Devil in the Desert: The Witness

Speaker 1 This is Deborah Roberts here with another weekly episode of our latest series from 2020 and ABC Audio, Devil in the Desert.

Speaker 1 Remember, you can get new episodes early if you follow Devil in the Desert on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast app. Now, here's the episode:

Speaker 3 chronic spontaneous urticaria, or chronic hives with no known cause. It's so unpredictable.

Speaker 4 It's like playing pinball.

Speaker 3 Itchy red bumps start on my arm, then my back,

Speaker 3 sometimes my legs. Hives come out of nowhere

Speaker 3 and it comes and goes. But I just found out about a treatment option at treatmyhives.com.

Speaker 2 Take that, chronic hives.

Speaker 3 Learn more at treatmyhives.com.

Speaker 7 In January of 2013, As Detective Ryan Peters inched forward in his investigation into the kidnapping of Michael and his roommate Mary Barnes, it dawned on him Newport police had a potential lead right under their nose.

Speaker 7 A Chevy Tahoe, a car involved in a high-speed chase months earlier. Police had spotted the Tahoe speeding through Newport Beach in the pre-dawn hours of September 26, 2012.

Speaker 7 After a chase, the officers lost sight of the vehicle. They found it later that night, dumped on Balboa Island.
It's a residential community in Newport Harbor. And the driver, he'd vanished.

Speaker 7 The Tahoe was registered to a Courtney Shigerian. Her husband was Hussein Nayeri, whose DNA had just shown up on a glove found in Kyle Henley's car.

Speaker 7 Now, Detective Ryan Peters knew that this Chevy Tahoe might have nothing to do with his kidnapping and torture investigation, but at this point, he couldn't leave any stone unturned.

Speaker 8 I don't want to ignore anything, and I want to fully invest all my time into every possible lead. I go and write a search warrant for the car, knowing that it's, you know, a long shot.

Speaker 7 Detective Peter's hunt for answers led him to the impound lot. He began to rake through the car.
Inside, he found some gift cards, keys, and paperwork.

Speaker 7 But then, he found something that changed the course of the entire investigation.

Speaker 8 I pull out this little box. I'm looking at it.
I'm like, what is this thing? And I realize it's a micro mini camera.

Speaker 8 And then I pull out another one from underneath the seat and it's another micro mini camera.

Speaker 8 And then I pull out like a small little case with two magnets on it and immediately realize this is a tracker.

Speaker 7 A GPS tracking device and two hidden cameras. Detective Peters emptied the car and took the box of stuff back to his office so that he could examine it more closely later.

Speaker 7 It turned out that those little devices had recorded hundreds of hours of footage over a period of months. And when he studied the footage itself, his jaw dropped.

Speaker 8 I'm at my desk and I remember opening it and the first image that pops up is Michael's house.

Speaker 7 These devices had been installed outside of Michael's home where he lived with his roommate Mary Barnes.

Speaker 7 And the GPS tracker had followed his whereabouts when he was at his parents' home, at his girlfriend's house, entering and leaving his property.

Speaker 7 The person who set up the tracker and the cameras could see exactly how Michael went about his day to the minute.

Speaker 7 Whoever had been watching Michael was studying him very closely and

Speaker 7 for a long time.

Speaker 7 I'm ABC News Chief National Correspondent Matt Gutman. This is Devil in the Desert.

Speaker 7 Episode 4,

Speaker 4 The Witness.

Speaker 7 As well as the surveillance cameras, the team had also found another important item in the Tahoe, a cell phone belonging to Hussein Nayeri.

Speaker 7 Matt Matt Murphy was the deputy district attorney on the case.

Speaker 9 And when they get into that phone, what they find is they find a series of orders that were placed for items which could have been used in this crime, including the stuff for the surveillance cameras and some other things.

Speaker 7 The phone had also been getting updates from a GPS tracking system. It had been receiving text messages about when the tracker left or entered a specific location.

Speaker 7 Based on the tracker's movements, it seemed to Detective Ryan Peters that it was stuck to a vehicle.

