The Box

Speaker 1 It's time for Black Friday, Dell Technology's biggest sale of the year. Enjoy huge savings on select PCs like the Dell 16 Plus featuring Intel Core Ultra processors.

Speaker 1 Plus, earn Dell rewards and enjoy many other benefits like free shipping, price match guarantee, and expert support.

Speaker 1 They also have huge deals on accessories that pair perfectly with your Dell PC and make perfect gifts for everyone on your list. Shop now at dell.com/slash deals.

Speaker 1 Deadline is sponsored by Capital One. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees.

Speaker 1 Just ask the Capital One bank guy. It's pretty much all he talks about.
In a good way, what's in your wallet? Terms apply. See capital One.com/slash bank.
Capital One NA member FDIC.

Speaker 2 I'm almost hysterical. My brother was crying as well.
I just remember hearing your dad's gone.

Speaker 3 He was in bed. There was something wrong with him.

Speaker 1 Did they tell you he was murdered?

Speaker 2 I don't think they used the term murder right away. I think they said like he'd been shot.

Speaker 1 Gone?

Speaker 4 Dead?

Speaker 1 Murdered?

Speaker 4 None of that

Speaker 1 seemed real.

Speaker 5 How could this happen? Was the house broken into?

Speaker 1 Did Bill have any problems with anyone? He had an affair a couple of years ago.

Speaker 6 Bill believes that there's this lady out there stalking him.

Speaker 2 Someone starts tapping on the window.

Speaker 1 Whoa.

Speaker 2 I knew something was happening. There was just a lot of panic.
My dad was panicked. My family was panicked.

Speaker 3 Did you shoot your dad?

Speaker 7 Why would you ask that?

Speaker 8 I see the guy for a weekend, but now he's murdered and you're coming to me.

Speaker 9 What actually happened the other night?

Speaker 11 I'm not sure what you want me to respond.

Speaker 12 Have you ever seen a murder case in which so many people were pointing at the wrong suspect?

Speaker 13 No, I just could not.

Speaker 1 I couldn't fathom this.

Speaker 6 A level of deviousness is just hard to get your head around.

Speaker 5 How much can one family bear?

Speaker 1 How do you contain horror?

Speaker 1 If this happened to you, where would you put it?

Speaker 1 In a box? Would you carry it with you everywhere?

Speaker 1 An anchor?

Speaker 1 Chained your soul?

Speaker 2 The box is full of demons.

Speaker 1 Would you live in dread at the day you knew you'd have to pry it open and look inside?

Speaker 2 The box full of like ghosts of my past. To confront a ghost like that, you gotta

Speaker 2 be ready.

Speaker 1 Or would you put it off? Would you wait till next year?

Speaker 2 I moved from state to state, and that box followed me with me. It followed me.

Speaker 1 Of course it did. It was his past inside that box.

Speaker 1 And now, here he was, prying it open.

Speaker 1 Will he ever be the same once he looks in there?

Speaker 2 It's a story. It's a story of a family.
And in this case, it's a story of my family.

Speaker 1 Here, more or less, is where the whole thing announced itself: Darby, Montana, deep in the Bitterroot Valley. A town conceived in iniquity and born in crime, some government man wrote long ago.

Speaker 1 Maybe so.

Speaker 1 I mean, diabolical hardly begins to describe it.

Speaker 14 People do crazy things.

Speaker 5 It's just such a waste. You know, it's such a beautiful family.

Speaker 1 It was June, a sunny Sunday afternoon, when a woman called 911.

Speaker 1 My name is Anne Scowd. I'm the one traveler that's road in Derby, and I just got home.

Speaker 8 And there's something wrong with my husband.

Speaker 8 There's blood, and his eyes are all bruised. He's called.

Speaker 8 Is he breathing, Tim? Is he breathing?

Speaker 8 fine.

Speaker 1 The ambulance whaled down local Highway 93, then up the west fork of the Bitterroot River.

Speaker 8 You want to try CPRM? Oh, I can't, I can't.

Speaker 1 Toward a collection of homes perched like supplicants beneath the staggering beauty of 10,000-foot Tracker Peak.

Speaker 1 On board the ambulance was Donna Reniker. What's it like going out in a call like that?

Speaker 15 As an EMT or a paramedic,

Speaker 15 you get this adrenaline rush when you get a call

Speaker 15 and you're thinking about all the things that you're going to possibly be faced with.

Speaker 1 We're getting people on the way, okay? Don't hang up on me. I don't want the light dad.

Speaker 1 I don't know if somebody said the house or what.

Speaker 1 For that reason, the woman on the line, Anne Stout, said she'd driven across a broad green meadow to a neighbor's house to make the call. Dispatch told the crew the call was a possible code black.

Speaker 15 Meaning possibly the person was dead. But you still don't know what you're walking into.

Speaker 1 As the ambulance approached the house, Donna's partner suddenly realized something.

Speaker 15 She said, you know, this must be Bill Stout's house. And I said, who's Bill Stout? And she said,

Speaker 15 we'll remember Ben because it had been a big thing in the community.

Speaker 1 Indeed. About which more later.

Speaker 1 But just then, memory snapped to attention. And so they couldn't help but wonder.

Speaker 16 And I don't want to insinuate anything.

Speaker 1 Could it have possibly been used to the site?

Speaker 4 What happened when you got to the house?

Speaker 15 Well, we walked in the house and my partner went to the left and I went to the right. I get almost to the laundry room and my partner says, Donna, in here.

Speaker 1 Here was a bedroom on the the east end of the house. There was something,

Speaker 1 someone under the covers.

Speaker 15 I lifted the comforter back and then you could see, obviously, it was a gunshot wound.

Speaker 1 Did it look like a suicide?

Speaker 12 Could it have been a suicide?

Speaker 15 Well, that was my first thought. Yeah.
Was

Speaker 15 did he shoot himself because the way he was laying in the bed?

Speaker 1 As the ambulance crew backed out of the house, investigators arrived in force to look at the body in the bed.

Speaker 1 County Attorney Bill Fulbright.

Speaker 6 There was definitely some appearances that maybe this was a suicide. Things started to unravel pretty quickly once the detectives and the deputies got the scene under control.

Speaker 1 Was there anything about the body that told them anything?

Speaker 6 You could tell that his body had been moved. Bill's body clearly had been rearranged.
After death. After death, yes.

Speaker 1 How could they tell?

Speaker 1 There was blood, a lot of blood, dried on his skin, but not in the places that blood would be. Unless somebody rolled him over after he'd been dead for a bit.

Speaker 1 And then, of course, there were the bed linens, which didn't make sense at all.

Speaker 6 There's a pillow that's partially covering his head, which

Speaker 6 struck everybody as odd if this was a person who committed suicide. There were blood spatter on some of the bed linens that the comforter had been put over.
And

Speaker 6 this blood had come very straight down and yet there was a comforter covering that part of the bed sheets.

Speaker 1 And finally, after all that complicated analysis by trained professionals, there was this.

Speaker 6 It was a pretty obvious thing right away that the handgun was not

Speaker 6 around Bill's body.

Speaker 1 No gun, not in the bed, or anywhere near Bill's body. Clearly, this was not a suicide.

Speaker 6 That became apparent very quickly. Correct.

Speaker 1 Somebody killed the guy. Correct.

Speaker 6 Killed by the hands of another.

Speaker 1 Hands of another?

Speaker 1 Such a loaded phrase.

Speaker 1 Turns out Bill's murder wasn't the only high-profile death in the Stout family.

Speaker 2 I will never forget crying on my bed, thinking my life's never going to be the same.

Speaker 1 My hero's gone. You're mourning him still.

Speaker 1 Yeah.

Speaker 2 For years I'd have these nightmares and we're getting chased and I'm trying to carry my brother.

Speaker 1 And later, fright in the night.

Speaker 2 Someone starts tapping on my window. Whoa.
I'm facing away from the window and I'm terrified. Someone's out there.
Like it's like a horror movie.

Speaker 1 Noah, stout, slim and strong, loved to run.

Speaker 1 Was a cross-country man, Gonzaga University in Washington State.

Speaker 1 That summer, home from college, he'd taken a weekend trip with old friends and returned on Sunday

Speaker 1 to the nightmare waiting on Trapper Meadow Road.

Speaker 2 My mom was hysterical and my brother was crying as well. I just remember hearing your dad's gone and thinking like what do you mean he's gone?

Speaker 1 Did they tell you he was murdered?

Speaker 2 I don't think they used the term murder right away. I think they said like he'd been shot.

Speaker 1 No one knew more than most the ways grief can drag a family down.

Speaker 1 Though it had begun, the stout family saga, so well.

Speaker 1 Bill, his apparently murdered father, had grown up in California, farm country, Central Valley. It's where he met and married Anne, adopted her little boy, Ben.

Speaker 1 Noah and Matt soon followed, and they idolized Big Brother Ben.

