The 'Crypto Wizard' vs. Nigeria

Speaker 1 This message comes from Capital One Commercial Bank. Access comprehensive solutions from a top commercial bank that prioritizes your needs today and goals for tomorrow.

Speaker 1 Learn more at capitalone.com/slash commercial. Member FDIC.
Heads up, this episode has a few curse words in it.

Speaker 2 This is Planet Money from NPR.

Speaker 1 There is this video that I've not been able to stop thinking about since I first saw it.

Speaker 1 It's a short video, just 39 seconds long, of a bearded man with a tight haircut, a white t-shirt, and a gold chain.

Speaker 1 And he is filming himself selfie style, but he seems to be holding the phone at this weird angle, as if he's trying to hide it from someone.

Speaker 3 Hello, my name is Sigrun Gambarian. I'm the head of financial crime compliance for Binance.

Speaker 3 I've been detained by the Nigerian government. for a month.
I don't know what's going to happen to me after today.

Speaker 1 If this is ringing a bell, it first made the rounds last spring.

Speaker 3 So I've got nothing wrong. I asked the United States government to assist me.

Speaker 3 I need your help, guys. I don't know if I'll be able to get out of this without your help.
Please help.

Speaker 1 Then the video just ends.

Speaker 1 It's haunting. I first heard about this guy and this video from legendary reporter Dina Temple Rastin.
Hey, Dina. Hey, there.

Speaker 1 Dina, you've been following this story, the story of Tigrin Gambarian, since day one.

Speaker 2 Yeah, I knew Tigrin. He's a former IRS investigator.
He's American, and I had interviewed him for a bunch of stories.

Speaker 2 So I found out pretty quickly that he'd been detained in Nigeria, and I thought they'd hold him for a couple of weeks. I had no idea that it was going to become such a saga.

Speaker 1 Yeah, and that saga is our episode today. Hello and welcome to Planet Money.
I'm Nick Fountain.

Speaker 2 And I'm Dina Temple Rastin, the host of Click Here, a cyber and intelligence podcast.

Speaker 1 Tigrin's story is about more than one man in a notorious Nigerian prison.

Speaker 1 It's about how people in places without stable economies have found refuge in cryptocurrency, how crypto can undermine state power, and how that state power fights back.

Speaker 2 So today, that story from Tigrin, himself. We landed the first recorded interview with him since his release.
And now we know all the details of his eight months in captivity and how he got out.

Speaker 1 Oh my gosh, you look great.

Speaker 1 So we're doing the same thing. Hey, how you doing? You look great.
It's good to see you, David.

Speaker 1 This message comes from Vanguard. Capturing value in the bond market is not easy.
That's why Vanguard offers a suite of over 80 institutional quality bond funds.

Speaker 1 actively managed by a 200-person global team of sector specialists, analysts, and traders.

Speaker 1 They're designed for financial advisors looking to give their clients consistent results year in and year out. See the record at vanguard.com slash audio.
That's vanguard.com slash audio.

Speaker 1 All investing is subject to risk. Vanguard Marketing Corporation, distributor.
This message comes from Capital One. Say hello to stress-free subscription management.

Speaker 1 Easily track, block, or cancel recurring charges right from the Capital One mobile app. Simple as that.
Learn more at capitalone.com/slash subscriptions. Terms and conditions apply.

Speaker 2 Let me tell you a little bit about Tigrin Gambarian. He's this Armenian-American guy, super smart, really easygoing.
The type of person who has a squat rack and a gaming chair at home.

Speaker 2 And a few weeks ago, I went to visit him at his house about an hour outside of Atlanta. Should we take off shoes? I'm sure.

Speaker 1 Are you guys hungry?

Speaker 1 No, thank you. Some backstory? Tigrin made his name working for the IRS.
He was a special agent there, a financial investigator. And he focused on investigating cryptocurrency and cyber cases.

Speaker 2 And Tigrin is a legend in this world. Before him, just about everyone in law enforcement thought crypto transactions were anonymous, totally untraceable.

Speaker 2 In fact, that's exactly why criminals in particular seemed to love it. They saw it as a way to commit a crime and leave no fingerprints.

