Diabolical

Speaker 1 Hey everybody, Ted Danson here to tell you about my podcast with my longtime friend and sometimes co-host Woody Harrelson.

Speaker 1 It's called Where Everybody Knows Your Name and we're back for another season.

Speaker 1 I'm so excited to be joined this season by friends like John Mulaney, David Spade, Sarah Silverman, Ed Helms, and many more. You don't want to miss it.

Speaker 1 Listen to Where Everybody Knows Your Name with me, Ted Danson, and Woody Harrelson sometimes, wherever you get your podcasts.

Speaker 2 At Capella University, we believe accessible education can make a difference. That's why we offer scholarship opportunities to all eligible students.

Speaker 2 Un futuro diferente estamá cerca de lo que cres con capella university. Learn more at capella.edu.

Speaker 4 She was receiving long, rambling emails threatening her life, saying that her husband is cheating on her.

Speaker 4 She's telling her to watch her back. She better get out of the picture.

Speaker 5 Menacing emails sent to a newlywed.

Speaker 4 The new wife went to authorities and said that she was being harassed.

Speaker 5 That's kind of when all the fireworks started happening.

Speaker 7 Obviously, this has to stop.

Speaker 5 What arrived next was far worse.

Speaker 4 Strange men appeared at her door and tried to attack her.

Speaker 7 Somebody was posting ads online saying that they wanted to fulfill this rape fantasy.

Speaker 5 Everything pointed.

Speaker 8 to her husband's ex.

Speaker 4 They said, we're going to have to take you into custody. You're incarcerated.
For potentially the rest of my life.

Speaker 8 But hiding behind the threats was a cyber secret.

Speaker 9 Evil. Something that the devil might do.

Speaker 5 So, who was the real devil? The DA in this case would use the word diabolical.

Speaker 4 I think he's close to the mark.

Speaker 7 A dangerous game with someone playing for keeps.

Speaker 4 I would wake up and I would think this is just a nightmare.

Speaker 4 And it wasn't.

Speaker 8 I'm Lester Holt, and this is Dateline.

Speaker 5 Here's Dennis Murphy with Diabolical.

Speaker 5 Locked in a cage. The shrieks of women howling in the night.

Speaker 4 This isn't real. This is like something you would see in a movie.
This doesn't happen in real life.

Speaker 5 How did a self-described goody two-shoes of Disney princess get swept away in a conspiracy so convoluted, so twisted?

Speaker 7 This is one of the most well-thought out, well-executed plans, and it's scary.

Speaker 5 Diabolical. Absolutely.

Speaker 5 I've tangled web, you bet. An altogether bizarre plot.
Complicated scheme. Very complicated, very creative.

Speaker 4 This is the most shocking form of love rivalry that I've ever seen.

Speaker 5 There would be allegations of harassment, cyber-stalking, assault, and attempted rape. Someone was going to get hurt.
Someone was going to jail.

Speaker 5 And at the end of the nightmare, well, no one saw that coming. You decide whether it was a love rivalry.
But in the beginning, it was clearly a boy-meets-girl love story.

Speaker 4 It was a very intense period of my life in the sense of just a very kind of whirlwind type of romance.

Speaker 5 August 2013, 20-something Michelle Hadley met a U.S. Marshal named Ian Diaz over a cup of coffee.
Things move fast. He told you that he loved you or you were beautiful?

Speaker 4 Yes.

Speaker 5 He started to hit you with a thunderbolt.

Speaker 4 Yeah, kind of early on, actually. Yeah, about the second date, he was telling me he loved me.

Speaker 5 Did you think, slow down, buddy, here?

Speaker 5 Did you welcome him?

Speaker 4 You know, I think when you're a young girl who's kind of been raised on the fairy tale princess dream, it's very exciting and flattering.

Speaker 5 Could this be her Prince Charming? She was meeting over at Cappuccino, the man she dreamed of since she was a little girl.

Speaker 10 She was very imaginative, very intelligent, and she just loved to play and create.

Speaker 5 Michelle's mother, Suzanne, and father, Michael, raised her and her younger sister in this modest home in Ontario, California. She was a cross-country runner, good student.

Speaker 4 I was an overachiever.

Speaker 5 The kid who ruined the curve for everybody else.

Speaker 4 Yeah, actually, sometimes.

Speaker 5 Michelle was offered a scholarship to attend Dickinson, a well-regarded liberal arts college back east in Pennsylvania. You must have both been very proud of how your child was working out.
Oh, yeah.

Speaker 5 Very proud.

Speaker 5 After graduation, she tried various careers before eventually landing a marketing job at Disney. And now she had met this man, Ian Diaz, the U.S.
Marshal, her very own Prince Charming.

Speaker 5 In December 2014, for her 28th birthday, he whisked her off to New York. He took her to the sweeping vistas atop Rockefeller Center and proposed.
And you said?

Speaker 4 I said yes. Yeah.
I said yes.

Speaker 5 It was time to find a starter castle to complete the fairy tale. Just minutes from her job at Disney, they bought into a new condo development in Anaheim.

Speaker 5 She would be able to watch the Disneyland fireworks from the roof.

Speaker 4 I put the whole-down payment down.

Speaker 5 You paid the whole down.

Speaker 4 I paid the whole down payment, yes.

