Verdict in the pharmacist poisoning trial. A deadly love triangle in paradise? And Bryan Kohberger is back in court.

Speaker 1 Struggling to see up close? Make it visible with Viz. Viz is a once-daily prescription eye drop to treat blurry near vision for up to 10 hours.

Speaker 1 The most common side effects that may be experienced while using Viz include eye irritation, temporary dim or dark vision, headaches, and eye redness.

Speaker 1 Talk to an eye doctor to learn if Viz is right for you. Learn more at Viz.com.

Speaker 2 From the Creator of Homeland, Claire Danes and Matthew Rees star in the new Netflix series The Beast in Me as ruthless rivals whose shared darkness will set them on a collision course with fatal consequences.

Speaker 2 The Beast in Me is a riveting psychological cat and mouse story about guilt and justice and doubt, now playing only on Netflix.

Speaker 4 Happy New Year, Year of the Snake.

Speaker 5 You're listening in to Dateline's morning meeting in 30 Rockefeller Center.

Speaker 4 So this story, it took 13 years for this to get to trial.

Speaker 5 Our editorial team is catching up on breaking crime news around the country we're totally following it and we're trying to work through the rest of the why don't you go why don't you try to talk to her but we've got you know these big attacks on the dna

Speaker 5 welcome to dateline true crime weekly i'm andrea canning it's january 30th and here's what's on our docket

Speaker 5 In Oahu, Hawaii, opening statements in the sensational second trial of a husband accused of murdering his wife's acupuncturist, turned lover.

Speaker 8 Eric Eric Thompson executed this murder

Speaker 8 nearly flawlessly.

Speaker 5 In Dateline Roundup, Brian Koberger, the man accused of murdering four University of Idaho students in their beds, is back in court as his defense team cries foul.

Speaker 5 She said things that were just absolutely untrue and couldn't have been true. Law enforcement knew that.

Speaker 5 Plus, you've definitely heard about defendants pleading guilty or not guilty, but did you know there are some other kinds of pleas defendants sometimes make?

Speaker 5 NBC News legal analyst Danny Savalos will be here to give us the basics.

Speaker 9 Many judges, many courts, many states will not allow Alfred pleas. They are controversial.

Speaker 5 But before all that, we're heading back to West Virginia and the trial of Natalie Cochran, the pharmacist accused of poisoning her husband Michael to cover up a multi-million dollar Ponzi scheme.

Speaker 5 Nearly six years after Michael's death, we finally have a verdict.

Speaker 5 We've been bringing you inside the courtroom for the trial of Natalie Cochran over the last few episodes.

Speaker 5 Last week, we finally got more insight into Natalie Cochran's defense as her attorneys began to make their case, calling to the stand friends of the couple, medical experts, and family, including both of the Cochrane's children.

Speaker 5 Do you know the defendant, Natalie Cochran?

Speaker 8 Yes, she is my mother.

Speaker 5 Dateline producer Jay Young was in the courtroom and joins us now to tell us all about the dramatic testimony and what the jury decided. Jay, thanks for joining us again.

Speaker 1 Thanks for having me.

Speaker 5 Yeah, so let's start with one of the first witnesses the defense called, Natalie and Michael's daughter, Nicole. What was the reaction like in the courtroom when she took the stand?

Speaker 1 It was palpable. You know, she took the stand.
She was very quiet, very reserved in how she started off and how she described her father, and she painted quite a picture.

Speaker 5 So the prosecution argued Michael died from an overdose by insulin injection given to him by his wife.

Speaker 5 But Nicole's testimony pointed to other potential sources of his health problems, which had started in the years leading up to his death.

Speaker 1 Well,

Speaker 1 she testified Michael was really into bodybuilding and

Speaker 1 how he appeared. And so he was an athlete and he took supplements to increase his muscle mass.

Speaker 1 And so she talked about how she would see her dad put basically a plate out and just dump a bunch of pills onto the plate and then take them every morning.

Speaker 1 She also talked about how toward 2017, this was a couple years before he passed, that his health wasn't great and that his health was in decline.

Speaker 1 And she painted a picture of her dad as someone who wasn't his robust self.

Speaker 5 Nicole spoke about Michael spending time in hospitals and she mentioned how his poor health was affecting him.