Speaker 1 But Tigrin suspected that these transactions were not as anonymous as people thought.

Speaker 1 So, night after night, with his infant daughter on his lap, he stared at long strings of letters and numbers, trying to figure out a way to follow transactions from one place to another.

Speaker 1 And through just determination, he was able to do it. He was able to trace transactions.

Speaker 2 This completely revolutionized high-tech crime fighting. He was involved in just about every crypto-related bust or investigation in the 2010s.
Alpha Bay, Mt. Gox, those were him.
Silk Road?

Speaker 2 Yeah, him too. When I was reporting on this and calling around law enforcement circles, people kept telling me Tigran figured out how to track all this.
They even called him the Bitcoin wizard.

Speaker 1 And over the next decade, he became kind of this evangelist for crypto.

Speaker 1 He believed that if done correctly, crypto could solve a lot of the problems in the financial system and maybe be more transparent than traditional banks.

Speaker 1 And so in 2021, Tigrin decided to leave government and take his talents to the largest cryptocurrency platform in the world, a company called Binance.

Speaker 1 Binance is what's called an exchange, basically a place to buy or sell crypto. And it had this kind of sketchy reputation as a place for money launderers and criminals.

Speaker 2 He was hired as the global head of intelligence and investigations, which meant working with law enforcement across the world, showing them the ways in which he tracked crypto transactions.

Speaker 2 So, in many ways, his job at Binance wasn't that different than what he was doing at the IRS.

Speaker 4 I don't handle business. I don't handle

Speaker 4 any products. My whole core duties, and which is all I do, is assist law enforcement.

Speaker 1 So, officially, Tecran was hired to help with law enforcement and compliance. But unofficially, he was sort of an ambassador for Binance and for crypto itself.
He was there to send the message.

Speaker 1 Crypto's Wild West days were over. That shady stuff Binance was doing was in the past.
Today's Binance is law-abiding and we're here to help.

Speaker 2 Which is why in February of last year, he found himself in Nigeria. He was there to meet top government and law enforcement officials.

Speaker 4 We agreed to go out there and meet with them, be like, okay, you know what? If you need anything, just to kind of even, you know, go above and beyond and help them out.

Speaker 1 Now, Nigeria, as a country, has a complicated relationship with crypto. By the time Tigrin Tigrin had arrived last year, their currency, the Naira, had been through years of turmoil.

Speaker 1 They had unpegged the Naira from the U.S. dollar.
Inflation had been high, like 30% annually. And so people had been buying up crypto as a kind of store of value.

Speaker 1 Instead of putting savings at a bank, they would buy Bitcoin or Ethereum. In 2024, Nigeria had the second largest cryptocurrency adoption rate in the world.

Speaker 2 For the Nigerian government, the rapid adoption of crypto meant less control.

Speaker 2 As more people started using Binance to trade Naira, the central bank's hold on the value of their currency felt like it was slipping away.

Speaker 2 And so they were starting to blame crypto for a lot of the country's economic problems.

Speaker 1 Which brings us back to Tigran. Tigran's trip to Nigeria was going to be quick, just a few days of back-to-back meetings.
He didn't even check a bag.

Speaker 2 The most important meeting was at the big law enforcement intelligence agency in Nigeria known as the National Security Agency, or NSA. Tigran was excited about the meeting, but when he showed up.

Speaker 4 They're like, oh, just come in to sit down. They'll come in in a little bit.
We waited for a couple of hours.

Speaker 2 Were you worried that you were waiting that long?

Speaker 4 It started getting a little weird.

Speaker 2 Tegram was there with a colleague named Nadeem Anjawala. Nadeem was younger.
He wasn't a former cop. He was more like Binance's business guy for Africa.

Speaker 1 And the two of them were waiting to meet with the head of the NSA to talk through how Binance and Nigeria could work better together. But that meeting never happened.

Speaker 1 Instead, eventually a bunch of Nigerian officials filed into the room. None of them were really making eye contact with Tigran or Nadim.

Speaker 1 And when the meeting did start, Tigrin realized it was not what they signed up for.

