Lorella Praeli on how Dems Can Win Back Latino Voters

Speaker 1 The holidays mean more travel, more shopping, more time online, and more personal info in more places that could expose you more to identity theft.

Speaker 1 But LifeLock monitors millions of data points per second. If your identity is stolen, our U.S.-based restoration specialists will fix it guaranteed or your money back.

Speaker 1 Don't face drained accounts, fraudulent loans, or financial losses alone. Get more holiday fun and less holiday worry with Life Lock.
Save up to 40% your first year. Visit lifelock.com/slash podcast.

Speaker 2 Terms apply.

Speaker 3 K Jeweler's Black Friday sale is on. Now's the time to get up to 50% off Black Friday deals.
With savings this big, you can get gifts for everyone on your list.

Speaker 3 Plus, if Black Friday lines aren't your thing, skip them. At K, you can buy online and pick up in store or get free shipping right to your home.
This holiday season, unwrap love and savings with Kay.

Speaker 3 Exclusions Apply, ck.com slash exclusions for details.

Speaker 2 This Marshawn Beast Mode Lynch. Prize Pick is making sports season even more fun.
On Prize Picks, whether you're a football fan, a basketball fan, it always feels good to be right.

Speaker 2 Right now, new users get $50 instantly in lineups when you play your first $5.

Speaker 2 The app is simple to use. Pick two or more players.
Pick more or less on their stat projections. Anything from touchdown to threes.
And if you're right, you can win big.

Speaker 2 Mix and match players from any sport on Prize PrizePicks, America's number one daily fantasy sports app. PrizePicks is available in 40-plus states, including California, Texas, Florida, and Georgia.

Speaker 2 Most importantly, all the transactions on the app are fast, safe, and secure.

Speaker 4 Download the PrizePicks app today and use code Spotify to get $50 in lineups after you play your first $5 lineup. That's code Spotify to get $50 in lineups after you play your first $5 lineup.

Speaker 4 PrizePicks, it's good to be right. Must be present in a certain six.
Visit PrizePicks.com for restrictions and details.

Speaker 5 This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Fiscally responsible, financial geniuses, monetary magicians.

Speaker 5 These are things people say about drivers who switch their car insurance to Progressive and save hundreds. Visit progressive.com to see if you could save.

Speaker 5 Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary, not available in all states or situations.

Speaker 6 With the state of today's economy, it is more important than ever to invest in products that last for years to come.

Speaker 6 As the seasons shift and get cooler, make sure your closet is stocked with durable layers that stand the test of time from American Giant.

Speaker 6 American Giants' clothes work harder and are wearable season after season.

Speaker 6 Their greatest hoodie ever made is made of the highest quality materials that are cut and sewn right here in the United States. So you're investing right back into your local community.

Speaker 6 Choosing American Giant means taking a stand for American manufacturing and hardworking Americans, something other megacorporations don't care about.

Speaker 6 From fleece to knit, all in a range of colors for versatile daily wear, American Giant delivers everyday pieces designed for everyday life.

Speaker 6 Feel the difference of quality made-to-last clothes from American Giant. Get 20% off your first order with CodeStaple20 at American-Giant.com.

Speaker 6 That's 20% off your first order at American-Giant.com with CodeStaple20.

Speaker 7 Donald Trump has gotten numerous disastrous polls since the election early in November.

Speaker 7 And one of the demographic groups that shifted to Trump in the 2024 election, but has now seemed to at least shift away from Republicans in the most recent November election, Latino, who's there's a recent poll out showing kind of massive, massive shifts just over the past few months alone.

Speaker 7 But let me just show you how they described it on CNN. Here they are.
Let's play this clip.

Speaker 8 The Latino vote, what are we seeing among the polls there? Yeah, what are we seeing? You know, one of the big shifts in 2024 from 2020 was that shift towards Donald Trump, right?

Speaker 8 Immigration played a key role in that. I want to start off with Latinos on Trump and immigration.
You know, back a year ago, what did we see on the issue of immigration?