Speaker 8 And I'm like, you got to be kidding me. Like, Jose Nayeri,

Speaker 8 whose DNA is on a glove in Kyle Hanley's truck, also has cameras linking him to watching Michael's truck. You can't refute that.

Speaker 7 So for me, this is huge.

Speaker 7 Remember, the glove was important to investigators because it connected Jose Nayeri to Kyle Handley, whose truck was seen at Michael's house the day before the attack.

Speaker 7 And now, the items found in the Chevy Tahoe strengthened that connection. Nayeri seemed to have been surveilling Michael for a period of months before Mary Barnes and Michael were kidnapped.

Speaker 7 The contents of the Tahoe raised another question.

Speaker 7 The truck didn't actually belong to Jose Nayeri. It belonged to his wife, Courtney Shigerian.
So what did Courtney know about the surveillance of Michael, and how much was she involved?

Speaker 9 You start to wonder, is this woman totally innocent?

Speaker 7 Back in September 2012, on the night the Tahoe was found on Balboa Island, police showed up at Courtney's door. She hadn't been helpful.

Speaker 7 She had refused to answer their questions and would not identify Nayeri as the driver.

Speaker 7 Later, she called to report that the car had been stolen and had come to collect it from the impound lot, but after the contents had been removed by Detective Ryan Peters, which gave Newport PD an opportunity.

Speaker 7 In the spring of 2013, Detective Ryan Peters invited Courtney to come down to the station. He said, hey, why don't you come get this box of stuff we took from your car?

Speaker 7 On the surface, it looked like normal police procedure, but this was actually a trap carefully laid by the investigators.

Speaker 7 When she came down to the station, police planned to get her to sign a document to get her stuff back.

Speaker 7 It was called a property release form. The document would have a list of everything inside the car.
The cameras, the GPS tracker, the phone.

Speaker 7 And when she signed that document, she would be saying, these are all of my possessions

Speaker 7 and if Courtney signed it would immediately incriminate her in this scheme to surveil Michael and with that leverage used against her detectives wondered if there was more she might be willing to share with them but would she sign

Speaker 7 on April 9th 2013 Courtney Shigerian arrived at the Newport Beach Police Department detective Peters was there to greet her.

Speaker 10 Can I help you? I'm just here to pick the property.

Speaker 7 The meeting was recorded by Detective Peters. In the tape, Courtney seems confident, poised, and all business.

Speaker 10 What's your name? Courtney Shigarian.

Speaker 10 Do you need my director's question?

Speaker 10 We do, yes.

Speaker 7 Ryan Peters explained that the contents of the Tahoe would be released to her. Yeah,

Speaker 10 that's just the items that we're releasing to you. Okay.

Speaker 10 You can take your stuff.

Speaker 10 Oh, I can take my stuff.

Speaker 8 I asked if everything was there, and I said, Yeah, and I kind of went through it.

Speaker 8 This is a camera, this is a tracker, this is a Pepsi can, this is change, this is trash, this is the slides, this is the clothes. And she's like, okay, great, yeah, I'll take it.

Speaker 8 And she signs for it and then goes to pick it up.

Speaker 7 Ryan Peters' plan worked. Courtney signed for the listed items.
But her reaction to the whole ordeal surprised Peters.

Speaker 8 No hesitation, no emotional response, no physical response to it. And she knows that that was involved in a crime.

Speaker 8 And now she's got me like, man, does she, maybe she doesn't know, maybe she has no idea what this is.

Speaker 7 Courtney seemed calm for a person whose car contained surveillance equipment. equipment that had been used on a victim at the center of a months-long investigation.

Speaker 7 Maybe she really didn't know exactly how serious this situation was. Detective Peters announced that he had a search warrant for her belongings.

Speaker 10 What is that? I'll talk to you about it. I'm Randy.
Nice to meet you. This is a search warrant for your person, your phone, your car, your house.

Speaker 7 All of a sudden, Courtney didn't seem so confident. And then Detective Peters began to ask his questions.