Speaker 4 One of the guys who's actually responsible for this

Speaker 4 comes in, kind of slaps a folder on the table, starts saying, you know, you've, you know, destroyed the Nigerian economy.

Speaker 2 The Nigerian authorities told them that Binance had tanked their currency, that they had laundered money, and that they had evaded taxes.

Speaker 1 According to Tigran, they basically said, we are not going to let you leave until we are satisfied that Binance is on the up and up.

Speaker 1 Among other things, they said they wanted Binance to pay those taxes and also some fines. And they said they wanted more control over the platform, including information on Binance's users.

Speaker 4 We want a user record for every single Nigerian user. Until that's done, you can't leave.

Speaker 2 We reached out to the Nigerian authorities for this story. They declined to comment.

Speaker 2 What we do know is that the Nigerian government has a history of being quick to find companies and seize their assets. But Binance had no assets to seize or to hold as collateral.

Speaker 2 In a sense, Tigran and Nadim became collateral.

Speaker 1 And where might the Nigerian government have gotten the idea of detaining someone from Binance and slapping them with enormous fines?

Speaker 2 We do have some breaking breaking news on a major crypto company, Binance.

Speaker 5 The CEO.

Speaker 1 Oh, yeah, it was us, the U.S.

Speaker 6 We are here today to announce that the Justice Department has secured felony guilty pleas from the world's largest cryptocurrency exchange.

Speaker 2 A few months before Tigrim was detained in Nigeria, the U.S. Justice Department announced this huge case against Binance.
They'd been investigating the company for years.

Speaker 2 And they announced that they had reached a plea deal with the founder and former CEO, a guy named Cheng Peng Zhao, also known as CZ.

Speaker 2 And he and the company agreed to plead guilty to a bunch of federal charges, including flouting anti-money laundering laws and violations of the U.S. Bank Secrecy Act.
They were fined $4.3 billion.

Speaker 6 This is one of the largest penalties we have ever obtained from a corporate defendant in a criminal matter.

Speaker 1 The announcement rocked the crypto world. And yeah, it might have planted an idea in the minds of Nigerian officials.

Speaker 2 Back in Nigeria, Tigrin and the business guy Nadim told officials, we're not top finance executives. We can't pay that fine.
We can't release that user data. That's way above our pay grade.

Speaker 2 And Nigerian officials were like, okay, then, call your bosses, because until that gets cleared up, we're keeping you here in Nigeria.

Speaker 1 Authorities took them to a safe house in the capital. Apparently, the conditions there weren't all that bad.
Tigran had access to a phone. He could talk to a lawyer.

Speaker 1 Nadim convinced the guards to buy satellite TV so they could watch movies. And the food, Tigrin says, it was good.

Speaker 4 There was a cook that was assigned to the house. Nadim was like ridiculous the whole time.
It was, it was crazy. He would like make crazy requests.
He kept asking for like smoothies in the morning.

Speaker 4 The cook would make him like two smoothies, like an avocado smoothie and whatever.

Speaker 1 Weeks passed like this. Not much action, a lot of smoothies.
Tigrin took to push-ups and pull-ups to stay fit and take the edge off his anxiety.

Speaker 1 But Nadeem was getting more and more freaked out, and Tigrin tried to comfort him.

Speaker 2 And then one day, about a month after they were detained, things took a turn. Tigrin went to Nadeem's room.

Speaker 4 It was dark, the lights were out, so I went up and knocked on his door. He didn't answer.

Speaker 2 He opened the door.

Speaker 4 I was like, Nadeem, Nadeem, are you there? No response. I just see, you know, just a mountain of like blankets and like pillows.
And I'm like, there's a foot sticking out from underneath the blanket.

Speaker 4 I pulled it off. It was, he stuffed the water bottle inside a sock, put it there.
So.

Speaker 2 Oh my God. Yeah.

Speaker 1 Nadeem had escaped. And Tigrin says, at this moment, he felt his heart sink.
For weeks, he and Nadeem had been in this together. He thought, surely Nadeem had at least left an explanation.

Speaker 1 But when Tigrin looked around for a note, he couldn't find one.

