William Dennis
The horrific murder of a young mother on Halloween night sends California investigators on the hunt for a costumed killer.
Season 26 Episode 09
Originally aired: October 27, 2019
Watch full episodes of Snapped for FREE on the Oxygen app: https://oxygentv.app.link/WatchSnappedPod
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Listen and follow along
Transcript
Weight loss medications are everywhere right now.
Everyone's talking about them, everyone's on them.
But let's be real.
Have you seen the price tag?
It's hard to believe they're actually accessible.
That's where HERS comes in.
HERS is transforming women's healthcare by providing access to affordable weight loss treatment plans.
They connect you with a medical provider who will work with you to determine the best treatment option for you.
So, if you've been struggling to find a solution to your weight loss journey, it's time to find the best option that works for you through HERS.
Start your free online visit today at forhers.com/slash snapped.
That's F-O-R-H-E-R-S dot com slash snapped for your personalized weight loss treatment options.
For HERS.com slash snapped.
Weight loss by HERS is not available everywhere.
Compounded products are not approved or reviewed for safety, effectiveness, or quality by the FDA.
Prescription required.
See website for full details, important safety information, and restrictions.
Actual price depends on product and plan purchased.
This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance.
You chose to hit play on this podcast today.
Smart choice.
Progressive loves to help people make smart choices.
That's why they offer a tool called AutoQuote Explorer that allows you to compare your progressive car insurance quote with rates from other companies.
So you save time on the research and can enjoy savings when you choose the best rate for you.
Give it a try after this episode at progressive.com.
Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates.
Not available in all states or situations.
Prices vary based on how you buy.
After years of trials and tragedy, she thought she had finally found the one.
He loved his job, loved his work, and loved his family.
They were quite happy.
Until one night on a lonely Virginia highway, a killer ended 20 years of wedded bliss.
The blood was all the way down her chest.
She was mostly just saying, help him.
You know, help him.
I don't know what to do.
He said, we've got to get out of here.
These guys are after me.
But as one determined investigator will discover, this highway to hell is littered with long-buried and shameful secrets.
Winsboro is a little town.
Everybody knows everybody's secrets.
I was very suspicious.
His story just didn't add up.
He told us to exhume the body.
We exhumed the body.
I glanced at her and it was like, I will get you.
I was scared.
I was really scared.
April 21st, 1988.
Roanoke, Virginia resident Clarence Crouch is driving down a secluded stretch of Interstate 581 when his radio crackles to life.
Clarence Crouch was monitoring his CB radio that night and heard a frantic call from a woman.
A lady who said that her husband had been shot and that he was on 581.
The frantic woman says she's not familiar with CB radios and asks for someone to call police.
Clarence recognizes the woman's location.
He was close by, so he figured he would try to find him and try to get help.
He relayed the information into the dispatch center and also went to her location.
Roanoke police officers Doug Allen and Jane Bush both respond immediately to the scene.
My primary concern then is to render aid to the person that's injured.
Upon arrival, they find Clarence Crouch and a conversion van parked askew on the roadside.
He said, there's a lady in here.
Her husband has been shot in the head.
He pointed out that, you know, they were in the back of the van.
I looked in the back door and you could see all the way up to the driver's and passenger seats.
And there was a gentleman laying there on a blanket.
The wife was laying directly behind the driver's seat and was cradling her husband's upper torso in with hers.
She was upset and crying.
Her husband's injury is unmistakably grave.
There was a lot of blood around his head area where he had been shot.
There was a lot of blood on the floor of the van.
The distraught woman identifies herself as Francis Truesdale.
The man barely clinging to life in her arms is her husband of 20 years, Jerry Truesdale.
She was mostly just saying, help him.
Help him.
I don't know what to do.
Jerry Truesdale's life began 260 miles south of Roanoke in the sleepy South Carolina mill town of Winsboro.
Population 3,200.
Jerry Truesdale was my first cousin.
His dad, and my dad were brothers.
Jerry was a good boy.
He worked hard.
