A Promise to Gloria

What if you could turn your curiosity for true crime into a degree? At Southern New Hampshire University, you can. Southern New Hampshire University offers over 200 degrees you can earn online, including subjects like forensic psychology and criminology.
And with some of the lowest online tuition rates in the U.S., Southern New Hampshire University makes earning your degree affordable. Find your degree at snhu.edu slash dateline.
That's snhu.edu slash dateline. Dateline is sponsored by Capital One.
Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One bank guy.

It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. What's in your wallet? Terms apply.
See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N.A.
member FDIC. Tonight on Dateline.
I remember them saying, we found a body. I just fell to my knees when I found out that Gloria had been murdered.

You're just trying to adjust to the emptiness.

How do you plan a funeral for your child?

She was 14 years of age, an innocent girl, walking to school alone.

Somebody was seen following her.

She never screamed. She never called for help.

I believe that this person had been watching her.

You have a mystery man that could be your killer.

We talked to classmates, friends at school, teachers.

Months turned into years and years.

There has to be a way to solve this.

They can take a piece of evidence that's 25 years old, 30 years old, and they can test it.

We knew exactly what we had to do.

I made a promise to her.

I said, Gloria, I'll find out who did this.

We needed to find the killer.

Get ready for a stunner of a mystery.

I'm Lester Holtolt and this is Dateline. Here's Andrea Canning with A Promise to Gloria.
The morning of December 6th got off to a bad start for Yvonne Pointer.

She had a nightmare, or maybe a premonition.

I had a horrible treat. Blood was everywhere.

But when I woke up that morning, I sat up in the bed, I was like, call the police, call the police.

When Yvonne grasped what was happening, she was relieved.

Every time I was in the room, I sat up in the bed. I was like, call the police, call the police.

When Yvonne grasped what was happening, she was relieved. Everything was fine, actually better than fine.

Her 14-year-old daughter, Gloria, would be getting a perfect attendance award at school.

Gloria was excited to get the day started.

Did she just have that bubbly personality that fit with being a cheerleader?

She did, and people loved her. She was always trying to help people with their problems.
I remember the first time I saw her cheer, when she said, Hello, people. How do you do? My name is Gloria.
And I just stood up and screamed, Gloria! And so she was like, Oh, no, that's my mother. Gloria called her best friend before sunrise and told her she'd stop by her house on the way to school to borrow a special comb for her hair.
She wanted to look her best for the awards ceremony. Gloria's cheerleading coach, T.
Stallworth, would be there to wish her well. Gloria would have probably been my friend.
You know, my buddy. We would have gone shopping.
She was like a daughter. We were that close.
Was she going to be something? She was going to be something. To be proud of.
I loved her. It was cold and snowy in Cleveland that morning all those years ago in 1984 when Gloria's mom, stepdad, and brother set out in their car to deliver newspapers.
Along the way, they spotted Gloria. I saw her walking down the street, which was in the opposite direction from which she was normally going to go.
And I rolled down the window and I screamed at her so loud. I was like, why are you going this way? So you didn't like the route that she was taking? I didn't like the route because she was going through the back way.
The cut through, which is what you was going through the cut through. I have always told her not to take.
Yeah, yeah. Gloria heard her mom, but still chose to take the shortcut to school.
She disappeared down the dark alley. Shortly after, Gloria's friend, Lamar Thomas, left home for school and caught sight of Gloria behind him.
She'd made it through the alley and was near the school, apparently with a friend. Are they crossing the street or are they already across the street? They went up outside our house and seemed like they were just goofing off and about to come, you know, just a few minutes later they'd be in the school.
Deshaun Haley, Gloria's boyfriend, was waiting for her in the school hallway. But there was no sign of her.
Deshaun, were you expecting to see Gloria that morning before homeroom? Yes. And were you looking for her? Every morning we'd hook up at the locker.
At her locker or mine. So yeah, I was looking for her.
He wasn't the only one. Gloria was now so late she'd missed the awards ceremony.
And her best friend told the principal she'd never made it to her house to borrow the comb. The office gave Gloria's mother, Yvonne, a call.
They just said, it's Gloria there, because they called her name to get this award, and she didn't respond.

You know, where's Gloria? And the kids kept coming to me and saying things like, T, they can't find her. The principal was so concerned, he made an announcement on the school's PA system, asking if anyone had seen Gloria.
When that came through the intercom, I'm like, what they talking about? She in school, so she was right behind me. And they said she never made it.
And so within about 20 minutes, the phone rang again. But this time, it was the principal.

