Josh Kraushaar: The Pro-Hamas Left

Speaker 1 Delta Airlines just turned 100 and is already shaping the next century of flight with the Delta Sustainable Skies Lap. Here, they're building the future of flight.

Speaker 1 Think electric air taxis and next-gen aircraft aiming to cut fuel burn significantly. And this isn't just future talk.

Speaker 1 Today, their fleet of Boeing 737s have marine-like finlets designed to reshape airflow that reduces drag. The future of travel is more sustainable, and Delta's leading the way.

Speaker 1 Learn more at delta.com/slash sustainability.

Speaker 2 Even though severe cases can be rare, respiratory syncytial virus or RSV is still the leading cause of hospitalization in babies under one.

Speaker 2 RSV often begins like a cold or the flu, but can quickly spread to your baby's lungs. Ask your doctor about preventative antibodies for your baby this season and visit protectagainstrsv.com.

Speaker 2 The information presented is for general educational purposes only. Please ask your healthcare provider about any questions regarding your health or your baby's health.

Speaker 1 It's October 27, 2023. I'm Trelly Sykes.

Speaker 1 Welcome to the Bulwark podcast, welcoming back one of our longtime friends and guests, Josh Kroshauer, who has a new job, editor-in-chief of the Jewish Insider, also the author of Axios' Sunday Sneak Peek, which I always read every Sunday.

Speaker 1 So Josh, welcome back on the podcast.

Speaker 4 Charlie, it's great to be back with you.

Speaker 1 I have to give people a trigger warning.

Speaker 1 This is going to be one of the most disturbing podcasts that we have done in a very, very long time because I want to lean directly into, I think, the moral depravity of the pro-Hamas left, which my caveat, I am not confusing sympathy for Palestinians with being pro-Hamas.

Speaker 1 Those are two distinct things. I'm also not suggesting that all leftists and all progressives are embracing the kinds of things that we are talking about.

Speaker 1 But as I've learned, that caveat doesn't work with a lot of people because there is kind of a culture out there that the sense that you're engaging in both sidesism or what about ism if you criticize anybody on the left.

Speaker 1 But this is a huge problem. And Josh, look, you and I have been doing this long enough.

Speaker 1 I am haunted by, I think, the worst mistake the people on the right made, which was to not confront the crackpots, the extremists, the people who are out on the fever swamp, because we never imagined that people like Marjorie Taylor Greene or Lauren Boebert or Matt Gates would be significant, that the bizarre YouTube freaks like Alex Jones and Steve Bannon, and yes, I am lumping them in, would in fact ever rise to a position of real influence.

Speaker 1 And then you wake up one day. And you realize that the Republican Party is not Mitt Romney.
It's not Liz Cheney. You know, it is Donald Trump.

Speaker 1 It is these freaks that we all told ourselves were kind of the crazy uncle in the corner.

Speaker 1 And I guess I'm sensing on the left, and I can just feel the comment section exploding here, this sort of the sense that, okay, so there are some really extreme folks out there who are rationalizing Hamas, who are anti-Israel, but you know what?

Speaker 1 They don't represent most Democrats. They represent a very, very small minority.
And it's true, Joe Biden has been solid on Israel.

Speaker 1 The vast majority of elected Democrats have been very solid on this issue. But I want to bounce this off you.

Speaker 1 How significant and how should we react to the fact that there is a large segment, not just on college campuses, but obviously focused there, of people who have decided that three weeks after the atrocities of October 7th, that they are going to rationalize what Hamas did, minimize it.

Speaker 4 To that question, Charlie, I mean, first of all, it's shocking.

Speaker 4 I feel like we can't hit more rock bottom, that you always see a new development in either part, either extreme of either party that makes you just your jawdrop.

Speaker 4 How is this degree of depravity, this degree of extremism celebrating the worst massacre of Jews in any given time since the Holocaust, a pogrom?

Speaker 4 And you have days later, college campuses erupting in celebration. And this isn't just a few fringe people.

Speaker 4 You know, when you had in 2019, the awful spectacle at UVA of neo-Nazis marching on UVA's campus saying, Jews will not replace us.

Speaker 4 That was bad enough, but that was, and then, and Trump's reaction to that was bad enough. But that was one campus in one moment with a bunch of fringe figures.
What we saw, Charlie, this week,

Speaker 4 really the last couple of weeks, is on dozens, if not hundreds of college campuses across the country, student groups on the left, on the far left, marching and celebrating the massacre of Jews and putting out exterminationist slogans and cheering.

Speaker 4 I never thought I'd see that.

Speaker 1 What's an exterminationist slogan? Let's be precise here. So, I mean, Free Palestine is.

Speaker 4 Yeah, I mean, from the river to the sea.

Speaker 1 That is wiping out the Jewish state completely. Yeah, that's true.

Speaker 4 And I never thought I would see. Yes, there's always crazies.
There are extremes. We've talked about campus culture, Charlie, on the show quite some time.

Speaker 4 But the degree to which both you would have the number of students celebrating and ripping down posters of hostages being held in Gaza by Hamas and these same protesters ripping them and tearing them apart and saying all kinds of insane things.

Speaker 4 I never thought I would say that would be like 100 UVAs, right, in one day.

Speaker 1 And again, we're not saying that you have to support everything that the government of Israel is doing or not be critical of Israel, but what is happening now, I think, is at a different level.

Speaker 1 You know, for example,

Speaker 1 when you have students at George Washington University project onto the side of the library, glory to our martyrs and free Palestine from the river to the sea. These are Hamas slogans.

