Cosmic Queries – Renaming Time

Hey, you wondering how you can invest in yourself and work towards a goal that will last?

Rosetta Stone makes it easy to turn a few minutes a day into real language progress.

You've heard me talk about Rosetta Stone in the past, and you know that I love the anytime, anywhere bite-sized lessons that allow me to go ahead and continue to learn Spanish so that I can know exactly what my mother-in-law is saying about me.

Maybe you're gearing up for a trip to another country, or maybe you're going to reconnect with family roots.

Or maybe you just want to impress people with the fact that, yeah, you know another language.

Well, now Star Talk Radio listeners can grab Rosetta Stone's lifetime membership for 50% off.

Visit RosettaStone.com slash Star Talk to get started and claim your 50% off today.

Jasla order me amigos.

Rosettastone.com slash StarTalk.

You ever walked around a neighborhood and wish you could see inside somewhere that was available for rent?

Well, let me just give you a tip.

Don't climb up on the ledge and look in the window.

People will call the cops.

Well, maybe you've walked past a place for rent and you wished you could peek inside.

Maybe even explore the layout, envision the natural light streaming through the windows, or plan where your vinyl record collection would go.

Well, at apartments.com, you can.

With tools like their 3D virtual tours, you can see the exact unit you could be living in at all from the comfort of your couch.

And if you end up wanting to see it in person, you can book a tour online without having to speak to a leasing rep.

Really envision yourself in your new home with apartments.com.

The place to find a place.

Chuck, we just did a grab bag and people ask questions from all over the world.

And finally, we know if you wear boxers or briefs.

Not coming up on Star Talk Cosmic Queries.

Welcome to Star Talk,

Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide.

Star Talk begins right now.

Star Talk,

Cosmic Queries.

Oh, yeah.

Chuck.

Hey.

You going to help me out here?

Of course.

Yeah.

Is there a theme today?

Nope.

This is a grab bag.

Just random.

Whatever they want.

Ask me anything.

Let the people speak and ask.

Okay.

Let's get right into it.

Inquiry minds want to know.

Here we go.

Let's get right into it.

Okay.

Eric44 says, hey, legends, Eric here, exercise physiologist and space flight physiology researcher from New York City.

Love it.

Look at that.

Love it.

He says, my question is, all motion requires time, but does all time include motion?

I would say the measurement of time.

requires not only motion,

but something that repeats.

Okay.

Think about it.

Right.

Have you ever measured time with something that did not repeat periodically?

The answer is no.

No, you can't.

A day repeats every day, seconds repeat, everything repeats.

Months repeat, years repeat.

So

where there is no repeated motion, there can be no coherent measure of time.

All you'd be able to do in your own reference frame is sequence events.

This came before that, before that.

Before that.

Right.

I remember in the before, four times.

No, the before, four, four, four times.

Right.

I'm older than you.

Right.

Before, four, four, four.

So now the sequence of events can be different depending on your reference frame relativistically.

You could be moving in a different direction and you will experience those events in a different sequence than I will.

But in my reference frame, like I said, if nothing repeats,

time cannot be measured

with any meaning or repeatability.

So that's a great, it's a fun, interesting philosophical question.

Yeah.

And, but space can exist without a time, I would think.

Space don't need time.

No, it doesn't.

I mean, it's space is like, I'm here.

You know, I'm not going anywhere.

You want to measure something?

That's your business.

That's fucked up for you.

I don't care what you measure.

I'm right here.

So there you go.

That's very cool.

Well, there you go.

Eric 45.

Oh, I answered that quickly.

That was a great one.

Wow.

Well,

we're off like a rocket.

This is Maurice Backer says, Dear Lord Nice, dear Dr.

Tyson, I am Iliada from the Netherlands, and I am 12.

My question is:

What is the one book that every 12-year-old should read?

And my name is pronounced Eli Elida.

Oh, okay.

Thanks for the phonetic there, Elida.

He knew in advance.

Yeah, I called you Ilada and yada, yada, yada.

Anyway,

stop.

No, no.

Okay, Elida.

And I didn't get it right.

She asked, I should read these beforehand.

Anyway, universal respect and greetings.

Delightful.

What a mature 12-year-old.

What a very mature 12-year-old.

That's clearly not written by an American cat.

Without a doubt.

You know?

So I'm very biased here because I only write books that I think people should read to get them enlightened about the universe.

Okay.

And I find gaps in the publishing landscape.