Speaker 10 Do you know who's saying that you?

Speaker 10 Uh, yes, that's my husband. That's your husband.
And Kyle Henley?

Speaker 10 Uh, I know who Kyle Henley is, but I don't want to talk about anything. I mean,

Speaker 10 I don't, I don't, I feel very off-put by what you're saying. I don't know what you're talking about.
This is weird. Why did you have me come in here to pick up items and now you're

Speaker 10 trying to ask me questions?

Speaker 7 It seemed like now, when it was past the moment of too late, Courtney had finally figured out the real reason she'd been asked to come down to the station.

Speaker 7 Matt Murphy, the deputy district attorney on the case, again.

Speaker 9 It's a jack-in-the-box moment, right? It's like, hey, we got bad news and we got some worse news.

Speaker 7 Bad news, you're not getting your stuff back.

Speaker 9 Worst news is this document that you just read implicates you as a co-conspirator in a case that potentially could send you to California State Prison for the rest of your life.

Speaker 7 Pushed into a corner, Courtney went on the defensive.

Speaker 10 Am I able to leave? No. You're still being detained for the, we're serving this warrant.
Okay, can my attorney police be president? You can call them when we're done.

Speaker 10 Well, why can't they call them right now? Because we're serving the warrant.

Speaker 10 Okay. We're serving the warrant right now.

Speaker 10 You're being detained right now by law enforcement.

Speaker 7 Courtney didn't know that she wasn't allowed to leave the police station.

Speaker 7 The police had a search warrant, and that meant that legally they could absolutely detain her, so she couldn't interfere with their search.

Speaker 7 Detective Peters asked, Do you want to talk about this in a different room? But Courtney didn't want to talk. At least, not about the questions they were asking.

Speaker 10 I don't understand why I'm being asked any questions at all. I don't know what you're talking about, and I

Speaker 10 feel very weird and off hook. I think it's just what happened.
I would just like to have my attorney present for everything. I don't know what you're talking about.

Speaker 7 Peters tried to calm her down. He told her she wasn't under arrest, but that he had to complete the serving of the warrant.

Speaker 10 You know, you're nervous. You're scared.
I get it. This is weird.

Speaker 10 Okay. So we could, I could, I also need to get a buckle swog of your cheek for your DNA.
For me? For you.

Speaker 10 Why me?

Speaker 7 She didn't want want to have her DNA sample taken, but in the end, she allowed them to take a cheek swab. She kept asking the officers, why were they interested in her?

Speaker 10 Why is there a church wine?

Speaker 10 Who are investigating the kidnapping of Michael J. Mary Barnes?

Speaker 7 Detective Peters kept having to tell Courtney, you are here because we suspect your husband's involvement in this crime.

Speaker 10 You're married to St. Nigeri.

Speaker 10 Can we talk to him?

Speaker 10 Can you call him? Come call me?

Speaker 7 Detective Peters hoped that Courtney was the missing piece of a puzzle that would finally reveal the whole picture of the crime.

Speaker 7 Or at the very least, maybe she could tell them where Nayeri was hiding. Now, Courtney knew that Nayeri was in Iran.

Speaker 7 He'd left right after Kyle Hadley was arrested in October of 2012, nearly six months ago.

Speaker 7 The detectives had begun to suspect that he wasn't hiding out at Courtney's apartment, but if he was that far away, they needed to know.

Speaker 7 She didn't tell investigators any of that. Instead, she shut down.

Speaker 7 She kept her responses to the mere basics.

Speaker 7 The conversation went on for almost an hour and a half, but despite their efforts, detectives couldn't persuade Courtney to open up. Right at the end, one of the officers tried to reason with her.

Speaker 7 He said, sometimes in cases, there are all of these roles, suspects, witnesses, and co-conspirators.

Speaker 10 And sometimes those lines get blurred, they get gray a little bit, and that's when it takes some soul-searching to ask yourself, who am I? Where do I fall in line in this?

