BTK /// Bind, Torture, Kill /// Part 1

TV's number one drama, High Potential, returns with star Caitlin Olson as the crime-solving single mom with an IQ of 160.

Every week, Morgan uses her unconventional style and brilliance to crack LAPD's most perplexing cases.

It's the perfect blend of humor and mystery.

She's breaking the mold without breaking a nail.

High Potential premieres Tuesday at 10-9 Central on ABC and stream on Hulu.

Oh, Gecko, I just love being able to file a claim in under two minutes with the Geico app.

Could you sign it?

Sign what?

The app?

Yeah, sure.

Oh, it rubbed off the screen when I touched it.

Could you sign it again?

Anything to help, I suppose.

Get more than just savings.

Get more with Geico.

Welcome to True Crime Garage, wherever you are, whatever you are doing, thanks for listening.

I'm your host, Nick, and with me as always is a guy that knows that April showers bring May flowers and Mayflowers bring pilgrims.

Ladies and gentlemen, the captain.

It's gonna be me.

It's good to be seen and it's good to see you.

Thanks for listening.

Thanks for telling a friend.

Today we are drinking Demon Dweller by the Green Man Brewery.

GarageGrade three and three-quarter bottle caps out of five.

Demon Dweller is an Imperial style aged in oak barrels and buried deep in the cellar.

They reluctantly released this creepy deviant for your reckoning.

And Demon Dweller was brought to us by these good keepers of the peace.

First up today, what day is it today, Captain?

Oh, yeah.

It's True Crime Garage Day.

A shout out to Adam in Cheshire, UK.

And a big we like your jib to Ashley in Franklin, Tennessee.

Next, a toast to Andrew and April at the Null Winery in California.

And a big cheers to a cheese head, Kitty, in Madison, Wisconsin.

And a shout to Patty in Salem and her sister, Laura in Dunstable, Massachusetts.

And last but not least, longtime friend of the show, Paul, in Germantown, Wisconsin.

Thanks, everybody, for the beers.

Thanks for the wine.

Thanks for the kind words.

If you want to help us out, go to TrueCrimeGarage.com and click on the donate button.

And we have a pre-order going on for Team Nick tanks, Team Captain tanks, nice jib tanks, skull logo tanks, and a very special douche canoe tank top.

So if you would like to get one of those, the order ends May 9th.

Well, thank you very much.

Thank you very much.

Everybody gather around, grab a chair, grab a beer.

Let's talk some true crime.

The following is a BTK offender criminal profile.

This profile was written several years after BTK's first set of murders.

It reads, The attached analysis is only only as good as the information that has been provided.

In addition, it may be necessary to totally change or modify this analysis if new information is developed, such as additional victims, more forensic evidence, or more information obtained from research.

Multiple Homicides, Wichita, Kansas

The murders of the offender known to the public only as the BTK are the result of a fantasy acted out.

A fantasy where for the first time in his life he is in a position of dominance.

He is an inadequate type, a nobody, who through his crimes has placed himself in a position of importance.

The BTK strangler is now a somebody who is receiving the recognition he feels is a long overdue.

He is not even very original in his crimes.

He has patterned himself after other killers, such as the son of Sam in New York City.

Most of the verbiage used by the offender in his letters probably comes out of recent publications in detective magazines.

The subject is alienated, lonely, and withdrawn.

He would not be expected to have any lasting relationships with others.

and would lead a solitary existence dominated by fantasy and magical thinking.

His killing is an attempt on his part to find affection and acceptance.

He fears everyone, including himself.

He would not be expected to have had any normal relations with women and probably has never had a normal heterosexual relationship with one.

When he is not killing, he experiences intense feelings that he is not normal and therefore he kills to cope with this disorder, an attempt to escape within his own fantasies.

Thus, he can be expected to kill again and to do so in a compulsive repetition pattern that he has already established.

His victims can be either male or female, who are both loved and outgoing.

His victims will be in a position of vulnerability where he can totally render them helpless.

His victims represent his own feeling of helplessness and hopelessness.

His own life has been disruptive.

He probably comes from a background where his family was broken.

He was raised by an overbearing mother who was inconsistent in her discipline and his father was absent either because of marital separation or death.

This would have occurred when he was a youth.

Your subject may have been raised by foster parents.

Your subject was an average student in the classroom.

However, he was more adept to disrupting the class by using profanity and pranks.

His language and statements make us believe that he has some military experience and or is a police buff.

He probably has had run-ins with the police in the past, such as assault and or breaking and entering.

During these break-ins, items taken will be items of insignificance.