Speaker 1 She noticed a big difference in

Speaker 1 his demeanor. She did testify about visiting him in the hospital and this was in the fall of 2018 prior to his passing in February of 2019.

Speaker 13 He said some kind things to my brother and I because he didn't think he would get another chance to.

Speaker 12 Is that all he told you?

Speaker 13 He told me

Speaker 13 that he always appreciated my intelligence and that he never told me that, but he wanted me to know it now just in case he never got to say it again.

Speaker 1 Did you take it as a farewell to life?

Speaker 13 I've always considered that to be kind of like my goodbye.

Speaker 5 Natalie's son also took the stand. He talked about his parents' business and about who was in charge and who wasn't.

Speaker 1 That's right. He actually testified very specifically about a time he remembers.
His mom was watching something on television, and his father was on a computer. And he asked his dad what he was doing.

Speaker 1 And according to the son, he said his dad told him he was working on some contracts with the company that he and Natalie had started. So that was all to indicate that his dad was very involved in

Speaker 1 the minutiae of the company.

Speaker 12 I think we all know who

Speaker 8 wore the pants in the situation. He definitely ran it way more.

Speaker 5 Right, because the prosecution had said that it was Natalie who was in charge, correct?

Speaker 1 That's right. That's right.
All along that the prosecution had said the Ponzi scheme that ultimately was revealed was all Natalie's doing, and Michael had no idea what was going on.

Speaker 5 So, the defense also challenged another key part of the prosecution's case: that Natalie poisoned Michael with insulin.

Speaker 5 And remember, investigators exhumed Michael's body twice to examine it. The first time, the manner of death was undetermined, and then the second, they found it was homicide.

Speaker 5 The defense argued in court that the body was simply too decomposed to make a determination, and they showed photos from the first autopsy in court in a very emotional moment.

Speaker 8 These are photographs, and they're somewhat gruesome.

Speaker 1 It was

Speaker 1 pretty hard to take.

Speaker 1 You know, I've seen a fair amount of crime scene photos over the years, and you heard Michael's mother sobbing

Speaker 1 after looking at the photographs. And it was a very disturbing moment, I think, for everyone in the courtroom.

Speaker 5 What did the defense's experts have to say about the findings from the autopsy?

Speaker 1 They concluded that the first autopsy done seven months after Michael's passing was in fact the correct ruling, that the manner and cause of death could not be determined.

Speaker 5 Yeah, and we have some sound from Dr. Priya Banerjee, a forensic pathologist, speaking about that.

Speaker 15 Unfortunately, embalming and burial does not keep the body in the same state as when one passes away. So even though the procedure is supposed to, it's still not perfect.

Speaker 5 The prosecution took an opportunity, you know, to cross Dr. Banerjee.
She really, she stood her ground with her findings.

Speaker 1 Yeah, she did. She basically said, look, there's very little that we can determine from Michael's autopsy.

Speaker 15 We don't practice in a black box. We always consider the circumstances.
We consider whatever records we have made available. But the autopsy is the gold standard, okay? His body is too decomposed.

Speaker 15 And in our field, it is acceptable to use undetermined as a cause of death and undetermined as a manner of death.

Speaker 5 So we move on, Jay, to closing statements. What were the arguments both the prosecution and the defense each wanted to leave the jury with?

Speaker 1 Well, I think on the part of the prosecution, they wanted to demonstrate that Natalie had a motive. And Natalie's motive was that Michael was about to uncover the Ponzi scheme that she had created.

Speaker 1 And so what she decided to do was to kill her husband. And so

Speaker 1 the defense tried to take the wind out of the prosecution's sale by saying Michael knew it was a Ponzi scheme. So Natalie had no motive to kill him.

Speaker 1 And if you believe that Natalie didn't have motive, then the prosecution's case collapses.

Speaker 5 So the jury started deliberating Wednesday morning and they came back with a verdict about only two hours later.

Speaker 18 We, the jury on the issues, joined, unanimously find the following. The defendant is guilty of murder in the first degree.

Speaker 5 Was that a surprise to you?

Speaker 1 Yeah, I mean, I think no one knew what was going to happen. The prosecution made it very clear they had no direct evidence in this case.
It was a circumstantial case.

Speaker 1 Now, they said that they had a mountain of circumstantial evidence, a blizzard of circumstantial evidence, but that was still going to be a stone that they had to get up the mountain.

