Atul Gawande on Elon Musk’s “Surgery with a Chainsaw”

Speaker 1 This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever think about switching insurance companies to see if you could save some cash?

Speaker 1 Progressive makes it easy to see if you could save when you bundle your home and auto policies. Try it at progressive.com.
Progressive casualty insurance company and affiliates.

Speaker 1 Potential savings will vary, not available in all states.

Speaker 2 The New Yorker Radio Hour is supported by Dell. It's time for Black Friday, Dell Technologies' biggest sale of the year.

Speaker 2 Enjoy huge savings on select PCs like the 16 Plus, featuring Intel Core ultra-processors.

Speaker 2 And with built-in advanced features, it's the PC that helps you do more faster. Plus, earn Dell rewards and enjoy many other benefits like free shipping, price match guarantee, and expert support.

Speaker 2 They also have huge deals on accessories that pair perfectly with your Dell PC and make perfect gifts for everyone on your list. Shop now at dell.com/slash deals.

Speaker 3 This is the New Yorker Radio Hour, a co-production of WNYC Studios and the New Yorker.

Speaker 4 Welcome to the New Yorker Radio Hour. I'm David Remnick.

Speaker 4 Two weeks after the inauguration of Donald Trump, the new president's chief campaign funder, his consolieri, and the richest man in the world, Elon Musk, tweeted in a tone of glee.

Speaker 4 We spent the weekend feeding U.S. aid into a wood chipper.

Speaker 4 Musk was, of course, referring to the Agency for International Development, an agency that has saved millions of lives.

Speaker 4 If the power of the United States means something positive around the world, the efforts of thousands of foreign aid workers in U.S.

Speaker 4 aid, doctors, nurses, logistics experts of all kinds, have a lot to do with that. But Musk and Trump see it otherwise and they have decimated the agency.
Into the wood chipper it has gone.

Speaker 4 Now the courts have blocked aspects of the federal purge of USAID, but the damage can't easily be undone. Atul Gawanda was a senior leader of USAID during the Biden administration.

Speaker 4 He ran critical health programs all over the world. Gawanda is a surgeon, an author, and my longtime colleague writing for The New Yorker.
He's been watching in absolute horror.

Speaker 4 as the agency has been summarily pulped. We spoke last week.

Speaker 4 Atul, President Biden appointed you as the Assistant Administrator for Global Health at USAID, and you stepped down on Trump's inauguration day.

Speaker 4 And he immediately began targeting USAID with an executive order that halted all foreign aid. Did you know or did you intuit

Speaker 4 that Trump would act the way he has?

Speaker 5 No idea.

Speaker 5 Previous Trump administration, they had

Speaker 5 embraced what they themselves called the normals. They had a head of USAID who was devoted to the idea of development and soft power in the world.

Speaker 5 Now, they had their own wrinkle on it, which I didn't disagree with. They called it the journey to self-reliance.

Speaker 5 They wanted to invest in Africa, in Asia, in Latin America to enable stronger economies, more capacity. And we weren't doing enough of that.

Speaker 5 And I actually continued much of the work that had occurred during that time.

Speaker 4 Well, tell me a little bit about what you were in charge of, what the good that was being done in the world.

Speaker 5 Yeah, so this is a job where I had 2,500 people between DC and 65 countries around the world working on advancing health

Speaker 5 and protecting Americans from diseases and outbreaks abroad.

Speaker 5 And the aim was to work with country to build their systems so that we protected the global health security and improved global outcomes of everything from reducing HIV AIDS and other infectious diseases like malaria and TB

Speaker 5 to strengthening primary health care systems so those countries would move on from depending on aid from donors.

Speaker 5 That work, in three years we documented being able to save more than 1.2 million lives after COVID alone.

Speaker 4 Let's pause on that. Yeah.

Speaker 4 Your part of USAID was responsible demonstrably for saving 1.2 million lives.

Speaker 5 Yeah. Part of my target was reduce the percentage of deaths in any given country that occur before the age of 50.

Speaker 5 And teams would focus on what were the top three to five killers. And in some places, that would be HIV.
In some places, that would be TB.

Speaker 5 It would include, you know, safe childbirth was a huge part of the work.

Speaker 4 What in the world was the case against this kind of work? What could possibly be the case against it?

