Pressed For Crime

Speaker 1 Get the gang together to enjoy fall flavors with savings from Whole Foods Market. The Cheers to Fall event is on now.

Speaker 1 Enjoy sales up to 25% off with Prime on comforting no antibiotics ever proteins your guests will love. Even better, score 50% off select frozen pizzas for game day with Prime.
That's right, 50% off.

Speaker 1 And remember to grab their tempting figgy-foggy chantali cake for a limited time. Celebrate fall with ease at Whole Foods Market.
Terms apply.

Speaker 2 A message from McAfee.

Speaker 2 Wondering why the post office is texting you or why you owe thousands of dollars in toll fees? Because someone's trying to scam you. The good news, McAfee can help.

Speaker 2 With McAfee's award-winning scam detection, it's easy to tell what's real and what's fake over text, in your inbox, and online.

Speaker 3 If they're fake, you want a free gift.

Speaker 2 Seriously? If they're faking it, they're not making it past us. Get award-winning scam detection today.
McAfee.com/slash keep it real.

Speaker 4 A brutal murder.

Speaker 6 Lots of suspects and conflicting evidence. But the forensics were clear on one thing: the killer knew his victim.

Speaker 9 And that alone gave investigators a head start.

Speaker 10 For many young women, the allure of the stage, theater, and the arts is difficult to ignore.

Speaker 5 19-year-old Heather Stigliano thought she might have what it takes to succeed.

Speaker 2 She liked to pose and model and be on stage, and she had a beautiful voice.

Speaker 11 After high school, Heather planned to pursue her dreams, but put them on hold for a year as a favor to her mother.

Speaker 12 I had just gone through a divorce, and she promised to stay with me for a year until I got my legs. And when that year was up, she made her plans and she moved.

Speaker 7 Her destination was Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, where she had some friends.

Speaker 14 She wanted to be in the entertainment industry. I knew she loved singing and I think that's one of the reasons why she moved down to the Myrtle Beach area because this area has a lot of entertainment.

Speaker 16 Heather rented a small apartment in this house near the beach and took a job as a waitress.

Speaker 5 But Heather found it difficult to get work as a singer, and she told her mother she was discouraged.

Speaker 12 She wanted me to come down. She was feeling homesick, and

Speaker 12 things were not going as well as she wanted it to go down there.

Speaker 17 It would be the last time Susan heard her daughter's voice.

Speaker 22 A week later, friends found Heather's body in her apartment.

Speaker 9 She had been beaten, stabbed, and strangled to death with an electrical cord.

Speaker 23 The crime was one of the most brutal crimes that I've seen as a prosecutor.

Speaker 22 Next to Heather's body, investigators found broken pieces of plastic.

Speaker 25 Small, black plastic pieces, particles found some on her body, some scattered around the room and laying next to her body, which we could not identify.

Speaker 15 There were no signs of forced entry, but the motive appeared to be robbery.

Speaker 11 Heather's wallet, her 35 millimeter camera, television set, and automobile were missing.

Speaker 23 We didn't understand at that time how he got in the house or anything else. So yeah, we were very concerned about it and we wanted to try to find him or her before

Speaker 23 another crime could take place.

Speaker 7 Police issued a be on the lookout call for Heather's car, a 10-year-old Chevrolet Monza with Pennsylvania license plates.

Speaker 25 We have a system called NCIC, National Crime Information Center.

Speaker 25 And we can enter stolen vehicles, stolen items, articles, pretty much anything, and it will go out nationwide.

Speaker 11 At the autopsy, the medical examiner photographed and then measured the wounds on Heather's body.

Speaker 28 There were 40 wounds in all.

Speaker 26 I will do diagrams, photographs, and acetate tracings. Lay a sheet of acetate over the body.
trace the injuries onto the acetate. Those are then kept as evidence.

Speaker 18 From the amount of decomposition, Dr.

Speaker 9 Downs estimated Heather had been dead for about a week.

Speaker 29 There were several stab wounds that were inflicted to her body after she died.

Speaker 26 There were some injuries that

Speaker 26 probably happened during the final few moments.

Speaker 24 It was obvious that there were at least three different

Speaker 24 methods of murder there because she had a wire that was around her neck.

Speaker 28 The medical examiner also found a bloody shoe impression on Heather's shirt and what looked like knife wounds on her neck.

Speaker 5 Both were indications the killer tried to subdue her.

Speaker 22 A rape test kit found no biological evidence of sexual assault.

Speaker 26 One of the things that you try to do as a forensic pathologist is to try to tell the story as best you can of what happened to an individual.

Speaker 26 In a case like this, where there is a savage attack on a young girl,

Speaker 26 you really want to try to answer those questions.

Speaker 18 In the search for the killer, investigators found a significant clue at the crime scene.

