The Hanoverian Succession

Speaker 1 This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

Speaker 2 It's finally here! Black Friday at Ulta Beauty. Take 30% off MAC foundations and lip colors.
Save $100 on the iconic Dyson AirWrap. And starting Tuesday, shop mascaras for $14 and lip colors for $12.

Speaker 2 Perfect for stocking up. To make it super easy, shop online and pick up in store or get same-day delivery.
Head into Ulta Beauty and shop Black Friday deals now through November 29th.

Speaker 2 Ulta Beauty, gifting happens here.

Speaker 1 Okay.

Speaker 3 Only 10 more presents to wrap.

Speaker 4 You're almost at the finish line. But first,

Speaker 4 there, the last one.

Speaker 4 Enjoy a Coca-Cola for a pause that

Speaker 1 refreshes.

Speaker 4 BBC Sounds, music, radio, podcasts.

Speaker 5 This is in our time from BBC Radio 4, and this is one of more than a thousand episodes you can find on BBC Sounds and on our website.

Speaker 5 If you scroll down the page for this edition, you can find a reading list to go with it. I hope you enjoyed the program.

Speaker 5 Hello, at the turn of the 18th century, Westminster politicians went to extraordinary lengths to find a Protestant successor to the throne of Great Britain and Ireland.

Speaker 5 Queen Anne had no surviving children, and following the old rules, there were at least 50 Catholic candidates ahead of any Protestant one.

Speaker 5 Yet, by passing the Act of Settlement in 1701, focus turned to Europe and the Protestant Princess Sophia, an electress of the Holy Roman Empire in Hanover, who became next in line to be crowned at Westminster Abbey.

Speaker 5 With me to discuss the Hanoverian succession are Andreas Gestrick, Professor Emeritus at Trier University and former director of the German Historical Institute in London.

Speaker 5 Elaine Chalice, Professor of British History at the University of Liverpool, and Mark Knights, Professor of History at the University of Warwick.

Speaker 5 Mark Knights, why was there a need for the Act of Settlement in 1701?

Speaker 1 The Act of Settlement was needed to secure the Protestant succession.

Speaker 1 And in order to understand that, we need to go back a little bit because Britain had been wracked by succession crises for 25 years.

Speaker 1 James, Duke of York, who became James II,

Speaker 1 was the subject of an enormous amount of controversy in the late 1670s and the early 1680s when there were attempts to exclude him from the succession. They failed.
He did become king.

Speaker 1 He became James II.

Speaker 1 And he fulfilled all the worst nightmares of his opponents by pursuing Catholic policies, triggering revolution in 1688. And one of the outcomes of that revolution was the Bill of Rights.

Speaker 1 And the Bill of Rights laid down that no future king should be a Catholic. Indeed, they weren't even allowed to have a Catholic wife.

Speaker 1 So as you were saying in the introduction, with the prospect of no Protestant heir from either William or from Anne, it became increasingly necessary necessary to settle the succession in the Hanoverian line, all the more so because

Speaker 1 England's arch enemy, France, had recognised James II's son, James Francis Edward, as the legitimate heir.

Speaker 1 So the prospect was for a succession war which would radiate across Europe, as indeed was happening with Catholic Spain at the time.

Speaker 1 And the war that broke out during Queen Anne's reign, the War of the Spanish Succession, was precisely another of these big conflicts over succession.

Speaker 5 Which party was most in favour of a Hanoverian ruler in the early days? And if so, why?

Speaker 1 So the later Stuart period, the later 17th century, early 18th century, is characterised by the birth of party politics. So we had the emergence of Whigs and Tories.
The names were very pejorative.

Speaker 1 They were given to the emergent parties in 1681. And the Whigs stood for tolerance towards Protestant dissent.
That was one of the bedrocks of their ideology.

Speaker 1 And they were also interested in expanding Britain's power overseas, particularly against Catholic threats.

Speaker 1 And the Tories were very devoutly wedded to the Church of England and they were much more sceptical of the sort of Whigs expansionist foreign policy.

Speaker 1 So the Whigs were the sort of, in a way, the natural supporters of the Hanoverian succession, because they saw in Hanover the Protestant champion that they had been looking for.

Speaker 1 The Tories, on the other hand, or indeed some Tories, because I should say that really the Tory party has different wings, but many in the Tory party were deeply uncomfortable with the idea of breaking away from the Stuart succession,

Speaker 1 inviting a foreigner who spoke very little English. It sort of fed into many of their prejudices.

Speaker 5 Thank you very much. Elaine, Elaine, Charlotte.

Speaker 5 How did they arrive at the idea that a successor from Hanover would be the answer?

Speaker 3 Well, I think from what Mark has already said, we're already specifying in the Act that it would have to be someone Protestant. And so consequently, we're looking for who in the line of succession.

Speaker 3 And of course the Hanoverians are in the line of succession. Sophia the Electress is actually a granddaughter of the Stuart line.
And so consequently she fits into that direct line of succession.

Speaker 3 They can argue that this is still a Stuart line. They can sort of cadge about a bit with that.
And they can then popularize that.

Speaker 3 And it's that kind of popularization of the Hanoverians that is part of what's going on here. So we're seeing that in a number of different ways.

Speaker 3 Once they've settled on that she's going to be the person who's going to inherit the throne, that she is directly the heir once Queen Anne's son has died. She gets written into the state prayers.

