaker 4 Detective Joey Ramirez with the Orange Police Department got the call that evening and he also had a bad feeling about everything.

Speaker 10 The family and friends had expressed that she was very responsible.

Speaker 4 And nobody had heard from her.

Speaker 10 Nobody.

Speaker 4 So Ramirez and his team went into action. They quickly figured out that if she left on her own accord, it didn't look like Maribel had planned to be out long.
She left her car at home.

Speaker 10 Her car was there.

Speaker 10 Her keys were gone. Her phone was gone.

Speaker 4 But her toothbrush was there. So was her big purse she used when she had a lot to carry.

Speaker 5 I woke up on Saturday and I thought, wow, this is seriously happening. So I posted a picture of her on Facebook and it was immediate.
People went into action.

Speaker 4 You might already know this if you watch a lot of Dateline, but missing adults usually don't receive the same kind of attention from law enforcement that missing children do, for example.

Speaker 4 And one of the things that makes a huge difference in cases like this is the involvement of family and friends.

Speaker 4 If you're on the phone a lot, if you're kind of banging on the door of law enforcement regularly, there's a better chance that they're going to move your case to the top of the list of things they're working on.

Speaker 4 Friends from the university got together. Family members, her roommate, lots of people who Maribel had touched wanted to help.
They hung flyers in English and Spanish. They reached out to reporters.

Speaker 12 It's very not like her after eight years of service in the Army to just disappear.

Speaker 13 Unusual thing was being next day, Friday morning, she was not here.

Speaker 6 I helped my mom pass out flyers around school, pretty much anything I could do.

Speaker 4 Did you think they'd find her?

Speaker 6 Yes, I did.

Speaker 4 Giselle was 14 at the time, but Detective Ramirez, who'd been a cop for more years than Giselle had been alive, was not as hopeful.

Speaker 4 When you've picked up no trace of her after a couple of days, you still think you're looking for a living person?

Speaker 10 The percentages are starting to drop.

Speaker 10 Not in our favor.

Speaker 4 Because by then you've called all the hospitals. All hospitals.

Speaker 4 Jails. There's an alert out that any police officer, what, in Southern California sees her.

Speaker 10 Correct. And the media was also helping.

Speaker 4 And nothing. Nothing.

Speaker 4 No Maribel on security tape from any nearby store. Police checked all of them.
They found only this image from the security camera outside the manager's office for her apartment complex.

Speaker 4 It's Maribel paying the rent. It's May 2nd at 8.18 p.m., the night before anyone realized she had disappeared.
Maribel seems to be alone.

Speaker 4 This was the thing nobody wanted to to say out loud in those first couple of days: that the longer somebody's gone without contacting anyone they know, the greater chance there is that it isn't going to end well.

Speaker 4 And that meant police had to start doing what they would do in a murder: going through the missing person's inner circle of friends and contacting people who knew her, people who loved her.

Speaker 4 Turns out there were a lot of people they suddenly needed to get to know, including a current boyfriend, an ex-boyfriend,

Speaker 4 and

Speaker 4 someone Maribel had just met. A guy she'd made a date with online.

Speaker 4 A guy whose name Maribel had apparently kept completely to herself.

Speaker 2 Coming up, the men in Maribel's life suddenly under scrutiny.

Speaker 7 You know, you're not under arrest, anything like that.

Speaker 2 And that haunting phone call.

Speaker 4 I already

Speaker 8 I'm just like calling just to let you guys know that that if something happens, I did it because I was trying to dissens my blow.

Speaker 4 Okay, this was something I've never seen before.

Speaker 1 When dateline continues.

Speaker 12 The Kia Sportage Turbo Hybrid has a full design, a spacious interior with 232 horsepower, and a 12.3-inch panoramic display to keep the adventure going and fit with the way you live.

Speaker 12 And with Sirius XM, every drive comes alive, bringing you closer to the music, sports, talk, and podcasts you love, right in your vehicle or on the Sirius XM app.

Speaker 12 Every Sirius XM-equipped Kia Sportage Turbo Hybrid includes a three-month trial subscription to SiriusXM, so the experience begins the moment you drive.

Speaker 12 Learn more at kia.com slash sportage dash hybrid, Kia movement that inspires.

Speaker 15 Hey everybody, Ted Danson here to tell you about my podcast with my longtime friend and sometimes co-host Woody Harrelson.