He was very, very loved by his sisters and his mom.
Winsboro was a good place to grow up in.
You could go out in the yard, and I did, and you could play all day long, not worry about anybody bothering you or hurting you.
So that's the kind of little town Winsboro was.
In 1967, when Jerry returned from a tour of duty in Vietnam, Winsboro hadn't changed, but Jerry had.
Like many returning veterans, he found it difficult to readjust to the slow pace of civilian life.
Jerry sought the familiar faces of family and friends.
We hadn't seen him in a long while at the time Francis was married to Red.
And I actually lived next door to her.
And Jerry came by Francis and Lil Red's house to see me when he came home from Vietnam.
Frances Beasley and her husband, Ronald Little Red Beasley, were fixtures in the community and had been married for two years.
While Francis was a stay-at-home mother, Little Red ran a local automotive body shop.
He was husky built, but he was short and had red hair, so he was called Little Red.
Little Red had really sweet demeanor,
very nice, nice to everyone, would go out of his way to help whoever he could, never met a stranger.
He loved to work on cars.
He worked in a shop, a mechanic, and he was a little bit of a, I don't want to call him a rousedabout, but a little bit of a daredevil.
On the weekends, Little Red liked to race cars at a local track with his best friend, a police officer named Herman Young.
Herman Young was black and little Red was white.
And in South Carolina in the 60s, those kinds of close friendships were rare.
Nevertheless, they worked on cars together, they raced cars together, and they just generally goofed around and had a good time with each other, just buddies.
Red's free-thinking ways were also exemplified by the loving acceptance he extended to his wife, Frances.
Francis had been married previously and got married again, had three children, and they had moved to Winnsboro and she had gotten a divorce.
For Francis Truesdale to move to Winsborough as a twice divorced single mother was kind of gossipy for people in Winnsboro.
But obviously Little Red with his wild and carefree attitude didn't bother him in the slightest.
She was in her early 20s at that point and seemingly they were quite happy.
Nice took over the job with Franc and Little Red.
Got to, you know, care for the boys and a clean house.
She would always want to be at the shop with Little Red, so that's where she spent her time.
Then, one fateful spring day, everything changed for Little Red Beasley.
Easter was in March that year, and that's when he had that brain hemorrhage.
Little Red was 29 when this stroke occurred.
Little Red was completely paralyzed on one side.
As I remember, he had very little
usage of his left hand, and Little Red could not walk.
He had gone from being a pretty energetic young man to being a paraplegic.
Well, quadriplegic, actually.
Jerry Truesdale and the rest of the community rallied around Little Red and Francis.
But Red's drastic transformation from charismatic husband and father to complete invalid proved almost too much for his loved ones to bear.
It was very sad because he'd always been so independent and to see him come back
and have to be lifted and moved from one chair to another, that was humiliating for him to see that he couldn't talk well at all.
His father has said he always thought that Little Red would somehow fight through the stroke and get back most of his faculties, but he never did and seemed to get worse and
at least not better.
Jerry watched helplessly as the burden of caring for Red consumed Francis's every waking moment.
Then, on July 6th, 1967, tragedy struck again.
Someone had pulled up and said, did you hear about Little Red?
He just committed suicide.
The story that I got was that Lil Red Beasley allegedly shot herself.
It was very sad to see that all of that had happened to him.
In the aftermath of the tragedy, Frances found comfort in the arms of the one person who could understand her loss, Jerry Truesdale.
It was quick out the little red
France and Jerry got married.
They were just ready to just accept it and move on.
So they just said that, you know, Lil Red's death is maybe a blessing because of the shape that he was in.
The newlyweds, Jerry and Francis, left Winsboro behind and made a new start in North Carolina.
He's just a truck driver, long-distance truck driver.
So he spent a lot of time on the road.
No matter how far afield Jerry's trucking career took him over the next two decades, he always knew Francis would be waiting for him at home.
Jerry Trusdale was married to her, you know, everything was fine and dandy.
