#538 - Dead With No Head - Kingman, Kansas

Hey, everybody. Just going to take a quick break from the show to tell you a little bit about a delicious dog food, Ollie.
If your dog could talk, they'd want Ollie. They'd ask you for Ollie.
That's what I'm talking about. It's a fresh whole food diet.
It's not just delicious. It can add, like, years to your puppy's life.
Yeah. You want that good, healthy food that's more tail wagging.
And this is. This is real food.
Like, this stuff looks good. I'd eat it.
Yeah. That's how I was like, this looks pretty good.
I might sit down with you on the floor and you could share. It is nice to be able to pop something down on the floor for him that looks like something that you'd put over rice or whatever and eat it yourself.
That's what I mean. It looks great.
All you need to do, you fill out their 30 second quiz that Ollie has for you. They create a customized meal plan based on your puppy's weight and activity level and health info in general there.
You get expert recommendations. Dogs deserve the best, and that means fresh, healthy food.
Head to ollie.com slash STM. Tell them all about your dog and use code STM to get 60% off your welcome kit when you subscribe today.
Plus, they offer a clean bowl guarantee on the first box. So if you're not completely satisfied, you'll get your money back.
That's O-L-L-I-E dot com slash STM and enter code STM to get 60% off your first box. Now back to the show.
Hi, this is Steve Buscemi. You know, the actor.
Well, now I'm an actor and podcast host.

From piece of work entertainment and campsite media

in association with Olive Productions

comes Big Time, an Apple original podcast.

Each episode follows the story of one misfit with big dreams

who isn't afraid to bend a few rules

or take a shortcut to get there.

Well, who steals bees?

I was duped.

I shoot you in the leg. This is Big time.
Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts. If you're a parent or share a fridge with someone, Instacart is about to make grocery shopping so much easier.
Because with family carts, you can share a cart with your partner and each add the items you want. Since between the two of you, odds are you'll both remember everything you need.
And this way, you'll never have to eat milkless cereal again. So minimize the stress

of the weekly shop with family carts. Download the Instacart app and get delivery in as fast

as 30 minutes. Plus, enjoy $0 delivery fees on your first three orders.
Service fees apply.

For three orders in 14 days. Excludes restaurants.
Hello and welcome back to Small Town Murder Express. Yay and choo-choo! Oh, yay indeed, Jimmy.
Yay indeed. My name is James Petrogallo.
I'm here with my co-host. I'm Jimmy Wissman.
Thank you folks so much for joining us all aboard the murder train, pulling away from the station. We have a wild episode tonight.
And again, it's going to be a lot of murder stuffed into a small amount of space. So it's good stuff.
We'll get to it very quickly. First of all, head over to shutupandgivememurder.com.
There you go. Tickets for live shows, number one.
Tickets to the virtual live show, though. There we go.
That is what you need to do. October 30th, virtual live show, Halloween-themed, crazy, spooky story, just like a regular live show, except you're in your living room.
Everything, the screen, the jokes, the story, it's all just like a regular live show. And we're wearing costumes, too.
There you go. It's gonna be great.
And that's available for two weeks after we do it, too. So you can buy it later.
You can buy it ahead of time. You can watch it 30 times.
You can do whatever you want with it for two weeks. Enjoy it.
Shutupandgivememurder.com. Also, patreon.com slash crime in sports is where you get all of your bonus material everything anybody five dollars a month or above which is a damn value it's a cup of coffee you get hundreds of back episodes you've never heard before a bonus stuff and then new ones every other week to one crime in sports one small town murder and you get it all let's every bit of it this week for crime and sports we're going to talk about that vince mcmahon documentary yeah not the wrestling part the other parts the the parts that what the fuck i am perplexed about from the moment he said it to to now and uh then for small town murder we are going to finish up ted bundy's psychological assessment of 1976 to find out if Ted Bundy's a violent person.

It's hilarious. Yeah.
Him doing those pictures and trying to analyze those pictures is hilarious to me. So we'll get into all that.
Patreon.com slash crime in sports is where you get that. That said, I think it's time, everybody.
No time to waste here. Let's all sit back, clear the lungs here, and let's all shout back clear the lungs here and let's all shout shut up and give me murder let's do this everybody okay let's go on a trip shall we let's go we're going to kansas yeah yeah still still excited yes we're going to kansas everyone okay uh we're going to south central kansas yeah the hardest part of kansas right in south central it is watts kansas watts kansas compton kansas we're going to it is uh 50 minutes to wichita so almost an hour a lot of the people that live here commute to wichita that's the the jobs here three Three hours to Edgerton, Kansas, which was our last Kansas episode.

Episode 489, Psycho Stepmom, one of my favorite of all time titles there.

This is in Kingman County.

It's Kingman and Kingman.

And it is area code 620.

A little bit of history here, quickly.

Did we say that's the name of the town?

What's the name of the town? Kingman, Kingman. I didn't say it.
It's Kingman, Kansas. Yeah.
That's where we are here. Kingman.
Kingman was laid out in 1874. That's when they did.
It was named, just like the county, for Samuel A. Kingman, who was a chief justice of the Kansas Supreme Court, and, of course, a hero to all young boys.
I mean, I had, when I was a kid, I had like, you know, like your Michael Jordan poster. And you got your all that.
You're like your He-Man figures when you're little. And then you also, of course, of course, have the life size Chief Justice of the Kansas Supreme Court Samuel A.
Kingman coin bank that you keep in the corner of your room. With the Kung Fu grip on the gavel.
It's important. It's important.
That's the good model. Cheap parents didn't get the Kung Fu grip.
You save five bucks. But I mean, really, you got to have the gavel grip in there.
Gavel grip. Gavel grip.
Kingman is known, apparently far and wide, they say on their website, as the town with plenty of soft spring water. How about that?

I just heard of it.

That's it's been,

it's been quoted.

I guess they've talked about it since 1940 about how great their water is in 1904.

There was a vote of 276 to 37 to approve a proposition that gave 35,000 in bonds to build waterworks. So this guy named John Hoover dug, he just started digging.
Yeah. He got a shovel and just started fucking digging until he hit water pretty much.
It was like, here is where it goes. And he dug the wells near where the light plant is now, where the electricity thing is, and found good water at 35 feet apparently nice work 35 he imagine digging 35 feet into the earth yeah but 35 feet is mad shallow it is good water but at 20 feet i'm like there's no water here i think keep going this isn't working you're over halfway i swear nope this is 20 feet's enough i i can't i can't even get out of this fucking hole.
You've got to get a rope to get me out of here, I think. He dug 35 feet.
35 feet. Reviews of this town.
Here we go. Four stars.
There's no five-star reviews to this town, by the way. Okay.
Four stars. Kingman is a small town with potential growth.
Yeah. Is it really? It's a great place to raise a family.
Down fall is there's not much available to entertain kids so it's not a great place to raise a family that would not be part of a place to raise a family it's a great place to raise bored children yes raise children who stare at ipads that's what this is uh three stars my hometown is not perfect no places and they i have to give credit to this reviewer because we always make fun of terrible over-the-top bad grammar this person correctly used a semicolon i'm impressed right good for you we still have some problems like teen alcohol use and small-scale drug use i.e marijuana oh no the kids are on the kids are on the? Is that what you're telling me? Oh, no.

A little bit of weed, a little bit of alcohol underage, and that's

the downfall? Wait, wait. Not teenagers.

No. Let me get this

straight. Teenagers are drinking alcohol and

smoking weed?

No. I don't buy it.
I can't imagine.

I don't buy it for a moment. The town has

little in means of entertainment,

which leads to the issues previously

mentioned. Yeah, they're bored.
What are you going to do? It's a great place to start a family, raise small children, and retire. So those are different things, though.
What about the time after your kids aren't small, but before you retire? You know, that 40 years, what do you do then? What about that really hard part of your life? You know, that whole part of your where you like live your entire life and stuff? That part?

What happens there?

People are kind and helpful.

Our school has community service days

every year. Like all small towns, the

older generations have a hard time letting

go of older ideals

and learning not to judge.