Speaker 5 So one case is that it could have been more efficient, right?

Speaker 5 That Americans imagine huge sums of money going to this work that, you know, polls show that they that they think that a quarter of our spending goes to foreign aid.

Speaker 4 So it's a minuscule amount.

Speaker 5 Yes.

Speaker 5 On a budget for our global health work that is half the budget of the hospital I did surgery in here in Boston, we reached hundreds of millions of people with programs that saved lives by the millions.

Speaker 5 It is at a level of scale I could never imagine experiencing. So the case against it is,

Speaker 5 you know, I woke up one day to find Elon Musk tweeting that this was a criminal enterprise, that this was democratic money laundering, that this was corruption.

Speaker 4 Where would he get this idea? Where does this mythology come from?

Speaker 5 Well, what's hard to pace apart is what is just willful

Speaker 5 ignorance, not just ignorance, it's lying, right?

Speaker 5 For example, there's a statistic that they push that only 10%

Speaker 5 of U.S. AIDS

Speaker 5 dollars actually got to recipients in the world. Now, this is a woful distortion of a statistic that says only 10% of U.S.

Speaker 5 AIDS funding went to local organizations as opposed to multinational organizations and others. There's a legitimate criticism to be made that that should be higher.

Speaker 5 More local organizations get the funds. I did a lot of work that raised those numbers considerably, got it to 30%.

Speaker 5 But that was not the debate they're having. They're claiming that the money is not actually reaching people and that corruption is taking it away.

Speaker 5 When in fact, the ability to get to enormous numbers of people has been a best buy in health and in humanitarian assistance for a long time.

Speaker 4 Now, the overall agency, as I understand it, had about 10,000 people working for it. How many are working at USAID now?

Speaker 5 Yeah, actually, the number is about 13,000.

Speaker 5 Over 80% of the contracts have been terminated,

Speaker 5 representing the work that is done by USAID and the

Speaker 5 for-profit and not-for-profit organizations they work with, like Catholic relief services and things like that.

Speaker 5 And more than 80% of the staff have been put on administrative leave, terminated, or dismissed one way or the other.

Speaker 4 So it's been obliterated.

Speaker 5 It has been dismantled. It is dying.
I mean, at this point, it is six weeks in.

Speaker 5 You have had 20 million people with HIV, for example, including 500,000 children who have received medicines that keep them alive, who've now been cut off for six weeks.

Speaker 4 A lot of people are going to die as a result of this. Am I wrong?

Speaker 5 Yeah. The internal estimates are that over 160,000 will die from malaria per year from the abandonment of these programs if they're not restored.

Speaker 5 That we're talking about 20 million people dependent on HIV medicines, and you have to calculate how many you think will get back on and how many will die in a year.

Speaker 5 But you know, you're talking hundreds of thousands in year one at a minimum. Just on the reduction in immunizations, you're talking about more than a million estimated deaths.

Speaker 4 I'm sorry, Atul, I have to stop my cool journalistic questioning and say, this is nothing short of outrageous. And how is it possible that this is happening?

Speaker 4 Obviously, these facts are filtering up to Elon Musk, to Donald Trump, and to the administration at large, and they don't care.

Speaker 5 The logic is to deny the reality, either because they simply don't want to believe it, that they're so steeped in the idea that government officials are corrupt and lazy and unable to deliver anything, and that a group of young 20-something engineers will fix it all, or

Speaker 5 they are indifferent. And when he waves around the chainsaw, we're seeing what surgery on the US government with a chainsaw looks like at USAID.
And it's just the beginning of the playbook.

Speaker 5 This was the soft target, right? This is affecting people abroad. It's tens of thousands of jobs at home.
So there's harm here. There's disease that it will get here, et cetera.

Speaker 5 But it was the easy target, and now it's being brought to NIH, to CDC.

Speaker 4 So the National Institute of Health, Center for Disease Control, and other such bureaucracies who do equal medical good will also get slammed.

Speaker 5 Are being slammed.

Speaker 4 From the outside, at least, Atul, and maybe from your vantage point as well, this looks like absolute chaos.

Speaker 4 I've been reading this week that staff posted overseas are stranded, fired without a plane ticket home. From the inside, what does it look like?