Speaker 1 I think everybody

Speaker 1 was surprised at the outcome.

Speaker 5 All right, Jay, thanks so much for coming on and keeping us up to date on this case.

Speaker 1 Thanks for having me, Andrea.

Speaker 5 Up next, heartbreak in paradise. We've got details from inside a Hawaii courtroom as a man accused of shooting his wife's lover is tried for the second time.

Speaker 2 Looking to crack the code on your career? Well, maybe it's time to get your degree. Southern New Hampshire University offers over 200 programs you can complete online.

Speaker 2 No set class times means you can do it all on your schedule. And with some of the lowest online tuition rates in the U.S., they make getting your degree affordable, too.

Speaker 2 Get started at SNHU.edu slash dateline. That's snhu dot edu slash dateline.

Speaker 7 Most holiday gifts end up in a drawer or the back of your closet or accidentally left at your cousin's house. Not this one.
Mint Mobile is offering unlimited premium wireless for $15 a month.

Speaker 7 That's their best deal of the year, aka a holiday gift you'll actually use every single day. Don't get them socks.
Get them premium wireless for $15 a month.

Speaker 7 Shop Mint Unlimited plans at mintmobile.com slash dateline. That's mintmobile.com slash dateline.
Limited time offer. Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for 6 months, or $180 for 12 months.

Speaker 7 Plan required, $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra.
Initial plan term only.

Speaker 7 Greater than 35 gigabytes may slow when the network is busy. Capable device required.
Availability, speed, and coverage vary. See Mintmobile.com.

Speaker 19 If you're a maintenance supervisor at a manufacturing facility and your machinery isn't working right, Granger knows you need to understand what's wrong as soon as possible.

Speaker 19 So when a conveyor motor falters, Granger offers diagnostic tools like calibration kits and multimeters to help you identify and fix the problem.

Speaker 19 With Granger, you can be confident you have everything you need to keep your facility running smoothly. Call 1-800 GRANGER, clickgranger.com, or just stop by.

Speaker 1 Granger for the ones who get it done.

Speaker 5 Three years ago, 47-year-old John Tokuhara, an acupuncturist in Honolulu, Hawaii, didn't show up for dinner with his mom.

Speaker 5 The next morning, she went to open the clinic their family owned and found him dead on the floor. He'd been shot in the face three times.

Speaker 5 A month later, our affiliate KHNL reported that a contractor named Eric Thompson had been arrested.

Speaker 8 Prosecutors say Eric Thompson shot and killed Tokuhara after he discovered that the acupuncturist was having an affair with his wife.

Speaker 5 But Eric's wife, Joyce, wasn't the only one having an affair with John Tokuhara. There were other love triangles, other angry husbands.

Speaker 8 Thompson's defense team has argued that police zeroed in on him and didn't thoroughly vet or consider other suspects.

Speaker 5 Eric Thompson pleaded not guilty to murder in the second degree and went to trial in the summer of 2023. A jury deliberated for more than three days but could not reach a verdict.

Speaker 5 Earlier this month, a new jury was sworn in and Eric Thompson's retrial began. Mark Carpenter from KHNL covered Eric's first trial and now he's on his second.

Speaker 5 He's here to tell us what is new this time around. Mark, thanks for making the time.

Speaker 8 Thank you so much. I really appreciate you having me.

Speaker 5 Mark, what happened here?

Speaker 8 So Eric and Joyce, our high school sweethearts, they had been having a hard time having a baby. And so Joyce had been going to Tokohara's clinic for fertility treatment for acupuncture.

Speaker 8 What we learned in trial is that over time, the relationship turned into something more.

Speaker 8 5,600 direct messages exchanged between the two of them on Instagram. They say it was a sexual relationship.
They say it was a romantic relationship.

Speaker 5 Yeah. And even after she had the baby, not only did they keep seeing each other, but she kept going to the clinic to get treated.

Speaker 8 Yeah, that's kind of how it all came out.

Speaker 8 That summer of 2021, Eric was on another island for a business trip, and he got of a notification that the door was open, and he looked at the cameras and he saw that Joyce was meeting somebody.

Speaker 8 And then, so when he came back from the island, he confronted her about it.

Speaker 5 And she admitted it. She admitted it.

Speaker 8 And from our understanding, the relationship ended right after.

Speaker 8 Six months later, Tokuhara was found dead at his clinic.

