Is My Dentist Scamming Me? (guest episode)

Happy New Year to all you listeners out there.

We here at Gastropod Headquarters are working hard on all the fascinating stories we're going to be sharing with you in 2025.

And while we do that, we've got something else to share to tide you over.

An episode made by our friends at Explain It To Me, a new show that calls itself the hotline for all the questions you can't answer on your own.

One of their listeners wanted to know why going to the dentist in the US is so confusing.

You have no idea what it's going to cost and if any of it's going to be covered, And frankly, it can sometimes feel a little bit like a scam.

Why isn't it just part of regular healthcare?

Are teeth somehow different from the rest of your body?

These are the nagging questions that Junklin Hill, the delightful host of Explain It To Me, gets to the bottom of this episode.

Enjoy, and we'll be back in a couple of weeks.

Support for this show comes from Pure Leaf Iced Tea.

When you find yourself in the afternoon slump, you need the right thing to make you bounce back.

You need Pure Leaf Iced Tea.

It's real brewed tea made in a variety of bold flavors with just the right amount of naturally occurring caffeine.

You're left feeling refreshed and revitalized so you can be ready to take on what's next.

The next time you need to hit the reset button, grab a Pure Leaf Iced Tea.

Time for a tea break?

Time for a Pure Leaf.

Support for this show comes from Pure Leaf Iced Tea.

When you find yourself in the afternoon slump, you need the right thing to make you bounce back.

You need pure leaf iced tea.

It's real brewed tea made in a variety of bold flavors with just the right amount of naturally occurring caffeine.

You're left feeling refreshed and revitalized so you can be ready to take on what's next.

The next time you need to hit the reset button, grab a pure leaf iced tea.

Time for a tea break?

Time for a pure leaf.

I did not go to the dentist for like health crisis, you know.

We should probably pull your wisdom together.

Isn't actually insurance.

I'm Jonathlyn Hill and you're listening to Explain It to Me, the hotline for all the questions you can't quite answer on your own.

This is how the show works.

You give us a call, tell us your question, and then we find out the answer and call you back.

Recently, we actually got a call from one of our colleagues, Matt.

Hey, my name is Matt, and I want to know how

tell if my dentist is scamming me.

I feel like through my entire adult life, every financial transaction with the dentist feels like really shady.

And so

why does the dentist always feel so shady and how can I tell if I'm being scammed or not?

Okay, bye.

Timing is everything.

Because just as Matt left this, I was scheduling my own dentist appointment.

So I wanted to know exactly what he meant when he said scam.

I called him back to find out more.

How do you feel about the dentist?

It's like always so awful.

What's awful about it?

So a couple of years ago, I went to the dentist and I like summarized it to my dentist and I was like, hey, just so you know, like I work really hard.

on taking care of my teeth, but every time you go in and poke at it with a metal hook, it is going to be like a Tarantino Tarantino movie.

And I really am trying, and I need you to know that.

And I also just feel like every time I go to the dentist, it's like a little bit of a mystery if they're going to be like, you're doing a great job or we need to do a major intervention.

And it never seems like there's a ton of rhyme or reason about it.

You know what gets me about the dentist more than anything?

It's the sounds.

It's like I can hear you poking around and like

just all the metal sound on bone.

Like I hear it inside my head.

Yeah, and then they want you to have feedback and you're like,

hello.

Hello.

Okay, well, great.

I really enjoy it.

Can you talk about instances where you've felt scammed by your dentist before?

Walk me through what happened from beginning to end.

Yeah, there's like one moment that I feel like I went from having a normal, didn't really think about it relationship with the dentist, at least on the financial side, to like, I don't know if I trust.

And it was 2018 or 2019.

And I was living in Washington, D.C.

at the time and I had to switch dentists.

And so I'm like going there and they're doing my cleaning.

And then the dentist is like, hey, we should probably pull your wisdom teeth.

The dentist has not.

booked in my mouth yet.

In theory, they've like looked at my x-rays and stuff, but they're like, here's what it'll cost to pull out all four of your wisdom teeth.

And like alarms went off of my head because i only have three wisdom teeth because oh my god because i had one pulled way earlier and so i was like you knew that i had wisdom teeth and just were like 1-800 insurance how much could we make to pull his wisdom teeth they were like you know it's not really an issue but we want to pull them before they become an issue and so i did like googling and the internet's like you know there's a reason you get your wisdom teeth pulled when you're like 16 or 17.

and it's because like your teeth keep growing around your nerves.