Speaker 1 But this is what really gets me, Josh. The one thing, I want to focus on one thing.

Speaker 4 We

Speaker 1 have had hundreds of Israeli civilians who were kidnapped or held hostage by Hamas, including children. little kids who've been taken away from their parents.

Speaker 1 And there has been this campaign around the world to call attention to the fate of the children. And so what they have done is they have put up posters.
And again, these are not political posters.

Speaker 1 This is an information campaign called Let the World Know. And there's no Israeli flag on the posters.
There's no mention of politics.

Speaker 1 They're kind of like, you know, missing children, the kind of thing that used to appear on milk cartons. And I want to read this article from the Free Press.

Speaker 1 And still.

Speaker 1 People all over the world, especially young, cool-looking people with nose rings and neon backpacks, are ripping them down.

Speaker 1 Across the internet, videos have emerged people angrily tearing down those posters wherever they find them in New York City, in Los Angeles, in San Diego, in Santa Cruz, in Richmond, in Miami, in Philadelphia, in Ontario, in Paris, in London.

Speaker 1 They're ripping the faces of real people who are missing, babies, children, teenagers, women, elderly. They're ripping them to shreds.
I have a real hard time getting my head around that.

Speaker 1 What would motivate someone to think that this is the way I'm going to express my political views. I'm going to go and I'm going to tear down these missing person

Speaker 1 signs. Just talk to me about this a bit, Josh, because to me, this is

Speaker 1 really embodies the moral depravity of the moment.

Speaker 4 This is Charlie the equivalent of Holocaust denial.

Speaker 4 Some of the people who, when they've been interviewed or asked why are they tearing down the posters of hostages, they said, no, no, Hamas didn't kill 1400 Jews. They didn't butcher 1,400 Jews.

Speaker 4 We talk about information bubbles. I mean, the degree of epistemological closure that they can't accept reality.

Speaker 4 You're seeing this not just among a couple of random people, but this is widespread among a lot of folks on college campuses.

Speaker 4 And we talk a lot about sort of, you know, the right wing and QAnon and some of the extreme factions on the far right. That's been a running theme in our politics for quite some time.

Speaker 4 We're now seeing sort of an emerging degree of extremism on the far left. And Charlie, this is really important.

Speaker 4 It's not among most of the Democratic Party, but it's concentrated among 18 to, you know, 25, 18 to 29 year olds.

Speaker 4 There was a poll, Mark Penn, Clinton's former pollster, did a poll that got a lot of attention.

Speaker 4 It's consistent with other public surveys that have been done in recent weeks that, you know, 95% of people over the age of 60, 80% of people over the age of 35, they view Israel very favorably.

Speaker 4 They condemn Hamas. Hamas is as popular as Vladimir Putin among most Democrats.

Speaker 1 That's the good news.

Speaker 4 But among 18 to 24-year-olds, college campuses, it's basically 50-50. There's just this dramatic change at the very youngest end of the progressive and left-wing spectrum, the youngest voters.

Speaker 4 Well, I think we kind of shared anecdotes. We're like,

Speaker 4 these kids are crazy. Like some of the stuff, some of the things going on on college campuses, some of the activists.

Speaker 1 There's real data showing.

Speaker 4 But now we have hard data. It's not just that one poll.
There are other polls that back that up. That this one fringe, this one faction,

Speaker 4 the youngest left-wing voters have a better view of hamas than they do of the the jewish state and that is something that has been a real wake-up you've seen jewish democrats especially liberals these are not these are not these are not like conservative these are liberal progressive jewish democrats who are wondering what the heck has happened to the movement what is been going on on our college campuses and we've seen so many examples charlie of this like at the leadership level where you it's not just the students charlie but you have university presidents university administrators that don't have a negative thing to say about hamas They can't muster the strength to speak with moral clarity about what happened in Israel on October 7th.

Speaker 4 And that's been a real wake-up call.

Speaker 4 I think a lot of folks on the center and on the right knew this was going on, and maybe they didn't realize the scope of it, but it's been a real wake-up call to progressives that are pro-Israel that have seen just the rot that has been taking place at these left-wing institutions.

Speaker 1 I'm going to dive into this a little bit deeper, but I mean, obviously, though, the political implications ought to be obvious, and they are immediate.

Speaker 1 I know that you've tweeted about this, or whatever tweet is called these days. There's a new poll showing a really dramatic drop in support for Joe Biden among Democrats, I think 11-point drop.

Speaker 1 We don't have all of the crosstabs, but is your suspicion that that may reflect his strong position on Israel, that it is young people who disapprove of his full-throated support of Israel and his condemnation of Hamas terrorism?

Speaker 4 Yeah, I mean, that's a Gallup poll that does show a notable drop-off in the last couple of weeks among favorability of Biden among Democrats.

Speaker 4 So it was in the 80s, which is a good position for anyone to be in. And it went down to the 70s in this last week.
I would love to see a test of Biden. Like they didn't test Biden versus Trump.

Speaker 4 And I think when you think about the broader politics, Charlie, Biden has shown stalwart support for Israel.

Speaker 4 I mean, I think that's, in the long haul, probably going to help him a lot more than showing weakness and equivocation when it comes to terrorism.

Speaker 4 I mean, Yes, Biden's caught between a rock and a hard place because he has this hard left base of young far left voters that are threatening to stay home or voting for Cornell West or even voting for Trump in some instances.

Speaker 4 I don't see that happening, but it's a threat that they're making right now.