All right.

Scientific landscape.

I say,

I'm going to bridge that.

I'm going to put something there.

I'm going to put something there.

So

I can say at age 12, writing like that.

And plus the Dutch, they're fluent in English.

Yeah, well, I mean, yeah, without the doubt.

Okay, so.

Even though they're freedom to prove to program,

no, that's not Dutch.

I know.

No, you're mixing that up with the Swedes.

With the Swedes, I know, but it's funnier when, you know, I like

Dutch is actually

that's actually Dutch, but it doesn't make for a funnier, you know.

Keep the fruit to protect the bro, makes for a funny joke.

But anyway, you're right.

My book, Astrophysics for People in a Hurry,

has a young people's version of it

called Astrophysics for Young People in a Hurry.

Now, I keep thinking young people should never be in a hurry.

Well, they got to get back to them video games.

You know what I mean?

I got to read this book quick because Valorant is waiting.

Halo ain't going to play itself.

Got to get back to the video game.

Let me see what Neil says before I get back to Roblox.

So,

that book was conceived for ages 8 to 12.

Oh, wow.

Which collectively is called The Tweens.

Right, right.

Right.

And its value is, it's not just that is it dumbed down?

No.

It's, it folds in a lot of my own background when I was that age, because I was a geek kid.

And so you get to sort of live with me through your own years that you're reading the book.

That's cool.

Okay.

So it might still have value to a precocious 12-year-old.

Right.

But if not, then just go right to Astrophysics for People in a Hurry.

It's not astrophysics.

It's real astrophysics.

Astrophysics.

It's astrophysics.

But I have cherry-picked it for the coolest stuff in the whole universe.

And that's what's there from Big Bang.

I call it the book you should read when you don't really want to know the granular details, but you want to be able to have a cool conversation of a cocktail book.

That'll totally equip you to do so.

Exactly.

So there's that.

But then, if he just wants to have fun,

definitely the Merlin book.

Oh, okay.

Merlin's Tour of the Universe.

There's a QA.

He's asking a question and answer right now.

It's illustrated by my brother.

It's just a fun, I think it's a fun book.

So forgive me for recommending my own.

For shamelessly promoting myself.

No, you're supposed to.

That's great.

Yeah, it's not shameless.

I'm doing it with people.

Right.

I know.

And you're like, I know what I'm doing.

Ain't no shame attached here.

So I think he will enjoy those.

I'm certain of it.

Okay.

Because they're written with that in mind.

That's all.

Now, is Elida a boy's name or a girl's name?

I don't know.

I don't know.

He or she?

Elida?

Elida.

Yeah.

Okay, let's neutral.

Let's de-genderize it.

Yeah, we'll call them they.

They.

So Elida, sorry to misgender you, if in fact that's what I did.

Right.

But those, I think any of those three books will,

as Chuck said, you can get some good reading in between video game playing

it's a gonna play itself

all right here's andrew bowen

i'm riding at the edge of our universe since the big bang

and moving with the expansion what does it look like when i'm facing back at us

and what does it look like when I'm facing outward ahead

it looks just like it does here and now oh

we

are at the horizon right of anybody who's at our horizon exactly and anybody at our horizon just sees the universe all around them like anybody else does there you go yeah yep that's right so what will happen what would happen is if you in this imagine this instant go to our horizon in this instant

light from us us

emitted 13.8 billion years ago is only now just reaching you.

You will see all of us as galaxies being born.

Right.

So

this would be your horizon.

That's what it is.

That's how that works.

Well, yeah, that's so cool.

We are all equally as far away from the origin of the universe as each other.

It's like being in the middle of the ocean.

Yes.

Yes.

Yeah.

You go to your horizon, you're still in the ocean.

You're still in the ocean.

Right.

That's so cool.

Wow.

Great question, Andrew.

I love it.

Oh, by the way, we don't know how far the universe extends beyond our horizon.

Right.

Just the way you don't...

There might be a point where land shows up, no matter how big the ocean is.

So there might be a point where you run out of

galaxies and galaxies and stuff.

Right.

But we don't know that because...

Because every direction we look, we see galaxies being born.

Exactly.

So we are deep within a space-time continuum that's much larger than our own bubble.

Yeah.

That's so cool.

But you know what would happen?

If.

If.

If.

if, one day, yeah,

the cosmic microwave background disappears.

Uh-oh.

And that would mean that our horizon, which is expanding at what rate?