And he said, call the police.

Just like that.

Did your heart just sink?

Yeah, I'm like, call the police for what?

But police were already on the scene.

They'd received a call about something suspicious at an apartment building near Gloria's school.

Officers made their way to the back of the building, including Detective Jack

Bornfeld. It was a metal fire escape, and there were steps, 15 of them, leading down to the basement level of the building.
It was dark, but officers could see something at the bottom of the stairs. Was Yvonne's premonition coming true? I remember them saying, we found a body.
An apartment building in Cleveland was now a crime scene. There was a body at the bottom of a dark stairway to the basement.
Former Cleveland homicide detective Jack Bornfeld. When they first went down there, they observed the victim.
She was laying on her stomach at the foot of the stairs. A school ID and book bag were found next to the body.
They belonged to Gloria Poynter. It was an appalling crime.
Gloria had been beaten to death. There was evidence of a sexual assault.
Detective Janice Abernathy was at the scene. It was very hard to sit there and look at this 14-year-old innocent child that was on her way to school to be victim of such a horrendous crime.
And a girl with so much promise. Yes.
Word spread quickly at Davis Junior High. The news was too much to handle for Gloria's boyfriend, Deshawn.

I heard people crying. They were saying she was dead.
And it was like, it was just going around. And I just couldn't, you know, couldn't handle it.
Couldn't believe it. I just ran out of school.
Just the day before, T. Stallworth had talked to her students about stranger danger.
and I never will forget Gloria said,

do we have to talk about that today, T? I said, yes, we do, because people are crazy. So I just fell to my knees when I found out that Gloria had been murdered.
After they identified Gloria's body, police went to Yvonne's house to deliver the awful news. I remember them saying, we found a body.
Before they could say another word, Yvonne collapsed to the floor. I was having an out-of-body experience.
It's almost like you go to a place of comfort, of denial. Yvonne's denial was easy to understand.
Just hours earlier, Gloria had bounded off to school, upbeat and full of life. Typical Gloria.
What kind of daughter was she? Gloria was the type of daughter that every mother wish she could have had. Very obedient, just a caring, loving person.
A child that the school loved and the teachers loved and everybody. I know I probably make it sound like she was so perfect, but she was.

What happens in those first days?

What are you doing?

What can you do?

The first days after the homicide, you're just trying to adjust to the emptiness.

But now you have a funeral to plan.

How do you plan a funeral for your child?

At the funeral home, Yvonne was warned not to look inside the casket, but she insisted on having a private moment with her daughter. I pulled the cover back, and I just looked at her from head to toe, and I said, Gloria, don't worry, I'll find out who did this.
You made her a promise that day. I made a promise to her.
And grief took a back seat at that moment because we needed to find the killer. Where did she die? Down there.
Down there. Finding Gloria's killer also became an obsession for Detective Abernathy.
It's just so hard to think about

and so horrific. Yes.

Detective Abernathy retraced

the route Gloria took to school on

December 6th, starting with

when she left her house at about 7 a.m.

You can almost imagine her walking

down this street on that freezing cold

day with all that snow.

This is the cut that kids refer

to as the cut. It's the alley.

Okay, so she was going to cut through here? She was going to cut

Thank you. down the street on that freezing cold day with all that snow.
This is the cut that kids refer to as the cut. It's the alley.
Okay, so she was going to cut through here? She was going to cut through here, which is a straightaway down to the street. Mm-hmm.
Detectives learned that at 7.10 a.m., Gloria was spotted by a teacher who was driving to school. She said Gloria wasn't alone.
Detective Jack Bornfeld. The female school teacher saw Gloria along with a male, and they split and walked around either side of the car.
And the female teacher remarked to her husband, I wonder what Gloria's doing out so early. In the minutes that followed, several other people saw Gloria with a man.
Because it was winter, the suspect had on heavy clothing, so they couldn't tell whether he was thin, medium, or heavy build. But it was a very general description.
Nothing specific that stood out. Nothing really easy to go on.
Correct. None of the witnesses saw anything to suggest Gloria was in danger.
She didn't show any side of fear. She didn't scream.
Not to mention, you described it as a whiteout. Yes.
Probably even harder to tell what's going on when there's all that snow. Exactly.
You have a mystery man that could be your killer. You don't know for sure.

Where do you start?