Speaker 5 One example, I have had people I've spoken to, you know, one case, a pregnant woman in their third trimester of pregnancy in a conflict zone, and they have maternity leave just like everybody else, but because the contracts had been turned off, couldn't get a flight out and were not guaranteed safe passage and couldn't get care for her complications and ended up having to get cared for locally in a place without the setup for being able to address her needs.

Speaker 5 One person said to me that I spoke to, she said, as she's enduring these things,

Speaker 5 my government is attacking me.

Speaker 5 We ought to be ashamed. Our entire system of checks and balances has failed us.

Speaker 4 Where is the agency most active? Who is it helping?

Speaker 4 And

Speaker 4 what's been the reaction in these countries, in the governments and among the people? I mean, the sense of abandonment

Speaker 4 must be intense on all sides.

Speaker 5 So I'll say there are broadly three areas. The biggest part of USAID is it's the FEMA for

Speaker 5 disasters abroad. It's called Bureau of Humanitarian Assistance, and they bring earthquake response, wildfire response, in conflicts, you know, famines.

Speaker 5 These are the people who suit up and get assistance and stabilize places where things are going wrong. You know, John F.

Speaker 5 Kennedy, when he formed USAID in 1961, said it was to counter the adversaries of freedom and to provide compassionate support for the development of the world. And those components are the ones where

Speaker 5 it's

Speaker 5 USAID has kept Ukraine's not only health system going, made important vital support to keep their energy infrastructure going as Russia attacked it, right?

Speaker 5 In Haiti,

Speaker 5 this is the response team that has sought to stabilize what's become a gang-controlled major part of the country.

Speaker 5 And our health teams kept almost half of the primary health care system for the population going. So around the world, stopping fentanyl flow,

Speaker 5 all of that has been wiped out completely.

Speaker 5 And in many cases, the people behind that work, I mean, many of the people were working with local partners to keep these things going, those partners are being attacked in country after country.

Speaker 4 Aaron Powell, what you're describing, beyond simple human compassion, is soft power. Describe what that is.
Why is it so important to the United States and to the world?

Speaker 4 And what will squandering it, what will destroying it, mean?

Speaker 5 The

Speaker 5 tools of foreign policy, as I've learned, are defense, diplomacy, and development. And the development part is the soft power part.

Speaker 5 We're not sending troops into Asia and into Africa and into Latin America.

Speaker 5 We're sending hundreds of thousands of civilians without uniforms who are there to represent the United States, to pursue common goals together, whether it's stemming the tide of fentanyl coming across the border, addressing climate disasters, protecting the world from disease.

Speaker 5 And that soft power is a reflection of our values, what we stand for, our strong belief in freedom, self-determination, and advancement of people's economies.

Speaker 5 bringing more stability and peace to the world. That is the fundamental nature of soft power, that we're not what Trump is currently trying to create.

Speaker 5 A world of simply might makes right, and you do what we tell you, because that does not create stability.

Speaker 5 It creates chaos and destruction.

Speaker 4 I'm speaking with Atul Galande. More in a moment.

Speaker 6 WNYC Studios is supported by Quince.

Speaker 3 I don't know about you, but I love fall.

Speaker 7 Crisp mornings, apple picking, and an excuse to break out my favorite layering pieces from Quince. This season's lineup is simple, but smart and easy with Quince.

Speaker 7 $50 Mongolian cashmere sweaters that feel like an everyday luxury, and wool coats that are equal parts stylish and durable.

Speaker 7 Their denim nails the fit and everyday comfort all at a fraction of what you'd expect to pay.

Speaker 7 And let's not forget that the holidays are right around the corner, and Quince has everything you'll need for gifts they'll love: stellar knife sets, luxurious bath towels, an impressive line of skincare.

Speaker 7 It's going to be hard not to keep all this stuff for myself. Give and get timeless holiday staples that last this season with Quince.

Speaker 7 Go to quince.com/slash radio hour for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada too.

Speaker 7 Q-U-I-N-C-E.com/slash RadioHour to get free shipping and 365-day returns. Quince.com/slash radio hour.

Speaker 2 The New Yorker Radio Hour is supported by Dell, introducing your new Dell PC, powered by the Intel Core Ultra Processor. It helps you handle a lot, even when your holiday to-do list gets to be a lot.