Them kids with their marijuana. I don't

like it. Bastards.
A large percentage

of people my age want to travel and experience more than simple small town life, myself included. Despite all of this, I would come back and maybe raise my own children here.
Make them just as bored as I am. That'd be great.
This place made me who I am. It's my home.
It sure is. It made you who you are, someone who uses semicolons correctly.
So this is a good school district i'm going to say uh three stars here crime is not too high but disturbing that most of the crimes committed are done by teens is that disturbing is that disturbing get a bowling alley what the fuck is wrong with you people they're they're bored get them something and how many teenagers have any forethought into what this behavior is going to do for the – they all fuck up in their teens. That's the point of your teens.
That's what you're there for. You're all hopped up on hormones.
You have no idea what you're doing. It's a mess.
You could see inside a 15-year-old's brain. It is like a spirograph fucking picture.
It's just a – wow, that's a lot of swirls and lines you got going there, kid. For sure.
Things to do here. The Kingman County Fair.
Okay. Okay.
Now, they have a button contest. Oh, what kind of button? Make a button for the fair.
Make a pin? Yeah. And the winner of the 2024 button contest is Owen Archer.
Congratulations to Owen. Hey, good for you, Owen.
Buttons are available for purchase at Kingman in Fisher Lumber. Whites.
Just Whites. That's the name.
That's the company. Whites.
Any white person at all around will sell it to you. Citizens Bank of Kansas and some other bank here.
Also at Cozy's Pizza and some other shit place. Buttons are $5 each.
The button will allow you to participate in the medallion hunt, barnyard Olympics, and you can enjoy the cattleman's dinner and receive a reduced rate to the admission to the bull blowout. Sounds like you're going to get fucked by a bull until your asshole falls out.
Pretty sweet deal. All you got to do is buy a button.
Buy a button, yeah. And they have a 4-H fashion review judging as part of this.
I don't know what the hell. Fashion for cows or horses? Who knows? Maybe it's who's got the best wranglers.
Maybe. There's a horse show, a dog show, a livestock exhibitors meeting.
That sounds exciting. There's also a 4-H, oh, a rabbit and poultry check-in.
You've got to have that. Treasure hunt begins.
That's nice. That happens at noon.
There's a sheep and goat weigh-in. Everybody wants to be there for that.
Bring your foam fingers and everything. A swine weigh-in as well.
And at 7, which I'm, this sounds pretty good. I kind of want to watch this.
The Barnyard Olympics. I don't know what that is, but I so want to watch a cow try to fucking do the uneven parallel bars.
I want that so bad. There's nothing more I've wanted.
Yeah, I want to see that chicken relay. Yeah, show me a big pig's floor routine.
I want to see what it does. Well.
It just shits and walks around. There's also a pet show for some reason.
Just bring your pets in. I guess that aren't like working animals or food or future food.
There's also an open class woodworking contest. Oh.
So there's that. You can whittle anything.
I guess so. Yeah.
Whittle what you want. And then there's also this, I had to get to the peewee bucket calf show.
Peewee bucket calf show. I don't know what a peewee bucket calf is.
I assume it's small, small, small cows, small cows. Uh, that said, I think it's time to get to some murder here.
Let's do this. Let's talk about some murder.
Let's go to 2011, okay? Okay. It's not too far back.
Everything is pretty much exactly the same. You're looking at an iPhone, checking your Instagram.
Exactly the same. So let's talk about a guy named Brett with two Ts.
Double T, Brett. Brett Seacat is his last name.
Stop it. S-E-A-C-A-T.
Seacat. So cool.
That is a cool fucking name. He sounds like a recreational vehicle.
What is that? One of them new Seacats? Fuck yeah, baby. 200 horsepower.
You fly over the water on these bitches, baby. It's a Seacat.
Yeah. It's nimble.
Fucker's got a dual 525.

Oh, baby.

Get me one of them.

This cat rocks.

One of them new sea cats, the Brett model.

So Brett Sea Cat is born in 1976.

And one thing you'll notice if you follow us on social media

and see the pictures of this stuff,

he's a handsome son of a bitch, this Brett Sea Cat.

He's handsome and he's got a cool name. He's got a cool Brett Seacat.
That sounds made up. That's like when Bart Simpson said, I'm changing my name to Joe Kick-Ass.
I'm changing my name to Brett Seacat. Fuck yeah.
That is so cool. He's a law enforcement trainer.
He trains cops. That's what he does.
He shows other people how to be cool. Here's how you get a wrist behind someone's back easy.
So he works for the Kansas Law Enforcement Training Center. He's a Kansas law dog? Kansas law dog.
Ain't no law around here, law dog. Sea cat's a law dog? Sea cat's a Kansas law dog.
And he teaches police recruits from around the state so he's like teaches academy guys he had previously worked for the sedgwick county sheriff's department and now he's working for kansas as a whole here um he starts dating a girl that he's known since high school but well after high school and i don't think they went to high school together. Okay.
Okay. Her name is Vashti Forrest.

Fuck yeah.

Okay.

V-A-S-H.

V-A-S.

V-A-S-H.

Make that sound, everybody.

It's fine.

V-A-S-H.

V-A-S-H-T-I.

That's exactly what it is.

Vashti Forrest is her name.

And so he starts dating her, I believe, around 2002 is what it seems like here.

Starts dating her when they're both 25 or so.

She works at Cox Communications in Wichita.

You son of a bitch.

We're having Cox Communications problems.

I'm so mad at that.

When I said that, Jimmy's eyes lit fire lit with fire come over vashti where are you vashti do you know anything about tech support she unfortunately is my modem fried or not no she unfortunately is a human resources business partner so isn't going to be able to fix. She just decides whether or not somebody gets fired for saying different words.
How exactly did you tell her that she looked nice in that dress today? What was the you were holding your dick while you were doing it, were you? So in 2004, they start to their relationship becomes very serious. So serious that they head on down to Belize to get married.
That's been a very popular place in the last 20 years. Yeah, because it's South America, sort of, but it's closer than that.
So it's like you can – because it's right at the top there. And real estate has gotten – well, it was affordable there.
So like all these blue collar guys, but like invested in a home there and they're gonna sell their place in america and move on down to belize and stay there even even though they've all seen the monster inside me things where something swims up their pee hole and then somebody's got their dick chopped off in belize not only pee hole invaders we're talking about fucking the storms they get there are yeah otherworldly unbelievable yeah there was a 90 day fiance there was a lady who was seeing a guy from belize and she went down there and like she was stuck on some other island because the storm had knocked all the power out no one could get a hold of anybody and she was like oh my god i hope he's not dead because a lot of houses collapsed from the wind. And I was like, this is crazy.

This sounds nuts.

They don't even have sturdy houses.

This is insane.

Like, what the fuck is happening?

And then things swim up their pee hole.

And then you got your pee hole being swam up by horrible things.

So they get married in Belize.

I'm sure the pictures were lovely.

Absolutely lovely.

Gorgeous.

They end up having two sons as well.

And they should still be minors. So I'm going to go ahead and leave their names out of this because there's no need.
Two sons. Who gives a shit? Anyway, so they, as the relationship progresses, a young marriage with two small kids, they have some issues.
Some signs of trouble start to pop up. But in November 2010, they began seeing a therapist together.
Good move. A couple's therapist that sees both of them together and then each of them individually as well.
Oh, that's nice. So they're working on it.
That's good for them here. They see Connie Sunderman, who's a clinical social worker for marital counseling.
And she met with them together, and she met with Vashti individually, and then a little less she met with Brett individually as well. When they first started this here, Vashti was expressing feelings of loneliness and isolation, and the therapist described this counseling as a last-ditch effort for Vashti prior to her filing for divorce.
Like, she's ready to file for divorce, and she says, I'll try this before we cash our chips in here. So I say I've done everything I can do.
Yep, the therapist said to see whether or not things could change within the marriage. So according to this therapist, Vashti's mood was sad and symptomatic of depression when they began counseling in November.
And that's not like her. It's not like she has.
Some people are just depressive naturally from time to time or whatever. That's not her type of deal.
This is she's depressed because she's sad about something. You know what I mean? So these symptoms, according to the therapist, improved dramatically.
and by April of 2011, Vashti was saying that she felt better than she had in years. She feels better.
So this therapist helped her, I guess, build herself back up. She said Vashti's outlook became hopeful.
She was making healthy life changes such as exercising, eating better, and planning to move closer to her sister and to her place of employment, which is Wichita.

Vashti would speak about her sons all the time, about how much she loved them and how much she loved being a mother.