Well, it's got to be, well, supposedly, isn't it faster than the speed of light?

No, no, no, no, no.

Just our visual horizon.

It's expanding at one light year per year.

Right.

So in a billion years, we'll be 14.8 billion years to our visual horizon.

All right.

So the point is, if the cosmic microwave background disappears.

and then you just see galaxies up to that edge, that means our horizon is washing over a part of the universe where there is no matter.

There are no galaxies.

Oh.

And we would have reached the edge of any material substance in the universe.

Right.

Cause we're.

Now, wait, is that because we're traveling?

No, no.

No, no.

Our horizon is continuing to move out.

It's because it's moving out.

It's moving out.

It's moving out.

So it will always find a galaxy being born.

Right.

Okay.

Until it dies.

I gotcha.

And so, right, once we get past that, that means nothing's there.

Nothing's there.

Oh, correct.

Nab.

That's finally getting beyond the ocean and land.

Right.

Yeah.

All right.

Wow, that was cool.

Tron Aries has arrived.

I would like you to meet Aries, the ultimate AI soldier.

He He is biblically strong and supremely intelligent.

You think you're in control of this?

You're not.

On October 10th.

What are you?

My world is coming to destroy yours, but I can help you.

The war for our world begins in IMAX.

Tron Aries, PG-13, may be inappropriate for children under 13.

Only in theaters October 10th.

Get tickets now.

The best business-to-business marketing gets wasted on the wrong people.

Think of the guy on the third floor of a 10-storey apartment block who's getting bombarded with ads for solar panels.

What a waste!

So when you want to reach the right professionals, use LinkedIn ads.

LinkedIn has grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals and 130 million decision makers and that's where it stands apart from other ad buyers.

You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company, role, seniority, skills, company revenue.

So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience.

It's why LinkedIn Ads generates the highest business-to-business revenue on ad spend of all online ad networks.

Seriously, all of them.

Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a free $250 credit for the next one.

No strings attached.

Just go to linkedin.com slash start.

That's linkedin.com slash startalk.

terms and conditions apply i'm gonna put you on nephew all right um welcome to mcdonald's can i take your order miss i've been hitting up mcdonald's for years now it's back we need snack wraps what's a snack wrap it's the return of something great snack wrap is back

i'm jasmine wilson and i support star talk on patreon this is star talk with neil degrasse tyson

So let's go to Young Han.

Young Han.

Y-O-U-N-G.

Okay.

Young Han, who says, Mr.

Tyson, I love your work and your show.

Can you talk about the Silurian hypothesis and how it impacts how we should view our own species, civilizations, and specialness or lack thereof here on Earth?

If advanced civilization is so fleeting and difficult to detect in our own fossil record, is it going to be easier or harder to detect in space?

Hmm.

Wouldn't it be fun if we were just the nth

intelligent civilization to rise up on planet Earth?

Or even the nth civilization of humans that had rose up

and destroyed themselves and rose up again multiple times.

So you'd think,

I think we would see a record of this

somewhere in the fossils.

Right.

You'd think

there'd be a statue of liberty sticking out of the ground.

Damn you!

Damn you all the animals, you apes.

I mean, that's an example of a Silurian

civilization that predated the planet of the apes because that was Earth right okay it seems to me we would find a record of it if we find

bones we find

other

fossilized artifacts of dinosaurs from 65 million years ago right then and by the way The biggest mammals of the day were these tiny little rodents running underfoot trying to not get eaten by T-rex as hors d'oeuvres.

Okay, So you can't presume

that there were big-brain mammals before that, because that was the origin of the mammals on Earth

around that time.

Around that time.

Right.

Is there a possibility that the civilization before us were not mammalian?

Okay.

So

I haven't seen any like dinosaur casinos

left over.

No, I mean, just you would see things.

Right.

We're not ignorant of the history of what happened in Earth's crust.

Here's where you'd have a problem.

Go ahead.

You can ask the question, what is the time scale for all of Earth's crust to get subducted back down and come out in a volcano?

Oh, okay.

Because that would destroy all that.

All the evidence would be gone.

Because it would become molten.

And then it would spew out again and cover the Earth.

Completely gone.

Right.

Okay, so different parts of the Earth are younger than other parts.

Right.

The middle of Iceland is brand new.

Right.

Like made yesterday.

All of the big island of Hawaii.

Iceland is on the mid-Atlantic ridge that is spewing out.

I visited there recently.