Now the same arms that Jerry Truesdale longed to come home to were cradling his nearly lifeless body.
Jerry was laying there.
He was struggling to breathe, but he was still alive.
My primary concern at that point was getting Jerry Truesdale help.
He does have a pulse, but the gunshot was preventing him from being able to give me any information.
Frances said to me that they had been at the rest area and that there had been some sort of an altercation between her husband and some other gentlemen, and that they had shot him.
Coming up, a terrified eyewitness recounts a desperate race for survival.
Jerry jumped into the van and said, We've got to get out of here.
These guys are after me.
And a surprising caller sends the investigation in an entirely new direction.
She had some doubt as to how the incident had taken place.
In the early hours of April 21st, 1988, a call from a Good Samaritan led police to a grisly scene by the side of a Virginia highway.
Officers found 41-year-old Jerry Truesdale lying in the arms of his wife, Frances, and bleeding from a gunshot wound to the forehead.
The key to this was to get him to a medical center as quickly as possible.
He still did have a pulse, and so they immediately put him on an ambulance and took him to the closest hospital which was community hospital.
After we had transported Jerry to the hospital I was preparing to get Frances to the same hospital so that she could be with him.
At this point Frances realizes that she doesn't have her purse with her.
It's still in the van and
I told her I would go back and get her purse for her and she insisted that she be the one that got her purse.
At that moment, it didn't really
make a lot of sense to me.
She didn't ask how he was doing once he was transported.
She was more concerned with other things like her purse.
When I got her to the hospital, I didn't stay with her very long at the hospital, but she was crying, but it wasn't like what I would expect.
She was almost cold.
Doctors rush Jerry into surgery and give investigators their first clue about the weapon used in the attack.
When Jerry was in the surgery, they found out it was a, you know, it was a small caliber gun.
It was a.22.
While Francis waits outside the OR for news of Jerry's condition, police cordon off the crime scene.
We call him an evidence technician, or an ET, and one respondent, we always did that for any crime scene.
We didn't at that point know where the gun was or if the gun had indeed been in the van.
So evidence technicians from the Roanoke City Police Department searched it looking for the gun.
The search of the van turns up nothing so their focus shifts to who might have fired a weapon.
The evidence technicians check and see if there's any gunpowder residue or anything on the hands of anybody present really.
They're the ones that go over to the hospital and they do the gunshot residue on the hands of the victim and Francis, you would simply use tape and you would tape around their hands and
then send it off to a laboratory somewhere and have it analyzed.
As the GSR samples are being sent off to the lab, the hospital releases a grim update.
Jerry's prospects of survival are next to zero.
That is when Mr.
Kazee showed up from state police and took over the investigation.
Barry Kazi was the state investigator that was assigned to handle the call.
Barry kind of takes on the chore of trying to find out what exactly happened in that van that night.
So he came and got our reports and spoke with myself and Sergeant Allen.
Virginia law enforcement legend Barry Kazee's reputation precedes him.
Barry Kazee is one of the best state police homicide investigators that I've had the pleasure of meeting.
He's the kind of guy that would walk out of a movie set with a rumpled hat, rumpled suit, and a rough voice that sounds like he smoked way too many cigarettes, but he's to the point and very matter of fact.
You did not want Barry Kazee dogging you because he never gave up.
He never closed a case until, in his mind, it was 100% closed.
He never left anything open.
And he got very, very angry if he run into dead ends and couldn't go any further with it.
after getting a thorough look at the scene detective kazi immediately turns his attention to frances truesdale the sole eyewitness to jerry's attack i set in on the original interview with her with detective kazi frances told us that they were on their way to tennessee she and her husband had been traveling down interstate 81 and they stopped at a rest stop
Frances told them that they ran into a couple of guys from New New York that tried to get money off of him.
Jerry jumped into the van and said, we've got to get out of here.
Said, these guys are after me.
And so she was driving and he was in the passenger side.
And the two guys in the car were chasing them and kept trying to cut them off with their vehicle.
Francis says that their pursuers quickly outmaneuvered her.