Speaker 3 We see her image being portrayed in prints, her son's image,

Speaker 3 later George I, his image is in prints. You know, these people are talked about.
There's gossip, there's news, the newspapers are talking, there's lots of information coming out.

Speaker 5 Can I take a couple of of steps back? Anne had 17 children and all of them died either in childbirth or very soon afterwards.

Speaker 5 That must have been so, obviously, unbearably distressing for her, but for people knowing what to do.

Speaker 3 Yes, oh definitely.

Speaker 3 The Stuart line has a desperately bad reputation for having healthy living children that are also legitimate. And Anne continued that.

Speaker 3 And so with the multiple pregnancies, and as you say, 17 different pregnancies,

Speaker 3 only one child actually living long enough, he's born in 1689, he dies in 1700, just after his 11th birthday, I think, of smallpox. Once the Duke of Gloucester, which is what he was called,

Speaker 3 has died, then we really are in a situation where we have to find some other heir because Anne's health is not good enough. She's clearly not well.

Speaker 3 It looks very unlikely that she's going to have any children that actually will survive. So someone has to be in the line of succession.
Otherwise we have a dynastic crisis.

Speaker 5 So they're the least bad option.

Speaker 3 Absolutely the least bad option. And they're actually quite a good option in lots of ways because they don't pose a real threat to the British.

Speaker 3 They aren't that big and that important a German family in that sense. They're a relatively new German family.

Speaker 3 But they're also staunchly Lutheran at this point in time, but seen as defenders of the faith. And that's really important if you're a Whig politician.
Also, they're very active against Louis XIV,

Speaker 3 you know, and Louis's aggrandizing, Catholicizing movement across Europe. And they're very much involved in that, in fighting back, in pushing back, in standing up for Protestantism.

Speaker 3 And so that makes them very popular in some ways in England.

Speaker 5 Andres, the Hanoverians had their own considerations, obviously. Who was supporting them in advancing their case?

Speaker 6 Well, it's an interesting question in the context of the succession: that, of course, in Hanover, opinions were also partly divided and at least not clear how earnestly or how eagerly one should follow up this possibility, which was still then in 1701 and hadn't even acceded to the throne, English throne.

Speaker 6 So that was still William III.

Speaker 6 And a lot could happen. Officially, it was Sophia, the granddaughter of James I

Speaker 6 and daughter of the winter queen of the Palatinate.

Speaker 6 So she was clearly a proper Protestant, but her husband had his eyes on actually different aims. He wanted to raise his family to the status of electors of the Holy Roman Empire.

Speaker 6 Traditionally there were seven electors in the Golden Bull of 1356 and only after the Peace of Westphalia there was for peace sake there was they created an eighth electorship and now Hanover came and wanted a ninth electorship and he was fairly close to that and he needed the Emperor to convey that title on to him and then announcing that he might be the next Protestant king of England or his wife might have been counterproductive.

Speaker 6 In 1692 he became that the emperor gave him this title but even then the imperial diet hadn't agreed to it. That took another 10 years.

Speaker 6 So there was a lot in limbo in the time but he left or that is why he left all dealings with England to begin with to Sophia the Electress.

Speaker 5 Can you tell the listeners who Leibniz was and why he played an important part in this?

Speaker 6 Yes, Leibniz had a very close relationship to Sophia. They were engaged in continuous debate, theological, philosophical, and Leibniz was also basically the court historiographer of the Hanoverians.

Speaker 6 And he had the task to write a history of the Guffs, because the Hanoverians, or the electors of Brunswick-Luneburg, as they're officially called, were

Speaker 6 came from the family of the Guffs.

Speaker 6 And Leibniz, in that context, was very keen not only to support the electorship but also then the house rising to the status of British kings and he did genealogical research which became quite important to show that the contacts between the Guelph family and the British royal families were much closer or have been closer for a long time and he went right back to Mathilde, daughter of Henry II Plantagenet, who married the Guelph Henry the Lion and in the public fashioning of the claim to the throne that played an important part.

Speaker 6 When the Act of Settlement was ceremoniously transported to Hanover, Sophia issued a medal and on that medal she had her face and on the other side she had Mathilde's face, not her mother, not her grandfather, but Mathilde.

Speaker 6 And that

Speaker 6 was a way to counteract the...

Speaker 6 well, the way the Act of Settlement was a bit of a parliamentarian thing.

Speaker 6 It didn't necessarily... of course it recognized the birthright but there was a different tone to it a Republican tone.

Speaker 5 What other reservations if any did the Hanoverians have about the Act of Settlement of 1701?

Speaker 6 The family, as from 1701, the family, and particularly Ernst August was dead, his son George, later George I,

Speaker 6 I think he took over the task. The electorship was clarified by then and he worked towards it very carefully, very cautiously, because a lot could still go wrong.

Speaker 6 As we heard, a Stuart Prince might convert to Protestantism again, their polling broke and others tried to convince them. but he then sort of continuously worked towards it.

Speaker 6 The Protestant priests in the electorate were of course delighted because her elector became the main defender of Protestantism in the Reich.

Speaker 6 He took over this role from Arkus von Saxon who had converted to Catholicism in order to conquer the Polish crown.

Speaker 6 And so the Hanoverians tried to step into that void and become the leading power in the imperial diet and in the Reich Protestant power.

Speaker 5 Thank you. Mark, there were 13 years between the act of settlement and the death of Queen Anne.
Those must have been turbulent years. Can you give us a sketch of that time?

Speaker 1 Yes, they were extremely turbulent years. Indeed, many historians refer to them these years as the rage of party.