Yeah, yeah.

It's this, this is a whole new land between where I was standing and another ledge on the other side.

And I did the math because continents drift about the rate your fingernails grow.

Oh, wow.

So I did a fast, and I calculated how many millions of years that would have taken, but still, it's new land compared to other places.

You go to places where it's not regenerated that rapidly and you don't find other evidence.

Okay.

So yeah.

Yeah, it's very unlikely.

Yeah.

Unless the dinosaurs were like the ABC TV show that used to be

called Dinosaurs, where

you never saw that?

No.

I just remember it was a little dinosaur and when I was.

I just remember the cartoon Land Before Time.

I remember that one.

Oh, yeah.

A Land Before Time.

Do I know that one?

It's a cartoon movie.

I don't think I know that one.

Yeah, dinosaurs, there was like

they were just living, they were just living like regular human beings.

They had jobs, they had everything, and everybody worked for one corporation called the We Say So Corporation.

And how did I miss this?

Yeah, and then there was one little baby dinosaur, and every time his father would come in the room, he would jump on his head and hit him with a pot and go, not the mama, not the mama.

In other words, like, I don't want you

get me, mom.

So, this is so this is like the Flintstones, except they're dinosaurs.

Yeah, that's it.

There's a whole world that they a whole world just like the Flintstones, but all run by dinosaurs.

Yeah.

It was a pretty wild little show back in the day.

There's the thing about like the size of their brains, you know, there's an issue there.

Oh, okay.

Just the higher levels of thought.

The higher levels of thought that might not be resonant

in a dinosaur whose brain is.

So it's an intriguing idea.

Yeah.

And I don't, but I don't, I think we would see evidence of it, and we don't.

Gotcha.

And so in that case, the absence of evidence is evidence of absence.

Ooh, I love it.

Which is not always the case.

Not always the case.

Yes.

Okay, here we go.

All right.

This is James H.

English, who says, hello, Dr.

Tyson, Lord Nice.

It's James from Denmark.

By the way, James,

we apologize.

We're so sorry.

And, you know, all this talk

of Greenland, we have nothing to do with it.

Okay.

We're just letting you know.

All right.

It's like, you know, it's like our uncle got into the liquor cabinet while he was on his meds, and now he's just sitting in a chair going, I know we should buy Greenland.

That's what I think.

So I'm sorry.

So here's what James says.

I heard on a previous episode that what we think of as singularities at the heart of a black hole may not actually exist, but I'm not sure I understood.

We know black holes exist.

But what does it mean to say the singularities may just be mathematical artifacts?

Yeah, good question.

I love these.

Pretty wild.

So if you just follow general relativity math,

the object collapses under its own weight.

As it collapses, the gravity on its surface continues to rise.

It reaches a point where the gravity on the surface has an escape velocity greater than the speed of light.

At that point, light does not escape, but it continues to collapse.

When we talk about the size of a black hole, functionally we're talking about the size of the event horizon.

But inside the event horizon, all bets are off.

So the matter keeps shrinking.

According to the general theory of relativity, the gravity is so severe that nothing can stop it.

And it shrinks to zero volume.

Yeah, right.

And wow.

And that's just crazy.

What does that even mean?

What does it mean?

We all presume that there's some other law of physics that's going to prevent that, but that calculation is at the limits of the applicability of the general theory of relativity.

Gotcha.

So that's why we know in advance that the general theory of relativity has limits.

Right.

Limits to its applicability.

There you go.

Right.

Whereas quantum physics have yet to find a limit.

Right.

And we got smart people on that frontier, string theorists, who are trying to send the math into that singularity to try to resolve that problem.

Because if you do, then you reconcile

general relativity with quantum physics.

Yes, you will.

Yeah.

That's pretty wild.

Yeah.

And more playfully, this fact that it goes to zero.

Right.

Some people say that's where God divides by zero.

Because remember, you're not supposed to.

You can't do that.

You're not supposed to do that.

I still don't know why.

I'm just like, you know.

Have you tried it?

Because zero divided by zero is I got nothing.

No, that's undefined.

Right.

That's my point.

But I can define it.

I started with nothing.

I divided nothing.

I got it.

From nothing, leave nothing.

There you go.

That's a good song.

Okay.

From nothing.

Leave nothing.

When I first heard that song, I said, really?

Is that the best math you can give me in this disco era?

I was in high school when that came.

Everybody was high on cocaine.