And the only thing she has a problem with is her marriage is suffering.

Everything else is fine.

She also, Vashti, expressed fear to her therapist about having possibly been sexually abused as a child, even though she doesn't remember that ever happening. That is, that's tough stuff.
Which is tough because at some point, I don't know, I'm not a therapist or a psychiatrist or a psychologist, so I don't know how to handle that. But it's almost like you want to go, well, if you can't remember it, then fuck it, didn't happen.
But at the same time, if it's fucking you up subconsciously and your brain's just blocked it out, then you might have to work through it. So I don't know how that works.
Yeah. And I got a friend who's going with going through it because he he he found it in therapy.
He didn't know that it was all there. And then now he's got it.
And now he's trying to deal with it after finding it. Yeah.
Can you imagine? Yeah. I i didn't want that i came here to try to feel a little better and you're fucking bringing back diddle

memories jesus christ god damn this isn't fun i don't know if that's a good therapist or not

no so um the they questioned whether um untreated abuse could cause psychological and behavioral

problems later on in life uh she was asking her vashti was asking the therapist and she said it's possible if it if it affected you to the point where you had to block it out or if it's just pre your memory. And who knows? So she said in a response to a direct question, the therapist asked her directly, are you going to harm yourself when she was depressed? Do I have to worry about you for self-harm? And Vashti said she would never commit suicide because of her religious beliefs and because of her sons who are young.
So she said you don't have to worry about that. She also said that she was scared of old Brett Seacat not handling the prospect of a divorce well.
Yeah, if your name's Brett Seacat, you just expect shit to work out. You know what I mean? Yeah, there's that.
And as a Brett Seacat, you don't have divorce filed on you. No, you do the filing.
Yeah. It's basically whatever Chuck Norris joke you want to have, replace it with Brett Seacat.
Yeah. It's the same fucking thing.
A whole line of Brett Seacat jokes. Yeah.
So also that she was worried just how that would work out. She also, so she's not depressed, though, by 2011, March, April.
She's not depressed. She's doing better.
She's, you know, just establishing a social life again of, you know, meeting other people. And she even makes a new friend, as a matter of fact.
Oh. A new man friend.
Oh, no. Yeah.
Her sister Kathleen says that just before filing for divorce, Vashti had, quote, become intimate with a friend. So she banged one of her friends is what she's saying here.
Which is, hey, you're an adult. You're breaking up with whatever.
That's none of my fucking business and further worried that her husband would find out yeah brett c cat don't take kindly to that at all the man teaches other men how to be men and uh he's not gonna deal with he teaches domination is what he teaches yeah he's not gonna deal well with this this is gonna hurt this is gonna be This is going to be interesting, but it's wild. But she was worried about that, but she was also hopeful with plans for the future.
But she's like, I hope fucking Brett doesn't find out. He's going to be pissed.
So she really liked, she talked about, she liked her job at Cox. She liked her weekends and her evenings.
She'd spend them with her boys and was always busy redecorating and doing shit and keeping herself busy around the house, too.

Now, she had a journal. Okay.
A personal journal she kept on a table beside the bed. So, bedside journal here.
In about March of 2011, Brett Seacat takes the journal to work and scans the pages and prints out numerous pages. Now, he'll say later on that he did this at Vashti's request because she wanted an electronic copy of the journal as a keepsake.
She wanted to also have like a digital file for it. She wanted it to be written, printed out, and digital.
Every archive in case the Smithsonian wants it. I'm sure she's like, get it to me in many forms, please.
I don't think so. I write impeccably.
Sotheby's is going to want to auction this shit. They're going to want this someday, right? So April 14th, 2011, Brett has a therapy session, and he says that if Vashti divorced him, she was divorcing the entire Seacat family, even the children.
She's just writing it off. No, you don't make the rules of what she wants to not who she wants to spend time with.
And it's just not you. The kids are fine.
He said that he would take the two boys and leave the country if he had to, to keep her from taking the kids away from him. The therapist said, well, that's illegal.
I have to tell you that. Right.
As legally, I have to tell you. And he also thought it was better for the boys to have one parent and one household instead of two households.
I'd rather them with me in fucking belize than right going back and forth doing two christmases that's bullshit if his dad has a car and i have a car and we're in the same house then they just have two cars but if we have two separate houses and i have somebody and he has somebody then there's four cars and that's a lot of cars that's you know what the boys are rich with vehicles it's just too many cars it's just too much boat so april 19th 2011 vashti has a session and she's particularly concerned today that brett would not take the divorce well and that she mentioned a dream he told her about that startled her a bit and i don't blame him oh boy here we go the therapist said quote she told me he awakened her from sleep and told her he had a dream that he would kill her why would he wake her up hey baby baby i just had a dream where i strangled the life out of you okay go back to sleep no. It's fine.
Yeah. I saw how springy your fallopian tubes are.
It's wild. I cut out your liver and I threw it in the front lawn.
It was insane. Okay, no.
Go back to sleep. Go back to sleep.
And he said it was a recurring dream as well. Oh my God, he's doing this a lot.
That's terrifying. Yeah.
She was worried about how he's going to react to the divorce and when you couple that with dreams of killing her she's very worried yeah she wanted to have someone with her and the children when he was served with the papers he didn't want she didn't want to be like just them in the house she um so the therapist and vashti arranged for a safety plan for vashti's protection when she served him with divorce papers. A B plan in case things go bad here.
Now, April 21st, 2011, Vashti makes a reservation at a hotel in Old Town, Wichita. I didn't know they had an Old Town, Wichita.
It was a reservation for May 19th, the same night as the Timcgraw concert in wichita so she's coming into wichita to party it up yeah and as we saw in san diego the people coming back from that concert those battered souls she's gonna be walking back to that hotel room cowboy boots in hand limping with bleeding feet on may 19th lots of blisterds with with her brand new boots. Oh, God.
Those people, man. It looked like they let people out of a cave that they were stuck in for five years when they got out of there limping and shit.
It was so weird. So April 29th, 2011, Brett drove to his office and opened an envelope containing divorce papers that she had given him.
Oh, boy. That afternoon, while still at work at the Law Enforcement Training Center, he located an overhead projector in storage and used it by himself for about an hour.
Just fucking overhead projecting things for some reason. Now, then he asked a maintenance staff guy, or a couple of guys, he's like, what's up, guys? You know how to fucking do things.
What's the best way to dispose of computer hard drives? They said our best would use a torch. He goes, otherwise, it's got to be all melted or else we'll be able to read shit.
And so he goes, okay, cool. And then he used a torch, melted hard drives, and threw them in a trash can.
Then he threw out three old cell phones as well. Did he torch those? Well, no, no, you just throw those out because they hadn't been used in a long time.
So he's like, I might as well get rid of these today. These and all my hard drives.
Right now. I'll just throw out.
Later that afternoon, he drove to a convenience store. He got gas.

Got some gas.

There you go.

Okay.

Bought some purchased fuel.

April 30th, the next day.

It is morning time, or afternoon, I apologize,

and police respond to a report of a fire and a possible shooting at the Seacat residence.

Oh, boy.