Speaker 5 They waited for the condo to be finished, and in June they moved in. But Michelle said, that's when the relationship changed.
Fell apart, actually.

Speaker 5 Two months later, she packed her Jeddah with whatever stuff she could fit in and left. Showed up at her parents' parents' doorstep.
Surprised? Tell me about that night.

Speaker 10 Um, well, I had gotten a text from her saying, can I come home? And I said, you don't even need to ask.

Speaker 5 Why were you not suited for him in your opinion?

Speaker 4 I didn't feel that the relationship was healthy for me.

Speaker 5 Not nurturing for you or?

Speaker 4 Not nurturing for me, yeah.

Speaker 5 Were there tempers? Were there...

Speaker 4 Let's just say that I'm not a strong personality. And so, you know, I have to be very careful the kinds of people I surround myself with.

Speaker 4 It's almost better for me not to be in a relationship than to be in a bad one.

Speaker 5 But there were still ties that bound the former couple. A mortgage, the deed to that condo in Anaheim, which became a source of tension.
Both hired lawyers, but it got personal.

Speaker 5 Michelle claimed Ian was unfaithful, even abusive. And she sent him a strange email, the language laced with religiosity and references to the Bible, Satan, and a mythical demon called Lilith.

Speaker 5 Please explain to your real estate attorney that God's God's law is above all laws, including the law of man.

Speaker 5 Lilith, you may try to hide behind the law of man, but it is a weak shield that will bend and crack against the sword of God.

Speaker 5 Ian denied her allegations and said he was so alarmed by Michelle's email that he applied for a restraining order against her.

Speaker 5 He accused her of infidelity and wrote, Because of her emotional instability, history of fits of rage, I fear for my safety.

Speaker 5 The request for the restraining order was dismissed a few weeks later, and the law of man prevailed, or so it seemed. The lawyers hashed out a compromise.

Speaker 4 We actually ended up getting a settlement agreement.

Speaker 5 Ian and Michelle signed it in November 2015. The deal allowed Ian to stay in the condo, but he had six months to get his own mortgage.

Speaker 5 Failing that, he'd have to sell the condo and split any profits with Michelle. Michelle stood to lose most of her down payment, about $10,000, but she said it was worth it.

Speaker 4 I moved on with my life completely,

Speaker 4 100% completely. I actually had started dating again.

Speaker 5 So you had this toothache of a problem with a condo because it was not a major part of your life.

Speaker 4 Well, and once the settlement agreement was signed, it was just a waiting game.

Speaker 5 She went back to school, started an MBA program at Chapman University. Ian, too, moved on quickly, married a woman named Angela.

Speaker 5 But the nagging condo issue still wasn't resolved, and the six-month deadline was approaching. And that's kind of when all the fireworks started happening.

Speaker 8 Soon, more emails, really frightening ones, aimed at a new target. When we return.

Speaker 4 Angela was claiming that she was receiving long, rambling emails saying that her husband, Ian, doesn't love her, that she better get out of the picture soon before he hurts her.

Speaker 8 And not long after the emails arrive, so do police.

Speaker 5 I said, what's going on out here? And the guy said, we just arrested Michelle.

Speaker 5 By June 1st, 2016, tension over the Anaheim condo Michelle Hadley and Ian Diaz had shared was once again starting to peak. The deadline was fast approaching.

Speaker 5 Ian needed to take over the mortgage or sell the condo. And that's when some odd events began to unfold.
Michelle's father, Michael, was at work. His youngest daughter was at their home in Ontario.

Speaker 5 I get a phone call from my youngest daughter saying, hey, somebody's knocked, beaten on the door. And I said, look outside.
Is there a police car? She says, yeah, there's two of them.

Speaker 5 I say, well, then open the door, because it scared her, I guess. And

Speaker 5 so a woman throws down a restraining order. Here you've been served, kind of thing.
Yeah, here you've been served with the police, two officers there. And it was from Angela Diaz.

Speaker 5 The restraining order was for Michelle, who was still living at her parents' home. It came from Angela Diaz, Ian's wife of three months, who had recently announced she was pregnant.

Speaker 4 Angela came into the picture not long after Ian and Michelle had actually broken up.

Speaker 5 Reporter Kate Bricolay covered this story for the Daily Beast. She spent hours digging through the curious emails Michelle sent Ian during the condo dispute.

Speaker 4 One minute she's very polite in thanking him for reminders on her car insurance. The next minute, you know, she's saying that he's Satan and the Antichrist.

Speaker 5 Even after they signed the agreement on the condo, the emails kept coming. Ian got this one on May 22nd.

Speaker 5 You told me I was your first love, but you did not treat me like the precious perfect treasure I am.

Speaker 5 You have sinned against God, and I want my power back because it belongs to us, the daughters of God.

Speaker 5 Then, something new and strange started happening. Angela began receiving emails too.

Speaker 4 Long, rambling emails saying that, you know, her husband, Ian, doesn't love her, that Michelle is, you know, his one true love, and that

Speaker 4 Ian is cheating on her. He manipulates women.
She better get out of the picture soon before he hurts her.

Speaker 5 These new emails to Angela sounded like Michelle's emails to Ian, complete with biblical imagery. But they came from multiple email addresses and were signed, Jason Ray.

Speaker 4 Telling Angela that

Speaker 4 she would always be Eve and that Michelle was Ian's Lilith, his truth, and that Angela would never be his one true love.