They weren't trying to do math.

Who are you trying to impress with this math?

Certainly.

I can hook you up with some good formulas.

Oh, that's so funny.

Okay.

Okay, here we go.

This is Michael Trilling.

He says, I'm an artist and I have been working in stained glass recently.

It had me thinking, how can light travel through some materials, but not others?

What makes something transparent at an atomic level?

Yeah, so I don't have a good answer for that.

I have an answer, but I know in advance it's.

It's not good.

Correct.

So I'm giving like a just-so answer.

All right.

Okay.

So transparent media,

there's nothing to change the pathway of the light through the medium.

And so it maintains a straight direction.

Okay.

Okay.

And so it comes out the other side.

You see whatever was on the previous side of that material.

If the structure of the lattice or the molecules or the atoms is such that the light is either absorbed or dispersed, Because it can still be transparent to light, but you can't see through it.

Right.

What's the word for the translucent?

Translucent.

Okay.

Light still gets through.

Frosted Frosted glass.

Frosted glass.

But the path the light took was varied, and so there's no coherent image that comes through to the other side.

There's a little-known fact, as this person surely knows, light travels slower in a medium than it travels in a vacuum.

Right.

It travels slowest in a diamond, which helps it internally reflect.

so that when light comes in from one direction, it pops out a different direction.

Right.

When it's cut, when the facets are just right.

Right, right, right.

So that's why diamonds have a certain radiance of their own when they're just really messing with the light that came in.

So

Rihanna was wrong.

It's not shine bright like a diamond.

It's just reflect, refract

like a diamond.

What was that from?

Ocean's 8?

No, she's a song.

She has a song, Shine Bright Like a Diamond.

Oh, sorry.

Everybody loves it.

It's not shining.

It's not shining.

Yeah, it's not shining at all.

Right.

Yeah.

Is that why they put her in Ocean's Eight?

Probably.

And that, and she's Rihanna.

Okay.

Okay, a couple more.

Go.

All right, here we go.

Alex Romillion says this.

Greetings, Dr.

Tyson and your ragtag team of lifelong learners.

I'm Alex from Northeast England.

My question.

There's a lot of talk about mining the moon.

Wouldn't that be a bad idea considering if we're transferring mass from the moon to Earth, we won't make the moon lighter because of the gravitational effects it has on Earth,

i.e the tides to weaken over time and eventually stop what other effects could it have

regards from a lifelong learner i love it and i love lifelong learners yes thank you for checking in yes okay a couple of things couple things first two things uh so

it is likely that whatever we mine on the moon will stay on the moon or go to other places in the solar system where we're doing work.

Right.

It's not likely that the moon has something so valuable that we need to bring back.

Because we want to bring it back to the Earth.

Especially since the moon was carved out of our crust in a collision between a Mars-sized protoplanet and Earth.

It side-swipes up.

Our crust goes into orbit,

coalesces to form the moon.

And so the moon is

our crust.

That's...

Probably not too valuable.

No, it's not too valuable, not too valuable.

Yeah.

To go there and then bring it back.

So now,

but suppose we did.

Suppose we mined 100% of the moon.

All right.

Brought the whole damn moon back piece by piece.

I love it.

Okay.

All right.

We still have tides.

Right.

From the sun.

The sun.

Sun's tides are about a third as strong as the moon tides.

Right.

All right.

So you still have tides.

Not as big, not as bodacious, but you still have tides.

How much heavier does Earth weigh?

The moon is a little more than 1%

the mass of the Earth.

Oh, that's nothing.

That's nothing.

I ain't doing nothing.

That ain't.

That ain't doing nothing.

That's a mosquito.

So if you weigh 100.

A mosquito on an elephant.

So 100 pounds on Earth,

you'd weigh 11 pounds and a little and change.

Oh, no.

That's barely worth it.

You fluctuate that just

between meals and between poop.

Right.

Okay, you fluctuate.

Yeah, that happens to me every morning.

You know what I mean?

Get up on the scale, like, damn.

Go to the bathroom.

All right.

right.

So, yeah, it's not that, don't worry about it.

Yeah,

it's a big moon, but Earth is even bigger.

There you go.

We good.

Huge savings on Dell AI PCs are here and it's a big deal.

Why?

Because Dell AI PCs with Intel Core Ultra processors are newly designed to help you do more faster.

It's pretty amazing what they can do in a day's work.

They can generate code, edit images, multitask without lag, draft emails, summarize documents, create live translations.

