Murdaugh on Trial: The Prosecution Rests

Speaker 1 Struggling to see up close? Make it visible with Viz. Viz is a once-daily prescription eye drop to treat blurry near vision for up to 10 hours.

Speaker 1 The most common side effects that may be experienced while using Viz include eye irritation, temporary dim or dark vision, headaches, and eye redness.

Speaker 1 Talk to an eye doctor to learn if Viz is right for you. Learn more at Viz.com.

Speaker 3 From the Creator of Homeland, Claire Danes and Matthew Rees star in the new Netflix series The Beast in Me as ruthless rivals whose shared darkness will set them on a collision course with fatal consequences.

Speaker 3 The Beast in Me is a riveting psychological cat and mouse story about guilt and justice and doubt, now playing only on Netflix.

Speaker 4 Are we recording?

Speaker 4 Okay, before we get started, Craig, you come on these podcasts with me with your really smooth Anchorman voice. I just want to remind you what the famous philosopher Loretta Lynn said.

Speaker 4 Where I'm from, this is not an accent.

Speaker 5 You should have saved it for the podcast.

Speaker 4 I just said it. They're recording.

Speaker 5 All right. Are we ready to start? All right, here we go.

Speaker 5 It was a pitch black night back in June of 2021 when Maggie and Paul Murdoch were found shot to death on their family's sprawling country property.

Speaker 5 That tragedy and the events that followed brought national, even international attention to tiny Hampton, South Carolina, as the life of Alec Murdoch, a third-generation member of a powerful legal dynasty, unraveled spectacularly.

Speaker 5 It's just so bad.

Speaker 6 They did it so bad.

Speaker 5 I'm Craig Melvin, NBC anchor and dateline correspondent, and this is Murdoch on trial. The prosecution rests.

Speaker 7 A perfect storm that was gathering that all came to a head on June 7th, 2021, the day the evidence will show he killed Maggie and Paul.

Speaker 5 As the trial plays out, we are going to be with you every step of the way with inside information and analysis on one of the biggest and most dramatic trials in South Carolina's low country in decades.

Speaker 5 In this episode, we'll go inside the prosecution's case.

Speaker 5 The state arrested after more than three weeks of testimony, dozens of witnesses, and Dateline producer Carol Gable has been in that courtroom in Walterboro, South Carolina from the very start.

Speaker 5 We sat down to talk about the highlights of the case so far and

Speaker 5 what's next.

Speaker 5 Hey there, my friend.

Speaker 2 How are we, Carol Gable?

Speaker 4 Well, I'm good, but I am in a massive deficit on doing doing any kind of exercise because we've been sitting on what is essentially a church pew for a month.

Speaker 5 Well, we appreciate your sacrifice, though.

Speaker 5 You could go a few weeks with that exercise and you'll be fine.

Speaker 5 We should remind folks who are listening, Alec Murdoch, who has pleaded not guilty to the murders of his wife and son.

Speaker 5 He has sat through weeks of testimony, ranging from first responders to detectives, former colleagues, his friends, family, even

Speaker 2 hired help.

Speaker 5 And you've been there as well. Describe for me, Carol, before we dig into some of the witnesses and evidence, describe for me what it's been like in that courtroom day in, day out.

Speaker 4 Well, I have to say, if you ask Hollywood to create the quintessential, charming, small southern town, it would be Walterboro. It's beautiful.
There are palmetto trees, the state tree.

Speaker 4 The courthouse was designed by the famed architect Robert Mills, who designed the Washington Monument.

Speaker 4 Ringed around that courthouse are reporters from around the United States who are doing live shots all through the day

Speaker 4 and covering this trial. There are very few spectator seats and people are standing in line to get those seats as early as 5.30 in the morning.

Speaker 4 I talked to someone today who's been there 10 times and they're in rapt attention. They've come on vacation.
It is really an amazing scene.

Speaker 5 What about the family and friends who are seated, who have occasionally, I've noticed, been seated behind Alec Murdoch? Are they there every day? Who have you seen come and go?

Speaker 4 The Murdoch family is there every single day. Many times, it's both his brothers, nieces,

Speaker 4 his sisters, brother-in-law, and of course, Buster has been there, I think, every single day.