Speaker 5 What does the prosecution think the motive was then if the affair had ended?

Speaker 8 They're trying to portray Eric Thompson as a controlling husband. He liked to keep tabs on her at all times.

Speaker 8 And that when he found out of the affair, especially with somebody that they had gone to for something so personal, he was incensed.

Speaker 8 And he had spent six months carefully trying to plan this and make it as perfect as possible.

Speaker 5 So lay out what prosecutors say happened. This is the middle of January 2022.

Speaker 8 They say that they have video surveillance that Eric Thompson parked maybe a few streets down and walked to John Tokohara's clinic.

Speaker 8 You never see him actually going into the clinic, but in the area of completely disguised.

Speaker 8 He's wearing a white bucket hat, sunglasses, a mask, one of those masks that you see during the time of COVID, gloves and long sleeves.

Speaker 8 They say he brought in a handgun, there was no fight, shot Tokohara three times in the face, and walked right out back to his car.

Speaker 8 And now, the whole crux with all this is that the white hat that this individual was seen wearing had fallen off his head and was picked up by a homeless person.

Speaker 8 Police in the area ended up recovering this bucket hat. Its hat was then tested, and they say it can't be ruled out that the DNA found on there does not belong to Eric Thompson.

Speaker 5 The prosecution says DNA evidence is pointing straight to Eric. This is like the smoking hat.

Speaker 8 Yeah, precisely.

Speaker 5 Or could be because the defense has a counter to that. They say the hat was mishandled by the police, and this summer their lab came under scrutiny.

Speaker 8 Honolulu Police Department's crime lab was audited by the FBI saying that it had outdated technology. This is equipment that is obsolete.
This lab is said to be subpar. in an FBI in review of it.

Speaker 5 Okay, and the defense's theory, how does it differ from the prosecutions?

Speaker 8 They say that Eric wasn't even there at all. They say that surveillance video will show that.

Speaker 8 They claim that he was actually on the other side of the island dumping construction material because of his work as a contractor.

Speaker 8 They also point to a theory that police only honed in on Eric because he was the convenient suspect. The most recent affair.

Speaker 8 There could have been other people out there who had motivation to attack him. John Tokuhara was seeing other women who had been in relationships.
Some of them had been married.

Speaker 8 They brought up the ex-husbands. They brought up the ex-boyfriends of these women.

Speaker 8 They say the men themselves say that HPD, yeah, while they did question them, they didn't question them and investigate them so thoroughly as Eric Thompson was.

Speaker 5 How are things going to play out differently for the prosecution with this second trial? Because, you know, whatever they were doing the first time didn't work if it ended in a, in a deadlock.

Speaker 8 Yeah, the prosecution was shocked that there was no unanimous guilty verdict the first time around.

Speaker 8 Our understanding is going into this second round here is that they're really going to ramp up the DNA evidence.

Speaker 8 What we're hearing in opening statements is that this time around, this white bucket hat was taken to a very reputable lab on the continental U.S., which the prosecution they say is much more accurate and zeroes in on Thompson even more.

Speaker 5 So, Eric's second trial began last week, and the first witness the prosecution called was John's mother. This is actually her second time having to testify in 18 months.
That That can't be easy.

Speaker 8 Yes, and completely awful.

Speaker 13 As I entered, I saw John on the floor.

Speaker 7 He was in a prone position.

Speaker 5 Yeah, and she's suing Eric for wrongful death.

Speaker 5 Yes. The prosecution also called witnesses to set up the surveillance video they say shows Eric near the clinic that day.

Speaker 5 And they're arguing: if you can't tell it's Eric, that's because he went to great lengths to conceal his identity.

Speaker 8 Eric Thompson executed this murderer

Speaker 8 nearly flawlessly. They say that he disguised himself, he disguised his truck.

Speaker 8 Whereas the defense said, there are so many of these trucks out there in Hawaii, the white Chevy Silverado, that is a very vague description right there.

Speaker 8 Also, too, they say when he found out about the affair, there was no confrontation.

Speaker 18 No contact with John Tokuhara.

Speaker 18 Calls, checks, nothing, direct or indirect.

Speaker 11 No threats or anger directed at John Tokuhara.

Speaker 5 Eric Thompson testified in his own defense in his first trial.

Speaker 10 I came to the realization that, you know, the problem was with me and Joyce. It wasn't,

Speaker 2 I mean, she cut him off.