They followed him down the road, caught up with him, and cut him off.
Jerry got angry about them trying to hurt them and everything.
So he told her, stop the van.
I'm going back and talk to him.
She said that he got out of the van and walked to the rear of the van and a guy stepped out of the car and shot him in the head.
She said she had grabbed him and dragged him back up into the van.
Frances' detailed description of the chase and the shooting holds investigators spellbound.
But when it comes to a description of the attackers, she doesn't have much.
She said it was two males that were in the confrontation with Jerry.
Usually you'll get whether they were wearing a plaid shirt or they were wearing green tennis shoes or something.
Something sticks out in their memory, but she could give no information about either one of these two people.
While Frances is unable to offer a description of the two men, she does remember crucial details about their car.
She said that the last that she saw them, they were traveling southbound on 581 in a light-colored Ford Granada with New York tags.
She said that it was a New York plate with R-U-D on it.
So I immediately told our dispatchers to notify, and we had officers that worked districts all the way out to the city limits.
We contacted New York to see if they could get us some more information on the vehicle, and we just kind of start picking up from there.
At that point in time, we're taking things at face value on what she's saying because that's all we've got to go on.
As day breaks, investigators canvass the interstate for clues.
We went and searched areas looking for guns, you know, along the roadway.
We drove that whole entire shoulder looking for some form of blood.
There was no blood in the road.
There was no blood in the road where she was at when we found her.
There was no blood in the shoulder or the road all the way up to 81.
Not finding blood on the outside anywhere.
That's a lot of bells going off there.
We eventually towed the van and did more of the work with the van down at our impound.
You know, they took blood tests and stuff and they printed for other strange handprints and all of that.
Now, investigators anxiously await word of a match for the make, model, and partial New York plate they've circulated.
We never got back anything from the surrounding jurisdictions that they had seen a light-colored Granada.
After two days of chasing dead ends, detectives get a dreaded update about Jerry.
We got word back from the hospital that he had, in fact, passed away.
So it became then, rather than a shooting, it became a homicide.
The shortage of evidence evidence puts the murder investigation in limbo until a phone call changes everything.
Barry Kazee received a call from Jerry's sister
and she had some doubt as to how the incident had taken place.
She called up to Roanoke and she ended up talking to Barry Gaze.
She got the ball rolling.
Coming up, a witness's conflicting stories are brought to light.
You can't stop the blood from flowing.
But there was her.
And an old friend unearths a deadly scandal from the past.
The very night that he got elected sheriff, he said that's going to be my first priority.
The rumor had been around for 21 years.
As much as I'd love to hold on to summer for as long as I can, I get excited for fall by thinking about my wardrobe, cozy sweaters, layering my scarves.
Quince nails it with luxury essentials that make your capsule closet effortless, easy, and always so stylish.
Think chic cashmere wraps or cotton sweaters.
The best part?
With Quince, everything is half the cost of similar brands.
They work directly with top artisans and cut out the middleman to give you luxury without the markup.
One classic I've been using every day since I got them is the Bally Polarized Sunglasses in green.
They're great great for road trips, pumpkin patches, or early mornings.
I don't want to risk my eyesight for style, so I'm glad Quince offers polarized frames in a cute style.
I've also been eyeing the Italian leather laptop backpack for a while.
I might just have to check out my cart right after this.
Elevate your fall wardrobe essentials with Quince.
Go to quince.com/slash snapped for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns.
That's q-u-in-ce-e.com/slash snapped to get free shipping and 365-day day returns.
Quince.com slash snapped.
Dreaming of hydrated skin?
Dime offers clean, master aesthetician crafted skincare products that deeply nourish, protect, and hydrate.
Their formulas, made with clean ingredients, lock in moisture for skin that stays soft, smooth, and radiant all season long.
Hydration starts with Dime's best-selling hyaluronic acid serum, delivering deep moisture where your skin craves it most.
This lightweight, fast-absorbing serum helps quench dryness, plump skin, and boost elasticity from the inside out.