Speaker 15 It's called Where Everybody Knows Your Name and we're back for another season.

Speaker 15 I'm so excited to be joined this season by friends like John Mulaney, David Spade, Sarah Silverman, Ed Helms, and many more. You don't want to miss it.

Speaker 15 Listen to Where Everybody Knows Your Name with me, Ted Danson, and Woody Harrison sometimes, wherever you get your podcasts.

Speaker 16 If you're an experienced pet owner, you already know that having a pet is 25% belly rubs, 25% yelling, drop it, and 50% groaning at the bill from every vet visit.

Speaker 16 Which is why Limonade Pet Insurance is tailor-made for your pet and can save you up to 90% on vet bills.

Speaker 16 It can help cover checkups, emergencies, diagnostics, basically all the stuff that makes your bank account nervous. Claims are filed super easy through the LemonAid app and half get settled instantly.

Speaker 16 Get a quote at lemonade.com slash pet and they'll help cover the vet bill for whatever your pet swallowed after you y'all drop it.

Speaker 4 This is the city of Orange, California in the county of Orange, California. Much of it is a small town stuck in time.

Speaker 4 There's a university, a zoo, cute local businesses, and a police department that doesn't have to deal with a lot of violent crime. After all, the happiest place on earth is just down the street.

Speaker 4 But in May 2013, Detective Joey Ramirez was far from happy. He had a lot of ground to cover and a strong sense that time was against him.
as he tried to figure out what had happened to Maribel Ramos.

Speaker 4 She just vanished. Yes.
How often does that kind of thing happen?

Speaker 10 It doesn't happen often.

Speaker 4 Now, we search for and cover cases like this, but the truth is they're rare.

Speaker 4 Whether it's in the city of Orange or where you live, people with families, people with jobs, people with classes to attend, and particularly people who are not involved in something criminal, they don't just unexpectedly go off the grid.

Speaker 4 Ramirez started by investigating the men in Maribel's life. It turned out there were a few of them.

Speaker 4 Yeah, she did. Mirabel sometimes met guys through a website called Plenty of Fish.

Speaker 4 That's how she found Paul Lopez. They'd been dating for a few months, and Paul had even joined her weekly softball game.
Lopez was the last person Maribel talked to on the phone.

Speaker 4 Now police wanted to talk to him.

Speaker 7 You know, you're not under arrest, anything like that.

Speaker 4 Ramirez sat across from Paul and asked about his relationship with Maribel.

Speaker 7 Nothing has been like exclusive. It's just been, you know, dating.
Okay. You date other people too? Me, yeah.
Okay.

Speaker 7 You don't know if she dates other people or not?

Speaker 15 I don't ask, don't tell.

Speaker 4 And he asked Lopez where he was on the night Maribel disappeared.

Speaker 7 Did you come into Orange at all on Thursday?

Speaker 4 No. Police also had to consider this.
Maribel had told Lucy that things weren't working out with Paul Lopez.

Speaker 5 She was in a match with Paul, so she was online talking to people.

Speaker 4 It wasn't clear if Paul knew, even as they kept dating, that Maribel was back on plenty of fish and had met a new man. He was a photographer who'd worked a lot with the military.

Speaker 4 It was a connection for both of them. How did she describe that guy?

Speaker 5 She said that. She said, oh, I met someone.
He's very interesting. We have a lot in common.

Speaker 4 And you thought, what? Good?

Speaker 5 I thought great.

Speaker 4 They planned a date for Cinco de Mayo, but two days before that date was to happen, Maribel vanished. So police talked to that photographer and made a recording of the conversation.

Speaker 10 You're saying you never actually met her in person. No.

Speaker 4 So he said, anyway. There was also an ex-boyfriend who'd been calling.
Police needed to check him out. And there was this lead.

Speaker 10 There was a person at Cal State Fullerton that was in the veterans association with her that had given her a bad feeling. He may have wanted to pursue some sort of dating relationship.

Speaker 4 But it gave her a bad feeling, how?

Speaker 10 She wasn't interested in him, and she didn't give him

Speaker 10 any attention yet, and he didn't go away.

Speaker 4 And by now, Detective Ramirez had learned something else. Just a little over a week before she vanished, Maribel Ramos had called 911.