They're called here. When they arrive, the second story of the house is engulfed in flames.
Shit's coming out of the windows. And Brett Seacat is standing in the backyard by the driveway holding his children.
Okay. Now, where's Vashti? The cop asked Brett, is there anyone else in the house right now? Yeah.
And he responded, my wife is in there. And they said, oh, my God, where is she? And they were going to go in and try to get her.
Yeah. And he said, quote, she's dead.
She shot herself. Her fucking head is gone.
Wow. That's what he said to the cop.
While he's holding children. While he's holding toddlers or seven-year-olds or whatever the fuck yeah her fucking head is gone oh my god brett brett c cats don't do emotion they not subtlety is is right out the window with brett c cat tells it like it is is what's up that's that's how brett c cats roll see she's dead no head hey boys yeah no it's okay baby it's good hey everybody just gonna take a quick break from the show and tell you a little bit about our safest sponsors simply safe and everyone has routines that you go through make you feel good make you feel secure like you have control over the world and a lot of times you don't but you do if you're us and it's on your routine includes arming your simply safe home security system.
You know, that's going to do well for you. So when we're heading out, both of us, we both have them in our houses, our studios, you lock up for the night.
Yeah. These, this simple step does more than just protect you.
It gives you peace of mind. You're going to feel good about leaving and then you're going to know it's going to be the same when you get back.
You'll sleep more soundly. I can leave the house with confidence and it's amazing how a push of a button can give you that kind of confidence.
And with Simply Safe, we love it. Like I said, it's in our studios, in our homes.
It's really easy to install too. You can get professional installation also, but if we can put it up, you can put it up.
Put it that way. Visit simplysafe.com slash small to claim 50% off a new system with a professional monitoring plan and get your first month free.
That's simplisafe.com slash small, S-I-M-P-L-I safe.com slash small. There's no safe like SimpliSafe.
And now back to the show. what's good for you and what's not.
But Thrive has it all in one convenient spot. They have everything.
They're a no-junk online grocery store that bans over 1,000 harmful ingredients and their team of product researchers. Like, I love a cookie, okay? I like a cookie.
I like a chocolate chip cookie. I like almonds maybe in it.
They have a delicious alternative I found here that is a gluten-free almond chocolate cookie, and it's delicious. And I'm like a cookie snob, too.
I usually don't like anything that's off. I don't know.
I want sugar and all that. But no, these are delicious, and they're gluten-free, and they're really good.
Try them out. You can find better options way easily with Thrive Market's Healthy Swap Scanner.
You can scan scan a product and it instantly recommends cleaner alternatives.

That's great.

So if you know you like this, but this isn't good for you, let's find a better alternative. Are you ready to make the switch? Go to thrivemarket.com slash smalltownmurder for 30% off your first order plus a free $60 gift.
That's T-H-R-I-V-E market.com slash smalltownmurder.

Thrivemarket.com slash small town murder. So Brett's, they come back and they go, what the fuck happened here? And he says, well, my wife was depressed and I was sleeping downstairs when this happened.
I heard a noise and a couple minutes, a moment later, I heard my wife wife she called me on my phone saying he should get the two boys and get them out of the house before they got hurt so then he said right after that he heard two pops and he said he went upstairs and saw flames and he said he saw his wife in their bedroom and tried to get in and save her,

but the fire was just too much, and he couldn't get to her here.

So, yeah, that's how it is, which is weird.

She's in the house, and she calls him on the phone and says this.

So, yeah, he claimed he heard a loud bang and went upstairs

and found her head fucking gone, fucking head gone, and the house on fire.

So he said he just grabbed their kids and ran outside and put the kids inside his wife's car for safety as any dad would do yeah and against the weather and anything else here so it's you know a spring day and it's probably chilly in the morning or anytime so brett said he then ran back upstairs left the kids in the car sure and you had the fucked up part is your wife's dead the house on fire, but you still have to tell the kids, hey, don't fuck with the directional thing. Don't like, don't press that button.
Don't, don't pull this thing into it. Don't put it in drive.
Don't put it to any of these to leave it. Yeah.
You got to still tell them all that. P is good.
So he then runs back upstairs. He says while on the phone with 911 to try to rescue his wife, but the smoke and the fire were too strong, forcing him to retreat.
No choice. Okay.
Problem is, though, as the cops are looking at him, he has no soot on him at all. It doesn't look like he's been in a fire.
You know what I mean? A lovely fellow. And he has no blood on him either.

So it doesn't look like he got anywhere near his wife.

And he only has, his only wound is a small burn on his foot.

That's it.

Oh, yeah.

The only wound he has.

Tiny little burn.

So they're like, that's weird.

I mean, hey, glad you're okay, but.

Great work.

Fucking weird.

So they said also when the cops got there, they said there wasn't something quite a little off about the way he was acting.

Yeah.

A little weird.

One of the cops said, quote, his demeanor seemed to be out of place for the circumstances.

There was no perspiration.

There was no blood or ashes.

And after rescuing the two children from a burning house and also discovering his wife's suicide, he just looked like he was pretty fresh, ready to go somewhere. Not even sweaty.
If you went in and you tried to fight the flames, you'd be covered in sweat. Ashes stuck to your sweat.
You'd be like, I tried. I had a breath.
Holy, if I couldn't do it. And I sprained my ankle.
I fell down the stairs. Whatever.
Choking a little. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah.
So the house has extensive fire damage, but it's not. It still stands because there's a lot of brick in it.
So a lot of the brick is still standing. A brick chimney is still in perfect.
You know, they're made for fire. So after the fire department extinguished the fire, that's when her body is found.
Vashti's body is found on a bed in the upstairs bedroom, on the master bedroom. And the investigator finds a Ruger Red Hawk 44 caliber revolver.
My God. That's why he said her fucking head is gone, because that would do that to you.
That was a dirty Harry gun. That's a law dog gun.
Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. That's a fucking Wyatt Earp gun, for Christ's sake.
It's a peacemaker, right? I would say so. So it is a revolver, and it's lying on the bed under her body with the barrel pointed down toward her legs.
A single gunshot wound through her head into her neck is the cause of death, and we'll go into the exacts there. And a five-gallon gasoline container was lying in the middle of the bed.
Okay.

Right there next to her.

Now, the injuries, the fatal gunshot wound to her neck and head, went from right to left, slightly downward from front to back. So you can imagine what that is, completely destroying her brain and her head.
Yeah. So he also said there was no soot found in her lungs and that she had a significant amount of urine in her bladder that would have felt like a urinary emergency, quote unquote.
Oh, she had to pee right now. She had to pee right now.
So she woke up is what that is. She's saying she woke up and they're saying she would if she would have woke up in the morning, she would have pissed before she did anything.
It would have been like, oop, I got to go pee.

That morning pee thing.

That means she woke up and was like, I'm burning it down right now.

Before I pee.

I'm going to kill myself.

I have to pee so bad I'll shoot myself in the head.

That's how bad I have to pee.

So that's weird.

The coroner's report also indicates that she nearly instantaneously died from the bullet wound to her head. But she had also sustained gunshot wounds to her torso, hip, and thigh.
Those wounds were consistent with rounds cooking off from the heat of the fire. Oh, fuck.
It was making the rounds go off, and the gun was shooting her more. Damn it.
Yeah, that's crazy. No smoke inhalation either in any of the tests.
No ash, soot, or smoke. Blood and urine tests were negative for alcohol and, you know, every drug under the sun.
The coroner had no conclusion as to whether it was a murder or a suicide. Really? I had no idea.
Big gunshot wound to the head. You guys figure it out by the scene, I guess.
So a neighbor who had been unable to sleep was awake and watching television that morning. She heard a sound which she described as sounding like a gunshot based on hearing gunshots in the past, she said.
Rather than look into it or anything else, she got frightened and covered her head with her covers until she saw emergency vehicles arriving.

She hid onto the covers like she's seven and the boogeyman is in the closet.

Yeah, with a flashlight.

What the fuck are you doing?

There's her and a flashlight under there going, I hope it goes away.

Hope it goes away, man. I hope it goes away.

Based on the timing of what was taking place on the TV show she was watching when she heard the gunshot, they concluded she heard the shot at 315 a.m. All right.
Now, the fire pattern here, an agent determined from the burn patterns and patterns and different kinds of damage that the fire started in the hallway and moved south to north in the bedroom. So outside the bedroom.
Didn't start on the bed where the gas can is.

It started outside in. Okay.
Like, you know, if you were doing that, you'd. Trying to, yeah.
Yeah. Trying to destroy the whole top.
Now, something else that didn't burn in the fire, by the way, that someone probably wishes would have burned in the fire and I think was meant to burn in the fire. They find printed papers, printouts of like website pages.

Uh-oh. burned in the fire and I think was meant to burn in the fire.
They find printed papers, printouts of like website pages regarding how to kill someone and make it look like a suicide. What? Literally that.
And they were sitting on the kitchen table of the house. Wow.
So right in play, he, that's a place where you go, well, that'll burn if the house burns.

It's the kitchen.