Speaker 4 But I do think that if Biden didn't speak out, if he didn't show stalwart support for Israel, he would lose support among a lot of pro-Israel Democrats. So that number would also go down.

Speaker 4 And he'd also lose support among moderates and swing voters because... Overall, support for Israel is as rock-solid as it's ever been right in the aftermath of October 7th.

Speaker 4 So the challenge for for Biden is to kind of, you know, he's dealing with, you know, a divided party, but it's important to note that it's a fringe of the party.

Speaker 4 It's like when Republicans have to satisfy the MAGA wing, though, though I will say that this is a smaller wing of the Democrats, at least right now, the Democratic Party.

Speaker 1 And so far, Joe Biden has not allowed that fringe to hold the Democratic Party hostage in the way that the right-wing fringe has been holding the Republican Party hostage.

Speaker 1 So that right now is a very, very important distinction, isn't it? Correct.

Speaker 4 And you've had some of the most outspoken outspoken defenders of Israel, some of them, the clarion calls of moral leadership, Richie Torres, Democrat from New York, Jackie Rosen, up for re-election, Democrat from some of the most outspoken defenders of Israel are Democrats.

Speaker 4 And they're the ones, including President Biden and a lot of the leadership in the administration, have been stalwart and shown strong solidarity with Israel. But they're getting pressured.

Speaker 4 They're getting pressured from that far left.

Speaker 1 Richie Torres is a very young Democratic congressman from the Bronx, quite progressive, and has been as outspoken in criticizing, say, you know, the DSA, the Democratic Socialists of America, as anyone that I've seen out there.

Speaker 1 I mean, really calling them out for their extremism.

Speaker 1 Now, look, critics are going to say when we talk about the people tearing down the posters and these various other things, they're going to say that we're nutpicking, that we are taking a few random extremists and we are elevating them, that we're doing, somebody said, this is the foxification of the bulwark that we're even talking about this.

Speaker 1 But the fact is that there is data, that there's a real problem.

Speaker 1 I mean, your publication, The Jewish Insider, wrote: In the two weeks since Hamas's massacre, Jewish students at American universities have expressed frustration and sadness at official university statements viewed as weak, in addition to being fearful of pro-Palestine student groups and faculty, some of whom about right celebrated Hamas's attacks.

Speaker 1 And we have had these incidents. We had the incident at Cooper Union where Jewish students were chased into the library, you know, where people were pounding on the door.

Speaker 1 Students at NYU chanting, we want it all. We don't want no Jew state.

Speaker 1 We have John Pedoritz writing about this today, that authorities are telling Jews in New York, in New York, that maybe they ought to kind of shelter in place, that there are these pro-Palestinian marches and it might not be safe.

Speaker 1 So there is this sense of fear and menace among Jewish students. that is real.
We're not just talking about social media chatter here. So talk to me about that.

Speaker 1 And I'm trying to remember the last time there was this much overt anxiety and evidence of danger to American Jews.

Speaker 4 Yeah, Charlie, I've never seen this degree of open, naked anti-Semitism out in the open to the extent that we've seen in the last few weeks. And keep in mind, this happened after

Speaker 4 the worst atrocity against Jews in any time since the Holocaust. And look, I'm a fan of data, as you know.
Like, I don't, anecdotes are fine, but let's look at the numbers numbers.

Speaker 1 Right. The data.

Speaker 4 The Anti-Defamation League tracks anti-Semitic incidents across the country. They keep a pretty thorough database.

Speaker 4 And they found that between last year, post-October 7th, October 27th, to this year, post-October 7th, anti-Semitic incidents jumped 388% in that same period. So it's a year-by-year comparison.

Speaker 4 It's a huge, that's not just a spike, it's a surge.

Speaker 1 It's a staggering number.

Speaker 4 And, you know, we've seen the videos, we've seen the pro-Hamas marches on campuses from Harvard to UVA.

Speaker 4 So we can see it with our own eyes, but the data, which the Anti-Defamation League tracks pretty assiduously, backs it up as well.

Speaker 1 This data is important because, again, the blowback that I get is, well, it's just a few people here and there.

Speaker 1 You're blowing it out of proportion. Well, this 388% increase in anti-Semitic incidents has occurred just since October 7th.

Speaker 1 A map of the incident shows clusters in various states in California and San Francisco Bay Area and Los Angeles featured high levels of anti-Israel rallies, some with support for terrorism.

Speaker 1 Numerous protests also took place around Detroit near the district represented by Representative Rashida Tlaiv. I want to talk about her in just a moment.

Speaker 1 Also, you have incidents of overt advocacy for Hamas and outright hatred toward Jews in New England, New York, Pennsylvania, and Maryland. This is again anti-defamation league.

Speaker 1 On October 8th in Clifton, New Jersey, a car with individuals holding Palestinian flags appeared to intentionally swerve out of its lane, nearly hitting a visibly Jewish family.

Speaker 1 Next day, on October 9th in Detroit, a Jewish student was harassed, shoved, called a fucking Zionist while painting a free speech rock with an Israeli flag on the campus of Wayne State University.

Speaker 1 On October 10th in Los Angeles, an individual shouted, I am Hamas, and made death threats to Jewish individuals standing by a kosher restaurant.

Speaker 1 On October 12th in Indianapolis, a man carrying an Israeli flag was assaulted by a pro-Palestinian protester. And this goes just on and on.

Speaker 1 On October 15th in New York, an individual allegedly punched a Jewish woman in the face at Grand Central Terminal when she was asked why. He responded, because you are Jewish.
On and on and on.

Speaker 1 Okay, so Josh, just step back from the politics of the moment. Why is this happening? Why is there this huge generation gap?

Speaker 1 As you pointed out, among older progressives and Democrats, overwhelming support for Israel.

Speaker 1 When you get to this younger demographic, the hope, the future of the Democratic Party, much, much more divided.

Speaker 1 What has been going on that has caused this kind of a dramatic rift, fall off of support for Israel to the point where we have a minority, but a sizable, significant minority, willing to actually rationalize some of the worst atrocities in our lifetimes?

Speaker 4 Well, we could spend the whole podcast going into the origins of this anti-Semitism, but I'll bring up two big points.

Speaker 4 Number one, the universities have become rotten in many ways, where you have the standards have gone down, the kind of activism and far left propaganda being taught to students.

Speaker 4 There's been a lot of documentation of this, been more on the center, center, right side of the aisle, but it's been, you know, this is an ongoing theme.

Speaker 4 And I think a lot of people are like, well, colleges are always like that. And we kind of took it with a grain of salt.
And now you see the product of these. professors.

Speaker 4 These are not just students, Charlie. You had a professor at Cornell, you know, literally spouting pro-Camas slogans, who was suspended for the time being, who was being cheered on by his students.

Speaker 4 And you see, you know, professors all over the country giving leave and excused absences to their students so they can protest Israel and participate in some of the vilest of anti-Israel.

Speaker 1 Okay, but is this really new? Let's go to this point. People will say, look, okay, you know, colleges have always been considered hotbeds of radicalism.
There's always been radical professors.

Speaker 1 I mean, they go back into the 1950s and you see the same kinds of complaints. Is this just the same old, same old? I mean, isn't this like the 1960s? or is there something new?

Speaker 1 Is there something distinctive happening now?

Speaker 4 I think there is something new. You know, the fact that you didn't see many university presidents condemn Hamas in the aftermath of, I mean, there's something different.

Speaker 4 That would not have happened 10 years ago, Charles.

Speaker 1 10 years ago. There's an idea

Speaker 4 you call it critical race theory, the wokeness, whatever you want to call it.

Speaker 4 I'm not an academic. I don't study these things closely, but people have been writing about it, that there's something different.

Speaker 4 There's a sickness going on at the university level where a lot of very extreme ideologies have been propagated. And being anti-Israel is part and parcel of a lot.
It's like buying the bundle.

Speaker 4 You can't be a true progressive in the eyes of a lot of these academics if you're not anti-Israel. So, that's one part of it.
The other big part, though, I think is important, which is social media.

Speaker 4 Jonathan Haight has written about like the changes in our politics after 2013 and 2014 when kids started using smartphones and the rise of extremism within the parties during that period of time.

Speaker 4 That tracks pretty closely with where this public opinion shifts when it comes to public opinion of Israel and even like tolerating Hamas.

Speaker 4 There was a good analysis that was written yesterday looking at TikTok and how TikTok basically promotes all kinds of the most idiotic anti-Israel propaganda to unsuspecting kids that just scroll on their phones.

Speaker 4 By the way, Charlie, there's been a lot of data from Pew that show that among 18 to 24-year-olds, what's the main source of news? TikTok.

Speaker 4 It's not the Wall Street Journal. It's not the New York Times.

Speaker 4 It's not the bulwark. It's not just

Speaker 1 TikTok.

Speaker 4 I'm a dinosaur. I'm 40.
You know, I'm kind of a dinosaur these days. but it's hard to imagine that you would actually get your news from a bunch of kids spouting off crazy things of these videos.

Speaker 4 The data is pretty clear that the youngest Americans, the college students, don't read newspapers. They don't read any real traditional news source.

Speaker 4 They don't even get their news from like a digital news source. They get it from TikTok.
They get it from these closed social media pieces.

Speaker 1 Let's stick with this for a moment because for some of our listeners, Why did it become part of the bundle that if you are left-wing, you have to be anti-Israel?

Speaker 1 I mean, that's not completely obvious, right? So what has happened here? I mean, I think there's been an escalation, but what is the left's objection to Israel?

Speaker 1 Longstanding.

Speaker 4 There's this doctrine that

Speaker 4 propagates that Israel is a colonialist state and we're here to cleanse the world of colonialism.

Speaker 4 And there's been a lot of commentary in recent days about the origin of these ideologies, the revolutionary nature, Charlie, of some of these, how someone could actually defend the bloodthirsty murder of children and elderly and civilians, like what happened in southern Israel.

Speaker 4 Like, it's hard to get your head around it, but there are ideologies that kind of rationalize these behaviors and they're percolating on college campuses.

Speaker 4 But I also think, Charlie, when you ask about the bundle, like we've seen it on the right, we've seen, you know, how is like being against funding for Ukraine have anything to do with anti-awokenness, right?

Speaker 4 What do they have to do with each other? But in the social media age, when people are just, you know, not thinking, but they're just emoting, right?

Speaker 4 That is like the incentive to just kind of bundle all these ideas together and and you're part of this this tribal group and that's we saw that a lot on the right in recent years and we're certainly seeing it on the left and dare i say this is almost even more extreme when you rationalize the butchery of of children and everyone they're kind of in the bundle of people who are oppressed so we have to have solidarity among all of the oppressed peoples of the world including the Palestinians.

Speaker 1 It does seem to be a leap, though. And I think this is what was really shocking to me and to others.
It's a leap to say, okay, I may sympathize with you politically.

Speaker 1 You know, Gaza is kind of a scandal for a long time. But then to watch what happened on October 7th

Speaker 1 and find ways to say,

Speaker 1 yeah, the Israelis had this coming. The lack of visceral, disgust, human.

Speaker 1 reaction to what was done. Because it's hard to imagine more graphic atrocities than what took place here.
And so

Speaker 1 you would think that, okay, people may have an ideology, but still have the capacity to be horrified.

Speaker 1 And I guess this is why I'm drawing this distinction between being sympathetic to Palestinians and just horrified by Hamas.

Speaker 1 I can understand why people would be very disillusioned and very suspicious of the government of Benjamin Netanyahu, who has been very divisive, you know, among Israelis.

Speaker 1 So, you know, nobody's giving him a blank check right now and yet how do you read these stories of the rape and the murder of women and old people and children and then

Speaker 1 decide that the next day you're going to go out and tear down posters with the kids' pictures on them there's something about the callousness and the depravity that seems almost separable from the ideology These far-left activists, Charlie, they view themselves as revolutionaries.

Speaker 4 We've seen this throughout world history, you know, the Jacumans or the during the Russian Revolution.

Speaker 4 I mean, that's the model for a lot of, and then you've seen, and again, I'm no scholar of the intellectual history behind some of these ideas, but that's how they just think that, you know, you need a revolution and you need to have awful things to happen for a revolution to take place.

Speaker 4 And surely I also think a lot of these people are ignorant.

Speaker 1 They're following the mob.

Speaker 4 I mean, I think how many kids actually know anything about what they're, you know, or understand what they're chanting.

Speaker 1 They're going through the high school halls going, you know, from the river to the sea. What percentage of those kids have any idea what that means? Right.
Right.

Speaker 4 The shock is that there's been sort of this alliance of like Islamist groups and far-left campus activists. So, what does an LGBT group have anything to do with Israel?

Speaker 4 But there's these alliances among certain communities on campus.

Speaker 4 I don't think anyone knows at all about what they're talking about, but there's a mob mentality where everyone kind of sees a video on social media, and then all of a sudden they gather and it's a festival of rage and hate.

Speaker 1 Lowe's knows that saving is always top of mind this season. Shop early Black Friday deals like 25% off select pre-lit artificial Christmas trees.

Speaker 1 Plus, get free select Dewalt, Cobalt, or Craftsman tools when you buy a select battery or combo kit. Lowe's, we help you save.
Ballot through 12-3 while supplies last. Selection varies by location.

Speaker 5 Visit your nearby Lowe's on East Starquez Avenue in Sunnyvale.

Speaker 3 Even when you're playing music,

Speaker 3 you're always listening to your baby, especially when RSV is on your mind.

Speaker 3 Bifortis, nercevimab ALIP, is the first and only long-acting preventative antibody that gives babies the RSV antibodies they lack.

Speaker 3 Baphortis is a prescription medicine used to help prevent serious lung disease caused by RSV or respiratory syncytial virus in babies under age one born during or entering their first RSV season and children up to 24 months who remain at risk of severe RSV disease through their second RSV season.

Speaker 3 Your baby shouldn't receive Baphortis if they have a history of serious allergic reactions to Baphortis, Nircevimab ALIP, or any of its ingredients.

Speaker 3 Tell your baby's doctor about any medicines they're taking and all their medical conditions, including bleeding or bruising problems. Serious allergic reactions have happened.

Speaker 3 Get medical help right away if your child has any of the following signs or symptoms of a serious allergic reaction, such as swelling of the face, mouth, or tongue, difficulty swallowing or breathing, unresponsiveness, bluish color of skin, lips, or underfingernails, muscle weakness, severe rash, hives, or itching.

Speaker 3 Most common side effects include rash and pain, swelling, or hardness at their injection site. Individual results may vary.

Speaker 2 Ask your baby's doctor about Bayfortis.

Speaker 3 Visit Bayfortis.com or call 1-855-BEFORTIS.

Speaker 1 Let's go back to where we started, the need of every group to police its own. Give me your take on all of this.
It seems that for the moment, the Biden administration has been very solid.

Speaker 1 The vast majority of Democrats pushing back very hard. People like Rashida Talib seem very isolated in the party right now.
How do you evaluate the pushback?

Speaker 1 I mean, yes, a lot of university presidents failed the moral test here, but at least in the political world, I am sensing a willingness to push back on it.

Speaker 1 And you, at the Jewish Insider, you've done some reporting on this. So what's your take? How do you tally this up?

Speaker 4 Publicly, President Biden has been pretty rock solid on showing his support. for Israel.

Speaker 4 In fact, I think a lot of people don't appreciate the differences between the last Democratic president, Barack Obama, who engaged in some degree of normalization and diplomacy towards Iran and had a lot of top staffers that were much more hostile to Israel than the current administration.

Speaker 4 And I don't think you would hear like a President Obama say, Hamas is ISIS, as President Biden has said. Yeah, I think the degree of support,

Speaker 4 the reminder that

Speaker 4 Hamas started this war and Israel's defending itself, as John Kirby said at the White House briefing yesterday, those are important things to say.

Speaker 4 And the White House has been pretty strong when it comes to showing a moral clarity that you you haven't always seen on the democratic party so look i think i think biden has done a great job in terms of his public messaging there's a concern in israel about well they they call it the bear hug where you know president biden goes to israel meets with the families of hostages shows an incredible amount of solidarity biden's approval in israel has surged in the last few weeks but there's also privately some urging that israel should be more restrained in its uh ground invasion of gaza that they shouldn't maybe they shouldn't you know take out hamas as as aggressively as they want to Maybe they shouldn't open up another front and try to take out Kezbullah.