Speaker 1 Anyway, their dad, Bill, was a tradesman, a drywall installer. That's how he met Mark and Denise Ecker.

Speaker 4 We had a downturn here in construction during the mid-90s, and

Speaker 1 he would

Speaker 4 take the family, load up the three boys and Ann, and he would start driving to Montana after he got off work.

Speaker 4 On a Friday, Bill wanted something else, and he found what he was looking for on several trips up to Montana.

Speaker 1 Found it here, outside the town of Darby. Plunked down years and years ago, a few miles as the crow flies from the Montana-Idaho border.
Jenny Levy was a cub reporter around here.

Speaker 14 It's a really beautiful place, I think, that attracts a diverse group of people. You have retirees and young families.

Speaker 1 But then there's kind of another side to the place, too, right?

Speaker 14 Right. There's an interesting group of people in the West, I think, that prefer to live on the boundary of wilderness.

Speaker 1 And in this out-of-the-way place, Bill bought 20 acres on Trapper Meadow Road and built this house with his very own hands. Do you remember anything about that move?

Speaker 2 I wasn't pleased about it, so I was a strong dissenter in our move. Some of my earliest memories, my dad telling me bedtime stories about a guy named Montana Mike, who was living all these adventures.

Speaker 2 When he moved there, he's like, I'm going to be Montana Mike. He was telling the stories as much to himself as he was to me.

Speaker 2 And that was really his dream to live somewhere that I think he felt he could feel unencumbered,

Speaker 1 feel free, I think.

Speaker 1 And Bill was happy, content. He did all the things Montana men did.

Speaker 5 You know, you look in the dictionary, there's Bill. There's Montana.
That rugged,

Speaker 5 you know, handsome, quiet hunter, the fisherman.

Speaker 1 Bill put up drywall around the valley. Anne worked at a guest ranch and later at a long-term care facility.

Speaker 5 Anne put so much of herself into raising those boys and having, making a happy family life.

Speaker 1 Those boys were, they were gentlemen.

Speaker 4 Bill would tell me how proud he and Nan were of the grades that the kids had because academically they were they were killing it.

Speaker 1 Until Ben was 18, he'd been away at college, was home on winter break.

Speaker 1 And one awful day he left an obscure note on the fridge and walked into the woods and killed himself.

Speaker 1 His death, that first family horror, now just a page and a file in a box. But Noah?

Speaker 1 Noah was just 11 and felt responsible somehow.

Speaker 2 I will never forget crying on my bed and thinking my life's never going to be the same.

Speaker 1 My hero's gone. You're mourning him still.
Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2 For years

Speaker 2 I'd have these nightmares and we're getting chased and I'm trying to carry my brother.

Speaker 1 Nothing was really the same after that.

Speaker 2 There was a stress that that piled onto my parents as a result of my brother's death.

Speaker 1 A marriage does come under enormous strain when a child dies, especially if a child dies in that way. It wasn't their fault.

Speaker 2 Ben had a challenge that he felt he couldn't overcome, and he chose to make a decision that was entirely his own.

Speaker 1 Mark Ecker suggested counseling. Bill's answer was unyielding.
Oh, no, no, no, no, we're good.

Speaker 4 So it was kind of that pack it down inside and maybe we can deal with it some other day.

Speaker 1 But now, seven years after the day of Ben's suicide on the same property,

Speaker 1 Bill was dead. I couldn't fathom this.

Speaker 4 Gone, dead, murdered. None of that

Speaker 1 seemed real.

Speaker 1 Oh, but it was. Did your mind go anywhere in particular?

Speaker 2 I mean, this is not something that happened in our small town, right? I mean, there were like two high-profile deaths in our community in a few years and they were my families at that house.

Speaker 2 Like how is this happening?

Speaker 1 How indeed?

Speaker 1 What's the old adage? Start close.

Speaker 1 There were sheriff's deputies coming to the door.

Speaker 1 The town with eyes everywhere.

Speaker 17 I got the best cameras you could get.

Speaker 6 The monitors speed through the little main street of Darby. It is often a useful tool during investigations.

Speaker 1 It's kind of of unusual for a little town like Darby.

Speaker 6 It's a little unusual.

Speaker 1 What did those eyes see?

Speaker 1 And hard questions for a son.

Speaker 3 Did you shoot your dad?

Speaker 3 Why would you ask that?

Speaker 1 A setting June sun, long and lazy, was busy playing with color on Trapper Peak as a flock of investigators settled into the house in the meadow with their probing eyes and endless questions.

Speaker 2 One of the questions I asked is something like, would anyone want to hurt your dad?

Speaker 2 My dad was like, again, like, was a very kind person, like fairly introverted, didn't know enough people to make them angry.

Speaker 1 So, said Noah. Said Bill's friends, no one would want to kill him.

Speaker 5 We would sit and talk and try to, how could this happen? Was the house broken into? Then they just lost Ben. So how much can one family bear?

Speaker 1 But as they looked carefully at Bill's body, his wound, his bed, investigators were focused on more specific things. They'd get to who did it, sure.

Speaker 1 But first, a question that just might lead them there.

Speaker 1 What time did Bill breathe his last? In his bed, before a bullet ended his life. When the detectives and the coroner first arrived, what was the estimate of the amount of time that Bill had been dead?

Speaker 6 When they first arrived, there was

Speaker 6 some indications that he'd been dead. I believe it was eight to ten hours at that point.

Speaker 1 So if they arrived at 5 p.m.,

Speaker 1 most likely that morning.

Speaker 6 Morning, correct.

Speaker 1 But that morning and all day, Bill had been alone at home. Anne and their 16-year-old Matt had spent the whole day 70 miles up the highway in Missoula shopping.

Speaker 1 They both told the detectives Bill must have been killed soon after they left. What was Bill doing when you left?

Speaker 3 Oh, he was still in bed sleeping.

Speaker 1 Matt confirmed they left that morning.

Speaker 4 We left the house about

Speaker 1 8.15, 8.30.

Speaker 1 An alibi, if investigators could confirm it.

Speaker 1 But who would have seen them? way out here in rural Montana.

Speaker 6 You might be surprised.

Speaker 17 They put him at the right place at the right time.

Speaker 1 This is Larry Rose, who's proudly worn the badge for three decades as Marshal of Derby, Population 800. So how long have you been Marshal here?

Speaker 17 35 years.

Speaker 1 Larry's office right here on Main Street is a cowboy movies fever dream. Animal skins, an old-fashioned jail cell.

Speaker 1 Just like time stopped in about 1880.

Speaker 17 We tried to keep it as Western as we could.

Speaker 1 But then, walk over here to the desk in the corner. That is a townwide, very sophisticated surveillance system.

Speaker 17 I got the best cameras you could get.

Speaker 1 There are video cameras everywhere. Cameras peering from flower pots, storefronts, planter barrels.
How many cameras? 60, I asked. Nah, more than that, said the Marshal.

Speaker 1 He's always watching.

Speaker 6 He monitors speed through the little main street of Darby. It is often a useful tool during investigations.

Speaker 1 It's kind of unusual for a little town like Darby.

Speaker 6 It's a little unusual.

Speaker 1 So, if the Marshals cameras could verify Matt and Ann had indeed driven up to Missoula that morning, maybe they'd be in the clear.

Speaker 3 Matthew and I just planned the night before to just go first thing in the morning and do things in Missoula.

Speaker 1 And sure enough, there were Ann and Matt driving Bill's red truck through Derby headed for Missoula at 8.28 a.m.

Speaker 1 Once there, they had breakfast at IHOP where Ann placed a call to Bill and got his voicemail.

Speaker 18 We're having breakfast right now at IHOP and then we're probably going to hit Costco last. So if you can think of more stuff that I need to pick up, call and let me know.
I'll see you later. Love you.

Speaker 18 Bye.

Speaker 1 Ann said she and Matt went on to make several stops, Walmart, the mall, and so on. And later in the afternoon, as promised, Costco, where again she tried to call Bill.

Speaker 18 I haven't heard from you yet, so you must not need anything. Call me right away.
Bye.

Speaker 1 The Marshals cameras showed them heading back through Derby on the way home at 3.40 p.m.,

Speaker 1 just as they said.

Speaker 3 We walked in and we were just putting things away, and I was yelling for Bill.

Speaker 3 And

Speaker 3 it was really quiet, so I didn't think anything of it.

Speaker 3 I figured he had gone somewhere.

Speaker 1 But about 40 minutes after no bill showing up, Anne opened the door to their bedroom. And

Speaker 3 he was in bed, and

Speaker 1 it didn't look like him.

Speaker 1 And then, said Matt, panic said in. The mom? No,

Speaker 1 we left the house on the call 911.

Speaker 6 So Matt backed up his mom's story about what they did during that day, their movements, their timeline. Yes, they had gone to Missoula and done various errands, correct?

Speaker 1 She was telling the truth? Yes.

Speaker 1 Still, investigators had to ask the obvious questions.

Speaker 3 Do you have anything to do with the death of Bill? No. I love Bill very much.