They can even extend your battery life so you never have to worry about forgetting your charger.

It's like having a personal assistant built right into your PC to cover the menial tasks so you can focus on what matters.

That's the power of Dell AI with Intel Inside.

With deals on Dell AI PCs like the Dell 16 Plus starting at $749.99, it's the perfect time to refresh your tech and take back your time.

Upgrade your AI PC today by visiting dell.com/slash deals.

That's dell.com/slash deals.

This episode is brought to you by Progressive, where drivers who save by switching save nearly $750 on average.

Plus, auto customers qualify for an average of seven discounts.

Quote now at progressive.com to see if you could save.

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates, national average 12-month savings of $744 by new customers surveyed who saved with Progressive between June 2022 and May 2023.

Potential savings will vary.

Discounts not available in all states and situations.

You know, between work and workouts, who has time to read every label in your food and supplement routine?

Guess what?

Now you don't need to.

Thanks to Thrive Market.

Their on-site filters do it for you.

Organic, low-sugar, high-protein, you name it, they can filter it.

Then, your pantry staples arrive fast and here's the best part, to your door.

Their groceries are high quality and no junk.

Over 1,000 sketchy ingredients restricted so you can shop worry-free.

You know, summer is a time of letting go, but it's time to get back to your regular routine.

And Thrive Market makes healthy grocery shopping effortless and affordable, giving members clean, high-quality groceries delivered to their door.

No label confusion, no stress, no markups.

Looking to cut out artificial dyes, process sugars, or try out some vegan alternatives?

Thrive Market has a ton of on-site filters so you can easily filter your preferences.

For me, it's all about not messing up my workouts.

So what do I want?

High-protein, tasty snacks that I can snack on without getting my trainer upset with me.

Go to thrivemarket.com/slash star talk to get 30% off your first order and a free $60 gift.

That's ThriveMarket.com slash Star Talk.

All right, this is Bass

Oosterveld.

And Bass says, greetings, Dr.

Tyson, Sir Chuck, Bass from the Netherlands here.

Something that's bothered me for a while is the term time.

Why do we still call it that?

Time isn't absolute, it's relative and experienced differently depending on our motion through space-time.

A photon doesn't experience time at all.

Wouldn't it perhaps be better to rename time in a scientific context?

Would something like observer-related perception of reality not be a better representative of what we should call time?

I'd love to hear your thoughts on this.

Have a beautiful day.

I don't have more time for this,

Mr.

Oosterveld.

Okay.

I have one answer.

So it's a cool, cool little thing that he's

positing.

Time has one syllable.

Exactly.

And what he read there, count the syllables.

Count the syllables.

Observer, relative

perception

of reality.

It's 14 syllables.

14 syllables.

Time has one syllable.

Right, exactly.

So take that word and make it mean what we want it to mean.

And by the way.

And that's the meaning of the word.

And you can't even say

what time is it with his.

You would have to say, what is your observer-related perception of reality right now?

And there's certain things that we do just because it's simple.

For example, our words that describe the sun and the horizon are pre-Copernican.

I don't say to you, Chuck, at what time does Earth rotate such that our sightline to the horizon reveals the sun sitting out there in space?

Instead, I say, when sunrise, When's sunrise?

And when's sunset?

And when sunset.

And I think we're okay with that.

Yeah.

Because the sun didn't really rise at all.

Well, from your point of view.

Right.

But still, it's a simple two-syllable word.

Yeah, right.

So I don't mind precision, but not at the expense of economy.

All right.

Very cool.

All right, here we go.

This is Zach Sweet, and Zach says, hello, Dr.

Tyson, Lord Nice.

Zach here from Moonsville, New York, or Munnsville, New New York.

You've talked about knowing mathematically how to create a wormhole in previous cosmic queries and other explainers.

I was wondering, what is keeping us from taking the mathematics from paper and applying them to the physical world, going from script to screen, so to speak?

Oh, I like that.

Thanks in advance.

I like that.

So

the problem is we're missing an ingredient.

Oh, really?

Yes.

We need matter

or some substance that has negative gravity.

Uh-oh.

Okay, so matter has gravity.

Right.

So matter can make black holes where you're compressing things down into one place.

Right.

And a wormhole requires you pry open the fabric of space-time.

Gotcha.