Speaker 1 So party politics really reached a crescendo, partly because of very, very frequent parliamentary elections, on average every two and a half years.

Speaker 1 So an almost constant ferment of electioneering. And there were some really big public debates, partly because government censorship had lapsed in 1695, so the press was unleashed.

Speaker 1 So, you have very vigorous debate in Parliament, but also very vigorous debate outside of Parliament.

Speaker 5 On this issue alone, or on many issues?

Speaker 1 On many, many issues.

Speaker 1 Such as the war effort. So, from 1702 to 1713, Britain was at war with France, and that war was enormously expensive on an unprecedented scale.

Speaker 1 It was a continental war, it was a land war, but it was also a sort of global war. It was being fought out in the colonies and so on.

Speaker 1 And in order to pay for that war, there had to be new innovations in the tax system. The Bank of England had been created in 1694 to create the financial mechanisms to supply this.

Speaker 1 So war was an extremely controversial point, but so too was religion. Religion was an extremely strong dividing line in this period, as we've already heard with the need for a Protestant successor.

Speaker 1 But Protestants disagreed amongst themselves, and they've disagreed particularly over how far the state should tolerate those who couldn't conform to the Church of England.

Speaker 1 1689 had ushered in a Toleration Act, which had given dissenters, as these non-conformists were known, some freedom of worship outside of the confines of the Church of England.

Speaker 1 But there were many who deeply, deeply resented that and remained very hostile to dissent.

Speaker 1 And in 1709, an inflammatory cleric called Henry Seychevrel preached a sermon that basically attacked the revolution of 1688 for its resistance against the Stuart line and attacked the role of the dissenters and wanted to restore the Church of England to its sort of former supremacy.

Speaker 1 and this created the largest propaganda outflow, the largest flow of print seen in the 18th century as a whole. So religion was really, really divisive.

Speaker 1 And one other point that's worth mentioning I think here in terms of the division is what's happening north of the border because although the Act of Settlement secured the succession in England, it didn't secure it north of the border in Scotland.

Speaker 1 And the Act of Union with Scotland, which created the state of Great Britain, was passed in 1707 in order to ensure that the Scots sided with the English, with the Hanoverian succession.

Speaker 1 And that created enormous discontent north of the border.

Speaker 5 Elaine, Elaine Jalas. A lot of the major figures here are women.

Speaker 5 Queen Anne, of course, and before her marriage, then Princess Sophia, and then Caroline of Ansbach, married to Sophia's grandson, also George.

Speaker 3 What does she have to offer?

Speaker 3 Caroline is probably one of the most underrated, I think, figures in the securing of the Hanoverian succession, because the Hanoverian succession depended upon having multiple generations.

Speaker 3 And this is one of the things that the Stuarts had not been able to do. And so when George I comes to the throne, he comes with a ready-made line of succession.

Speaker 3 And that ready-made line of succession owes not necessarily to him because he's, of course, coming without a queen.

Speaker 3 His queen is being kept under house arrest effectively in Germany, but he is coming with the Princess of Wales and that's Caroline and she already has a son.

Speaker 3 So he not only, George I is coming not only with a son who is an adult, but he's coming with a grandson who is in the direct line of succession. And then when Caroline is here,

Speaker 3 she also has daughters, so there are other options. And then she has another, well she has several other sons, but only one who lives, and that's the Duke of Cumberland.

Speaker 3 And so she's actually ensuring that the succession lasts. And there's a wonderful poem, actually, that's written by Joseph Adderson.
And it really picks up exactly this.

Speaker 3 And it's done as a squib, and it's sent out as, you know, printed and published. And just a couple of lines of it.

Speaker 3 And it says, he starts out and he says, no longer shall the widowed land bemoan a broken lineage. and doubtful throne, but boast her progeny's increase and count the pledges of her future peace.

Speaker 3 And that was exactly what they were thinking. This woman, through her maternity, has given us the future.

Speaker 5 Thank you very much. Andreas, in 1714, Sophia died and then Anne died and George I was crowned and obliged to live in London.
How was it supposed to run Hanover from London?

Speaker 6 That was one of the biggest problems of the succession and it was partly a problem because the British politicians were very eager to not make the same mistake as in 1689 when William III brought a lot of Dutch people with him and filled his government with his Dutch advisers.

Speaker 6 So the Act of Settlement said no Germans can be employed within the British government.

Speaker 6 And likewise no British should be employed in Hanoverian government or on the British payroll.

Speaker 5 That sounds as if it's going to be very awkward, then.

Speaker 6 It was very awkward. And it's interesting, before George came across to England, he issued a similar statement in Hanover.
So no British advisers on the Hanoverian payroll.

Speaker 6 And there were really intentions to keep the two governments apart, which was, of course, extremely difficult. So what he did, he set up German chancery in St.

Speaker 6 James's Palace with about eight people, his advisors, and at the same time he gave power to the Privy Council and a few other colleges to rule Hanover. But of course, he limited their powers.

Speaker 6 So for everything more important, they had to come back to him. And that's interesting.
The whole power sharing, so to speak, rested on a very efficient postal system.

Speaker 6 And of course,

Speaker 6 of both sides were suspicions raised that the other side had influence on their affair.

Speaker 6 So there was permanent strife, some friendships, but also a lot of strife between the British on the one hand and the Hanoverans on the other hand. And it had a

Speaker 6 the whole thing had a second level as well.