That's where all the fire goes. Oh, yeah.
So searching throughout the house, they found them on the dining room table, water-soaked PowerPoint presentation that included information about suicide wounds and death investigations, specifically death investigations involving fires. Hilarious.
One of the pages discussed investigations distinguishing between homicides and suicides, and one page discussed reasons for suicides, including severe marital strife, recent emotionally damaging experiences, financial difficulties, humiliation, and revenge. My God.
But when they said, hey, bro, Brett, pray tell. What up with that? The fuck, man? Like, what is this about? It's going down, clown.
He said, oh, that was just discarded paper that I took home from work. Oh, that's mine.
So that was just, yeah, that's mine. But it wasn't, I took it home like as like a kindling.
It wasn't, you know, for like a fireplace, a bonfire. He claimed it? Yeah, yeah.
He said, well, because he said it came from work. I don't know.
I didn't look what it was. I just grabbed a bunch of discarded paper from the recycle thing at work, and I just took it home.
It's weird that it happens to be all about how to kill your wife and make it look like a suicide in a fire. Very strange.
Hey, Mr. Seacat, what's this? Oh, that's not a good answer brett see brett c cat doesn't need logic brett c cat plays by the seat of his pants here just saying uh-oh in their face that ain't the right answer but i would say now oh yeah no those are mine you fail but i had no idea what they were or anything so brett talks to a co-worker here, and he says, yeah, I thought everything was fine.

He tells a co-worker.

He said, my wife out of nowhere kissed me that morning or on the – yeah, that morning here, the day before.

She kissed me, and he said, that evening we argued over custody of the kids.

But he said, I went to sleep on a downstairs couch.

And then he tells the co-worker the same story, and he's, fire beat me back. Then the police talked to Vashti's coworkers here.
Okay. They talked to her coworkers, and three of her coworkers at Cox Communications said that they had conversations with her.
Two of them mentioned threats from Brett. Oh.
Melissa Beasley and Scott Hankins testify later on that Vashti told them Brett threatened to kill her, burn down the house, and make it look like she was the one who did it. Very specific threat.
Why did he say that? Then print papers out talking about it. What the fuck are you doing, dude? Wow.
He's far too confident. This is, it is, how great must it be just to be a handsome guy named C-Cat? You just get to say and do anything you want.
Anything you want and the people will buy it. Yeah.
Or he thinks they will. He doesn't expect to ever have consequences.
Fuck no. He even told her, quote, he could get away with it because he was in law enforcement and knew about those sort of things.
And, quote, firemen were idiots. This is coming from a man who leaves an instruction manual on how to do exactly what he just did on his kitchen table.
They're idiots. That is the consensus view of firemen too, though.
Well, yeah, yeah. I'm not saying he's wrong, but I think he's a moron, too, is what I'm getting at.
It's very funny that he just, like, screams the playbooks. Firemen are idiots.
Firemen are idiots. Vashti had also said Brett had threatened to kill himself or take the boys away and disappear.

So then, remember our therapist friend here?

She gets what she called a very unusual phone call or a very unusual conversation with Brett Seacat about five hours after Vashti was found in the house.

Yes.

She called him at about 9.30 a.m. after he'd already called her office and asked for advice on how to tell his children their mother had committed suicide.

Not that she was dead.

We can worry about the hows when they're older.

Yeah, the what's and such. We can just go, Mommy's not coming home.
How do we break that news?

You don't tell a four-year-old that Mommy committed suicide.

Your mom's a weak bitch. Yeah.
Listen, mommy couldn't take it anymore because she's weak. Fucking Dexter didn't even find out.
Mommy's not here because she's not a sea cat. Dexter didn't find out his dad really killed himself until like season seven.
He was like 42 when he finally found out. There was no reason to tell him when he was younger he's not not able you can't capably process that information brett no but he's trying to set the narrative though she committed suicide dad's a great dude so this lady said that she was alarmed by that and told him not to tell their boys that the mother had committed suicide don't do that just say she was injured and not coming back and then you can close the loop from there over the years time goes by sprinkle in pepper in a couple more details then he said quote i killed her vashti is dead and it's my fault oh my so she said okay you know me this.
Why and when and where and how and tell me all of you think. Have you heard of the Menendez brothers? Yes.
You don't know who I'm fucking. Shut up.
Stop telling me. Jesus, you don't know who's in this office right now.
He then said that, no, no, no, I told my wife that I was going to take the kids away. That's why.
And I didn't kill her myself, but I caused this. She said, quote, he told me that he knew she was dead because of the pool of blood.
That's how he looked in and saw her. She said she described him as quite calm when she spoke with him over the phone, and she felt the entire situation was very unusual since he had contacted her within two hours of this of the death happening here.
She said he just told me matter of factly what was happening well that's how sea cats roll though honestly we don't we don't have time for it's we don't have time for panic hey i haven't got time for the pain i don't know what to tell you we don't have we don't have time for a lot of things well most people run out i run in that's all i'm saying there it is yeah i'm a sea cat he she said he just told me matter of factly what was happening um she um uh yeah they they asked her later did he ever choke up when speaking with you like did it ever emotionally hit him she said nope he's acted very detached like he had during the six months that she'd counseled him so it wasn't an unusual behavior for him but it's unusual behavior for normal nuance with this guy but uh yeah it's just normal for him it's abnormal for everyone for everyone else yeah and him but the blaze had been concentrated in the back of the home which is where the master bedroom and vashti's body were um the room itself was badly damaged They said there was a lot of charring.

And Vashti's burned body was resting on the

bed, which had been burned down to the

metal springs. Jesus.

Mattress gone. Metal springs.
So she is

burned up, you have to imagine.

There's not much left of her. No, and

she was on a mattress that burned like that.

That's not good. They said something at

the scene, though, sparked

some concern here. Underneath her left side was the pistol here with the barrel pointed downward.
So the one cop said, how could the gun end up where it was located under her body if she had shot herself in the head with it? How's that work? Yeah, I mean, her hand would have to drop and go straight. It would go sideways or up, right? Yeah, it would have to be like in the front my point is like if you if you shoot yourself in the head and you think of where the kickback is it's away from your body yeah unless you put it under your chin and that giant fucking gun oh there's no way she's controlling that no her arm is going to be straight out next to her probably maybe with her finger still gripping maybe not.
So, yeah, they said that was very odd. They said if she had shot herself while she's lying down, the gun would have fallen onto the floor.
If she'd been sitting up and shot herself, the gun should have remained on the right side like we just did. It just didn't make sense.
Yeah, we just reenacted it exactly like you said. We didn't even need any training from Brett Seacat to do it.
No, no. I fired a weapon before.
I know. Also, the trajectory of the shot to the head that killed her was odd, too.
This is a forensic pathologist said the trajectory of the bullet is really significant because if you're holding a gun in your hand and you're shooting yourself behind your right ear, normally the trajectory is pointed to the opposite side. But the autopsy report indicates that its right to left is slightly downward and also lightly front to back.
Due to that trajectory, you almost have to bend your arm around, which is very uncomfortable to do to yourself with a fucking 44, especially. Sure.
They said the lack of soot and carbon monoxide in her airways and bloodstream also triggers alarm bells.

Yeah, she did this before she started a fire?

That's the thing.

They said even if she did it right after, there'd be something.

There was nothing.

No fuel, nothing in there.

They speculated she was likely already dead and therefore unable to breathe, obviously, when the fire was set.

Due to the inconsistencies between Brett's story and the condition of her body, they're still unable to pinpoint the manner of death because she's too badly burned. They end up two days after this.
They are very suspicious of Brett, obviously. Of course.
I mean, this is clear here. But they can't really arrest him right now because all they have is the fact that, you know, it's very suspicious.
So they continue to investigate. And then they find in the driver's seat of Vashti's car was her journal.
And the most recent entry seemed to be a suicide note. It said, Brett, I can't do this.
I can't fight this out. Take care of our boys.
Be sweet to the. She names them.

I won't name them.

Hold them both and tell them mommy loves them every night.

I'm taking care of the house.

I'm taking care of the house.

Oh, OK.

He she then says to the one son, you are so wonderful, mommy, so proud of you.

Be a good big brother.

And then to the other one, stay strong and don't ever lose that smile.

I love the two of you and we'll be watching over you from heaven.

Yeah, don't lose that smile as mommy kills herself.

Lots of small children just smile away when their mommies die.

That happens a lot.

Smile through life as they're motherless because she committed suicide.

Jesus.