Speaker 4 And they have been,

Speaker 4 you know, they've been very cordial and polite. People go up and speak to them.

Speaker 5 I mean, your heart really has to

Speaker 5 go out to Buster. Here's a young man who loses his mother and his only brother.

Speaker 5 And his father is accused of killing them. And every day he's in court listening to at times grisly details about how they were killed, why they were killed.

Speaker 5 I just, I can't begin to fathom what must be going through that poor young man's mind.

Speaker 4 People watch him. I watch him for his reaction.
And he's been very stoic. You know, there have been tears on that family row often.

Speaker 4 And Alex has cried. I mean,

Speaker 4 he's sobbed during points of the trial.

Speaker 5 What do you think was the testimony or evidence that elicited the most emotion from either Alec or Buster or the family?

Speaker 4 I think the family for sure was that pathologist.

Speaker 4 She basically said Paul's brain was blown off. I mean, it was just gruesome.

Speaker 4 And Maggie was also

Speaker 4 killed in

Speaker 4 especially one of the final two fatal shots in essentially an assassination sort of way. It's just really gruesome.

Speaker 5 And to have to sit there and listen to those details.

Speaker 5 Yeah, I can't even begin to fathom it.

Speaker 5 What about the defendant, Carol?

Speaker 5 What have you noticed about Alec Murdoch so far during the course of this trial?

Speaker 4 Well, he comes in every day and he usually has the lawyer sort of

Speaker 4 file folder under his arm with all the papers and he's dressed you know perhaps like he would if he was going into a courtroom to try a case

Speaker 4 so and he's of course between his two lawyers he's represented by someone you know well de Carputlian state senator former prosecutor former head of the South Carolina Democratic Party and now a very successful private attorney.

Speaker 4 His other co-counsel is is an experienced and well-regarded trial attorney that I have to add is from my hometown, Anderson, South Carolina.

Speaker 5 Of course.

Speaker 4 And then the prosecution team is led by Creighton Waters. He's a 24-year veteran of the Attorney General's office.
Actually, it's a team of seven lawyers from the AG's office.

Speaker 4 And in fact, Alan Wilson, the AG himself, has been there virtually every day, which, as you know, with the caseload

Speaker 4 he oversees, it's quite rare that he would do that. But he's at the table directing what's going on.

Speaker 5 You know, one of the knocks that I have heard and read from legal analysts from the beginning of the

Speaker 5 state's case is that

Speaker 5 the state was presenting evidence and information in a somewhat disjointed way. and at times boring and at times the minutia

Speaker 5 seemed to to be, you know, just sort of mind-numbing, if you will. And they really, one of the criticisms was that the state really hadn't done a great job of connecting the dots.

Speaker 5 And then all of a sudden, with their very last witness, this special agent from SLED, the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division, Peter Radofsky, he gives us

Speaker 5 this timeline. And not just a timeline, but at one point, there's a color-coded timeline of Alex's car movements.
There's digital digital phone evidence, text messages, GPS info.

Speaker 5 And I felt like at times we were essentially watching and listening to

Speaker 5 this countdown to murder.

Speaker 7 Do both Maggie's and Paul's phone lock forever around 8.49? They do.

Speaker 5 And it, you know, from where I was watching, your vantage point was different, Carol, but it seemed like the state at the end of the presentation of their case did a pretty solid job of laying out the timeline.

Speaker 4 I think you're exactly right. When we came into the trial, there was a very tight timeline that had been fairly well established during which this crime could have happened.

Speaker 4 Alex said for a long time that his day went like this, that he went to the office. He got up, he left the office in the 5, 530 range.

Speaker 4 He meets Paul at Moselle, which is how they refer to their their country property where Paul and Maggie were murdered. They ride around and he says they rode around in a couple of vehicles.

Speaker 4 They looked at trees, planting, sunflowers. Maggie arrives.
They have dinner that housekeeper Blanca had left for them on the stove.

Speaker 4 After he eats, he says he got on the sofa and napped, which is a routine of his.

Speaker 4 Then he gets up in the nine range. He texts Maggie saying, hey, I'm going to go to mom's.