Speaker 2 And in this moment, Tigrin realized it was going to be just him, all by himself, against the government of Nigeria.

Speaker 4 When

Speaker 1 He knew he had, what, minutes before the guards figured out that Nadim had escaped. And he knew that once that happened, all hell would break loose.

Speaker 1 At the very least, he'd probably lose access to his phone and the world.

Speaker 2 So he tiptoed out to the courtyard where no one could overhear him, and he pulled out that phone and hit record.

Speaker 3 Hello, my name is Siegran Gambarian. I'm the head of Financial Crime Compliance.

Speaker 1 This was that haunting video that made the rounds.

Speaker 3 I'll be able to get out of this without your help. Please help.

Speaker 2 Two days after he sent that video, Nigerian authorities started officially charging Tigrin with tax evasion.

Speaker 2 They also said he was complicit in helping Binance launder $35.4 million in illegal transactions, and that Binance was operating without a license.

Speaker 1 And once he was arraigned, he was not sent back to the guest house with the satellite TV and the chef. This time, his treatment was much worse.

Speaker 4 They treated me like Hannibal Lecter when they're transporting me. It was ridiculous.
Like two trucks full of people with rifles, one in the front and one in the back. It was insane.

Speaker 1 The prison he ended up in is infamous. It's called Kuja.
It's where Nigeria puts ISIS militants. It's actually one of the largest prisons in Nigeria.

Speaker 2 Tigrim wasn't put in general population. He wasn't going to be bunking with some ISIS guy.
He got his own cell.

Speaker 4 It was just a cell with no air conditioning,

Speaker 4 nothing.

Speaker 1 Cockroaches.

Speaker 4 There was a mattress and a ton of cockroaches just everywhere, just like infestation.

Speaker 2 By then, the authorities had taken away his phone. But as he looked around him, it looked like all the prisoners had their own phones.
And he said, how do I get me one of those?

Speaker 2 And the first night he was there, he gets an opportunity to buy one.

Speaker 4 One of the guard comes in, didn't ask. He just opens the door, sits down in bed, and says, like, I'll sell you a phone for $25,000.
I'm like,

Speaker 4 what? It's like, yeah, you're a Binance executive. You're a billionaire.
You can afford this.

Speaker 4 I'm like, I'm sorry. You got that wrong guy.
He's like, okay, fine, $5,000. I'm like, no, I'm like, I'm not a billionaire.

Speaker 1 Yeah.

Speaker 1 It was at this moment that Tigrin starts to realize that while he was locked away, the Nigerian government had been painting this picture of him as not only the cause of all of Nigeria's money problems, the inflation, the speculation, but also as a billionaire, an evil one, and a crook.

Speaker 1 How was Tigran gonna get out of here? That is after the break.

Speaker 5 This message comes from Apple Card. AppleCard members can earn unlimited daily cash back on everyday purchases wherever they shop.

Speaker 5 This means you could be earning daily cash on just about anything, like a slice of pizza or a latte from the corner coffee shop.

Speaker 5 Apply for Apple Card and the Wallet app to see your credit limit offer in minutes.

Speaker 5 Subject to credit approval, AppleCard issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA, Salt Lake City Branch, terms and more at Applecard.com.

Speaker 5 This message comes from BetterHelp. President Fernando Madera describes how BetterHelp Online Therapy has helped him.

Speaker 7 For me, sometimes I just need to go and talk to somebody that is not going to judge me, right? It's going to be there and going to listen to me.

Speaker 7 And I can't start just saying, look, I'm not feeling right today. And it feels natural.

Speaker 5 I love it.com slash NPR for 10% off your first month.

Speaker 1 Support for this podcast comes from GMC. At GMC, ignorance is the furthest thing from bliss.

Speaker 1 Bliss is research, testing, testing the testing, until it results results in not just one truck, but a whole lineup.

Speaker 1 The GMC Sierra lineup, featuring the Sierra 1500, the Sierra Heavy Duty, and the all-electric Sierra EV. Because true bliss is removing every shadow from every doubt.
GMC, we are professional grade.