Speaker 4 So there's concern that privately they're kind of using the capital they've built up to sort of caution the Israelis and not to go

Speaker 4 quite as tough against Hamas.

Speaker 1 You hope they are, though, right?

Speaker 1 I mean, you hope that they are exercising restraint and saying, you know, if in fact you go in and there are massive civilian casualties, that you will squander a lot of goodwill and that you will have handed Hamas the kind of propaganda victory that perhaps they had hoped for.

Speaker 4 On the Israeli side, too, that there's a war cabinet in Israel with Ben-Netanyahu and Galant, his defense minister, and one of the opposition leaders who's now a part of this war cabinet.

Speaker 4 They need to figure it out. There are different views on how to prosecute this war.
So I think that's just sort of a sidebar to the public displays of support that this White House has shown Israel.

Speaker 4 You know, you mentioned Rashida Tlaib, and I think the one similarity I think you're seeing, and we've reported on this at Jewish Insider, between the early years of Trump when you asked Republican lawmakers, what do you think of this Trump tweet?

Speaker 4 What do you think of this crazy thing Trump said? And they claim not to hear it, or they would say, like, I don't believe that, but I don't know. You know, I'm not going to condemn Donald Trump.

Speaker 4 We heard, aside from a few Jewish Democrats that have been very, very strongly pro-Israel, like Richie Torres and Jared Moskowitz from Florida, a couple others.

Speaker 4 But the vast majority of House Democrats claimed not to really Hakeem Jeffries said he didn't know about Rashida Talib's tweet about basically falsely accusing Israel of bombing bombing that hospital in Gaza and keeping it up even after it's been debunked.

Speaker 4 We talked to at least, I think, about a half dozen additional House Democrats who condemned what Tlaib had to say, but would not criticize Tlaib herself.

Speaker 4 So you're seeing that same dynamic where it's like, I don't know the tweet. I haven't seen the tweet.

Speaker 4 I haven't seen what they're saying, or I don't agree with what they're saying, but I'm not going to criticize the extremists themselves.

Speaker 1 Okay, so this is actually a pretty good segue to our discussion of what's going on with Congress right now.

Speaker 1 One of the first things that's going to happen under the new speaker uh the fifth string speaker of mike johnson will be censures and votes on expulsion they're going to have an expulsion vote apparently on george santos they're also going to have a censure vote on rashida tlib what is your sense i'm guessing that that will pass because the republicans have the vote how will democrats vote on that the censure of rashida tlib i don't think it was a smart first move to have marjorie taylor greene be the person who uh wrote the legislation i mean that's just nobody's accused them of being political geniuses here.

Speaker 4 I mean, you're literally looking at the two extremes. I mean, that's where politics are these days, Charlie, that's Bleed versus Marjorie Taylor Greene.

Speaker 4 Look, the resolution, I think, is generally sensible, but there's some language about an insurrection. There were a bunch of pro-Camas people that gathered in a House office building.

Speaker 4 It wasn't January 6th, though. There were a lot of awful slogans, but it wasn't an insurrection.
That's the language of that resolution.

Speaker 4 So essentially, Marjorie Taylor Greene is giving Democrats an out to to vote against this resolution.

Speaker 4 Even though I think you would get, if it was a more sensibly worded resolution calling for Rashida Talib's censure, I think you would get bipartisan support.

Speaker 4 But everyone misses an opportunity to miss an opportunity. That's the state of our politics these days.

Speaker 1 Exactly.

Speaker 4 So, yeah, I don't think that's going to get much Democratic support just because there's some poison language that was written in that resolution.

Speaker 1 Lowe's knows that saving is always top of mind this season. Shop early Black Friday deals like 25% off.
Select pre-lit artificial Christmas trees.

Speaker 1 Plus get free select DeWalt, Cobalt, or Craftsman tools when you buy a select battery or combo kit. Lowe's, we help, you save.
Ballot through 12-3 while supplies last. Selection varies by location.

Speaker 5 Visit your nearby Lowe's on East Starquez Avenue in Sunnyvale.

Speaker 1 Dude, this new bacon, egg, and chicken biscuit from AMPM, total winner-winner chicken breakfast. Chicken breakfast? Come on, I think you mean chicken dinner, bro.
Nah, brother.

Speaker 1 Crispy bacon, fluffy eggs, juicy chicken, and a buttery biscuit? That's the perfect breakfast. All right, let me try it.
Hmm, okay, yeah. Totally winner, winner chicken breakfast.

Speaker 1 I'm gonna have to keep this right here.

Speaker 1 Make sure every breakfast is a winner with the delicious new bacon, egg, and chicken biscuit from AMPM. AMPM, too much good stuff.

Speaker 1 Let's talk about the other big story of the week. After three weeks without a speaker, we finally have a speaker.

Speaker 1 In my newsletter this morning, I'm, with all due respect, you know, the NPR headline is something like: House Republicans end their infighting and elect a speaker of the house.

Speaker 1 And I said, sorry, no, the infighting is not over. They still hate one another.
The dysfunction is a pre-existing condition.

Speaker 1 So give me your sense of this ending where you end up with a guy that we all had to Google because nobody had ever heard of Mike Johnson. Guy has a very, shall we say, checkered, colorful record.

Speaker 1 Apparently, kind of a nice guy, but Edam Kinzinger describes him as Jim Jordan in drag. How is Mike Johnson going to do?