So you'd be parking this negative matter, this negative gravity substance, in a way that you pried open a tunnel through the fabric of space-time

itself

so we would know how to configure it right how much of it we need right but we don't have it gotcha now there are people who say well what about dark energy that's a negative gravity

in the vacuum of space of space right since we don't know what it is i'm not saying let's set up a factory to make wormholes out of it i'm not ready to do that okay right if one day we know what it is and then we can harness it and then package it and sell it yeah yeah and i'm all in for for wormholes.

Oh my gosh.

That'd be very cool.

I want wormholes everywhere.

Yeah.

Like in the back of your refrigerator connected to your grocery.

Okay.

Now you're going Homer Simpson on

no, I'm running low on milk to check on you.

I just reach into the refrigerator.

I'm at the grocery store, grab some milk.

Oh, no, no, the grocery does that for you.

Oh, he'll just have your package.

Oh, he stocks your fridge from the wormhole.

Because they just open it up.

All right, I'll take it back.

That's dope.

That's totally dope.

Oh, I love it.

Yeah.

Yeah.

You're never low on any supply, and they'll know the rate, and you don't have to go travel.

Yeah.

And oh my gosh.

Wow, that is Fresh Direct Direct.

That's the wormhole edition of Fresh Direct.

So, and there's so many things that we just take for granted require transportation systems that would just be rendered obsolete with wormholes, such as

on Star Trek, the transporter.

Right.

Right.

You don't need to deconstruct

your entire body molecularly, put it into a pattern buffer, and then beam it somewhere and recreate it.

Hoping you get the same thing.

Hoping that you get the same pattern in the exact same sequence.

Bone and neurosynthesis with memories and everything.

Yeah, you just walk through a portal and you're there.

There you're there.

Yeah, that's

it.

Would render that solution to travel obsolete.

Yeah, but it would just ruin like the most awesome effect that Star Trek came up with, which is

it's very cool all right we got time for two more all right we got a lot done today we got a lot done today wow all right here we go am i getting better at giving short answers maybe i think the questions might be helping no i'm joking

yes here we go this is james uh liggett hi y'all This is James from Midland, Texas.

Midland, Texas.

I know Midland, Texas.

The place where baby Jessica fell down the well.

James, let me explain something to you, James.

Let me just help you out for a second.

Stop.

That is not a claim to fame.

Stop it.

That y'all let a little baby fall down a hole

and that you couldn't get her out

and that the whole country

find about it.

The whole country learned about it.

The whole country learned about it before you were able to get this child out of that hole.

Okay.

I know Midland.

It's the Twin Cities there, Midland and Odessa.

Midland and Odessa.

Yeah.

Okay.

Yeah.

The rich folk live in Midland.

Oh, okay.

Well, back when I was there, that was

a very very clearly understood divide

in the landscape.

All right.

All right.

Well, James says this.

Since photons have no mass, how do they carry the image?

of their source to, say, a telescope or an eyeball.

So what does it mean to say we see something because we process photons?

There seems to be nothing there in a photon to process.

Where?

Love it.

In the mass, in the massless energy of a photon is this information that we receive.

This keeps bugging me, man.

So please help me.

Let me hook up my boy from Midland.

Fidel.

All right now.

Midland, Texas.

Midland, Texas.

Midland.

So

here you go.

Here we go.

If you took all the photons and just crammed them through the one little opening and didn't have a lens,

then you would not have an image.

You would just have light.

That's what we do when we take a spectrum of an object.

We take all the light, funnel it down into what's called a slit, goes through the prism or equivalent device, and you see how much

energy, how many photons of different wavelengths is coming from that source.

It's not an image at all.

It's not an image.

You don't know what the hell the thing looks like.

Right.

But you have this many that are red, this many blue photons.

This has extra photons in a particular place because an atom is sending you energy extra in that zone.

And you just look at the spectrum, and that is a no-image measurement of the object.

If you take the photons and have a lens,

then there's a photon that came from your nose, a photon that came from your toe, a photon that came from the top of your head.

It's a different color, but your hair is black, your skin is brown, your shoes are red, and so this will be a red photon.

This will be a black photon.

And the lens reconstructs where they came from.

onto your detector.

You focus it up.

The photon lands exactly according to what the the image was.

So you're right.

A photon alone contains no image information.

You need the ensemble of photons to do so.

Wow.

Dude, that was a really good question.

Yeah, and I hope he feels good about that.

Yeah, you should be.

I learned something just then.

That's really damn cool.

You know?

All right.

All right.

Well, last question.

As you said.

All right.

This is Alan Short.

Short from the Netherlands to Midland Odessa to Denmark.

Yep.

To northeast England.

Well, you're going to love this one.

This is Alan Short from Thailand.

Thailand?

No, I'm joking.

I'm lying.

This is Alan Short from Italy.

Italy.

Italy.

Bungiorno Alan.

He says, with a profound admiration and the utmost awe of Professor Tyson and HRH Chuck Nice.

I don't know what HRH means.

His Royal Highness.

I'll take it.

When I was a kid, when we have juvenile sensing,

we say his Royal Heiny.

Yeah, I was about to say,

because that's exactly, I was going to say Royal Heimparts, but don't, yeah, Royal Heiny.

Okay, according to one theory, our universe is located inside of a black hole.

If this is the case, where is our universe's singularity?

Likewise, seeing as we have proof that our universe is expanding, why are we not seeing other black holes, presumably themselves being self-contained universes, expanding and taking over our universe with much love?

Thank you, Alan.

Brian Green would be better to answer that, so I'll give what I can.

Okay.

All right, so a couple of things.

All right.

Some equations related to a black hole apply to our entire universe.

Okay.

Such as we have an event horizon.

We have a horizon.

Right, we do.

It's analogous to event horizon of a black hole.

Correct.

If you look at the density of matter in the universe out to that event horizon, it is the density of matter you would need to make a black hole the size of our universe.

But is it a black hole?

Okay.

And so if it is, then there ought to be a singularity somewhere

we haven't seen.

We don't know where it is.

Right.

Okay.

And so.

Unless we're just the information of the black hole.

Oh.

And so what we're seeing

is the holographic information of the black hole.

The black hole is is inside.

I want to be more than information.

I want to be a boy.

And

that's Italian.

That's a Pinocchio reference.

That's a Pinocchio reference.

Oh, my God.

We have done it, people.

That is how you stick a lantern.

Go to Italy and end up with Pinocchio.

All right.

So that could be just where the analogy breaks between the universe and what a black hole is.

So you have a couple similarities.

But one last point, and we'll end on this: that the equations of a black hole, and there's a book here that I can dig out that will describe them.

And

our guy correctly noted that a whole new space-time opens up inside the black hole.

If you look back at us, the future history of the universe runs its course, and a whole other space-time opens up.

So each black hole would contain a universe.

A universe.

But that universe is not sharing the space-time of our universe.

So they're worried, will it fill up or bump in?

No, in higher dimensions, you can fit everything.

Right.

Yeah, it doesn't make a difference.

That's right.

You can fit it all.

That's so cool.

Just a quick thing.

You have a sheet of paper that goes to infinity.

Right.

It's two dimensions.

If I go into a third dimension, I can have another sheet of paper that goes to infinity.

And it does not intersect the first.

Exactly.

In fact, I can have an infinite number of

one above the other.

Correct.

So when you add higher dimensions, you don't have to think or worry about, you know, stepping on each other's toes.

Cool.

It can happen.

Right.

It just,

it's not a thing.

Right.

All right.

Yeah.

I think we got to call it quits there, Chuck.

Well, that was a good one.

That was very hodgepodge.

Yeah, I like it.

I like it when they're all over the place and all over the world.

All over the world.

All right.

Very good.

This has been a Star Talk Cosmicquaries Grab Bag Edition.

Those are fun.

Yeah.

Love those.

Chuck, thanks for doing that.

Always a pleasure.

All right, Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist, reporting from my office at the Hayden Planetarium.

As always, keep looking up.

I'm gonna put you on, nephew.

All right, Uncle.

Welcome to McDonald's.

Can I take your order?

Miss, I've been hitting up McDonald's for years.

Now it's back.

We need snack wraps.

What's a snack wrap?

It's the return of something great.

Snack wrap is back.

Honey, do not make plans Saturday, September 13th, okay?

Why, what's happening?

The Walmart Wellness Event.

Flu shots, health screenings, free samples from those brands you like.

All that at Walmart.

We can just walk right in.

No appointment needed.

Who knew we could cover our health and wellness needs at Walmart?

Check the calendar Saturday, September 13th.

Walmart Wellness Event.

You knew.

I knew.

Check in on your health at the same place you already shop.

Visit Walmart Saturday, September 13th for our semi-annual wellness event.

Flu shots subject to availability and applicable state law.

Age restrictions apply.

Free samples while supplies last.