Speaker 6 Who's really going to pay for this? And George had a very clever system. So for example the costs of the postal system were divided.

Speaker 6 England had to pay to Holland and Hanover paid for the postal stunt from Holland to Hanover.

Speaker 6 But there was also employing eight people in London was slightly above the means of his privy purse in Hanover.

Speaker 6 They were on the payroll in Hanover, but he had to supplement, give them a London allowance and that came out of the English Privy Purse, which was strictly speaking against the Act of Settlement.

Speaker 6 And there are other instances where he found it in the end, in fact, so complicated that as early as 1716, he formulated a will where he recommended the dissolution of the personal union.

Speaker 6 And he wanted to end it. The British...
politicians said, don't do that, that will throw this country back into complete disarray and we will repeat the Stuart's Protestant succession.

Speaker 7 Succession.us. The games are super exciting, and you can actually win.
MyPrize.us is the most fun, free-to-play social casino around. Everyone deserves to win big.

Speaker 7 All the slots and table games you love with incredible bonuses. Sign up today for an incredible welcome package.

Speaker 1 MyPrize.us is a free-to-play social casino. Users must be 18 or older to play.
Void work prohibited by law. Visit myprize.us for more details.

Speaker 7 When you need a break, make it memorable. Visit myprize.us.
Real prizes, real winners, real easy.

Speaker 8 As a sports fan, you want the best way to watch your favorite teams at home. And now, you can experience Game Day in all its glory with a 2025 Samsung Super Big TV.

Speaker 8 It's super big and super clear, giving you a closer view than the sidelines. And you can go big without the blur thanks to Super Size Picture Enhancer.
Select Black Friday deals start now.

Speaker 8 Go big and save big on the ultimate fan-worthy TVs at Samsung.com. Sales dates vary by model.

Speaker 8 Super size picture enhancer utilizes AI-based formulas available on 85-inch and larger TVs on models QN70F and above.

Speaker 1 This is Jacob Goldstein from What's Your Problem.

Speaker 1 Business software is expensive. And when you buy software from lots of different companies, it's not only expensive, it gets confusing, slow to use, hard to integrate.

Speaker 1 Odo solves that because all ODU software is connected on a single affordable platform. Save money without missing out on the features you need.

Speaker 1 Odoo has no hidden costs and no limit on features or data. Odo has over 60 apps apps available for any needs your business might have, all at no additional charge.

Speaker 1 Everything from websites to sales to inventory to accounting, all linked and talking to each other. Check out Odo at odoo.com.
That's odoo.com.

Speaker 5 There was plenty of disorder and array, Mark, around the coronation of George I.

Speaker 5 More than a celebration, wasn't there?

Speaker 1 Yes, indeed. Although rioting, of course, wasn't new.

Speaker 5 What What did the rioters do?

Speaker 1 The rioters were essentially protesting against the coronation but championing the Church of England.

Speaker 1 They saw the Hanoverian succession as giving carte blanche to the dissenting non-conformist communities

Speaker 1 and they saw this as a threat to the Church of England.

Speaker 1 So all that animus that I was talking about earlier on that had been whipped up by Sir Chevreux sort of comes out again with these coronation riots.

Speaker 1 And they attacked over 40 dissenting meeting houses and destroyed them as a sign of their displeasure. That's not to say that there weren't also lots of loyalist demonstrations at the same time.

Speaker 1 And indeed, because Britain was so polarised at this point between these rival camps of Whigs and Tories, dissenters and Church of England people, there was real rivalry.

Speaker 1 So this sort of came to a head at the end of May.

Speaker 1 So the 28th of May was George I's birthday and so there were lots of loyalist celebrations about that, provoking Jacobite, that's the name given to those who are opposing the Hanoverians and supporting a Stuart restoration, provoking them to riot.

Speaker 1 The very next day was a key day for the Jacobite community because the 29th of May marked the accession of the Stuarts, the restoration of the Stuarts in 1660.

Speaker 1 So that gave them an opportunity to come out onto the streets with roses and oak leaves and laurels and so on as a sign of their continuing adherence to the Stuarts.

Speaker 1 So you get these sort of almost festive ritualised moments of contestation between rival groups and they become very, very serious.

Speaker 1 So it's not just at the coronation, but those riots continued into 1715.

Speaker 1 Indeed, they crescendoed in 1715 to the extent that the government had to introduce a special piece of legislation to curb the rioting, the Riot Act, which we still talk about the Riot Act being read to people.

Speaker 1 And that's because the 1715 Riot Act was a warning to the crowds that if they failed to disperse, they could essentially be shot.

Speaker 1 And that had the desired effect eventually, but not before widespread rioting which affected 50 to 60 different towns across England and Wales.

Speaker 5 Was any or many people shot?

Speaker 1 There were not so many people shot but there were numerous arrests, probably about 500 arrests in 1715 to try and clamp down.

Speaker 1 The other thing of course was that the government had very good spy network and it knew about the Jacobite unrest that was being planned and they instituted a number of of arrests to prevent major uprisings in England.

Speaker 5 London sounds to have been in a, and other cities and towns, to be in a sort of controlled uproar.

Speaker 5 Elaine, can you just develop the idea of that 1715 rebellion? Just a little so the listeners are up to speed on it.

Speaker 3 Okay, the best thing to think about with that is that we've had a number of different possibilities already of invasions, of Jacobite invasions, either they're threats. Invasions of England.