Speaker 3 He was very important to my life the way it was. I had had enough bad things happening in my life, and he was always the stable person.

Speaker 1 Matt, on the other hand, said things that were a little surprising.

Speaker 3 Did you say you loved your dad?

Speaker 3 I just didn't really feel like there was much love for me in it. Did you shoot your dad?

Speaker 3 Why would you ask that?

Speaker 7 Well, I need to know.

Speaker 3 No, I did not shoot my dad.

Speaker 6 I mean, I don't...

Speaker 3 Why would I shoot my dad? Okay. Well, see, I don't know.
If there are answers, I need to hear them from you. Because there's a wonderful woman in there that needs to know.

Speaker 3 I don't know. I honestly don't know anything about it.

Speaker 1 Okay.

Speaker 3 Would you suspect that your mother would?

Speaker 3 I don't think so.

Speaker 3 I mean, occasionally they didn't really like have...

Speaker 3 I mean, they have their little, you know, little things.

Speaker 1 They?

Speaker 1 Little things?

Speaker 1 Well, now that was certainly true. The untold story.

Speaker 1 Maybe not so little.

Speaker 2 Someone's out there, and I'm terrified.

Speaker 1 A late-night visitor who, for some reason, is targeting Noah's father. Do you remember what you were thinking? Like, what did you do?

Speaker 1 Noah Stout unpacked the case file of his father's murder, pulled out page by page, and was transported right back to that Sunday evening in June when Bill's body was found.

Speaker 1 And those investigators were so full of questions.

Speaker 2 And the only thing I knew was going back to two years before that, right?

Speaker 1 Thing was, Noah did know about someone who seemed to want to hurt his dad.

Speaker 1 So did his mother, Anne,

Speaker 1 though it took a few painful questions to get there.

Speaker 3 Did Bill have any problems with anyone?

Speaker 3 No,

Speaker 3 he got along well with everybody, but

Speaker 3 he had an affair a couple of years ago.

Speaker 1 And there it was, a path to follow. Anne told the investigators that two years before the murder, Bill attended an old friend's wedding halfway across the country in Fort Smith, Arkansas.

Speaker 1 Spent the weekend in a hotel where he became

Speaker 1 reacquainted, shall we say, with an old flame.

Speaker 3 He told me that they only had sex a couple of times, but I think it was more of

Speaker 3 that

Speaker 3 they talked on the phone.

Speaker 1 It was midlife stupid, said Bill. After Anne found out somehow and confronted him, and he confessed.

Speaker 1 He swore it was over. And it was.

Speaker 1 For him, that is.

Speaker 1 Not for her.

Speaker 1 When and how did you become aware that something had happened, that your dad had maybe transgressed?

Speaker 2 I remember

Speaker 2 overhearing what was being yelled and putting two and two together.

Speaker 1 Why were they fighting? Because, said Anne, that woman, that Arkansas woman, wouldn't let it go.

Speaker 1 And what began to happen here on Chapper Meadow Road was terrifying. I remember it was late at night and my parents were arguing or something like that.

Speaker 1 And at one point I hear one of my parents say, she's coming here.

Speaker 1 And

Speaker 1 I was like, what's happening?

Speaker 2 And who's coming here?

Speaker 1 Then, said Noah, in the still silence of a Montana night, he heard a car grinding up their long driveway, heard it stop outside the house.

Speaker 2 And someone

Speaker 2 starts tapping on my window. Whoa.
I'm facing away from the window, and I'm terrified. And

Speaker 2 someone's out there. Like, it's like a horror movie.
So the next morning we come outside and our cars have been egged and some other things have been thrown in our cars.

Speaker 19 Like what?

Speaker 2 Like like poop and like just things have been thrown on our cars

Speaker 2 and i know that's pretty disgusting yeah okay yeah it was um yeah do you remember what you were thinking like what did you do dad like like what what is happening

Speaker 20 911 5 o'clock the next morning yeah my my car just got egged and what's your name uh bill stout s-t-o-ut

Speaker 1 bill called the sheriff's office to report the vandalism and to tell them about the enraged woman who, with a sister now, was making his life a kind of hell.

Speaker 20 It's two people from Arkansas, and they've been harassing. It's a remote area, so if you hurry, you might catch them.

Speaker 1 Bill told them, too, that he'd been getting weird hang-up phone calls. And he and his kids and even his friends started getting hateful emails from someone with a strange handle.

Speaker 4 I started getting an email

Speaker 4 from

Speaker 5 Freak of Arc.

Speaker 4 Freak of Arc. But I started getting these emails and the emails would say things like,

Speaker 4 Bill and Ann

Speaker 4 are not going to remain married.

Speaker 5 And I'm reading this and I'm thinking, what does this mean? Why are they sending them to you?

Speaker 1 So many emails. This one said Freak of Arc was changing her email address to Montana Barb 2001.

Speaker 1 Letters arrived too, postmarked from Fort Smith, Arkansas, one containing an invitation to a welcome to Montana Together Again barbecue for Barbara and Bill.

Speaker 1 An engagement party of sorts.

Speaker 1 Mark finally decided to say something to Bill.

Speaker 4 We're sitting in a restaurant in Salinas.

Speaker 4 And at one point during breakfast, I said to Bill, I said, hey, I'm not sure exactly, how to say this, but I'm getting several emails, and he stopped me and he said, no, Mark, just, it's this crazy person.

Speaker 4 And I said, okay, so I shouldn't, you shouldn't be worried about any of these. And he said, no, no, don't, don't be worried about it.
So we just let the whole thing go at that point.

Speaker 1 Then less than two weeks before Bill's death, two things happened. A car followed Noah home late one night.

Speaker 1 So what did your dad say? About that car following you up the driveway.

Speaker 2 I believe he said something like, I should have gotten my gun or something like that.

Speaker 1 Then, a few days later, somebody took the gun.

Speaker 2 I decided, well, it's probably you misplaced it or something like that.

Speaker 1 The gun, a 9mm pistol, was normally stored in a gun safe in Bill and Ann's bedroom closet. Bill was in a panic.
Had that woman gotten into the house?

Speaker 6 He called a report into the sheriff's office. saying this handgun's missing and he's concerned because he knows or he believes that there's this

Speaker 6 lady out there who won't leave him alone,

Speaker 6 stalking him.

Speaker 1 Well, and there's been evidence that she's been right there at the house, tapping on the window,

Speaker 21 putting feces on the car.

Speaker 4 Yes. Eggs.

Speaker 6 It's very clear that this deeply affected Bill. He was worried.

Speaker 1 And now Bill was dead.

Speaker 1 Sheriff's detectives received calls. from nearly a dozen friends and family members of Bill's about the woman in Arkansas.
Her name?

Speaker 1 Barbara Miller. My reaction was:

Speaker 1 they got a murderer running around.

Speaker 4 Put out a dragnet.

Speaker 1 Find this woman.

Speaker 6 There were people all the way from here in Montana to down in California that were pointing their finger at Barbara Miller.

Speaker 10 Yes.

Speaker 1 Did that angry woman have something to do with what happened to Bill Stout? Barbara Miller of Arkansas

Speaker 1 was about to receive a visit from investigators looking into a homicide.

Speaker 6 She was definitely a person of interest to a suspect, somewhere in that category.

Speaker 1 Questions? Would there be answers?

Speaker 8 I'm not going to let you talk anymore. Oh, that's fine.
I'm not. I was just wondering.

Speaker 1 I'm not going to let you spot.

Speaker 1 Bill Stout had been in the morgue two days when detectives made their move on the woman from Arkansas. Not personally, though.
They didn't rush to the airport.

Speaker 1 Instead, they'd picked up the phone, called the sheriff in Fort Smith, Arkansas, and asked if he'd mind sending some detectives around to Barbara's place.

Speaker 1 That is, the woman with whom Bill Stout had a brief affair, who was suspected of harassing him and his family, sending humiliating emails, perhaps stealing his gun, and maybe killing him.

Speaker 6 She was definitely a person of interest to a suspect, somewhere in that category.

Speaker 8 Oh, is this the Miller residence?

Speaker 1 At first, she said she had no idea why those detectives were so ramped up about her.

Speaker 8 I see the guy for a weekend

Speaker 8 and talked to him for a couple of months, and now he's murdered, and you're coming to me. Well, we're talking to everybody, and so what we're doing is just trying to find out, you know,

Speaker 8 everybody that he knows why am i being questioned well because he knew you and and so we were just wondering well why would someone in arkansas want to hurt him you should be looking for somebody who killed him right

Speaker 8 i don't see how i could help

Speaker 1 so then the detectives changed tack a little and asked her about her email and that certainly produced a response.

Speaker 8 I'm not going to let you tap any of my emails. Oh, that's fine.
I'm not. I was just wondering.
I'm not going going to let you spy.

Speaker 8 I didn't

Speaker 8 do anything. I haven't seen him.