Speaker 8 Latino voters trusted Kamal Harris more than Donald Trump, but by just two points. One, two.
Look now at Donald Trump's net approval rating on immigration among Latinos. He is 38 points underwater.

Speaker 8 That is a 36-point shift, essentially, from where we were a year ago on immigration. Kamala Harris and Donald Trump are basically tied on the issue of immigration.

Speaker 8 And now on the issue of immigration, Latinos despise, hate Donald Trump. 38 points underwater.
In their mind, he is doing something absolutely wrong when it comes to immigration.

Speaker 7 What about the Latino vote overall?

Speaker 8 What about the Latino vote overall? All right, how do Latinos feel about Donald Trump overall? Let's take a look here. This, I think, sort of gives the game away.
Yeah, oh my goodness.

Speaker 8 I mean, that is the phrase of the day. Trump's net approval rating among Latinos.
In early February, again, he was just two points underwater. Look at where he is now.

Speaker 8 Late October, minus 34 points, 34 points underwater, a shift of 32 points over the course of this year. I should point out this is the CBS News Yuga Paul, but I was looking at the average of Paul's.

Speaker 8 I was looking at our own Paul. Very similar shift.
20, 25, 30 point shifts on the net net approval rating away from Donald Trump among Latinos overall.

Speaker 8 Again, whatever Donald Trump is doing in office in the minds of Latinos, it is not working. They have turned against him in massive, massive numbers.

Speaker 7 Right before that November 4th election a few weeks back, Democratic Senator Ruben Gallego, who has been outspoken and fighting for bringing Latino voters back to the Democratic Party, and he was saying there was a lot of red flags heading into the 2024 election.

Speaker 7 Here's what he said before Election Day. Let's play it.

Speaker 9 Look, I can tell you what I saw when I was campaigning in New Jersey, in one of the most Latino areas of New Jersey. When I was in Virginia, campaigning there in working class areas and Latino areas,

Speaker 9 people are worried about the cost of living, and they're asking where

Speaker 9 is the Republican Party, and where is President Trump? They promised to bring down the cost of living, they promised to

Speaker 9 make things more livable. They promised to go after the criminals that are in our communities, that are here illegally.

Speaker 9 And say what we're seeing is costs of everything going up, and you're separating families and you're racially profiling Latinos.

Speaker 9 So I think you're going to see a very strong reaction tonight from very Latino areas of both states, really putting a check on this presidency and the lawlessness that is occurring under the guise of these Republicans.

Speaker 7 And we did ultimately see that happen on November 4th. And now we're getting more data.
The latest Fox poll shows that Donald Trump's net approval rating is 38%.

Speaker 7 When you go into areas like the economy, I mean, he is deeply underwater, only 61% or 61% disapproval. On the issue of health care, 64% disapproval.

Speaker 7 Here's how Brett Baer had to even address the issue on Fox here. Let's play it.

Speaker 10 But the issue of affordability, the issue of how people feel about the economy popping up in our latest polls, personal financial situation now, excellent, good, 40% only fair or poor, 60%.

Speaker 10 You can see that changing from july condition of the u.s economy also a perception totally upside down 76 to 25 and that changing a bit and then economic conditions for the nation and you personally uh again

Speaker 10 25 positive 76 negative for the nation and then 60 40 personally and as we see ice agents

Speaker 7 invading areas Charlotte, Chicago, Los Angeles, Portland, and frankly, other cities that deserve probably the same amount of attention. Those are some of the high-profile invasions.

Speaker 7 We're hearing from Latinos in those communities who voted for Trump, like this Latino for Trump man. And here's how he described the issue.
Let's play it.

Speaker 11 And Willie, you told me that you voted for President Trump in 2024.

Speaker 11 Do you regret that decision? Tera pientes es a decision.

Speaker 13 Yes, 100%.

Speaker 14 Why do you regret that decision?

Speaker 13 That's That's because it's nothing that's true. It's not true.
You know, and

Speaker 13 the first time he says something,

Speaker 13 and now, example, and the Latino people, we see everything is different.