Speaker 4 He leaves at 9.06,

Speaker 4 gets to his mother's house,

Speaker 4 sits on the bed with her, holds her hand, watches a game show,

Speaker 4 and then stays about 20 minutes and then leaves and gets back to Moselle. And then we know the 9-1-1 call occurred at 10.06.

Speaker 4 When in fact, Maggie and Paul, and now we know Alec, went down to the kennels where Paul was taking care of a friend's dog.

Speaker 4 And the dog had a tail problem, which I personally, it looked like a mangy tail to me. And so he was trying to take a video of the problem for his friend.

Speaker 4 And

Speaker 4 what do we hear in the background? We hear Paul, Alec, and Maggie.

Speaker 4 Nobody is seen on the video just the dog, but several witnesses testified you hear all three of them. On the stand, they said that's Alex calling to the dog.
Come here, Bubba.

Speaker 4 So if he is down at the kennels at 8.44,

Speaker 4 he can't be napping.

Speaker 5 Murdoch had maintained repeatedly that he had never been down to those dog kennels. And then you have Creighton Waters who

Speaker 5 on a number of occasions over the last few weeks had witness after witness identify his voice on the video.

Speaker 7 And what voices did you hear?

Speaker 4 Paul's, Miss Maggie, Mr. Elliot.

Speaker 7 Whose voices did you recognize on that video?

Speaker 7 Paul Murdoch, Maggie Murdoch, and Alex Murdahl. Whose voices did you hear? Paul Murdoch, Maggie Murdoch, and Elliot Murdoch.

Speaker 7 Could you tell where they were located in that video? Did you get a sense of where that was? Dunkin's.

Speaker 5 So it's going to be interesting to see how the defense explains

Speaker 5 that he lied.

Speaker 5 And not only did he lie,

Speaker 5 it's kind of one of those lies where now

Speaker 5 it's glaringly obvious that he was lying because you had at least five or six people say, oh, that's Alex's voice. No, no, that's his voice.
No question.

Speaker 4 Once that dogtail video came out, I mean, the defense's timeline is just blown up. I mean, he lied to Sled three times on a videotaped interview.
So it's not someone's interpretation. It's Alex saying

Speaker 4 that three times, at least three times.

Speaker 7 Did the defendant repeatedly deny ever being at the Kennels at that time period? Yes, he did.

Speaker 7 Various interviews with law enforcement. What time was that here on video? 8.44.
And what time do Paul and Nagy's phones go silent forever? 8.49 is when their phones went silent forever.

Speaker 5 It's difficult to

Speaker 5 overstate how vital I think the timeline is ultimately going to be for jurors who are

Speaker 5 deciding this case.

Speaker 4 I think so, because I think jurors are very sensitive to people that have big inconsistencies in his story.

Speaker 3 Looking to crack the code on your career? Well, maybe it's time to get your degree.

Speaker 3 Southern New Hampshire University offers over 200 programs you can complete online. No set class times means you can do it all on your schedule.

Speaker 3 And with some of the lowest online tuition rates in the U.S., they make getting your degree affordable, too.

Speaker 3 Get started at snhu.edu/slash dateline.

Speaker 2 That's snhu.edu slash dateline. Most holiday gifts end up in a drawer or the back of your closet or accidentally left at your cousin's house.
Not this one.

Speaker 2 Mint Mobile is offering unlimited premium wireless for $15 a month. That's their best deal of the year, aka a holiday gift you'll actually use every single day.
Don't get them socks.

Speaker 2 Get them premium wireless for $15 a month. Shop Mint Unlimited plans at mintmobile.com slash dateline.
That's mintmobile.com slash dateline. Limited time offer.

Speaker 2 Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for 6 months, or $180 for 12 months. Plan required, $15 per month equivalent.

Speaker 5 Taxes and fees extra.

Speaker 2 Initial plan term only.

Speaker 2 Greater than 35 gigabytes may slow when the network is busy. Capable device required.
Availability, speed, and coverage vary. See Mintmobile.com.

Speaker 8 If you're a maintenance supervisor at a manufacturing facility and your machinery isn't working right, Granger knows you need to understand what's wrong as soon as possible.

Speaker 8 So when a conveyor motor falters, Grainger offers diagnostic tools like calibration kits and multimeters to help you identify and fix the problem.