Speaker 10 Did you kill John Tokuhara? No, I didn't.

Speaker 5 Do you think you'll see him take the stand again?

Speaker 8 Absolutely. I think for the jury, they want to see, like, can we believe this guy?

Speaker 5 Joyce is standing by her husband. Has she been appearing in court this time around?

Speaker 8 Yes, she has. Yep, she's been right behind him in the first row.

Speaker 12 All right, Mark, we'll keep an eye on this one.

Speaker 5 Thank you so much.

Speaker 8 Yeah, very fascinating. Thank you so much.

Speaker 5 Coming up, we've got two big stories to talk about in Dateline Roundup.

Speaker 5 New information from the courtroom about the roommate who was inside the house and survived when four University of Idaho students were murdered.

Speaker 5 And updates from the trial trial of Monica Cementilli, the woman accused of plotting to kill her hairstylist husband. Plus, did you know there are lots of different ways to plead guilty?

Speaker 5 NBC News legal analyst Danny Savalos will be here to break it down for us.

Speaker 20 Hey, weirdos, I'm Elena and I'm Ash and we are the hosts of Morbid Podcast. Each week we dive into the dark and fascinating world of true crime, spooky history, and the unexplained.

Speaker 17 From infamous killers and unsolved mysteries to haunted places and strange legends, we cover it all with research, empathy, humor, and a few creative expletives.

Speaker 20 It's smart, it's spooky, and it's just the right amount of weird.

Speaker 17 Two new episodes drop every week, and there's even a bonus once a month.

Speaker 20 Find us wherever you listen to podcasts.

Speaker 9 Yay! Woo!

Speaker 14 If you're a smoker or dipper ready to make a change, you really only need one good reason. But with Zen nicotine pouches, you'll discover many good reasons.

Speaker 14 Zinn is America's number one nicotine pouch brand.

Speaker 9 Plus, Zin offers a robust rewards program.

Speaker 14 There are lots of options when it comes to nicotine satisfaction, but there's only one Zen. Check out Zen.com/slash find to find Zen at a store near you.

Speaker 14 Warning, this product contains nicotine. Nicotine is an addictive chemical.

Speaker 22 ONDEC is built to back small businesses like yours.

Speaker 21 Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, Ondeck's loans up to $250,000 help make it happen fast.

Speaker 21 Rated A plus by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star Trust Pilot reviews, ONDEC delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at onDeck.com.

Speaker 22 Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by ONDEC or Celtic Bank. ONDAC does not lend in North Dakota all loans and amounts subject to lender approval.

Speaker 5 Welcome back. Joining us for this week's Dateline Roundup is Dateline Digital Producer Veronica Mazeka.

Speaker 12 Hey, Veronica.

Speaker 6 Hi, Andrea.

Speaker 5 So for our first story, we're off to Boise, Idaho, where there was an important hearing last week in the case of Brian Koberger.

Speaker 5 He is the man accused of the 2022 fatal stabbings of four University of Idaho students. Brian Koberger has pleaded not guilty and, as of now, is set to go to trial this summer.

Speaker 5 Veronica, bring us up to speed on this latest hearing.

Speaker 6 Yeah, so there was an evidentiary hearing that took place over the span of three days last week.

Speaker 6 It was basically just for the judge to consider some of the defense motions attacking the prosecution's case. Anything from how they collected evidence to the credibility of their witnesses.

Speaker 6 And their arguments focused a lot on the investigators' DNA analysis.

Speaker 5 Yeah, and for people who don't remember, law enforcement initially connected Koberger to the crimes through DNA on a knife sheath found at the crime scene.

Speaker 5 They used genetic genealogy to connect that DNA to Koberger by finding relatives of his in public online ancestry databases, which we're seeing so much of these days.

Speaker 6 Koberger's defense, they basically are saying that this violated Koberger's privacy. They really just want that evidence excluded from trial.

Speaker 6 They said that the police should have had a more specific search warrant before they analyzed the DNA from the crime scene.

Speaker 5 Someone we haven't heard much about until these hearings was a surviving roommate who was in the house at the time of the murder.

Speaker 5 She's expected to be a witness for the prosecution, but the defense had questions about her.

Speaker 6 So the defense is arguing that the surviving roommate isn't a credible witness.