Speaker 5 Then another email to Angela appeared. The subject line, die.
The message, I hope you are scared of death tomorrow. Be prepared.
Don't sleep. Be watchful of the daughters of God.

Speaker 5 The email continued, we will steal your child and we will watch as it dies. Angela said when she looked to see who sent this email, it was from Michelle Hadley.

Speaker 5 You can understand from Angela's point of view why she'd be so rattled. Right.

Speaker 5 A barrage of emails arrived on May 31st, 2016. Be warned, Angela, you've lost.
I am going to end you. You will suffer.
I will pray for you.

Speaker 5 The next morning, June 1st, Angela filed for for that restraining order, the one police served at the Hadley's home.

Speaker 5 It read in part, Miss Hadley has been emailing me for over one week, repeatedly threatening my life, my marriage, my safety, slandering my husband.

Speaker 5 The rhetorical language you used in your email to your ex had a kind of a biblical Old Testament ferocity to it. They said, this is the same person.
Well,

Speaker 4 no comment on that, but,

Speaker 4 you know,

Speaker 5 but to your ears, it was not at at all. No, no.
Michelle admits she did send fire and brimstone emails to Ian, though she was reluctant to discuss them on camera.

Speaker 5 She later told us it was a symptom of post-traumatic stress disorder, which she blamed on her volatile relationship with her ex. But she told us she never sent any emails to Angela.

Speaker 5 In fact, Michelle says she didn't even know her.

Speaker 4 I've never heard of her. I've never communicated with her.

Speaker 5 Couldn't say where she lived or pick her out of a lineup.

Speaker 4 Exactly. I mean, I'm assuming she lives at the condo with him, but aside from that, that's the extent of what I know about her.
I don't know what her job is. I don't know where she works.

Speaker 4 I know nothing about her background.

Speaker 5 Or so she said. Police thought otherwise.

Speaker 7 There is very compelling evidence.

Speaker 5 Sergeant Darren Wyatt was the public information officer for the Anaheim Police Department. There was some very vivid, religious, ferocious imagery that was clearly written by Michelle to her ex.

Speaker 5 that seems to be the same kind of emails that are coming to Angela. Did that drive some of your theory about the case?

Speaker 7 I can't talk about specifics, but there is clear and convincing evidence to believe that Michelle Hadley was the person who was sending the emails.

Speaker 5 A judge ordered Michelle to cease all contact with Angela and Ian. But the emails continued.
June 6th, you will pay for this. I hope to God you are ready for the pain I will show you.
Then this.

Speaker 5 Burn in the fiery pits of hell tonight as by God's law, you will be hurt. Three weeks after the restraining order was filed, police returned to Michelle's parents' house.

Speaker 4 They have a search warrant for my devices, and so I hand all my devices over. I give them all the passcodes, and he opens up my cell phone.

Speaker 5 The officer looked through her email account, checked the activity there, then arrested Michelle for violating the restraining order.

Speaker 5 I heard door slamming out in front, and I went out in the front, and I said, what's going on out here? And the guy said, they just arrested Michelle. Arrested your Michelle? Yes.

Speaker 5 She was placed in a holding cell. Her parents posted a bond to get her out.
And after a very long night, they picked her up from the Anaheim Police Department.

Speaker 10 There she was sitting on the steps out in front.

Speaker 5 It's one of the stranger days of your life. The strangest.

Speaker 5 But strange days were only beginning.

Speaker 5 Coming up.

Speaker 8 From daggers by email to danger at the front door.

Speaker 7 Somebody was posting ads online through Craigslist saying that they wanted to fulfill this rape fantasy.

Speaker 5 When Dateline continues.

Speaker 11 Hey, weirdos, I'm Elena, and I'm Ash, and we are the hosts of Morbid Podcast.

Speaker 6 Each week, we dive into the dark and fascinating world of true crime, spooky history, and the unexplained.

Speaker 11 From infamous killers and unsolved mysteries to haunted places and strange legends, we cover it all with research, empathy, humor, and a few creative expletives.

Speaker 12 It's smart, it's spooky, and it's just the right amount of weird.

Speaker 11 Two new episodes drop every week, and there's even a bonus once a month.

Speaker 6 Find us wherever you listen to podcasts. Yay! Woo!

Speaker 2 At Capella University, we believe accessible education can make a difference. That's why we offer scholarship opportunities to all eligible students.

Speaker 2 Un futuro difrente estamá cerca de lo que cres con Capella University. Learn more at capella.edu.

Speaker 3 Did you know that parents rank financial literacy as the number one most difficult life skill to teach? Meet Greenlight, the debit card and money app for families.

Speaker 3 With Greenlight, you can set up chores, automate allowance, and keep an eye on your kids' spending with real-time notifications.

Speaker 3 Kids learn to earn, save, and spend wisely, and parents can rest easy knowing their kids are learning about money with guardrails in place sign up for green light today at greenlight.com slash podcast

Speaker 5 June 2016 Michelle Hadley was out on bail living with her parents Anaheim police suspected Michelle had sent threatening emails to her ex-boyfriend Ian and his pregnant wife Angela even though on its face it didn't make much sense a young woman who's lived an exemplary life, good student, she's trying to get an MBA.

Speaker 7 Well there's two sides to every person and all we're seeing is the evidence that looks very clear that everything is originating from Michelle Hadley.