Speaker 1 Barbara Miller's mind raced as the detectives asked their invasive questions. And then the penny dropped.

Speaker 7 They think I did it.

Speaker 1 Well, they certainly suspected it. Which made perfect sense given what the police had heard about Barbara from Bill's family and his friends and his co-workers.

Speaker 1 She was a little reluctant at first to tell us the story of how she got involved in all this.

Speaker 1 Her

Speaker 1 liaison with Bill and all the rest of it.

Speaker 1 Understandable, really, given.

Speaker 1 Barbara said she and Bill sort of slid into a relationship in their late teens. Bill was a friend of her brother's, and things happened.

Speaker 1 When you first got together with him, did you have expectations that this was forever?

Speaker 7 I did.

Speaker 1 But before long, it seemed Bill had other ideas.

Speaker 7 He basically told me he had already gotten married once, right out of high school, and

Speaker 7 it didn't last very long. He was very disillusioned with marriage.

Speaker 1 How was that for you?

Speaker 7 I thought I could change his mind, but

Speaker 7 obviously he didn't feel the same way about it that I did.

Speaker 1 And with that, it was over.

Speaker 7 It was my decision to move on.

Speaker 1 How'd he take it?

Speaker 7 He was fine. I mean, as far as I know, I didn't have any more contact with him.

Speaker 1 And pretty soon, Barbara married someone else, moved with him to Arkansas, had a couple of kids, and forgot all about Bill.

Speaker 1 Until it was 2005, a newly divorced Barbara attended her sister's wedding at this hotel in Fort Smith, Arkansas. And it just so happened Bill was invited too.

Speaker 1 He'd kept up his friendship with Barbara's brothers. Were you like looking for another husband at that stage? Or were you?

Speaker 7 No, I was just, I was fine.

Speaker 1 But on the evening Barbara got to the hotel where the wedding was being held?

Speaker 7 We had been to the Bachelorette party. And when we got back, he was there.

Speaker 7 So

Speaker 1 what was it like to see him at this family gathering?

Speaker 7 It was surreal. I didn't know he was going to be there.
He looked just the same.

Speaker 1 30 years on. Oh, yeah.

Speaker 7 Yeah.

Speaker 1 Yark a little flip when you saw him?

Speaker 7 Yes. I hadn't kept up with him at all.
So we had a lot to talk about.

Speaker 1 And that bar talk turned into hotel room talk.

Speaker 1 Turned into something else. Along the way.
For Bill anyway. Inconvenient truths took a little holiday.
What did he tell you about his circumstances?

Speaker 7 He told me that he was separated. and living apart from his wife.

Speaker 1 Was he looking to get a divorce? Did he say this?

Speaker 1 Might even have meant it, as biology worked its eternal magic in that little weekend hotel room.

Speaker 1 And then Barbara drove home and Bill flew back to Montana, still both blissfully wrapped in a gauzy veil. For weeks, there were calls every day, letters, cards.

Speaker 1 According to Barbara, plans were made for her to visit. and then move to Montana.
Until, a couple of months later, something changed.

Speaker 1 Tell me what your first intimation was that there was something wrong.

Speaker 7 He didn't call that night and

Speaker 7 the last couple times I talked to him he sounded distant and like you know he was having second thoughts.

Speaker 1 And after that, said Barbara, they never spoke again.

Speaker 7 What was that like? That was sad. I was hurt.

Speaker 1 Oh, yeah.

Speaker 7 And,

Speaker 7 but I understood.

Speaker 1 Now, two years after she said she last heard from him, detectives were on her doorstep. Detectives who weren't so sure she was really all that surprised and offended.

Speaker 8 I mean, you could ask all the questions you want.

Speaker 16 That is the story.

Speaker 22 End of story.

Speaker 1 Oh, but it wasn't. Not even close.

Speaker 1 Barbara Miller...

Speaker 6 seemed to be completely baffled.

Speaker 1 Not only was she baffled, there was someone she was frightened of.

Speaker 8 I'm very scared of her. I don't want to upset her.
I don't want to be involved.

Speaker 1 They were all here in the file, the pages that revealed his father's betrayal of his mother's trust.

Speaker 1 And the awkward questions those detectives in Arkansas had good reason to put to Barbara Miller, the woman Bill Stout had betted, then feared. He was terrified of her, of what she might do.

Speaker 1 He was sure it was Barbara who sneaked onto his property, vandalized his home.

Speaker 1 911.

Speaker 20 Yeah,

Speaker 20 my car just got egged.

Speaker 1 Who tapped on his son's window at night?

Speaker 1 Who'd repeatedly emailed Bill's friends and family from an account called Freak of Ark?

Speaker 4 He said, no, Mark, it's this crazy person.

Speaker 1 When Bill told the sheriff that his nine millimeter pistol suddenly vanished, he said he was pretty sure Barbara was behind it.

Speaker 2 He said, like, I've had a problem with this woman in the past. And my dad was killed less than a month later.

Speaker 1 But a strange thing happened when Arkansas detectives questioned Barbara all about this. How did she respond to those questions?

Speaker 6 Barbara Miller seemed to be completely baffled by the sudden appearance of law enforcement interested in Bill Stout. She said.
She said.

Speaker 1 Barbara's version of events was very different. Like, after Bill made it clear their relationship was over, she said she sent only one angry email.
And after all that, nothing. No cards, no letters.

Speaker 1 Said she knew nothing at all about an email address called Freak of Ark

Speaker 1 and didn't do any of the awful things Bill thought she did up in Montana. In fact, Barbara said she was the one living in fear, not of Bill, but of Bill's wife, Anne.

Speaker 8 I'm very scared of her.

Speaker 8 I don't want to upset her. I don't want to be involved in this.

Speaker 1 Scared? Of sweet, kind-hearted Anne stout?

Speaker 1 Please.

Speaker 1 But that's what she claimed. Barbara Miller told those detectives that after the affair with Bill broke off, it was she who started getting a series of unnerving emails and phone calls from Anne.

Speaker 21 Or so she said.

Speaker 1 What was the nature of the conversations?

Speaker 1 Was she angry? Were they friendly?

Speaker 7 You know, as far as I can remember,

Speaker 7 she was trying to

Speaker 7 be calm about it. I could hear, you know, the animosity and the anger.
come through every now and then, but she was trying not to let that come out. I didn't want to be rude.

Speaker 7 It's almost like she wanted to be my friend. I didn't want to be her friend, but I didn't want to hurt her feelings either.

Speaker 1 Southern manners?

Speaker 1 Perhaps. Or maybe she was only too aware that Bill's wife might want to teach her a lesson.

Speaker 7 My boss called me into his office and told me.

Speaker 1 What did he tell you?

Speaker 7 He asked me, you know, what's going on? Because he got a phone call from a woman who said that I was using the company email

Speaker 7 for personal business. Oh.
Because she had threatened to

Speaker 7 put a restraining order on me, have the police come and serve it to me there.

Speaker 1 But as detectives stood in front of Barbara's house just outside Fort Smith, Arkansas, none of that mattered now.

Speaker 1 The only thing that did was to find out whether Barbara killed Bill Stout up in Montana or not. Barbara needed an alibi right quick.

Speaker 7 Well, I showed him my telephone bills. I showed him, you know, I, listen,

Speaker 7 I go to work every day. I said, well, well, what day did this happen?

Speaker 1 Well, as we told you, it was a Sunday. Happened to be the 10th of June.
So where was Barbara then?

Speaker 7 And I said, I was at Walmart. I have a receipt.

Speaker 1 This Walmart, in Van Buren, Arkansas, to be exact.

Speaker 1 Or so she said.

Speaker 1 So the detectives checked it out.

Speaker 7 They went to Walmart and got the footage of my husband and I buying

Speaker 7 groceries for a birthday party that we were going to.

Speaker 1 Here it is, just before 1 p.m., more than 1,600 miles across the country, a good 25-hour drive away from the home where Bill was killed.

Speaker 7 You were at Walmart that time. I was at Walmart.
And I'd never even been to Montana, period.

Speaker 1 Once they saw that, they're probably a lot nicer to you.

Speaker 7 Yeah, they were just doing their job.

Speaker 1 Sure.

Speaker 1 But though they searched high and low, detectives could not find even a hint of evidence that Barbara played any part in Bill's murder, didn't shoot him herself, and didn't hire anybody else to do it either.

Speaker 1 So it couldn't have been her. Couldn't have been her.

Speaker 1 I think this is perhaps the first time that I've sat across from a person accused by at least 10 other people of committing a murder.

Speaker 1 And yet you're really kind of a nice person who lived 1,500 miles away from where it occurred.

Speaker 7 And had

Speaker 7 no knowledge of it till

Speaker 7 after it happened.

Speaker 1 So then, who did?

Speaker 1 And what about all those cards and letters and emails? All the harassment of Bill Stout and his wife Ann and his two sons and many of his friends by someone called the freak of Ark.

Speaker 1 There's a devious architecture to this sort of thing.