Speaker 6 They allege that what the police reported in their affidavit to get the search warrants of Koberger's DNA and property isn't actually the story that the roommate told police.

Speaker 6 The defense also says that the police withheld information about the witness's possible memory problems or impairment on the night of the murder.

Speaker 5 She's not sure what she heard or saw was real or whether it was a dream. And she said things that were just absolutely untrue and couldn't have been true.

Speaker 6 But the prosecution really pushed back on that.

Speaker 5 We know it wasn't a dream because they found the evidence discovered the next morning. How did the judge react?

Speaker 6 The judge has not made an official ruling yet, but seemed skeptical of these arguments.

Speaker 2 I can't find any case law that would support that idea that somehow a warrant would be needed for DNA left at a crime scene.

Speaker 5 Okay, we'll keep an eye on what the judge decides on these various motions.

Speaker 5 For our next story, we're off to Los Angeles for an update on a case we first told you about last week.

Speaker 5 Monica Cementilli is on trial for allegedly orchestrating the 2017 murder of her husband, respected Hollywood hairstylist Fabio Cimentilli. Monica's trial got started last Friday.
How's it going?

Speaker 6 So the prosecution gave its opening statements on Friday, and they really laid out their case against Monica.

Speaker 6 She was wiping away her tears, as they called her, the mastermind of the plot to kill Fabio. The defense, on the other hand, they are calling Robert Baker as their star witness.

Speaker 6 He was Monica's lover, and in 2023, he pleaded no contest to Fabio's murder and is currently serving a life sentence.

Speaker 5 Yeah, and Robert Baker, you know, isn't trying to trade favors or anything. He maintains that Monica was never involved in the plot.
How does the prosecution plan to dispute that? Right.

Speaker 6 So they said in their opening statements that he's changed his story over the years and therefore he's an unreliable witness.

Speaker 5 Okay, lots of updates. Thank you so much, Veronica.

Speaker 6 Thank you.

Speaker 5 Most of the cases we cover on Dateline end up with a defendant in court having to make a decision how to plead to the charges against them.

Speaker 5 And it probably seems obvious they can plead guilty or not guilty.

Speaker 5 But covering the case of murdered Hollywood hairstylist Fabio Cimentelli these past few weeks, where one of the defendants pleaded no contest to the murder charge against him, it reminded us there are some special kinds of pleas you can make.

Speaker 5 Here to walk us through it is NBC legal analyst Danny Savalos. Hey, Danny.

Speaker 9 Hi, Andrea.

Speaker 5 So good to have you back. So to start, defendants, of course, have that choice, as we mentioned, guilty or not guilty, which seems like the obvious two choices.

Speaker 9 Yes, and there are actually some other pleas that are much more rare. And those are the Alfred plea and the no contest or no lo contendre plea.

Speaker 5 So what is the difference between the two?

Speaker 9 In a no-contest plea, you're basically not pleading guilty. You're not pleading anything.
And you're sort of going limp and allowing the government or the court to find you guilty.

Speaker 9 In an Alfred plea, the defendant is pleading guilty, but maintaining their innocence.

Speaker 9 And they enter an Alfred plea because they believe in their heart of hearts they're innocent, but the evidence is just so overwhelming.

Speaker 5 Right. And some of our listeners might recognize that term Alfred plea from two big cases.

Speaker 5 One of them is Michael Peterson, famously accused of murdering his second wife, Kathleen, after her body was found at the bottom of a staircase. He took an Alfred plea.

Speaker 5 And then there was Pam Hupp, who our listeners might recognize from Keith's podcast, The Thing About Pam.

Speaker 5 She was accused of killing a man she'd lured to her home, and before facing trial, she took an Alford plea, too. So why was an Elford plea right for them, Danny?

Speaker 9 Yeah, for Peterson, he'd been convicted of murdering his wife, Kathleen, in 2003. He was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Speaker 9 In 2011, a new trial is ordered after a judge vacates his conviction. And then in 2017, he takes an Alford plea instead of going to face a second trial.

Speaker 9 So you can see the benefit to the state is that they get their guilty verdict. He's sentenced to time served.
He's able to leave prison.

Speaker 9 And he can tell himself that the nature of my plea was that I am innocent, even though as far as the government and the paperwork and the courts are concerned, I am guilty.

Speaker 5 And Pam Hup?