Speaker 13 And the first time, example,

Speaker 13 he says he go to cash the delinquentes.

Speaker 11 Criminals.

Speaker 13 Criminals. Yeah.
And right now,

Speaker 13 he don't follow to criminals. He go to specific to Latino people.

Speaker 7 I want to bring in Lorella Praelli right now. Lorela, it's great to see you.
Lorella was undocumented for 15 years of her life. She's now the co-president of Community Change.

Speaker 7 And it's great to have you here now for your whole life since you've been here in leadership roles. Before then, you've been saying...

Speaker 7 Got to focus on the immigrant community. You got to focus on immigration.
You got to focus on immigration, Democrats. And I think they've ignored that in 2024 to their peril.

Speaker 7 And just because we see these results and this backlash to the horrific, dehumanizing treatment by Donald Trump of the immigrant population, that doesn't mean that that's going to be a winning strategy approaching the midterms and in 2028.

Speaker 7 So let's first, though, discuss what you saw happen, and then let's discuss what needs to happen, though, to bring back the trust. So first, Lorella, what happened?

Speaker 14 Well, Ben, I don't think anyone should be surprised by the kind of the numbers and the shifts that we're seeing right now, because when you do, when your government carries out this kind of coordinated campaign to tear millions of families and hardworking people from their communities, people who are raising children, building neighborhoods, creating the kind of culture and society.

Speaker 14 and life that makes this country run and that makes this country what it is, people are going to turn against you.

Speaker 14 And so I want to start with where we are right now, because unless you're living inside of one of these communities, unless you've seen routines break down overnight, unless you've watched the fear on a parent's face when they hear a knock on the door, unless you've seen a child afraid to go to school, it's almost impossible to grasp the scale of what is happening right now around our country.

Speaker 14 And so the mistake and the strategic errors that Democrats have made time and time again is to pretend that it's not happening, to pretend that Republicans aren't leading with immigration as their issue, and to

Speaker 14 think that, you know, by not leaning in and by not having an affirmative vision on what to do on immigration, that that's enough, that it'll go away.

Speaker 14 And what I think is that the assault that we're seeing right now isn't only physical or psychological, it's also economic.

Speaker 14 And that's what the results of the off-year elections told us: that the administration's actions are hitting everyone's daily lives. And we can talk about that more.

Speaker 7 Let's talk about that more right now, which is the economic impact. We know psychological.

Speaker 7 You see what's happening.

Speaker 7 Literally invasions of cities, rounding up brown people, throwing them into concentration camps, going into restaurants, stores, Home Depot parking lots, food vendors, farms.

Speaker 7 And the Trump regime spokespeople are like, yeah, whatever. We do what we're going to do.
They're, you know,

Speaker 7 making no distinction between criminals, as we saw that one person say before, and they view if you're here, whether you're undocumented or even if you were on temporary status or even if you're a citizen and your skin is brown,

Speaker 7 they round you up, psychological, physical.

Speaker 7 Let's talk about economic, though, because Trump went in and was also kind of promising economic riches right around the corner, and I'm going to uplift you. Democrats kind of ignored that.

Speaker 7 And so Trump's scam seemed to override any message about economic prosperity that could have been made. So, talk us through that.

Speaker 14 Well, I think what you see across the country is that families are facing skyrocketing prices for food, for housing, child care, elder care, and immigration policies directly tie to these, right?

Speaker 14 And so, recently we saw that the Department of Labor actually acknowledged that current policies are hurting farms. They're making it harder to hire workers.
They're driving up the price of food.

Speaker 14 And so, you have all these industries that rely on immigrant immigrant labor, constructure,

Speaker 14 construction, home health care, child care. They're also seeing the strain.
And that translates directly into higher costs for everyday families, right?

Speaker 14 So groceries, housing, childcare, the building of new homes. These are policies that target.

Speaker 14 The policies that target immigrant communities actually make life more expensive and more precarious for everyone. And so we have to think of immigration policy as economic policy.