This case rests on good old-fashioned police work,

pounding the pavement and knocking on doors.

Nothing happens like on TV, you know, at the end of an hour you got the bad guy.

But just hours later on that snowy day, another frantic call, another attack. Could it be the same man who killed Gloria? There's some detectives at the time said, well, this got to be the guy.
Own a 2020 or newer car or truck that's been in for repairs under warranty. You might have a lemon.
Defective vehicles, known as lemons, sometimes slip through even the best automakers. You don't have to settle for one.
Lemon Law Help is here to get you the compensation you deserve. With millions recovered for car owners, they're known for big wins.
Best part? No out-of-pocket costs to you. Call now at 855-952-5252 or visit LemonLawHelp.com.
Don't wait. Get the help you need today.
Paid spokesperson. Every case is different.
Results vary. Courtesy of Roger Kiernos, Knight Law Group, LLP.
Hey, everybody. It's Rob Lowe here.
If you haven't heard, I have a podcast that's called Literally with Rob Lowe. And basically, it's conversations I've had that really make you feel like you're pulling up a chair at an intimate dinner between myself and people that I admire, like Aaron Sorkin or Tiffany Haddish, Demi Moore, Chris Pratt, Michael J.
Fox. There are new episodes out every Thursday.
So subscribe, please, and listen wherever you get your podcasts. Hi, we're Mochi Health, your long-term weight loss solution.
We'll connect you with a board-certified provider to discuss your unique goals. Eligible patients can access custom-formulated GLP-1 medications at an affordable fixed price.
Deliver to their door monthly. Take our free eligibility quiz at joinmochi.com and use code AUDIO40 at checkout for $40

off your first month of membership. That's

joinmochi.com.

Results may vary. Eligible GLP-1 patients typically lose 1-2 pounds per week in their first six months with Mochi when combined with a healthy lifestyle.
1984 1984 was a frightening year in Cleveland.

The news of Gloria Poynter's murder came on the heels of several other attacks targeting young girls.

Gloria was the fourth girl. It was four 14-year-old murdered in like three months, times.
Had that been weighing on you, just hearing the news about these other girls? Absolutely. Because I didn't know who her killer was, I was so afraid to be at home by myself when no one was there.
So you would come here? I would come to the church, and some days I would sit for eight hours at a time. Didn't feel comfortable at home, didn't feel comfortable in the streets, but here I felt comfortable.
Meanwhile, detectives were developing leads. We spent a lot of time tracking down every individual that we could, canvassed the entire area house to house.
And some rumors started to pop up about possible family members being involved. Who would you say kind of rose to the top first as someone that you thought could be responsible? Her stepfather.
Why? What was that relationship like? Gloria and her stepfather did not get along. She did not like the man.
Gloria and her stepfather were often at odds and detectives thought his reaction to her murder was suspicious. He was cold, indifferent, and his attitude was really poor.
So he wasn't even mourning her death, it felt like? No, no, no. Nope.
He did not mourn. Did you ask, did you have anything to do with this? Absolutely.
You know, he said, no, he didn't. Did you believe him? At this point, I don't believe anybody.
But once detectives put together a timeline of the crime, they determined Gloria's stepfather was delivering newspapers at the time she was killed. So you essentially...
He was ruled out. He was ruled out.
He was completely ruled out. So police turned their attention to Gloria's boyfriend, Deshaun, and started digging into their relationship.
Her mother didn't allow her to date. Right.
So it wasn't like she can go home and say, Mom, Deshaun coming over in Hobbit, no way. And at that morning, was there a possibility that she was trying to get to school early so she could meet Deshaun? You brought Deshaun in for questioning.
Yes. He was scared.
He was upset. Did you feel like they were kind of putting the pressure on to get answers? It was rough.
I mean, I didn't know what the heck was going on. Like, why do they keep coming to me asking these questions? They ask me the same questions over and over again.
They obviously think that I did something or I'm guilty of something. I started thinking maybe I am guilty of something.
But Deshaun denied any involvement in Gloria's death, and several people said he was in school at the time of the attack. So detectives moved on, and a few days later, another suspect emerged.
This one was a neighbor. He concerned me because he was weird, you know, and strange and whatever, and always talking about female body parts, you know.
And I thought if anybody, he could be somebody that would do something like that. Yvonne says the man was disturbed, and his pattern of inappropriate behavior turned positively creepy at Gloria's wake.
When he got to the casket, he leaned over and kissed her on the lips. And we all just kind of went, what? What just happened? So that's why the next day, on the way to the funeral, he was taken in for investigation.
Not too many people kiss a corpse, except for maybe a loved one. You know, but for a stranger to do it.
Did he do or say anything in your interviews that was giving you a bad vibe? Not really. Not really.
We just kept an eye on him. Investigators built a long list of possible suspects, but knew they needed a break to solve the case.
And they got one. At around 6.30 p.m., hours after Gloria was killed, there was an attack on another girl not far from the school.
She escaped, and a man named Rommel Broom was arrested. Detectives thought he might be responsible for Gloria's attack, too.
He had a record of previous rapes. There were some detectives at the time who said, well, this this got to be the guy.
So you think it's possible he's struck or tried to strike twice in one day? This is what they were thinking. He was number one on the hit parade, so to speak, and he was checked out top to bottom, inside, forward, backward.
Detectives circled back to the witnesses who'd seen Gloria with that mysterious man and showed them a photo lineup that included Broom. Two witnesses picked him out of a photo lineup.
Yes, but again, you got to understand, the witnesses that observed the suspect with the victim only saw him from the side or the back. Nobody got a good look at his face because it was windy and snowing and cold that day.

The identification was too murky and there was no other evidence to bring charges.

But Broome was positively identified by witnesses in the case of Trina Middleton,

one of the other 14-year-old girls killed in Cleveland that year.

On October 3rd, 1985, Broome was convicted for Trina's murder. The judge sentenced him to death.
But there was still no justice for Gloria, even though detectives believe Broom killed her too. So Yvonne decided to ask Broom herself.
Guess what I started to do? Write letters to Will Mill. My name is Yvonne Pointer.
They say you murdered my daughter. I just need to know if you did.
I would write that letter to him over and over. Would he write back? No, not ever.
The fact that he's not writing you back, does that make you think maybe he did it? No, no, it didn't make me think he did it, but it kept the door open. That if you did, just say it so we can put an end to this nightmare.
Yvonne's nightmare would endure for years as she waited for a response. Those years brought grief and frustration, but also a new way

to solve crimes, DNA

technology. Could it possibly

solve Gloria's case?

This man hoped so.

Was the Gloria Pointer case one that you felt

should be looked

at right away? It was one of the first cases

that we opened up.

Yvonne Pointer never stopped mourning her daughter.

Over time, she channeled that pain

into helping others

enduring similar tragedies.

She gave speeches across the country.

And at home, she focused on projects to fight crime, like a midnight basketball league. Hoping to keep kids off the streets and give them something to focus on.
We thought if we can get these people who are committing the crimes into the gym between 10 p.m. and 2 a.m., that would reduce crime.
And it did. She became a surrogate mom to the kids in the neighborhood, comforting and counseling when they had no one else to turn to.
Gloria's murder really led you on a path you never expected. I was feeling unqualified for the task, but then I think about God doesn't call to qualify.
He qualifies to call. Part of that calling meant keeping Gloria's case front and center every time a new police chief took over.
I was on a quest, and I went through, I think, five or six police chiefs. When Ed Tomba became deputy chief, she met with him as well.
I went to him. I said, OK, here I am, and we're going to solve Gloria's case.
I introduced myself to every chief. Sometimes I would get these ideas of what we could do to help solve the case, and Tombo was right there.
He never said, you're bothering me. Quit calling my office.
He was just a wonderful, wonderful person. What really struck me about Yvonne was she said she wanted to be a partner.
She wanted to help in any way that she could to resolve this case and that she would never, ever criticize anybody or make any assumptions. But she said that she had a calling to keep the memory of her daughter alive and to find out exactly what happened to her.
And Janice Abernathy, she kept working the case even after she left the job. How badly did you want to solve this case? Enough that when I retired, I worked on the case and constantly keeping in touch with them and giving them any ideas that I may have had that I recall that they may want to look into.
As the years passed, Yvonne went to extremes to try to solve Gloria's murder. Reaching out to convicted killers, maybe they knew a convict who claimed responsibility.
And she kept writing to Ramel Broom, who was on death row for the murder of another young girl in the neighborhood. Police suspected he might have had something to do with Gloria's death, too.
I was worried that he was going to die without answering my question. Not hearing back from Broom left Yvonne despondent.
But maybe the answer would come from somewhere else. Back then, Judge Richard Bell was an assistant prosecutor inundated with unsolved cases.
He got an idea. I went to the county prosecutor at the time, and I asked him if we could open up a cold case squad, the first ever cold case squad in a prosecutor's office.
Was the Gloria a pointer case, one that you felt should be looked at right away? It was one of the first ever cold case squad in a prosecutor's office. Was the Gloria Poynter case one that you felt should be looked at right away? It was one of the first cases that we opened up.
