State of North Carolina v. Joan Little

With a Spark Cash Plus card from Capital One, you earn unlimited 2% cash back on every purchase.

And you get big purchasing power, so your business can spend more and earn more. Capital One, what's in your wallet? Find out more at CapitalOne.com slash Spark Cash Plus.
Terms apply. It's going to happen to that equation as the TV industry gets smaller and smaller and smaller.
On to explain it all is the veteran sports business journalist, John O'Ran. That's this week on channels from the Vox Media Podcast Network.
This episode contains references to sexual violence. Please use discretion.
I knew I wanted to be a criminal lawyer from the very beginning. I knew that there was a problem in this society with many poor people and African Americans being incarcerated.
And if I wanted to help people, that's who I wanted to help. So I really didn't have any question in my mind the first day of law school until I graduated that I wanted to be a criminal lawyer and a criminal defense lawyer.
This is Karen Bethia Shields. She grew up in North Carolina, and after college, she enrolled at Duke University Law School.
It was 1971. I don't think I ever met a black female lawyer until I was in law school after my first year in law school.
How was law school? It was something to be tolerated. It was hard and it was made to be hard, but I'm competitive, but all my classmates were competitive, and law school was competitive.
While at Duke, Karen started interning with a lawyer in Durham, North Carolina, named Jerry Paul. Jerry Paul was a white male lawyer who did a lot of civil rights work in North Carolina.
He was one of the lawyers that a lot of lawyers did not particularly care for. He handled all the cases that were very controversial in the area, and he represented Southern Christian Leadership Council, SCLC, in North Carolina.
And so he represented them when they handled the discrimination cases, integration cases all across the state.

So we went with him around on his cases and we saw how the criminal justice system really works. Karen was one of the first three black women to graduate from Duke Law School.
After graduation, she immediately started working with Jerry Paul. They used to tease me when I was interning with Jerry and them

that my first case was going to be... After graduation, she immediately started working with Jerry Paul.
They used to tease me when I was interning with Jerry and them

that my first case was going to be a first-degree murder case to get my feet wet. I thought they were playing, but that was true.
I'm Phoebe Judge. This is Criminal.
The day I got my bar exam results was the day that Jerry Paul brought Joanne Little into the office and said that he wanted me to help him represent her. And Joanne Little was a young African-American woman that lived in Washington, North Carolina, Beaufort County, that was accused of killing a jailer who was trying to rape her.
This was in the late summer of 1974. Karen had heard something about Joanne Little in the news.
I was coming back from the beach. I think it was like a Labor Day weekend, and it was on the radio.
And what came on the radio was that a black woman had killed a white jailer trying to escape from jail.