Speaker 2 Because it's built with all-day battery, plus powerful AI features that help you do it all with ease, from editing images to drafting emails to summarizing large documents to multitasking.

Speaker 2 So you can organize your holiday shopping and make custom holiday decor and search for great holiday deals and respond to holiday requests and customer questions and customers requesting custom things and plan the perfect holiday dinner for vegans, vegetarians, pescatarians, and Uncle Mike's carnivore diet.

Speaker 2 Luckily, you can get a PC that helps you do it all faster, so you can get it all done. That's the power of a Dell PC with Intel Inside, backed by Dell's Price Match Guarantee.

Speaker 2 Get yours today at dell.com slash holiday. Terms and conditions apply.
See Dell.com for details.

Speaker 2 The New Yorker Radio Hour is supported by ATT. There's nothing better than feeling like someone has your back and that things are going to get done without you even having to ask.

Speaker 2 Like your friend offering to help you move without you even having to offer pizza and drinks first. It's a beautiful thing when someone is two steps ahead of you, quietly making your life easier.

Speaker 2 Staying connected matters. That's why in the rare event of a network outage, ATT will proactively credit you for a full day of service.
That's the ATT guarantee.

Speaker 2 Credit for fiber downtime lasting 20 20 minutes or more, or for wireless downtime lasting 60 minutes or more caused by a single incident impacting 10 or more towers.

Speaker 2 Must be connected to impacted tower at onset of outage, restrictions, and exclusions apply. See ATT.com/slash guarantee for full details.
ATT, connecting changes everything.

Speaker 6 Lattice is the first comprehensive HR platform where people and AI succeed together.

Speaker 6 It helps every employee grow faster, every manager lead more effectively, and every company unlock their people's full potential. Stop settling for HR tools that hold your company back.

Speaker 6 Build a future where technology doesn't replace people, but actually elevates them. No regrets.
Ready to see the power of people plus AI? Visit lattice.com/slash no regrets.

Speaker 6 That's l-at-t-t-ice.com/slash no regrets.

Speaker 4 Now, what about Secretary of State Marco Rubio? What's his role in all of this? Back in January, he issued a waiver to allow for life-saving services to continue.

Speaker 4 That doesn't seem to have been at all effective.

Speaker 5 It hasn't happened, right? So

Speaker 5 it's clear that he's not in control of the mechanisms that make those things happen.

Speaker 5 Doge

Speaker 5 does not approve the payments going out and has not approved the payments going out to sustain that work.

Speaker 4 Atul, we're talking about public health. And here at home, we've got a measles outbreak in in Texas and New Mexico.

Speaker 4 RFK Jr., whose views I think our listeners are familiar with by now, has advised some people to use cod liver oil.

Speaker 4 Where could the United States be in a couple of years from a health perspective? What worries you the most about what's going on?

Speaker 5 Measles is a good example. There's actually now been a second death.
We haven't had a death from measles in the United States in years.

Speaker 5 We are now back up globally to over 100,000 child deaths.

Speaker 5 And as you start seeing what happens is we not only pull the rug out from an organization like USAID, handcuff CDC, but then also ban even communication, let alone funding for with the World Health Organization.

Speaker 5 I was on the phone with officials at the World Health Organization. The U.S.
had chosen measles as a major area that it wanted to support.

Speaker 5 So it provided 80% of the support in that area and let other countries take other components of WHO's work. And so now that money has been pulled out on measles programs around the world.

Speaker 5 And having a Secretary of Health who has done more to undermine confidence in measles vaccines than anybody in the world means that that's a singular disease that can be breaking out.

Speaker 5 And we'll see many more child deaths that result from that.

Speaker 4 Aaron Powell, Atul,

Speaker 4 on another subject, I understand that you've been called in to testify in a lawsuit.

Speaker 4 What's the case and what's at stake there?

Speaker 5 Well, I've been asked to prepare to testify. So the lawsuit is the one that is making its way through the federal courts.
U.S.AID is the testing grounds for some fundamental questions.

Speaker 5 It starts with if a president decides that they're not going to pay the bills that the government has contracted with people to pay, whether that's lawful or not.