And so as you get older, they only want to pull them out if there's an issue, according to, you know, what I googled.

And then here's this dentist wanting to pull out four of my three wisdom teeth.

And so I'm like, I don't know, I'll think about it.

And I deferred.

When I moved to Oakland, I had this gum issue.

And they're like, you know, probably it's because your teeth are really crowded.

So if we pull your wisdom teeth out, it'll be easier.

And you should go.

They want those wisdom teeth bad.

All want my wisdom teeth because it's like an expensive thing, is what I deeply believe.

Ever since then, Matt's been on high alert for scams at the dentist.

By the way, it's very important to note that not all dentists are scammers.

And Matt doesn't necessarily think dentistry is a scam.

In fact, he takes his oral health really seriously.

He told me he has notifications on his phone that remind him to floss.

But even when you have a quote-unquote good dentist, there are still parts of the dental experience that can feel weird.

Matt said that part of what makes him so uncomfortable at the dentist is how he pays for his dental work.

It's completely different from how he pays for other medical care.

I think the dentist can sometimes feel like I'm being scanned because unlike when I'm at sort of like my regular doctor's office, there isn't this step where, you know, they say like, hey, we recommend you do something

and

here's what it's going to cost.

That just feels like so out of how I think about healthcare, like having to also then like kind of like think about like not only like, do I want this procedure, but do I want to pay for this procedure and how do I want to pay for this procedure?

We're going to go find experts to talk to.

Is there a kind of person that you hope we talk with?

I want to hear from like a dentist who's just equally frustrated by all of this.

I have to imagine that they're, you know, went to dental school because, you know, they really cared about making people's smiles great and helping with their teeth.

And I imagine they're like, I wish I could just fix people's teeth and bill it to insurance.

I want to know why I'm so often talking about money at the dentist.

I want to know why going to the dentist feels so different from going to any other healthcare appointment.

I want to know if I really need this procedure or if the dentist is kind of trying to scam me.

So that's our assignment for today.

We're going to figure out why dentistry can sometimes feel like an email chain letter from 2005 and what Matt can do next time he feels skeptical about a suggestion from his dentist.

Hi, Lisa.

How?

Our Dr.

Simon.

No, please call me Lisa.

Goodness, please call me Lisa.

Okay.

Very nice to meet you.

Thanks so much for having me on the show.

How would you introduce yourself at a party?

Oh boy.

Not by talking about my job in any way.

Well, pretend you're at a party in DC where everyone talks about their job because we're annoying.

So my name's Lisa Simon.

I'm a general dentist who was working in a community health center when I realized that the ways that dental care and medical care were separate was really harming my patients and I wanted to do something about it.

Essentially, one day Lisa thought, huh, we need to think about oral health as part of overall health.

So she made plans to do just that.

She went back to medical school and did an internal medicine residency on top of the dental school she'd already done.

So I have been in training for way too long.

Way, way too long.

Now she does internal medicine, but she also researches ways dentistry and medicine can work in tandem with one another.

So that fed up dentist Matt wants to hear from, she fits the bill.

And she's going to help us understand the system from the practitioner's perspective.

Lisa is clearly very dedicated to healthcare, but I also wanted to know what her experience is like when she's the one in the dentist's chair.

No, I'm 100% nervous and deeply afraid of being judged.

I did not go to the dentist for like genuinely a horrifyingly long amount of time, which I attributed to like medical training and COVID and stuff.

But the reality is just that like the dentist I wanted was me in a mirror in my house, which is like not actually how you can practice dentistry.

So now I go to my like best friend who I know will never judge me.

And mostly we talk about like coding various statistical analyses.

And then she tells me my teeth are fine and I feel safe.

Okay, I understand what you mean by that sense of judgment because I'm not going to say how long it was because it is embarrassing and I would judge me.

I can assure you that I would never judge you.

Like I think that feeling of judgment is really interesting.

Yeah, why do we feel so, why does the dentist feel so judgmental?

What's going on?

And again, I don't want to act like medicine is like way better at this because people definitely feel judged.

Oh, the doctor.

People who go to the gyno know that the bedside manner and how they talk to you can make or break that experience.

Yeah, and it's the same thing in dentistry.