These items would have been taken because of a fetish or to feed a strong urge to take an article of of clothing or an item that he is fond of or the satisfaction of committing a crime that will leave little evidence to investigators.

BTK may have a history of voyeuristic activity and he may have an arrest record for these types of offenses.

He hunts his victims by selecting neighborhoods where he can peruse different houses without being detected.

Furthermore, his victims will live in an area where if need be, he can have an easy escape route, such as a neighborhood park where he can hide to elude police.

His killings are impulsively motivated and without elaborate planning.

He seeks out targets of opportunity.

Such individuals of this type suffer from insomnia and thus find it difficult to hold steady employment.

Control of himself and of his environment is essential to such a person.

Although he is gaining in confidence, he is still shy, withdrawn, and isolated.

As a counter-strategy technique, your department must not make any statements concerning the killer's mental condition.

Do not allow the media to label him as some kind of psychotic killer.

If they have already done so, your best strategy will be to align yourself with the killer and not the psychiatric experts.

Any press releases should clearly state that he is a killer who must be apprehended.

and that he is not a psychotic animal.

This approach may reduce the killer's anxiety and reinforce his own guilt feelings.

This removing any psychiatric excuses for his acts and leaving him responsible for his murders.

Extended periods between his murders may be for reasons when he was absent from the area, either as a result of military service, schooling, incarceration, or mental treatment.

It is not uncommon for subjects such as yours to frequent police hangouts in an attempt to overhear officers discussing the case.

Such offenders may be at the crime scene observing detectives investigating the case.

All of this allows the murderer to fulfill his ego and gain a feeling of superiority.

He may go so far as to telephonically contact your department and provide details specific to his crimes.

Your advantage in this case is his very strong self-centered attitude will be his downfall.

He will provide information to a friend or an acquaintance at a local tavern concerning information he knows about the case.

He may even pretend to be an officer working the case.

He may carry a fake badge on his person.

If so, he may use this to gain entry into his victims' homes.

BTK will continue to kill until he is caught or killed.

Dennis Rader, born in March of 1945 in Pittsburgh, Kansas.

And he would be the oldest of four children born to William and Dorothea Rader.

Dennis's father, who went by bill, was a member of the U.S.

Marine Corps.

When he retired from the Marines, he went to work for the Kansas Gas and Electricity in 1948.

Dennis' mother, Dorothea, was a bookkeeper.

Dennis had three younger brothers, Jeff, Paul, and Bill.

The family moved to Wichita, Kansas when Dennis was young, and it was there that he would spend most of his childhood.

The Raiders lived in a working-class neighborhood on North Seneca Street.

Dennis's childhood friends describe his father Bill as strict but never cruel.

Bill's cousin Lee Raider commented that he could not remember a time when Bill Raider's family had done anything that might attract attention, much less cross the law.

And from all accounts, Dennis was a normal, average child.

Yeah, and later in life, he would describe his father as distant and his mother, well, she was the disciplinarian.

Now, Dennis tried to be the good kid.

He was a member of the Boy Scouts and participated in church youth group activities.

Dennis attended Riverview Elementary School, and his teachers later stated that Dennis was an average student, although some other reports indicate that he got poor grades.

Kids who grew up with him say that Dennis loved dime store novels and comic books.

And like most kids, he played cops and robbers until it was dark.

As he got older, people who knew him from his school days report that Dennis exhibited withdrawn tendencies.

He was described to be a quiet and polite young man who preferred to keep to himself.

He was also described to be a person that would think before he spoke.

He would always listen very carefully when spoken to and would give you his full attention.

What?

One of Dennis's former friends described him as utterly lacking in a sense of humor, but tending to be focused.

In the eighth grade,

in the eighth grade, Dennis was chosen to be a crossing guard.

He carried a big red stop sign and told classmates and drivers when to go and when not to go.

But otherwise, Dennis appeared outwardly unremarkable and blended seamlessly into the background.

In 1963, Dennis graduated from Wichita Heights High School.

He got a job working at a grocery store.

But in 1965, he decided to move away from Wichita to go to Kansas Wesleyan College.

Dennis joined a fraternity, but he was a poor student and he soon returned to Wichita and enrolled in a community college.

By the summer of 1966, at age 21, Dennis had decided to join the U.S.

Air Force.

He did his basic training and technical training in Texas.

Yeah, I believe he spent four years in the Air Force.

Yes, and he would achieve the rank of sergeant.

At 26 years old, Dennis returned to Wichita in 1970.

And in May of 71, he married 23-year-old Paula Dietz, a bookkeeper.

Paula had also grown up in Wichita and had gone to the same high school as Dennis.