Speaker 4 Who's filing the suit?

Speaker 5 So the suit is the AIDS Vaccine Coalition called AVAC and the Global Health Council, along with a group of other U.S. AID partner organizations.

Speaker 5 that are suing Donald Trump to do three things, pay their past bills, which are due, lift the freeze on foreign aid, and enable an apparatus, including the staffing in USAID, to continue the work that Congress had mandated be performed.

Speaker 5 So it's three different questions. One is,

Speaker 5 do you abide by your contracts, which if the government can do that, can drop contracts instantly? I mean, a government invoice promising to pay is treated like cash in the world. So if the U.S.

Speaker 5 is no longer trusted to pay, that's going to have destabilizing consequences for the economy.

Speaker 4 Aaron Powell, how did the Supreme Court get involved?

Speaker 5 So that first question,

Speaker 5 the court ruled that the government had to pay its bills and put in a restraining order indicating that those bills had to be paid by such and such a date.

Speaker 5 The government sued, and it went all the way up to the Supreme Court. And it's a narrow question.
Does the government have to pay its bills?

Speaker 5 The court said, yes, it has to pay its bills. Five to four vote.
It was an open question whether the court would simply give carte blanche. And so that was a narrow ruling, but a big deal.

Speaker 5 And right now, you know, the government is supposed to pay the bills this week, and we'll see if they do.

Speaker 5 The second question is that whether they followed proper procedures in terminating the contracts of all of these organizations. There is a law about how much notice you give and

Speaker 5 not only notice, that you do it for individualized cause. You cannot en masse masse terminate an entire agency.
And so that's being tested.

Speaker 5 And then the third test is whether there is a separation of powers, that when Congress says, here are the funds that the executive branch is supposed to spend to stop HIV in the world, you know, these are so-called earmarked funds.

Speaker 5 They are specified what their uses are, and that the executive branch doesn't have the option to simply,

Speaker 5 you know what, it's not, that sounds like a good suggestion, but I'm going to use it in a different way.

Speaker 5 Those are the three core questions. And I've submitted an affidavit and potentially being asked to testify on what the normal processes were when we,

Speaker 5 in the Biden administration or in previous administrations, terminated contracts or laid off people or dealt with fraud, waste, and abuse.

Speaker 4 You know, I had the feeling that you,

Speaker 4 even in a short time, loved

Speaker 4 being in the federal government, which always sounds funny to people's ears because the federal government and bureaucrats and pointy heads and all that are made fun of constantly in political rhetoric.

Speaker 4 But what I hear in our conversation is a sense of tragedy that is not only public, but that is felt very intimately by you.

Speaker 5 I did not expect going into government would be as meaningful to me as it was.

Speaker 5 I went into government because it was the COVID crisis and I was offered an opportunity to lead the international component of response. We got 700 million vaccines out to the world.

Speaker 5 But what I found was a group of people who could achieve scale like I'd never seen, mission-driven. None of these people went in for the money.
It's not like they had any power.

Speaker 4 I assume all of them could have made more money elsewhere.

Speaker 5 Absolutely.

Speaker 5 And, you know, many of them spent their lives as foreign service officers living in difficult places in the world. And, you know, I remember Kyiv was under attack.

Speaker 5 So about eight weeks after I was sworn in. And I thought I was going to be working on COVID, but here is this thing erupting.

Speaker 5 First of all, our health team, along with the rest of the mission and embassy and Kyiv, had to flee for safety. But within a week, they already were like,

Speaker 5 we have TB breaking out. out we have potential polio case how are we going to respond and my critical role is to say

Speaker 5 what's going to kill people the most right now Russia has shut down the medical supply chain and so 100% of the pharmacies just closed 250,000 HIV patients can't get their meds a million heart patients can't get their meds let's get the pharmacies open and by the way they've attacked the oxygen factories and are put the hospitals under cyber attack and they they their electronic systems aren't functioning.

Speaker 5 And this team, in four weeks, were able to move the entire hospital record system to the cloud, allowing protection against cyber attacks, got oxygen systems back online, and were able to get 50% of the pharmacies open in about a month and ultimately got 80% of the pharmacies open.

Speaker 5 That is just incredible. Like, yes, I mean, are there some people I had to deal with who were overly bureaucratic? Did I have to address some

Speaker 5 people who were not performing? Absolutely.