Speaker 14 And here's the catch with Latino voters.

Speaker 14 It's not a net gain for Democrats when they turn against Trump because Democrats are not actually making a compelling case about what the future needs to look like. And so

Speaker 14 I think that that's where the opportunity is right now. And to understand that Republicans have said, well, we are not only against.
illegal immigration.

Speaker 14 We're not only trying to target and round up undocumented people. We actually want to shut down all legal avenues of immigration in this country.
So they're against all legal channels.

Speaker 14 And what Democrats need to do in this moment is actually lay out that compelling economic vision and say, that is also how we lean into immigration in this country.

Speaker 14 But this idea that you don't have to talk about it creates a vacuum. And in that vacuum, the right fills it with lies, with scapegoating, and with fear.

Speaker 7 Let's talk about what the future needs to look like in just a moment. But one of the things I want to ask you is how should Democrats or just people in general handle the fact that Donald Trump has

Speaker 7 these kind of plants in Latino communities who are community leaders who frequently sell out the community and they make these promises and they're trusted people sometimes on the media and the radio stations.

Speaker 7 Frequently they start on the media like Congresswoman Salazar and then become Congress members because they were in people's living rooms. And the people in Florida trust them.

Speaker 7 And she's got a compelling story. Her family fled the Castro regime and she's Cuban.

Speaker 7 And I've been through communism. And

Speaker 7 I'm here to stop communism. And the left is communist.

Speaker 7 Let me just show you, you know, this is their message that they run with. And while we may go, and I think Democrats at their peril said, nobody believes this crap.

Speaker 7 We all know that she's, you know, this stuff worked in 2024. So let me just show you Congresswoman Salazar right after the 2024 election.
She made a promise. I promise you, I spoke to Trump.

Speaker 7 He's only going after the bad guys, the bad ombre. He's not going after you.
Trust me. And she does it in her very charismatic way.
Here, play this clip.

Speaker 12 I am sure that we're not, that the Trump administration is not going to be targeting those people who have been here for more than five years, that have American kids, that don't have criminal records, that have been working in the economy and paying taxes.

Speaker 12 I am sure that they're going to hone in on the criminals who arrived less than four years ago.

Speaker 12 Because I wrote the Dignity Act, and I am the first one who understands that you have to give some type of dignity to those who have been here for more than five years, people who have roots in the country, not people who are coming to commit crimes.

Speaker 15 If I can just clarify from you, have you received those kinds of details from anyone in a potential Trump administration? Because so far what we've heard is is a proposal for mass deportations.

Speaker 15 We have about 30 seconds left. Have you gotten those assurances?

Speaker 12 Mass deportation to those who are committing crimes, who have been here for less than five years.

Speaker 12 You understand that you have millions of undocumented who are contributing with the economy and are helping our country to be a better one.

Speaker 7 You know, I haven't been undocumented in my life. I come into this interview and life with a degree of privilege that I just hope every day I can utilize it to shed light on certain issues.

Speaker 7 But I understand how an undocumented population that is trying to live what they view as an American dream sees a compelling person like that on TV, you know, and she's well-spoken and she's energetic and she goes, I promise you, he's not doing this.

Speaker 7 We're in the, look at me. I'm like you.
And then boom, they destroy. How do we deal with that?

Speaker 14 Well, I think there are a few things. One is the Democratic Party lost credibility with Latino voters for many years, right?

Speaker 14 Every year, every four-year cycle, they would make this promise: we're going to do comprehensive immigration reform. We're going to legalize people who have been here for a long time.
That's one.

Speaker 14 So they lost credibility. In this last election, what we saw is people said, well, they're not going to do anything about it.
Trump is going to target criminals.

Speaker 14 And so instead, we want to vote for someone who has something to promise and something promising promising to say about the economy. And that's how they end up voting for Trump.
And now

Speaker 14 the Trump administration, in the way that it is not bringing down the cost of living, you know, we have an affordability crisis in this country.