They settled in the Park City area just north of Wichita, not far from the home in North Wichita where Dennis had grown up.

And didn't Dennis Rader work in the meat department?

Yeah, he did this at the IGA Superstore while attending Butler County Community College.

There he earned an associate degree in electronics in 1973, but in 1972, Dennis actually left the IGA Superstore to go work for Wichita's largest employer at the time.

This is the Coleman Company, a manufacturer of camping supplies.

Yeah, they make the grills.

Yeah, amongst a bazillion other things.

He worked on an assembly line there, building heating and cooling units.

Dennis left Coleman in 1973 to go work for Cessna, a manufacturer of small aircrafts.

But by late 1973, he was let go.

And in 1973, Dennis started taking classes at Wichita State University, taking criminal justice classes.

Do we know why he was let go, or was it just like a situation where they laid off a bunch of people?

I honestly, I don't know.

He had a background in electronics, and that's what he was in the Air Force for.

So I'm a little surprised that he would be let go.

I don't know if there were major cuts back then or if he just couldn't hack the work.

You got to keep in mind, Dennis Rader, while he will present himself throughout the course of his life as being above average intelligence, trying to be superior to the rest of us, he is very much a very average guy in his intellect.

So by the end of 1973, Dennis Rader, he's married, he's unemployed, but he's taken some college classes.

But Dennis is also hiding a secret.

So, all of these mundane details paint the picture of a completely normal, even somewhat dull life.

But by his own admission, Dennis developed fantasies about bondage, control, and torture from a very early age while still in grade school, in fact.

When his mother would spank him, remember he said that she was the disciplinarian.

When his mother would spank him, Dennis would later say that he felt a mixture of pain and pleasure.

Once he reached puberty, Dennis dreamed of tying up girls and having his way with them.

Dennis has admitted to torturing and killing cats and dogs when he was young by hanging them in barns.

He also had a fetish for women's underwear.

He realized that he could kind of keep his fantasies of torture and murder a secret from everyone else.

And one way that I think he helped himself kind of keep these things quiet to kind of quiet the beast, if you will, was by stealing underwear from undergarments from women and from girls in the area.

He'd put them in his pocket and walk around and sniff them.

No, no, but

no one in his life ever imagined that this average, unremarkable boy was leading a depraved inner life that would become dramatically more pronounced when he reached adulthood.

Now, according to the journals that Dennis kept from his time at Kansas Wesleyan State and Salina in 1965, it was during this period that he first started trolling for victims to act out his fantasies, although it appears that he did not have any success in actually carrying anything out at that time.

His journals also indicate that it was around this time that Dennis was able to successfully break and enter into homes and buildings, stealing small items of interest to him.

He found this sort of activity exhilarating.

Dennis further admitted that while in the Air Force, he would peep at women undressing.

He would stalk women and he would burglarize their houses to steal their underwear.

While he was in the Air Force, he began to spend time with local sex workers.

He was trying to get them to play along with his fantasies, his bondage obsession, but he was unsuccessful at getting any of them to play along with this.

He would later say that he thought that they feared that he was going to take it too far.

Right.

I mean, this guy that you don't know is paying you for sex, and then he's probably saying,

I'll pay you a little bit extra if you let me tie you up.

They're probably going, yeah, I'm not.

I'm not going to let that happen.

And that's an interesting thought because I'll tell you what, something that we will learn about Dennis as we go through his life and his crimes.

Um, I'm of the suspicion that maybe he wasn't paying them for sex.

I don't know that he had the confidence to have sex with a professional.

Um, being so he was just hanging out with them.

I know, I bet you he was paying them to spend time with them, but I don't think that he lacked the confidence to actually have sex with them.

TV's number one drama, High Potential, returns with star Caitlin Olson as the crime-solving single mom with an IQ of 160.

Every week, Morgan uses her unconventional style and brilliance to crack LAPD's most perplexing cases.

It's the perfect blend of humor and mystery.

She's breaking the mold without breaking a nail.

High Potential premieres Tuesday at 10-9 Central on ABC and stream on Hulu.

The first few weeks of school are in the books.

Now it's time to keep that momentum going.

IXL helps kids stay confident and ahead of the curve.

IXL is an award-winning online learning platform that helps kids truly understand what they're learning, whether they're brushing up on math or diving into social studies.

It covers math, language arts, science, and social studies from pre-K all the way through 12th grade with content that's engaging, personalized, and yes, actually fun.

And in case you didn't know, IXL is used in 96 of the top 100 school districts in the U.S.

It's the start of school.

This is when you learn if your kid is struggling with a specific topic.