Speaker 5 And did I have to drive efficiency? And in every place, you have to do that. But this was America at its best.
And I was so proud to be part of that.

Speaker 5 And what frustrated me was in that job, I had to speak for the U.S. government.
I couldn't write for you. during that time.
I couldn't. I know.
I couldn't tell the story.

Speaker 5 I've got a book I'm working on now that that I hope to be able to unpack all of this, but it is, I think, a sad part of not getting to be part of my leadership that I didn't also get to communicate what we do, partly because U.S.

Speaker 5 aid is restricted in certain ways from telling its story within the U.S. borders.

Speaker 4 Atul, if you could tell Elon Musk and Donald Trump directly what you're telling me about

Speaker 4 lives saved, good works done, the benefits of soft power to the United States and to the world,

Speaker 4 and so on. Do you think it would have any effect on them at all?

Speaker 5 Zero.

Speaker 5 There's a different worldview at play here. It is that power is what matters, not impact, not the overall maximum good that you can do.

Speaker 5 And

Speaker 5 having power, wielding it in ways that can dominate the weak

Speaker 5 and partner with your friends. When I say partner with friends, I mean partner with people like Putin who think the same way that you do.

Speaker 4 Well, a final question then.

Speaker 4 Is it irreparable? Is this damage done and done forever?

Speaker 5 This damage has created effects that will be forever.

Speaker 5 It will not come back. Like let's say they turned everything back on again and said, oops, I'm sorry.

Speaker 5 I had a discussion with a minister of health just today

Speaker 5 and

Speaker 5 he said,

Speaker 5 I've never been treated so much like a second-class human being.

Speaker 4 This is a foreign minister of health.

Speaker 5 Yes, this is a minister of health in another country, let me just say.

Speaker 5 And, you know, for decades, America was there.

Speaker 5 I never imagined America could be indifferent, could simply abandon

Speaker 5 people

Speaker 5 in the midst of treatments, in the midst of trials, clinical trials, in the midst of

Speaker 5 partnership, and

Speaker 5 not even talk to me, not even

Speaker 5 have a discussion so that we could plan together. Okay, you're going to have big cuts to make.

Speaker 5 We will work together and figure out how to solve it. That's not what happened.

Speaker 5 And, you know,

Speaker 5 never will trust the U.S. again.

Speaker 5 And we are entering a different state of relations. You know, in some ways, I think there will be,

Speaker 5 we are seeing lots of other countries stand up around the world, our friends, Canada,

Speaker 5 Mexico,

Speaker 5 but

Speaker 5 African countries too, Europe. Everybody is taking the lesson that America cannot be trusted.

Speaker 4 It's tragic and outrageous, no?

Speaker 5 That is beautifully put. What I say, it is,

Speaker 5 I'm a little stronger. It's shameful and evil.

Speaker 4 Atul Gawande, thank you.

Speaker 5 Thank you.

Speaker 4 Atul Gawande was assistant administrator of the U.S. Agency for International Development until January.
He's a surgeon, a professor of health policy, and a longtime contributor to the New Yorker.

Speaker 4 This is the New Yorker Radio Hour. I'm David Remnick.
Thanks for listening. See you next time.

Speaker 3 The New Yorker Radio Hour is a co-production of WNYC Studios and The New Yorker. Our theme music was composed and performed by Meryl Garbis of Tune Yards, with additional music by Louis Mitchell.

Speaker 3 This episode was produced by Max Balton, Adam Howard, David Krasnow, Jeffrey Masters, Louis Mitchell, Jared Paul, and Ursula Summer, with guidance from Emily Botine and assistance from Michael May, David Gable, Alex Barish, Victor Guan, and Alejandra Deckett, the New Yorker Radio Hour is supported in part by the Torina Endowment Fund.

Speaker 8 Famous Amos. It's a brand synonymous with chocolate chip cookies.
It's also the creation of my dad, Wally Amos.

Speaker 8 When he passed away last year, I set out to understand how he became one of the most famous black men in America and how his life and our family unraveled.

Speaker 8 From Vanity Fair, this is Tough Cookie, the Wally Famous Amos story. Available wherever you get your podcasts.