Speaker 8 Hi, Orange Police. Hi, it's not an emergency, but I just, um, is there recording? Is there a what? Is this conversation recording? Yes, every conversation is recorded.

Speaker 4 Maribel wanted it on the record. She wanted police to know that she was very afraid of someone.

Speaker 8 I'm just like calling just to let you guys know that if something happens, I did it because I was trying to defend myself.

Speaker 4 Okay, that was something I'd never seen before. A person who was missing, a person who was potentially murdered, deliberately calling 911,

Speaker 4 recording themselves in their own words and warning they might commit murder.

Speaker 8 All I'm trying to say is that I'm warning.

Speaker 8 Honestly, I will fight for my life and I swear I will kill him.

Speaker 4 What was she afraid of? Not clear.

Speaker 4 Who was she afraid of?

Speaker 4 That was another story entirely.

Speaker 2 Coming up, Maribel's roommate sits down with police.

Speaker 7 So you were doing your own surveillance? Yes.

Speaker 2 Did he know something that police didn't?

Speaker 4 We've covered a few stories in which family and friends tried to solve the case themselves. This could be one of those times.

Speaker 4 By now, posters blanketed the city of Orange. Maribel Ramos was missing, and her family was frantic.

Speaker 5 As soon as I got a call that she didn't interrupt her baseball game, I got the worst feeling in the world.

Speaker 4 Putting himself out there with all the rest was Maribel's roommate, Casey Joy.

Speaker 13 She's my only family I have. She's my best friend, and I never have to come back, that's all.

Speaker 4 Casey had moved from Tennessee to Southern California for a job. He had no family and few friends here.
So he turned to Maribel, and she was happy to include him.

Speaker 4 She even arranged for Casey to tutor her niece in math.

Speaker 6 He seemed nice,

Speaker 6 respectful.

Speaker 4 He

Speaker 6 liked to be involved with the family and my aunt.

Speaker 4 He didn't have a family of his own so he kind of attached himself to yours. Yeah.
But they weren't boyfriend and girlfriend. No.

Speaker 4 Even so, in photos, Maribel and KC seemed to be having a great time. They even went on a cruise together.
Soon, police would be talking with Casey Joy.

Speaker 7 Yeah, that's a good idea.

Speaker 4 The formalities over. Detective Ramirez started asking about Maribel.

Speaker 7 As you know, right now, there's some people, some family and friends that are worried about Maribel, your roommate.

Speaker 7 I'm also a friend, and I care about her very much.

Speaker 4 But he said he had no idea what happened to her.

Speaker 7 So when was the last time that you saw her?

Speaker 4 The next night, when the cops were called to Maribel's house, Casey wasn't there.

Speaker 4 He explained he'd been so worried that he did his own investigation, watching his own front door from his car parked out front.

Speaker 7 detective movie if somebody was coming back to their crime scene or whatever. I want to see who's going to knock him out the word.
So I just parked a car in the front.

Speaker 7 I took my notebook, had a binocular in theory. So you were doing your own surveillance? Yes.
Thank you.

Speaker 4 That sounded strange to me then, and okay, it still does, but keep this in mind. Right now, a lot of you consider yourselves amateur detectives, and some of you are pretty good at it.

Speaker 4 We've covered a few stories in which family and friends tried to solve the case themselves with varying degrees of success, and

Speaker 4 this could be one of those times.

Speaker 4 Except, here's what was weird: some odd injuries to Maribel's roommate, Casey Joy.

Speaker 10 He's sitting across the table from me, he's wearing short-sleeved shirt, he has jeans on and sandals. And instantly, I can see scratches on both his arms.

Speaker 10 He's got a scratch across his forehead from his hairline to his eye.

Speaker 7 How'd you get all these scratches on you?

Speaker 7 We go to Eisenhower Park all the time. Uh-huh.

Speaker 7 You go go exactly, we pick up at the pond,

Speaker 7 we pick up fishing lines all the time. You go there,

Speaker 7 fishing lines.

Speaker 7 Those are from fishing lines? No, no, no, no. I'm ready to explain.

Speaker 4 Casey explained he was walking the dogs when he saw a fishing line in a bush. Worrying about the ducks in the park getting caught in the line, he reached in to remove it and got all those scratches.

Speaker 10 There was one particular set of scratches on his right bicep that, to me, clearly looked like

Speaker 10 scratches from a hand.