Speaker 16 The killer put a pillow under Heather's head, but there was no blood on the pillow.

Speaker 25 It looked to me like it had been placed there,

Speaker 27 not a part of the scene.

Speaker 5 And it looked as if the killer knew her.

Speaker 18 At the crime scene, investigators found several clues to the identity of Heather Stigliano's killer.

Speaker 5 The evidence showed the killer tried to clean up her apartment afterwards.

Speaker 24 There was several places there was blood found, but it was obvious that somebody had tried to wipe up a lot of the blood, a lot of smears and stuff like that.

Speaker 9 Analysts applied a chemical called Amido Black to the bathroom and kitchen floor.

Speaker 8 It was determined that this chemical would react to the dried blood left at the crime scene.

Speaker 8 Evidence such as footwear impressions, those that were partially visible, and some that you couldn't see at all.

Speaker 17 Seconds after it was applied, multiple shoe impressions appeared

Speaker 18 from a size size 11 athletic shoe.

Speaker 16 It was the same shoe impression found on Heather's shirt.

Speaker 8 You know it belongs to the bad guy.

Speaker 8 When you get evidence like that, it's been a good day. So you feel good inside.

Speaker 5 In a search for suspects, Investigators spoke with Heather's friends, co-workers, and acquaintances, and there were quite a few.

Speaker 14 She was very friendly. She'd loved to be with her friends.
She wanted to to be part of anything that had energy.

Speaker 5 Police discovered that Heather had an ex-boyfriend, Jack Norton, who was a pilot stationed at nearby Pope Air Force Base.

Speaker 25 Heather was having some problems and wanted to get back up with him.

Speaker 25 We didn't know if they had gotten back up and some domestic situation going on, argument, struggle, or something like that might have happened.

Speaker 9 Investigators asked military officials where Norton was stationed on the week of Heather's murder.

Speaker 24 Found out that he wasn't around during the time that she would have died.

Speaker 9 Norton had been in Saudi Arabia that week and was eliminated as a suspect.

Speaker 5 Next, Heather's family told investigators that she had had a problem with a man at a Halloween party several days before her murder.

Speaker 5 She claimed that an Air Force captain named Robert Dolan had sexually assaulted her at the party.

Speaker 12 Well, she had drank a little bit more than she should have. She did tell me that she thought that she had been raped by one of the

Speaker 12 husbands of one of the guests there

Speaker 12 while she was passed out.

Speaker 24 Well, I think he had around 17 years in the Air Force and I think three kids. And that would be a motive.
This was going to ruin his career. There was no doubt about it.

Speaker 30 Captain Dolan's wife, Carol, also became a suspect.

Speaker 24 We felt that Carol had gotten word that Heather was going to the police about this, about being sexually assaulted by her husband.

Speaker 24 And of course, that just gave us more reason to suspect Carol of either committing this homicide or her letting her husband Robert know and him committing this homicide or them together.

Speaker 9 Heather never did report this incident to police.

Speaker 5 When questioned, Captain Dolan and his wife cooperated fully with the investigation and provided their fingerprints for analysis.

Speaker 8 I compared the non-ink prints to the latent prints taken from the crime scene, and none of the ink standards were identified to the latent prints of the crime scene.

Speaker 25 We couldn't say he didn't do it, but there was nothing indicating he did do it.

Speaker 5 Then, investigators identified a fourth suspect.

Speaker 9 Chris Harkins was Heather's friend, who stayed in her apartment when he was in Myrtle Beach on business.

Speaker 24 After interviewing Chris, it was found that they were just friends, that there was no sexual contact or anything like that between them.

Speaker 16 And Harkins had an alibi.

Speaker 5 He was in Lexington, South Carolina, 160 miles away the week of Heather's murder.

Speaker 9 Then investigators got an unexpected call from an antique dealer 26 miles away in Pauley's Island, South Carolina.

Speaker 9 He and his wife read about Heather's murder in the newspaper and had some information they thought might help.

Speaker 25 They told us of a gentleman who had come down there. He looked like he had been in some type of a scrap or a fight, and he was trying to sell a camera.

Speaker 11 The camera was the same make and model as the one missing from Heather's apartment.

Speaker 24 Just real suspicious acting to them the whole time. He even got a little aggravated when they said they didn't want it.
He told them he just wanted some money. And he had a look that scared them.

Speaker 5 He described the man as white, mid-30s, with dark hair.

Speaker 22 And he had the presence of mind to write down his license plate number on his coffee cup.

Speaker 25 It was registered to Heather Stigliano, who is our victim.

Speaker 35 I know every operating system I come back in my candid role.

Speaker 36 I'm going to come out of the city of experience and have worked with several people from your company.

Speaker 3 I've been recognized for my passion.

Speaker 36 My team is everything.

Speaker 37 LinkedIn delivers candidates who rise above the rest with an up-to-date view into shared connections, skills, and interests you won't find anywhere else.

Speaker 37 See why 86% of small businesses who post a job on LinkedIn get a qualified candidate within a day. Post a job for free at linkedin.com/slash achieve.
LinkedIn, your next great hire is here.

Speaker 35 New Icy Hot.

Speaker 38 Nighttime Recovery relieves pain at nighttime while your body recovers.

Speaker 1 Icy Hot, you're so back.

Speaker 35 Running a business comes with a lot of what-ifs, but luckily, there's a simple answer to them.

Speaker 27 Shopify.

Speaker 35 It's the commerce platform behind millions of businesses, including Thrive Cosmetics and Momofuku, and it'll help you with everything you need.

Speaker 35 From website design and marketing to boosting sales and expanding operations, Shopify can get the job done and make your dream a reality. Turn those what-ifs into

Speaker 35 sign up for your one dollar per month trial at shopify.com/slash special offer.

Speaker 36 This Marshawn Beast Mode Lynch. Prize Pick is making sports season even more fun.
On prize picks, whether you're a football fan, a basketball fan, it always feels good to be right.

Speaker 36 Right now, new users get $50 instantly in lineups when you play your first $5.

Speaker 36 The app is simple to use. Pick two or more players, pick more or less on their stat projections.
Anything from touchdown to threes, and if you're right, you can win big.

Speaker 36 Mix and match players from any sport on PrizePicks, America's number one daily fantasy sports app. PrizePicks is available in 40 plus states, including California, Texas, Florida, and Georgia.

Speaker 36 Most importantly, all the transactions on the app are fast, safe, and secure.

Speaker 39 Download the Prize Pix app today and use code Spotify to get $50 in lineups after you play your first $5 lineup. That's code Spotify to get $50 in lineups after you play your first $5 lineup.

Speaker 39 Prize Picks, it's good to be right. right.
Must be present in certain states. Visit prizepicks.com for restrictions and details.

Speaker 5 An antique dealer gave police a detailed description of the man driving Heather Stigliano's car.

Speaker 5 From that description, a police artist created this composite sketch, which was distributed to news outlets throughout the country.

Speaker 6 As a result, employees of a local construction company in in Myrtle Beach told police that they recognized him.

Speaker 24 They said, well, we had a subject named James Whipple that worked here, but all of a sudden was just gone, never called in, never give us a notice.

Speaker 24 He's been gone for about a week now, which was kind of connecting some of the timeline.

Speaker 5 James Whipple was 38 years old and had a police record in four different states.

Speaker 25 He had several burglaries, grand larcenies, unauthorized use of vehicle, petty larcenies, even a DUI or two with

Speaker 25 resistant arrest.

Speaker 4 Six days later, police found Whipple in Melbourne, Florida, driving Heather Stigliano's car.

Speaker 25 I was on top of the world. In one day, we came up with two bits of

Speaker 25 information,

Speaker 27 a suspect in a car.

Speaker 13 But what connection, if any, did Whipple have to Heather Stigliano?

Speaker 9 Investigators learned that Whipple knew Heather's friend, Chris Harkins, because they had worked together in the past.

Speaker 24 But that was the only connection that Whipple had had with Heather at the time.

Speaker 24 They

Speaker 24 had briefly met right then, and he left with Chris. There was no other connection between Heather and Whipple.

Speaker 5 Inside Heather's car was a virtual treasure trove of evidence.

Speaker 8 Found a lot more than I expected to find.

Speaker 8 Went through a methodical process of working from the outside in on the vehicle.

Speaker 9 Under the front seat, investigators found a bent serrated knife, a broken clothes iron, a pair of men's athletic shoes, and bloody clothing.

Speaker 5 They sent the knife to forensic pathologist Dr.

Speaker 18 Jamie Downs.

Speaker 29 With the serrated knife, I looked at the separation of the tines of the serrated knife, the little points stuck out, and noted that those were at repeated intervals, very consistent repeated intervals.

Speaker 22 Dr. Downs then compared the size of the serrations to the knife marks on Heather's skin, and they were the same.

Speaker 26 A group of abrasions on the side of her neck, no bigger than a half an inch, was matched back to a knife knife in the possession of the suspect in the case.

Speaker 9 Dr. Downs also compared the clothes iron found in Whipple's possession to Heather's wounds and concluded the iron had also been used in the crime.

Speaker 5 Next, Steve Derrick wanted to see if the black plastic pieces from the crime scene came from this iron.

Speaker 8 So at that point, it became a puzzle. After everything was photographically documented, started gluing the plastic pieces back together.

Speaker 5 After some trial and error, Derek discovered the pieces fit perfectly.

Speaker 8 The pieces from the crime scene and the iron in the car created a link to Whipple

Speaker 8 being at the crime scene.

Speaker 18 Investigators also analyzed the athletic shoes found in Whipple's possession.

Speaker 17 They were size 11, the same size as the shoe impressions found in blood at the crime scene.

Speaker 9 Steve Derrick used standard red fingerprint powder to dust the right shoe, then made an impression on a transparency. The size and tread pattern were the same.

Speaker 5 More importantly, the wear patterns known as accidental characteristics were virtually identical.

Speaker 8 The right shoe that had been taken from Whipple was the shoe to the exclusion of all others.

Speaker 5 Derek also concluded this was the shoe which made the bloody impression on Heather's shirt.

Speaker 8 The outsole design of Whipple's shoes matched this bloody impression on the t-shirt.

Speaker 6 And tests showed that clothing in the car contained Heather's blood.

Speaker 18 In his very first interview with police, James Whipple confessed. I did it to see her fix my drugs.
I did it because of

Speaker 18 damn crack cocaine.

Speaker 40 You'll get your damn money. You'll get your drugs one way or the other.

Speaker 24 He said, I killed her, and I deserve the death penalty for doing what I did to this young lady.

Speaker 10 James Whipple told police his addiction to crack cocaine had taken over his life and that the need for money to support his habit drove him to murder.

Speaker 41 The victim's family and friends can't get on with their lives until justice has been served and put the laws here behind them and try to get on with their lives.

Speaker 24 His family indicated that he had had some real problems with drugs and that he had an anger, a problem, that he had lost his wife, his marriage, his kids, and everything because of the drugs.

Speaker 24 And they said that it was something that he could not control at all.

Speaker 9 Whipple knew Heather Stigliano and knew she worked as a waitress and would have cash in her apartment.

Speaker 25 He knew that she worked at a restaurant, had good tip money, usually on most nights.

Speaker 13 Prosecutors believe Whipple went to Heather's apartment for one reason and one reason only.

Speaker 31 Money.

Speaker 20 He asked Heather if his friend Chris was there, which was probably a ruse to see if she was alone.

Speaker 30 Heather said she had his telephone number and allowed him inside.

Speaker 16 Desperate for money and high on drugs, Whipple attacked.

Speaker 9 He struck her with the clothes iron,

Speaker 5 which broke the plastic housing, then strangled her to death.

Speaker 18 Whipple took her money and whatever household items he thought he could sell.

Speaker 21 He also stole her car.

Speaker 9 The next day, Whipple said he returned to Heather's apartment to clean up.

Speaker 9 He wiped his fingerprints and tried to remove as much blood as he could.

Speaker 28 But forensic tests found the shoe impressions he thought he had cleaned.

Speaker 21 Before leaving, Whipple placed the pillow under Heather's head, a sign he knew her.

Speaker 11 He also took the clothes iron and knife later found in his possession.

Speaker 9 A short time later, He tried to sell Heather's camera to an antique dealer who notified authorities.

Speaker 3 We told the jury Jim Whipple was guilty in terms of committing the offense.

Speaker 3 He had confessed not only to police, and the judge was going to allow those confessions in because all of them were done properly, but he had talked to journalists, he had talked to detention officers, he had written letters telling everybody he'd committed this terrible crime.

Speaker 40 Just want to say I'm sorry, not that it's going to help.

Speaker 40 I'd also like to say that I believe in capital punishment. That's the only thing that I deserve.

Speaker 24 I never had a murder suspect, you know, confess like that and ask for the death penalty and say it so many times.

Speaker 9 James Whipple was convicted of first-degree murder, but didn't get the death penalty. Instead, he was sentenced to life in prison without parole.

Speaker 11 This, in my mind, is the second

Speaker 23 most horrific case that I've ever been involved in in terms of the trauma to the victim, the torture that the victim endured,

Speaker 23 the level of violence used to commit the murder.

Speaker 41 I deserve the punishment I get.

Speaker 33 I feel horrible about what I've done.

Speaker 33 I wish I could bring her back and trade legs with Academy.

Speaker 5 The forensic analysis not only identified the perpetrator, but documented the extent of his brutality.

Speaker 14 Forensic scientists is amazing

Speaker 14 the evidence that they can find from a piece of hair,

Speaker 14 you know, a little DNA or

Speaker 14 what have you, but no, it doesn't surprise me in the least.

Speaker 5 That really, to me, is impressive.

Speaker 26 That's what forensics is, is answering questions that haven't even been thought of yet.

Speaker 8 Anytime I can bring a case to a positive conclusion and provide a service to one of my fellow citizens, and I've done my job, I feel good.