Speaker 1 Visit gmc.com to learn more. This message comes from Kachava.
Sometimes people stock their fridge with good intentions, only to have their future self sacrifice nutrition for convenience.

Speaker 1 Keep your body and mind nourished with whole body meal shakes from Kachava. It's got 25 grams of protein, 6 grams of fiber, greens, and so much more, but it actually tastes delicious.

Speaker 1 Try one of Kachava's indulgent flavors today. Shop now through December 2nd to get 30% off your first purchase of two or more bags.
Go to cachava.com and use code NPR.

Speaker 1 Eventually, Tigrin did get a phone and he was able able to talk with his family. He says he spent hours on video calls with his 10-year-old daughter.

Speaker 1 They'd talk while she played video games late into the night. And on those calls, he says he tried to pretend things were normal, that he was just on a long business trip.

Speaker 1 But later, he found out that she'd known all along. She'd Googled him.

Speaker 2 Months go by. And even though Tigrin's a strong-willed person, spending that long in a seedy prison cell started to wear him down.
Not just mentally, but physically.

Speaker 4 I just can't believe that, like, I'm still here. You know, it's, I just spent my, you know, 40th birthday in

Speaker 4 Nigerian prison, for God's sake.

Speaker 2 And then one morning, he wakes up feeling sick.

Speaker 4 It feels kind of like food poisoning. So, when the next thing I know, I'm throwing up.

Speaker 1 In May, about three months into his detention, Tigrin got malaria. Pretty common in Nigeria.
It's treatable. Like a bad flu, but worse.
But if it is not treated, it can be debilitating, even deadly.

Speaker 1 And Tigrin was not getting good care. His malaria led to pneumonia.
Eventually, he became bedridden, and that aggravated some of his back problems. He ended up unable to walk.

Speaker 1 He needed a wheelchair to get around.

Speaker 2 But according to Tigrin, when he was in public for court appearances, Nigerian officials wouldn't let him use the wheelchair.

Speaker 2 There were local journalists showing up, and he said officials thought pictures of him in a wheelchair would be bad press and show that he wasn't being taken care of.

Speaker 1 Yeah, there's this incredible video from last September. Tigran is in this echoey courthouse hallway with a single crutch.
He's struggling to walk, and he's getting more and more frustrated.

Speaker 1 Because there is a guard in brown fatigues trying to get him into a courtroom.

Speaker 1 But when Tigrin keeps reaching for the guard's hands, the guy will not help. Every few steps, Tigrin has to rest against the wall.

Speaker 2 This video, showing how much Tigrin's health had declined, made it onto social media. And it seemed to shift things in his favor.

Speaker 1 Yeah, but the key thing that turned the tide for Tigrin was when Nigerian prosecutors actually started to lay out their case against him in court filings.

Speaker 4 The only evidence that they had in my charging documents was my business card that said I was head of the global intelligence investigations.

Speaker 4 In my entire charging records against me, my business card is the only evidence in

Speaker 1 Tigrin was expecting the Nigerian prosecutors to at least have gone through the motions of building a case against him.

Speaker 1 But instead, what they had tying Tigrin to these alleged crimes was a single sheet of paper, a photocopy of his business card.

Speaker 1 And that, that was the moment, it seems, that Tigrin's case really changed for the U.S. government.

Speaker 2 Yeah, the whole time Tigrin had been detained in Nigeria, I'd been calling sources at the Justice Department, the White House, and even one high-level State Department official saying, what are you doing to get this guy out?

Speaker 2 They wouldn't go into detail, and they weren't authorized to speak on the record, but I got the impression that they were dragging their feet. Maybe because the U.S.
saw Nigeria as a partner?

Speaker 2 Maybe because, at first blush, Nigeria's case against Tigrin seemed so much like the U.S.'s own case against Binance.

Speaker 2 But after prosecutors submitted their evidence, it became clear that Nigeria's case against Tigrin was nothing like the one the U.S. had brought against CZ, the founder of Binance.
The U.S.

Speaker 2 case was years in the making. They had reams of evidence, emails, voice messages, transactions.
Nigeria had none of that. And when this came out, U.S.
officials seemed to kick it up a notch.