Speaker 8 With Granger, you can be confident you have everything you need to keep your facility running smoothly. Call 1-800-GRANGER, clickgranger.com or just stop by.

Speaker 1 Grainger for the ones who get it done.

Speaker 5 Let's talk about

Speaker 5 some of the witnesses, Carol, that you've seen and heard from. Let's start with Maggie's sister.

Speaker 5 How effective was her testimony?

Speaker 4 Oh my gosh, I don't think you can underestimate the effectiveness.

Speaker 4 She came in and it was a little disarming because she looks like Maggie, as you might expect, and very quiet and calm and was quite complimentary of the relationship with

Speaker 4 Maggie and Alec and how they vacationed together. And, you know, everything

Speaker 4 was

Speaker 4 good and

Speaker 4 just a heartbreaking account of learning that her sister had been murdered. And then after all of these comments about how it unfolded, then she says, but all that changed in September.

Speaker 4 And everyone knew what that meant.

Speaker 4 That

Speaker 4 the Emperor suddenly had no clothes. This giant financial problem is collapsing.

Speaker 4 At that point, information started coming out about some things that Alec had done financially

Speaker 4 that we had

Speaker 4 no

Speaker 4 idea about.

Speaker 5 I also found it interesting, you know, when she talked about Alex's

Speaker 5 demeanor and the conversations that they had shortly after the murders, and that he, according to her, seemed to be more interested in

Speaker 5 still clearing Paul's name with regard to the boat accident, clearing his name. more interested in that than finding out who had just killed his wife and son.

Speaker 5 Exactly. And she had pointed that out.
That wasn't something that I'd really known before her testimony.

Speaker 4 Exactly.

Speaker 4 That was new. So you're right.
That was very arresting.

Speaker 5 What about the testimony that we heard from

Speaker 5 Alec Murdoch's mother's caretaker?

Speaker 5 What did you make of what we heard from her?

Speaker 4 Well,

Speaker 4 she clearly didn't want to be there, didn't want to testify. She was very emotional.

Speaker 4 She said that Alec usually did not come that time of the day to visit his mother.

Speaker 4 But then, you know, he's there 20 minutes and she says that later, a few days later, he comes to her and says, remember, I was here for 40 minutes. Remember?

Speaker 4 He didn't overtly tell her to lie, but it does seem that he's definitely trying to lay down a timeline of what he did that night.

Speaker 5 You know, Carol, one of the things that I think was probably striking for a lot of folks is here you have this family that, you know, I mean, they've got a lot of help. I mean,

Speaker 5 there's a housekeeper.

Speaker 5 There's a guy that just looks after the dogs. There's the caretaker for mom.

Speaker 5 They've got a lot of folks around them that

Speaker 5 the Murdochs have been paying to help them for years.

Speaker 5 I find it it striking that I'm sure

Speaker 5 that there was an assumption made

Speaker 5 that they would just do what they were told. You know, but

Speaker 5 that's one of those things that I have found a bit strange because I'm sure, again,

Speaker 5 generational wealth, generational power, and ultimately the people who have been propping them up. If he's convicted, these are going to be some of the same folks who helped do him in.

Speaker 4 Well, certainly, I think, especially with the caregiver for Miss Libby, I mean she was obviously tortured,

Speaker 4 had a very tortured demeanor on having to admit or

Speaker 4 say it's true

Speaker 4 that he said, remember, I was here 40 minutes. It was very hard.
And of course, they are the employer. And

Speaker 4 do you fear for your job?

Speaker 5 I did think it was noteworthy to point out Judge Newman's handling of the case so far.

Speaker 5 It is, you know, this is a closely watched case, and this is a judge who, for folks who might not know, longtime judge,

Speaker 5 but also a judge who lost his son.

Speaker 5 His son, who's just a few years younger than me, also an attorney.

Speaker 5 His name is Brian Newman, Judge Newman's son. He drops dead

Speaker 5 of a cardiac event less than two weeks before this trial was set to start. And instead of delaying the trial, Judge Newman insisted that the trial go on.

Speaker 5 And from my vantage point, Carol, looking at it objectively, it seems as if the judge has just really had sort of a masterful control of that courtroom.

Speaker 5 And under the circumstances, I think that's something that should be applauded.