Then they figure out, once they talk to all the neighbors, that the gunshot happened.. Remember through what she was watching on TV and what was happening at that exact moment.
315 was the gunshot, which he didn't call 9-1-1 till 3.57 a.m. Wow.
4 a.m. That is almost 45 minutes.
Yeah. In between when the gunshot occurred and when he called the cops.
And if she's dead and the fire's not started yet, what the fuck? What the fuck? So very interesting. Then when they talked to all of her friends and coworkers and recalled that Vashti had asked them, do you think Brett is capable of killing me? Because he told me he would kill me and burn it down and make it look like a suicide.
Anyway, they bring him in for an interrogation and he says one of the worst fucking things ever in an interrogation. This is a very guilty fucking statement.
Quote, I'm smart enough. Uh oh.
Number one. No, you're not.
I bet you're not. Print out, dude.
Yeah.

You left the playbook.

Right there.

Bill Belichick.

You left it on the counter.

You couldn't have found all the info you wanted and then thrown that shit out in a dumpster at the McDonald's or something so no one would find it.

You left it on the kitchen table, you lazy fuck.

Wow.

So he said, I'm smart enough that if I wanted to kill my wife, I have come up with something better than this this is what a crazy person does oh okay well they say well hands behind your back mr crazy sea cat because you're under arrest chief sea cat you've given us nothing to believe that you didn't do this so um then vishti's family makes a statement and they say, Brett liked to control every aspect of everything he did. I think that came out in the trial later on.
He's controlling and manipulative and by her filing for divorce, she had taken the power out of his hands and he couldn't deal with the loss of control. Okay.
And another person said, this was the first time he had been served with papers.

They talked about the problems in their marriage, and they had always agreed to work on it.

This time, her words to us were, how will I know that I'm through this time by what I say?

How can I make it clear to him, basically?

And he was a little territorial, if you will, possessive.

Not a Brett Seacat.

And he wasn't going to allow her to leave him and take the two boys. This show, Small Town Murder, is sponsored by BetterHelp.
We're huge proponents of therapy because everybody needs it too. And independence is very glorified.
It's easy to forget. And we're all better when we have a little support system behind us.
And therapy can be a great source of support for any area of your life when it's time to shift the focus here from doing it all on your own to maybe, maybe it's a little better if we ask for some help here or there. It doesn't hurt and there's nothing wrong with it.
And we've benefited greatly from therapy. Just talking to Jimmy about something he wanted to talk to his therapist about this week.
So, I mean, if you can't beat it, makes therapy affordable and convenient, actually, which is a big barrier to a lot of people. Serves over 5 million people worldwide.
You access a diverse network of more than 30,000 credentialed therapists with a wide range of specialties. And you can easily switch therapists at any time for no extra cost.
Build your support system with BetterHelp. Visit BetterHelp.com slash smalltownmurder today to get 10% off your first month.
That's BetterHelp, H-E-L-P.com slash smalltownmurder. Now back to the show.
Hey, everybody. Just going to take a quick break from the show to tell you a little bit about Life 360.
It's a new year. Things are going on.
You're juggling your family. You've got school things to do.
And I know you're always taking a kids to sports. You've got a new driver in the house.
You have a new driver in the house like Jimmy does here. You're juggling all this stuff.
You need to get Life360. It's a location-sharing app that works whether you're on iPhone, Android, doesn't matter.
Life360 makes coordinating your family's daily routines and activities so much smoother. You open up the app, you can see real-time locations for everyone in your family.
That takes away all the stress of wondering, where are they? Are they going to be here in 10 minutes? When are they coming? How fast are they going? Like you do with your son. You can monitor.
That's great. Jimmy's been monitoring his son because he's a new driver.
That's what's awesome. It really does.
You can coordinate things, you know, and you, because I mean, obviously you could text somebody, but you don't want them texting and driving. So this way you can just look at it.
It's really awesome. It's amazing how much more coordinated your family can be.
Family proof your family with Life360. Visit Life360.com or download the app today and use code SMALLTOWNMURDER to get 15% off.
That's Life360. That's life 360 dot com code small town murder.
Now back to the show. Hey, everybody, just going to take a quick break from the show to tell you a little bit more about Chime.
Things are expensive. The world is an expensive place and it only gets more expensive every day.
And the last thing you want is a credit card debt hanging over you. Nobody wants that.
It's horrible stuff. What you can do is enter the Chime Credit Builder Card.
This is a secured credit card with no annual fees. You can build credit with money you set aside and avoid interest or expensive debt.
Those terrible, high, awful interest rates that you get on some of those credit cards. Chasing your tail sometimes.
It's hard. That's what it is.
You'll never get ahead. Plus, you can get access to my pay and get up to $500 of your pay before payday with no mandatory fees.
That's excellent. You got to do it here.
You get a Visa credit card, no annual fees, interest, or credit check. That's good stuff there.
You use it everywhere. Visa cards are accepted, so it's not some special weird card you can't use anywhere.
Turn your everyday purchases into steps toward your financial goals with Chime's Secure Credit Card. Get started today at chime.com slash smalltownmurder.
That's chime.com slash smalltownmurder. Chime.
It feels like progress. The Chime Credit Builder Visa Card is issued by the BankCorp N.A.
or StrideBank N.A. Spot Me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply.
Out of network ATM withdrawal and OTC advance fees may apply. Late payment may negatively impact your credit score.
Results may vary. MyPay eligibility requirements apply.
Credit limits range from $20 to $500. Go to Chime.com disclosures for details.
Yeah. Her brother, Vashti's brother, said that on one occasion she poked her head in a co-worker's door and said, do you really think he could kill me, burn the house down, and make it look like a suicide? Which is very specific.
How will I know that he's got the message? How will I know he'll leave us alone? How will I know that he won't kill me? How will I know that he won't, that it's a suicide? Let's get Whitney involved in this mess. Yeah.
She's got her own problems. She's the album of an anthem, man.
She's got her own fucking problems, I think. Well, she's dead now, but she had her own problems.
Plenty of problems. That's why she's dead, shit.
That's why she's dead. There's a movie, by the way, a biopic on her, and it is hilarious.
It came out? It's from like 2022. Oh.
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. It's really fucking funny, though.
It's real funny. And they don't like cut.
It changes. It's like 1984, and the next thing you know, she's hanging out with Bobby Brown.
You're like, what happened? How did years go by? They don't even tell you in this movie. It's a mess, this movie.
So anyway, the brother said she was afraid. Of course.
And despite the appearance that the marriage was perfect, it wasn't. Her sister, I think, said Vashti was very private about their marriage, didn't share a lot.
That's just who she was. And it probably was a year before she told us she was going to file for divorce.
She began sharing some of the threats he had made. And of course, the signs were there.
He was becoming more and more controlling with her. They said, what signs do you mean?

And they said that Brett began to change in front of the family's eyes.

She said the lack of social life with her friends, everything was geared around him.

He didn't care to come to family functions and more and more.

And first he would go to church with her.

Then he stopped.

And he didn't come see the necessity in doing things that normal people do. He was becoming more withdrawn and more critical of her.
Yeah. The marriage is imploding.
Yeah. And he's fucking becoming a weirdo here.
So Vashti's brother said he never imagined anything like this could happen to his sister. He said, I didn't see it coming because it's so hard for human nature to encompass that type of evil act.

Yeah, that's a big thing.

So do you hear people threaten or you hear them allude to things? But at the end of the day, I think it's very hard for good people to really fathom that someone could perpetuate such an act like this. Sure, sure.
Not for us. We fucking do this twice a week.
Every week. Every week, babe.
Two days a week. Yeah.
Brett's trial, he sought to say that she had attempted or contemplated suicide on five prior occasions. Five times.
Only thing is, he's the only one who knows about this. She didn't tell her therapist.
She didn't tell her friends. He didn't call the police.
He didn't file some report. No, just five times.
So the state filed a pretrial motion seeking exclusion of that testimony about the prior suicide attempts and the district court held that the previous suicide incidents were too remote in time to be relevant to the defense because she was depressed three years ago and tried to kill herself doesn't mean that that's her state of mind then which makes perfect sense i know that's true so and it's also completely uncorroborated again so the prosecutor in the opening here said that Brett was a manipulative man who used his law enforcement background to try to make it look like his wife shot herself.

The defense just said, come on, it's a suicide.

Even the coroner can't decide whether it was death or homicide, suicide or homicide.

What the fuck?

Yeah.

The coroner said, I don't know.