Speaker 10 And maybe that's what you should think about.

Speaker 7 After that, the interview ended awkwardly. Courtney didn't seem like she wanted to do any soul searching.
She wrote down their details, and then, with the search complete, she was free to go.

Speaker 10 Any questions?

Speaker 7 Courtney left without the tracking equipment from the Tahoe.

Speaker 7 Detective Peter's great plan had turned out to be only partially successful.

Speaker 7 He didn't get the crucial information from Courtney that he might have been hoping for, like the location of her husband or confirmation of his involvement in the crime.

Speaker 7 And he may have spooked Courtney, possibly burning their best chance of getting closer to Nayeri.

Speaker 7 But Courtney had walked right into their plan to implicate her in the surveillance scheme. They'd gained leverage.

Speaker 7 Now, they needed to figure out how to use it. The question was, how could they reel her back in and get her to talk?

Speaker 11 Audiences and top critics are celebrating.

Speaker 12 Rental Family is the perfect feel-good movie of the year.

Speaker 5 What do you need me for?

Speaker 12 We need a talking-awite guy. Academy Award winner Brendan Fraser delivers a masterful performance.

Speaker 7 This girl needs a father.

Speaker 5 I hate you.

Speaker 13 She hates me.

Speaker 11 It's worth being apparent. Yes.

Speaker 12 In this tender and funny film about the importance of connection.

Speaker 5 This is amazing. It's cool, but it's fake.

Speaker 13 Sometimes it's okay to pretend.

Speaker 12 Rental family, now playing Molney in theaters. Ready to PG13.
Maybe inappropriate for children under 13.

Speaker 5 Give it up for Chicago.

Speaker 11 Sebastian Maniscalco's new stand-up special, It Ain't Right, is now streaming on Hulu.

Speaker 5 30 years ago, Jeff Bezos, complete nerd. Bezos now ripped to shreds on his super yacht and the boxes keep

Speaker 5 coming.

Speaker 11 Watch Sebastian Maniscalco It Ain't Right. Now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for bundled subscribers.
Terms apply.

Speaker 14 It started with a phone call in the early hours of the morning.

Speaker 15 911, what is the address of your emergency?

Speaker 14 A terrified woman tells the operator she's been kidnapped, assaulted, and that she's trapped in a room with her attacker.

Speaker 14 He's fallen asleep, so she quietly and ever so carefully finds his phone and calls for help.

Speaker 4 Is there any way you can get out of the building? I don't know without waking him and I'm scared.

Speaker 14 This 911 call began an investigation that would turn the town of Ashland into a crime scene.

Speaker 15 We've got something big going on here.

Speaker 16 The first thing to hit my mind is a monster.

Speaker 14 A new series from ABC Audio and 2020, The Hand in the Window. Out now, wherever you listen to podcasts.

Speaker 16 An all-new season of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives is now streaming on Hulu.

Speaker 2 Mom Talk started as a sisterhood, and that's gone to flames. New secrets and lies are coming out.
This is going to be catastrophic.

Speaker 2 We're fighting for our marriages, and the girls are just putting us through hell. They make everything about themselves.

Speaker 12 I can't.

Speaker 2 Hopefully, this doesn't end in a bloodbath.

Speaker 16 Watch the Hulu original, The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for for bundle subscribers. Terms apply.

Speaker 16 Two rings surrounded by a steel cage.

Speaker 16 Oh my god, are you kidding me? This is gonna be a war.

Speaker 17 Stream Survivor Series War Games, November November 29th at 7 Eastern on the ESPNA.

Speaker 13 Coming to Disney Plus and Hulu.

Speaker 11 Cassidy, get us home.

Speaker 13 Jonas Brothers, you got it. It'll be the best Jonas Christmas ever.

Speaker 13 Can't wait to see you guys. We love you.
If they can only make it home.

Speaker 8 What's going on? Our tour plane burned? No.

Speaker 7 We cannot miss Christmas.

Speaker 1 Nothing can stop us from getting home now.