Speaker 1 I mean, how much rope is he going to get from the people who have shown a willingness to burn down the house if they don't get their way?

Speaker 4 You're right.

Speaker 4 I had to go to my almanac of American politics to look at the Mike Johnson bio because he's a bit of a, you know, you know, he's not been a prominent member of the House Republican caucus, but he's a very socially conservative Republican, dating back to before he got into Congress.

Speaker 4 He has strong ties to the Christian conservative community in his district and across the country.

Speaker 4 Even Liz Cheney in her book, or in John Carl's book, actually, said he was a close friend of hers when they first were freshmen in Congress. But when he denied the results and sponsored

Speaker 4 efforts to overturn the election, that was a breaking point for Liz Cheney. On everything else, he's pretty much in the same space.
as Jim Jordan. But I will say that like a lot of people do change.

Speaker 4 I mean, there is an evolution when you're in leadership. It's easy to throw bombs when you're in the backbench or you're not in leadership.

Speaker 4 And it's going to be an interesting test to see if there's any evolution that takes place because that was the problem.

Speaker 4 I mean, look, the best case scenario for Republicans is that he has credibility with the right. Maybe they listen to him more than they did with Kevin McCarthy.

Speaker 4 And if that's the case, then maybe he has. I mean, it's the Nixon goes to China dynamic.
Maybe in a best case scenario, he can keep the right in line and actually forge a more pragmatic path.

Speaker 4 But I think, as you laid out, Charlie, that's not going to be easy. The Republican Party is divided between the MAGA.

Speaker 4 I think the majority, it's fair to say, is now in the MAGA camp, but you still do have a sizable share of rank-and-file Republicans.

Speaker 4 And that's, look, then you have the eight Republicans who, you know, defenestrated Kevin McCarthy and are nihilists that really just destroyed the institution for three weeks.

Speaker 4 So it's not going to be easy for Mike Johnson. I guess the only thing you can say politically is I don't think anyone really knows who he is.

Speaker 4 And it may take some effort for Democrats to brand him negatively, even though he does have a pretty, pretty MAGA-oriented record.

Speaker 1 I think unless they're really, really bad, they will be able to brand him. But, you know, you look back on what happened.

Speaker 1 And, you know, the day before he was elected, I think it was very much in doubt whether any Republican could get 217 votes. Steve Scalise couldn't.
Tom Emmer couldn't. Jim Jordan couldn't.

Speaker 1 Kevin McCarthy couldn't. And so it was kind of remarkable that he got unanimous support.
So a couple of things happened.

Speaker 1 You had, you know, as I described it, the squishes, you know, did what squishes do. They, you know, one after another, they caved in.

Speaker 1 It just felt like that one of the underrated factors here was just simple exhaustion. They just were sick of it.
He was the next man up.

Speaker 1 And all the people who like might have appeared to be taking principled stands or might have cared about some issue, the Ken Bucks of the world, the Michael Awlers, it was like, okay, we're just done with it.

Speaker 1 It felt like an exhausted caucus. It was just done with it.

Speaker 4 Look, Charlie, it was embarrassing. I mean, the Republican Party looked like the most dysfunctional governing on the planet after the...
And they knew they looked stupid.

Speaker 4 I mean, they defenestrated their leader. They couldn't find anyone else.
Jordan, Scalise, Emmer, no one was acceptable.

Speaker 4 These ugly personal feuds, by the way, which continued to this day, are now out in the open. And continued.

Speaker 4 I think it's fair to say there's a bigger or as much, at least as much of a divide between the MAGA wing of the Republican Party in the Congress.

Speaker 4 and like the McConnell wing, right, in the Senate, which has a lot of different views on major policy issues as there is between like McConnell and Democrats, right?

Speaker 4 And on foreign policy, McConnell was actually echoing Joe Biden and supporting the foreign aid package or kind of invasive Israel.

Speaker 4 We'll see what happens in the House, but I know a majority of the Republicans in that body are dead set against anything for Ukraine.

Speaker 4 So we talked about like different countries of coalition governments, right? Republicans essentially have a coalition party, right?

Speaker 4 They have two sides of the party that are increasingly at odds with each other on fundamental issues of what it means to be a conservative.

Speaker 4 And I think that the loyalty to Trump kind of papers over some of those really serious ideological divisions that are only growing.

Speaker 1 And this is what's so interesting about what Mike Johnson is going to do.

Speaker 1 It looks like the Gates caucus is going to give him a little bit of flexibility on not shutting down the government, going ahead with a CR

Speaker 1 for the next couple of weeks. But this is not a honeymoon.
This is a reprieve. Because, again, as you mentioned, the math hasn't changed.
The divisions haven't changed.

Speaker 1 This is still Donald Trump's party. So I guess the immediate question was: will they shut down the government? Probably not.
But what happens with Ukraine and Israel?

Speaker 1 Because that seems to be the one real breaking point,

Speaker 1 not just between Democrats and Republicans, but as you point out, between the Senate Republicans and now the magafied House majority. What do you think is going to happen? How will this get resolved?

Speaker 1 Joe Biden and Mitch McConnell want to link Israel and Ukraine. Republicans in the House aren't going to go along with it.
What happens?

Speaker 4 So I think you're right about on the government funding. I think that there will be something of a reprieve.
The Republicans don't want to go through the chaos of the last three weeks all over again.

Speaker 4 It's interesting.

Speaker 4 Mike Johnson was one of the Republicans who voted against Ukraine aid in the House beforehand, but he did give comments since being elected speaker, signaling maybe a little bit of a degree to compromise or have a larger discussion.