And if so, IXL is the way to catch up.

It's the way to give them a leg up and to keep up.

Or if you want to get ahead, it's great too.

Studying for test, they have features on there that families are finding especially helpful.

I think you are going to like and enjoy, and your kid is going to like and enjoy and learn with IXL.

Make an impact on your child's learning.

Get IXL Now and True Crime Garage listeners can get an exclusive 20% off IXL membership when they sign up today at ixl.com slash garage.

Visit ixl.com slash garage to get the most effective learning program out there at the best price.

This show is sponsored by BetterHelp.

Where do you go in order to solve your life's problems?

Do you call your best friend?

Do you have a group chat?

Are you standing in line to get coffee oversharing with strangers?

Well, let me tell you, don't do that.

There's a difference between that and actually talking to a therapist.

That's where BetterHelp comes in with clinically trained and licensed therapists.

They've been around for over a decade, helped millions, and out of 1.7 million client reviews, they got a 4.9 rating.

BetterHelp does the initial matching work for you so you can focus on your therapy goals.

A short questionnaire helps identify your needs and preferences.

And if you aren't happy with your match, switch to a different therapist at any time.

It's fully online and you can pause your subscription whenever you need to.

With over 30,000 therapists, BetterHelp is the world's largest online therapy platform, having served over 5 million people globally.

As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of experience.

Find the one with BetterHelp.

Our listeners get 10% off their first month at betterhelp.com slash garage.

That's better.

H-E-L-P.com slash garage.

This show is proudly sponsored by BetterHelp.

Check out betterhelp.com slash garage today.

While you're buying new school supplies and trying to plan a new schedule this season, the last thing you want to factor in is a giant wireless bill.

But with Mint Mobile, you can get the coverage and speed you're used to for way less money.

For a limited time, Mint Mobile is offering three months of unlimited premium wireless service for $15

a month.

That's right.

$15 a month for really great premium wireless service.

I love Mint Mobile.

Why?

Because it's the same great service that I get with other providers that shall not be named at a fraction of the price.

So great service, save money.

That's Mint Mobile.

Get this new customer offer and your three-month unlimited wireless plan for just $15 a month at mintmobile.com/slash TCG.

That's mintmobile.com slash TCG.

Upfront payment of $45 required, equivalent to $15 a month.

Limited time, new customer offer for the first three months only.

Speeds may slow above 35 gigabytes on unlimited plan.

Taxes and fees extra.

See Mint Mobile for details.

All right, we're back.

Cheers, me, mateies.

Cheers, Captain.

Tuesday, January 15th, 1974, in Wichita, Kansas.

As expected, this was a cold day.

And like most other days, 15-year-old Charlie Otero counted down until the final school bell rang.

3 o'clock.

Charlie collected his things and he made his way outside.

Charlie was 15 years old and in the 10th grade.

It was his duty as the oldest child to gather up his brother and sister and lead the charge home, back to their little white house with black shutters on North Edgemore Street.

The family had only been in town for a little more than 10 weeks.

They were still figuring out the logistics of their new life together in Wichita.

They still had boxes of household items that were to be unpacked.

Charlie's brother Danny was just a tad younger at 14 years of age, and their sister Carmen June, she was 13.

Now, their home was not terribly far from their school, so it was a short walk on a cold day.

When they arrived at the little house, the door was locked as usual, and the family dog, Lucky, Lucky was out in the fenced in backyard, pacing near the gate.

Charlie used his key to unlock the door.

When they entered the home, they noticed the kitchen had been left in a strange manner.

It was incredibly hot inside the house.

Charlie expected to see his father Joseph.

Their father Joseph was a hardworking man, but he had practically been confined to the home after a recent car accident.

In the kitchen, open food containers were sitting on the countertops, and it looked like someone was making a sandwich.

Charlie called for his father several times, but got no answer.

The three kids walked the house looking for their mom, dad, little brother, and sister, anyone who may be home.

Charlie opened the door to the master bedroom and walked into a horrific scene.

His mother lay dead on the bed, his father lifeless on the floor.

Charlie called out to Danny and Carmen June.

Both parents were bound at the feet and wrist.

One of the children grabbed a knife from the kitchen, and the children cut bindings from their parents.

This was a hopeless effort, as both had been dead for a couple of hours.

Charlie ran to the kitchen, grabbed the phone receiver hanging on the wall, and called Zero for the operator.

Charlie listened but heard nothing as the phone was dead.

He would not be able to call police or medics.

He shouted for Danny and Carmen to join him as he ran to the neighbor's house.

They pounded on the door.