I will say that I think in medicine, we've started to understand, like, from an empirical level, that making people feel judged and unsafe doesn't change their behavior.

And if anything, it makes them less likely to be honest with us and more likely to keep doing what they're doing.

Like, so even though people still feel judged in the medical settings, like we are trying to move away from that.

And somehow I feel like that just hasn't trickled down into dentistry.

So I think it's this like legacy and maybe partly this dichotomy between medicine and dentistry where we almost act like dentistry is optional and medicine is obligatory, which is like not how our bodies work at all, that like kind of feeds into this feeling of people being worried that a dentist or hygienist is going to judge them.

I posed Matt's question to Lisa.

Why does going to the dentist sometimes feel so scam adjacent?

Where is this Firefest energy coming from?

So there is a sort of fundamental tension to the way dentistry is paid for, which is that the average dentist is in private practice and their income is dependent on providing a procedural service to you.

So they are incentivized to offer more services to you and you are disincentivized from wanting to pay for them, which is 100% not to say that most dentists are scamming you, but rather there's this misalignment in terms of what our goal would be, which is to never get a cavity, and what dentists' goals are, which is to make money doing a lot of procedures that they're very skilled at.

Yeah.

This can exist in medicine, but it really doesn't in a lot of ways, both because because most physicians are employees of a larger health system.

So like when I practice primary care, I truly, like my income is not remotely dependent on whether you get a PAP test in a particular visit or a COVID vaccine or something.

And also because we've really shifted in how we pay for medical care to a more value-based system that focuses on and emphasizes keeping people healthy and focuses less on the individual procedures they need to get there.

Have you heard it described in this way by laypeople?

Is the sentiment that Matt has, is that common or something you've heard before?

I hear it all the time.

I would say the second most common dental-related text message I get, second to like, oh, my friend has this dental problem.

Can you look at this picture?

Is

my parents' friend saying, my dentist retired and I have a new dentist and I don't trust them.

I think they're scamming me.

Are they scamming me?

And even within the field, I've heard it referred to as the mechanics principle.

Oh my gosh.

Yeah.

It's kind of the same idea.

Like, at least I don't know anything about my car.

I like bring my car to the mechanic and the mechanic's like, oh, yeah, pretty bad conflubulator you got there.

Like definitely need to repair it.

And I'm like, I have no knowledge or expertise to be able to tell if that is true or if I am being scammed.

Yeah.

Like if you told me a confubulator was real, I'd be like, probably.

Is it?

It may be real.

I mean,

I know so little about cars.

It could be a real car thing.

But the reality is that like, one, most dentists are probably not like scamming you in this like evil mustache-trolling way, but also, like, there can be legitimate sort of clinical differences in someone's style.

So, you may have a more conservative dentist in the sense of like they're going to wait and see if this gets bigger and maybe it doesn't need a filling right now.

Or you might have a dentist that's kind of more aggressive and wants to treat something earlier just because, like, they have different clinical experiences and they're legitimately recommending what they think would be best for you.

And that can also be a tension.

But it can contribute to this feeling of like, is anyone going to tell it to me straight?

Yeah.

So why is it still so expensive to get dental work done?

Why does it feel so different from regular health insurance?

So in one way, dental insurance is super expensive, which is that for the average person, like a dental procedure, like an implant is a crazy amount of money out of pocket.

In other ways, dentistry is actually super duper cheap.

It's only 4% of our average healthcare expense as a country.

And you know, if you think about like the single cost of like being in an ICU in a hospital for a day, which could easily be like $50,000, like that's way more expensive than dental care.

The difference is what you as a patient see.

And like certainly there's like horrible medical bankruptcy and debt that people take on when they are underinsured for health issues.

But fundamentally, like the idea behind medical insurance is that if this super expensive, absolutely horrible nightmare thing happens to you, you are not financially on the hook for it.

Dental insurance isn't actually insurance.

It just doesn't work that way.

It's a discount plan.

And what it does is it makes the cheapest things like your cleaning or your exam or your x-rays that you get every year free or really cheap.

But if you actually need things, you are going to pay progressively more and more of the cost of these more expensive things, which is basically the opposite of how medical insurance works or the opposite of how medical insurance was originally designed to work.

So should we even be calling it insurance?

Like, should we call it like, oh, a discount plan?

Or like, here is your dentist loyalty card.