At the time of Gloria's murder in 1984, crime scene investigators collected every scrap of evidence from the scene, even before they knew how important it might be someday. You've got to understand, too, at the time of this homicide, there was only blood typing.
There was no DNA. All right? That didn't come until maybe 10 years later.
And thank God for that. Over the years, investigators had tried to use developing DNA technology to solve the case.
There were squabs taken of the victim at the time of her autopsy. There were also her underwear and her clothing, shoes, socks, were still in custody at the coroner's office.
So we had that looked into again and had it tested for DNA. They were able to get a profile, albeit a week one by today's standards, and sent it off to various DNA databases, but didn't get a match from any of them.
As the years went by, DNA technology kept improving, producing more markers and better matches. So Richard Bell's unit tried again.
We decided, let's go back in now, and let's see whether or not there's anything more that could possibly be tested. They were able to develop a slightly better DNA profile and compared it to persons of interest in the case.
And none of those multiple samples that we submitted came back as a hit at that time. All these years, Gloria's boyfriend, Deshaun, felt like he was living under a cloud.
Was that getting around that you kept being interviewed and how the police were viewing you? Was it affecting your life? It would definitely affect my life. With other people? Wherever I went, people knew.
That's Gloria Pointer's boyfriend. Investigators would end up testing Deshaun's DNA against the stronger DNA profile.
He wasn't a match. This was vindication for you.
And now finally, everyone knew for sure, for 100% sure it was not you. Right.
But more especially for Ms. Pointer, she didn't know who did it.
And maybe it could have been me, you know. And I don't know if that even crossed her mind, but it was good that it was cleared up that definitely it was me.
Investigators also checked Ramel Broom, and his DNA didn't match either. While that seemed to rule him out from killing Gloria, detectives and Yvonne couldn't shake the feeling that Broom was somehow responsible.
I knew his execution date was coming, and I wrote him again. I said, Romel, please don't take it to your grave.
If you did this, just say it. I forgive you.
In 2009, 25 years after Gloria's murder, Romel Broom's execution day arrived. That morning, he did

something he'd never done before. He sat down and wrote Yvonne a letter.
Was this finally the

confession Yvonne had been waiting for? and for repairs under warranty, you might have a lemon. Defective vehicles, known as lemons, sometimes slip through even the best automakers.
You don't have to settle for one. Lemon Law Help is here to get you the compensation you deserve.
With millions recovered for car owners, they're known for big wins. Best part? No out-of-pocket costs to you.
Call now at 855-952-5252 or visit LemonLawHelp.com. Don't wait.
Get the help you need today. Paid spokesperson.
Every case is different. Results vary.
Courtesy of Roger Kiernos, Knight Law Group, LLP. Hey, everybody.
It's Rob Lowe here. If you haven't heard, I have a podcast that's called Literally with Rob Lowe.
And basically, it's conversations I've had that really make you feel like you're pulling up a chair at an intimate dinner between myself and people that I admire, like Aaron Sorkin or Tiffany Haddish, Demi Moore, Chris Pratt, Michael J. Fox.
There are new episodes out every Thursday. So subscribe, please, and listen wherever you get your podcasts.
Hi, we're Emoji Health, your long-term weight loss solution. We'll connect you with a board-certified provider to discuss your unique goals.
Eligible patients can access custom-formulated GLP-1 medications at an affordable fixed price. Deliver to their door monthly.
Take our free eligibility quiz at joinmochi.com and use code AUDIO40 at checkout for $40 off your first month of membership.

That's joinmochi.com.

Results may vary.

Eligible GLP-1 patients typically lose 1 to 2 pounds per week in their first 6 months with Mochi when combined with a healthy lifestyle.

September 15, 2009, the morning of Rommel Broome's execution. It was his last chance to respond to all those pleading letters from Yvonne.
That morning, he finally wrote back. Just hours later, an unimaginable scene unfolded in the death chamber.
Prison officials had trouble finding a vein for the lethal injection. Authorities called off the execution and moved it to a later date.
Days later, his letter to Yvonne arrived. I went to my post office box and there was this big brown brown envelope, and it had from Romel Broom.
My heart almost stopped, and he said, with my dying breath, I did not murder your daughter. Broom wrote that maybe Gloria's killer thought he'd gotten away with the crime because police believed Broom was responsible.
He wrote, that is not the case. Did you believe what he wrote in that letter? I did, but it only opened the door for more questions.
He thought he was about to be executed. He had no reason at this point to lie.
He could have just told the truth. But he encouraged me, as a matter of fact, in this letter to keep looking.
That's exactly what she did. It had been so long, 25 years, since that snowy day frozen in time and frozen in the memory of Gloria's cheerleading coach, T.
Stallworth. I was hoping to prepare and shape Gloria's life.
But after Gloria, I was not able to trust life anymore. And still telling my students, when you go out there, you be careful.

Stop trusting everybody.

And I started doing a segment that wasn't even in the health book about street smart kids.

Because of Gloria.

You know, and I would tell them about Gloria. Gloria's friend, Lamar Thomas, who saw her outside school that morning, could never bring himself to visit the place where she died.
Yeah, it haunts me. I never went over there to even view, you know, what all took place over there.
I blame myself because if she would have screamed or yelled or would have been right there. But for years, you know, I just was like, it was my fault.
Over the years, he stayed close with Gloria's mother. Like so many other kids in the neighborhood, he leaned on her for comfort and advice.
She didn't help me out so much. I just like to, you know, give back like she didn't give you back.
And I do just try to go over there, cut her grass, keep the yard work up, rake leaves, do something for her, since she done a lot for, you know, for a lot of people. For Gloria's family, the years never dulled their grief or their determination to find her killer.
Then, in 2013, almost 30 years since Gloria died, something caught the eye of Yvonne's sister, Sylvia. It was a newspaper article in the Cleveland Plain Dealer about using improved chemical DNA processing to solve cold cases.
Sylvia perked up. You felt like this could be something that could help you all? I thought so.
That maybe this could crack the case? No, I thought, why aren't they looking at her case? Sylvia emailed one of the reporters, Rachel DeSalle. She responded right away.
I'll look into it. I'm surprised you all haven't heard anything by now.
Then that's when things started happening. DeSalle, the reporter, called the DA's office to ask if DNA from Gloria's case could be entered into the national DNA database known as CODIS.
When she contacted our office, I contacted the coroner himself and I asked whether or not the case could be put into CODIS. We had asked for it to be put into CODIS on several occasions.
Even though prosecutor Richard Bell had obtained the strongest DNA profile yet, it still didn't meet the standard for CODIS.

But two days after the reporter called,

the DNA was submitted to the state DNA database.

All they wanted was one breakthrough, one match.

Boom.

Boom.

We get the hit. Over the years,

prosecutor Richard Bell's cold case unit had submitted several DNA samples

from Gloria Poynter's case

to DNA databases.

Then in 2013,

Bell submitted his strongest profile yet.

And... Boom.
Boom. We get the hit.
A DNA hit on a case that haunted Cleveland for decades. I can see you getting emotional just thinking about it.
No. It was that important to you? It's important.
It was important for the case. It was important for Yvonne.
It's something that we had been hoping for for a very long time. Thanks to the DNA match, Tim McGinty, then a Cuyahoga County prosecutor, suddenly had a potential name and face for Gloria Pointer's killer.
58-year-old Hernandez Warren. Then immediately I said, let's do a record check on this guy, see where he's been, and boom, he'd been to the penitentiary, and what for? Rape.
Bingo. Warren had a long rap sheet that included 16 years in prison for rape and felonious assault.
Now he was back living comfortably in the community. Once you get the DNA, that's just the first step.
Now you're going to have to confront the killer. Warren had grown up less than a mile from Gloria.
He even went to the same school, Harry E. Davis Jr.
High. He was 29 when Gloria was murdered.
So we had a team meeting. You got the FBI, you got the prosecutor, you got the Cleveland police, you got the sheriff, you got the detectives themselves.
Working closely with the FBI, investigators strategized about how to get Warren to come clean. They decided against a shock and awe arrest, opting instead to simply ask for Warren's help.
We had a team that would knock on the door with the ruse that they wanted to look at old cases in the area from the 1970s and the 1980s. Warren agreed to talk.
Like I said, if you guys need anything to have food, any drink. He agreed to talk to the police and the FBI without an attorney.
First off, do I have to call you Warren? You call me your name. Do the investigators straight up tell him, we have your DNA? No, absolutely not.
You want him to make the first move. You want him to explain whether or not he knows the person.