Speaker 4 And that says to you he was in a fight.

Speaker 10 It does.

Speaker 7 When was the last time you guys had any sort of an argument? Actually, the Thursday.

Speaker 7 This Thursday?

Speaker 4 That was the last night anyone saw Maribel. The night she was caught on camera paying the rent.
Which, Casey said, was what they were arguing about.

Speaker 7 What would happen?

Speaker 4 It turned out Casey had recently lost his job and could no longer pay his share of the rent. Maribel had asked him to move out.
That was reason for concern, of course. And so was this.

Speaker 4 Detective Ramirez had learned about the 911 call Maribel had made 11 days before she disappeared. And he knew that in that call, the man Maribel said she might have to kill

Speaker 4 was Casey Joy.

Speaker 8 His full name is Kwan

Speaker 4 Chul.

Speaker 8 What I understand is Kwan Chu Joy.

Speaker 7 Now, weren't the police out to your house recently because you guys had an argument? We've been drinking quite a bit that night,

Speaker 7 and she started yelling at me.

Speaker 4 Casey said it was all just a drunken misunderstanding.

Speaker 7 I don't like you. I'm not attracted to you.
She starts screaming and yelling. I said, Maribel,

Speaker 7 we had a great time tonight. What's the problem?

Speaker 4 What was the problem? Detective Ramirez heard from Maribel's family something very interesting. Casey Joy had wanted to be more than just roommates with Maribel Ramos.

Speaker 4 When did it become apparent to you that Casey sort of had a crush on your sister?

Speaker 5 Yeah, he called me and then he just says,

Speaker 5 I'm like in love with your sister.

Speaker 4 So I was like, oh, this is great. Because you knew that your sister wasn't in love with him.

Speaker 5 Yes, and that's a bad situation. So at that point, I'm like, okay, Casey, you know,

Speaker 5 you know, you're a good man, and I'm sure you'll find somebody out there for you, but.

Speaker 4 But it's not going to be her. Yeah.

Speaker 4 Now, the woman Casey had told Lucy he wanted had told him that not only did she not love him, but he had to basically get out of her life.

Speaker 4 Despite that. Casey continued talking with police.
Mr. Joy was being cooperative.

Speaker 15 He was.

Speaker 4 Talking to officers, officers, let you guys take stuff out of the house.

Speaker 10 He did.

Speaker 4 And never showed up with a lawyer.

Speaker 10 He did not.

Speaker 4 Doesn't sound like that did a lot to set aside your suspicions. No,

Speaker 10 he didn't.

Speaker 4 Suspicions, sure, but no proof of crime had even occurred. Maribel Ramos was missing.
That's all anyone knew.

Speaker 7 Ready, sir?

Speaker 4 And so Casey Joy walked out of that police station, like all the other men in Maribel's life, a free man

Speaker 4 coming up he knew a lot more than he was telling us finally the clue detectives had been waiting for no one had searched there no but he's looking at it yes and you won't believe how they got it very smart detective work when dateline continues

Speaker 17 hey everybody it's rob low here if you haven't heard i have a podcast that's called literally with rob low And basically, it's conversations I've had that really make you feel like you're pulling up a chair at an intimate dinner between myself and people that I admire, like Aaron Sorkin or Tiffany Haddish, Demi Moore, Chris Pratt, Michael J.

Speaker 14 Fox.

Speaker 9 There are new episodes out every Thursday.

Speaker 17 So subscribe, please, and listen wherever you get your podcasts.

Speaker 18 A massage chair might seem a bit extravagant, especially these days. Eight different settings, adjustable intensity, plus it's heated, and it just feels so good.

Speaker 18 Yes, a massage chair might seem a bit extravagant, but when it can come with a car,

Speaker 18 suddenly it seems quite practical. The Volkswagen Tiguan, packed with premium features like available massaging front seats, It only feels extravagant.

Speaker 16 If you're an experienced pet owner, you already know that having a pet is 25% 25% belly rubs, 25% yelling, drop it, and 50% groaning at the bill from every vet visit.

Speaker 16 Which is why Lemonade Pet Insurance is tailor-made for your pet and can save you up to 90% on vet bills.

Speaker 16 It can help cover checkups, emergencies, diagnostics, basically all the stuff that makes your bank account nervous. Claims are filed super easy through the Lemonade app and half get settled instantly.