Speaker 4 Well, exactly. And he is, his voice is very melodic.
In fact, I'm thinking he has a career reading reading bedtime stories for audiobooks because his voice is so calm. And

Speaker 4 he never gets excited. He never raises his voice.
It's very calm. He's been very

Speaker 4 even,

Speaker 4 steady, constant through the whole trial.

Speaker 5 One of the more significant decisions by Judge Newman in the case, Carol, was this

Speaker 5 decision to allow the financial crimes and evidence related to the financial crimes to allow that to be introduced in this case? Ultimately, I guess we'll know how significant that was. But

Speaker 5 in that moment when you were in court, how much of a surprise was that?

Speaker 4 Well, we all knew it was coming, and we knew that the state wanted it in, and of course the defense did not.

Speaker 4 The judge was very specific when he made his ruling that he was letting it in not to talk about Alex's character, but for the weight it might carry in people's minds toward motive.

Speaker 4 Now, I don't know how you don't take away something from character if you hear about that, but that's what the judge said. And there are people that think that might be an appealable issue.

Speaker 5 You know, you and I talked

Speaker 5 during our last podcast about motive.

Speaker 5 And it it it it seems as if so far um that this the state's

Speaker 5 thesis if you will is basically alec murdoch killed his wife and son to

Speaker 5 distract or to buy some time

Speaker 2 um

Speaker 5 and and you know i it i'm sure on when the when the defense presents its case, it'll do its best to shred that thesis. But based on what you've seen and what you've heard in that courtroom,

Speaker 5 the motive itself,

Speaker 5 is that something that seems to be resonating with jurors?

Speaker 5 Or do you get the sense that there was so much financial crimes, evidence introduced that it's going to be difficult for jurors to decipher or even buy into that idea, period?

Speaker 4 I think it's clear that he had no internal stop button to steal from his own law firm,

Speaker 4 from his own own best friend, from his clients. I don't think there's question about that.

Speaker 5 It did seem as if, if you were watching and listening to the evidence presented, that testimony especially,

Speaker 5 that folks around him were starting to catch on.

Speaker 4 Yes.

Speaker 7 Thank you, Your Honor. May it please the court.

Speaker 8 The statement called Jeannie Secinger.

Speaker 4 Especially that

Speaker 4 CFO in that firm.

Speaker 2 Oh, yeah.

Speaker 7 When you receive this check,

Speaker 7 what, if anything, is your realization?

Speaker 4 That he stole the money, that he'd been lying.

Speaker 2 She, oh, she was

Speaker 4 a tiger with a tail. She was on him

Speaker 4 just saying, Where's the money? Where's this money? Where's this money? And you could tell she

Speaker 4 took it personally that there was money missing and that the firm had to pay back to clients millions of dollars.

Speaker 7 State calls Mark Tinsley.

Speaker 4 So Mark Tinsley is the lawyer who represents the family of Mallory Beach,

Speaker 4 a young woman who was killed back in 2019 when the boat she was in, allegedly driven by Paul Murdoch, crashed into a bridge piling. Tinsley is suing the Murdoch family because of that crash.

Speaker 7 And that meant you were seeking a personal recovery against him. He was always going to have to pay and pay a lot of money.

Speaker 5 Carol, what did we hear from Mark Tinsley on the stand about

Speaker 5 motive and what happened to his case, what he thought was going to happen to his case in the wake of the double murder?

Speaker 4 Well, he did two things. Number one, he outlined a potential reason.

Speaker 4 He called it the fuse was lit, because he was coming after Alec.

Speaker 4 personally for his personal money because he didn't have great insurance that would have applied to the boat case.

Speaker 4 So Mark Tinsley was coming after a lot of money and they had a little run-in at a lawyer meeting where basically Alec says, bro, I think we're friends. We were friends.
What is this?

Speaker 4 I hear about that. And Mark says, I'm coming after you.
And I'm coming after you personally for that money. So he says that.

Speaker 4 So we know that that's a pressure point for Alec, according to Mark Tinsley but Tinsley also testified that after the murders happened he felt his client's case against Alec was over because no one would want to find against Murdaugh in the boat accident after he lost his wife and son Did that have any effect that tragedy of their deaths did that have any effect on your assessment of the boat case and how everything fit together if things were how they initially appeared?