Speaker 4 Only

Speaker 4 you won't be alone this trip.

Speaker 7 You lost all three of your passports?

Speaker 11 It's Christmas. Anything can happen, right?

Speaker 13 A very Jonas Christmas movie, now streaming on Disney Plus and Hulu with a TBPGDL.

Speaker 7 When the investigators began digging into Courtney Shigerian's life, they spotted something in her bank records.

Speaker 7 Courtney had been giving money to Nayeri, money that had been given to her by her family, who were supporting her through law school. That gave law enforcement an idea.

Speaker 18 I was like, why don't you call the girl's father, right? Because we wanted to get Courtney turned around and off of Team Nayeri and onto Team DA.

Speaker 7 This is Deputy District Attorney Heather Brown, a longtime colleague of Matt Murphy. She had joined the case a few months earlier.

Speaker 7 It was she who came up with the idea to go around Courtney and focus on her family. Courtney's family hadn't approved of her relationship with Nayeri.

Speaker 7 They had once been close, but In recent years, Courtney had been drifting away. She didn't even tell them that she and Nayeri had married back in 2010.

Speaker 7 Her relationship with Nayeri had kept her isolated.

Speaker 7 And even when things started to go awry in their marriage, like when Courtney had to call the police when Nayeri had bruised her arm, she hadn't told her family.

Speaker 7 She was totally focused on Nayeri and on keeping his secrets.

Speaker 7 But what if her family could help steer her back into the investigator's hands? Maybe if they could get through to her, maybe they could tell her just how much trouble she was in.

Speaker 7 Heather Brown's strategy was something Detective Peters was willing to try. Three weeks after that first meeting with Courtney, he called up her father.

Speaker 8 And I told him, I said, hey, your daughter is drastically involved in a violent kidnapping.

Speaker 8 If she's going to go to law school, if she's going to have any sort of family in the future and start over and have a come to Jesus moment, it's right now. And you need to help me do that.

Speaker 8 But getting off the phone with him, like I wasn't sure.

Speaker 7 On this phone call, Courtney's father learned two huge pieces of information. One, that she was married to someone he'd previously expressed serious concerns about.

Speaker 7 And two, that she was now implicated with this man in a serious crime.

Speaker 7 Within minutes, Ryan Peters got a call from Courtney's lawyer, a man named Lou Rosenblum.

Speaker 7 Whatever Courtney's father had done behind the scenes had moved things along fast. Lou said he was willing to work with Ryan Peters to help Courtney get back on the investigator's good side.

Speaker 7 They came up with a plan together. Newport Beach police would offer Courtney a way to cooperate by using a proffer.
A proffer is an agreement between law enforcement and a person involved in a case.

Speaker 7 The person agrees to be interviewed, but there are conditions of protection.

Speaker 7 The investigators get information that could help their investigation, but they can't use any of that information against the person giving it.

Speaker 7 It didn't mean that Courtney was completely off the hook. They could still press charges against her based on evidence collected from other sources, but it was a start.

Speaker 7 And it would be the first time that investigators could sit down and ask their questions to a receptive witness.

Speaker 7 Courtney's lawyer, Lou, wanted to impress on Courtney the importance of this interview. He told her to be honest.
He said, there are no second chances here. One lie can ruin everything.

Speaker 18 It was only maybe within 48 hours. She was sitting down at Newport Beach with her attorney, attorney, and she was telling us everything she knew.

Speaker 7 Now, the Newport Beach Police Department sits just off a two-lane road next to a golf course.

Speaker 7 Its parking lot is ringed with palm trees, and from the front door, you can see the lush golf course right across the street. Courtney's proffer interview was in the conference room inside.

Speaker 7 On May 7th, 2013, Courtney walked into the room filled with Newport PD representatives. The investigative team said she looked scared out of her mind.

Speaker 7 Courtney's lawyer was there, as were Deputy District Attorney Matt Murphy and Ryan Peters.

Speaker 10 Today is May 7th, Tuesday, at 1443 hours. Interview with Courtney Shigerian.

Speaker 7 Detective Peters started off with the basics. How exactly did she know Jose Nayeri? They went over the significant dates of their relationship and Nayeri's involvement in growing and selling weed.

Speaker 7 Courtney also confirmed right off the bat what the investigators had begun to suspect. Nayeri was gone.
Once again, he had fled to Iran.

Speaker 10 Okay, the 912307, that's the number that he's using now? In Iran.

Speaker 10 Um,

Speaker 10 okay.

Speaker 7 That wasn't all Courtney was willing to share. Detective Peters dove right into the question he really wanted to ask.
This time, Courtney held nothing back.

Speaker 10 Can you tell me who's involved in the kidnapping? Just identify people. Yeah.

Speaker 10 Hussein Nayeri.

Speaker 10 Kyle Hanley.

Speaker 10 And their third person.

Speaker 10 I don't know his actual name, but Hussein referred to him as Brown.

Speaker 7 This was the biggest break in the case so far. Courtney was willing to confirm that Nayeri and Hantley and a mysterious third man were the ones who had committed the kidnapping and torture.

Speaker 7 And even though Courtney didn't know exactly who Mr. Brown was, she had another name for them, Ryan Kvorkian.

Speaker 10 Hussein and Ryan were very close.

Speaker 7 Ryan Kvorkian was another graduate of Clovis West High School in Fresno. His wife was close to Nayeri, and Courtney thought she might have been involved with planning the crime.

Speaker 7 And crucially, not only could she confirm the investigators' suspicions about who had committed the crime and give them a lead for the third man, she could also finally explain the motives behind it all.

Speaker 7 It came back to Nayeri's marijuana growing.

Speaker 10 Hussain told me that he showed his product to Michael. Michael had his friend try it.
The friend said that it had too much chemicals in it and they wouldn't buy it for that price.

Speaker 10 And Hussein got offended and was like, you know, what is this guy telling me that you did it? This is good product.

Speaker 7 She said that after Michael had refused to pay him what he asked for, Nayeri had sent Kyle to talk to Michael. Try him again with the exact same weed.

Speaker 7 Michael had paid Kyle for it, but Nayeri felt that the payment wasn't enough. He felt cheated.

Speaker 7 After that, she said that Nayeri wanted Kyle and Michael to become friends.

Speaker 7 Just as Michael had told investigators in the days after the attack, Kyle Hanley went with Michael on a trip to Las Vegas, where tens of thousands of dollars were spent partying.

Speaker 7 What Michael didn't know was that Kyle was reporting everything back to Nayeri.

Speaker 7 A plan formed between Nayeri, Kyle, and Mr. Brown.
They believed that Michael had huge amounts of cash. They decided to track him and find out where he stored it, and then steal it.

Speaker 7 Courtney wasn't protecting Nayeri anymore. In fact, a lot had changed for her in just a few days.

Speaker 7 With her father reaching back out to her and her lawyer laying out the risks of not participating in the investigation, Something had shifted.

Speaker 7 As well as cooperating with the law, she was was also working on repairing the damage that her relationship with Nayeri had done to her personal life.

Speaker 7 Lou, her lawyer, had found a therapist for her within 24 hours of getting her to agree to a proffer meeting. Now she was signed up to daily sessions.

Speaker 7 Lou wanted to get Nayeri out of her head to deprogram her from Nayeri's influence. She was back in close contact with her family, and she'd cut off all contact with her husband completely.

Speaker 7 She'd picked aside.

Speaker 7 And now, Courtney was holding nothing back, even on the parts that made her look just as bad as him.

Speaker 7 Investigators wanted to talk to Courtney about the surveillance on Michael.

Speaker 7 They knew that Nayeri was monitoring Michael's house in Newport Beach, but they had also discovered that he was watching Michael's parents' house and that the family had a dog.

Speaker 7 This dog presented a problem for Nayeri. Courtney thought he wanted to be able to install cameras inside Michael's parents' home and the dog would bark at anyone approaching their property.

Speaker 7 So one day, Nayeri asked Courtney to pick up some meat at the store.

Speaker 10 And I asked why, and he said that he got something that was poisonous for dogs because he wanted to poison the

Speaker 10 dog that I was at Michael's parents' house. And he said, Oh, can you make hamburgers with this? Because he's like, I need to

Speaker 10 poison that dog to make him sick so that I can go into the house because the dog barked a lot or whatever. Did he?

Speaker 10 I'm pretty sure I made the hamburgers, or he made the hamburgers, because I remember he wore gloves and had to handle it carefully.

Speaker 10 And I think he gave the,

Speaker 10 I think he did it.

Speaker 7 Thankfully, the poison didn't work.

Speaker 10 Because I feel like I heard him complaining after the fact

Speaker 10 about the fact that the dog didn't get sick. Oh.

Speaker 10 Sometimes it's hard to remember because there's just so much more.

Speaker 7 DA Heather Brown said this detail was damning.

Speaker 18 You can admit to a lot of things, but like making poison burger patties for someone's dog is sure to get you on America's top 10 I hate you list.

Speaker 7 After learning more about how Nayeri operated, investigators started to see Courtney in a new light.

Speaker 7 They viewed her as someone who had been harmed by Nayeri, someone manipulated by him, someone held captive.

Speaker 18 I think that she was very young and troubled when she met Hossein, and he filled a void in her life at that time and made her feel safe when

Speaker 18 really

Speaker 18 he was

Speaker 7 anything but safe.

Speaker 7 Courtney was also able to show investigators that the surveillance, as well as being menacing, had also shaped the night of the crime itself.

Speaker 7 Remember, for months, this team, Nayeri, Kyle Hanley, and the still unidentified Mr. Brown, were watching Michael's daily whereabouts.

Speaker 7 And one day in early September 2012, the tracker on Michael's car showed him taking a trip. He drove out of Newport, through Orange County suburbs, and into the Mojave Desert.

Speaker 7 He went with a friend to look at a tract of land he was thinking about buying. There are abandoned gold mines out there that, in recent years, have been the subject of a real estate boom.

Speaker 7 He drove around, decided not to invest, and went home, thinking nothing of it.

Speaker 7 But Courtney told investigators that this trip hadn't gone unnoticed by Nayeri.

Speaker 10 Hussein had put a GPS on his car. Someone had gone out to the desert and circled in an area in the desert.

Speaker 10 And Hussein one day had asked me, he says, why would someone go out to this remote area and just keep circling around? Doesn't make sense. And I said, I don't know.
And he says,

Speaker 10 it makes a perfect place for someone to bury a bunch of money. He said, yeah, it's probably right.

Speaker 7 Michael had inadvertently done something he would live to regret. He had unwittingly drawn a map of his own kidnapping route.

Speaker 7 Courtney had spelled out the motive for the crime, and now the night of the kidnapping made sense. The reason the attackers had ignored Michael's offer of $100,000,

Speaker 7 why the sports car in the garage wasn't taken. Nayeri really thought there was a million dollars buried somewhere in the desert.

Speaker 7 And when they couldn't find the million, that's when things turned ugly. Months of work, all that surveillance down the drain for nothing.

Speaker 7 Courtney even had details of who Nayeri said was responsible for the worst parts of the torture of Michael.

Speaker 10 Hussein told me that Kyle drove and that Hussein and Brown were in the back with the two victims.

Speaker 10 Hussein told me that they beat him with the cables and Hussein told me that Hussein directed Kyle to cut off the victim's penis in retaliation for the victim not giving them the money that they believed was buried out in the desert.

Speaker 7 Courtney's proffer interview was three hours long. At no point did she waver or change her mind or refuse to answer.
And by the end, the investigators made plans to talk with her in a few days.

Speaker 7 She wasn't out of the woods yet. She could still face charges for her role in the crime she'd described to them.
She was helpful, convincing even.

Speaker 7 But there was more investigating to do and no telling of what detectives might find.