Speaker 16 Get a quote at lemonade.com/slash pet, and they'll help cover the vet bill for whatever your pet swallowed after you yelled, drop it.

Speaker 4 The days were ticking by and still no Maribel. Forensic results were coming in, DNA, fingerprints, cell phone data.
None of it added up to anything that told the cops what had happened to her.

Speaker 4 So police were looking at the usual suspects, like her boyfriend Paul Lopez.

Speaker 4 Lopez worked for the gas company and went from call to call in a company company truck.

Speaker 4 The GPS on that truck put him nowhere near the city of Orange on the night Maribel was seen on that security video. That is until about midnight.
Lopez told police that's when he went home.

Speaker 4 He said he was alone and could prove it.

Speaker 7 My parking spot is actually right by a surveillance camera. So the surveillance camera would show you parking.

Speaker 4 That was enough to get Lopez off the list. There was that ex-boyfriend who'd been calling.
Maribel had never mentioned he'd been a problem, and police didn't think he was involved.

Speaker 4 There was the photographer from the website Plenty of Fish. His cell phone data placed him in San Diego, out of the area at the time in question.

Speaker 4 And the veteran from Cal State who'd come on too strong?

Speaker 4 He was in Japan. None of them could be connected to Maribel's disappearance.

Speaker 4 So in the end, there was just one person the cops couldn't stop looking at. The first person to report Maribel missing, her roommate, Casey Joy.

Speaker 11 Orange Sleece Dispatcher is, oh, this is not an emergency. And I have a roommate, she's 36 years old, and she didn't come home last night.

Speaker 10 I felt she most likely was dead.

Speaker 10 I felt that there was a high probability Mr. Joy was responsible for it.
And he knew a lot more than he was telling us.

Speaker 4 So Detective Ramirez became Casey Joy's shadow. He showed up at his house.
So when you say work, she works at Fort Furton. Caltech Furton?

Speaker 4 No question. Plenty of cases are made or lost in those police interviews.
And I've seen detectives do all kinds of things to get a suspect talking and keep a suspect talking.

Speaker 4 And in the case of Maribel Ramos, Casey Joy did the one thing that nearly every criminal attorney I've ever met will tell you not to do.

Speaker 4 Keep answering questions from police without knowing what the questions are going to be. And he did all of it without a lawyer.

Speaker 7 This is Bree. Bree, this is Casey.
He's been very cooperative with us.

Speaker 7 He's got

Speaker 7 Hustin movies. Now you can take this to pick up fingerprints.

Speaker 4 He says to you, oh, I've seen this movie and now you're going to take my fingerprints. He's like a pro.

Speaker 4 He's seen it all.

Speaker 10 He's being very relaxed. I felt that he was very confident that we weren't going to figure it out.

Speaker 4 What Mr. Joy apparently didn't know was that other officers were watching him 24-7.

Speaker 4 The surveillance teams noticed he was spending a lot of time at the public library, and he was using the computers there, probably because police had taken away his phone and Maribel's computer.

Speaker 4 which was the one KC normally used.

Speaker 10 Initially, we would have an undercover policeman go into the library, walk around him, see what he's doing. And at one point he's seen googling can a cell phone be tracked if it's turned off?

Speaker 4 Well that's certainly suspicious. It is.

Speaker 4 Detective Ramirez was consulting daily with Orange County Deputy District Attorney Scott Simmons.

Speaker 4 There are things that can be called into question, but they're not immediately proof of anything.

Speaker 9 Exactly, and that's why we didn't arrest him right away.

Speaker 4 Police needed to see exactly what KC Joy was doing on those library computers. That would require a very unusual plan.

Speaker 4 They obtained a search warrant allowing them to watch, in real time, every move made on the computer. This was something I hadn't seen before.

Speaker 4 It was very proactive, and to me it felt like a big-time move by a small police department that usually doesn't work cases like this. It was very smart detective work.

Speaker 4 This is a recording of Casey's actual computer keystrokes and mouse clicks. That's Casey checking his email.
That's Casey applying for a job.

Speaker 4 That's Casey typing in, how long does it take a body to decay?

Speaker 4 Suspicious maybe, but not enough. And then he did this.

Speaker 10 He pulled up a Facebook page that showed there was going to be an awareness walk in the near future.