That's all I heard. So by the time I got to the office, that's all the information I had until our secretary said, Jerry's coming into office with that Joanne little woman that you heard about.
And I said, yes. He says he wants you to help represent her.
And so when I came out of the office, I was expecting to see an older black woman. And Jerry had told her that he had a black female lawyer that was going to help him represent her.
And she was looking for older female lawyers. So we both did a double take.
Joanne was 20. Karen was 25.
She was surprised. I was surprised.
She looked so young. And the information that I had heard on the radio made me think she was an older, mature person.
She looked scared and frightened, which she should have been. She did talk a little bit, but not that much.
But, you know, we carried on a conversation. We didn't talk too much at all about the case at that time.
Clients don't normally tell you everything the first time you meet them anyway. And this was so traumatic, you had to be very careful.
Karen learned that a few months earlier, Joanne had been convicted on robbery charges and sentenced to 7 to 10 years. She spent 81 days at the Beaufort County Jail before she escaped.
Eventually, she told Karen the whole story. She told me that Alligood, who was the jailer, Clarence Alligood, had come into her cell with an ice pick and demanded favors.
His modus operandi was that he would give snacks to the women inmates, which he was not supposed to do after hours. And then he would come back and ask later for sexual favors.
And this particular night, Joanne was the only female inmate in those quarters. And he came in and had an ice pick.
This is the ice pick that the jailers used to clean out clogged drains and things. And he told Tom for her to give up, give him what he wanted, to have her to have oral sex with him.
And they struggled, and she was able to get away from him. in the course of the struggle.
She was able to get the ice pick away from him. And they struggled, and she was able to get away from him.
In the course of the struggle, she was able to get the ice pick away from him, and there were a number of ice pick stab wounds. Fortunately, she was able to get her clothes and get out of the jail.
He had the keys there, so she was able to unlock the jail door and got out. This was around three o'clock in the morning.
And then she was able to go into the community, and she hid in the black community. First, she went to a relative's home who would not take her in because they were looking for her all across North Carolina, especially in Washington, North Carolina.
And she finally found a man whose name was Pop Barnes. He was an older man, and he took her in because he knew that she was in trouble.
Joanne knew Pop Barnes because she'd gone to the high school across the street from his house. She said he'd sit on the porch in the mornings and she'd greet him on her way to school.
His house wasn't far from the Beaufort County Jail. Pop Barnes said he'd try to get in touch with her mother for her and that he'd ask his son to find her a lawyer.
It wasn't long before police arrived looking for her. She said she saw an officer from the window holding a rifle.
She hid in the bedroom between the bed frame and a feather mattress and heard Pop talking to them loudly so that she would know what was going on. And he would not tell them where she was.
And they offered him even a year's salary just to tell them that he wouldn't do it because he felt that she needed help. Joanne later testified, quote, Pop said my life meant more to him than their money.
The police came and searched the house multiple times. Joanne's mother, who lived nearby, was followed by police everywhere she went.
In 1974, North Carolina was one of a handful of states that still had an outlaw statute. And there was talk of officially declaring Joanne an outlaw, meaning any citizen could kill her on sight and not be prosecuted.
Joanne hid at Pop Barnes' house for six days. On the sixth night, someone knocked on Joanne's window.
It was a family friend, a woman named Marjorie Wright. I found her through and by some friends of mine.
They told me they thought she was there. I was going from door to door knocking until I found her.
When I found her, she was scared to death. Marjorie told Joanne she was going to take her to someone who could help her safely turn herself in.
They had a plan to sneak Joanne out of the house without the police seeing. Another woman, wearing a wig, was going to walk into the house.
Joanne would put on the wig and walk out as the woman. Then Marjorie would drive her to a meeting point with a lawyer, Jerry Paul.
Joanne said okay. And then I looked up the street and I see this car coming.
And it was a police car and had the lights off. So then there's a great big, you know, grown one of them evergreen bushes like you got.

It was a great big one of those there. And I threw her back behind that evergreen bush.
And I kind of, you know, stooped down myself. And that's the only thing that saved us.
But after he passed, then I opened the door, and then I went back and got her and put her into the car and took her to Jerry. Jerry Paul took Joanne to the house of a professor in Chapel Hill,

where she could stay hidden until they worked out what would happen next.

At this point, Joanne said she didn't know that the guard, Clarence Alligood, had died.

And that was the thing that impressed me,

because it was only after she had been rescued by Jerry Paul that she found out that he had died. Her words, which always haunted me, because I don't think I would have said it, but she said, if I had known he was going to die, I wouldn't have run.
She was even offered an opportunity to leave the country, and she wouldn't do it.

She says, no, I want to stay here.

I want people to know what really happened.

That was another thing that impressed me, because if I had an opportunity in her place,

I probably would not have been in the United States.

But she refused to take that offer up.

She said, I want people to know what happened to me.

And she wanted to tell her story.

And arrangements were made with the State Bureau of Investigation for her to turn herself in.

We'll be right back.

Support for Criminal comes from Quince.

I have a trip to look forward to. It doesn't matter how far in the future it is.
If you'd like to get ahead of any summer trips you've planned, it's not too early to start looking now for a new outfit or two to take on vacation with Quince. They have 100% linen shorts for just $30, and linen tank tops and short sleeve button downs to match.
Plus a bunch of other things you might need for a trip. Suitcases, luggage tags, duffel bags, packing cubes.
I'm always interested in learning more about packing cubes. Personally, I like Quince's wide leg linen pants.
They're very lightweight, come in a lot of colors, and wash and dry well. Everything at Quince is priced 50-80% less than similar brands.
They say they're able to do that by partnering directly with top factories. For your next trip, you can treat yourself to the upgrades you deserve from Quince.
Go to quince.com slash criminal for 365-day returns, plus free shipping on your order. That's Quince.com slash criminal to get free shipping and 365-day returns.
Quince.com slash criminal. Support for Criminal comes from Bombas.
I've been wearing Bomba socks for years. I give them as gifts.
They're simple and well-made and last forever. My current favorite is their half-calf with stripes.
They're the perfect height and never fall down. And they don't have seams on the toe.
Bombas also makes grip socks for Pilates classes, running socks, compression socks, and wool socks for hiking. They've got slippers, shoes for the beach, and clothes too.
I'm about to try their crew neck t-shirt, which is 100% cotton and has very good reviews. One more reason I like Bombas, for every item you purchase, they donate an item to a person experiencing homelessness.
And as of about a month ago, Bombas is going international. They offer worldwide shipping to more than 200 countries.
Go to Bombas.com slash criminal and use code criminal for 20% off your first purchase. That's B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash criminal, code criminal, for 20% off your first purchase.
Bombas.com slash criminal, code criminal. Shortly after Joanne Little turned herself in, the case was presented in front of a grand jury.
One of the jury members was a distant relative of Clarence Alligood's. Karen Bethea Shields says that the state's chief medical examiner had also reached out to her and lawyer Jerry Paul, alerting them to evidence that supported Joanne's case.

He says you need to see the medical examiner's autopsy report.

It showed that semen was found on Clarence Alligood's leg.

And therefore, it was a little bit more to it than she just wanted to get out of jail.

The medical examiner offered to testify in front of the grand jury, but they declined to hear from him. Joanne was indicted on first-degree murder charges.
If she was found guilty, she'd receive a mandatory death sentence. The editor of North Carolina's Washington Daily News wrote that Clarence Alligood was a good man who had died in the

line of duty. A writer for the paper misreported Joanne Little's age as 25, not 20.

The New York Times sent a reporter named James Reston Jr. down to Washington, North Carolina.

He wrote that people referred to it as Little Washington, or the original Washington, because they said it was the first town to be named after George Washington.

And he spoke with people in the town about Joanne's case.

He wrote, quote, she wasn't defending her honor in that cell. She'd lost that years ago.
Reston also reported that one woman, speaking in a, quote, soft, ladylike fashion, said, even if a girl has loose morals, she should be able to pick the man she wants to be raped by. I knew that it was a difficult case, but I also knew that we had the truth on our side and also believes in Joanne Little.
It started adding up when we started getting some of the information, we'll call discovery, from the state. Some of the evidence that they had, we had to really search for it.
For instance, the ice pick, the weapon that was used to stab out of good. We couldn't find that for a while because one of the deputies had put it in his locker.
Then we were able to get people interested in her case. We were able to raise funds for her because, as you know, the criminal justice system is not for poor people as far as amounting a good defense in a criminal case.
Groups like the North Carolina Black Panther Party and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference started organizing for Joanne all across the country. They held rallies.
One chant they used was, One, two, three, Joanne must be set free. Four, five, six.
Power to the ice pick. Rosa Parks, then in her 60s, co-founded a Detroit chapter of the Joanne Little Defense Committee.
Karen Pathea Shields says they didn't want to go to trial in Beaufort County, but they needed to convince a judge that Joanne couldn't get a fair trial there. Because of the attitudes on racism in that county, so we were able to do a survey to show the court that we need to have a change of venue, and that's why the case was moved to Wake County.
The trial was scheduled for the summer of 1975 in Raleigh. I saw her every day.
I would travel from the office in Durham and go to Raleigh, and I would visit her. So we were really more like sisters for a while, while she was in jail, in prison, and we could talk, you know, as young black women.
When I decided to let her know, now I'm the lawyer part, it got a little bit difficult. It's like with a child, you know, you're real pleasant, pleasant, pleasant, then you have to discipline, then they get a little upset.
Well, she got a little upset. I said, no, I said, I'm your lawyer, and we're going to have to do this, this, and this.
She didn't particularly like that too much. She's a Taurus just like me, a little stubborn.
But I liked her. I really do like her.
Was she nervous? Yes, she was nervous. The first time I really saw her nervous other than in my office was when we turned her in to the State Bureau of Investigation,

and there were two law enforcement officers

that brought her into the SBI director's office,

and they had her handcuffed and shackled.

I was extremely upset because she was little,

and they were two big men, and they had her hands behind her back, and she was shackle. I was extremely upset because she was little and they were two big men and they had her hands behind her back and she was shackled.
I hated that and I saw her fear then and anybody looking at me saw my anger, which lasted for a long time because I thought it was unnecessary for her to be bound and shackled like that with all these law enforcement officers around. And I just felt it was humiliation.
Did you know what the state's strategy would be? Yeah. They were going to show that she was a slut.
They were going to demean her. And they had one theory.
She wanted to get out, and she lured him into her cell, and then she stabbed him and she escaped. That was their strategy.
And the way they would do that would be able to deal with the racist attitudes that people had about black women, and also the fact that they would try to say that she was a whore, a prostitute, and everything. She was not.
She was a young lady who had some trouble as a juvenile, but a lot of things that they said were not true, and we had to deal with that. I talked to her about that, and she understood what their strategy was.
Our strategy was to show that it was self-defense. She defended herself.
I think that was the first time that that defense had been used in a rape case. One of the most difficult things was to deal with the issue of rape, because during that time, people had preconceived notions about women that got raped.
They brought it on themselves. Women couldn't really get raped.
I remember when I was in undergrad school in East Carolina, a friend of mine was raped. She was African American.
The The person that raped her was African-American. And Jerry Paul came down, and the judge told him, ain't nowhere in the world a black woman can get raped.
I never forgot that. And I remember that the whole time during representation of Joanne Little.
The judge assigned to the case

was a man named Hamilton Hobb during representation of Joanne Little.

The judge assigned to the case was a man named Hamilton Hobgood.

He knew it was Karen's first trial out of law school.

He never called me Karen.

I think in his part of the state, they pronounced Karen, K-ren.

And he would say, K-ren, how you doing today?

And he was very fatherly, you know, and very respectful of me. The state had a number of prosecutors, but Karen remembers one in particular, Lester Chalmers.
First time I saw him was the day of the first day of the trial. He came into court and he introduced us.
I'm Lester Chalmers, the special prosecutor.

I said, uh-huh.

Then I looked at his tie, and that was the KKK sign.

I later found out that he represented the KKK.

So I didn't really have any warm feelings about him from day one.

The jury selection began on July 14th. There is a pool of 300 potential jurors.
One reporter wrote, quote, the defense in selecting the jury will utilize a relatively new technique based on psychological profiles. They looked at things like body language.
I thought we had pretty good odds. I'm not overly optimistic.
I'm realistic. But you also understand I was young, too, at that time.
And that was probably a good thing. That's why a lot of times folks will talk about young lawyers, and I say sometimes that's the best ones to get because they don't have a lot of nonsense going with them.

They just do what they have to do.

But I was optimistic the whole time.

Joanne testified.

She told the jury that Clarence Alligood brought her cigarettes and sandwiches that she hadn't asked for, and that he'd asked her for sex.

She said, I told him no, and I would really appreciate it if he left, and he left. But then, later that night he came back.
She said, quote, he said that he had been nice to me, and it was time that I be nice to him. She testified that she asked him to leave, and he did not.

On the witness stand, Joanne Little spoke quietly.

When you read the trial transcript, you see that over and over she's being asked to speak louder.

She said Clarence Alligood had been holding the ice pick near her head.

Quote, he threatened me with the ice pick, and I then did what he told me to do.

She said that she tried to grab the ice pick, and it fell on the ground.

Her lawyer asked what happened next, and she said,

he went for the ice pick.

Her lawyer said, and what happened?

And Joanne Little said, I grabbed for the ice pick. Joanne described stabbing Clarence Alligood multiple times with the ice pick and said that he fell to the ground and she saw blood on his face.
She said she grabbed her clothes, took his keys, and ran. At one point, one of the prosecutors, a man named William Griffin, asked Joanne why she hadn't immediately gone to the police.
She said, I felt at that point that they would shoot me down, instead of taking me into custody and making sure that I had safety. She said she knew if she didn't run, I wouldn't have had a chance to be in this courtroom now to tell what happened.
One reporter noted that the prosecutor made Joanne go through painful details again and again. Did you go down on your knees in front of the bunk, he asked.
The reporter wrote, when she did not respond, he shouted the question three more times, until she said, he forced me down. The New York Times reported that

the prosecution sees Joanne Little as calculating and murderous,

a hardened criminal,

with the instincts of a black widow spider.

We'll be right back. Today Explained here with Eric Levitt, senior correspondent at Vox.com, to talk about the 2024 election.
That can't be right. Eric, I thought we were done with that.
I feel like I'm Pacino in three. Just when I thought I was out, they pull me back in.
Why are we talking about the 2024 election again? The reason why we're still looking back is that it takes a while after an election to get all of the most high quality data on what exactly happened. So the full picture is starting to just come into view now.
And you wrote a piece about the full picture for Vox recently, and it did bonkers business on the internet. What did it say? What struck a chord? Yeah, so this was my interview with David Shore of Blue Rose Research.
He's one of the biggest sort of democratic data gurus in the party. And basically, the big picture headline takeaways are...
On Today Explained. You'll have to go listen to them there.
Find the show wherever you listen to shows, bro. Karen Pathea Shields gave a closing argument in Joanne Little's trial.
She decided she wanted to show the jury the dimensions of Joanne's cell at the Beaufort County Jail. We put masking tape down on the floor of the courthouse and used that as Demacia evidence to show how close the cells were and where Joanne was and where Alligood was.
And I used that in my closing argument, and I would step in the cell, and I would put them in Joanne's shoes, and I would put them in Alligood's shoes. I wanted to feel what Joanne felt on that night, and I would use that cell and I would go step in and out of the cell.
During the closing argument, the jurors started crying, and that scared me. I didn't know what to do.
Remember, this is my first argument, and some of them were crying, and my mind was going, what should you do? You can't stop. They may think because you're a female, you can't deal with folks crying.
So I kept on, and I got through it. Karen told the jury something that her father had told her when she was a child.
My father gave me my first lesson on empathy. And he says, but for the hands of time, you could be in her shoes and she could be in yours.
That's what I use for the jurors, to put them in Joanne's shoes. And when I finished, the courtroom was real quiet and I thought I had done something wrong.
I went in the bathroom, and that was the first time since we had gotten the case, since I met Joanne, that I broke down and just cried. I just cried.
And I knew then we had done all we could do. The jury deliberated for just under an hour and a half.
They found Joanne Little not guilty. Surprise might be an understatement for some people, but a lot of the folks on our defense team were not surprised, okay, because we believed in her story, and we believed in her defense.
I remember there's a picture of us, someone took a picture, we were just grinning, and I was so happy for her, because I always knew if she had been given the opportunity, she would have been, she would have really excelled in a lot of things. One thing Joanne did that a lot of people didn't know about, Joanne could express herself better in writing than she could by speaking.
So a lot of times she would express herself through poetry and in writing. But she's very smart.

And one thing that bothered me,

someone somewhere, some teacher somewhere,

should have seen the potential in this young lady rather than seeing something negative.

What did it feel like to win the case, your first case?

Ooh.

It was most interesting to me.

Like I said, a lot of things happened so fast. Ooh, it was most interesting to me.

Like I said, a lot of things happened so fast that when I go back and I start looking at it and I said,

oh, I did that, but I was very happy.

I was very pleased.

The New York Times reported that Joanne began sobbing

when the verdict was read,

and that as she was leaving the courthouse, she said, it feels good to be free. But in the end, Joanne couldn't go home yet.
She unfortunately had to serve some time for the breaking, and we lost that appeal, breaking, entering, and larceny that she was in jail for originally in Beaufort County.

And then, a few years later, in 1977,

Joanne escaped from prison again.

She was recaptured in Brooklyn nearly two months later.

In an interview at Rikers Island,

Joanne said she'd escaped by scaling a fence,

and she did it because she was fed up.

She said she hadn't been treated fairly.

She said she'd gotten test results indicating she might have tuberculosis,

and no one at the prison had done anything about it.

She was brought back to North Carolina and eventually released in 1979.

Karen says today, Joanne keeps mostly to herself.