Speaker 9 Yeah, Pam Hup had entered an Alford plea to avoid the death penalty.

Speaker 5 Who does it favor more then? Does it favor the defendant more? Because they're still going to face some consequences.

Speaker 1 Absolutely.

Speaker 9 There is a real-world consequence of pleading no contest because you can later on dispute your liability if you're sued in civil court for the same conduct. That is not the case with an Alfred plea.

Speaker 9 You're essentially foreclosed from even arguing against your guilt or liability in a later court proceeding.

Speaker 9 But other than that, there really isn't a whole lot that differentiates either an Alfred plea or a no-contest plea from a straight-up guilty plea.

Speaker 5 I'm assuming you can't appeal this plea deal later on. Is that true?

Speaker 9 Yes, for the most part, you'll go to sentencing. You will be sentenced.
And in fact, you might get a worse sentence because you haven't accepted responsibility.

Speaker 9 And one of the key factors in sentencing at the state and federal level is whether or not the defendant is accepting responsibility after they pleaded guilty.

Speaker 5 So why does a judge allow it then if they they don't like it? Is it because the person just won't budge and, you know, plead straight up guilty?

Speaker 9 Yeah, you know, we've all sort of grown up with the idea of plea bargaining, but this is not something that courts are required to accept.

Speaker 9 And the federal rules, for example, expressly disfavor the idea of an Alfred plea. Many judges, many courts, many states will not allow them.
They are controversial because

Speaker 9 for people like victims' families who come to court, they want to see see someone take accountability for their actions.

Speaker 9 It's understandable that they're frustrated because the person is not taking responsibility, even though they may be, at least on paper, pleading guilty.

Speaker 5 And Danny, you are

Speaker 5 not just a defense attorney who plays one on TV. You are actually a defense attorney.

Speaker 5 I always think about when a defendant has to make that decision,

Speaker 5 if a plea deal is being offered.

Speaker 5 I can't even imagine being an attorney with the defendant sitting in the the room mulling over that life-changing choice.

Speaker 9 It's one of the most terrifying things for me. And I'm the attorney.
I don't even have to make the choice.

Speaker 9 I have to deliver those options to a client, go to trial where the evidence is very strong, spend a lot of money, and then at the end, you roll the dice.

Speaker 9 And if you're convicted, you will get a much worse sentence than if you plead guilty and enter into a plea bargain.

Speaker 5 And imagine if you're innocent and you have to make that choice.

Speaker 1 Absolutely.

Speaker 11 Just very complex.

Speaker 5 Thank you so much, Danny, for breaking it down for us.

Speaker 1 Thank you.

Speaker 5 That's it for this episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly. If you want to learn more about the cases discussed in this and other episodes, head to our website at datelinetruecrime weekly.com.

Speaker 5 And coming up this Friday on Dateline, Keith has an all-new two-hour mystery. She was a criminal mastermind on a deadly crime spree.
She was also a mother.

Speaker 5 The inside story of Santa Kimes and her two very different sons.

Speaker 23 He could not believe what had happened because hadn't his mother told him a thousand times, we're innocent. We're innocent.

Speaker 5 Watch The Devil War White, airing this Friday at 9-8 Central on NBC or stream it starting Saturday on Peacock. To get ad-free listening for all of our podcasts, subscribe to Dateline Premium.

Speaker 5 Thanks for listening. Dateline True Crime Weekly is produced by Frannie Kelly and Katie Ferguson.
Our associate producers are Carson Cummins and Caroline Casey.

Speaker 5 Our senior producer is Liz Brown Kurloff. Production and fact-checking help by Sarah Kadir.
Veronica Mazeka is our digital producer. Rick Kwan is our sound designer.
Original music by Jesse McGinty.

Speaker 5 Bryson Barnes is head of audio production. Paul Ryan is executive producer.
And Liz Cole is senior executive producer of Dateline.

Speaker 8 Anything else, anyone? All right, thanks so much.

Speaker 7 This time of year, many are checking off their holiday gift lists. But identity thieves have lists too, and your personal information might be on them.
Protect your identity with Life Lock.

Speaker 7 LifeLock monitors millions of data points every second and alerts you to threats you could miss. If your identity is stolen, LifeLock will fix it, guaranteed, or your money back.

Speaker 7 Save up to 40% your first year at lifelock.com dateline. Terms apply.