And luckily, their neighbor was home.

They told him that they found their parents dead in their parents' room, and then they called the police.

While they waited for police to arrive, the neighbor ventured to the Otoro home to see if he could help in any way.

He saw what the children had seen, and he knew it was too late.

The first to arrive on the scene were the medics.

They arrived just five minutes after the call was placed.

When they arrived, the three OTERO teenage children were standing out front waiting for their arrival.

The children were begging for the medics to go inside and help their parents, but the EMTs explained that for now, they would have to wait for police to arrive on the scene to clear the house and give them the okay to go in.

When the neighbor man was describing to the first responders what he had saw in the bedroom, the medics began to think that they might be at the scene of a murder-suicide, that maybe somehow in a fit of rage, Joseph had killed his wife and then killed himself.

All right, let's get into the investigation a little bit to get a better understanding of what may have happened to these two people in that house that day while the children were at school.

Well, I just want to point out something that supposedly it's a murder-suicide, but we have legs bound and arms bound, right?

Well, that's where I think the confusion comes in.

So, and what we will see happen here is the children, when they found their parents, the parents were bound at the hands and feet.

Remember, the children went to the to the kitchen, they got a knife and they cut the bindings from their parents trying to revive them or save them or something.

So when the neighbor goes in to see what had happened, all he sees is Joseph, the father, dead on the floor, the mother dead on the bed, and there's a knife lying next to Joseph, the father.

So he tells this to the medics, and the medics are like, crap, this is a,

these kids just walked in to the result of a murder-suicide of their parents.

So inside the home, Captain, in that master bedroom, the two people that were found dead were Joseph Otero Jr., who is 38 years old, and his wife, Julie, aged 34.

The Oteros have five children, three of which we have already introduced.

These are the three oldest children, and again, they were Charles, who is 15, Danny, who is 14, and Carmen, who was 13.

They had walked home from school and found their parents dead in the home.

The other two children attended a different school.

They were, like their older brothers and sisters, they walked to and from school as well, but they were younger, so they were in elementary school.

Now, Charlie, the oldest of the children, did not want his little sister, Josephine, who was only 11, and his little brother Joseph, age 9, to see the swollen, stiff bodies of their parents like he had.

So Charlie stayed on the scene to help in any way that he could, but he sent Danny and Carmen off to intercept the younger children before they could make it all the way home.

Around this same time, a police officer had arrived.

This is Officer Bola.

He went into the home and made his way to the master bedroom.

He stepped into the room.

He saw the bodies of Joseph and Julie.

He touched their skin to gauge temperature.

Both bodies were cold and stiff as rigor had set in.

They had both been dead for a few hours.

And Joseph's body would be lying on the floor on his back.

Now, next to Joseph was a plastic bag and a knife.

Julie was barefoot, and her body was on the bed.

She had dried blood around her mouth and nose.

She had some bruising around her neck as well.

There was some type of cloth lying next to her.

Now, her feet were still bound by white cord.

Strips of cord lay next to each of the bodies.

Someone had opened all of the drawers to the dresser and rummaged through them.

Okay, so I want to go over some information provided to the police by Charlie or the other children.

And we kind of got into this a little bit before, but just to kind of clear it up.

So the knife...

Next to Joseph's body was the knife from the kitchen that the children had used to cut the bindings from around his wrist.

Right, so not from the perpetrator.

So that also explains the cord lying next to Joseph.

The plastic bag had been on Joseph's head that was found next to him.

This was removed by the children as well.

The cloth that was lying next to Julie was actually a gag that her daughter had removed when they found her.

The cord lying next to her had been tied around her hands.

So they first thought maybe a murder-suicide like we talked about, but this because of what the neighbor had described.

However, the neighbor had not realized that he was seeing, it was an altered crime scene, altered by the children trying to save their parents.

It was very brave of them for the children to try to save their parents.

Yeah, so now

the police know that both of the victims had actually been tied up and left that way when the children had found them.

Then the officer made his way to another bedroom.

Inside this room, to his shock and surprise, there was another body.

This was little Joseph.

He was found dead in his room, lying on his side next to the bunk bed.

He and Danny shared that room, him and his older brother.

In the room with him, were a phone book and a chair with a broken leg.

The chair was from another room and had been moved into the boy's bedroom.

Why the investigators did not know?

The boy had been tied around his ankles, and the cord ran from his ankles up behind him and bound his hands together behind his back.

The boy's hands were swollen to about three times the size of their normal size.

The boy's face and head were covered with multiple items.

A t-shirt and two plastic bags all hooded the boy's head.

The officer then set off to search the remainder of the home.