Speaker 1 Unexpected, complicated, even sophisticated.

Speaker 1 But almost always with a little flaw.

Speaker 1 When Anstout came home, Bill had been dead for eight to ten hours. A pretty big window.

Speaker 21 It could mean Bill was alive when they left.

Speaker 1 It could mean he was dead when they left, but it was really very much up in the air.

Speaker 6 Correct.

Speaker 1 And later. Have you ever seen a murder case in which so many people, close to the victim, were pointing at the wrong suspect?

Speaker 6 That was one of the unique things about this case. It was the product of some detailed planning before the crime.

Speaker 1 Looking to crack the code on your career? Well, maybe it's time to get your degree. Southern New Hampshire University offers over 200 programs you can complete online.

Speaker 1 No set class times means you can do it all on your schedule. And with some of the lowest online tuition rates in the U.S., they make getting your degree affordable, too.

Speaker 1 Get started at SNHU.edu slash dateline. That's snhu.edu slash dateline.

Speaker 22 If you're a smoker or dipper ready to make a change, you really only need one good reason. But with Zen nicotine pouches, you'll discover many good reasons.

Speaker 22 Zen is America's number one nicotine pouch brand. Plus, Zin offers a robust rewards program.
There are lots of options when it comes to nicotine satisfaction, but there's only one Zen.

Speaker 22 Check out Zen.com slash find to find Zen at a store near you.

Speaker 22 Warning, this product contains nicotine. Nicotine is an addictive chemical.

Speaker 23 If you're a custodial supervisor at a local high school, you know that cleanliness is key and that the best place to get cleaning supplies is from Granger.

Speaker 23 Granger helps you stay fully stocked on the products you trust, from paper towels and disinfectants to floor scrubbers.

Speaker 23 Plus, you can rely on Granger for easy reordering so you never run out of what you need. Call 1-800GRANGER, clickgranger.com, or just stop by.
Grainger for the ones who get it done.

Speaker 1 A few days after Bill Stout's life was so cruelly ended, his family and friends gathered in Darby to say their goodbyes to a man who loved Montana.

Speaker 2 And it was packed and people shared a lot of nice memories that I hadn't heard of.

Speaker 2 Things like, you know, I was in need and your dad fixed my house for free and said, don't worry about it and things like that. There's so many people there that care about you, care about your family.

Speaker 2 Sure. And it was a day I'll never forget.

Speaker 1 But investigators were right back at square one. Their initial suspect, Barbara Miller, now ruled out as the person who killed Bill in his bed.

Speaker 1 And yet, there seemed to be so many red flags about her. How could Bill have been so wrong?

Speaker 6 Up to the day he died, Bill actually believed Barbara Miller was stalking him and had ill intent.

Speaker 1 So, if Barbara didn't kill Bill, who did? Detectives called in Bill's family. More questions to ask.

Speaker 24 I'm at the Revalli County Sheriff's Office in the interview room with Ann Stout.

Speaker 1 Again, they went over hour by hour the last weekend of Bill's life.

Speaker 24 Is there something that you feel that I may have missed during our first conversation?

Speaker 1 Remember, the first coroner on the scene said Bill likely died about eight to ten hours before his body was found.

Speaker 1 And that was Sunday afternoon, about 5 p.m., meaning he was likely murdered in the vicinity of 8 a.m.

Speaker 1 when Ann and Matt were just leaving or had just left for a day of shopping in Missoula. Both Ann and son Matt repeated what they'd said before.
They simply didn't know what happened.

Speaker 21 So it could mean Bill was alive when they left.

Speaker 1 It could mean he was dead when they left, but it was really very much up in the air. Correct.

Speaker 1 And Matt said he was absolutely certain he did not hear a gunshot. So the detectives went back to pay another visit to the Marshal of Derby and his cameras.

Speaker 1 Anne had told detectives that on the day before he was murdered, Saturday, June 9th, Bill went for a ride on his Harley. Said he was going to Missoula.

Speaker 1 And sure enough, 1.58 p.m. Saturday afternoon, there is Bill riding his motorcycle through town, heading north.

Speaker 1 Then, 3.31 p.m., detectives found Bill walking into the Harley-Davidson store in Missoula and walking back out 10 minutes later, 3.41.

Speaker 1 But from there,

Speaker 1 for several hours, it was unknowable. Riding his Harley, maybe? Did he see anyone? He told his wife he stopped and had a beer, which, according to Anne, was out of character.

Speaker 11 Anyone who knows him would tell you that he never drinks during the day. Never.

Speaker 1 Was Anne wondering if Bill, given his past affair, had been cheating on her again?

Speaker 1 Yeah. No, the detectives found the bar where Bill stopped and confirmed he had one beer.

Speaker 1 Apparently, alone. And a few hours later, 7.55 p.m., the Marshals' cameras caught Bill riding south through Darby back toward home.

Speaker 1 Which meant he would have arrived a few minutes after 8 p.m.

Speaker 1 Which comported exactly with what Anne had told them. She said she was grilling steak for dinner.

Speaker 11 So Bill drove up right when I was barbecuing, right when I was taking it off the grill or turning it over. I gave it to Matthew and I told Bill his will be a second.

Speaker 25 Okay.

Speaker 11 And then I put broccoli on for Bill. We just steamed broccoli and Matthew won't eat broccoli.

Speaker 10 Okay.

Speaker 24 And did you have a potato?

Speaker 11 Baked potatoes.

Speaker 1 Well, Bill and Anne were in for the evening. Matt had plans.

Speaker 6 After dinner, Matt had left for a bonfire with the high school friends.

Speaker 1 The Marshall's cameras caught Matt driving through Derby in his suburban at 9.08 p.m. Anne said she and Bill watched TV

Speaker 1 and then made love.

Speaker 1 At around 10 p.m., Bill called a friend and made plans to go horseback riding the next day. That would be Sunday.

Speaker 1 Cameras caught Matt driving back home through Derby at 11.28 p.m. Saturday.
Anne said she waited up for Matt, then joined Bill in the bedroom where he was already fast asleep.

Speaker 9 So you woke up the next morning in your bed?

Speaker 11 I went to sleep in my bed. I always sleep in my bed.

Speaker 1 And it all fit. Most of it confirmed by those cameras.
But there was one more little thing. One more official-looking piece of paper.
Noah fished out of that box.

Speaker 1 What could Anne Stout tell investigators about that?

Speaker 6 We now knew we were dealing with a very narrow window of time.

Speaker 1 Could broccoli solve this murder?

Speaker 6 The stomach stops digesting at the moment of death. Yes.
The delicate things in our food are what you would see disappear first, and they were still there.

Speaker 1 It was Friday, five days after Anne Stout called 911 to report the death of her husband Bill here on Chopper Meadow Road. The scene, the Rivali County Courthouse, up the road in Hamilton, Montana.

Speaker 24 Today's date is June 15, 2007.

Speaker 1 And investigators were about to deliver some unpleasant news because after Bill's death, an autopsy had been done.

Speaker 1 And according to the medical examiner, Bill Stout did not die on Sunday morning at around 8, like the coroner on the scene had guessed. How did they know?

Speaker 1 Broccoli.

Speaker 1 That last meal Ann cooked for Bill on Saturday night when he got back from his motorcycle ride. It was one of his favorites.
Steak, broccoli, and potatoes.

Speaker 1 And now, said the medical examiner, that last meal had told its story.

Speaker 6 The stomach stops digesting at the moment of death. Yes.
And what the medical examiner noticed was immediately upon seeing the stomach contents,

Speaker 6 things that digest very quickly, potatoes, which they had, hadn't digested. In fact, he used his fingers like this, and he said that the florets on the broccoli were still recognizable.

Speaker 6 And those delicate things in our food are what you would see disappear first, and they were still there.

Speaker 1 Meaning that Bill Stout must have been shot to death after eating his last meal, 9 p.m. or soon after, on Saturday night.

Speaker 1 How did that change your theory of this crime?

Speaker 6 At that point, dramatically changed the landscape of the investigation because we now knew we were dealing with a very narrow window of time,

Speaker 6 which became pretty evident was a window of time in which Anne was alone with Bill.

Speaker 1 And if Bill Stout was killed when he was was alone with Ann on Saturday night, well,

Speaker 1 that changed everything.

Speaker 1 Ann Stout, quite obviously, had no idea what she was walking into with her attorney just off-screen here that day at the sheriff's office.

Speaker 9 So, Ann, in this folder are the results of our investigation.

Speaker 26 Okay.

Speaker 9 Can we pull up to the table together, you and I?

Speaker 11 I do not want to see. I can't already share it with you.

Speaker 24 I don't have anything

Speaker 1 of graphic.

Speaker 9 Yeah, I don't have that.

Speaker 10 Kate?

Speaker 1 Thing is, it wasn't just that last meal they wanted to talk to Anne about. Crime scenes do tend to tell a story, even if sometimes it's hard to discern exactly what that story is.