Speaker 3 Invasions of England. Where effectively what's been going on all the way through here is there are dynastic concerns and there's a dynastic threat.

Speaker 3 And what we see is that threat trying to be pushed through to actually have a true rebellion, a change of government in 1715, and it fails.

Speaker 3 But in the failing of it, what happens is that the Whigs who come through this next election and who George I is already encouraging people to vote Whig in this election, they come in with a majority and they use their power to actually purge the Tories from power.

Speaker 3 And George I is in favour of this. He has no problem with that.
And this idea that the Tories are out of power, they're out of place, they're out of the court and basically they're in the cold.

Speaker 5 Thank you. Andreas, we had George I straddling Britain and Europe.
Did one benefit more than the other? What was the balance there?

Speaker 6 Well, that was a big question even at the time and it of course concerned the fact that that foreign policy was officially the prerogative of the king, but the act of settlement had already curbed his powers in that respect as well.

Speaker 6 He wasn't allowed to involve the United Kingdom in any war that might primarily benefit Hanover.

Speaker 6 And the split between Tories and Whigs also extended to the different foreign policy aims. And the Tories were a blue-water party.
They wanted a navy and and no standing army.

Speaker 6 The Whigs were more on the side of we need balance of power in Europe for our security as well, especially to end the Jacobite threat as well.

Speaker 6 So, at the time, there was a dispute, historians dispute who has actually profited more.

Speaker 6 Some came out with a compromise. Actually, his foreign policy might have benefited both sides.

Speaker 6 It's clear to begin with, he used the Royal Navy to follow some of his aims in the Great Northern War, because we had not only the War of the Spanish Succession, which ended in 1713, but from 17 to 1720 we had a second major war, which ended with the rise of Russia, but it was against Sweden dominating the Baltic.

Speaker 6 And Britain had, of course, also interests in Baltic trade. They needed a wood and

Speaker 6 navy stores basically from the east, but it's clear that Hanover profited. They got two territories, Verden and Bremen, which they desperately wanted because it gave them access to the sea.

Speaker 6 So the question who benefited most

Speaker 6 is probably until 1716-17 Hanover benefited more.

Speaker 6 And then George realized the opposition in Parliament was so strong against any further major involvement where Hanover might profit more than Britain that he learned his lesson and did respect British interests more.

Speaker 5 Mark, can we take that on a bit? Can we detail the economic impact that the succession had on Great Britain and Ireland?

Speaker 1 Yes, so the Whigs, as the natural supporters of George I

Speaker 1 were delighted because his new regime seemed to guarantee stability and success for the Protestant Empire abroad.

Speaker 1 So the American colonies, for example, which were helping to drive the economy, were very, very supportive of the succession of George.

Speaker 1 And those colonies were beginning to generate income from the slave trade in a very significant way.

Speaker 1 One of the clauses of the peace treaty that had ended that major war with France in 1713 gave a contract to Britain to supply 4,800 slaves per year to the Spanish colonies.

Speaker 1 And that contract was given to a company called the South Sea Company, which became initially quite a successful venture, but then, perhaps, as listeners will be aware, collapsed in very dramatic fashion, very controversial fashion in 1720, causing the first big stock market crash.

Speaker 1 But I think perhaps the other really interesting economic aspect of the Hanoverian succession is actually, again, north of the border in Scotland, because one of the consequences of the Act of Union had been to push up Scottish taxes and the Scots felt very aggrieved at this.

Speaker 1 There was a tax on malt, for goodness sake,

Speaker 1 a tax on salt, and those were deeply resented. So the economic benefits north of the border were not at all as visible as they were south of the border or in the empire as a whole.

Speaker 1 And indeed that resentment and that economic grievance was one of the things that helped to fuel the discontent that broke out in Scotland in 1715.

Speaker 5 Thank you. Elaine, can you tell us about Walpole and his role as Prime Minister and the effect, which is, I think, considerable, but you're going to tell us more than that, that he had?

Speaker 3 Yeah, Walpole is a fascinating character. He's basically coterminous with this period.
He comes into Parliament in 1701, so by the time that George

Speaker 3 has come to the throne, he's quite an experienced player. And he's very articulate, very active, an excellent communicator.

Speaker 3 And what he does is he's able to, first of all, he plays a role in the family itself because of course George I and George II have desperate problems with each other.

Speaker 3 And so one of his roles in actually even coming to power and taking that position is to

Speaker 3 effect a reconciliation between the king and the prince of Wales. And that's really, really important.
And interesting there again, he's working through the women.

Speaker 3 He works through Melissina, George I's mistress, and he works through Caroline, George II's, or Prince of Wales's wife. So he's doing that.

Speaker 3 But also then what he's doing when he comes into Parliament is he's really, he's interested in calming things down, pacifying things, and he's able to take the disaster that is the South Sea bubble and find a strategy through it to be able to protect the king and try and

Speaker 3 sort out the worst of the South Sea bubble impact so that he has the king still on side, he has the king's mistress and his half-sister on side, and he's able to then bring together the Whig schism.

Speaker 3 and have them unite behind him and

Speaker 3 move the country forward in a much more peaceful way.

Speaker 3 He's also, very shortly after that, we will have the Septennial Act, which is in 1716, which is passed, and that stops this rage of party, age of party that Mark was talking about by giving us an extended parliamentary session and that's really important.

Speaker 1 Thank you.

Speaker 5 We've mentioned this but I'd like to go back there again Mark for a moment the impact of the Hanoverian succession on Scotland and Ireland.