She doesn't really talk about the trial anymore.

She's doing fine.

She's doing it. Karen says today, Joanne keeps mostly to herself.
She doesn't really talk about the trial anymore.

She's doing fine. She's doing fine.
I think a lot of people would be surprised how her life has turned out in spite of what she had to go through. I know I am.
But, you know, she has done well. Joanne Little was the first woman in U.S.
history to be acquitted of murder using the defense that she used deadly force to resist sexual assault. When you were first brought into this case, did you have any idea about how big and important it would become? Oh, no.
Oh, no, no, no. No, not at all.
Not I thought this was a regular criminal case. It wasn't until they got publicity in the New York Times.
And that's when you start having, it became bigger than just a regular criminal case. But it was good that it happened that way because people could really start saying what the judicial system was like in North Carolina and other places.
And that's when a lot of folks were critical of us on how we defended. They said, you put North Carolina on trial.
I said, we put the judicial system on trial, the justice system on trial. And that's what it should do every time you have a criminal case or a case in court, because the prosecutor and defense attorney have the same objective in mind, finding justice, fairness, what is the truth.
And if you do that, both sides should be happy. Karen kept practicing law.
She mostly worked on criminal cases. And then, around the late 70s, a new judge position opened up in Durham County.
And then the former, the first black judge that we had in Durham County, Judge Pearson, he asked me, I was in court one day, and he called me up to the bench, scared me to death. He says, I want you to put your name in the pot.
And then Christmas Eve, I got the phone call. Well, it was around Christmas Eve because my grandmother was still living, and I was scared.
I said, I don't know if I really can do this. And that's when she gave me my theme song for the rest of my legal career.
I don't feel no ways tied.

She started singing it to me.

And I got the phone call that I had been appointed.

And I was the first female and the first black female judge

in Durham County and the second in the state.

I don't believe he brought me this far to leave. Karen served as a judge for five years.
Today, she's back to practicing criminal law. And I enjoy it.
I still enjoy it now. Now, when I stop enjoying it, if that comes tomorrow, I'll stop tomorrow.
But I still enjoy practicing law.

I still enjoy trying cases. I don't try as many as I did when I was 25, but I still enjoy it.
And I love the law. Is Joanne's case something that shaped the lawyer you've become? Oh, yeah.
Oh, yeah. And like Jerry Paul and Jim Rohn were teasing me when I was interning with them to get my feet wet.
Well, it did. It almost drowned me.
But it did. I saw the law from different standpoints, you know, on my very first case.
I saw how it could be and how it should be. My husband said to me, you're the only person I know that really believes in the law like you do.
I said, I do. I said, the law is great.
It's just that men and women decide what the law is. It's men and women who have their own fallacies that decide how to interpret that fairly.
That's a hard job to do. I felt good about the rate that the jurors brought back in because they looked at the evidence in trial

and they, I think that basically they related to me as a human being to put themselves in

the same position.

And they came out with a verdict that spoke the truth. Criminal is created by Lauren Spohr and me.
Nadia Wilson is our senior producer. Katie Bishop is our supervising producer.
Our producers are Susanna Robertson, Jackie Sujiko, Lily Clark, Lena Sillison, and Megan Kinane. Our show is mixed and engineered by Veronica Simonetti.
This episode was mixed by Emma Munger. Julian Alexander makes original illustrations for each episode of Criminal.
You can see them at thisiscriminal.com. Special thanks to Thomas Mills, who wrote to us about Joanne's story story if there's something you'd like us to look at in an episode email us at hello at this is criminal.com and you can sign up for a newsletter at this is criminal.com slash newsletter we hope you'll join our new membership program criminal plus once you sign up you can listen to Criminal episodes without any ads, and you'll

get bonus episodes with me and Criminal co-creator Lauren Spohr, too. To learn more, go to thisiscriminal.com slash plus.
We're on Facebook and Twitter at Criminal Show, and Instagram at criminal underscore podcast. We're also on YouTube at youtube.com slash criminal podcast.
Criminal is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.

Discover more great shows at

podcast.voxoutube.com slash criminalpodcast. Criminal is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.

Discover more great shows at podcast.voxmedia.com.

I'm Phoebe Judge.

This is Criminal.