Speaker 1 And from the moment investigators walked into Ann and Bill's house, something didn't smell right about this one.

Speaker 1 Literally.

Speaker 6 One of the pervading things spoken of by people who had been in the house early on was that there was a very powerful smell of bleach throughout the house.

Speaker 1 Almost like someone had been cleaning up. And sure enough, pretty soon they came across three loads of still wet laundry smelling strongly of bleach and stuffed into various places.

Speaker 1 like in this laundry hamper. And inside the hamper? More than just clothes.
What was a holster doing in there? And a rubber glove. What did they find on that glove?

Speaker 6 On the outside of the glove and on the inside of the glove, DNA matching and stout.

Speaker 1 Of course, there might have been an innocent answer. These could have been her regular cleaning gloves.
Who knew, really?

Speaker 1 But as for the holster, it was made for a 9mm pistol. And now, things were about to get worse for Anne.
Because remember, that gun Bill had reported missing from the safe just before his death?

Speaker 1 It turned up to maybe 50 feet away from Bill's prostrate body.

Speaker 6 The handgun was found to be in the garage inside of one of the saddlebags on Bill's motorcycle. It's a big clue, of course.

Speaker 1 The gun, the glove, the cleanup. Was there another logical explanation? One that pointed not to Anne, but to another person in the household? Maybe? As the killer?

Speaker 1 So far, she'd had an explanation for everything.

Speaker 1 So maybe she had another one.

Speaker 1 Maybe.

Speaker 9 What actually happened the other night?

Speaker 11 I don't know what... I don't know what you're asking or I'm not sure what you want me to respond.

Speaker 1 And in the hot seat.

Speaker 9 I've got a time of death that shows that Bill wasn't alive when you left that morning.

Speaker 1 All the transcripts were here. for Noah Stout to read if he dared.
Read, for example, about the moment in the police interview with his mother when things got real.

Speaker 1 When those detectives in the room with Anne were about to attempt to link her with Bill's murder, her husband, Noah's father.

Speaker 1 The moment was this.

Speaker 1 They read her her rights.

Speaker 24 With those rights in mind, do you want to

Speaker 24 talk to me?

Speaker 11 Yes. All right.

Speaker 1 Then they seemed to back off a little. They complimented Anne for the fine young men she and Bill had raised.
Their interviews, too, had gone into the box, Noah's and Matt's.

Speaker 1 Uncomfortable interviews about their mother, their father, about what happened.

Speaker 10 We thought they were wonderful young men.

Speaker 24 I wanted to just ask you, though, is your impression of your boys that they're truthful?

Speaker 26 Yes. Okay.

Speaker 11 Very much so.

Speaker 1 Okay.

Speaker 1 And then here it came.

Speaker 1 No more niceties.

Speaker 9 I guess at this point I would

Speaker 24 ask you:

Speaker 10 what actually happened the other night

Speaker 11 I don't know what I don't know what you're asking or I'm not sure what you want me to respond.

Speaker 9 Well

Speaker 24 here's what I would ask you to respond.

Speaker 10 I'll tell you that we can we will if you want work our way through all of this but I'll tell you also that the results of our investigation show that you killed Bill.

Speaker 11 They do not show that. They do not prove that.
And you do not know that because it did not happen.

Speaker 6 Her reaction was one of,

Speaker 6 how could you say that about me?

Speaker 1 Oh, they were just getting started.

Speaker 9 We know the gun wasn't stolen.

Speaker 24 It was taken.

Speaker 9 We know because Noah told us, and you just told me that he's truthful.

Speaker 11 Noah is very truthful, and so is Matthew.

Speaker 9 The Bill told him I didn't leave that gun safe unlocked. I didn't misplace that gun.

Speaker 10 Someone took it out of there.

Speaker 9 Someone with a key opened that gun safe and took that firearm.

Speaker 9 Both of your boys have told me they didn't do it.

Speaker 26 I don't think that they didn't.

Speaker 11 And I didn't do it.

Speaker 9 You know, and I've got a time of death that shows that Bill wasn't alive when you left that morning.

Speaker 9 You told me that he spoke to you.

Speaker 24 He died before you left.

Speaker 24 Okay.

Speaker 9 Now that's science. That's not me.

Speaker 11 No, that's not science. What was his time of death?

Speaker 10 Well,

Speaker 24 actually, I wish that you would tell me that.

Speaker 1 Oh, God.

Speaker 1 See,

Speaker 24 I'm trying, I would like to work through this with with you.

Speaker 11 You are asking me a question that I don't have the answer for.

Speaker 1 He isn't going to take you into custody. Oh, God!

Speaker 1 I'm not that tough.

Speaker 1 Do you have to take me into custody?

Speaker 26 You know where I'm at. I'll give you my passport.
I have it. You can take every, any physical object.

Speaker 16 You can release me to somebody's custody. You don't know me.
You don't know me.

Speaker 16 And

Speaker 10 what? You're under the arrest for the murder of Bill Stowe.

Speaker 10 Nothing was wrong that night. Good stuff happened.
I need to have you turn around and put your hands up.

Speaker 1 Oh, God. I've never been in trouble, please.

Speaker 1 I'm a woman. Put your hands behind your back.
Oh, God, I've never had this.

Speaker 1 Everything I've lost in my life, everything when Bill died, you don't know what happened.

Speaker 11 I didn't think I even needed an attorney.

Speaker 11 And I want to remind you that I probably shouldn't say anything.

Speaker 11 Here's what happens now in

Speaker 10 another officer and I will escort you to the detention center. And you'll be booked into the Valley County Jail.

Speaker 9 You will

Speaker 10 continue to be able to have access to

Speaker 11 your council. Please don't leave me.

Speaker 2 That Friday,

Speaker 1 I went running.

Speaker 2 And when I came back, my cell phone had a voicemail from the sheriff. And he said, Noah, I just wanted you to know if we've arrested your mom.

Speaker 1 What was it like to hear that?

Speaker 2 I was shocked. Like, I was, you know, I'm still mourning my dad.
I've lost one parent.

Speaker 2 Five days later, essentially, I'm losing another parent.

Speaker 1 Noah was not the only one in shock. Out in California.

Speaker 4 To get this phone call, and I'm thinking to myself, this is crazy. She was, you know, wife of the year, mother of the year, hit me hard.

Speaker 1 Not Anne, they thought. Not Anne.
Unthinkable. Impossible.
All that planning, that careful orchestration, not the sort of kind-hearted Anne would do.

Speaker 1 Was it?

Speaker 1 Had detectives made a massive mistake?

Speaker 4 I was leading a charge up the mountain that

Speaker 4 you got the wrong person.

Speaker 13 Anne did not do it, and would not do it, and could not do this.

Speaker 16 Some stories never make national headlines, but stories from small towns towns and coastal communities deserve recognition too.

Speaker 16 I'm Kylie Lowe, host of Dark Down East, a true crime podcast that gives voice to victims through investigative journalism and powerful storytelling.

Speaker 16 Set in my home state of Maine and the greater New England area, it's my goal to dig through the archives to bring the stories of the people at the heart of these cases to light.

Speaker 16 Listen to Dark Down East, wherever you get your podcasts.

Speaker 28 Hey everybody, Ted Danson here to tell you about my podcast with my longtime friend and sometimes co-host Woody Harrelson.

Speaker 28 It's called Where Everybody Knows Your Name and we're back for another season.

Speaker 28 I'm so excited to be joined this season by friends like John Mulaney, David Spade, Sarah Silverman, Ed Helms, and many more. You don't want to miss it.

Speaker 28 Listen to Where Everybody Knows Your Name with me, Ted Danson, and Woody Harrelson sometimes, wherever you get your podcasts.

Speaker 29 If you're an experienced pet owner, you already know that having a pet is 25% belly rubs, 25% yelling, drop it, and 50% groaning at the bill from every vet visit.

Speaker 29 Which is why Lemonade Pet Insurance is tailor-made for your pet and can save you up to 90% on vet bills.

Speaker 29 It can help cover checkups, emergencies, diagnostics, basically all the stuff that makes your bank account nervous. Claims are filed super easy through the Lemonade app and half get settled instantly.

Speaker 29 Get a quote at lemonade.com/slash pet, and they'll help cover the vet bill for whatever your pet swallowed after you yelled, drop it.

Speaker 1 When word spread through Montana's Bitterroot Valley that the suspect in Bill Stout's murder was his wife, well, the reaction was, Anne?

Speaker 1 Surely not Anne.

Speaker 1 Former reporter Jenny Levy.

Speaker 14 She was very kind and very well-liked, and I think when it came out in the public, she's charged with homicide. That's a very big gasp in a very small town.

Speaker 1 Back in California, the Stouts' close friends Mark Ecker and his wife Denise weren't just gasping. They were yelling, hell no.

Speaker 4 I was leading a charge up the mountain that you got the wrong person.

Speaker 13 Ann did not do it, and would not do it, and could not do this.