She's a charred body. How the hell do I know what the fuck is going on with a bullet wound in it that's all i know three bullet wounds or four yeah so then they talk about the suicide note they get the prosecution gets a forensic for uh document examiner for the kansas bureau of investigation yeah he said that there were certain incongruities in the last journal page that led him to conclude that the writing had been traced from other samples of her handwriting oh what would you use to do something like that to trace something you'd want it to be bigger than normal really you wouldn't want to do it on the page maybe a light project oh with a light behind it that yeah wow weird right that's helpful yeah that'd be real to do that.
They said that the discrepancies included tremorous writing, so doing it slow and not fucking smooth. Not crisp.
And smearing, which contrasted sharply with the fluid writing that was highly consistent in her known writing samples. Because when she's writing in her journal, she's not unsure of that shit.
She's just writing. He pointed to features indicating the writing had been done slowly with added corrections to certain letters to make it look better.

He noted Vashti's lowercase d was very consistent throughout many of samples of her handwriting, but it was formed using a different stroke in the last journal page.

Didn't do it the same.

These and other specific disparities led him to conclude that the suicide note was probably traced and was a spurious document. And then they bring in the projector guy to say yes.
The co-worker said yeah, he asked to use an overhead projector and was in there for like an hour. So that makes sense.
Then they bring in the psychotherapist now. Let's bring the therapist in here.
And under questioning from under questioning from c cat's attorney she acknowledged she had previously diagnosed vashti with depression after she started counseling but she found uh she said she found evidence of a depressive episode or that vashti had been depressed in the past but it wasn't consistent in her life she's she gets depressed by things not just her general events... Events.
Yes. Not her brain chemistry.
It's not like that. It's not just how she does it.
There's environmental occasions that do this to her. Absolutely.
So then a co-worker testifies, saying about the... He said he could get away with it because firemen were idiots, which is hilarious.

It's fucking funny. Also said that Brett had threatened to kill her, take the boys away.
Under cross-examination, all Brett's attorney did is repeatedly question him on whether he was fucking Vashti. And he said, absolutely not.
so Brett's police chief friend comes in here

and this guy says

that the instructor Brett And he said, absolutely not. So Brett's police chief friend comes in here.

And this guy says that the instructor, Brett, had said that he bullied his wife the night before she was found shot to death in the couple's home.

Said that he, this is Kingman Chief Mark Holloway, testifies that Brett Seacat convinced his wife to stay and to let him stay in the home for several months despite the problems by threatening to take the children to Mexico. He told this guy that his wife was a pushover and wasn't a fighter so he could get her to do things.
They bring in a handwriting quote unquote expert for the defense here. And I use these quotes because this woman here, what's her name? Avis.
Avis Odenbaugh. Avis.
Like the rental company? Exactly like the rental company. She testified, she concluded the handwriting in the note matched the handwriting of the person who wrote in the journals.
Okay. Same thing.
She was called on his behalf and said that the journal page was the product of natural writing and that the journal page in question was written by the same person who wrote the other entries in the journal. She ruled out tracing on the text based on apparent ink flow.
She also testified differences in handwriting between the journal page and other samples of her handwriting could be explained because of mood or tension or other things. So the cross-examination here, she concedes that she is not currently certified by any forensic document examining organizations and is currently semi-retired.
What are your credentials? Oh, I don't have them. I had some years ago, but I don't know.
I don't keep up on shit. So the prosecutors then displayed a board with another sample of her have vashti's handwriting alongside the suicide note the expert admitted that there are discrepancies between the two so he he had her completely go against her own testimony in front of the whole jury see now don't you see it right there oh yeah i see it brett testifies oh really oh yeah he's got to go up there.
Hell, yeah. I'm telling you, this guy thinks he can pull off anything.
He does, yeah. He said, I would never burn our house down.
Our house? Wow. Never.
I thought I wouldn't kill my wife. I would never expose my children to any situation like that.
Okay. Oh, yeah.
He also said he did feel guilt, and the therapist wasn't lying. He felt guilt in the hours before she died.
He had threatened to shame him if she left him. I don't know what that means.
Shame him? What is it, the 1400s? Shame. What are we talking about? What does that matter? Stand in the street and ring bells every time I walk by.
What letter are you going to put on my sweater? What are we we dealing with there yeah you're a policeman how many policemen are divorced dude nobody gives a shit yeah that's what i mean it's he's such a fucking egotistical lunatic unbelievable that would look bad on me if we got a divorce so that played into the um he also said so he said that that also plays into the defense argument that Vashti was unstable, possibly use of her.

He says that she was using a prescribed diet drug known as HCG, whose side effects include depression. Yeah.
Okay. He then also says that while he felt responsible, he did not pull the trigger.
He explained that during their argument, he told Vashti that if she insisted on a divorce,

he would expose her alleged affairs

with coworkers, knowing it could

jeopardize both her job and parental

custody rights. Oh, she's fucking a

coworker. Which, yeah, who else is she meeting?

She comes home, she's got the kids,

she doesn't go anywhere else. She's there for fucking eight, nine

hours a day. Yep.
So the

defense attorney said, why did you tell her,

the therapist, that it was your fault? He said, because it was and then he he bowed his head and and appeared to choke up a little bit yeah he said for 19 years i was the one who protected vashti i finally pushed her into what i was protecting her from so it was my fault okay you know that's what a does, takes responsibility for when he drives his wife to kill herself.

I'm metaphorically

responsible for this.

You know, it's more of an abstract

type of thing, but still.

Closing arguments here.

The prosecutor said that

Seacat was full of uncontrollable

rage because his wife filed for divorce

and was kicking him out of the house. It was very simple.

She said he was like a burning fuse. That's why was reckless because he's a fucking reckless asshole the jury deliberates for six hours on this that's pretty quick that's quick too long i think on this one pretty easy this one seems like a pretty open shot if i watched him testify and say that shit i'd be laughing in the jury box like is this motherfucker serious there's no evidence that he's been more metaphoric or nuanced in his entire fucking life now all of a sudden he's all i i'm responsible no it's yeah in a roundabout way now he's abstract poetry he's using the fuck out of here before he was like i'll kill you and burn the house down and then say that you fucking killed yourself because firemen are idiots.
We know you're responsible because you went and bought gas, dude. That's the other thing.
Now he's all subtext. Before he was all exposition and now it's all, he's just subtext.
That's all it is. So six hours of deliberation, guilty of all charges including arson and child endangerment and murder and all that good stuff here.
All kinds of, yeah. So during sentencing, he gets up.
Now, this is his time to say, my bad, Your Honor. Be metaphorical again.
You beg for forgiveness. My bad.
Shit was awful. I snapped.
Come up with with something or say i respectfully whatever i i

don't think i did it but you know i i understand the authority i said firemen are idiots i meant

me yeah i'm the idiot you weren't a volunteer fireman were you your honor like in the no okay

good instead he says this the opposite of what he should be saying he says i teach about crimes i

know what covers up crimes and what doesn't i know that a bullet hole has never been covered up by a