Speaker 1 So in Ireland where there was of course a Catholic majority

Speaker 1 the Protestant elite were nevertheless in the ascendant and they had all the levers of power power and so Ireland remained entirely quiet.

Speaker 1 That was a very different picture in Scotland where there was rebellion.

Speaker 1 At the end of 1715 James Francis Edward Stuart is proclaimed James III

Speaker 1 and a series of uprisings occurred in Scotland which initially had

Speaker 1 some success. Big cities like Aberdeen, Dundee were captured.
There was even a Jacobite force that came as far south as Preston. But eventually those Jacobite risings were pushed back and defeated.

Speaker 1 And by the spring of 1716,

Speaker 1 the Jacobite rebellion had largely failed, mainly because it lacked any support from France.

Speaker 1 So there was no invasion force that could have ousted the Hanoverians, no invasion force that could have placed the Stuart regime securely north of the border.

Speaker 1 But also the Jacobites lacked arms, they lacked real organisation, the British Army remained very loyal. So really the odds were stacked against the Jacobites in Scotland.

Speaker 1 There was some residual uprising in the Highlands, but again that was relatively quickly extinguished. But it was a scary moment for the powers in London.

Speaker 1 Sighs of relief I think when that was brought to a close.

Speaker 5 Elaine, what impact did this have on the lives of the general public?

Speaker 3 The succession itself. Impact, I suppose, is difficult to judge, particularly probably if you were a tenant farmer somewhere in Lincolnshire, it probably didn't have a huge amount of impact on you.

Speaker 3 But if you were a member of the landed gentry or if you were a member of the aristocracy and you were playing your cards right, that was if you happened to be a Whig or you had to be Whig aligned, it opened up all kinds of possibilities for you.

Speaker 3 It opened up possibilities for power, for patronage, for preferment, for profit. So

Speaker 3 there were lots of opportunities in that sense. In terms of wider developments, it had implications in various other ways.

Speaker 3 Certainly you have people like Caroline of Ansbach, Queen Caroline later, who's very interested in religion and involved in religious preferments as well, so the involvement in patronage in that way.

Speaker 3 George I is very involved in military, he controls the military patronage effectively, but that's very much his thing.

Speaker 3 And so the people who are wanting military preferment, that is going to be extremely important if you're

Speaker 3 playing on the king's side in that way. But there's also implications for art, for garden design.
Caroline does her own garden following an English pattern and sort of popularizes that.

Speaker 3 She gathers people together who are artists.

Speaker 3 She gathers people together who are writers. This is a period of real ferment and real growth in terms of the arts and literature, in terms of

Speaker 3 popular culture in that sense. We bring in the opera, Italian opera becomes really important.

Speaker 3 Handel and Handel's music comes over. over.
There are all kinds of different aspects to where people could have cultural impact, if not necessarily direct personal impact.

Speaker 1 And Caroline's also really important in inoculation, isn't she? Absolutely. She was spreading the idea that inoculation wasn't dangerous.

Speaker 1 This was a new Enlightenment scientific idea to prevent disease and she was really quite instrumental I think in

Speaker 1 popularizing that.

Speaker 3 She has some of her children inoculated, yes, which was seen as being really dangerous at the time because of course it was

Speaker 3 a live virus that they were using. This is something that was brought over from Turkey by Lady Mary

Speaker 3 Wortley Montagu.

Speaker 1 Yes.

Speaker 6 But it's interesting that in Hanover it took another 100 years to introduce smallpox inoculation. And it just shows how little cross-fertilization

Speaker 6 it was under the French occupation when they started to vaccinate against smallpox.

Speaker 5 Can we go back for a moment at the cultural impact? It was colossal, wasn't it? Handel alone was colossal.

Speaker 3 Oh yeah, yes, very much so. Handel becomes sort of the quintessential English composer.
And

Speaker 3 we think of doing any coronation now, we're thinking of Zadok the Priest. And

Speaker 3 absolutely important there. He's involved in all kinds of things, including things like the involvement in the Foundling Hospital in London.

Speaker 3 And that, again, is something that gets initiated because of the fact that Coram, who has connections to the court, uses the court women to get to Caroline, who then builds on that.

Speaker 3 Now that's later than the Hannoverian succession, but that's part of that kind of wider implication of what's going on.

Speaker 5 And yes, early on there was a great deal of ridiculing of the Hanoverians.

Speaker 5 How bitter was that and when did it die out?

Speaker 6 Of course it was very bitter. The fact that the Licensing Act lapsed and created the opportunity for unique

Speaker 6 critical public sphere was on the one hand wonderful and all proto-liberals

Speaker 6 were fascinated by what happened in England.

Speaker 6 But of course if you're at the receiving end it was a complicated thing and the Hanoverians, but not only the kings, it was also the government, was very much at the receiving end.

Speaker 6 And we can think about

Speaker 6 satires like Swift, Gulliver's Travels, which is a bitter satire on particularly on the Whigs, but also on the king. And then, as from 1720,

Speaker 6 more printed caricatures started to appear.

Speaker 6 The South Sea Bubble was one of the first very successful prints where the king and his government, but also his mistresses, were attacked because they profited partly or they had invested massively.

Speaker 6 But all they could do is basically follow things up through libel, and they partly did that.

Speaker 6 But I think they soon learned that this didn't have the right effect, and they just had to grin and bear it. And it went on

Speaker 6 George II, George III, and basically died down, probably with George IV a bit, but not really.