Speaker 7 It would have affected, I mean, yes, it did, and it would have ended the case. Why? What had changed after this terrible tragedy?

Speaker 6 Well,

Speaker 7 nice people get good verdicts. If Elek is the victim of a vigilante, nobody's going to hold him accountable.
It doesn't make any difference what he did or how clearly what he did contributed.

Speaker 7 The case would be over against Elek.

Speaker 5 It was also interesting to hear, and we'd spent some time during one of our dateline episodes devoted to this topic talking to some of the victims of

Speaker 5 Alec's financial schemes, crimes.

Speaker 5 So, Gloria Satterfield,

Speaker 5 for folks who may have forgotten how she fits into the story, she was

Speaker 5 so much more than just the housekeeper. I mean, she essentially helped rear Buster and Paul.

Speaker 5 And,

Speaker 5 you know,

Speaker 5 one day at the house she she she falls down trips over some of some dogs on the porch and and um takes a nasty tumble ends up in the hospital for a few days and she ends up dying and

Speaker 5 the family discovers sometime later that the settlement money from that fall has

Speaker 5 allegedly been stolen by Alec Murdoch.

Speaker 5 I found it curious that that was

Speaker 5 of the witnesses that could have testified to some of the financial wrongdoings

Speaker 5 they focused in on Gloria Satterfield. I would assume, Carol, because she was so close to that family.

Speaker 4 The son that testified, and you and I met him early, he's really come a long way. He's matured during this awful, awful process.
And I thought he was very articulate about the loss they suffered.

Speaker 7 And you recall recall what Elliot would tell you about the case? Yes. At first, it started off as it was going to be a hard case, and then it turned into we're making progress.

Speaker 7 Did he ever tell you that I've been a recovery for $3.8 million against that? No.

Speaker 7 Did he ever pay you one penny of $3.8 million?

Speaker 7 No.

Speaker 4 Put a face on the financial crimes. You know, you can say it.
You can say he stole millions. But when you see the faces of those victims and you hear their voices and you realize, you know,

Speaker 4 they're just salt of the earth people, and yet, in Alex's mind, it was okay to rip them off.

Speaker 5 Yeah, you've got to wonder if the prosecution's motive there was essentially to say to the jury, if a man would do something like this to someone who is practically part of his family,

Speaker 5 what else would he be capable of?

Speaker 4 Exactly. Yeah, I don't think calling them was an accident or not well thought out.

Speaker 5 But as we wrap this thing up, my friend,

Speaker 5 the defense is

Speaker 5 going to get started. There are reports that among their first witnesses

Speaker 5 is going to be Buster.

Speaker 4 Buster is definitely on the witness list.

Speaker 4 So we'll hear from him. And there's been a lot of talk about Buster.

Speaker 5 Of course, of course. It seems as if the defense is poised to essentially say to the jury, our guy is a liar.

Speaker 5 Our guy is a thief.

Speaker 5 But our guy would not kill his wife and son.

Speaker 5 That best I can gather so far, based on what I've heard from the cross-examination of the witnesses so far, that seems like that might be the central theme to their defense.

Speaker 4 I think it's totally their theme. And I think the hanging question is,

Speaker 4 how was

Speaker 4 Alec Murdoch's life better with his wife and son dead

Speaker 4 when he was in the position we know he was in?

Speaker 4 And I don't know that anybody has drawn a straight line to that. Because you've got to get an advantage if you're willing to do that.
And what was it for him?

Speaker 5 I'm Craig Melvin. Thank you so much for listening to this episode of Murdoch on Trial.
I hope you'll join us next time after the defense rests.

Speaker 5 Murdoch on Trial is produced by Michael Narty with Haley Barber and Jared Crawford and edited by Jaclyn Speyer. Alex Loray is the associate producer and Paul Ryan is the senior producer.

Speaker 2 This time of year, many are checking off their holiday gift lists. But identity thieves have lists too, and your personal information might be on them.
Protect your identity with LifeLock.

Speaker 2 LifeLock monitors millions of data points every second and alerts you to threats you could miss. If your identity is stolen, LifeLock will fix it guaranteed or your money back.

Speaker 2 Save up to 40% your first year at lifelock.com slash dateline. Terms apply.