Speaker 1 But when Ann's trial began a year later, it soon became apparent that prosecutors believed the murder was just the final act in a richly complex and inventive two-year campaign.

Speaker 1 Her intent to humiliate Bill.

Speaker 1 And long before she pulled the trigger to kill him, to make sure that family, friends, colleagues, the police would point the finger of blame at the woman with whom he'd had his fling, Barbara Miller.

Speaker 1 Have you ever seen a murder case in which so many people close to the victim were pointing at the wrong suspect?

Speaker 6 That was one of the unique things about this case was the

Speaker 6 success Ann had at diverting attention to a very specific person.

Speaker 1 A level of deviousness that's just hard to get your head around.

Speaker 6 It was the product of some detailed planning before the crime.

Speaker 1 But as so often happens with would-be diabolical killers, there were mistakes.

Speaker 1 When detectives visited Anne's office at the long-term care facility and took a little dive into her computer, they uncovered what looked like research into something uncaring.

Speaker 6 The internet search histories included things like how to poison people, how to murder somebody.

Speaker 1 Those hang-up phone calls? Bill thought it was Barbara breathing into the phone before hanging up.

Speaker 1 Investigators traced the calls to this payphone, steps from Anne's desk.

Speaker 1 And when they ran down the Freak of Arc email account, the IP address was the stout's own home computer.

Speaker 6 So it all fit together in everybody's mind that this Yahoo email was actually Barbara Miller.

Speaker 1 And then it turns out to come from... Ann's basement.
Correct.

Speaker 1 And the letters and cards starting soon after Bill confessed to his intemperate weekend, the Bill and Barbara barbecue invitation, they were all postmarked Fort Smith, Arkansas. Clever.

Speaker 1 How did she do it?

Speaker 1 Detectives talked to the Fort Smith Postmaster, who received occasional envelopes full of letters addressed to Montana, which were dutifully stamped Fort Smith and put into the outgoing mail.

Speaker 1 Detectives discovered the subterfuge in Anne's car, unsent copies of those same cards and letters.

Speaker 6 Anne's fingerprints were on the outside of the envelope, which would not be unusual.

Speaker 6 But when they opened it, not only did her DNA seal the envelope, but the only things found on the letter inside were latent prints from Anne Stout.

Speaker 1 So many mistakes.

Speaker 6 So many mistakes.

Speaker 1 Mistakes, yes, but also more,

Speaker 1 a level of fiendishness.

Speaker 14 It sort of smelled like really really incredible, sublimated anger that was really calculated and directed at hurting Bill and embarrassing him and humiliating him.

Speaker 1 First, you destroy him while he's alive, and then you kill him.

Speaker 14 My goodness. I think, too, that there was a lot of sympathy for this victim.
And it seemed that Bill really tried to

Speaker 14 recover from that affair and wanted to. And maybe Anne

Speaker 14 falsely welcomed him back in and said, let's move forward. But then immediately thereafter, there were this trail of letters and phone calls and this trail of harassment.

Speaker 1 The state's theory?

Speaker 1 The culmination of Anne's multi-year plan came just 10 days before Bill's murder, when, they claimed, Anne Stout stole Bill's gun from the safe, stashed it and its holster in the laundry hamper, where Bill would never look.

Speaker 1 But there was a problem. Anne had no experience firing a gun.

Speaker 1 So look at this. Detectives found this list in her bedside table with an entry Anne claimed were instructions to use the washing machine.

Speaker 1 But

Speaker 6 our lead detective looked at that

Speaker 6 and said that if you kind of read between the lines,

Speaker 6 That might be instructions on how to load and shoot a firearm. The red being when the safety's on, there's no red showing.
When the safety's off, there's a little bit of red color showing.

Speaker 1 But to make sure she could actually fire the gun, the state believed Anne tried it, fired a practice round. How'd they know?

Speaker 1 A neat piece of detection beginning in this box of ammunition from Bill's gun safe.

Speaker 6 When they opened the box toward the middle of the box, there were three missing rounds. In addition, there was a little flower that was inside of this box and inside of a box of ammunition.

Speaker 1 A flower?

Speaker 1 Now that was a puzzle until an investigator noticed an unusual plant just outside the stout's front door, same little flower.

Speaker 1 So he looked at the dirt beneath the plant and there it was, a spent shell casing, one of the missing rounds.

Speaker 6 We believe that she took a practice round. When nobody was home, the spent shell landed by that plant.
One of those little flowers gets in the box.

Speaker 6 She puts the box back, and the botanist narrowed the time that that plant blooms to about a 10-day window of time. That all happened within

Speaker 6 10 days or so of Bill's death.

Speaker 1 Which is right around the time he's reporting the gun is missing. Exactly.
And after she killed Bill?

Speaker 6 I have every reason to believe she simply carried the weapon out into the garage, wrapped in a towel, stuck it in the handbag.

Speaker 1 Oh, and there was insurance to half a million. The beneficiary? Anne.

Speaker 1 So the affair with Barbara Miller. Correct.
The $500,000 in insurance money.

Speaker 1 Angry woman scorned. If you had to pick a motive here, what was it? It's...

Speaker 6 difficult to ascribe a single motive. The question that stands out is what would motivate someone to put in multiple years of planning and carrying it out.

Speaker 6 There was a level of anger behind this that did not go away.

Speaker 1 My my.

Speaker 1 What could Ann Stout's defense attorney say to all that?

Speaker 1 I guess what you inherited was a pretty bad set of facts.

Speaker 1 Maybe fairly. Some of it.

Speaker 1 So what did she think happened?

Speaker 19 Someone came in the house and did it.

Speaker 1 Not her.

Speaker 19 I mean, they were gone. She and Matt were gone to Missoula.

Speaker 1 And those searches for how to kill someone on Ann's computer?

Speaker 19 Other people had access.

Speaker 1 Noah Stout was not allowed to sit through his mother's trial, since he was a witness, after all.

Speaker 1 That's why, when he opened up the box holding her case file, he finally learned what he wasn't privy to as he waited patiently here outside the courtroom for his turn to testify.

Speaker 2 Time seemed to just take forever. I got to know that little hallway pretty well.
It was definitely surreal.

Speaker 1 Surreal, too, for Bill's friend Mark, who by now had testified and had heard enough of the case against Anne to feel betrayed.

Speaker 4 She duped me. I did not feel comfortable making eye contact with her, just knowing what she had done

Speaker 1 to a very dear friend of mine. Yes, what she'd allegedly done prompted prosecutors to make it known, however briefly, they were considering pursuing the death penalty.
But,

Speaker 1 as we all know, a competent defense can make all the difference. This is Anne's attorney, Ed She.

Speaker 1 I guess what you inherited was a pretty bad set of facts.

Speaker 1 That'd be fair to say.

Speaker 1 So, what did she think happened?

Speaker 19 Someone came in the house and did it. Not her.
When they were gone, she and Matt were gone to Missoula.

Speaker 1 And all that evidence that seemingly pointed to Anne

Speaker 1 was, said She

Speaker 1 just poorly interpreted. Examples?

Speaker 1 Ann, he said, didn't know anything about that half-million-dollar insurance policy on Bill's life, despite what appears to be her signature on it.

Speaker 1 Or that Welcome to Montana barbecue invitation sent in envelopes bearing Ann's DNA. How did that get there? Well, who could know?

Speaker 6 He said.

Speaker 1 The freak of arc emails created on the family computer?

Speaker 1 Wasn't her.

Speaker 1 And at Ann's workplace, those searches on her office computer, how to poison someone, how to kill someone?

Speaker 19 Other people had access.

Speaker 1 Why would other people be looking at a way to kill somebody when her husband's the one who winds up dead?

Speaker 19 There's lots of stuff you can't explain.

Speaker 1 What about Bill's 9mm, the pistol that went missing shortly before his murder and then was used to kill him? and was later found in the saddlebag of Bill's Harley. She, he argued this.

Speaker 1 If Anne was the cunning mastermind of some diabolical plot, then why would she dump the gun in the garage?

Speaker 19 You use common sense. If you're smart enough to do all of that, then you're not going to be dumb enough to stick it in the saddlebag.

Speaker 1 Besides, he said, the towel the pistol was wrapped in was unlike any other towel in the house. Must have maybe belonged to somebody else.

Speaker 1 You get the picture.

Speaker 1 So then back to the main question. How did Bill Stout end up with a bullet in his head?

Speaker 19 When I hired the pathologist I had, that's when I thought, maybe we have a shot.

Speaker 1 Maybe you have a shot how?

Speaker 19 That he committed suicide.

Speaker 1 You think there's a chance he actually did commit suicide? Yep.

Speaker 1 All kinds of reasons, said Defense Attorney Sheehy. Bill was underwater on his mortgage, couldn't pay his bills, was facing tax liens.

Speaker 19 My pathologist demonstrated to a jury how you could put the gun behind the back of your head,

Speaker 19 and he testified that he had had prior autopsies where people had done that.