Speaker 5 But the case against Michelle went way beyond threatening emails. Police had evidence she was up to something much more sinister, something stomach churning.

Speaker 5 It began in early June, about the same time as the deadline on the condo was approaching.

Speaker 7 Somebody was posting ads online through Craigslist saying that they wanted to fulfill this rape fantasy.

Speaker 5 Rape fantasy is a genre?

Speaker 7 I don't think I've ever heard of this. I had never heard of it either until this particular case, but apparently, yes, there's a market for it.

Speaker 5 It's a type of personal ad. You can find them on Craigslist and elsewhere online.
Men seeking women who want to meet and act out a rape. A woman responded to the ad.

Speaker 5 I have been dying to have a rape fantasy occur. If you can fulfill this tonight, please let me know.
I am 30, tall, gorgeous, and ready. I have a Yorkie I walk every night.
Come find me.

Speaker 5 The email gave an address, the condo in Anaheim, where Angela and Ian lived. On June 13th, Angela and Ian told police a man showed up at their door, expecting to have violent sex with Angela.

Speaker 5 They told police they sent him away, but other men followed, all invited by email responses to rape fantasy ads.

Speaker 7 It escalates again, now to the point that Angela Diaz calls the police department and reports that another person had shown up and had actually tried to rape her.

Speaker 5 Police officers responded to Angela's 911 call.

Speaker 7 What did they encounter? They encounter a very distraught Angela Diaz who says that another person had shown up and

Speaker 7 cracked on her neck and her shirt is torn.

Speaker 5 This is way beyond internet misdemeanor mischief. This is a criminal act in your city.

Speaker 7 Most definitely a criminal act.

Speaker 5 Who was inviting men to rape Angela? Police believe there was no question it was Michelle Hadley. That's what led them to arrest Michelle outside her parents' home.

Speaker 5 Angela reported that during the night Michelle spent in jail, she received no threatening emails. But then Michelle made bail.
She was out.

Speaker 7 And almost immediately, the emails start again.

Speaker 5 So is there kind of a feel here of, look, we warned you about this activity? Correct. And it's continuing.
Correct. This is a very complicated complicated scheme, Kate.

Speaker 4 Yes.

Speaker 5 Daily Beast reporter Kate Bricolay tried to unravel the story from her office in New York City. Angela Diaz appeared to be the victim at the center of an increasingly dangerous game.

Speaker 4 She was afraid for her life. She was afraid to go anywhere.
She felt that she had to uproot her whole life, take down her online profiles, and hide.

Speaker 5 July 11th, two weeks after Michelle bailed out of jail, a new rape fantasy ad appeared on Craigslist and a response.

Speaker 5 Once again, the email directed the man who placed the ad to the home of Angela Diaz. And what would Michelle's motivation be in doing this campaign?

Speaker 4 It's interesting. I mean, there's the fact that there's some sort of a love triangle going on, right? There's two women, one guy,

Speaker 4 and there's also the unsold condominium.

Speaker 5 The condo was still a factor in the story. The bank had not approved Ian and Angela for a mortgage.
So it was time to sell as agreed to.

Speaker 5 But that wasn't going to happen, according to Michelle's father. The ex-boyfriend was digging in his heels.
He's not going to sell the condo. He does not want to move out, period.

Speaker 5 He just makes that clear. On July 12, 2016, even as she remained under investigation for cyber-stalking and worse, Michelle filed a breach of contract lawsuit against Ian over the condo.

Speaker 5 The next day, Angela called police. Another man was outside her condo.
Anaheim detectives found a 17-year-old in the courtyard. He told police he was responding to a Craigslist ad.

Speaker 5 I think the day before yesterday, it was... Tony Rakakis was the Orange County District Attorney.

Speaker 9 We've got to get her off the street. It's hazardous to Angela at this point.

Speaker 5 Michelle looked like a loose cannon out there. She did.
Capable of harm.

Speaker 9 Absolutely. Absolutely.

Speaker 5 Police got a warrant and once again, arrested Michelle Hadley.

Speaker 10 It's very hard to see your daughter being placed in handcuffs. And I just kept saying to him, no, no, I can't believe it.

Speaker 5 This time, it was much more serious. Michelle was charged with stalking, making criminal threats, and six counts of attempted rape for directing those men to Angela Dia's door.

Speaker 5 Michelle's second arrest got the attention of reporters both in Orange County and across the country.

Speaker 4 The headline seemed too kooky and convoluted to even be true.

Speaker 5 Bail this time was $1 million. dollars.
Michelle faced life in prison. Is this rock bottom moment for you, Michelle?

Speaker 4 Absolutely. It's the scariest moment of my life.

Speaker 5 Coming up,

Speaker 8 a princess behind bars. I stood out like a sort of thumb with no Prince Charming in sight.

Speaker 4 I got a death threat letter. What if one of the girls goes after me? What happens then?

Speaker 5 The charges and the headlines were devastating.

Speaker 5 In an article in her hometown paper, the shorthand was that Michelle Hadley was the psycho ex-girlfriend from hell, the mover behind a lurid and devious plot.

Speaker 5 Her parents, Michael and Suzanne, couldn't, wouldn't believe it. There's nothing in character with the Michelle that you've raised here.

Speaker 5 Not at all.