Once your skin is prepped with the serum, seal in all that hydration with their Dewy Day Cream, a rich, luxurious moisturizer designed to provide all-day softness and lasting glow.
Together, this powerful duo keeps your skin smooth, supple, and luminous, even in the harshest weather.
Shop the duo now at dimebeautyco.com.
That's dimebeautyco.com and get the hydrated skin of your dreams.
After two weeks of searching, police in Roanoke, Virginia have found no trace of the two mysterious men Frances Truesdale claims are responsible for the roadside murder of her husband Jerry.
But the investigation takes a sudden turn when Detective Barry Kazi receives a phone call from Jerry Truesdale's sister, Anne Letrick.
She loved her brother dearly, and when she was in the hospital, Francis had told the family a couple of conflicting stories.
Francis originally said he was shot outside of the vehicle and that she had grabbed him and pulled him up and put him between the seats.
Later on, she says that he was shot inside the vehicle and that he slumped over and she just kind of maneuvered his body between the seats and laid him down.
The conflicting stories Frances shared with Jerry's family raised significant doubts for investigators.
I do not think that she would have been big enough or strong enough to deadlift him off the ground and get him into the van as small as she was and as frail as she was.
And see, if she had pulled him from the back of the van to the front of the van where she was sitting, there would be a blood slide all the way back through the van.
You can't stop the blood from flowing.
But there was her.
According to Jerry's sister, Anne, another incident took place decades earlier and hundreds of miles away in Winsboro, South Carolina.
It appears Jerry isn't Francis' first husband to die under suspicious circumstances.
She believed that Francis had killed Red Beasley.
That's what caused Barry Kazee to go to Winsboro to start investigating the suicide of Little Red Beasley.
To find the truth about Ronald Little Red Beasley's death, Kazey must start with the official version of the story.
Barry goes directly to their sheriff's department there and pulls the records of the suicide and starts to talk to the investigators down there.
Kazi quickly learns that the recorded facts don't add up and that the whole community knows it.
Winnsboro is a little town, and as a little town, everybody
knows everybody's secrets, and they also know everybody's rumors.
And the rumor that Francis Truzio had actually killed Little Red and faked it to make it look like a suicide had been around for 21 years.
Through a series of one-on-one interviews with family members, friends, and caregivers, Barry Kazi pieces together a very different version of events.
Following Little Red's debilitating stroke, rumors swirled about Jerry Truesdale and Red's wife, Francis.
Maddie and I always helped to take care of everything around the house so Francis could be free to stay with Little Red.
Jerry would come over at the house a lot
and I would see them sitting on the sofa or whatever, kissing and making out.
According to the Beasley's then 17 year old housekeeper Maddie Caldwell, the morning of July 6th, 1967 began much like any other.
But I do remember Jerry Truesdale came by the house that day.
Franza went to the car and they talked
and Jerry left and she came and Francis came back inside.
Maddie says that Jerry's visit was brief but as the morning unfolded she noticed a change in Francis.
It was a lot of weird behaviors going on.
She got real nervous after
Jerry Truesdale came back.
Frances told her to go outside and fold clothes.
This is in the summertime when it was hot, and she said that Ms.
Truzel closed all of the doors and the windows.
Francis had the radio turned up loud, both television and the radio.
And while I was at the clothesline, it was probably about 10 minutes or less, I heard a gunshot went off.
I heard Francis running to the door calling me.
And when Francis opened the door, She was all bloody.
She told me, Maddie, come here, come quick.
So I went inside and Lil Red was lying face down with the rifle on the left side.
Francis said he shot at her and then stuck the gun in his mouth and shot himself.
Maddie and others agreed, however, that Francis' disabled husband simply couldn't have committed suicide in this way.
My first reaction was,
why did Francis shoot Lil Lil Red?
I said, there's no way
this boy ain't killed himself.
There was a 22 rifle.
I've been in the coroner's office for 40 something years and I've only known two people that committed suicide with 22 rifles.
And Lil Red Beasley was one of them.