Speaker 1 The U.S. strategy to get Tigrin out was, it seems, Pretty simple, a full court diplomatic press.
For months, U.S.

Speaker 1 officials were told to bring up Tigrin at the beginning of every meeting they had with Nigerian officials, with the foreign minister, the finance minister, the national security advisor, but also the minister of culture, the minister of sports.

Speaker 1 And this strategy went all the way to the top, all the way to then-President Joe Biden.

Speaker 2 According to four people close to the case, Biden was scheduled to meet with Nigeria's President Tanubu. That was last September at the UN General Assembly in New York.
And U.S.

Speaker 2 officials had signaled that Biden was going to raise Tigrin's case in those meetings.

Speaker 2 And according to my sources, President Tanubu ended up skipping the entire UN General Assembly, maybe to avoid the embarrassment of that meeting.

Speaker 1 Tigrin's health, meanwhile, continued to deteriorate. And eventually, the pressure, or maybe the embarrassment, became too much.

Speaker 1 The Nigerian government announced they were going to release Tigrin on humanitarian grounds. They said they were just releasing him so that he could get medical care.

Speaker 1 Binance set a private plane to pick up Tigrin. They flew him to Rome.
And then he took a commercial flight back to the U.S.

Speaker 1 All told, he spent about eight months in detention. He's still recovering from the medical issues related to getting malaria.
And he still works at Binance.

Speaker 1 By the way, we did reach out to Binance for this story, and they did not respond to our questions about Tigrin.

Speaker 2 For now, he's no longer running the investigations team. He was away for so long, they brought in someone else to do the job, temporarily.

Speaker 2 Tigrin initially went to Nigeria to help the government use crypto for their law enforcement efforts. But that project is pretty much dead.

Speaker 2 Tigrin says Binance doesn't cooperate with Nigerian officials anymore. Neither do many other crypto companies.
People in Nigeria are still using crypto, but now it's back to the Wild West.

Speaker 2 And Tigrin is kind of over helping them change that.

Speaker 2 Would you ever go back to Nigeria?

Speaker 4 I don't think my wife wife would let me go back to Nigeria once.

Speaker 1 Or like outside the house.

Speaker 1 By the way, Tigrin and Nadeem haven't spoken since Nadeem escaped. We did reach out to Nadeem.
He didn't get back to us.

Speaker 1 But as for what happened to him, Tigrin suspects that he hopped the guesthouse wall, got an Uber to the airport, and caught the first flight out. He had a second passport.

Speaker 2 In November, Nadeem sent Tigrin an email saying he wanted to explain why he left and why he did what he did. Tigran waited two months to respond.

Speaker 2 And when he did, he basically said, I don't have that much to say to you. You could have at least given me a heads up.
I almost died in that prison.

Speaker 1 When I said that Dina is a legend, I meant it.

Speaker 1 We worked in the same office for a few years and I learned so much from her by osmosis, by watching how she reports, and I'll admit it now to you, Dina, by eavesdropping on your phone conversations.

Speaker 1 If you want to hear more stories like this one, you can check out Dina's show. It's called Click Here.
It comes from Recorded Future News.

Speaker 1 This episode of Planet Money was produced by Emma Peasley and Sean Powers. It was edited by Jess Jang.
It was fact-checked by Sierra Wadez and engineered by Cena Lafredo.

Speaker 1 Alex Goldmark is our executive producer. Special thanks to the great Karen Duffin.

Speaker 2 I'm Dina Temple Rustin.

Speaker 1 And I'm Nick Fountain. This is NPR.
Thank you for listening.

Speaker 5 This message comes from Shipbob. Nothing ruins your holiday faster than the customer emails like, where's my order? Or worst of all, why can't you deliver by Christmas?

Speaker 5 But peak doesn't have to be chaotic when Shipbob's in your corner.

Speaker 5 Shipbob helps brands like Our Place, Bloom Nutrition, and Tony's win the holidays with reliable, scalable, fast, and cost-effective fulfillment. Make this your best holiday season yet with Shipbob.

Speaker 5 Go to shipbob.com slash NPR for a free quote.