So this young girl here is Gloria Plainer. Okay.
I'll take a better look at her. You wouldn't have any association with her, right?

No.

Okay. All right.

Not to my knowledge.

Not to your knowledge?

I'd like you to sit still as possible.

Next, police gave him a polygraph.

Did you cause any of those injuries to Gloria?

No.

He failed.

Investigators decided to put more pressure on Warren.

Do you remember her?

No, I don't.

So they brought in a new team of detectives to question him for a second day.

Handcuffed to a chair.

You're almost placing yourself in the courtroom while you're watching this interrogation. I know what I need from the witnesses.
And making an ironclad. It has to be tight, because if it's not, with the personality that he has, he was going to try to manipulate his way out of it.
You were scared. You was on the drugs.
You wanted to get away. This is Gloria's body.
It's her body. It's her face.
It's her picture. And he would turn the picture over so he wouldn't have to look at it.
Can I cut that out? Please. This was rattling him.
It was rattling him. This right here.
Finally, Warren cracked. I was thinking about one thing.
What's that? Her dying. Her dying.
Her death, right? So all these years you've been thinking about her death. Since it happened, her death.
How could I do it? How could I do it? I'm like, damn. He confessed and told investigators what really happened on December 6, 1984.
Warren said he spotted Gloria on her way to school and approached her, grabbing her by the elbow. He said he strong-armed her to the bottom of the stairwell behind the school, attacked her, and beat her to death.
Is this it? I guess so. 29 years after Gloria's murder, police arrested Warren and called Yvonne to tell her they'd at last caught the killer.
Yvonne met them in a police conference room, a picture of Warren face down in front of her. They turned the picture over and slid it across the table, and they said, do you know this person? I said, I've never seen him before in my life.
And again, I wanted to know, are you sure? Are you sure? That's what I kept asking. Are you sure? And they would say, it's him.
Yvonne called Detective Abernathy, who remained involved in Gloria's case long after her retirement.

What was your first reaction to that?

I said, oh my gosh.

I said, thank you, Lord.

It's so bittersweet because it doesn't bring Gloria back.

But it gives Yvonne what she needed all these years.

And you. I gotta take a break.

Yeah, of course.

It's amazing that after all this time,

this is still the reaction that you have.

My empathy lies with all of a lot of other people

who've lost their child to such vicious crimes. Yeah.
Emotions a hardened detective never let go of. Until now.
It's finally released. It's finally released.
It's finally released.

You cared about her so much. I mean, I was going through my own troubles when I was younger then, and she brought me peace and joy.
She made you feel better about your life. About me.
Yeah. Mm-hmm.
Warren pleaded guilty to aggravated murder and rape. Because Yvonne didn't want the death penalty.
He was sentenced to life with the possibility of parole after 30 years. Hernandez Warren is perhaps one of the most dangerous people to have walked the streets of Cleveland.
He didn't see himself as a monster, but he was. He was a monster.
In spite of her immense loss, when Yvonne Poynter came face to face with her daughter's killer at his sentencing hearing, she chose to forgive. Second Timothy 4 and 7 says, I have fought a good fight.
I have finished my course. I have kept the faith.
May the Lord have mercy on your soul. In the years since Gloria was killed, Yvonne has made it her life's work to speak out against violence.
And I'm not okay with what happened to my child. About how crime disproportionately devastates people of color.
You were inducted into the Ohio Women's Hall of Fame. You went all the way to the White House.
You became a minister. Look at all these things that you have done in the years since Gloria died.
Her homicide gave me the option that I could lay down and die, or I could rise up and live. And along the way, I became the person who I was looking for.
How do you want people to remember Gloria? I want people to remember Gloria as a child who had a right to live in spite of the color of her skin.

And that there's so many other Glorias out there who deserve the same thing.

Exactly.

Sounds to me like Gloria's life saved other lives through your work.

It didn't save her life, but it is saving other lives. That's all for now.
I'm Lester Holt. Thanks for joining us.
If your 2020 or newer car or truck bought or leased from a California dealer has been in for repairs under warranty. We'll be right back.
Votation for big wins. They fight for your rights.
Best of all, you'll pay zero out of pocket. Call 877-294-1717 today for a free evaluation or visit LemonLawHelp.com.

Paid spokesperson. Every case is different.
Results vary.