There was no way that Red Beasley was able to get up, get a gun, get the bullets off the top shelf of the cabinet.
load the gun and commit suicide because he was bedbound, chairbound, unable to do anything for himself.
And if police records were to be believed, Red Beasley's death was actually his second suicide attempt in a span of two weeks.
I remember in particular one day before the shooting.
I went to his room to make sure he was okay.
And Francis blocked me and said, oh, don't go in there.
He's tried to kill himself.
He's tried to cut his throat and his wrist.
And when I looked into the room, the sheets and cover were covered with blood.
And he was just like a little pitiful moan.
She called 911, and Little Red was rushed to the hospital where they patched him up, and he went home.
It was barely a week later when Little Red supposedly got the gun and committed suicide.
Barry Kazee, when he heard this, found it very shocking.
He said, how does a man who can only move his left hand cut his left wrist?
If he removed his left hand, he would have cut his right wrist.
So he found this very suspicious.
In fact, it seems the only people who accepted Frances' version of events were the local police.
If you knew Frances,
you would understand
that she
had a way.
of convincing the police that Little Red was in such a state of mind that that would have caused him to try to commit suicide.
It tended to be a town that respected authority, was very insular.
The sheriff was the boss.
And in this county, in that time, I think the sheriff only had five deputies.
And the case had been dropped and no one raised their suspicions, at least to anybody officially.
I was scared.
I was a teenager and the police back then were different than they are now.
They didn't have all the technology and everything that they have now, but nobody wanted to listen to me anyway.
I was just a teenager.
They believed her.
They believed what she said.
While police decided not to investigate further, Red's friends and family have no doubt what motivated Frances'
actions.
Francis, she wanted to get rid of Lil Red so she could be with Jerry Tulsdale.
Jerry came back from Vietnam.
He was handsome and here she was, you know, had an invalid husband and she was attracted to Jerry.
Hardest hit was Red's best friend, Herman Young.
Well, I was told that Francie threw a big party the day after Lil Red was shot.
Herman Young came by Francie in Little Red house that Friday night.
to sit, you know, with Francis, you know, console her.
Herman said he heard all the laughing, screaming, dancing, music.
He said he just sat there in his car and sobbed and never went in.
In the decades since, the officials who signed off on Little Red's suicide have passed away.
Kazi's journey to the truth brings him to the current Fairfield County, South Carolina coroner.
Barry Gaze was telling me about Frances Truesdale and her husband, Jerry.
He said, but as I'm investigating this case, I'm hearing about another husband that died in your county.
And was you the coroner then?
And I said, no, sir, I wasn't the coroner then, but we're working on that case.
Coroner Joe Sylvia tells Barry Kazi he's not working alone.
As it turns out, Little Red Beasley's old friend Herman Young has recently been elected sheriff of Fairfield County.
Herman Young made a promise
that if he was ever elected sheriff, that he was going to do his best to reopen that case.
And Herman Young knew like I did from day one that Little Red Beasley didn't kill himself.
I mean he knew that in his heart just like I did.
And he carried that around for all of those years and I did as well.
Coming up, justice threatens to slip through investigators' fingers yet again.
He said, you all have a better case against Frances down here in South Carolina than we have against her in Virginia.
Why come y'all ain't trying her?
In our gut, we felt like she was the suspect and it committed the murder, but we really had no proof of it.
After a tip led Virginia state investigator Barry Kazi to Winsboro, South Carolina, the suspect list in the roadside murder of Jerry Truesdale has narrowed down to one name, Frances Truesdale.
Detectives suspect Frances may have the blood of two husbands on her hands.
Ann Littrick, who is Jerry Truesdale's sister, alerted Detective Barry Kazee that she thought that Frances Truesdale had also killed Little Red Beasley back in 1967.
Barry told me that it was, in his professional opinion, that it was impossible to have been a suicide.
I think it's a very big coincidence that both of the husbands died from gunshot wounds of a.22-caliber weapon.