Speaker 5 It's actually 180 degrees so out of sync with her behavior. They went to see Michelle on her first day in jail after being charged.
Is this going to be a conversation with phones through glass? Yes.

Speaker 5 Yes. There are cells without cages, but she's in a caged one.
You know, I don't know why she always has to be in a cage one, but she does. Michelle's bail was set at $1 million.

Speaker 5 To get her out, Mike and Suzanne would have to come up with about 10% of that. That's $100,000 cash.
They told their daughter they had enough to do that or to hire a good lawyer, but not both.

Speaker 5 Bottom line is we're going to have to fight this, and there's no bail.

Speaker 5 And that's it. How tough is that, Suzanne? You had the money, you could have had her home for dinner.

Speaker 3 Yeah,

Speaker 10 it was pretty tough.

Speaker 4 I told my dad I was scared to death. I didn't know what was going to happen in jail, but I told my dad I was like, I can handle it.
Don't worry about me. Go get a good attorney.

Speaker 5 And you're incarcerated. Yep.

Speaker 4 For potentially the rest of my life.

Speaker 5 The girl who loved Disneyland, fairy tale princesses, and her morning Starbucks, said she'd stay behind bars and tough it out. Jailhouse denims were her new black.

Speaker 4 Well, I stood out like a sort of thumb.

Speaker 5 What is your cell like? Tiny.

Speaker 4 They have two bunk beds, a table and two chairs, and then your toilet is actually attached to your sink. So everyone can kind of see in.
So you never get any privacy.

Speaker 5 What is the day of your day?

Speaker 4 They wake you up at 4:30 a.m., then they bring you your breakfast. Which is what?

Speaker 4 It's usually some sort of gruel-looking potato mash. I don't even know how to describe it.

Speaker 5 And I'm guessing not a foamy Starbucks.

Speaker 4 No Starbucks.

Speaker 5 While we're talking about food, what's lunch?

Speaker 4 Bologna sandwich and really, really nasty bologna. I almost didn't eat for the first, you know, three or four days.

Speaker 5 Michelle, the sounds at the jailhouse.

Speaker 4 Yeah, good luck sleeping in jail.

Speaker 4 The door slamming is very loud, and the women at night sometimes scream like banshees. So you'll hear it echoing throughout the jail.

Speaker 5 The population of street-hardened prisoners took a close look at the petite young woman from the good home now living in their cell block.

Speaker 5 Checked her out especially after that story about her in the local paper got passed around.

Speaker 4 After that article, I had women coming up to my cell door harassing me about it. I got a death threat letter at one point slipped under my cell door.
What if one of the girls goes after me?

Speaker 4 What happens then?

Speaker 5 One of the women who took you under your wing said, you got to toughen up, girl. Yeah.
Talking to you.

Speaker 5 You need to develop a little swagger. Yeah.

Speaker 4 Well, apparently I walk like a church mouse and that's not cool. And she said, you're going to get hurt in here because you look weak when you walk.

Speaker 5 You need to become Scarface, huh? Yeah, yeah, yes. Of course, to the outside world, she already was Scarface.
Kate Bricole of the Daily Beast reported on the case.

Speaker 4 These were incredibly serious charges that Michelle was facing. Felony charges that included attempted forcible rape.

Speaker 5 Meanwhile, Michelle's parents were in crisis mode looking for an attorney. You don't have criminal defense attorneys on your speed dial, I'm guessing.
Correct. We do not.

Speaker 5 Mike and Suzanne wanted the right lawyer to deal with a cyber crime. They also wanted to start working on Michelle's defense right away.
Their daughter was in trouble.

Speaker 5 So they started their own investigation.

Speaker 5 Was it clear to you, Mike, that if you're going to claw your way out of this thing, you've got to understand the story told by the computers? Correct. The forensics of this gap.
Absolutely.

Speaker 5 So you've got to learn a whole bunch of jargon. I know IP addresses and all the other stuff.
An IP address is a numeric code that identifies a computer network or an individual device.

Speaker 5 Mike had copies of all the incriminating emails from the evidence filed with that restraining order. He started going through them with software that traces IP addresses.

Speaker 5 This investigative software that you use to become your own detective, is that something you've got to go to Caltech to get a copy of? Is this NSA material? Oh, gosh, no.

Speaker 5 It's the 15-year-old kid material. As Mike got results, Suzanne would organize them.

Speaker 10 He would print out on yellow pads of legal paper all the IP addresses. And then I would take all of them.

Speaker 10 and I put them on a spreadsheet and then we highlighted where certain IP addresses were the same.

Speaker 5 The idea being that this IP address is going to go back to a physical location.

Speaker 10 Yes.

Speaker 5 If they could trace an email sent from one location and prove Michelle was somewhere else at the same time, it could be an alibi.

Speaker 5 But to DA Tony Rakakis, it looked like a bad set of facts for Michelle Hadley.

Speaker 9 Looking at the emails and the pictures and the ads,

Speaker 9 looked like Michelle Hadley was just doing this terrible thing, stalking and victimizing of Angela.

Speaker 5 The wheels of justice were grinding slowly, and the lives of two young women were hanging in the balance.

Speaker 8 Coming up, Michelle gets a break.

Speaker 10 She was in class.

Speaker 8 And a lawyer with a mission.