Speaker 4 A walk to help find Maribel. It was.

Speaker 10 He Google mapped that park

Speaker 10 and zoomed in onto it. He then panned out,

Speaker 10 navigated over about eight to ten miles.

Speaker 4 This area that he was zeroing in on, was it an area that had crossed your field of vision at all? No.

Speaker 4 Here, Casey is Google mapping a place that no one had searched. Watch as he zooms into that area with the tree.
That tree didn't figure in the investigation in any way.

Speaker 9 Not in any stretch of the imagination.

Speaker 4 No one had searched there. No.
And no reason for that to be in the paper or anywhere else. No.
I mean, it's out in a remote canyon location. But he's looking at it.
Yes.

Speaker 3 Yes.

Speaker 4 By the time Casey was walking out of the library that afternoon, police were already headed to that tree.

Speaker 15 Coming up.

Speaker 2 Another startling discovery.

Speaker 20 This is way off the beaten path. We didn't know what to think.

Speaker 2 And the suspect speaks. Hear from Casey Joy himself.

Speaker 4 You're being framed here?

Speaker 21 I said yes.

Speaker 4 As he dug deeper into Casey Joy's background, Detective Joey Ramirez found more and more evidence that Casey was infatuated, even obsessed, with Maribel Ramos.

Speaker 4 For instance, the time Maribel told KC he was too old for her, and he responded by getting plastic surgery. $12,000 later, he's got a different face.

Speaker 10 Correct.

Speaker 4 And he says the reason he got it is because of the woman who's missing.

Speaker 10 Correct.

Speaker 4 Now, here was Casey at the public library. Google mapping a remote wilderness area.
Since the dawn of detective novels, killers have returned to the scene of the crime.

Speaker 4 But these days, there's no need for the bad guy to even get in his car. Now, it can be done with the click of a mouse.

Speaker 4 The good guys still have to do it the old-fashioned way.

Speaker 4 Detective Sean Hayden got the call on the radio. Drive out to rustic Majessica Canyon, southeast of the city of Orange.

Speaker 20 We didn't know what to think. This is very rural area.
No one would be out here mountain biking or hiking. This is way off the beaten path.

Speaker 4 At the other end of the two-way radio, Detective Brian Stanley was re-watching Casey's Google search, trying to give Detective Hayden better directions.

Speaker 4 Casey focused on an intersection and then moved over to the tree.

Speaker 22 In the center of the shot, there's one tree that looks like a bush out in the middle of the wash. So I told him to look for that tree and then in the wash from that area.

Speaker 4 Hayden and his partner found the tree, then moved off the road and past the barbed wire fence, and then they knew knew they were close.

Speaker 20 As we were kind of trekking through this brush here, the first and foremost thing we found was an overwhelming smell of like a decaying body or something dead and my partner and I kind of turned our head and we looked over and we saw this kind of shallow gravesite.

Speaker 10 One of the detectives called and said, Joey, you're not going to believe this.

Speaker 10 We found her.

Speaker 4 Maribel Ramos had been left alone in that dusty canyon since before anyone knew she was missing.

Speaker 4 Now Ramirez knew it was time for one last meeting with Casey Joy.

Speaker 7 Well thanks for coming down here voluntarily. I really appreciate it.

Speaker 7 You're going to get me right back to the library then I'll have to walk.

Speaker 4 Ramirez didn't tell Casey that Maribel had been found. He just tried for the final time to get Casey to be the one.
who would say what had happened.

Speaker 7 Casey, I think that you have the answers in your heart that you do and that you should share the go.

Speaker 4 So once again, Casey Joy walked out of the interview room. He didn't get far.
This time, he was arrested and charged with the murder of Maribel Ramos, the woman he had loved who had not loved him.

Speaker 4 When he was taken into custody, Casey Joy was wearing Maribel's dog tags. Casey Joy pleaded not guilty.
And in July 2014, a year after Maribel vanished, he went on trial for her murder.

Speaker 9 It's Maribel Ramos.

Speaker 9 Maribel is no longer with us.

Speaker 4 The prosecution laid out the evidence against KC. The unrequited love, the scratches, the 911 call, and finally the computer searches.

Speaker 9 He's wondering, how close is Mirabel's body to where they're doing that awareness search?

Speaker 9 That's why he goes to Google Maps.