Speaker 7 Still, she had left them with a name to check out, Ryan Kvorkian, the possible Mr. Brown.

Speaker 7 The team wanted to get a sample of Kvorkian's DNA. They would test it and see if it matched the DNA that was found on the zip tie at Kyle Hantley's house.

Speaker 7 So on September 25th, 2013, the team located Ryan Kvorkian. He was in Lancaster, a town on the edge of the Mojave.

Speaker 7 Detectives went to his home and then spent the day following him as he moved around town.

Speaker 18 He at one point went into the 24-hour fitness to work out and the one cop said to the other cop like, hey, I'm a member. Are you a member?

Speaker 18 And so they decided to go into the 24-hour fitness and follow him around the gym. So while he was working out, he tossed his towel that he had been wiping his sweat with.

Speaker 7 Investigators brought that towel back from the 24-hour fitness, swabbed it, and sent it to the lab. Soon, they got an official DNA hit.

Speaker 7 Ryan Kvorkian's DNA matched the cut zip tie that was found at Kyle's house.

Speaker 7 Courtney was right. They had found their third man.

Speaker 7 Deputy District Attorney Matt Murphy then went back to Courtney's attorney with an idea.

Speaker 9 And it was essentially, look,

Speaker 9 let's give her a chance to redeem herself by luring Hussein Nayeri out of Iran.

Speaker 7 They offered Courtney a chance of not just cooperating, but actively participating in the investigation. They wanted her to help them lure Nayeri out of hiding and help deliver him to the police.

Speaker 7 It was her chance to save her own life.

Speaker 7 But to do that, Courtney would have to go back to speaking to Nayeri, a man she'd now incriminated in her proffer interview and who she had abruptly cut off contact with.

Speaker 7 Now, she had to worm her way back into his life without raising suspicion. And for their plan to work, investigators needed Nayeri to trust Courtney implicitly, just as he had done before.

Speaker 7 So, first, Courtney attended the funeral of Nayeri's uncle, knowing that word would get back to him. And it did.

Speaker 7 Nayeri had a bouquet of flowers delivered to her door, and a few days later, in mid-June of 2013, husband and wife were back on speaking terms.

Speaker 10 Thank you for my flowers.

Speaker 7 What Nayeri didn't know is that now his wife isn't just the chief witness in the investigation against him, but also a secret informant.

Speaker 4 I know.

Speaker 15 This is the best gift you could have given. Just give me a phone call.

Speaker 4 You have no idea my hands are shaking right now.

Speaker 4 I am.

Speaker 7 Courtney Shigarian has become the Newport Police Department's best chance of bringing him down.

Speaker 19 They think any, you know, second I'm gonna tip him off.

Speaker 18 I was terrified for Courtney.

Speaker 19 If Hussein ever finds out,

Speaker 19 or when he finds out, that

Speaker 19 I've done all this and I've been recording it, he's gonna kill me.

Speaker 7 Devil in the Desert is a production of ABC Audio, ABC News Studios in 2020. Hosted by me, Matt Gutman, this series was produced by Madeline Wood, Camille Peterson, Amy Padoula, and Kiara Powell.

Speaker 7 Our supervising producer is Susie Liu. Music and mixing by Evan Viola.

Speaker 7 Special thanks to Liz Alessi, Katie Dundas, Janice Johnston, Eamon McNiff, Jake Lefferman, Katie Muldowney, and Michelle Margulis. Josh Cohan is our director of podcast programming.

Speaker 7 Laura Mayer is our executive producer.

Speaker 6 It's one of Britain's most notorious crimes, the killing of a wealthy family at Whitehouse Farm. But I got a tip that the story of this famous case might be all wrong.

Speaker 15 I know there's going to be a twist, won't they? A massive twist. At every level of the criminal justice system, there's been a cover-up in this case.

Speaker 6 I'm Heidi Blake. Blood Relatives is a new series from In the Dark and the New Yorker.
Find it now in the In the Dark podcast feed.