Could the killer or killers have left something behind?

Could there be some trace as to who had committed these horrible murders?

After searching the main level, Officer Bola ventured to the basement.

The basement was dark and he could not find a light switch, so he relied on the light of his flashlight.

Once at the bottom of the stairs, he moved the beam around to see what was in the room.

He spotted, you know, normal things, items you would expect to find in a basement, boots, extra clothing, old toys, things like that.

He noticed an opening.

There was another room down there.

So still not having found a light switch, he walked slowly toward the doorway using his flashlight to guide his steps.

Once in the room, he first noticed that the room felt and appeared to be smaller than the room he had just been in.

This smaller room housed the family's washer and dryer, their washing machine and their dryer.

As Officer Bola backed up and started to pivot back around to the exit.

Yeah, to the stairs, right?

Yeah, well, his back and shoulder brushed up against something something at this point.

Something with some weight to it.

He swung his arm around to reach out to the object, but when he hit it with his forearm, it gave way and it moved.

Now, this terrified the officer, and he started to back up, you know, shuffling his feet to maintain his balance as he pulled his other hand around to shine the light on the object that he had just touched, that had just moved.

As he fell back and spotlighted the object, he could feel the color run from his face as he realized that he was looking at the dead body of a young, almost teenaged girl.

Her mouth was gagged, her hands tied behind her back, her head and shoulders slumped in a lifeless position.

A noose was around her neck, and she was hanging just a foot or two of rope from a pipe that had run the length of the ceiling.

The body swayed from where he had bumped into it and hit it with his arm.

Yeah.

The officer had to announce to the other officers responding to the call

that there were four bodies at 803 North Edgemore Street.

It's a quadruple homicide.

After a little bit of time to confirm the detective's suspicions, the officer told the three teenaged Otero kids that they had walked home from school together, that their parents and their young sister and brother had all been killed that day before they arrived.

Police scoured the home and yard for clues.

Detectives and officers set out on foot to canvass the area and interview neighbors.

Over the course of the evening, they spoke with three separate individuals that provided them with a similar clue.

All three of these people had seen the Oteros vehicle.

This is a Plymouth station wagon.

It was being driven by someone other than the Oteros on that day.

One said that he had seen a short, possibly Middle Eastern man driving the vehicle.

One said he saw some man, but not Joe Otero driving.

And another said, I don't know who was driving the vehicle, but the vehicle backed out of the driveway so fast that this eyewitness had to slam on his brakes to avoid crashing into the car.

Right, so we got three

very undetailed accounts.

Yeah, I think I know

it was a man.

Right.

Well, and the thing is, I don't, it's one of those situations where you don't know that you're seeing the Otero's car being driven by somebody else.

You're just seeing a car that matches that description.

Right.

And then later realizing some shit has happened, some stuff has gone down.

Now, oh, I saw a car that looked just like theirs, but I didn't think it was theirs because it was a man that I didn't recognize

driving the vehicle.

Now, later that night, Captain, they ended up finding the vehicle at Dylan's grocery store.

Somebody had left it in the parking lot at Dylan's grocery store.

An eyewitness later told police that they had seen a man park the vehicle, exit the vehicle, and walk away.

The man was visibly nervous to the point that he was shaking.

And they're not the most detailed accounts, but at least we do have eyewitnesses in this investigation.

Yeah, and they're all similar.

One man having been driving the family's vehicle.

So as for more details, Captain, so Joseph Otoro, he served in the Air Force for 20 years, and he had recently retired at the rank of master sergeant.

The Oteras had been married for about 16 years.

Julie, his wife, had worked at the Coleman Company plant.

Joseph had once been a champion boxer.

Now, I don't know if this was while he was in the Air Force or a local thing when he grew up in New York,

but he was a boxer at one point in his life.

And Julie and the children studied and practiced judo.

So the FBI would later tell investigators that the fact that we have four members of a family that were all trained fighters attacked and killed in their home pointed to two possibilities.

Either they were dealing with multiple offenders or, and what they believe to be the most likely situation, is that they were dealing with a single killer that was able to gain entry to the home and and used a gun to control the four individuals.

The other issue here is, like you said before,

the husband, the father, he was basically housebound because of a car accident.

So, you know, he could have been in a lot of pain having difficulties moving and stuff.

So he might not have been able to fight.

Well, and I also think

the reason why they believed that we're working with a single offender here is because they firmly believe that this was a sexually motivated home invasion and murders.

And the murderer appeared to have a fascination with bondage, strangulation, and suffocation.