Speaker 5 This is kind of the case you go to law school for. This is the reason you become a lawyer.
When Dateline continues.

Speaker 1 Hey everybody, Ted Danson here to tell you about my podcast with my longtime friend and sometimes co-host Woody Harrelson.

Speaker 1 It's called Where Everybody Knows Your Name and we're back for another season.

Speaker 1 I'm so excited to be joined this season by friends like John Mulaney, David Spade, Sarah Silverman, Ed Helms, and many more. You don't want to miss it.

Speaker 1 Listen to Where Everybody Knows Your Name with me, Ted Danson, and Woody Harrelson sometimes, wherever you get your podcasts.

Speaker 2 At Capella University, we believe accessible education can make a difference. That's why we offer scholarship opportunities to all eligible eligible students.

Speaker 2 Un futuro diferente estamá cerca de lo que cres con Capella University.

Speaker 3 Learn more at capella.edu. Did you know that parents rank financial literacy as the number one most difficult life skill to teach? Meet Greenlight, the debit card and money app for families.

Speaker 3 With Greenlight, you can set up chores, automate allowance, and keep an eye on your kids' spending with real-time notifications.

Speaker 3 Kids learn to earn, save, and spend wisely, and parents can rest easy knowing their kids are learning about money with guardrails in place.

Speaker 3 Sign up for Green Light today at greenlight.com slash podcast.

Speaker 5 Each day in jail was a struggle for Michelle Hadley. Not just the daily grind, but the death threats, the fear, living in legal limbo.

Speaker 5 She took comfort writing long letters to her family, trying to convince them and maybe herself that she was okay.

Speaker 4 July 21st, 2016. Dear Ma, Daddy, and Rebecca,

Speaker 4 my commissary order finally arrived today, so I have paper and decent pencils, among other goodies.

Speaker 10 Writing has always relaxed me, and since I'm pretty sure this ordeal is the most stressful of my life to date, you can expect to get letters from me.

Speaker 10 I wanted to send you one positive thing and one thing I want to do when I'm free as much for my mood and sanity as for yours.

Speaker 10 One positive thing.

Speaker 10 I haven't had this much time to read in a long time.

Speaker 4 Wish list, a gourmet burger and a glass of red wine. All my love.
Michelle.

Speaker 5 I hear a lot of you reassuring them in that.

Speaker 4 That was exactly what was happening. I didn't want them to worry too much.
I didn't want them to be afraid.

Speaker 4 They were already fighting so much on the outside and doing so much work, you know, and I wanted them to be proud

Speaker 5 of

Speaker 4 what a brave girl they had raised.

Speaker 5 But as the weeks turned into months, her brave front started to crack.

Speaker 4 There were mornings when I would wake up and I would open my eyes and I would see the white jail cell wall and I would think, Okay, I'm going to wake up a second time. This is just a nightmare.

Speaker 4 And it wasn't,

Speaker 4 it was for real. I was starting to feel like I was slipping away.

Speaker 5 You felt your humanity slipping away? Yeah, she looked absolutely not even close to a criminal. That's your gut talking, right? My gut's pretty good.

Speaker 5 Michelle's parents hired defense attorney Michael Giusti to defend their daughter. Justy felt an instant connection to the Hadleys.

Speaker 5 I looked at Michelle's family, and

Speaker 5 to a large extent, I saw my family. I saw

Speaker 5 I saw a working-class family who fiercely defended their child. She was a young, ambitious MBA student who was nothing but bright-eyed and optimistic.
And who was facing life in prison?

Speaker 7 For no reason.

Speaker 9 No reason.

Speaker 5 So this is kind of the case you go to law school for.

Speaker 5 This is the reason you become a lawyer.

Speaker 5 Michelle's mom and dad showed Justy the computer research they'd done on the emails at the heart of the case. Michael Hadley was convinced they'd found something crucial.

Speaker 5 Why are Michelle's digital fingerprints on this thing? They're not. There's no digital fingerprints whatsoever.
It looks like it's coming from Michelle.

Speaker 5 It looks like somebody's trying to make it look like it's coming from Michelle, that's for sure.

Speaker 5 The Hadley spreadsheet showed some of the incriminating emails were sent when Michelle could prove she was in a classroom at Chapman University. Here's Michelle.

Speaker 5 At school, she's at Chapman, and here's emails coming.

Speaker 10 And she's in class. She was in class doing her final course presentation.
There's no way she's going to be sending this email.

Speaker 5 The Hadleys thought they had it. Proof that Michelle was innocent.
But Defense Attorney Giusti disagreed. He knew it would take skillful legal legwork to convince prosecutors.

Speaker 5 A district attorney is never going to buy my evidence. A district attorney is going to have to convince themselves that they have evidence which might accidentally coincide with what I have.

Speaker 5 In fact, police and prosecutors were still doing everything they could to link those emails to Michelle.

Speaker 7 We have a very skilled detective who was working on the case, and he was in constant communications with the district attorney's office and trying to piece it together to help prove a case and solidify it for court.

Speaker 9 The problem was it just it wasn't coming together. These electronic messages were coming

Speaker 9 from a different place, and we couldn't verify that it was coming from Michelle Hadley's device.

Speaker 5 It was a blow to the prosecution's case. But there was more evidence than just IP addresses.

