Nightfall

Speaker 1 the Creator of Homeland, Claire Daines and Matthew Rees star in the new Netflix series The Beast in Me as ruthless rivals whose shared darkness will set them on a collision course with fatal consequences.

Speaker 1 The Beast in Me is a riveting psychological cat-and-mouse story about guilt and justice and doubt, now playing only on Netflix.

Speaker 2 If you're a maintenance supervisor at a manufacturing facility and your machinery isn't working right, Granger knows you need to understand what's wrong as soon as possible.

Speaker 2 So, when a conveyor motor falters, Granger offers diagnostic tools like calibration kits and multimeters to help you identify and fix the problem.

Speaker 2 With Granger, you can be confident you have everything you need to keep your facility running smoothly. Call 1-800-GRANGER, ClickGranger.com, or just stop by.
Granger for the ones who get it done.

Speaker 3 It's gut-wrenching. There's a body laying off the side of the road.
This young woman was shot three times. This was a murder.

Speaker 4 A young single mom out with friends on game day.

Speaker 5 It was packed.

Speaker 4 But as night fell, fear grew.

Speaker 3 They're asking us, Do you know anybody that would want to harm your sister? Was it someone that was a stranger? Was it someone that we knew?

Speaker 6 I just had this weird feeling that there is something she was hiding.

Speaker 4 Tucked away in her kitchen, a clue to it all.

Speaker 3 On top of the refrigerator was a manila folder. Did that just give you chills? It was horrible.
Why didn't she just tell us?

Speaker 4 Did a secret lead to murder?

Speaker 3 It's got to be unimaginable.

Speaker 7 I'm Lester Holt, and this is Dateline.

Speaker 4 Here's Andrea Canning with Nightfall.

Speaker 3 I'd ask that you all close your eyes for a few minutes this morning.

Speaker 3 I'd like for you to envision Roan County in the middle of October.

Speaker 3 The leaves are changing. There's a little bit of a nip in the air.

Speaker 3 Now envision Brooke Morris standing there

Speaker 3 and

Speaker 3 Brooke feels like she's been punched in the throat. She's been shot.

Speaker 3 Brooke feels like a bomb goes off in her body.

Speaker 3 This is the second second shot, and it tears through her chest.

Speaker 3 She's terrified, and she's in extreme pain.

Speaker 3 Thank you. You can open your eyes.
The final minutes of a young woman's life. Detailed in a Tennessee courtroom.
A tragedy that devastated her family and friends. This cannot be happening.

Speaker 6 It was really the worst day of my entire life.

Speaker 3 Who would do this to our friend Brooke? It was awful. It was horrible.
It was a horrible time. Secrets exposed, but would justice be served? It was never ending.
Never ending. And I was so frustrated.

Speaker 3 Most people who knew Brooke Morris remember her radiance and zest for life. She was always, always, always dancing everywhere she went.

Speaker 3 Caitlin Oakle met Brooke when they were teenagers, growing up just outside Knoxville, Tennessee. Brooke, the yin to Caitlin's yang.
We kind of balanced each other out.

Speaker 3 She was a girly girl, and I was more the tomboy.

Speaker 3 So I'd go to her house and change into a thousand outfits and trial makeup and do our hair, and then she'd come to my house, and we'd ride foilers and play on the farm.

Speaker 3 Sounds like you two were almost more like sisters. Oh, yeah.
We even fought like sisters.

Speaker 3 That's when you know you're good friends. Yes, yes, for sure.

Speaker 3 This is Brooke's real sister, Brittany, and their mom, Tina. What did she like to do?

Speaker 1 Clothes.

Speaker 3 Clothes. Very, very girly.
Yes. Loved doing hair and stuff like that.
She was just a girly girl. A little Southern Belle.

Speaker 1 Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Yeah. Yes.

Speaker 3 The little Southern Belle grew into a beautiful young woman, sometimes blonde, sometimes brunette. Brooke always drew people into her lively orbit.

Speaker 6 Really spontaneous, fun, hilarious. I'm just the life of the party.
Could literally make friends with anyone.

Speaker 3 Dina Renee was one of them.

Speaker 6 She would come over to my house and she'd be like, we're going out tonight. We're going to have fun.

Speaker 3 And that meant one thing on fall Saturdays in Knoxville. Volunteers football at the University of Tennessee.

Speaker 3 Oh my goodness. If you are not from Tennessee, you better watch out.
The strip is completely packed. There are ball fans everywhere.
It is so much fun. Lots of kicking out, lots and lots of fun.

Speaker 3 Lots and lots of orange. Lots of orange.
Was this something that Brooke looked forward to? Oh, yeah. On Saturdays? Yeah, all of us at that age, you know.
That was what you did on Saturday.

Speaker 3 You wanted to get your orange and white outfits and

Speaker 3 figure out where you're going to be.

Speaker 3 October 15th, 2011 started out as one of those fun days. The Vols were taking on Louisiana State and Brooke was tailgating with friends.
But by nightfall, something was terribly wrong.

Speaker 3 911, where's your emergency?

Speaker 1 We're down here on Blair Road.

Speaker 3 40 miles away from Knoxville, a couple was driving down a country road. They were keeping an eye out for crossing deer when their headlights illuminated something else.

Speaker 3 And there's a body laying off the other road. Okay, I need somebody to check for a pulse.

Speaker 3 She's a bloody mess, ma'am. I understand.

Speaker 3 Chief Deputy Tim Phillips of the Roan County Sheriff's Office had just finished watching the football game when Dispatch called him at home.

Speaker 3 What information were you given before you arrived at the scene as you were driving there?

Speaker 8 Essentially, I had a white female that was deceased that was laying on the side of the road.

Speaker 3 The body had been found just after 8 p.m. at the intersection of two quiet rural roads not far from the chief's home.
The woman had not been dead for very long.

Speaker 3 When you arrived here, what did you see?

Speaker 8 The victim's body was over here on the side of the road, close to the intersection here at Old Blair.

Speaker 3 Right on the road?

Speaker 8 Yeah, right on the white line, you know.

Speaker 3 What did she look like? What could you see?

Speaker 8 She was well-dressed, wearing blue jeans, boots, and a bright orange shirt. She had her purse there with her and everything.

Speaker 3 IDing the victim was the easy part. Her driver's license was found right in her purse at the scene.
It was 23-year-old Brooke Morris.

Speaker 3 The hard part would be unraveling the mystery that led to her death on this lonely country road. Was it someone that was a stranger to us? Was it someone that we knew?

Speaker 3 All kinds of things were coming into our heads, you know, trying to figure this all out.

Speaker 4 When we come back, what had happened to Brooke?

Speaker 3 They're asking us, do you know anybody that would want to harm your sister?

Speaker 1 And we're like, we don't have a clue.

Speaker 4 The hunt for a killer begins, and it starts close to home.

Speaker 3 Ex-husbands, husbands, spouses are always looked at. They are.

Speaker 8 Our main objective is to try to find out what he'd been doing that evening.

Speaker 3 Brooke Morris had been found dead on the side of a rural road. 40 miles away in Knoxville, her older sister Brittany felt a sudden wave come over her in the middle of the night.
She woke her husband.

Speaker 3 And I said, I just feel really sick, like just all of a sudden, really sick at my stomach. And he was like, well, what do you think's going on? I'm like, I don't know.
I just feel really nauseous.

Speaker 3 And it wasn't 20 minutes later, I get a phone call. Sheriff's deputies were looking for her mother, Tina.
He didn't want to tell us much until he talked to mom first.

Speaker 3 Tina was at a friend's house. Both Chief Phillips and Brittany headed over there.
Mom, you know, comes to the door and then she looks at me and she's like, it's Brooke, isn't it? And I'm like, yeah.

Speaker 3 How did you know?

Speaker 3 I knew it had to be because Brittany was there.

Speaker 1 Yeah.

Speaker 3 You know, so it had to be.

Speaker 9 I've delivered

Speaker 8 more than my share of death notifications. And this particular one was,

Speaker 8 I'll never forget it. I just asked her to sit on the couch and we sat there for a second.
I said, you know, where... Is Brooke Morris your daughter? And said, she is.

Speaker 8 And I said, well, she's been murdered.

Speaker 3 She passed out, cold.

Speaker 3 So, I mean, we had to get her to, you know, come back to. And I think we were just all shocked.
When Tina came to, she could hardly process what had happened. It was almost like it was not real.

Speaker 3 You know, you've got the wrong person. It's not her.

Speaker 3 But it was real. Brooke was dead.
She'd been shot three times, once in her neck, once in her chest, and an execution-style style shot to the back of her head.

Speaker 3 I could not believe that another human could be so heartless. You know, they're asking us these questions like,

Speaker 3 who would, do you know anybody that would want to harm your sister? And we're like,

Speaker 1 we don't have a clue.

Speaker 3 I could not even think of someone that would want to hurt Brooke. In any way, everybody loved Brooke.
But investigators had to start somewhere.

Speaker 3 Although only 23 years old, Brooke already had an ex-husband, Clayton Morris. She met him soon after high school.
He was kind of country, you know. They just hit it off.

Speaker 3 They just had fun together and started dating, and then the surprise popped up. She comes home with some news, some big news.

Speaker 3 She was totally excited, of course.

Speaker 3 I was not so much excited.

Speaker 3 Brooke, then 20 years old, was pregnant. I thought Brooke was too young for one thing.
And,

Speaker 3 you know, it's just, it's not what I had hoped for her at that time. Brooke and Clayton were determined to make a go of it as a family.
So before they became three, they got married.

Speaker 3 Then they had this sweet baby that just

Speaker 3 stole my heart. in an instant.
Didn't that make it all better? It did. When you met your grandson.

Speaker 3 Yes. And how was Brooke as a mom? Did she just take right to it? Oh, yeah.

Speaker 3 They moved into a house and both had jobs. But the young couple soon realized that family life came with grown-up responsibilities and problems.
Did she confide in you at all about how things

Speaker 3 were not great at home? Yeah, of course. She talked to her friends about it.
We tried to be as supportive that we can, but we were on such a different level than she was.

Speaker 3 You know, here we were still single, and she was married with a baby. So hard for us to kind of relate in that area.
But I think

Speaker 3 she knew that it wasn't going to work, you know.

Speaker 3 After two years, the couple split. Brooke moved out and Clayton stayed in the house with their son.
But Brooke's family says she and Clayton were committed to raising the child together.

Speaker 3 Well, she lived, you know, just a few doors up from Clayton, and they had shared custody of the baby. Was it an amicable divorce or did they fight?

Speaker 3 They had some disagreements, you know. They definitely had some disagreements.
Ex-husbands, husbands, spouses are always looked at. They are.

Speaker 3 Did you feel he was an important person to talk to as well?

Speaker 1 We did.

Speaker 3 Did you call him right away?

Speaker 8 We actually went and seen him.

Speaker 3 It was the middle of the night, just hours after Brooke's body was discovered. When investigators arrived at Clayton's house, Chief Phillips woke him up.
So, what do you say to him then?

Speaker 8 We didn't tell him that Brooke was deceased, and our main objective is to try to find out what he had been doing that evening.

Speaker 3 You want to hear his story before you talk about what happened to Brooke.

Speaker 3 Clayton told investigators he had their son that weekend. He said he was at work all day Saturday and then spent the evening at home.
Could he have left the child and gone out? He could have.

Speaker 10 Coming up.

Speaker 3 We were all just trying to figure out who would have done this and why.

Speaker 4 Scouring the scene of the crime, bullets and Brooks' phone. What will they reveal?

Speaker 8 Very helpful to us.

Speaker 4 When dateline continues.

Speaker 1 Struggling to see up close?

Speaker 2 Make it visible with Viz.

Speaker 1 Viz is a once-daily prescription eye drop to treat blurry near vision for up to 10 hours.

Speaker 1 The most common side effects that may be experienced while using Viz include eye irritation, temporary dim or dark vision, headaches, and eye redness.

Speaker 1 Talk to an eye doctor to learn if Viz is right for you. Learn more at Viz.com.
Looking to crack the code on your career? Well, maybe it's time to get your degree.

Speaker 1 Southern New Hampshire University offers over 200 programs you can complete online. No set class times means you can do it all on your schedule.

Speaker 1 And with some of the lowest online tuition rates in the U.S., they make getting your degree affordable, too.

Speaker 1 Get started at SNHU.edu slash dateline. That's snhu dot edu slash dateline.
Most holiday gifts end up in a drawer or the back of your closet or accidentally left at your cousin's house. Not this one.

Speaker 1 Mint Mobile is offering unlimited premium wireless for $15 a month. That's their best deal of the year, aka a holiday gift you'll actually use every single day.
Don't get them socks.

Speaker 1 Get them premium wireless for $15 a month. Shop Mint Unlimited plans at mintmobile.com slash dateline.
That's mintmobile.com slash dateline. Limited time offer.

Speaker 1 Upfront payment of $45 for 3 months, $90 for 6 months, or $180 for 12 months. Plan required, $15 per month equivalent.
Taxes and fees extra. Initial plan term only.

Speaker 1 Greater than 35 gigabytes may slow when the network is busy. Capable device required.
Availability, speed, and coverage vary. See Mintmobile.com.

Speaker 3 Brooke Morris was laid to rest at just 23 years old. And while her friends said their goodbyes, her mother Tina admits to being in denial about Brooke's death.

Speaker 3 I kept thinking, you know, she's going to call. She's going to call.
I know she's going to call and she's going to say, mom,

Speaker 3 you know, it was a

Speaker 3 big mix-up, you know, I just couldn't grasp that she was gone forever.

Speaker 3 Tina had a very hard time.

Speaker 3 I remember being at her funeral and Tina was holding this picture of Brooke just crying just hysterically. I mean, two people had to carry her to the grave site.

Speaker 3 Along with grief, there was something else. How scary was it to you that whoever did this was out there? Oh, very scary.
I mean, because they've taken something from you?

Speaker 3 I mean, what are their motives for us? Roan County investigators, tasked with bringing Brooke's killer to justice, had spoken to her ex-husband, Clayton Morris, the night of the murder.

Speaker 3 Were you getting any kind of a vibe from Clayton?

Speaker 8 You know, sometimes you can read people and, you know, people throw off body language, but he just seemed like, what in the world's going on?

Speaker 3 and despite the tension during the marriage and divorce those who knew brooke best didn't think her ex-husband was a killer i just never entertained that thought clayton was a good person so i didn't think that you know he would be capable of doing something like that to brooke

Speaker 3 more importantly clayton's alibi checked out investigators cleared him If not the ex-husband, then who? Who had Brooke come in contact with that weekend?

Speaker 3 Investigators retraced Brooke's steps, starting not with the game on Saturday, but with the night before, Friday. Friends told investigators they had tickets to a concert.

Speaker 6 She was super excited about going to that. So she was just like, okay,

Speaker 6 I've got to go find something to wear. I'm going to go to dinner.

Speaker 3 After dinner, Brooke left her car in a shopping center parking lot near the restaurant and drove with friends to the concert. She spent the night at Dina's house.

Speaker 6 I called it Hotel Dina. Like everyone just stayed.

Speaker 6 Left it unlocked for everyone, you know.

Speaker 3 The next day, Saturday, was the Tennessee LSU football game and everyone was looking forward to tailgating. But the fun day turned sour.

Speaker 3 Brooke borrowed something out of Dina's closet and the girlfriends had an argument about it.

Speaker 6 I had found out she wore it without asking.

Speaker 3 It was a silly fight, but it stuck with Brooke. She didn't tailgate for long.

Speaker 6 She had been calling all these people to pick her up, take her to her car, because she wanted to change her outfit for the for that night.

Speaker 3 Brooke's friend, Albert Dotson, had been tailgating with her earlier in the day.

Speaker 5 So we would like break off. And I was with some other friends of ours at that time.

Speaker 5 So I'm not really sure where she was.

Speaker 3 Neither Dina nor Albert ever saw Brooke again.

Speaker 3 And with more than 100,000 football fans flooding the city for the game, Finding Brooke's killer was like looking for a needle in an orange haystack.

Speaker 3 I thought that maybe someone had kidnapped her. You know, we were all just trying to figure out who would have done this and why, what was their motive.
It was a very horrible time.

Speaker 3 Did you think that maybe it could be connected to the game?

Speaker 1 You never know.

Speaker 1 You can never rule it out.

Speaker 8 It's Tennessee football and, you know, she so happened to be wearing a bright orange top. And if anybody knows anything about Tennessee football, bright orange is a color for the Tennessee Valles.

Speaker 3 But Brooke's body had been discovered about 40 miles from the football stadium, and investigators were still stymied as to how she ended up there.

Speaker 3 Did it lend itself to that she maybe was dumped here, or did you think that she was actually shot here?

Speaker 8 Based off of everything that was here at the scene, it appeared that she was shot here.

Speaker 3 The crime scene itself yielded little physical evidence, no fingerprints, no tire marks, and no murder weapon, only Only some brass, as they call it.

Speaker 8 They found spin ammo.

Speaker 8 They found live ammunition.

Speaker 3 Three shell casings, as well as some unfired bullets, all from a.32 caliber gun. That brass was sent to be tested in a lab.

Speaker 3 While investigators turned their attention to one item at the crime scene that could possibly provide some quick leads, Brooke's cell phone. It was right there, unlocked and in her purse.

Speaker 8 You can find a lot out about a person within seconds of

Speaker 8 going over the person's cell phone, so it was very helpful to us.

Speaker 3 In fact, Brooke's phone provided investigators with a major lead to pursue. Two leads, actually.
Two men. Investigators wanted to talk to them, but they'd have to find them first.

Speaker 8 It's always a concern whenever you have somebody that you'd like to talk to and you can't get to them to talk to them.

Speaker 10 Coming up,

Speaker 4 who were these two men?

Speaker 8 We do consider people like him a person of interest.

Speaker 4 And what was their relationship to Brooke?

Speaker 3 There's still something going on that shouldn't be going on.

Speaker 3 The brutality of Brooke Morris's murder fueled the search for her killer.

Speaker 8 We really hate that they came into community and committed such a crime.

Speaker 3 Roan County investigators had cleared Brooke's ex-husband, Clayton, but they had two other men to look at. Two men whose names and numbers were right there in Brooke's phone.

Speaker 3 Who was Brooke communicating with that day that seemed to be of potential importance?

Speaker 8 Daniel Hawkins.

Speaker 3 This is a man she used to date.

Speaker 8 This is a person that we believe she had a relationship with, yes.

Speaker 3 I think they were talking, nothing too extreme.

Speaker 5 Maybe a couple dates.

Speaker 3 Albert knew Daniel through mutual friends.

Speaker 5 We would just hang out with Daniel. You know, I would text him and be like, hey, man, are you coming out? And he'd meet up with us.

Speaker 3 But Albert hadn't spoken to Daniel that weekend and didn't know Daniel and Brooke had been texting each other, making plans to meet up.

Speaker 3 Investigators say they called the number listed for Daniel on Brooke's phone. He didn't answer.
You couldn't find him? Couldn't find him. Investigators learned Daniel lived in Colorado.

Speaker 3 He'd just been in knoxville for the weekend were you worried that you couldn't get a hold of him and he was out there yeah it makes you wonder you know what's going on are they intentionally trying to avoid you daniel had flown back to colorado by the time he got on the phone with a sheriff's investigator basically interviewed him and got his whereabouts where was he from what i understand he was at the ball game daniel hawkins told investigators he was at the stadium watching the football game as he texted with brooke on and off throughout the afternoon the game ended just before 7 p.m.

Speaker 3 Brooke's body was found just after 8 p.m.

Speaker 3 So if Daniel was telling the truth, investigators had to figure out if he had enough time to get through the crush of Vols fans, meet up with Brooke, and make the 40-mile drive here to Roan County to commit the murder, all within about an hour.

Speaker 3 As investigators looked at Daniel's timeline, they saw he was still texting Brooke long after the game ended. The last text was just a little past midnight.
It read, Where are you, darling?

Speaker 3 By then, Brooke had been dead for more than four hours.

Speaker 8 Until we clear him and rule him out, we do consider people like Daniel Hawkins a person of interest.

Speaker 3 But Daniel Hawkins wasn't the only person texting with Brooke. Who else had Brooke been texting with?

Speaker 8 Sean Smoot.

Speaker 3 What did you learn about Sean Smoot?

Speaker 8 We found out that he ran an all-state office there in West Knoxville.

Speaker 3 Married? children.

Speaker 8 Married, was no longer married at that particular time.

Speaker 3 Amy Denglinger is a former employee of Sean's. What were your impressions of Sean? Seemed like a nice enough person, outgoing,

Speaker 3 typical sales,

Speaker 3 easy to get along with.

Speaker 3 Sean Smoot. The name rang a bell with Brooke's family and friends.
Not long after Brooke's divorce, Sean had hired Brooke as an assistant in the insurance office.

Speaker 3 I remember the day that she had the interview. We had lunch right before and she was so excited, you know.

Speaker 3 It was a real job and I said there's going to be so much potential for you to move up in this company, you know. I was really proud of her.

Speaker 3 Did you feel like this was kind of the fresh start Brooke needed? Yeah, we did. We thought, we all thought it was going to be a good thing for her.
Did she seem happy? Oh yeah, she loved it.

Speaker 3 I think there was a couple other ladies in the office that she worked with. Everybody got along and she she enjoyed it.
She had formed a really,

Speaker 3 I guess, taut relationship with her boss. But Brooke's family had no idea how close Brooke's relationship with her boss Sean Smoot actually was.

Speaker 3 Some of her friends did.

Speaker 5 Well, she had told me in the beginning that she had started working for this guy,

Speaker 5 Sean Smoot, and a little bit down the road

Speaker 5 I had like saw him out eating or something like that.

Speaker 5 As things progress in their relationship, I was like, what's going on here? I was like, this guy, he seems a bit older. Is he, you know, does he have a family or anything like that?

Speaker 5 And she was like, yeah, she's like, he's married.

Speaker 3 An affair with a married man. I don't really think that she was like committed to that relationship.
I think it was just her.

Speaker 3 Just coming through a divorce and she had this attention from this man. But there's still something going on that shouldn't be going on.

Speaker 3 Brooke left the job after just a few months. But it was clear, to investigators at least, that Brooke and Sean were still in touch.

Speaker 3 Her phone showed calls between them on the day of the football game, and they'd been texting back and forth. Did you call him?

Speaker 8 Our attempts to call him were unsuccessful.

Speaker 3 Another one who's not around.

Speaker 1 That's correct.

Speaker 3 Detectives decided not to wait for Sean to pick up his phone. They went to his house in the early morning hours after Brooke's murder.
You go over there, is he home?

Speaker 8 He is.

Speaker 3 Sean told investigators he had seen Brooke the day before. She'd called him from downtown Knoxville asking for help.

Speaker 3 Remember, Brooke's tailgating plans had gone awry, and she'd wanted to go home and change her clothes. She needed a ride to her car, which had been left at a restaurant the night before.

Speaker 3 Sean said he agreed to give her a lift, but so they went to a bar to watch the game first.

Speaker 8 He had picked her up and they had went to, I think, Wild Wings and Buffalo Wild Wings. It's two different restaurants within the same square mile of each other.

Speaker 3 Sean said he then dropped Brooke off at her car in the parking lot where she'd left it. Did he say he didn't know where she went after that?

Speaker 8 He was at home. He said he didn't know where she went.

Speaker 3 So had Brooke met her killer there in the parking lot or sometime later? Perhaps she left to meet up with that other guy she'd been texting, Daniel Hawkins.

Speaker 3 But as far as investigators knew, Sean Smoot was the last person to have seen Brooke alive. And as investigators checked out his story, something wasn't adding up.

Speaker 3 So is this one of the first now where this guy's not being straight with us?

Speaker 8 It wasn't one of the first, it was one of the many.

Speaker 10 Coming up.

Speaker 3 I went in her kitchen, and on top of the refrigerator was a manila folder.

Speaker 4 A secret Brooke never shared with her family.

Speaker 3 Did that just give you chills when you found that manila envelope? It was horrible.

Speaker 4 When dateline continues.

Speaker 3 Some stories never make national headlines, but stories from small towns and coastal communities deserve recognition too.

Speaker 3 I'm Kylie Lowe, host of Dark Down East, a true crime podcast that gives voice to victims through investigative journalism and powerful storytelling.

Speaker 3 Set in my home state of Maine and the greater New England area, it's my goal to dig through the archives to bring the stories of the people at the heart of these cases to light.

Speaker 3 Listen to Dark Down East, wherever you get your podcasts.

Speaker 11 Hi there, it's Andy Richter, and I'm here to tell you about my podcast, The Three Questions with Andy Richter.

Speaker 11 Each week, I invite friends, comedians, actors, and musicians to discuss these three questions. Where do you come from? Where are you going? And what have you learned?

Speaker 11 New episodes are out every Tuesday with guests like Julie Bowen, Ted Danson, Tig Nataro, Will Arnett, Phoebe Bridgers, and more.

Speaker 11 You can also tune in for my weekly Andy Richter Call-In Show episodes, where me and a special guest invite callers to weigh in on topics like dating disasters, bad teachers, and lots more.

Speaker 11 Listen to the three questions with Andy Richter wherever you get your podcasts.

Speaker 9 If you're a smoker or dipper ready to make a change, you really only need one good reason. But with Zen nicotine pouches, you'll discover many good reasons.

Speaker 9 Zinn is America's number one nicotine pouch brand. Plus, Zinn offers a robust rewards program.
There are lots of options when it comes to nicotine satisfaction, but there's only one Zin.

Speaker 9 Check out Zinn.com/slash find to find Zin at a store near you.

Speaker 9 Warning, this product contains nicotine. Nicotine is an addictive chemical.

Speaker 3 Investigators working Brooke Morris's murder case were taking a hard look at two men she'd been talking to the day she was killed. Daniel Hawkins said they tried to meet up, but never did.

Speaker 3 Were Daniel's friends able to back up his alibi?

Speaker 8 His alibi was verified.

Speaker 3 He was really at the game.

Speaker 7 Yes.

Speaker 3 Because of the time the game ended, detectives concluded Daniel Hawkins couldn't have been in Roan County at the time of the murder. He was eventually cleared by authorities.

Speaker 3 But could they verify Sean Smoot's story? He told investigators he and Brooke grabbed a drink after he picked her up.

Speaker 3 Sure enough, here's a video of them at one of the restaurants he said they went to. Here they are taking their drinks out to the patio.
Another camera captured the couple leaving at about 6.30 p.m.

Speaker 3 Brooke is walking several steps ahead of Sean. Something Chief Phillips thought was telling.

Speaker 8 Normally, if people are happy and all that stuff, you think they would walk out together.

Speaker 3 And if there was something going on, maybe she was like, you know, I want to to just get away from him or whatever i be glad he drops me off my car this is the parking lot where sean smoot said he dropped brooke off at her car none of the security cameras around here had the car in view but it was still sitting here the next day after brooke died which made investigators wonder was sean smoot telling them the truth and if he wasn't where did they really go so they decided to trace his steps they pulled his cell phone records and found something unusual in the two and a half hours after sean and Brooke had last been seen together, there was no activity on his cell phone.

Speaker 3 And here's what also stood out. Around 11 p.m., his phone started pinging off towers along this major interstate heading out of Knoxville.

Speaker 1 Then it looked like Sean turned around.

Speaker 3 His phone started pinging in the other direction, all the way back to his house.

Speaker 3 Did he talk about why he was maybe about to leave town, but didn't, or why he turned around?

Speaker 8 Well, initially talking to him, he had told us that he was at home all night.

Speaker 3 So that's an inconsistency for you.

Speaker 1 It is.

Speaker 3 Investigators were becoming increasingly suspicious of Sean Smoot, and they weren't the only ones.

Speaker 3 Brooke's closest friends never really suspected her ex-husband Clayton or Daniel Hawkins, but they knew her relationship with Sean had been stormy.

Speaker 5 She would just, you know, tell me little things here and there.

Speaker 3 Her friends say Sean had a temper, and Caitlin witnessed it firsthand one night after a dinner. Sean was drunk, Caitlin says, so she didn't want Brooke to drive home with him.
He did not like that.

Speaker 3 He began to get very angry and we drove just down the street, pulled into the parking lot and I pulled up right beside her car and she opened the door and Sean was like right there, grabbed her by the arm.

Speaker 3 I told her, Brooke, just get back in the car. And so she did.
She got back in the car and we drove off.

Speaker 3 Friends say similar incidents followed. Brooke felt Sean was stalking her, showing up unannounced and uninvited when she was out with friends, even after she stopped working for him.

Speaker 3 She definitely knew that something was wrong. You know, after he was obsessive with her, calling her multiple times and texting her and then stalking her,

Speaker 3 you know, she knew that, you know, this man has got some issues. I've got to try to get away from him.

Speaker 3 Brooke reached her breaking point and in January 2011 did something she thought would get Sean out of her life forever.

Speaker 5 She was like, I'm done with this situation. He won't leave me alone.
I'm, you know, I'm going to the wife. She needs to know about the situation.

Speaker 3 I think she was probably tired of living in the secret. You know, she wanted to be free from the situation.
The wife knows he'll leave me alone.

Speaker 3 Yeah, I mean, you know, if I'm honest with the wife, then maybe, you know, they can try to work out their problems and he'll leave me alone. But it backfired.
Sean's marriage imploded.

Speaker 5 And she was just like, I've gone to the wife. She's getting a divorce.
She's made him move out.

Speaker 6 He lost everything after that. Yeah.

Speaker 3 And friends say Sean continued to harass Brooke. In fact, they say things only intensified.
Beyond emotional abuse, was it physical?

Speaker 1 Yes.

Speaker 5 She had just told me that Sean was

Speaker 5 getting violent.

Speaker 3 He broke broke into her apartment one night, came in through the bathroom window, threw her head up against the tile floor. Brooke's family didn't know about any of this.

Speaker 3 Their relationship, the alleged violence. It wasn't until after her death that her family finally learned Brooke's secret.
Did that just give you chills when you found that manila envelope?

Speaker 3 It was horrible. It was Brittany who discovered it.
As she went about the grim task of cleaning out Brooke's apartment. And we were kind of getting stuff in order to pack away and send.

Speaker 3 And so I went in her kitchen and on top of the refrigerator was a manila folder.

Speaker 3 Brittany opened the folder. It was an order of protection Brooke had taken out about a year before her murder against her former boss, Sean Smoot.
And it was page after page of just

Speaker 3 crazy stuff that he did to her. And I'm just like,

Speaker 3 this is horrifying. Like, I didn't even know that any of this was happening.

Speaker 3 The document details a litany of alleged violent outbursts by Sean, including the time Brooks says he broke into her apartment and attacked her.

Speaker 3 Why didn't she just tell us, you know, that this is what I'm going through? I need help. Why do you think she didn't want to share with you what was going on in her life?

Speaker 3 She knew we'd have a fit. I mean, I would have hunted him myself

Speaker 3 hurting her in any way.

Speaker 3 And I think she knew that. Brooke's friends, who knew about the Order of Protection, were surprised to find out she and Sean were talking on the day of the football game.

Speaker 3 Nobody knew that she even had contact with him.

Speaker 3 But to investigators, there was something different about this particular Order of Protection. Brooke had asked the judge to allow her and Sean to have social contact.

Speaker 3 And sure enough, they had continued to talk and spend time together. So they had to wonder if things were really that bad between Brooke and Sean.

Speaker 3 The investigation dragged on for weeks, then months. It was almost too much for Tina to bear.
I got really frustrated. Yeah, I did.

Speaker 3 You know, and I'm sure they had to hear my wrath a few times because, you know,

Speaker 3 I'm a mother and I wanted to know who did it and I wanted him put behind bars. But a major break in the case was coming.
Would a jury be able to put it all together?

Speaker 3 I said, were you directly or indirectly involved?

Speaker 10 Coming up.

Speaker 4 A murder charge at last and a powerful moment in court.

Speaker 3 All goes silent and Brooke Morris is dead. I wanted them to envision this young woman being shot three times.

Speaker 4 A verdict.

Speaker 1 What would it be?

Speaker 3 Brooke Morris's family and friends had come to a heart-wrenching conclusion. She had been in a violent relationship with Sean Smoot, a relationship that ended with her murder.

Speaker 3 Did it just seem so easy to you that, okay, they can go arrest him now? Like we know who did it. Oh, absolutely.
But that didn't happen.

Speaker 3 And you know, I kept thinking, well, surely any day now, any day now.

Speaker 3 Investigators had their suspicions as well, and they were trying to build a case against Smoot. He was the last to see her alive.
They had an allegedly violent relationship.

Speaker 3 He had lied to investigators. But so far, they had found no physical evidence tying him to the crime.
You were able to search Sean Smoot's apartment?

Speaker 1 We were.

Speaker 3 Do you find anything?

Speaker 8 We find an empty box that once contained a firearm with some ammunition.

Speaker 3 No gun.

Speaker 7 No gun.

Speaker 3 The box was for a.32 caliber pistol, the same caliber as the murder weapon, and the ammo?

Speaker 8 That was the same style of ammunition that was found at the murder scene.

Speaker 3 But without the actual gun itself, The circumstantial case wasn't strong enough to charge Smoot with murder.

Speaker 3 Then, the crime lab released its ballistics report showing that marks on shell casings from the crime scene matched marks on a bullet found in Smoot's home.

Speaker 3 His missing handgun appeared to be the murder weapon. That's a huge connection.

Speaker 8 It is pretty much the connection.

Speaker 3 In June of 2012, eight months after Brooke was killed, Sean Smoot was indicted on charges of first-degree murder.

Speaker 3 Did you immediately identify with her just being this young woman who was clearly so vulnerable? Oh, absolutely.

Speaker 3 Prosecutors Bob Edwards and Tiffany Tiffany Starr-Smith saw this case as a relationship turned deadly. We're still talking about domestic violence.

Speaker 3 We're still talking about orders of protection and all of the things that go wrong in those situations. You had no witnesses.
You had no DNA from your suspect. You had no murder weapon.

Speaker 3 That's a lot of things you didn't have. If we didn't feel like we could prosecute it and be successful, we would have never indicted it.
We would have never proceeded with it.

Speaker 1 Circumstantial cases

Speaker 1 allow you to be creative. You can take a set of facts and weave a story together for your theory of prosecution.

Speaker 3 Sean Smoot insisted he was innocent. He cycled through five different defense attorneys, and the trial was delayed again and again.

Speaker 3 It was

Speaker 3 surreal. Really, you know,

Speaker 3 because it had been reset 22 times. 22 times.
It's torture. It is.
It is torture. The trial finally started in July 2016, nearly five years after Brooke died.

Speaker 3 Robert Jolly, Smoot's fifth attorney, believed the state's case was weak for one simple reason.

Speaker 7 I don't think that they did very...

Speaker 7 thorough investigations of anyone other than Mr. Smoot, and even his investigation wasn't very thorough.
Even in Rome County.

Speaker 3 Jolly told the jury just how little that investigation had uncovered.

Speaker 7 There are no fingerprints. There is no gunshot residue test.
There's no DNA test.

Speaker 7 There's absolutely no evidence that links Mr. Snoop to Ruben County on that evening.

Speaker 3 The defense sought to prove that the evidence the state did have wasn't actually incriminating. Like the missing gun that Sean owned, yes, it was the same caliber as the murder weapon, but.

Speaker 1 There are

Speaker 7 however many million of people in this country who own guns, and this was a very common weapon.

Speaker 3 The defense also argued that the ballistics report linking shell casings from the crime scene to a bullet at Smoot's home had no actual science behind it.

Speaker 7 There is no scientific evidence of that or any standards that show that.

Speaker 7 There is not currently a standard that shows that every firearm makes unique marks.

Speaker 3 As for the volatile relationship described in the Order of Protection, the defense pointed out that Smoot never admitted to any of the allegations and he was never charged, much less convicted, of any assault on Brooke.

Speaker 7 The order doesn't mean that Mr. Smoot ever did anything.
It doesn't mean that Mr. Smoot admitted that he did anything.

Speaker 3 And the Order of Protection didn't prevent them from seeing each other, which they clearly did.

Speaker 7 She continued to treat Sean as a friend, as someone that she would do activities with.

Speaker 3 Did you worry that that could be confusing to the jury? Absolutely. And I think that's the underlying question anytime that we're talking about domestic violence.

Speaker 3 Why does anyone go back? The prosecutors hoped any doubt the jury may have regarding Smoot's guilt would be wiped away when they called their key witness to the stand.

Speaker 7 Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the true or false?

Speaker 3 Amy Denglinger, who was working for Smoot when Brooke was murdered, says her impression of the the nice, outgoing man who hired her didn't last. Why did it change?

Speaker 3 He was cold. He got angry

Speaker 3 easily,

Speaker 3 not satisfied, really, ever. In court, she testified about what happened the Monday following Brooke's murder.

Speaker 3 And at that point, I asked him if he was directly or indirectly involved, and he said both. Did you take that as a total admission of guilt?

Speaker 1 Absolutely.

Speaker 3 Absolutely.

Speaker 3 It had taken nearly five years after Brooks' murder to get her alleged killer before a jury. It took the jury less than four hours to reach its verdict.

Speaker 3 We, the jury, find the defendant, Sean Nelson Smooth,

Speaker 3 guilty of premeditated first-degree murder of brook and Cole Morris.

Speaker 3 What's the emotions that you're feeling when you hear that word? Well, of course we can't show emotion in court. Okay, what's going on on the inside? On the inside, I'm screaming.
I'm jumping for joy.

Speaker 3 For the prosecutor, the case was about more than winning a conviction. There's a lesson to be learned.

Speaker 3 For a woman watching this who is maybe going through a similar situation, what's the message from this story for her? Get out.

Speaker 3 Get help. Get out.
Don't go back. It's not going to change.

Speaker 3 Speak out and don't be afraid. Don't be ashamed because, you know, it's not your fault that you're being treated this way.
You should never be treated that way.

Speaker 3 The jurors also had to decide Smooth's sentence. That's when Prosecutor Tiffany Starr-Smith asked them to imagine the horror of Brooks' last moments.

Speaker 3 I'd ask that you all close your eyes for a few minutes this morning. Were you hoping that having the jury close their eyes like that would have a powerful impact?

Speaker 3 I wanted them to try to envision this young woman out in the middle of nowhere

Speaker 3 being shot three times by an angry man that she was afraid of.

Speaker 3 All goes silent.

Speaker 3 And at 23 years old, Brooke Morris is dead.

Speaker 3 The jury sentenced Smoot to life without the possibility of parole. His conviction and the sentence have provided comfort for Brooke's family, but not closure.
I can't make any more memories with her.

Speaker 3 The only memories I have are past memories. I mean, it's hard.

Speaker 3 She's always in my heart. She will always be in my heart.
And,

Speaker 3 you know, we had, I had 23 wonderful years with Brooke.

Speaker 3 I wish I had 53 more, but unfortunately, I don't. But I know where Brooke is.
I know I'll see her again.

Speaker 3 And that gives me hope.

Speaker 4 That's all for now.

Speaker 9 I'm Lester Holt.

Speaker 4 Thanks for joining us.

Speaker 1 This time of year, many are checking off their holiday gift lists. But identity thieves have lists too, and your personal information might be on them.
Protect your identity with LifeLock.

Speaker 1 LifeLock monitors millions of data points every second and alerts you to threats you could miss. If your identity is stolen, LifeLock will fix it, guaranteed, or your money back.

Speaker 1 Save up to to 40% your first year at lifelock.com/slash dateline. Terms apply.