And one particular FBI agent believed that the likelihood that more than one offender would share the same distinct sexual urges and murderous fantasies, well, he believed that to be very unlikely.

Yeah, and there's some evidence to support this.

Yeah, both female victims were found partially disrobed.

Seaman was found present on Josephine and on the floor of the basement.

From the appearance of the kitchen, now it looked like the killer or killers gained access to the house and surprised the Otero family while the children were preparing their school lunches before leaving for their school day.

There were food products.

out on the counters and table.

The girls' winter gloves were discovered just outside of the house, and police had a theory on this, that they were making their lunches, and Joseph told the little girl to take out the trash.

She goes outside and is grabbed up by the offender, who then took her inside and was able to gain control because he already had a hostage.

Right.

So he used her like, hey, do what I say, I'm going to shoot her.

Yeah.

And also, there was no sign of a struggle anywhere in the house.

No sign of breaking and entering.

Right.

And because this was a family of fighters, again, we have the gun is the thought here to gain control.

The things that the police found the most alarming was that nothing appeared to have been taken from the home.

So not a robbery gone bad, as most would think.

And secondly, the cords and bags and ropes used in the murders didn't come from inside the home, leading to the terrifying thought that the killer showed up prepared, that he intended to kill the family before he ever entered the home.

The police theorized about the chair with the broken leg as well.

The chair was from another room.

This was told to them by the children.

The police theorized that the killer, after using a gun to gain control of the family, tied them up.

Then he killed Joseph, the father, first to get rid of the biggest threat to him.

Then he molested and killed the mother.

The boy who

suffocated due to the plastic bags, the killer placed the chair in the room.

And their theory, this is just a kind of a wild speculation theory here, but they wondered if maybe he had held the little girl, that he sat with her in the chair, forcing her to watch her brother die.

And during this struggle, maybe the leg to the chair had broke.

And after the three were dead, then he takes the girl to the basement because

it was actually her.

They wondered if it was actually the little girl that he had targeted,

and that maybe he wanted to spend some time with her.

Now, he hung her with a rope over the top of a pipe in the basement.

He masturbated.

Some sick shit, maybe.

Yeah, he masturbated either while she was being killed or just after.

I'd say sick shit, and then he just dropped that on us.

Well, then he collected everything that he brought to the home with him.

He cranked up the thermostat and then left in the family's vehicle.

Now, the two detectives that took the case, I mean,

cranked up the thermostat.

I don't know how hot it was in the house, but the children and police and medics all described the home to be extremely warm, and they believe that the offender cranked up the thermostat to maybe speed up the

decomposition process.

That maybe they would decompose a little faster if it was 90 or 95, or I don't know how hot it was in the home.

But the two detectives that took the case, Captain, I found this to be extremely interesting and dedicated on their part.

They had a suspicion, even though they thought it might be a small chance, they thought that there was a small chance that the killer might return to the scene of the murders.

So the two detectives that caught the case, they actually spent several nights staying overnight at the murder house.

So

going on with some more police thoughts here.

Can you imagine that?

That'd be us.

We'd be on the case.

Chief would say, hey, you two knuckleheads, you guys like to talk to each other.

You guys are going to stay in the house.

Just wait till he comes back.

Yeah.

Well, and I want to point out a few things.

As this is going on, you've got to understand the confusion here amongst just the officers involved in the investigation because this is not a crime that they're used to seeing.

Okay, this is not a crime that anybody is used to seeing where a whole family, well, most of a family is wiped out in the course of a morning or afternoon.

Yeah.

And you have little to no evidence left behind.

The thing here, though, too, is Captain, when you have a situation like this, you know, in Wichita at the time, you know, it was a big city, yes, but they didn't have a high murder rate.

And the murders that they had, they typically solved them fairly quickly back then because usually they were committed by somebody.

If a family member was killed, good chance it was killed by another family member.

You know, people on the inner circle were killing, committing these types of crimes.

They were solved very quickly.

This situation,

we have where police are not fully understanding what they are seeing.

They're not fully understanding the crime that took place that day.

And so therefore, you have officers and investigators that are not going to share the same theories about what took place that day.

Yeah, because it's not just...

It's not just a murder.

Right.

We have a rape.

Well, not rape.

Okay, so it's not actual rape because there was no penetration.

Right, right, okay.

Okay, so sexual assault.

Correct.

And he's basically masturbating to the torture that's going on.

You know,

these wouldn't have been fast deaths.

You know, they weren't.

It's not like putting a gun to somebody's head and pulling the trigger.

This type of death, this type of killing takes some time.

And he

jerked off to it.

Right.

He enjoyed witnessing it, whether it was during or after.