Speaker 5 There was the bad blood between Michelle and Ian, the restraining orders, those harrowing attempted rapes of Ian's new wife, Angela.

Speaker 5 and that fire and brimstone language of the threatening emails so distinctive and seemingly in Michelle's voice. So that language of religious retribution made it appear to be Michelle.

Speaker 5 You can stand before God on this thing.

Speaker 9 That's right. And that caused the police and our investigators as well to look at it and say, well, this is Michelle writing this.

Speaker 5 One thing was clear, though. The computer forensics had blown a sizable hole in the prosecution's case.
Justy seized the moment and worked out a deal.

Speaker 5 The DA would release Michelle from jail, but he would not drop the charges against her. And And the investigation would continue.
After 88 days, Michelle walked out of jail.

Speaker 4 On the outside, basically my parents, they were there waiting for me and

Speaker 4 got my coffee.

Speaker 5 Famous coffee, the good cup of coffee.

Speaker 4 Yeah, the good cup of coffee.

Speaker 4 Which, oh man, I had been dreaming about that for so long.

Speaker 5 It was an incredible moment for the Hadleys. A legal victory, but not the end of the road.
She's still in jeopardy. She's still charged with the same crimes.
And she's got an ankle bracelet on.

Speaker 5 She had an ankle bracelet on.

Speaker 4 You know, I already felt like I was so scarred from jail.

Speaker 4 And wearing that device, you kind of still feel like you're an animal.

Speaker 5 And

Speaker 5 I just remember thinking,

Speaker 6 how did I get here? I didn't do anything.

Speaker 5 Coming up.

Speaker 8 If Michelle wasn't sending the emails, who was? And why?

Speaker 8 The DA has a word for it.

Speaker 5 Diabolical. How did that word come to you?

Speaker 9 Diabolical is something evil.

Speaker 5 With every thump of her heart, Michelle felt she was losing a little part of herself. Out of jail, but not out of jeopardy.

Speaker 5 Free to go to a high-end coffee shop, but not allowed to remove the ankle bracelet tracking her.

Speaker 4 I had wrapped it with this

Speaker 4 sports bandage because I was so embarrassed to be wearing it, you know.

Speaker 5 But everything was about to change. After a thorough search of Michelle's digital devices, investigators concluded the damning emails did not come from them.

Speaker 7 We actually have a lab,

Speaker 7 our own computer forensics lab, and then we have people that are very well trained. And that's really how this came to fruition, that we were able to determine that Michelle Hadley wasn't the suspect.

Speaker 5 This was momentous. After months in jail, after the ankle bracelet, Michelle Hadley was cleared.

Speaker 4 You're happy, but your emotions are all over the place because you're kind of coming out of this fog.

Speaker 5 Now police faced a daunting new investigation. The suspect could be literally anybody with a cell phone or access to the internet.

Speaker 7 We can't show where it was coming from without the service of a search warrant and then getting the information from the internet service provider. And it took months.

Speaker 5 Police needed critical data from internet providers to confirm the precise times and locations of the cyber attacks against Angela.

Speaker 5 They executed more than 50 search warrants and court orders during their investigation.

Speaker 7 There's very few cases where we've had to write that many search warrants just to get to the bottom line, to get to the truth.

Speaker 5 And when they finally started getting the information they needed, the results were stunning.

Speaker 5 The ugly trail of ones and zeros seemed to show that at least some of the hateful emails were coming from the condo in Anaheim. The one Ian and Michelle had been to court over.

Speaker 5 The one Ian and Angela were now living in. The condo, suddenly looking like the scene of the crime and the motive, all in one.

Speaker 4 This is where Angela and Ian lived, and I don't think that they wanted to leave.

Speaker 5 So if the ex-girlfriend, crazy psycho ex-girlfriend in the public eye is incarcerated in a way, that resolves some of these financial issues?

Speaker 4 Right. They'll have complete control over their residence.

Speaker 5 And now both of them were suspects. Ian, the U.S.
Marshal, and Angela, the pregnant newlywed.

Speaker 5 In a way, it makes more sense if you're looking at conventional motivation that it would be the ex-boyfriend, Diaz, rather than the woman he married.

Speaker 4 Right, exactly.

Speaker 5 But the deeper they looked, the more police zeroed in on the woman Ian married and all the bizarre goings-on swirling around her.

Speaker 5 One that stood out was Angela's report that someone tried to rape her in the garage of the condo.

Speaker 9 You have to go to an alley to get to the garage, and the garage doesn't have an address on it.

Speaker 5 So you're wondering how this alleged assailant actually found her.

Speaker 9 That gets to be a question. But then also there were some surveillance cameras that were in the area.

Speaker 5 And presumably would have shown someone trying to enter.

Speaker 9 And you didn't have that. We didn't have that.

Speaker 5 What about the scene itself?

Speaker 9 When you start questioning whether or not this could have happened in her story about how she fought the guy off and compare that to the rather light injuries that she was showing, it all started looking a little bit sketchy.

Speaker 5 Investigators uncovered more sketchy behavior.

Speaker 5 Angela seemed to have a troubling history.

Speaker 9 We start seeing some of the fraudulent things that she's, you know, that she's been involved in. Some bad checks.
Bad checks.

Speaker 5 Faking a cancer episode.

Speaker 9 Faking a cancer episode. Things like that.