Speaker 14 And also in the ways in which they are targeting communities across this country, they're racially profiling you.

Speaker 14 If you speak Spanish, if you are brown, if you're Latino, you know, they've been authorized to go after you based on what kind of occupation you do.

Speaker 14 So they're going into people's lawns and targeting workers.

Speaker 14 What happens now is what is the vision that Democrats have that actually pull that Democrats have that can pull Latinos back into a place of, I can vote for you with more confidence.

Speaker 14 And that is not going to happen, just to be really clear, Ben. only by being against Trump.

Speaker 14 And by the way, I don't see enough of our national Democratic leaders making the case today or being outraged about what is happening, but also putting forth a new vision.

Speaker 14 And so we can't go back to a system that didn't work because the system we've had for a long time doesn't work.

Speaker 14 And, you know, it doesn't actually benefit working families and communities that are struggling across the country.

Speaker 14 But we, so we have to push back against the cruelty while also saying we can build an immigration system that allows families to reunify, that allows us to have farm workers to feed the country, that allows us to have home health care workers for our elders and entrepreneurs to create jobs.

Speaker 14 And this is a place where they can actually lead, showing that immigration policy can be humane and also strategically align with the future of this country. And so

Speaker 14 that's the work ahead. And you have to do it by investing on the ground, right? So I also did Latino vote work before in the electoral context.

Speaker 14 And what we've seen for a long time is that Republicans have have been making investments over time, building these trusted voices, building these trusted messengers.

Speaker 14 And Democrats have totally abandoned that because they have always made this wrong assumption about us and the Latino electorate, which is you're just in a mobilization category.

Speaker 14 I don't have to do any work to persuade you. You're already going to vote for us.
And I think Latinos got fed up and they said, absolutely not. You are not delivering for my community right now.

Speaker 14 And I am not going to give you my vote. You're not actually earning it.
And that's the opportunity now.

Speaker 7 And I think it's an opportunity that should absolutely not be squandered. There's clearly a

Speaker 7 openness right now for any trust that may have been breached heading into 2024 because of just the horrific treatment by the Trump regime. I think there's now a, hey, you're going to...

Speaker 7 You're going to support me because I don't want to support this, but are you with me in a way, though, that I think everybody recognizes? We don't want criminals here.

Speaker 7 You could still say all of these things. No one wants criminals.
No one wants terrorists. We should absolutely make sure that people are brought to justice who engage in all of that.

Speaker 7 But we also need a humane, dignified process that recognizes the way the country works.

Speaker 7 And I hope there's an openness for that now and an honest dialogue about that and a view that we should defend basic human dignity, like basic humanity, because seeing these ICE Gestapo roam the streets like SS troopers and, you know, and go through neighborhoods, I mean, it is, it is a tragic thing indeed.

Speaker 7 Anything you want to say before we go?

Speaker 14 Well, Ben, in every way, every day, ordinary people are already leading the way, right? So all of these neighborhoods around the country that are organizing and taking matters into their own hands.

Speaker 14 they are already doing that with courage. They're already being brave.
They're already showing up.

Speaker 14 And so I actually think this is a time when elected officials need to follow the playbook of people on the ground and get that courage themselves, find that fire themselves, because we're absolutely, absolutely not going to come out of this moment stronger or with a winning path for the future unless they get the cojones to actually lead in this moment.

Speaker 7 Well, Lorella Perelli, it's great to have you here. Great to have this conversation.
A compelling story, Lorella, just the fact that you were undocumented for so long,

Speaker 7 leading in the community in a positive way, co-president of Community Change. Thanks so much for joining us.

Speaker 14 Thank you, Ben.

Speaker 7 Everybody, hit subscribe. Let's get to 6 million subscribers.

Speaker 5 Want to stay plugged in?

Speaker 16 Become a subscriber to our Substack at MidasPlus.com. You'll get daily recaps from Ron Pilipkowski, ad-free episodes of our podcast, and more exclusive content only available at midasplus.com.