And that's why when we spoke earlier about Dennis Rader spending time with sex workers,

now he has said that he had sex with these sex workers.

I actually question if he would have been able to physically, because

when we see his crimes, he doesn't show that

he's capable of that, that there's something in his makeup that does not allow him to do that.

Now, we talked about the police and investigators.

Capable of

jerking off.

Right, but that's mentally that's much different than

actual intercourse.

So

we talked about some of the different police and investigator theories and thoughts as to motive.

There were three popular ones.

at the time of the early investigation.

And one was that this could be some type of revenge killing, that somebody went out to kill one member of the family or wipe out the entire family for some purposes of revenge.

The other theory as to motive, number two, was the family had recently moved from Panama and Joseph was a pilot.

So there were some people that wondered, could this be something that is tied to the drug trade or some type of gang hit?

Was

Joseph involved in anything, moving drugs,

things of that nature, and somebody had sought him out to put an end to him, and the other three were just collateral damage?

The third theory, and this is probably the most terrifying one when you think about the community, is that Mrs.

Otero and the little girl were actually targeted by the killer, and the killer was surprised to find the father at home that day.

And there's some thoughts to support this theory, and that being that there were no cars in the driveway when the killer had entered the home.

And remember, Joseph was only home because just a couple of weeks earlier, he had been in a car accident.

So the car

that he drove was in the shop because it was being fixed.

And Joseph was off of work nursing some injuries.

Right.

So I'm assuming there was a way that the killer would have been able to see into the garage to see if there was cars in the garage.

Well, their vehicle was home, the one that the OTERO mother typically drove.

Right.

But the other one was gone.

Correct.

And so even if the killer had been watching the house, if he wasn't watching the home

consecutive days,

he might not have any clue that Joseph would have been in the home.

There was no evidence to support or to suggest to him that Joseph was there.

So the police had, like we said, little to no leads.

The case was going to go cold very quickly.

This was until October of that same year, until October of 1974.

This is when police picked up a man for molesting a little girl behind the public library.

This man, his name is Gary Sebring.

Now, this is a man with a lengthy criminal record that included bestiality bestiality that he had committed in the local park there.

Now, so he's picked up for possibly molesting this little girl behind the library.

Now, during the interrogation regarding that attack on the little girl, he started talking about the OTERO murders and saying some weird stuff.

He said, you know,

had he done the OTERO murders, he would have committed them with his brother, Ernest, and their friend Thomas Meyer would have helped them commit this crime.

So it'd be three people.

Yeah.

And he would have raped their cat.

Well, all three of these men had a record of sex offenses.

The brother Ernest was brought in for questioning.

Police were looking for Thomas Myers.

Now, it took some time for them to find this Thomas Myers character.

He was eventually located after he tried to take his own life.

Now, all three men were found to be mentally unstable, and they were all taken to a mental hospital for observation.

They remained there for quite some time, but none of the three would be charged with the quadruple homicides.

Yeah, anybody that's raping an animal is obviously not mentally stable.

Well, yeah, you touched on

something there, Captain, that the FBI would say as well.

They found that these three individuals,

they didn't find any of them capable of getting away with these murders.

That it would have gotten out of hand.

The crime scene would have looked much differently.

It just didn't make any sense to them.

Now, they're not just, the police are not just going to go off of the FBI's thoughts and theories on this.

There was also no evidence to suggest that they had anything to do with these.

One of them probably read about it in the newspaper or overheard people talking about it.

This was a very, very famous crime when this took place in 1974.

Wichita had not witnessed or experienced something of this level before.

Like I said, none of them would be charged in the quadruple homicide, but there was plenty of news coverage regarding the arrest of these three men.

And the real killer was watching and reading it all.

And the thought that someone else may take credit for his hard work was making him very, very angry.

Don't forget to check out the Stitcher app and Stitcher Premium.

Yeah, check out our show off the record on Stitcher Premium today.

The first episode is out now.

It's $4.99 a month.

Not only do you get our show, but you get all of our shows commercial free and you get a bunch of other shows.

It's all for $4.99.

All right, we'll see you back here in the garage tomorrow for part two of this four-part series on the BTK killer.

Until then, be good, be kind, and don't live.

Great brands, great prices.

Everyone's got a reason to rack.

You know they have Mark Jacobs?

Nike?

Yes.

Just so many good brands.

Join the Nordy Club at Nordstrom Rack to unlock exclusive discounts on your favorite brands, shop new arrivals first, and more.

Plus, get an extra 5% off every rack purchase with a Nordstrom credit card.

More perks, more value.

That's why you rack.