Speaker 5 The DA says Angela lied about something else, too. She was not pregnant with Ian's child.
But it wasn't the trail of lies that really mattered.

Speaker 5 It was the trail of emails that ultimately cracked the case. It turned out the emails sent from the condo didn't come from a computer at all, but, says the DA, from a cell phone, Angela's cell phone.

Speaker 5 In an already Beyond Strange case, this turned things up to 11.

Speaker 4 Their original victim ended up being their number one suspect.

Speaker 5 How's that for Whiplash?

Speaker 4 I don't think anyone could believe it.

Speaker 5 It was time. Six months after Michelle Hadley was first charged, Angela Diaz was arrested and jailed.

Speaker 9 Good morning, and thank you all for coming.

Speaker 5 DA Tony Rokakis held a press conference

Speaker 5 and delivered the stunning news.

Speaker 9 I'm here to announce the filing of a felony complaint against Angela Marie Diaz by the Orange County District Attorney's Office.

Speaker 5 There were no charges against Ian, the man in the middle. The DA said Angela Diaz was the mastermind and sole actor in an elaborate scheme to portray herself as a victim.

Speaker 5 She had quite simply framed Michelle Hadley. Michelle is accused of being Angela, who turned out to be Angela pretending to be Michelle pretending to be Angela.
The charges were just that convoluted.

Speaker 5 Angela accused of sending herself threatening emails, inviting men to her own home to rape her, inflicting injuries on herself, and all to put her husband's ex-girlfriend behind bars.

Speaker 5 What's more, at least for a few months, authorities say she succeeded.

Speaker 9 When someone who's innocent gets arrested and charged with a crime, that's not just a bad day. It's a nightmare.
It needs to be made clear in the media and in cyberspace. Ms.

Speaker 9 Hadley is an innocent victim of a diabolical scheme.

Speaker 5 How'd that word come to you? And what do you mean now about diabolical in this scheme?

Speaker 9 Diabolical is something evil. It's something that the devil might do.

Speaker 5 Not to be too glib, your theory was wrong, but you untangled it. Is that what happened here?

Speaker 9 Well, that is right.

Speaker 5 You're sorry that the first theory was wrong.

Speaker 9 Absolutely. You know, it's a terrible thing to

Speaker 9 accuse an innocent person.

Speaker 5 Were the apologies enough? Your county authorities doing, in effect, a walk of shame, saying we got this terribly wrong.

Speaker 4 I appreciate the apologies, but the apologies don't rebuild your life.

Speaker 4 And the apologies don't undo what's been done.

Speaker 4 I'll carry this around for the rest of my life.

Speaker 5 To attempt to get justice for Michelle, her lawyer filed a lawsuit against Angela Diaz, Ian Diaz, and the city of Anaheim.

Speaker 5 In 2021, the city, without admitting liability, agreed to pay Michelle $1,795,000. Ian Diaz and Angela Diaz reached separate settlements with Michelle.

Speaker 7 The Anaheim Police Department, our detective, didn't create the situation Angela Diaz did.

Speaker 7 We did what we had to do as the circumstances came about and as the evidence presented itself up to and including continuing to investigate and exonerating Michelle.

Speaker 5 In October 2017, Angela pleaded guilty to to felony charges, including kidnapping, false imprisonment, perjury, and forgery. She was sentenced to five years.
Ms. Diaz does need

Speaker 5 not only punishment, but does need help. She appears to be, in the court's view, devoid of any sense of empathy or compassion to others,

Speaker 5 or any kind of realization as to the impact. that one's actions have on another person's life.
And one other thing Angela lost besides her freedom was her husband. Ian had their marriage annulled.

Speaker 5 Allison Mark Golan, Angela's defense attorney, believed Ian deserved a closer look.

Speaker 4 The failure to investigate adequately the role of Ian Diaz in it is a serious concern.

Speaker 5 We reached out to Ian hoping to speak to him, but got no response. Turns out, federal prosecutors also had questions.

Speaker 5 After investigating his role in the scheme, they charged Ian Diaz with conspiracy to commit cyberstalking, cyberstalking, and perjury. In March 2023, the now former U.S.

Speaker 5 Marshal was convicted on all counts and sentenced to 10 years and one month. He's filed an appeal.

Speaker 5 When we last sat down with Michelle, her personal struggle was far from over.

Speaker 5 A struggle to rekindle the spirit of an innocent young woman whose life was changed forever by something, well, something diabolical.

Speaker 4 I don't think there's anything more evil than finding a girl who believes in the best in humanity and who loves other people deeply and making her question

Speaker 4 who she is, making her question her faith in humanity.

Speaker 8 That's all for now.

Speaker 9 I'm Lester Holt.

Speaker 7 Thanks for joining us.

Speaker 12 Hey, weirdos, I'm Elena.

Speaker 11 And I'm Ash, and we are the host of Morbid Podcast.

Speaker 6 Each week, we dive into the dark and fascinating world of true crime, spooky history, and the unexplained.

Speaker 11 From infamous killers and unsolved mysteries to haunted places and strange legends, we cover it all with research, empathy, humor, and a few creative expletives.

Speaker 12 It's smart, it's spooky, and it's just the right amount of weird.

Speaker 11 Two new episodes drop every week, and there's even a bonus once a month.

Speaker 6 Find us wherever you listen to podcasts.

Speaker 3 Yay! Woo!