While Little Red's death was swept under the rug in 1967, Kazee has made contact with two men in Winnsboro, South Carolina, who've made it their business to prove that Little Red was murdered, Coroner Joe Sylvia and the new Fairfield County Sheriff, Red's best friend, Herman Young.
When Herman Young was elected sheriff, the very night that he was elected, I asked him, I said, Herman, what do you think about opening up this Little Red Beasley case?
And he said, that's going to be my first priority.
All signs point to Francis Truesdale as a potential black widow killer responsible for the deaths of two husbands.
Barry Gazeke said, you know, he said, You all have a better case against Frances down here in South Carolina than we have against her in Virginia.
Why come y'all ain't trying her?
And I said, Well, we're working on trying to get her.
In our gut, we felt like she was the suspect and had committed the murder, but we really had no proof of it.
And so you run into that very frequently where you feel certain that this person is guilty, but you just can't prove it.
Despite a meticulous search of Jerry Truesdale's crime scene, police haven't obtained sufficient evidence to charge and convict.
Now, believing that Francis has killed before, Kaziz team focuses on motive.
They weren't necessarily fighting or talking about divorce, maybe, at that point, but she was having a very active lifestyle while her husband was on the road working.
Barry told me that Francis was probably having an affair.
A search of the couple's financial records provides the final piece of the puzzle.
Barry was convinced that Frances Truesdale had killed her husband to gain a $250,000 life insurance policy.
As far as I know, he was in perfectly good health at the time.
And so the killing, once in this case, appears to have been purely for financial gain.
Investigators now believe they know what really happened that fateful night on the highway.
In my my head, she was driving the van.
Jerry was sleeping in the back on the blanket and everything and she shot him in the head.
I think she planned that whole trip and I think she shot him and then I think she disposed of that weapon and cough gave him enough time to probably bleed out and then was calling for help.
Just like she tried to do with Little Red.
Her whole case when they were investigating Jerry's murder was that she didn't know anything about guns, so she couldn't possibly have been involved with shooting him.
She didn't even know how to shoot a gun.
But detectives discover that Frances's claims don't hold water.
As Barry did more investigation, he found out that she was actually quite comfortable with weapons and had fired them on more than one occasion.
I took care of her at Fairfield Memorial Hospital on a Saturday and saw a gun in her pocketbook.
Ms.
Frances walked around in them days with a handgun in her purse all the time.
And she was intimidating, so people were scared of her.
We surmised that possibly the gun had been in that purse, and that was the reason that she was very hesitant to let me touch it.
Although the case lacks a confession, a murder weapon, and indisputable forensic evidence, Virginia investigators believe the inconsistencies in Frances' story are enough to finally seek an indictment.
We didn't have a whole lot of physical evidence, and Barry's doing what he can, but it's not something that just falls in your lap.
It's a lot of investigation, and Barry did a lot of legwork to pull that together.
Early November of 1990,
we were told that we were going to be subpoenaed because they had, in fact, charged her with the death, with the homicide.
It was big news that Frances had killed another man in Virginia, and basically the talk around town was that she probably killed Lil Red Beasley as well.
What was going through my head?
I say, finally, justice coming for Lil Red.
You know,
that was going through my head.
Coming up, a long-dead victim helps make the case for murder.
He told us to exhumed the body, we exhumed the body.
In February of 1992, 50-year-old Frances Truesdale's murder trial gets underway in Roanoke, Virginia.
She stands accused of killing her husband of two decades, 41-year-old Jerry Truesdale.
Despite their belief Frances executed Jerry in cold blood, prosecutors are apprehensive about their lack of concrete evidence, and Frances knows it.
I think that she had pretty much already made up her mind that no one would convict her with the circumstantial evidence that we had, and so she was kind of emotionless.
Francis remains unmoved as witness after witness testifies to Francis' changing story and the history of gun-toting intimidation stretching back decades.
And I was the last person to testify.
She just looked hard.
She stared at me just like I just had never been stared at before.
And when I finished and got off of the witness stand and walking out, I glanced at her and it was like, I will get you.