Like, yeah, is insurance the word we should be using?

Honestly, I feel like that's a great point.

Like, it's not insurance.

Like, to call it insurance is maybe more of a scam than any other kind of scamming that's being done.

And it's not to say that it might not be financially a good idea for an individual person, but as a structure designed to take care of a badly unmet need in our society and to provide healthcare, it's not the way I think any of us would like design it from first principles.

Yeah.

Another thing that I've kind of been thinking about in the research for this and getting ready to answer this question for Matt is, you know, we've even in the language we're talking about it, we say dental versus medical, which feels a little weird to me because dentistry is

medicine.

Like,

am I wrong in that?

Like, why?

Even the language and how we talk about it, it's like, oh, here's dental and here's medicine.

Like, they aren't, you know, part of the same thing.

Teeth are in my body.

Yeah.

And if you talk to any patient who's really struggled to get dental care, like, it's very intuitive to them.

Like, no patient is like, why, like, shouldn't we incorporate oral health into my overall health?

Like, big guy, they're like, I have a terrible toothache.

It kept me all up all night.

And I have this infection.

And now I'm in an emergency room, which is like very medical.

Like, they've had an exclusively medical experience.

And also, just like, obviously, it's their body.

I think that the way we talk about it maybe epitomizes how deep this separation runs.

Like it affects our language surrounding it.

It affects how we talk about the importance.

Like we can't help ourselves.

It's just so fundamental to what dentistry has been for so long.

Okay, so a lot of the weirdness Matt experiences at the dentist might be traced to the fact that dentistry and medicine are separate, and they have been for a really long time.

But why?

How did dentistry and medicine get so far apart?

That's after the break.

Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start?

Thumbtack knows homes.

So you don't have to.

Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin?

Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is with thumbtack you don't have to be a home pro you just have to hire one you can hire top-rated pros see price estimates and read reviews all on the app download today bundle and safe with expedia you were made to follow your favorite band and from the front row we were made to quietly save you more expedia made to travel savings vary and subject to availability light inclusive packages are at all protected charlie sheen is an icon of decadence.

I lit the fuse, and my life turns into everything it wasn't supposed to be.

He's going the distance.

He was the highest-paid TV star of all time.

When it started to change, it was quick.

He kept saying, no, no, no, I'm in the hospital now, but next week I'll be ready for the show.

Now, Charlie's sober.

He's going to tell you the truth.

How do I present this with any class?

I think we're past that, Charlie.

We're past that, yeah.

Somebody call action.

AKA Charlie Sheen, only on Netflix, September 10th.

So today, we're figuring out why the dentist feels scammy sometimes.

I called up another expert to find out why dentistry and medicine got on such separate paths.

Mary Otto is an independent journalist who's covered social issues and oral health for years.

Before she went indie, she covered healthcare at the Washington Post.

She also wrote one of the books on teeth and dentistry.

It's called Teeth, the story of beauty, inequality, and the struggle oral health in America.

Tell me about the story that first got you into Teeth, into covering oral health care.

I was working at the Washington Post on the Metro's desk back in 2007.

It's a day in January.

I found myself at the bedside of a 12-year-old Maryland schoolboy named Diamante Driver.

I was at Children's Hospital.

A few days earlier, he had come home from school, not feeling well.

He was such an active little boy.

His grandmother was worried, and she took him to a little community hospital nearby where he was diagnosed with sinus infection and an abscessed tooth.

He got some medicine, came home.

A couple days later, he was much worse.

The doctors told her that this infection in his tooth had spread to his brain.

He was rushed to children's hospital.

That's where I met him and his mom.

He'd had two brain surgeries.

Finally, this infected tooth had been extracted, but he, you know, he was fighting for his life.

And

it turned out there was a shortage of dentists in that community who accepted federal health care benefits for poor kids.

And dental benefits are entitlement for poor children under Medicaid.

But it turned out, as I was to learn in my reporting, it was care that hundreds of thousands of children across the state of Maryland and millions of children across the country just weren't getting.

There's just a shortage

of Medicaid dentists in so many communities.

And

that shortage had, you know, left the driver family behind.

I mean, Mrs.

Driver knew where to get shots for the kids to go back to school and sports exams.

You know, those were health care needs.

She could handle, but it turned out getting dental care was this gap, this just a divide in our health care system that she couldn't navigate.

Even with the help of a professional, they finally found basic visit for

little brother, but by then Diamante was so sick and he did, he died.

The story was a horrible story to write, but it led to congressional hearings.

reforms, and a whole new kind of attention to

the oral health needs of millions of poor children and adults across our country.

I remember Diamante's story, too.

I was in high school at the time and didn't live in the DC metro area, but it made national news.

It was the first time I realized how important going to the dentist actually is.

It was scary, this idea that missing appointments could kill you.

Diamante's story really impacted Mary, and she wanted to try to find out how the situation came to be how did we get to a place where dentistry was so dangerously separate from health care and so much harder to access for people to find out she went back into the history way back

dentists

were sort of self-trained folks a system that dated back to the middle ages there were people who were barbers who provided these treatments or even blacksmiths some in some places you know there were all kinds of things were used to fill decayed teeth even molten lead there've been different kinds of people sold treatments like leeches and herbs to relieve the pain of miserable and difficult problem to have

so originally dentists were not the most highly trained, but that started changing in the 19th century in America.

As As the country became an industrial powerhouse, lots of lines of work changed, including medicine.

Back in 1840, there were two dentists who were Chapin Harris and Horace Hayden, were actually very scientific-minded men.

Horace Hayden was actually also a geologist.

It sounds like dentistry was a side hustle back in the day.

It was, but these two guys were deeply invested in it, you know.

Okay.

And Chapin Harris, he had imported books from France and England where there were dentists who were actually working in hospital settings and taking oral disease and health seriously in a way that the tradespeople who were calling themselves dentists here in this country weren't thinking about.

And he and Horace Hayden actually decided they would go to the College of Medicine in Baltimore and approach the doctors about adding a course in dental care to the medical training.

And the doctors, as the story goes, sent them away.

They said the subject of dentistry was of little consequence.

And these two guys didn't take no for an answer.

They set up what's remembered as the first, the world's first college of dentistry.

And it became a model for dental education in this country.

And this historical quirk is why dentistry and medicine are so separate.

They're like two parallel lines, developing alongside each other, but never intersecting.

Even the way they're both insured is different.

The first real earnest effort at creating a dental insurance system was right after World War II.

It was

1951, I believe.

This dentist named Max Shane, he was out in California, and he worked with the Long Shoremen's Union, and they had health care benefits.

This was in the early days of workers getting workplace health care benefits.

You know, after the war and during the war, but largely after the war, a lot of workplaces started instituting benefits as part of the compensation for their workers.

And some of the most ambitious and full-blown plans were kind of masterminded by unions.

You know, it became, you know, part of a worker's expectations that health care would be part of his or her compensation on the on the job.

And these longshoremen ended up with some extra money in their benefit account, I guess, after covering everybody's health care benefits.

And they said, why don't we get a dental benefit for our kids?

And they went to this dentist named Max Shane, who was delighted to take up this challenge.

He designed this plan.

And then he actually set up clinics to treat the children.

And

the local dental associations just, they hated this.

They called it a form of communism, you know, or, you know,

they said, you know, this is a closed system.

You know, you're shutting out your, you're anti-competitive.

This clinic that you have is depriving us of patients.

And it was a big battle.

Dr.

Shane actually had to go before the House Un-American Activities Committee that was during the

era.

And it turned out this was part of a larger kind of, of, you know, socialized medicine was one of those concerns of organized medicine and organized dentistry.

You know, this was like seen as a threat to the private practice system.

As a result of all of that, the way dental offices are set up, the way we pay for dental care, it all works differently than our medical systems.

And even if we wanted to combine medical and dental systems right now, it would be really difficult.

In part because the systems can't even communicate with one another.

Our dental charts are typically kept in different coding languages than our medical charts.

Medical charts have diagnostic codes.

Dental charts have treatment codes.

And treatments are billable.

Insurance just adds another layer of confusion.

Most dental coverage in the U.S.

is private, and there are millions of Americans who don't have private medical or dental insurance.

But adult benefits under Medicaid for low-income adults are still left up to the states.

They're basically kind of an optional part of the problem.

It's up to the states because under the Affordable Care Act, dental care isn't considered an essential health benefit for adults on Medicaid.

It's not covered by Medicare either.

Medicare, which covers millions of retired adults,

has never included routine dental coverage.

And as you might remember,

not too long ago, there was a big push to add dental benefits to Medicare during President Biden's administration.

It failed, but this is an ongoing effort by oral health care advocates.

But still, some of these millions of adults without dental benefits.

And so today, the only group of people who have a guaranteed right to dental care are children on Medicaid.

But even though children get that insurance coverage now, it's still incredibly hard to find a dental provider because there's no mandate that dentists accept Medicaid, which is why it was so hard for Diamante Driver's mom to find treatment for him.

And that's just another example of how dentistry's differences can have real consequences.

I just hope we can all think about oral health, you know, in new ways and ask the kind of questions that need to be asked and make the kind of requests that need to be made to have a better handle on this

important part of our healthcare system.

After the break, we're going to find out if dentistry and medicine could ever get back together.

Plus, I want to know how to navigate these like tricky financial interactions at the dentist.

We get some tips from Lisa Simon.

Stay tuned.

Starting a business can seem like a daunting task, unless you have a partner like Shopify.

They have the tools you need to start and grow your business.

From designing a website to marketing to selling and beyond, Shopify can help with everything you need.

There's a reason millions of companies like Mattel, Heinz, and Allberds continue to trust and use them.

With Shopify on your side, turn your big business idea into

sign up for your $1 per month trial at shopify.com/slash special offer.

Tires matter.

They're the only part of your vehicle that touches the road.

Tread confidently with new tires from Tire Rack.

Whether you're looking for expert recommendations or know exactly what you want, Tire Rack makes it easy.

Fast, free shipping, free road hazard protection, convenient installation options, and the best selection of Bridgestone tires.

Go to tire rack.com to see their Bridgestone test results, tire ratings, and reviews.

And be sure to check out all the special offers.

Tireact.com, the way tire buying should be.

We're excited to tell you about a podcast we think you'll love called Decoder Ring.

Decoder Ring is a slate podcast all about cracking cultural mysteries, hosted by Willa Paskin.

And if you're a fan of getting the weird true stories behind things, which if you listen to Gastropod, you surely are, then we think you'll really enjoy it.

The show tackles an enormous variety of curious conundrums.

There's an episode about how a made-up fruit, the blue raspberry, took over the candy aisle, but also one about why the tooth fairy hasn't been commercialized the way, say, Santa has.

Ever wondered why single-subject magazines about everything from Taylor Swift to Robert Redford to the Paleo Diet, why they've taken over the CVS checkout lane?

They've got an episode on that, too.

Named Best Pop Culture Podcast by the iHeart Podcast Awards and a Best Podcast by Vulture, Decoder Ring will make you see the things that are all around you differently and more deeply.

Make sure to follow Decoder Ring to unravel even more fascinating stories.

That's Decoder Ring, available wherever you listen to your podcasts.

You're listening to Explain It To Me.

I'm John Glenhill.

Now that we know how and why dentistry is distinct, it's also important to understand what that separation means for patients, like my colleague Matt.

There can be less regulation in dentistry than other forms of medicine, which can mean some dentists could be over-treating some patients.

Though experts say it's hard to know exactly how much of that is happening day to day.

That said, there have been times where it's gotten pretty extreme.

Like in 2010, when a government investigation revealed that a chain of dental offices was performing unnecessary procedures like extractions and fillings on children with Medicaid, that company ended up owing $24 million to the federal and state governments.

So there can be real life consequences to this historic separation.

But also, it's 2024.

Why haven't we just merged dentistry and medicine and made it easier for ourselves?

That's what I asked Lisa, our dentist-turned internal medicine physician.

I think a lot of it is inertia.

Like once a dental school exists, it's really hard to say, shut down the dental schools.

Like dental school is done now.

You're going to be a dental residency, even if we all agree like maybe that's the best way to do things which like it may or may not be um and especially with the way insurance works it can be very difficult to mandate insurance structures to change or to expand their coverage in various ways and then Also, just to kind of be frank about it, there's been a lot of lobbying on the part of organized dentistry, like the American Dental Association.

And I'll say diplomatically that that is changing and evolving.

More recently, the Affordable Care Act really didn't include dentistry for similar reasons.

And in 2021, President Biden's Build Back Better Bill included a Medicare dental benefit that got removed because of lobbying efforts.

So we're in a world where there's also a lot of people who maybe don't want this gap to be filled.

What's the thought process behind those lobbying efforts?

So Part of it is just like, this is the way things have always been done in dentistry.

And if you are a dentist, you probably don't see a lot of downside to that.

This is how you're used to making your income.

You're probably pretty comfortable.

And the patients that you see are self-selecting to be people who can afford to participate in our current fractured dental system.

A lot of the people who are so utterly failed by the way dentistry works in our country are people who are going to emergency departments with their toothaches and are never meeting a dentist.

So a lot of this might be just oversight to a certain extent from the people who want things to stay the way they are.

I think it's also hard because there is such stigma against poor oral health health in our country that it's really difficult for there to be, you know, patient advocates telling their stories about why it's so difficult to get dental care or afford dental care in America in ways that there aren't for a lot of other disease conditions that really benefit from our need to listen to communities and listen to people who've gone through this and not, you know, just a bunch of talking heads or nerdy researchers like me.

Is there a realistic way to combine the dental and medical fields?

What would have to happen for that to happen?

I think there are ways that we could bridge medicine and dentistry that would maybe not make it a perfect world, but would be really meaningful and important to individuals.

So like at a structural level, I think things that are really important are things like dental coverage.

So, you know, right now, as you mentioned,

dental care is an essential health benefit for children on Medicaid.

And

Medicaid doesn't actually require a copay or much cost of any kind for individuals who are eligible for that benefit.

Like that's true insurance, right?

Like they're not paying anything.

Making that mandatory across all 50 states for adults on Medicaid would be amazing.

That would be millions of people who, even if they don't have ideal dental access, now have some dental access and some dental coverage.

Additionally, doing something like providing a Medicare dental benefit, which would affect 65 million people, would be incredible.

And there have been sort of a slow trickle of moves to provide some sort of Medicare dental coverage to a very small number of people with very specific diagnoses, like going on dialysis or getting an organ transplant.

But expanding that to everybody would be a huge game changer.

Okay, so it sounds like it's not realistic that clinically we're going to see sort of this combination of things, but it does sound a little more hopeful on the insurance side.

I guess, would it be a good idea to kind of merge these things clinically, or is it kind of like, all right, they're separate for a reason.

Let's keep it that way.

I think everything's better when it's integrated.

Like, I don't know if you are in a health system where like if you go to the doctor, you like can go on your patient portal and like check

labs.

Oh, yes.

That kind of information exchange is really valuable for everybody.

Right now, that exists, but like totally separate from dentistry.

Dentists are just like writing on their paper charts or using an EHR that's exclusive to dentistry and they cannot see what doctors are writing.

They cannot write to doctors.

So that's another way where having any sort of integration would like dramatically benefit patient safety and patient outcomes and probably be really satisfying for providers too.

And then in an ideal world, would it be super amazing to like be able to be like, oh, I see something, like let me send you to dental down in the hallway, like right now for a walk-in visit.

Or like, if you're admitted to the hospital, a dental hygienist could come and clean your teeth while you're there.

Like there are so many ways that this could be really beneficial for patients and like could exist in a world where we pay for dental care and transmit dental information differently than we do now.

But I think part of that is we need to build the infrastructure to do it.

And then all of this innovation can come.

So I want to get some practical tips too.

What can listeners do if they are unsure about a diagnosis at the dentist?

Like, what can they do to feel a little more confident and self-assured when they get in that chair?

So the first thing I always tell anyone when this question comes up is that if you don't feel like you have a good relationship with your provider of any kind, you should find another one because that kind of trust is so important in healthcare.

But the other thing is that if you're just concerned about a specific recommendation, if you feel confident enough to ask for their reasoning, they should treat you with respect and provide it.

There may be a very good reason why they're telling you what they're telling you.

And at the very least, they should be able to kind of back it up.

The other thing is that any, you know, reasonable, caring, empathic dentist is going to be fine if you say, like, oh, I need to think it over or I want to see a second opinion.

Because that's a totally valid thing to do.

Lastly, if you just feel like private practice dentistry, for whatever reason, is not the right place for you to get care that feels trustworthy, there are other opportunities.

So, community health centers have amazing, robust dental clinics.

Most community health center dentists are really in it to take care of people and make the world a better place.

And they are very, very unlikely to recommend that you do something you don't need because they are too busy to do that and they are not making money on those recommendations the way other dentists who own their practices might be.

And then the other option is the dental school clinic, which can be an amazing place.

I taught, I went to dental school, I taught a dental school.

I think dental school clinic care is really good.

The caveat is it is real slow.

But you might also look into whether faculty at a dental school are providing care somewhere because they might be sort of similarly focused on the educational aspect of things or the

public health aspect of things rather than like the individual procedures that might change their personal calculus.

All right, Lisa Simon, thank you so much for explaining this to us.

Thanks.

It was really great to talk to you.

Thank you for having me.

After talking with Lisa and Mary, I called up Matt to tell him what I found.

Matt, how are you doing?

I'm doing well.

I'm really excited to learn why the dentist always kind of feels like a racket.

I told Matt what Mary said about dentistry's origins and why it still feels so separate from the rest of medicine.

I told him about 1840 and how the Baltimore doctors wouldn't let the dentist set up a class at their medical school and how they've been separate ever since.

They just never reconsidered it ever again.

Yeah, they were just like,

it's almost like, you know, like a, I think of almost like a family tree and there are all these branches.

But they mostly were like, ah, we could do something different now.

But they were like, nope, we decided that teeth are a different thing.

So we'll never reconsider that it will have ramifications as far into the future as we can get yes baffling

Matt wanted to hear from a frustrated dentist so I told him all about Lisa and how she saw the differences in history and insurance affect care today

so if we wanted like to rework dental insurance so that like when you needed some bigger thing done, it wouldn't suddenly be like, and here's where you're going to have to pay us a couple hundred bucks, thousand bucks.

We would be paying like much bigger dental premiums.

Can you see yourself like getting your x-rays and taking them to someone else?

Is that something you do?

Yeah, I think I could potentially do that.

If they ever tell me I need to do something else, I can say, hey, I want to think on it.

I guess they're not going to say like, well, well, we're not going to fix your teeth if you don't decide now.

It's not like somebody else is going to buy my teeth out from under me.

Yeah.

Like a used car.

Yeah.

At least like

we aren't in that dystopia yet.

Yet.

Yeah.

And if you feel like you're really getting scammed, like if it's egregious, you can report the provider to the dental licensing board or to your dental insurance company.

Good to know.

Yeah, you can snitch.

I'm pro-snitching most of the time.

Next time I get some real bad vibes, I'm going to call up the California Dental Licensing Board.

Yeah.

So how do you feel about all of the knowledge you have today?

Did you learn anything?

How you feeling?

I feel some empathy.

I still feel like frustrated with the system, but it's nice to know, I suppose, that the dental professionals feel similarly frustrated, that they're all kind of stuck in this system and that we're all, we're all a bit in this together.

And I think that I feel a little more equipped.

you know, next time there's a high dollar option in front of me to think about whether I really need this or not.

And Lisa even said she goes to like one of her friends who is a dentist for dentistry because she knows that person is not going to judge her and like shame her for her flossing habits.

I got to go make some dentist friends.

Yeah, that's what you got to do.

You got to find out the bars that dentists hang out in.

Oh my God.

And befriend them.

I don't know if I think I'd rather just spend the money.

All right, Matt.

I'm glad we could explain it to you.

Thank you for explaining it to me.

That's it for this episode of our new podcast, Explain It to Me.

Thanks to Matt for the question and Mary Otto and Lisa Simon for the answer.

As you heard, listeners like you are a big part of the show.

So if you have a question, something you'd like us to explain to you, give us a call.

Our number is 1-800-618-8545.

We'll also also include those deets and more in our show notes.

This episode was produced by Sophie Lalonde.

It was edited by Catherine Wells.

Mixing and sound design by Andrea Kristen's daughter and Christian Ayala.

Carla Javier is our supervising producer.

And I'm your host, John Clan Hill.

Thanks for listening.

Talk to you soon.

I had every intention of asking for my wisdom teeth and I got mine pulled recently, but then I was kind of too stoned to like to want to ask in the moment.

But my mom, when she got her wisdom teeth out, you know, before I even existed, took them and then she mailed them to my father, who was like working on the other side of the country.

That was like part of their early courtship.

Wait, that's love.

Did he wear them around his neck?

No, but they made her way back to her because like anytime that story came up, they'd like kind of emerge emerge out of a drawer and like be on the counter for a couple of days.

Oh my gosh, my mom made me throw them away, and I could have used them to like send to my one true love.