Speaker 4 And it was murdered. The defense pointed out there was no DNA, fingerprints, cell phone info, or standard forensic evidence that tied Casey Joy to Maribel's murder or to the crime scene.

Speaker 4 We don't know what happened.

Speaker 21 What kind of force was used?

Speaker 19 Nobody knows.

Speaker 21 Who used it first?

Speaker 19 Nobody knows.

Speaker 4 Was there a weapon used?

Speaker 19 Was it used by Maribel or was it used by Casey Joy? Nobody knows.

Speaker 4 Casey Joy told me police arrested the wrong guy. Are you dangerous?

Speaker 19 Me? I'm the perfect, most honest guy there is and most trustworthy. I'm a gentleman.

Speaker 4 As for that computer search of the area where Maribel's body was found, Casey said he didn't do it. Someone else did by remotely accessing the same computer right after he had used it.

Speaker 21 Cops are all pointing finger at me. Only thing they had was that map, Google Map.

Speaker 4 You're being framed here?

Speaker 21 I said yes.

Speaker 4 The jury didn't buy it.

Speaker 23 We, the jury, in the above-intelligction, find the defendant, Kwancho Joy, guilty of the crime of felony to whip.

Speaker 4 Casey Joy was convicted of second-degree murder. He insisted the jury got it wrong.
And in our interview, just as he did with police, he seemed ready to talk all day.

Speaker 4 Except, of course, about Maribel Ramos. You had a crush on her.

Speaker 21 Nope, we are absolutely not. It was, I always maintain that we are platonic friends.

Speaker 4 That part of the interview was absolutely unforgettable. Because while we spoke, this convicted murderer seemed to kind of forget where he was, which was in the lockup.

Speaker 4 He began by saying he didn't want to talk about his relationship with Maribel.

Speaker 4 And I insisted. And then he got angry.
You never told Lucy that you had a crush on her.

Speaker 21 Nope, I never said that.

Speaker 4 You never said you were in love with her.

Speaker 21 Nope, never said that either.

Speaker 4 You weren't obsessed with her.

Speaker 21 Nope, I was not obsessed with her.

Speaker 4 If you got plastic surgery, let's not get into that.

Speaker 21 If you got plastic surgery, I'm going to walk up if we want to keep on, we want to talk about my trial.

Speaker 4 All of a sudden, he stands up like he's going to leave, like he's a free man. That part didn't work out so well.
I want to know about your relationship with Maribel. Done, done, sir.

Speaker 4 Casey Joy was sentenced to 15 years to life. He's eligible for parole in 2024.

Speaker 4 Maribel Ramos graduated from college posthumously. Her niece Giselle, who Maribel had always hoped would follow in her footsteps, instead ended up walking the path meant for her aunt.

Speaker 6 I received her diploma and I got to sit in her seat and walk upstage and receive everything.

Speaker 5 It was so difficult to be there.

Speaker 5 It was difficult to see my daughter in such pain.

Speaker 4 walking for her aunt.

Speaker 4 The day this story first aired on Dateline was also the day my own father died. Like Maribel, his service in the Army was a big part of what shaped him.
And like Maribel, he was fluent in Spanish.

Speaker 4 I was definitely thinking a lot about both of them that day.

Speaker 11 Maribel Ramos, we lost this gal a couple years ago. She was an Army veteran.

Speaker 4 Regularly in Old Town Orange, they lower the flag for the fallen who served.

Speaker 4 But Maribel has a legacy. Giselle seems well on her way to becoming the successful woman Maribel had hoped for.
Your mom says that you've sort of been the rock.

Speaker 6 Yeah.

Speaker 4 That they wouldn't have made it through this without you. Yes.

Speaker 4 Where'd you get that toughness? From her.

Speaker 4 From Maribel. Yeah.

Speaker 2 And that's all for this edition of Dateline. We'll see you again Friday at 10, 9 Central.

Speaker 4 I'm Lester Holt for all of us at NBC News. Good night.

Speaker 18 A massage chair might seem a bit extravagant, especially these days. Eight different settings, adjustable intensity, plus it's heated, and it just feels so good.

Speaker 18 Yes, a massage chair might seem a bit extravagant, but when it can come with a car,

Speaker 18 suddenly it seems quite practical. The Volkswagen Tiguan, packed with premium features like available massaging front seats, it only feels extravagant.