Speaker 6 All the Georges were subject of ridicule, and behind it, at least at the beginning, was a lot of the Jacobite hate against them.

Speaker 6 They were sort of portrayed as brutes whoring round town and uncivilized people. It's in the background is also the age of politeness where they seem not to fit into that.

Speaker 6 And then of course their foreignness and there was a lot of London xenophobia involved in it.

Speaker 3 Yeah, I think the xenophobia is a really important one, but it's also

Speaker 3 part of what George I gets is the,

Speaker 3 for criticism, comes from sort of sexual criticism because of the fact that when he comes over to England, he's coming with his mistress and long-term mistress, Melissina von den Schulenberg, but he's also coming with his half-sister, Sophia Charlotte von Kielmanseg.

Speaker 3 And the English don't know what to do with these two.

Speaker 3 And they, first of all, they call them the elephant and the maypole, because one is very heavy and one is very thin, and neither of them are seen to be particularly pretty but they also are thinking this this is sexually deviant you know what in the world is going on here are they both his mistresses and so the idea that you know he's a brute he's not very civilized he doesn't like socializing he hides out he doesn't have very good English and he's got all these weird women you know so this is all something that that's used to attack him

Speaker 1 Maybe the French Revolution also salvages some of the Georgian reputation because the challenge from the Republican French means in some way a sort of focal point of attention on the monarchy in Britain and around George III in a way that it hadn't done beforehand and you get a lot of popular enthusiasm for the monarchy not not always that long-lived but that the monarchy becomes a really central institution in the way that it hadn't done before.

Speaker 5 Well thank you very much. Thanks to Elaine Chalice, Mark Nice and Andreas Gestik.
Next week we go to the 12th century for probably the greatest writer of epic romances in Persian, Nizami Ganjavi.

Speaker 5 Thanks for listening.

Speaker 3 And the In Our Time podcast gets some extra time now with a few minutes of bonus material from Melvin and his guests.

Speaker 5 Starting with you Elaine, what would you like to have said you didn't get time to say?

Speaker 3 I suppose the thing I would like to say is we're thinking, sort of expanding a bit more on how people in England actually thought about or learned about what was going on with the Hanoverian Hanoverian succession.

Speaker 3 And I think we could say a little bit more about that because I think it works on multiple levels. And so

Speaker 3 we've got personal stuff going on, people talking to each other, you know, the gossip and the news, the court, socialising, the assemblies, people going back into the local counties and the assize meets and the race meets, going to bath to take the waters.

Speaker 3 All of these places are places where gossip and news are spread. But it's also, and I think we picked up and we touched on this a bit, this is a period of huge amount of development of the press, real

Speaker 3 press activity. And so we've got our first daily newspaper in 1702, the Daily Courant.

Speaker 3 And by 1711, we've got The Tattler, The Spectator, Jonathan Swift's Examiner. They're all there.
They're all publishing. And you've got press in the localities as well.

Speaker 3 So Newcastle, Dublin, the bigger towns all have their own newspapers. And so we're getting the news out there.
And the papers are spreading this news.

Speaker 3 And one of the things that I thought was really interesting when I was doing a little bit of digging around was thinking about the uncertainty that we've talked about in that lead-up, the very lead-up to the actual succession.

Speaker 3 And it's already there in 1712.

Speaker 3 So, for instance, the Newcastle Courant in 1712, June of 1712, leads on its front page with a reprint of the address from the Lord Mayor of London and the Alderman and the Common Councilmen asking the Queen, Queen Anne, to commit publicly to the Hanoverian succession.

Speaker 3 It's that concerning, there's that nervousness. She then, they've got an answer from her then following immediately after that on the page, front page of the paper, saying yes she confirms to it.

Speaker 3 But even three or four pages further in that paper, there's another report, this time from the House of Commons having had a vote.

Speaker 3 to say that they have entire confidence in Her Majesty for ensuring the Protestant succession. This is 1712, two years before, and it's already out there.

Speaker 3 So people are actually learning about what's going on, not only because it's something they talk about and it's something that the Act of Settlement's done, but because of the fact that it's in the press.

Speaker 3 It's there for them. They could read it or they can have it read to them.

Speaker 1 Mark?

Speaker 1 Well very much picking up on that,

Speaker 1 I'm interested in talking more about the press and some of the sort of golden age of political journalism at this time.

Speaker 1 So we heard a little bit about Swift. Swift was extremely active during the reign of Queen Anne.
He was one of the principal propagandists for

Speaker 1 Anne's ministry, of Robert Harley in particular, who recruited him to write for the government, as was Daniel Defoe.

Speaker 1 Daniel Defoe sent as an agent to Scotland in order to cultivate public opinion in Scotland for the Act of Union and producing a lot of propaganda

Speaker 1 and also other

Speaker 1 really important writers like Joseph Addison and Richard Steele, who wrote this incredibly influential periodical called The Spectator.

Speaker 1 Again, articulating the Whig vision. But interestingly, Steele and Addison fall out slightly after the Hanoverian accession.

Speaker 1 Steele is much more of a populist

Speaker 1 than Addison, and he's always banging on about liberty and the rights of the people.

Speaker 1 And Addison is much more interested in order.

Speaker 1 Let's just get everything peaceful.

Speaker 1 And eventually these two

Speaker 1 really able writers who had worked so closely together move further and further apart.

Speaker 1 And they actually have a breach in 1719 when they fall out over another piece of legislation, which they have very, very different views about. It's called the Peerage Act.