Speaker 4 So the mood in the caucus is to fund Israel, not Ukraine, or at least to separate the two, not bundle them together. And a lot has happened since McCarthy was ousted as Speaker.

Speaker 4 And I do wonder if the mood has changed a little bit in terms of trying to help Ukraine.

Speaker 4 A lot of Republicans in the Senate are linking the fight for freedom and the fight against totalitarianism and tyranny. And Biden's doing the same.

Speaker 4 And it may be a tough sell, but the mood may have shifted a little bit. And maybe Johnson has a little more running room than McCarthy would have on that front.

Speaker 1 Well, I mean, that's obviously, you know, urgently necessary.

Speaker 1 And again, we're in this situation where if there was an up or down vote on the floor of the House, I think Ukraine aid would pass overwhelmingly with a bipartisan majority.

Speaker 1 The question is whether or not he can allow that vote to take place, given all this.

Speaker 1 Okay, this feels like a footnote and maybe even an irrelevant footnote, but it is interesting in the far reaches of MAGA.

Speaker 1 And I've gotten used to now looking at things that, again, you might have ignored before, kind of the cloud on the horizon, you know, because we've seen how fast that cloud on the horizon comes here.

Speaker 1 The number of sort of right-wing media influencers who are going after Johnson because of, and they're holding against him comments that he made back in 2020 that were sympathetic to George Floyd, you know, the black man who was murdered in Minneapolis.

Speaker 1 And at the time, he had some sympathy for him. He said, yes, it was murdered.
And he talked about, you know, the problem of being black in America.

Speaker 1 And it's a very different Mike Johnson than we've seen more recently.

Speaker 1 Well, you have folks on the right who are now saying, you know, he can't really be MAGA if he, in fact, believed that black lives actually mattered and showed sympathy and concern about racism.

Speaker 1 And so I don't know whether this is going anywhere, but anytime these things percolate, you at least have to be aware that there are folks in the MAGA world who are already, you know, planning to, you know, cut him off at the knees.

Speaker 4 Well, look, the lesson from this whole conversation is that crazy ideas that bubble up online can suddenly become mainstream overnight. We've seen that lesson.
Exactly. And we're seeing it all over.

Speaker 4 And, you know, you may joke about it or think it's marginal, but those are the types of ideas that can really atastasize.

Speaker 1 And one of the reasons, again, to repeat what we said before, is this is the real danger of the tribalization is that when you buy in, you have to buy the bundle and you have to buy all the allies.

Speaker 1 And some of those allies are going to take you to places you do not want to go. And trust me, I have lived this experience.
So

Speaker 1 it's with a great deal of history that I am urging people on the left, like, do not downplay what is happening right now because the future comes at you really hard and fast in ways that you did not necessarily expect.

Speaker 1 Josh Crash Hour, thank you so much for joining us again. We're going to look forward to your Sunday newsletter from Axios.
It comes out every Sunday.

Speaker 1 When should we get it in our mailbox?

Speaker 4 Every Sunday afternoon. Just sign up at axios.com to sneak peek and you can sign up at JewishInsider, jewishinsider.com and get our daily kickoff newsletter every weekday, Monday through Friday.

Speaker 1 Which I do. Josh is, of course, is the editor-in-chief of Jewish Jewish Insider.
And thank you all for listening to this weekend's Bulwark podcast. I'm Charlie Sykes.
We will be back on Monday.

Speaker 1 We'll do this all over again.

Speaker 1 The Bulwark Podcast is produced by Katie Cooper and engineered and edited by Jason Brown.

Speaker 1 This is Matt Rogers from Lost Culturalistas with Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang. This is Bowen Yang from Los Culturalistas with Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang.
Hey, Bowen, it's gift season.

Speaker 1 Stressing me out. Why are the people I love so hard to shop for? Probably because they only make boring gift guides that are totally uninspired.
Except for the guide we made.

Speaker 1 In partnership with Marshalls, where premium gifts meet incredible value, it's giving gifts.

Speaker 1 With categories like best gifts for the mom whose idea of a sensible walking shoe is a stiletto, or best gifts for me that were so thoughtful I really shouldn't have.

Speaker 1 Check out the guide on marshalls.com and gift the good stuff at Marshalls. This is Martha Stewart from the Martha Stewart podcast.
Hi, darlings. I have a little seasonal secret to share.

Speaker 1 It's the new Kahua Duncan caramel swirl. Kahlua, the beloved coffee liqueur, and Duncan, the beloved coffee destination, paired up to create a treat that is perfect for the holidays.

Speaker 1 So, go ahead, treat yourself. Cheers, my dears.

Speaker 6 Must be 21 or older to purchase. Drink responsibly.
Kahlua Caramel Swirl Cream Liqueur, 16% Alcohol by Volume 32 Proof. Copyright 2025, imported by the Kahlua Company, New York, New York.

Speaker 6 Duncan trademarks owned by DDIP Holder LLC, used under license. Copyright 2025, DDIP Holder LLC.

Speaker 7 If you're a custodial supervisor at a local high school, you know that cleanliness is key and that the best place to get cleaning supplies is from Granger.

Speaker 7 Granger helps you stay fully stocked on the products you trust, from paper towels and disinfectants to floor scrubbers.

Speaker 7 Plus, you can rely on Granger for easy reordering so you never run out of what you need. Call 1-800GRanger, clickgranger.com, or just stop by.
Grainger for the ones who get it done.