Speaker 1 Had committed suicide that way. Yep.
How would he commit suicide when there was no gun on the bed with him?

Speaker 1 Well,

Speaker 19 I have a theory.

Speaker 1 Which is what?

Speaker 19 That someone moved the gun, not her.

Speaker 1 Who would have taken a gun, put it in his Harley, but not killed him?

Speaker 1 I mean, who would do such a thing?

Speaker 19 I have some ideas, but I don't really want to discuss that.

Speaker 1 The defense seemed to imply that if not Anne, it must have been someone else in the house. So who might it be?

Speaker 1 Well, there was an obvious of unstated possibility. The prosecutor didn't appreciate the inference.

Speaker 6 There was apparently a strategy to

Speaker 6 point to the various items using the handgun, for an example. And the phrase over and over is used, well, we can't prove specifically who moved that handgun.
It might have been Matt.

Speaker 6 It might have been Noah.

Speaker 1 That's not a strategy you like.

Speaker 6 I did not like it. I thought it was offensive to

Speaker 6 these young men and the memory of their dad.

Speaker 1 But the defense attorney said

Speaker 1 that wasn't his intention. In fact, he said if anyone did move the gun, it might have been out of concern for Anne, who, remember, had already lost her son Ben to suicide years earlier.

Speaker 1 The theory then would be that somebody would come in the house, find a person committed suicide, and in order to spare the feelings of the family or whatever,

Speaker 1 had taken the gun and then hid it somewhere.

Speaker 19 Yeah, it happens.

Speaker 1 That's just.

Speaker 19 It happens.

Speaker 1 And attorney Sheehi said he had evidence to back up the idea that the medical examiner was wrong, that Bill wasn't killed right after that Saturday evening meal, that he was still alive Sunday morning before he killed himself.

Speaker 1 The evidence? Coffee. There was caffeine in his bloodstream.

Speaker 1 Why would that make a difference?

Speaker 19 Because that means someone got up and made coffee.

Speaker 1 Suggesting it was morning.

Speaker 1 And Stout said when she and Matt returned home, the TV was on and tuned to CNN, Bill's favorite channel. But what about the steak and broccoli in Bill's stomach?

Speaker 1 The dinner the medical examiner used to pin time of death to Saturday night. Well, said the defense, sometimes Bill got up and ate leftovers for breakfast.

Speaker 1 And he likely did that on Sunday as he sat alone in the house. But to ask anybody, somebody's got steak and broccoli in their stomach.

Speaker 21 It's not breakfast you're talking about.

Speaker 19 He would eat it for breakfast, according to his sons and her.

Speaker 4 That's just weird.

Speaker 19 I think it's weird my own son eats pizza for breakfast.

Speaker 1 Uh-huh.

Speaker 19 You know, you never know.

Speaker 1 Was all this a little too clever? Even cynical?

Speaker 1 Well,

Speaker 1 there's one more thing you never know,

Speaker 1 and that is what a jury might do:

Speaker 1 the verdict.

Speaker 2 It's like riding a roller coaster.

Speaker 19 When they read it, she was standing up, and I had to push her back down into the chair.

Speaker 1 She was in shock. Yep.

Speaker 1 The streets of the county seat, little Hamilton, Montana, were alive all that June.

Speaker 1 The whole town seemed to be watching as this soft-spoken, respected woman, this mother of three, stood trial for a crime so calculating, few could even conceive of it.

Speaker 14 There were a lot of people in the courtroom every day. It was packed.

Speaker 1 And Stout's defense attorney Ed Sheehy had argued this was no murder at all, but a a suicide by Bill Stout's own hand. They all waited six hours while the jury decided what to believe.

Speaker 1 And then...

Speaker 1 Is it possible to describe what it was like when you're watching them come back in and you're waiting for them to do it?

Speaker 2 Oh, it's like riding a roller coaster.

Speaker 7 Like these 12 people

Speaker 2 are making a decision that's going to impact

Speaker 1 you

Speaker 2 the rest of your life.

Speaker 1 There were no cameras present for the verdict, but the picture is vivid still in Attorney Sheehee's mind.

Speaker 19 When they read it, she was standing up. She had her hands on the table.
She became as stiff as a board, and I had to push her back down into the chair.

Speaker 1 She was in shock. Yep.

Speaker 4 In shock, because the verdict was guilty.

Speaker 1 And seconds later, Anne Stout was led out of the courtroom and into this hallway.

Speaker 2 The judge said, you can say goodbye to your mom now.

Speaker 2 And so we go in there, my brother and I, and I've never seen

Speaker 2 someone in as much shock as she was. And she was just bringing us close to her and telling us that she loved us.

Speaker 2 And

Speaker 2 that was the last time that I...

Speaker 2 Saw my mom outside of a prison cell.

Speaker 1 Except for one time, for her sentencing, when the prosecutor asked the judge to send Anne to prison for life without parole, and Noah,

Speaker 1 just 19 at the time, took the stand on his mother's behalf.

Speaker 30 I really take offense at the fact that someone recommends that my mother has no redeeming social value. And when I think about justice, I don't think that the fact that

Speaker 30 the only contact that my father's grandchildren will have with my mother,

Speaker 30 with their grandmother or grandfather will be through putting their hand against a

Speaker 30 bulletproof glass.

Speaker 30 And that's not justice to me.

Speaker 1 It was a slightly surreal scene in the courtroom, and even more so when Anne herself rose to speak.

Speaker 11 I cannot explain to you how his death had devastated my life and that of our families.

Speaker 27 Today I speak not only for myself,

Speaker 25 I speak as the widow of my husband, Bill.

Speaker 1 It was, in a word, bizarre.

Speaker 27 Bill's death has left those who cared about him

Speaker 27 mourning for the man he was.

Speaker 27 Gone forever is the friend he was to me,

Speaker 27 the son he was to his in line

Speaker 27 and father to the young men that he was so proud of

Speaker 27 and the husband he was today.

Speaker 1 It also left the judge unmoved. The reason

Speaker 1 that

Speaker 25 your children will be deprived of your company It's not because you've been convicted of this crime, it's because you've committed this crime. That's the court's judgment in this case.

Speaker 25 You'd be committed to Montana State Prison for a woman for the rest of your natural life.

Speaker 1 Anne Stoud, who declined our request for an interview, will be eligible for parole, but not until 2038, when she is 73 years old.

Speaker 2 I think giving someone something like a life sentence removes someone from the equation and thinks that we don't need to think about this person anymore.

Speaker 1 Son Matt declined our requests for an interview, but he keeps in touch with his mom and visits her in prison when he can. And Noah does too.

Speaker 1 In fact, after his mother went to prison, Noah attended law school, where the murder of Bill Stout was used as a case study for students in a class on evidence.

Speaker 1 The young man who finally had the courage to look in the box, the case file that told his family story.

Speaker 1 Has it helped to look inside?

Speaker 1 It didn't help right away.

Speaker 2 Definitely pretty sad when I was reading it because I,

Speaker 2 I mean, something you live with every day, knowing that I've opened it, I've looked at it, and

Speaker 2 it doesn't change me as a person.

Speaker 2 Doesn't make me view my family any differently.

Speaker 1 No.

Speaker 1 Oh, he read those dreaded files, saw the terrible evidence in there, and relived the worst days of his family's life. What has happened to you has been a terrible thing, a series of terrible things.

Speaker 1 But you've chosen a deliberately positive, kind of uplifting path to follow. And that's not easy.
So it seems to me it's like walking along the ridge of a mountain.

Speaker 1 You can get knocked off pretty damn easy.

Speaker 2 Yeah, and it's kind of putting one forward in front of the other and life happens.

Speaker 1 He's a bright man, is Noah Stout. Sees the world clearly.
But this,

Speaker 1 this is just different.

Speaker 1 Did you have a profoundly sad feeling that your mother killed your father?

Speaker 2 It didn't matter to me. He's still my mom.
I know that my dad raised me, that regardless of the worst possible thing my mom could do, I would still defend her and I would be her supporter.

Speaker 1 Did you take her at her word? Yeah.

Speaker 1 But she didn't do it?

Speaker 2 Yeah. I mean, it was my mom.
Just my mom.

Speaker 1 No matter what he saw in that box, he told us, no matter what it proved to a court of law, or what others may say about his choice. He is and always will be his mother's son.

Speaker 1 And he loved them both up here in their place of paradise under Trapper Peak. Still does.

Speaker 1 Regardless of the horror he carries around in that box.

Speaker 22 If you're a smoker or dipper ready to make a change, you really only need one good reason. But with Zinn nicotine pouches, you'll discover many good reasons.

Speaker 22 Zinn is America's number one nicotine pouch brand. Plus, Zinn offers a robust rewards program.
There are lots of options when it comes to nicotine satisfaction, but there's only one Zen.

Speaker 22 Check out Zen.com/slash find to find Zen at a store near you.

Speaker 22 Warning, this product contains nicotine. Nicotine is an addictive chemical.