Speaker 1 So you get these really interesting dynamics amongst the sort of key journalists. And in some ways that that reflects sort of changing patterns of

Speaker 1 censorship as well. So there isn't a formal censorship in this period after 1695.
But there are all sorts of ways in which the government can clamp down on writers and on publishers.

Speaker 1 And during the Tory

Speaker 1 ascendancy, let's put it like that, between 1710 and 1714, lots of Whig publishers and Whig writers are prosecuted and put out of business and then the pendulum swings the other way and in the early years of George I's reign equally there's a lot of repression of Jacobite newspapers.

Speaker 1 I think 13 Jacobite newspapers are forced to cease publication.

Speaker 1 So there's real control over what's said even without the sort of formal mechanisms of censorship.

Speaker 5 Andres,

Speaker 6 Perhaps I would like to add a little bit to these ongoing debates about the succession in newspapers and in Parliament.

Speaker 6 And it's very interesting that in 1706, I think it was, Electress Sophia tried to come to England. And she wanted to be recognized by Parliament and she also wanted some money.

Speaker 6 But Queen Anne was absolutely against it. She couldn't see eye to eye with Sophia and said it was like looking at her coffin every day, seeing the Hanoverians around the court.

Speaker 6 And similarly, they wanted George, the latest George II and Callai wanted to send her, their son, to England beforehand so that he got a bit of

Speaker 6 English manners or

Speaker 6 and that was rejected as well. So it wasn't

Speaker 6 the possibility of them sort of gradually filtering in was prevented primarily by the court. And

Speaker 6 at the same time, there was Bolenberg in 1710 and others negotiating with the pretender whether he would convert to take over the throne. So everything was open until then, and it was

Speaker 6 most of it was out in the public, and

Speaker 6 people were agitated about it.

Speaker 3 Just to pick up on that as well, when Sophia Sophia plays that game effectively, and it's a game that's played with the Tories, and the Tories are using that as a political trick to get the Whigs into a bad spate.

Speaker 3 And I think that's really interesting because it brings us back to the kind of politics we have nowadays, where

Speaker 3 the idea of issuing this invitation to

Speaker 3 Sophia to come to England is if the Whigs had disapproved of that, if they vote against it, well then

Speaker 3 they're going to support the Queen, but they're going to look like they don't support the Hanoverian succession. And so you've got some really interesting maneuvering going on.

Speaker 3 But what you do get that comes out of that a little later on is the Regency Act.

Speaker 3 And that's one of the things I think we hadn't actually talked about is how do you ensure that we have a peaceful, smooth line of succession.

Speaker 3 And what they've done is, what we get is we get the passage of the Regency Act, which basically says government's going to go on as it was for the next six months, if necessary, until the king gets here.

Speaker 3 And we we will basically hold everything more or less till then. And that works.
And of course, one of the key things about the succession is it is peaceful, it is smooth.

Speaker 3 And George doesn't actually arrive until September, what, 18th or something like that. And Anne had died on the 1st of August.

Speaker 3 So there's a period there where effectively we could have had chaos, all kinds of chaos, and we don't.

Speaker 5 Well, our producer Salmon Tillerson is about to enter.

Speaker 1 Does anyone want tea or coffee?

Speaker 1 Melvin?

Speaker 5 I think I'll try a cup of coffee, Brad.

Speaker 6 a check.

Speaker 3 Melvin? Coffee black.

Speaker 1 Tea, please.

Speaker 6 Tea.

Speaker 1 Thank you very much. Thank you.
In Our Time with Melvin Bragg is produced by Simon Tillotson and it's a BBC Studios audio production.

Speaker 9 What happens when at-home DNA tests reveal more than you bargained for?

Speaker 1 My birth mum was still here. She's still alive.
Six new stories of reconnecting and rupturing families.

Speaker 3 I just couldn't believe it.

Speaker 1 I...

Speaker 3 I had a sister after all.

Speaker 9 Lives Lives upended and long buried secrets.

Speaker 1 I then wrote back and said, look, the ripples from this will be enormous. What do you want to do?

Speaker 9 The new series of The Gift with me, Jenny Kleeman, from BBC Radio 4. Listen now on BBC Sounds.

Speaker 4 It's time your hard-earned money works harder for you. With the Wealthfront Cash account, your uninvested cash earns a 3.5% APY, which is higher than the average savings rate.

Speaker 4 No account fees, no minimums, and free instant withdrawals to eligible accounts anytime. Join over a million people who trust Wealthfront to build wealth at wealthfront.com.

Speaker 4 Cash account offered by Wealthfront Brokerage LLC, member FINRA SIPC, and is not a bank. APY on deposits as of November 7th, 2025, is representative, subject to change, and requires no minimum.

Speaker 4 Funds are swept to program banks where they earn the variable APY. It's time your hard-earned money works harder for you.

Speaker 4 With the Wealthfront Cash Account, your uninvested cash earns a 3.5% 3.5% APY, which is higher than the average savings rate.

Speaker 4 No account fees, no minimums, and free instant withdrawals to eligible accounts anytime. Join over a million people who trust Wealthfront to build wealth at wealthfront.com.

Speaker 4 Cash account offered by Wealthfront Brokerage LLC, member FINRA SIPC, and is not a bank. APY on deposits as of November 7th, 2025 is representative, subject to change, and requires no minimum.

Speaker 4 Funds are swept to program banks where they earn the variable APY.