I'm not going to a fire to try to cover this up. This is the kind of sentence you believe you'll need for a Kansas Supreme Court nomination.
You are going. It gets better.
So he's saying you're corrupt, number one. Yeah.
yeah you're using me for career you're using me to benefit yourself and then he says you are going to hell for what you've done in this case he said that to the judge you're going to hell for what you did that then he said he vowed that the evidence that you and the prosecutors colluded to suppress will one day be presented and I will be free. Okay.
What do you think of that, Your Honor? Yeah, what do you say? The judge says, well, stupid. Thank you for your input.
Yeah. Appreciate you speaking.
Number one, your guilt is overwhelming. Number one.
Never even thought you weren't guilty for a second. I just did this because it's constitutional.
You have to, yeah, let you do it. Evidence to support your defense of suicide was totally unbelievable and totally unsupported by any credible evidence.
Right. He said that your wife was not depressed or suicidal, but was looking forward to a future with her two sons after the divorce from your stupid ass was finalized and dealing with you today.
I don't think I fucking blame her. He should have said I divorce.
Now I see why he said that her family hit it on the head in their victim impact statements when they described C-Cat as being self- self-centered and narcissistic he said your statement this morning confirms to me that you live in some sort of bizarre alternate reality you don't want to hear that uh he also said that he considered the fact that you haven't admitted guilt and had an admitted responsibility or expressed any remorse that's a big part of this sentence by the way it. It's a problem, yeah.
He said, you haven't admitted guilt. You haven't admitted responsibility.
And you didn't this morning even express remorse that Vashti is no longer on this earth. One of the victim's family asked me to show you no mercy, and I don't intend to show you any mercy.
Oh, shit. You didn't show Vashti any mercy on April 30th, 2011.
You, sir, may fuck off life in prison without the possibility of parole for 25 years on the murder, as well as more than five more years for the aggravated arson conviction and seven months for each child on the endangerment conviction, all to run consecutively. Suck it.
Suck it. You're not going to be so handsome in 31 fucking years are you chief didn't think so and then you have to go before the parole board and beg and you better fucking have some remorse by then or they're not gonna let you out either no way if he goes in with this bullshit to the parole board he'll be in there for the rest of his fucking life you bet and he deserves it so vishti's family said her mother's Vashti.
Did I say Vashti? Yes, Vashti. Vashti's family said that she had begged her daughter not to serve him with divorce papers, fearing it might set him off.
What is she supposed to do? She said, I begged her those last two months not to serve him papers, just to separate and let him get acclimated first and to move in with us one thing at a time you know like telling your kids their mother committed suicide one thing at a fucking time you know do that and her words were i don't want to endanger your lives that's what she said so bashti yep that is so fucking sad bashti's mother and brother said said the verdict brought a sense of relief to the family. She said, it was a little surreal.
I felt justice had been done, and I felt like the boys were safe. So there was a Dateline episode here in 2013.
This happened, too. It was like right after it happened before any of the stuff I'm going to talk about here in a second yeah um it's called burning suspicion and they fucking he just was convicted yeah they're just now and we want to talk about it they're like they had that one of those big tapes you know those big studio tapes they had one like ready is it in yet hey down i'm gonna put it in it's in we're showing it tonight he's gone he's guilty it in.
It's in. We're showing it tonight.
He's gone. He's guilty.

That's what it feels like here.

Golly.

So, 2014, there's a custody battle between the face-off between the maternal and paternal

families.

His parents and her parents.

Yeah.

Well, since your kid killed my kid, we get these kids, right?

I think we win.

Yeah.

Yeah.

I mean, you can visit them. And you raised a murderer, so you don't get to raise these kids now.
Sorry. Your parenting is questionable.
Yeah, you raised a real twat. You know what I'm saying? It's a struggle between the mother and sister of Vashti Seacat.
She was killed there. And there, okay.
So the judge has set a two-day trial to decide who will be the legal guardian. And it's the same judge who provided over the trial, by the way.
Oh, that's great. That's terrific.
All we know is not him. Yeah.
That's real good stuff. He appeals this case.
Wow. Really? Yeah.
The Supreme Court considered the admissibility of various out-of-court statements that Vashti had made when she told coworkers and her therapist that her husband threatened to kill her by burning down the house and making it look like a suicide. The court determined that out-of-court statements were properly admitted either because they were not hearsay or because they satisfied an exception to the hearsay rule.
The court next considered whether evidence that Brett sought to introduce relating to a purported history of suicidal tendencies by his wife had been incorrectly executed. Okay.
to admit evidence of legal and illegal drug use by Vashti Seacat. So they did a great job.
Because it didn't fucking matter. You killed her.
It doesn't matter if she's on anything. The court also found no error in the admission of testimony by a witness referring to Brett Seacat's narcissistic personality.
A non-professional witness. I mean, that's just something you can say if you know somebody.
It's pretty inflammatory, but you can say it. You can say it.
It's an opinion. It might be a stupid opinion, but it's an opinion, dammit.
It's hyperbole for sure. Yeah.
Justice Lee Johnson authored a concurrent opinion also signed by another judge that took issue with the majority's characterization of an out-of-court statement as not being hearsay and with the majority's holdings that evidence of either suicidal tendencies, earlier suicidal was not relevant so a couple of judges disagreed about the one part about the out of court statements but agreed with them about the other shit so overall they agreed everybody did they affirm the conviction saying other evidence in the case was so strong a jury would have convicted ccat even if the excluded evidence had been allowed we'll give it to you we'll fucking you can have it we'll give you that bullshit you're still not getting out you punk motherfucker he's still shot her he still burned it down burned it down and lied like an asshole and then told the judge that he's going to hell for it so not working out um 2022 he filed another motion claiming ineffective assistance of counsel now why yeah saying that there was evidence that the defense failed to present that would clear him of the crime what's that oh boy what would that be provide it now man provide it you were at the house you can't say someone else came in and did it what the fuck uh the motion was filed in 2020 and the court of appeals denied the civil motion saying the and Seacat's attorney did not err in any way during his trial or the appeal that followed. Keep on keeping on, Brett Seacat, you twat fuck.
I mean, it would have had to have been a murder, and if it was a murder, why would she text you, I'm going to commit suicide, get the kids out of here so they don't get hurt? It's fucking crazy. What are you talking about, man? You don't know what you're talking about.
So there you go. He'll be in jail for a while now.
At least 20, 40-something until he gets out. So that's good for everybody there.
So check him out there if you ever end up in a Kansas State prison. Say Heidi Ho to old sea cat there.
And do that. Also, head over to ShutUpAndGiveMeMurder.com.
Get your tickets for virtual live show. October the 30th is when it's live, but you can watch it for two weeks after that.
You can watch it that night and over and over again or whenever you want in those two weeks. You can buy it any time in those two weeks.
Enjoy it, just like a regular live show, except we're going to be wearing costumes and you're going to be in your living room. So it's going to be fun stuff.
Can't wait. Get your tickets now.
We love it. Shut up and give me murder.com.
Also for the rest of the year too. I think there's some tickets left in Austin, New York and Boston.
Phoenix gone. So there you go.
Check that out. Also Patreon you want.
Patreon.com slash crime in sports. That's where you get all the bonus material.
Anybody $5 a month or above. What do you want? A cup of coffee? One cup of coffee that might not even be good, might not even be hot, or hundreds of back episodes of bonus shit you've never heard, and new ones every other week.
This week, what you're going to get, one crime in sports, one small town murder. Like always, you get it all.
This week for crime in sports, we're going to talk about the Vince McMahon documentary and specifically some very strange comments he made about some very horrible incidents that allegedly took place. Then for Small Town Murder, we're going to finish up the Ted Bundy psychological assessment of 1976.
We're going to find out, spoiler alert, is Ted a violent person? Who knows? While he describes pictures of people doing normal things.

Crazy shit there.

Patreon.com slash crime in sports.

Make sure to follow on social media at Small Town Murder on Instagram.

Small Town Pod on Facebook at Murder Small on Twitter.

You want to find us individually?

You can do that.

Shut up and give me murder.

Drop down menu.

Pow, pow.

Do that.

Keep coming back.

And until next week, everybody, it's been our pleasure.

Bye. Pow Pow.
Do that. Keep coming back.
And until next week, everybody, it's been our pleasure. Bye! If you like Small Town Murder, you can listen early and ad-free now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple podcasts.
Prime members can listen early and ad free on Amazon Music. Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey at Wondery dot com slash survey.
Are you captivated by the dark and mysterious world of true crime? Wondery Plus offers you the ultimate true crime experience with early access to new episodes, exclusive content, and a seamless ad-free listening journey. With Wondery Plus, you'll get access to hundreds of podcasts, including more than 50 true crime series like Dr.
Death, the shocking true story of a trusted surgeon who brought unimaginable pain and suffering to his patients. This was not an operation that was performed.
This was attempted murder. And there's Morbid, the hit podcast that's a lighthearted nightmare.
With Wondery Plus, you get access to exclusive bonus content, too, allowing you to dive deeper into the cases you love. Like in Suspect, where an ordinary Halloween party turned into a terrifying murder mystery that left its mark on the community.
This case is one of those rollercoaster rides where it's like, no, he did it for sure. No, for sure he did it.
Each story is crafted to keep you enthralled, revealing the complexities and motivations behind every crime. Subscribe to Wondery Plus on the Wondery app, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify today.
Unlock the door to a world of true crime like never before. with Wondery plus on the Wondery app, Apple podcasts, or Spotify today.

Unlock the door to a world of true crime.

Like never before with Wondery plus the best true crime stories are always at

your fingertips.