A verdict comes swiftly.
I believe the jury may have been out a couple of hours.
It was not a long time.
They did find her for a second-degree murder and that she was sentenced to a 20-year sentence in Virginia.
While Jerry Truesdale's family and supporters cheer Frances' conviction, the legal victory doesn't leave them entirely at ease.
I always had in the back of my mind that she may come up for parole one day and get it and get out.
I was glad that she was incarcerated, but I didn't think she got enough of time for killing Jerry Truesdale.
Down in Fairfield County, South Carolina, Sheriff Herman Young and coroner Joe Sylvia struggled to get their own day in court to get a first-degree murder conviction for the death of Little Red Beasley.
Herman Young, the sheriff, was somewhat frustrated.
The case wasn't moving forward.
And they wanted it to go to trial.
I knew deep down that, you know, that the solicitor didn't want to try this case.
I knew it and of course Herman Young knew it as well but we kept working on it.
Well the very thought that Francis Truesdale could be out without this case of Little Red Beasley's suicide being retried concerned a lot of people.
Ann Letrick said if you all would have done your job back in the days when Little Red Beasley got murdered by Francis, then my brother might still be alive today.
South Carolina's state solicitor finally agrees, but but with conditions.
He told us to exhume the body, so we exhumed the body.
We had a forensic pathologist on site when it was being done.
In order to prove that Red Beasley didn't shoot himself, prosecutors need to track the path of the bullet that killed him 20 years ago.
They want to find out where the bullet had lodged in his mouth.
And it was lodged in the roof of Little Red Mouth.
Little Red, despite being basically completely paralyzed, had somehow managed to put the barrel in his mouth and using his left toe, which is one of the few things on his body that could move, kill himself.
There was no way he could have done any of that.
Based on the exhumation evidence and eyewitness testimony, a grand jury indicts Frances Truesdale for the 1967 murder of Little Red Beasley.
Her trial begins on November 18th, 1996, nearly 30 years after the crime.
The first thing that went through my mind was,
I cannot believe after all the years that I'm sitting here in the courtroom for Francis for just be dying up a little red.
The trial that was decades in the making lasts a mere two days.
In November the 20th, 1996, Francis was found guilty.
The judge asked Francis, did she want to say anything up here?
And she said, no, sir.
So that when he, the jury, you know, sentenced her and told her that she had life in prison without parole.
Everyone greeted each other, cried on each other's shoulder, and they was happy that justice had been served.
I was very, very relieved.
that she had been convicted and that she would be in prison a long, long time and she would not be able to get out and hurt anyone else.
In the years since Frances' conviction, the town hasn't lost sight of their victory.
Letters they have other family members and whenever they see me in the supermarket, they will always stop and speak to me and they will thank me for my testimony.
that was given that day at the trial.
My hat goes off to Herman Young and Barry Gaze
and Ann Lettrick, the sister, because they were all instrumental in pushing and digging and they kept on until they got what they needed to bring justice for the Beasley family, which was so long overdue.
It really made me feel
really good about law enforcement.
More than 30 years after his sentencing, William Michael Dennis still sits on death row.
He is currently housed at San Quentin State Prison.
It's all a light-hearted nightmare on our podcast, Morbid.
We're your hosts, I'm Alina Urquhart, and I'm Ash Kelly.
And our show is part true crime, part spooky, and part comedy.
The stories we cover are well researched.
Of the 880 men who survived the attack, around 400 would eventually find their way to one another and merge into one larger group.
With a touch of humor.
Shout out to her.
Shout out to all my therapists throughout the years.
There's been like eight of them.
A dash of sarcasm and just garnished a bit with a little bit of cursing.
That motherf is not real!
And if you're a weirdo like us and love to cozy up to a creepy tale of the paranormal, or you love to hop in the Wayback Machine and dissect the details of some of history's most notorious crimes, you should tune in to our podcast.
Morbid.
Follow Morbid on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can listen to episodes early and ad-free by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts.