In Broad Daylight

Speaker 1 Struggling to see up close? Make it visible with Viz. Viz is a once-daily prescription eye drop to treat blurry near vision for up to 10 hours.

Speaker 1 The most common side effects that may be experienced while using Viz include eye irritation, temporary dim or dark vision, headaches, and eye redness.

Speaker 1 Talk to an eye doctor to learn if Viz is right for you. Learn more at Viz.com.

Speaker 1 From the Creator of Homeland, Claire Danes and Matthew Rees star in the new Netflix series The Beast in Me as ruthless rivals whose shared darkness will set them on a collision course with fatal consequences.

Speaker 1 The Beast in Me is a riveting psychological cat and mouse story about guilt and justice and doubt, now playing only on Netflix. The neighborhood had everything a burglar wanted to find.

Speaker 1 Private yards, wealthy homes. And she had the worst of possible luck.
And that he picked her. Yes.

Speaker 1 I'd like to report an attempt at breaking.

Speaker 1 A mother home alone. The cops race to her front door as she walks into an ambush in her backyard.

Speaker 2 How does somebody die within a matter of seconds with officers all around her home?

Speaker 3 Surreal. It was awful.
It really just all came crashing down.

Speaker 1 Your first thought at that time, it's a burglar gonna ride. But the killer, caught red-handed, starts pointing fingers.
One of the jobs on one of the burglary stage.

Speaker 5 This is a guy who aspired to be a hitman.

Speaker 6 She was a sitting target.

Speaker 1 Doesn't that mean that you can now go out and charge them all with murder?

Speaker 4 I have no facts.

Speaker 1 So detectives lay a track.

Speaker 4 Trying to play cat and mouse.

Speaker 7 He was already really paranoid about being fed up.

Speaker 4 He held up a little note that says, are you wired?

Speaker 1 Will they catch their prey?

Speaker 3 You hold your breath. The world kind of stops.

Speaker 1 You never think it's going to be you.

Speaker 3 Oh, no, no, no, no.

Speaker 1 No. No.

Speaker 1 The young man is right. In fact, this is the kind of thing that just doesn't happen to anyone.

Speaker 8 No, never.

Speaker 8 Never would have thought I would have ever seen anything like this.

Speaker 1 No, and not here. Not in this neighborhood, in this house.
But certainly not. Surely not.

Speaker 1 At the very moment when at least three policemen were just outside the front door and just over the backyard wall, not more than 30 feet away.

Speaker 1 We had to be told a few times just to get it in our heads what happened.

Speaker 1 What happened here in broad daylight under the very noses of the cops

Speaker 1 was murder.

Speaker 1 Long Beach, California, a town that may have been cheated a little in the City Pride Department.

Speaker 2 A lot of people assume it's like LA, but it's not. It's different.
It has its own identity.

Speaker 1 Do you think it's different culturally or or just?

Speaker 2 I think so. I think Long Beach is sort of its own beast.

Speaker 1 Sure.

Speaker 2 It's a little more working class.

Speaker 1 Yes, and it's one of those 50 suburbs in search of a city that everybody calls L.A.

Speaker 1 But Long Beach is a brawny city unto itself. Half a million people, 52 square miles, a busy airport, a big university, an oceanfront, a long beach,

Speaker 1 and its share of wealth and poverty, and of course, crime.

Speaker 2 Lots of scope for a person who's no shortage of work for yeah if you cover crime

Speaker 1 Tracy Manzer covered the police speed of the local paper the Long Beach Press Telegram she was fair to the cops they trusted her so maybe that's why one November morning

Speaker 2 A contact within the police department came over to me in the midst of this sort of press conference and said you need to go to Bixby now.

Speaker 2 And I was a little taken aback.

Speaker 1 Taken aback because Bixby was not a name you heard on the crime beat.

Speaker 2 So it was very clear to me something major was going on. Packed up my stuff, ran out the door, and got to the scene.

Speaker 1 The scene was in Bixby Knowles. Quiet and affluent.
Leave it to beaver homes on carefully tended tree-lined streets.

Speaker 1 Violent crime is unheard of in Bixby Knowles, which is just the way they like it here.

Speaker 1 And maybe that's why, if they grew up here or moved here, they stay close,

Speaker 1 like Rachel Kearns.

Speaker 8 Everybody's very friendly, always waving. You don't get that a lot in Southern California.

Speaker 1 Rachel still lives near the house she grew up in.

Speaker 8 We were able to play as kids at all hours of the day. We didn't have to worry about

Speaker 8 anyone ever hurting us or coming after us. It was a really safe neighborhood.

Speaker 1 But then came that November morning when Tracy Manzer roared over there in her car.

Speaker 2 I had no idea what I was going to, what I was going to find, but I knew based on how I was told about it that it was going to be something, you know, very bad.

Speaker 1 Oh, and it was.

Speaker 2 I was barely out of my car before I saw the homicide lieutenant, the homicide sergeant, two commanders, and obviously a bank of black and whites.

Speaker 2 So my first thought was there was an officer involved shooting. Either an officer had been shot and killed,

Speaker 2 or an officer had shot someone.

Speaker 1 But no, not that. No.

Speaker 1 What really happened was far stranger than that. Long Beach Police Department.
Yes, I'd like to report. I believe we have an attempted break-in going on at the moment.

Speaker 1 It was a neighbor who saw it, like the start of some dreadful shock movie, rolling out in slow motion. It was 11:03 a.m.

Speaker 1 It's taking place at my neighbor's, which is the house just to the west of me. Okay.
One just west of you? Yes.

Speaker 1 It's the Schochner residence. Okay.
The Schochner's, the caller's next-door neighbors. Several cops responded, were there in minutes.

Speaker 1 And as they talked to the 911 caller, they heard and saw a little white dog barking incessantly from a window at the Schochner's house. It was a little, what, American Eskimo or something?

Speaker 2 Yeah, not a very large dog, kind of flappy, fluffy, yappy dog.

Speaker 1 The petite, framed woman came to the window to see what her dog was barking at. An officer gestured to her, come outside.

Speaker 1 Clearly bewildered, she finally opened the door.

Speaker 2 So he's telling her that they got a call from a neighbor that they saw a prowler. And would it be okay if they looked in her backyard and looked around the house? And she had said that that was fine.

Speaker 1 But hold on, the woman said to the police. Let me grab the key.
The gate is locked.

Speaker 2 So she closes the front door, walks through the house, and walks out the back door.

Speaker 1 Three cops waited outside the front door. Two more cops pulled in right here in the alley behind the house.

Speaker 1 And then, to their great surprise, the prowler jumped over the backyard wall, practically into their arms.

Speaker 1 They searched him, found jewelry in his pocket, and a taser and a cell phone, and a knife with blood on it. The cops out front waited for the woman to return.
She didn't. 10 seconds, 20 seconds.

Speaker 1 Did a minute go by? They decided, time to go in. They opened the door, looked through the house, and what they saw was not just terrible, but a riddle, a deception, a piece of pure evil.

Speaker 1 What could have happened in that house? Well, it was surrounded by police officers.

Speaker 3 I didn't believe it. I thought it was a joke.

Speaker 1 Until your father arrived with tears in his eyes.

Speaker 3 That was when I knew something was wrong.

Speaker 1 It was a mild day that particular November 8th, California weather, not quite noon. And as usual, it was quiet in Bixby Knolls here in Long Beach.

Speaker 1 Quiet, and in that quiet, more menacing than anybody understood.

Speaker 1 As police, responding to a call about a prowler, waited outside the front door, neither they nor the half-awake homeowner sensed the jeopardy as she closed the door in their faces and went in search of a key for the gate to the yard.

Speaker 1 Seconds ticked by. The dog barked.
The woman didn't return. So the cops, still not getting it, went in too late.

Speaker 2 She was attacked and she was killed right then and and there while the officer was on her front porch.

Speaker 1 Just extraordinary. Yeah.

Speaker 1 The victim's name was Lynn Schochner. She was 50 years old.
When they found her lying quite dead just outside her own back door, they could clearly see the bright red gash across her throat.

Speaker 1 How was it possible? The policemen were just outside her front door, and more cops were in alert mode out in the alley.

Speaker 1 But the only apparent witness to the silent murder of Lynn Schochner was Lynn's little dog, Zoe.

Speaker 1 Horrified officers found her lying by Lynn's side, her white coat spattered red.

Speaker 1 Back at police headquarters, Long Beach cops like undercover man Chris Nelson heard the chatter.

Speaker 7 We were sitting in the office, and we used to have a police radio on in the office listening to what's going on on the street.

Speaker 1 This was bad.

Speaker 7 We were right down the hall from homicide, and, you know, knew right away that this turned into a call-out, you know where there

Speaker 1 somebody got killed now crisis mode detective richard birdsall took the call get down there fast your first thought at that time do you remember what it was

Speaker 4 it's just a it's a burglar gone a ride did you have at the same time a sense of how the hell could we screw up like that like anybody else you're trying to discern why she did what she did and what did the officers say what was the conversation

Speaker 1 oh yes there were lots of questions this would be ugly why did she go back in the house? Why did the cops let her? Why didn't they move in faster?

Speaker 1 How could they let the murder happen right under their noses?

Speaker 7 That was really disturbing. And, you know, you hate to second judge another cop, but there were mistakes made.

Speaker 1 After all, a neighbor reported a prowler in the back alley, a prowler who may have sneaked into her house. But she, the victim, didn't seem to believe that.

Speaker 4 She had a little

Speaker 4 Eskimo dog that barked at butterflies. And there's nobody in the backyard.
This dog would have allured me to anybody.

Speaker 1 But

Speaker 1 she was wrong.

Speaker 4 She was wrong.

Speaker 1 Lynn's son, Charlie, was a freshman in high school then. He was sitting in math class.
Somebody told him he was wanted in the principal's office. On the way there, he thought he was in trouble.

Speaker 1 And then, when they told him...

Speaker 3 I didn't believe it. I thought it was a joke.

Speaker 1 Until your father arrived with tears in his eyes.

Speaker 3 That was when I knew something was wrong.

Speaker 1 His father, Manfred, or Fred as most people call him, came to take Charlie home. How was your father?

Speaker 3 Upset. I mean he was definitely

Speaker 3 crying.

Speaker 1 He couldn't drive.

Speaker 3 You know, I didn't really have eyes for him in that moment. It really.

Speaker 1 You're just a mess. Yeah.

Speaker 1 And Charlie still could not believe what he was hearing.

Speaker 3 It really didn't set in, really, until I actually saw the house. And

Speaker 3 then it really just all came crashing down.

Speaker 1 His home was a crime scene.

Speaker 3 The house was taped off

Speaker 3 and

Speaker 3 just people going in and out of the house, a lot of neighbors around.

Speaker 3 Like everything you see on TV.

Speaker 1 You never think it's going to be you.

Speaker 3 Oh, no, no, no, no.

Speaker 3 It's surreal. Very much so.

Speaker 1 What does that loss feel like?

Speaker 1 Yeah.

Speaker 3 I can't put it into words. It was

Speaker 3 tremendous. It was awful.

Speaker 3 I immediately call Mark and

Speaker 3 I'm babbling on the phone. I can't even speak.

Speaker 1 Mark Jica is Charlie's uncle, Lynn's brother. After the initial shock,

Speaker 1 there's disbelief. I didn't burst into tears right away.
I didn't start screaming. I was just stunned.
Lynn grew up in Ohio. She was the baby of the family, the only girl.

Speaker 1 Here she is with her two older brothers, John and Mark. But Lynn was not like them.
She was a tentative girl, whereas my brother and I were very outgoing. Their father died young.

Speaker 1 Lynn often fought with her mother. Codependent, love-hate, call it what you want.
She got married, moved to California with a brand new husband. It didn't work out, ended pretty quickly.

Speaker 1 But then one day she went to a ball game, Dodgers versus somebody who knows, and she found him, the right guy, her guy, Fred Schochner.

Speaker 1 He was almost 14 years older than she was, but it didn't seem to matter. Didn't hurt either that Fred was a very successful man.

Speaker 1 Anyway, this time it clicked. They had an intimate wedding on a boat off the California coast.
The captain did the honors, and they lived alone together in that house in Bixby Knolls.

Speaker 1 Until finally, after 11 years, they had a son who grew up to be Charlie.

Speaker 1 As parents, they encouraged him to try new things.

Speaker 3 It was one of the Olympics, and we were watching gymnastics, and I just turned around to my parents and go, I'm going to do that. And I think like a month later, I enrolled in gymnastics.
So

Speaker 3 it was very much a supportive environment.

Speaker 1 And Lynn doted on her only son. It might be trite to say this, but she loved him more than life itself.

Speaker 1 He was the center of her universe.

Speaker 1 So, after what happened, Mark flew out to California right away to comfort Charlie and Fred and to make funeral arrangements for his only sister Lynn.

Speaker 1 And at the very same time, as if in another world altogether, a world devoted to the minuche of violent crime, Detective Richard Birdso poked around the entrance of this burglary gone bad.

Speaker 1 He could perhaps write up a report, be done with it, make the growing bad press go away.

Speaker 1 But no, Richard Birdsell was a troubled man.

Speaker 4 You see, we know something's wrong. My partner and I just feel something's wrong, but we don't know yet.

Speaker 1 Wrong? Well, of course it was.

Speaker 1 But the wrong the detective had in mind was not the grief or the loss of the vitriol thrown at the police. No, it was almost like a smell, the kind that sticks in your nose.

Speaker 1 Something off.

Speaker 1 One of the strangest things of all was the alleged killer himself. Not your typical burglar.

Speaker 4 In his words, he always wanted to be a cop.

Speaker 1 And this wasn't your typical burglary, eh?

Speaker 4 I worked in Burglary Division for four years, but I've never had one come with a device that's used simply for killing.

Speaker 1 Young Charlie was a lucky kid to grow up in a place like Bixby Knoll.

Speaker 3 Tree-lined street, beautiful neighborhood. It's a wonderful place to grow up.
Would ride my skateboard all around the block, take my dog with me.

Speaker 1 He was lucky too to have Lynn for a mother. How did she make you feel?

Speaker 3 I guess how a parent should.

Speaker 1 Safe.

Speaker 3 Safe, happy, welcome, loving.

Speaker 3 just good.

Speaker 1 But now Lynn Schochner was gone, killed in a burglary. And Charlie, just 14 and grief-stricken, was so angry at the police.

Speaker 3 You didn't do your job.

Speaker 3 How could that happen with you being right there? That's just negligence.

Speaker 1 Charlie was far from the only one. This was a broad daylight murder.
Police officers just outside the front door when it happened.

Speaker 1 I can imagine that people would be kind of upset in the neighborhood that a burglar had been there,

Speaker 1 had robbed a house like that, killed a woman, and the cops couldn't prevent it. Right.

Speaker 2 I think the majority of the neighborhood was just stunned and shocked by the violence.

Speaker 2 You know, how does somebody who's in her own home die within a matter of seconds with officers all around her home?

Speaker 1 Tracy's paper, the Long Beach Press Telegram, was reporting on the community backlash. There was fear and, of course, anger.

Speaker 1 Cops often tend to pull together in the face of a thing like that, but in private, harsh judgments, said the undercover cop, Chris Nelson.

Speaker 7 I'm sorry, just don't let her go back into a situation like that. So what was the talk? Police 101.

Speaker 7 At the very minimum, you go with her.

Speaker 1 So what was the feeling in the talk around the department when this happened? They f ⁇ ed up. Detective Richard Birdsell, used to asking tough questions, suddenly found himself answering them.

Speaker 1 I gotta think that the department would kind of adopt a bit of a defensive stance at that point because you know the public's gonna say, what the hell was going on here?

Speaker 1 Why did you guys let that happen, right?

Speaker 4 Yeah, they did. You know, because you're trying to defend the officers and they didn't do anything wrong.
You were waiting for someone to bring you the key.

Speaker 4 And they waited a short period of time within a minute. You know, they're yelling for her, ma'am, can you come back? Hello, where are you?

Speaker 1 Just a minute or so. Enough for Lynn to surprise the burglar who stabbed her in the neck and grabbed some jewelry and ran into the arms of the police.
The detective prowled around the crime scene.

Speaker 4 We see that there's the bedroom, drawers

Speaker 4 were open, jewelry, things are thrown around. So you look like a lot of things in disarray.

Speaker 1 Looked like a standard daytime burglary. Gone horribly bad, of course, when Lynn encountered the robber.
But one thing stood out like,

Speaker 1 well, like a bloody knife.

Speaker 4 I worked burglarly division for four years, but I've never had one come with a device that's used simply for killing.

Speaker 1 So, time to focus on that so-called burglar caught with a bloody knife in his pocket. His name was Nicholas Harvey.
He was 22 years old, and this was unusual.

Speaker 4 He didn't have a criminal background. He'd never been in trouble with the law before.

Speaker 1 Seemed like a reasonably nice young man.

Speaker 4 Yeah, very personable. I mean, he came across that way.
He wanted to ingratiate himself with us as law enforcement. You know, in his words, he always wanted to be a cop sometime in his life.

Speaker 1 And here he's robbing and killing a woman. Correct.

Speaker 1 He'd been an athlete in high school, still worked out a lot, was a personal trainer at his local gym. It's a big muscle-bounce sort of character, wasn't he? Correct.
From Port Wynemie? Port Wineme.

Speaker 1 But that's way up the coast.

Speaker 4 Bounce up by Ventura.

Speaker 1 In other words, about 70 miles from the crime scene. But why would he commit a robbery so far away from home?

Speaker 4 That's one of the flags that immediately came up.

Speaker 1 When Detective Burtzow and his partner first asked him, Nick gave them an answer that frankly still didn't make sense.

Speaker 4 We came at him and, you know, his initial story was, oh, I heard this is a good area.

Speaker 1 Really?

Speaker 1 There wasn't a good area closer to home?

Speaker 1 Well, then Nick gave them another answer.

Speaker 4 He wanted to get out of his area and he worked out at a local gym up there where he was a gym rat and worked out with police officers and did martial arts with police officers.

Speaker 4 So he felt they would recognize him.

Speaker 1 When he said that,

Speaker 1 did it seem plausible?

Speaker 4 No, it wasn't plausible at all.

Speaker 1 And one other thing. Remember how when police arrested him, they found jewelry in his pocket? Turned out it was fake.

Speaker 1 Even though Lynn had lots of real diamonds right there to be taken. along with other valuable items.

Speaker 4 If you're going to do a daytime burglary and you just kill somebody, you're going to make the effort to get the good stuff. But he didn't.

Speaker 1 So, either Nick Harvey was the world's worst burglar, or burglary wasn't the point of his visit. The detectives pushed him hard.

Speaker 4 But he didn't want to change his story. We went at him for hours and we walked out of there going, This is not what it seems to be.

Speaker 1 Just a hunch, of course. No way to prove it.
Until 70 miles up the coast, a man picked up the phone to call the police.

Speaker 1 A family feud. I wrote that letter, I signed the letter, I handed it to my sister, and I dared her to give it to me.
What's that all about?

Speaker 1 Detective Richard Birdso didn't believe for a moment that he was investigating a burglary gone bad. For one thing, a guy doesn't travel 70 miles just to break into a house.

Speaker 1 But for all his suspicions, Birdzel couldn't prove a thing. That is, until a man who knew Nick Harvey called the police and said.

Speaker 4 Nick Harvey came to him and offered him some money, several hundred dollars, to say, hey, can you drive me down to Long Beach?

Speaker 1 He agreed. They met at a park and ride parking lot, and he drove Nick's car.
The driver also said Nick told him why he needed to go to Long Beach.

Speaker 4 Nick Harvey said he was an enforcer for the local drug dealers up there, so he thought he's coming down there just for that one reason.

Speaker 1 Honestly, he had no idea the agenda included murder, said the driver.

Speaker 4 He never knew that he was going to come down to take someone's life.

Speaker 1 Of course, the guy was probably lying, so they put him under arrest. Anyway, his claim that he thought he was driving a drug enforcer didn't make a lick of sense.

Speaker 1 The notion that suburban housewife Lynn Schochner was somehow tangled up with drug dealers that had been targeted for execution is frankly preposterous.

Speaker 1 Lynn had been living a quiet life for 25 years, married to a man with a lot going for him. He was a wealthy man.
For years, Fred earned top dollar in the aerospace industry.

Speaker 1 Not to mention all the family money he inherited. They were able to afford things that none of of us growing up could possibly afford.
We were blue-collar working-class people, and

Speaker 1 we didn't know many millionaires growing up.

Speaker 1 He bought her things, jewelry, and that sort of thing.

Speaker 1 Well, right out of the gate, they bought a very nice home in an exclusive suburb of Long Beach, Bixby Knolls.

Speaker 1 So that was a big step up.

Speaker 1 Mark remembers flying out to see Lynn after she got married. She was dying to show off her home, show off her new life.

Speaker 1 Lynn seemed happy, said Mark.

Speaker 1 She set out, I think, with special determination, having had her first marriage, not last,

Speaker 1 to make this one work and function.

Speaker 1 To make a complete family, a desire that only intensified once Charlie came along.

Speaker 1 She wanted her son to be the best person he could be and would stop at nothing to make sure that he got that.

Speaker 1 Around Bixby Knowles, the Schochners were considered a perfectly normal, if upscale, family. Certainly not the kind of people who would be targeted by drug dealers.

Speaker 1 Of course, members of the family had a slightly more intimate perspective. Mark, for example, loved his sister, but found Fred a little obnoxious.

Speaker 1 He wasn't shy about dropping hints about the extent of his holdings.

Speaker 1 Mark didn't see them very often.

Speaker 1 He lived way across the country in Georgia, but when he did come to visit in Long Beach and they went out for dinner, Fred always managed to monopolize the conversation and somehow stick Mark with the bill.

Speaker 1 Cheap,

Speaker 1 totally opinionated,

Speaker 1 absolutely self-involved.

Speaker 1 So when he invited Lynn and Charlie to visit him in Georgia, I basically told my sister not to bother to bring him, stay as long as she wanted, leave her old man at home.

Speaker 1 And on one of those visits, Mark told Lynn exactly how he felt. I said, How can you let someone run your life and forget about yourself?

Speaker 1 Afterward, he sat down and wrote many of the same things in a harshly worded letter to Fred. I wrote that letter, I signed the letter, I handed it to my sister, and I dared her to give it to him.

Speaker 1 Did you think she actually would? I didn't know,

Speaker 1 but she did.

Speaker 1 That took guts? It did.

Speaker 1 It did.

Speaker 1 And frankly, Mark was pleased when a few years later, after a quarter century of marriage, Lynn told him they were splitting. And Fred moved out of the house in Bixby Knolls.

Speaker 1 She changed somehow after your father left?

Speaker 3 She seemed freer, seemed happier,

Speaker 3 more able to get excited, just really

Speaker 3 interested in everything and very lighthearted.

Speaker 1 But her happiness was short-lived. And when Mark first heard she was murdered, his mind went to a very dark place.
Could Fred have had something to do with it?

Speaker 1 But as much as he disliked Fred, he just couldn't see it. There were no connections in their personal life to this person who committed the crime.
No, it seemed pretty clear.

Speaker 1 Fred had nothing to do with Lynn's murder. Besides, Lynn changed the locks on the house after Fred moved out.

Speaker 1 Could it be someone she hired to install some protection actually came back to rob her and wound up killing her?

Speaker 1 After all, such a person would have seen that Lynn had valuable things around her house in this very nice neighborhood. The neighborhood had everything a burglar wanted to find.

Speaker 1 Private yards,

Speaker 1 wealthy homes. And she had the worst of possible luck in that he picked her.

Speaker 1 Yes.

Speaker 1 And now the family came together in grief. And when he saw Fred,

Speaker 1 we hugged, chated condolences.

Speaker 1 Within five or ten minutes,

Speaker 1 he mentioned the letter. He said, do you still believe that? I said,

Speaker 7 no, that's water over the bridge.

Speaker 1 We need to get on with our family. We need to stick together.
Fred moved back into the family home. He and Charlie and the rest of the family leaned on each other.

Speaker 1 Well, around the neighborhood, people absorbed the news that police had the driver, a possible accomplice, in custody.

Speaker 1 Neighbors wondered, were more people involved?

Speaker 8 There was concern that there were others that might come back to more houses and more homes and that they were violent.

Speaker 1 But that fear soon turned to anger when another bit of news swept through Bixby Knowles.

Speaker 1 The police let the driver go.

Speaker 1 Detectives were convinced Nick Harvey didn't have a motive to commit murder, but just maybe someone else did.

Speaker 4 My partner discovered that there was a person that you talked to multiple times right before the murder.

Speaker 1 Ever since Lynn Schalkner was murdered in her own home, as police stood outside, Criticism of the Long Beach Police Department had been intense, emotions raw.

Speaker 2 The officers were extremely upset. My understanding was

Speaker 2 one of the officers who was on the call

Speaker 2 had a nervous breakdown

Speaker 2 or an episode like that afterward because it was just

Speaker 9 too much for him.

Speaker 1 Detective Richard Birdsall knew, even as he investigated Lynn's murder, that her family was angry with the police. Yeah, they were.

Speaker 4 They're upset like anybody would be. And like the press.

Speaker 4 I I mean, everybody else was upset with us that we didn't do our job to protect someone's life because that's ultimately what we're supposed to do.

Speaker 1 Lynn's husband, Fred, even threatened to sue the Long Beach PD for not protecting his wife.

Speaker 1 And so Detective Burtzel knew he'd take even more heat when the news leaked out that police had arrested an alleged accomplice of the suspected killer and then, just as quickly, released him.

Speaker 1 But that's exactly what Burtzel did. Released the man who admitted he'd driven the killer to the crime scene.
But the detective had a plan.

Speaker 4 We actually put an active feed on his phone. We want to find out who he's talking to.
We have the driver. We have the killer.
Now we want to find out if there's more people involved.

Speaker 1 Detective Birdzel didn't believe Nick Harvey was a drug enforcer, just didn't buy it. So he hoped that by releasing the driver and tapping his phone, he could uncover what was really going on.

Speaker 1 There was just one problem.

Speaker 1 After he was let go, the driver didn't reach out to anyone.

Speaker 4 The only person he ever spoke to was Nick Harvey.

Speaker 1 No, the driver was not part of a larger web. He had nothing whatever to do with Lynn's murder.
So he was telling the truth?

Speaker 4 It turned out, yes.

Speaker 1 Dead end.

Speaker 1 So they kept on digging into Nick's background. And remember, this was a guy with a clean record.
He came off like a perfectly ordinary young man.

Speaker 4 We talked to the family. I mean, they were all incredulous that he would ever do something like that.
Mixed family. Mixed family, correct.

Speaker 1 Incredulous?

Speaker 4 It didn't fit him. Didn't fit his persona.
Never thought he would be capable of doing something like this.

Speaker 1 So when you asked his family about him, how did they characterize him?

Speaker 4 At that time he worked out a lot. He was doing steroids but just didn't really have a focus in life.
He actually was a trainer for the local gym up there. And that's all he did.

Speaker 4 He did a bouncer at a bar, not in the trouble of a lot. He wasn't someone that'd attract trouble to himself.

Speaker 1 But somehow, he'd found plenty of trouble. Police started to figure out how when they subpoenaed his phone records.

Speaker 4 My partner discovered that there was a person that he talked to, Frank Jaramillo,

Speaker 1 and

Speaker 4 multiple times right before the murder.

Speaker 1 Frank Haramea? Correct.

Speaker 1 Frank Haramillo, aka El Cubano, once managed the gym where Nick trained. Odd person to call just before committing a murder, unless, of course, he was in on it.
How to find out?

Speaker 1 Step one, said Chris Nelson. Go back to Nick Harvey.
Lean on him a little bit.

Speaker 7 You got to talk to this guy before he gets arraigned. Because once he's arraigned, you're screwed.

Speaker 1 He's going to get an attorney.

Speaker 7 Sure. And his attorney is going to tell him to shut up.

Speaker 1 Just what Bertzel and his partner were thinking. So they confronted Nick again.
Now two days after Lynn's murder.

Speaker 1 You need to be fully truthful with my partner and I right now because it's only going to,

Speaker 1 you know, it benefits you to tell the truth. This is getting uglier and uglier.

Speaker 4 We went at him one last time. Tell us your story.
He reiterates almost exactly what he said before.

Speaker 1 Which was that he killed Lynn Schochner because the burglary he tried to carry out went bad. The cops still didn't buy it.
Kim and I have been doing this a long time, Nick.

Speaker 1 We need to take Nick and responsibility now.

Speaker 1 Take care of Nick now, please.

Speaker 1 Tell him be truthful with us.

Speaker 1 Because we're not going going to stop Nick. Him and that's our job.
And that's when Nick's story started to change.

Speaker 1 I was hired to hit the house. I don't know why.

Speaker 1 I don't know if they didn't ask. That is, said Nick.
He was hired to commit a burglary. One that, depending on what he could steal, might prove very profitable.

Speaker 3 What's the amount of your promise?

Speaker 1 What was the amount plus

Speaker 1 $2,500?

Speaker 1 B.S., said the cops. He was hired to kill, and they knew it.
Because those phone records told a very different story than he did.

Speaker 1 And finally, Nick Harvey cracked.

Speaker 4 Remember Nick Harvey's words like, yeah, you guys are good.

Speaker 1 He got me. Just like that.
Just like that.

Speaker 4 And then he cops out.

Speaker 1 Yes, he said. Frank Haramillo, the guy they called El Cubano, hired him to kill Lynn Schochner.
gave him $2,500 up front, promised $2,500 more when the job was done.

Speaker 1 Why a guy would commit murder for a measly five grand was one question, but a more urgent one was this.

Speaker 1 Who was this El Cubano, really?

Speaker 1 And why would he pay a guy to kill a housewife in Long Beach?

Speaker 1 It's always the husband, right? But in this case, police didn't seem to think so.

Speaker 3 The detective was very quick to assure me that they have no suspicions of that.

Speaker 1 The plan had been as simple as it was ugly. Nick Harvey, in exchange for just $5,000, was to kill a Long Beach housewife named Lynn Schochner, stage it like a burglary.
and get away clean.

Speaker 1 Instead, Nick was in jail facing murder charges, and detectives were prying apart a conspiracy. Nick had already told them he'd been hired by a man named Frank Haramillo, who went by El Cubano.

Speaker 1 Nick met El Cubano at an El Torito restaurant, he said, where he was paid half up front.

Speaker 1 What do you do with that money?

Speaker 1 I

Speaker 1 move side and buy a hunch and

Speaker 1 bedroom stuff.

Speaker 1 He spent the $2,500 on new furniture from a store called the Couch Potato.

Speaker 1 But when the time came to earn the rest of his money, to kill Lynn, he said, for a moment, he got cold feet.

Speaker 1 Truth be told,

Speaker 1 when I got there,

Speaker 1 I didn't want to do it

Speaker 1 at all.

Speaker 1 In fact,

Speaker 1 when I was sitting there, I was sitting actually at the budget door, and I was

Speaker 1 that part of it. I actually thought about leaving that when she came walking on.

Speaker 1 That's when he went into something like fight-or-flight mode, he said. He killed her.

Speaker 1 And then he quickly ran into the house, pulled out some drawers, grabbed some jewels to make it look like a burglary.

Speaker 1 But then, when he tried to escape, he discovered to his horror the cops were, or appeared to be, waiting for him.

Speaker 1 So then, listen to this: Harvey had a question for the detectives. Can I ask you another question on to be able to have this.
How did it bring you there so fast?

Speaker 1 Neighbor.

Speaker 1 There's people near my

Speaker 1 father get out of the car. He's found the cops raving out there.

Speaker 1 Not until I got back over the walk and I saw the van.

Speaker 1 When I saw the van, I guess that's what I said. Let's just discover myself.

Speaker 1 That is, he thought he was being double-crossed by his friend, Frank, aka El Cubano. That's why he decided to stick to the botched burglary story, he said.
Maybe he'd just get second-degree murder.

Speaker 1 And once he got out of prison, he was going to find Frank. And I'd take care of him myself.

Speaker 1 The detectives played along, of course, let Nick dream up whatever conspiracy theory made him happy.

Speaker 1 But meanwhile, they requisitioned El Cubano's phone records, and they found something quite surprising.

Speaker 4 Not only had Frank Harvey able talking with Nick Harvey, but he also had talked to the husband, Fred Schalkner. Fred Schauckner.

Speaker 1 Fred Schauckner, Lynn's husband of 25 years.

Speaker 1 On the surface, it didn't make much sense. After all, Fred had been cooperative with detectives from day one.

Speaker 1 And yes, he had moved out of the family house, but he told them the break was amicable. She was my best friend, he said.

Speaker 1 And yet, not long after the murder, young Charlie sought out Detective Birdsell and whispered an awful question.

Speaker 4 Did my dad have something to do with this?

Speaker 1 Charlie remembers what they told him.

Speaker 3 The detective was very quick to assure me that they have no suspicions of that. They don't think that would be something that was happening.
And if they had thought that,

Speaker 3 that they would already have looked into it and not to worry about that.

Speaker 1 Is that what detectives really believe?

Speaker 1 Well, no.

Speaker 4 We have to sit there and look at him in the eye and say, well, we'll catch everybody who's involved.

Speaker 1 But not say we suspect him.

Speaker 4 Exactly.

Speaker 1 They believed they simply couldn't tell Charlie or the rest of the family what they were discovering, afraid that Fred would find out, stop talking to them. So Charlie stayed at home with his father.

Speaker 1 His uncle Mark was allowed, even encouraged, to believe that Fred was not involved, even as the detectives were getting the real story from the hitman, Nick Harvey.

Speaker 1 Do you know who talked to Kaban

Speaker 1 regarding this?

Speaker 1 Yep, who

Speaker 1 So doesn't that mean that you can now go out and arrest Haramito and Fred Chaukner? Charge them all with murder, right then.

Speaker 4 We wish. Remember, it's a co-conspirator statement.
I have no facts. I've got a statement for one person.

Speaker 1 That person, Nick Harvey, was an admitted killer and demonstrated liar.

Speaker 1 And with the police department under so much scrutiny, they didn't dare arrest anybody without solid proof. Just think of the scandal if, on top of everything else, the prosecution failed.

Speaker 1 They did find Fred's business card in Harvey's wallet, but that wasn't enough either.

Speaker 1 Meanwhile, the public and Lynn's family would be encouraged to believe it was a simple case of a burglary gone bad. A murder the cops should have prevented.

Speaker 4 I couldn't go out there and defend my department as much as I wanted to.

Speaker 1 You couldn't say anything.

Speaker 4 And I can't tell the press. I can't tell, I mean, we can't defend ourselves because the suspects' persons of interest are the ones we're looking at.
We don't want to alert them.

Speaker 4 We don't want them to get lawyers.

Speaker 1 So inside and outside the Long Beach PD, the pressure was on.

Speaker 4 And my department was on one of the quick resolve because we have a black eye. The press was just beating us up daily as of what we did.

Speaker 1 So the clock was ticking. Detectives needed to prove the murder for hire plot, and they needed to do it fast.

Speaker 4 So that was the whole game is trying to play cat and mouse, trying to get more. We want to get them to talk.
We want to get them to communicate.

Speaker 1 but wasn't going to happen by the look of it, even though they kept talking to Fred. You kept going to the husband, playing dumb, of course, but hoping he'd panic and call El Cubano.

Speaker 4 I mean, to the point where we were calling almost every day, but again, trying to give a reason so he wouldn't become more suspicious than what he was.

Speaker 1 Oh, just one more question, sir.

Speaker 4 Exactly. I felt like Columbo.
Oh, one more, sir.

Speaker 1 This was a game, of course, with deadly consequences, and it it was about to get real.

Speaker 1 Fred and Frank finally start talking.

Speaker 4 We had like 60 plus phone conversations between them. How's he doing, bud?

Speaker 1 It has been a rotten, rotten time. But will it help detectives catch a killer?

Speaker 1 Looking to crack the code on your career? Well, maybe it's time to get your degree. Southern New Hampshire University offers over 200 programs you can complete online.

Speaker 1 No set class times means you can do it all on your schedule. And with some of the lowest online tuition rates in the U.S., they make getting your degree affordable, too.

Speaker 1 Get started at SNHU.edu slash dateline. That's snhu dot edu slash dateline.

Speaker 10 Most holiday gifts end up in a drawer or the back of your closet or accidentally left at your cousin's house. Not this one.
Mint Mobile is offering unlimited premium wireless for $15 a month.

Speaker 10 That's their best deal of the year, aka a holiday gift you'll actually use every single day. Don't get them socks.
Get them premium wireless for $15 a month.

Speaker 10 Shop Mint Unlimited plans at mintmobile.com/slash dateline. That's mintmobile.com/slash dateline.
Limited time offer.

Speaker 10 Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months or $180 for 12 months plan required $15 per month equivalent taxes and fees extra initial plan term only greater than 35 gigabytes may slow when the network is busy capable device required availability speed and coverage vary see mintmobile.com If you're a maintenance supervisor at a manufacturing facility and your machinery isn't working right, Granger knows you need to understand what's wrong as soon as possible.

Speaker 12 So, when a conveyor motor falters, Granger offers diagnostic tools like calibration kits and multimeters to help you identify and fix the problem.

Speaker 12 With Granger, you can be confident you have everything you need to keep your facility running smoothly. Call 1-800-GRANGER, ClickGranger.com, or just stop by.

Speaker 1 Granger for the ones who get it done.

Speaker 1 Death has a way of bringing people together, as it did in the case of Lynn Schochner. She was a private woman, had very few friends beyond her son, Charlie.
And yet.

Speaker 3 We had a big service for her. It was amazing how many people came out from her mother.

Speaker 3 It was nice. I just remember

Speaker 3 at that point I couldn't even cry.

Speaker 3 I was just still

Speaker 3 depressed and shocked. And

Speaker 3 I felt bad for that for a long time.

Speaker 1 Well, that's pretty normal. Yeah.

Speaker 1 Do the tears come?

Speaker 1 Yeah.

Speaker 3 It took a while, but they did.

Speaker 1 Meanwhile, Detective Richard Birdsell was chipping away at the case, but far too slowly for the likes of his bosses at the beleaguered Long Beach Police Department, still under fire for not preventing a murder.

Speaker 1 The detectives had found some connections among the three suspected conspirators, but not nearly enough to go to court.

Speaker 4 You have a murder for hires. Okay, now you've got to go arrest everybody.

Speaker 4 I'd love to, but do I have a probable cause? No, I really don't. I've got to prove more.

Speaker 1 So the detectives kept dropping in on Fred, all very non-threatening.

Speaker 1 And then finally, they asked him if he happened to know anyone in the Port Wai Nee area. That's where hitman Nick Harvey lived.
And Fred said, yes, he did.

Speaker 1 The man he knew, he said, was Frank Haramillo, just a guy he met when Frank managed a gym in Long Beach.

Speaker 1 In fact, said Fred, he'd bought a used BMW from Frank for $25,000, and Frank was going to deliver the car when he returned from an overseas business trip. in New Delhi.

Speaker 1 Of course, from phone records, the cops knew perfectly well that Frank, aka L. Cubana, was in fact at home, about 50 miles north of Long Beach, in Woodland Hills.

Speaker 1 But Fred kept talking, and ever more Chatty volunteered he'd lend Frank more than $100,000, which made sense given what detectives had already learned about Frank.

Speaker 4 He had a fetish for watches and living the lifestyle of the rich and famous, and he really didn't have a full-time job.

Speaker 1 But if Frank thought he was taking advantage of Fred, the detectives believed it was just the opposite.

Speaker 4 I think Fred Schochner wanted to own Frank Haramillo in some way.

Speaker 1 So Frank already had the $100,000.

Speaker 1 Now he's on the hook, big time, to Fred. And Fred says, to get off the hook, you got to make this happen.
Correct.

Speaker 1 Then slate's wiped clean. Yep.

Speaker 4 Absolution of all debt.

Speaker 1 So, in the detective's view, Fred was the mastermind, using his financial leverage to manipulate Frank, who in turn hired Nick for a bargain basement price.

Speaker 1 But Fred still didn't know the cops even suspected him. Didn't have any idea, for example, that they were tapping his phone.
So, when Fred actually began calling the cops to play Mr.

Speaker 1 Cooperative, they recorded every word. Hello, officer.
This is Fred Schochner. Hey, Mr.
Schochner, how you doing?

Speaker 1 There has never been anything as bad as this in my life.

Speaker 1 And I hopefully hope there never will be. Well, I don't blame you.
But you asked me a couple of questions, and let me give you some information. Okay.

Speaker 1 The check that I wrote to Frank was cashed on October 29th.

Speaker 1 25,000. Yeah.
Okay.

Speaker 1 That was for the BMW. That was for the BMW.

Speaker 1 And look at this. On the check, there's a note that indicates the BMW would be delivered between between 11-7 and 8.

Speaker 1 Lynn was murdered on the 8th of November.

Speaker 1 I called him today and asked about the status of the car on the voicemail. Okay.

Speaker 1 Yeah, you called him today? You didn't happen to ask him if he's back in the country yet, did you? No, I just left a voicemail.

Speaker 13 Oh, okay.

Speaker 1 And does this sound like Fred is having fun toying with the cops? Yeah, any other questions that you have for us at this time?

Speaker 1 Happy fishing.

Speaker 1 Why is it going so long? That's a good question, because the fishing isn't answering, right?

Speaker 13 Well, like I said, you know, I told you from the beginning, it's a pretty simple case. Yeah, but our clock's back on the other line's ringing.

Speaker 1 Sure. In the middle of the conversation, Fred got another call from Frank Haramillo.
Fred puts him on hold, continues to speak with the detective, even offering a theory about the killer, Nick Harvey.

Speaker 1 You know, the kid from Port Winemi

Speaker 1 may have been someone that was associated with the lock change. It may have been someone that was associated with someone she met and tried to help.
Exactly.

Speaker 1 Fred hung up with the detective and picked up his cell phone to talk to Haramio. That call was also recorded.
Hello, did you hear a lot of that? Um, kind of.

Speaker 1 Okay, good.

Speaker 1 I don't need to talk about it. Okay.

Speaker 1 How's you doing, bud?

Speaker 1 It has been a rotten, rotten time.

Speaker 1 All the, there's so much sympathy and so much activity surrounding it, it's unbelievable.

Speaker 1 So just as the cops had been hoping, Fred and Frank talked, but not a word from either one to establish they were involved in a murder.

Speaker 4 We had like 60 plus phone conversations between them, and you're tapping them all. And we're tapping in them all.

Speaker 1 But they just didn't slip up. So it was time, the detectives decided, to launch the undercover squad led by Chris Nelson.

Speaker 7 I was armed with information now. Nick Harvey's told the homicide guys what's up.
They've told me. So now,

Speaker 7 if you're Frank and Fred,

Speaker 7 freaking frack,

Speaker 7 your biggest concern is that Nick's caught.

Speaker 1 Yeah, of course. And you want to make sure he's not going to say that.

Speaker 7 What does he have to trade?

Speaker 1 First, Detective Nelson decided he'd go for broke by phoning Fred Chalkner himself and claiming to be the hired killer, Nick Harvey. So how did you go about doing this?

Speaker 7 I went to county jail and I used one of their inmate phones because I wanted the pre-recording. It says, you're receiving a call from a California penal institution, blah, blah, blah.

Speaker 7 And he hung up on me, I think the first time. There's a pause there where they ask you if you're willing to accept.

Speaker 7 And he said, no, click.

Speaker 7 And then I waited about five minutes and I called him again.

Speaker 1 And this time, Fred took the call.

Speaker 7 I said, I'm the guy that did that work at your house for you.

Speaker 7 And I said, well, I'm going to need my other half.

Speaker 7 I'm going to need my money,

Speaker 7 you know, for an attorney. And he says, well, you already have it.
And I said, no.

Speaker 7 And he said, well, you need to talk to your guy.

Speaker 1 Your guy.

Speaker 1 He could only meet Frank Jaramillo. But he didn't say the words, didn't say anything incriminating.

Speaker 1 And so

Speaker 1 now he tries something different, much riskier. Time to get Uncle John involved.

Speaker 1 Detectives set a trap.

Speaker 7 I'm the one that can keep Nick quiet.

Speaker 7 You're going to give me money.

Speaker 1 But will Frank walk into it? He's more than Quinn's. I don't, you know, I really don't have money to help him out.

Speaker 1 After days of repeated calls and interviews with Fred Schochner, detectives had elicited some tantalizing details, but not enough evidence to arrest him for Lynn's murder.

Speaker 1 So, they decided to focus on suspected middleman, Frank Jaramillo, El Cubano.

Speaker 1 Undercover cop Chris Nelson had a plan to set a trap to make Frank believe he was about to be fingered by the hitman, Nick Harvey. So he'd phone Frank and portray himself as A relative of Nick's

Speaker 1 with a past of my own.

Speaker 7 Not particularly liking cops. You know, I'm the one that can keep Nick quiet.
And what are you going to give me in exchange for that? You're going to give me money.

Speaker 1 Afraid Frank would recognize the trap and hang up on him, Detective Nelson elected to make up a very unthreatening persona.

Speaker 7 So I thought, well, I'll be Uncle John, you know, that his mother sent down from the Bay Area to see what's really going on and what Harvey got himself into.

Speaker 1 Oh, Uncle John places a call to El Cubano. Hey, Frank? Yes.
Frank, hey. Hey, my name's John.

Speaker 1 Now, to set the trap, he'd say Nick needs money for a lawyer. But he seems to think you or Fred will help him out.

Speaker 7 He doesn't want a f ⁇ ing public defender.

Speaker 7 Okay.

Speaker 1 Frank tells Uncle John he knows Nick, but he's more than Quinn's. I don't, you know, I really don't have money to help him out.
At first, Frank doesn't seem to take the bait.

Speaker 1 Yeah,

Speaker 1 if I can help him anyway, I understand. I would, but

Speaker 1 I'm sorry that I apologize. I can't.
But then carefully, Uncle John reels him in.

Speaker 1 He seemed to think that if somebody didn't reach out to him, he told me, not so much you, but he told me to tell, have you tell Fred

Speaker 1 that if he didn't get some help pretty soon,

Speaker 1 he was going to go to the cops. Okay.
So, give me a call tomorrow and I'll see what I can do to help you, partner.

Speaker 1 But after all that, Frank did not make the all-important and incriminating call to Fred Schochner, asking for money.

Speaker 1 Until the very next day, Uncle John tried again. Hey, did you get a hold of Fred? No, but between you and I, I don't mind taking care of him, but.

Speaker 1 Frank asked for time and agreed to meet Uncle John in person to hand over some money. Do you know where the Thousand Oaks Mall is at?

Speaker 1 Thousand Oaks Mall. It's off of Lynn Road.
Lynn?

Speaker 1 Yes, off the 101.

Speaker 1 Lynn Road. The irony was apparently lost on Frank Haramillo.

Speaker 1 It was mid-morning, late November. Detective Nelson was worried.
Would he show up?

Speaker 7 You sit in a parking lot by yourself, and you kind of go over and share your your heart races a little bit.

Speaker 7 I mean, it's crunch time, and you feel like everybody's kind of depending on you to get this done.

Speaker 7 You want it to go well.

Speaker 1 So, the idea is you're reeling them in like a fisherman, but there are times when you don't know what's going to happen.

Speaker 7 Right. You know, could have a fray in the line, have a break.

Speaker 7 Had that happen a few times, but not this time.

Speaker 1 There was Frank in a brand new Lexus SUV.

Speaker 1 Frank?

Speaker 13 Yeah, that's me.

Speaker 13 That's not a liar.

Speaker 1 Oh, yes, referring to the less expensive car he said he'd be driving.

Speaker 1 Oh, yeah. My wife is having quite a support.

Speaker 13 That's sweet.

Speaker 13 I know what you're spent your money on.

Speaker 1 Money from Fred Schochner is what the cop meant. Frank did not take that pay.

Speaker 14 I gotta get going.

Speaker 1 Hard to tell from the video, but Frank coughs up the money.

Speaker 13 I gotta grandpa right now because there's no monitoring my accounts.

Speaker 13 You know, he is.

Speaker 13 Are they looking at you?

Speaker 1 Detective Birdsell was inside a van listening to the whole thing go down.

Speaker 4 When you finally get something like that's cold. Oh, that was the nail in his coffin.

Speaker 1 So the instant he offered that thousand dollars, you knew, I got him. Yep, we got him.

Speaker 4 He locked himself into it.

Speaker 1 And a couple of days later, Detective Birdsell and his partner paid Frank a visit to snap their trap shot.

Speaker 7 They basically brace him with, you know, who's this guy, John? It's our understanding you gave him some money, and he's like, I don't know what you're talking about, you know, like.

Speaker 1 I've never met any guy named John.

Speaker 7 Yeah, you know, I come into the room a few minutes later, and whoops. Yeah, and it was like the old look of the century.

Speaker 1 Then he realized you're a cop. Yeah.
Oh, man.

Speaker 7 He just hung his head and

Speaker 7 he just he looked sick.

Speaker 7 I think the whole world came crashing down at that point.

Speaker 4 You could see the look in his eyes like the deer in the head of life. And then he just started giving it all up.

Speaker 1 At home with Fred Scharkner, behind closed doors. You thought all families were like that? Yeah.

Speaker 3 It was always just

Speaker 3 that's what families did.

Speaker 1 Nearly a month after Lynn Schalkner was cut down at her own back door, her killer was behind bars. But her husband, Fred, was still a free man and back in the family home with Charlie.

Speaker 1 The press was in the dark. Long Beach was in the dark.
No one seriously believed, but the police now firmly believed, that Fred Schachner ordered and paid for his own wife's murder.

Speaker 1 As Charlie's uncle Mark said,

Speaker 1 Never in my wildest dreams, even after she was killed, because of the circumstances, nothing pointed at Fred.

Speaker 1 And the police did not point at Fred. That said to Take the Richard Burtza.

Speaker 1 They had their reasons.

Speaker 4 We used them in a lot of respects, and

Speaker 4 you felt guilty because they're beating their chests and they're upset, and they had no idea that the father of Charlie is the one that set the whole thing up.

Speaker 1 Well, remember, maybe some idea.

Speaker 3 I mean, I always had my suspicions.

Speaker 1 In spite of the fact that it was a burglar, and the police said it was a burglar,

Speaker 1 you still suspected your father?

Speaker 3 I didn't want to put it past him as much as, like, as a kid, you don't want to suspect someone of that.

Speaker 3 It just seemed

Speaker 4 false.

Speaker 3 Like, there were clues, there were little tics of stuff that you...

Speaker 3 It just seemed wrong.

Speaker 1 It started the day his mother was murdered, when he and his dad surveyed the house, ransacked during the burglary.

Speaker 3 He had me go back and clean up all the jewelry that had been overturned and spilled out.

Speaker 1 What does that do to your mind?

Speaker 3 It made me very numb.

Speaker 3 Very numb. I just, it was a task, and I did it, and then I went to bed.

Speaker 1 And your dad went to bed in the house with you?

Speaker 1 Charlie understood his father intimately, of course. And he alone knew the secret.
Understood his father in a way that had been hidden from the outside world for years.

Speaker 1 Charlie may have looked like any other happy suburban kid, but at home, he said, he understood normal life to be the constant expectation of moments of terror, frequent, unpredictable rages, abuse, a mother desperately trying to protect him.

Speaker 1 And so he would want to beat you with a belt, and she would try to prevent it, and that would produce an argument between them.

Speaker 3 And then he would beat her.

Speaker 1 How often?

Speaker 3 Often enough that as a child I knew what was going on. But then that was normal so I didn't know what was wrong.

Speaker 1 You thought all families were like that?

Speaker 3 Until I had friends really come over and

Speaker 3 they noticed stuff and

Speaker 3 it was weird for them to notice things and to comment on it.

Speaker 3 But yeah,

Speaker 3 it was always just...

Speaker 3 that's what families did.

Speaker 1 Year after year, it went on, said Charlie, until his mother came to whisper her own secret. She was finally going to leave Fred.

Speaker 3 My mom was tucking me in at night when I was 12 or so, and she was talking about how she was thinking about doing this,

Speaker 3 and that she was so nervous about doing it and didn't know if it was the right choice or... what to do about it.

Speaker 1 What'd you think?

Speaker 3 My first thought was very excited because it was just

Speaker 3 great to be able to think of getting away from him.

Speaker 1 And then finally, more than a year later, Lynn hired family law attorney Lisa Brandon. What did she tell you she wanted from you?

Speaker 6 She wanted a fair division of the property.

Speaker 1 But, said Lisa, Fred controlled all the finances. So she didn't know how much money they had as a family.
No. How much money did they have as a family?

Speaker 6 Well, including the equity in the home, probably six to seven million.

Speaker 1 Which, in a legal separation by California law, would be split down the middle. But Lisa said Lynn told her Fred would never part with any of that money.

Speaker 1 Lynn also told her about Fred's physical abuse. And so, with the pending separation, Lisa worried about Lynn and Charlie's safety.

Speaker 6 I wanted her to move out of the home with Charlie. She wouldn't do it.
She wouldn't leave her home. She wouldn't disrupt Charlie.
He was just starting high school.

Speaker 6 They'd lived in the neighborhood forever.

Speaker 6 So she was a sitting target.

Speaker 1 Did she understand that it was dangerous for her? Yes. Yes.
And yet she went ahead and did it anyway.

Speaker 6 That's how important getting out of that relationship was to her. She was willing to risk her life, and she told me that.

Speaker 1 Lisa told Lynn she should at least get a restraining order against Fred.

Speaker 6 It wouldn't make a damn bit of difference.

Speaker 1 That's what she told you.

Speaker 6 Huh. If he's going to kill me, he'll kill me.

Speaker 6 Restraining orders won't stop him.

Speaker 1 Too late now, of course.

Speaker 1 But what about Charlie? The detectives, worried about his safety, called Lynn's brother Mark.

Speaker 1 He'd gone back across the country to Georgia, and urged him to invite Charlie for an extended visit with him and his wife, Susan, even though they did not tell Mark about their suspicion.

Speaker 1 I was surprised. I am still to this day that Fred allowed that to happen, but he did.

Speaker 1 Perhaps Fred had more pressing things to think about. Whatever his reason, he put Charlie on a plane to Georgia just in time for the main event in the murder investigation.

Speaker 1 Frank Haramillo, under arrest as the alleged middleman, was spilling it all, telling police he took money from Lynn's husband, a lot of it, and used a little of it to hire the killer, Nick Harvey.

Speaker 1 And then, with a little polite arm twisting, Frank agreed to help set a trap for the suspected mastermind, Fred Schauckner. But wait a minute, did you promise him something? And he said.

Speaker 4 I didn't promise him anything.

Speaker 1 No.

Speaker 1 So why would he do it?

Speaker 4 I think in his mind, because we got him on everything else, he was trying to dig himself out of a hole.

Speaker 1 Or maybe Frank didn't understand how deep the hole was. As undercover cop Chris Nelson prepared Frank for his big meeting with Fred, El Cubano got a call from his wife.

Speaker 7 He said, Hey, I'm down here with a cops and I'm helping them. And he goes, I'll be home later.

Speaker 4 He actually thought he was still going home.

Speaker 7 He even told me, He goes, Well, I didn't kill her.

Speaker 7 And I wanted, I almost wanted to slap him and go, No, you just hired somebody else to.

Speaker 1 Oh, you must have known. I mean, you got to be blind and deaf not to know that.
You'd think.

Speaker 7 We used to laugh, like, is this guy for real?

Speaker 1 Frank set it up, called Fred's Einline, got the answering machine. Hi, you reached the shock nurse.
Still Lynn's voice.

Speaker 1 I'm gonna try on your cell phone, bud. We'll take it easy.

Speaker 1 Fred picked up the phone. Hello? Hello? Hello? You there? Yeah, what's going on, bud?

Speaker 3 Nothing much.

Speaker 1 And they agreed to meet 7:30 in the evening at a local restaurant.

Speaker 1 I'll try to be there on time. All right, bud.
that's all came around 7:30, bud. Right? Goodbye.

Speaker 1 Less than two hours later, Frank, wearing the same hidden camera the detective used to catch him, walked into the restaurant to meet Fred Schochner.

Speaker 7 I set him up with the camera and the audio, and we got a table a couple tables away, three of us, to make sure that he didn't run. So he had your eyeballs on him.

Speaker 7 Yeah, and we wanted to see everybody's reaction. And

Speaker 7 we had, of course, the audio. We had a surveillance team outside listening to everything.

Speaker 1 One problem, 7.30 came and went. Minutes ticked by.
No Fred.

Speaker 7 He was already really paranoid about being set up.

Speaker 1 Would he show? And what if he didn't?

Speaker 11 Hi there, it's Andy Richter, and I'm here to tell you about my podcast, The Three Questions with Andy Richter.

Speaker 11 Each week, I invite friends, comedians, actors, and musicians to to discuss these three questions. Where do you come from? Where are you going? And what have you learned?

Speaker 11 New episodes are out every Tuesday with guests like Julie Bow and Ted Danson, Tig Nataro, Will Arnett, Phoebe Bridgers, and more.

Speaker 11 You can also tune in for my weekly Andy Richter call-in show episodes, where me and a special guest invite callers to weigh in on topics like dating disasters, bad teachers, and lots more.

Speaker 11 Listen to the three questions with Andy Richter wherever you get your podcasts.

Speaker 14 If you're a smoker or dipper ready to make a change, you really only need one good reason. But with Zen nicotine pouches, you'll discover many good reasons.

Speaker 14 Zinn is America's number one nicotine pouch brand. Plus, Zinn offers a robust rewards program.
There are lots of options when it comes to nicotine satisfaction, but there's only one Zen.

Speaker 14 Check out zinn.com/slash find to find Zinn at a store near you.

Speaker 14 Warning, this product contains nicotine. Nicotine is an addictive chemical.

Speaker 15 Just got a new puppy or kitten?

Speaker 1 Congrats!

Speaker 15 But also, yikes! Between crates, beds, toys, treats, and those first few vet visits, you've probably already dropped a small fortune, which is where Lemonade Pet Insurance comes in.

Speaker 15 It helps cover vet costs so you can focus on what's best for your new pet. The coverage is customizable, signup is quick and easy, and your claims are handled in as little as three seconds.

Speaker 15 Pro tip: LemonAid offers a package specifically for puppies and kittens. Get a quote at lemonade.com/slash pet.
Your future self will thank you. Your pet won't.
They don't know what insurance is.

Speaker 1 It all came down to this place, this moment.

Speaker 1 After nearly a month of painstaking investigation, detectives had engineered a face-to-face meeting between the murder middleman, Frank Harramillo, and the suspected mastermind, Lynn Schachner's husband, Fred.

Speaker 1 This is where Frank would attempt to get Fred to say something to incriminate himself. Except Fred was late.
Had he finally realized they were laying a trap?

Speaker 1 7.30, 7.33,

Speaker 1 7.35.

Speaker 1 Nothing. If he didn't show, this could all fall apart.
Then, a signal from the surveillance van. There he was.

Speaker 7 The guys outside saw him kind of casing the place to make sure he wasn't being, he was already really paranoid about being set up.

Speaker 7 And

Speaker 7 he came in with his notepad.

Speaker 13 Hey, old man, how you feeling?

Speaker 1 Now, all eyes were on Frank and Fred.

Speaker 7 And they both, at this point, look like they've been rode hard and put away wet.

Speaker 7 I mean, just Jarmillo's tired looking, and, you know, you can imagine the amount of stress that must be going through him.

Speaker 7 And then the old man, who didn't look like he was doing particularly well either.

Speaker 1 Does he look frightened or something?

Speaker 7 Yeah, they both looked scared.

Speaker 7 They both looked like trapped rats on a burning ship, you know.

Speaker 1 And, as they feared, Fred was suspicious. He sat down, said not a word, but he'd written something on his notepad.

Speaker 4 I wish Point Fred Shock had lifted that note up that says, are you wired?

Speaker 4 I'm not.

Speaker 4 It's very possible.

Speaker 7 I thought he was going to walk. You know, I thought, you know, this guy's going to come to his senses and realize this.

Speaker 1 Stand up and turn out and walk out the restaurant. But he didn't.

Speaker 1 He stayed and they talked. Frank tried to get Fred to admit his role.
Fred deflecting his attempts.

Speaker 13 You know that you and I would not be sitting here if

Speaker 13 you didn't want Lynn killed. You know that.

Speaker 1 But Frank kept going at him. And Fred finally let something slip.

Speaker 13 I'm scared, Fred. I don't know.
I understand you're scared too.

Speaker 13 We have to understand, we would not be in this position if it wasn't for

Speaker 13 it wasn't for Linda. We would not be here.

Speaker 13 That's good.

Speaker 13 And if it hasn't been sloppy on the next part,

Speaker 1 Fred. Fred referring to Nick Harvey, the hired killer, for the first time, connecting himself to Lynn's murder.
But Frank kept going after him as if he knew they needed more.

Speaker 13 We would not f ⁇ ing be here if it wasn't for you.

Speaker 13 We would not be here. We wouldn't.
And we wouldn't be here if it wasn't for the way you fed up.

Speaker 13 If he fed up and got caught, that's him. He's doing the time for you.

Speaker 13 Okay, if he had known that,

Speaker 7 it's like watching two old married couples arguing back and forth about whose fault it was that the

Speaker 7 dinner was called or something.

Speaker 1 But of course, this argument was deadly serious.

Speaker 13 Get to understand. We needed a finger race this problem.

Speaker 13 This is your problem, okay? Get to understand. Listen to me.
No, this is not my problem. It's our problem.

Speaker 13 Isn't it?

Speaker 13 I would have to say it's more your problem.

Speaker 1 Fred was still very suspicious of Frank. Asked a few more times if he was wired.
And Frank, frustrated now, tried to goad him.

Speaker 13 I killed Lynn?

Speaker 13 You're saying that I killed Lynn? Nope. You were right.

Speaker 13 You're saying I killed Lynn? Nope. Who wanted her dead?

Speaker 13 You're asking me that question. Who wanted her dead?

Speaker 13 Who benefited from that, Fred? Nobody did.

Speaker 1 Frank argued like a man who wasn't acting. Maybe he wasn't.

Speaker 13 Oh, really? Then who wanted her dead? Me?

Speaker 13 Ask me that question.

Speaker 1 Who wanted her dead?

Speaker 13 Not me.

Speaker 1 The tension between the two seemed to reach a breaking point.

Speaker 13 You

Speaker 13 would act off

Speaker 13 allow us to think and talk together. Can't understand.
That's why I'm here. No, what you're here is trying to incite me and to do things.
Oh, really?

Speaker 13 Okay, you know, Fred, why don't you just go home? Whatever money I owe you, I'll f pay you back. I asked you a simple question you cannot answer it.

Speaker 1 And just as Fred was walking away, Frank gave it one last shot.

Speaker 13 Why don't you admit what you did wrong? I haven't done anything wrong. Okay.

Speaker 13 And I did everything right? No, you haven't done anything either, have you? No. That's what you told me on the phone? You need to quiet an expand.

Speaker 13 I don't have the words to quite an experiment because you have all my cash. And I'll say what you want to give me with here.

Speaker 13 I'll give it back to you, and you can

Speaker 13 do money next.

Speaker 1 And that was it. Maybe not exactly the words Detective Burtzow hoped to hear, but after weeks of dead ends and intense pressure, getting Fred on tape saying those things finally made his case.

Speaker 1 What was the mood in the van you were sitting in?

Speaker 4 It was elation.

Speaker 1 We got it up.

Speaker 1 Finally, enough evidence to arrest him.

Speaker 1 But they didn't. They let him go home just to see what he'd do.

Speaker 4 That's a CV reaches out to somebody because now he's scared.

Speaker 1 Back at the restaurant, Frank waited for an all-clear signal from the detectives. And the waiter, who'd frequently served the Schochner family, stopped by to reminisce about Lynn.

Speaker 1 Putting Frank in a very uncomfortable spot.

Speaker 13 There's nothing that anybody can say.

Speaker 1 He wasn't able to complete his thought. And soon, Fred would be having a very different kind of conversation with the police.

Speaker 1 What a mess. And Fred forgot to clean up.
He didn't throw his trash in time.

Speaker 4 Nope.

Speaker 13 I'm a 29-year-old man, Fred.

Speaker 1 Before he got mixed up with Fred Schochner, Frank Harrimillo, aka El Cubano, had so many possibilities.

Speaker 1 He had just recently married a wonderful woman, a school teacher, who had no idea what her husband had done or what he was facing.

Speaker 1 But it was too late for that. Frank did not go home to his wife that evening.
He submitted to a pair of handcuffs and was carted off to jail. And Fred?

Speaker 1 Well, Fred did go home under the watchful eye of the undercover cops, who also conducted a thorough search of the restaurant for those notes Fred wrote.

Speaker 1 They found nothing, nor did Fred Fred contact anyone else that evening. And so, the next morning.

Speaker 4 We just showed up 9 o'clock in the morning and cut him in his pajamas and disheveled. I mean, you could tell he hadn't slept a lot that night.

Speaker 1 Did he look shocked, worried, upset? Very shocked.

Speaker 4 And very upset while we were there. And, you know, our response is, we're here to arrest you.

Speaker 1 They took him away. And when they searched his house, They found one last piece of evidence in a trash can.
One of those notes Fred scribbled in the restaurant. Sloppy Nick, it said.

Speaker 1 He didn't throw out his trash in time. Nope.

Speaker 1 Across the country in Georgia, Charlie got the news.

Speaker 3 Yeah, that was

Speaker 3 another kind of happy moment, to be honest.

Speaker 1 That's quite a place to get to in life when you're happy that your father's been arrested for murder.

Speaker 1 The murder of your mother, mind you.

Speaker 3 Yeah, it's uh

Speaker 3 I mean, no one wants to, no one would want to actually say oh gosh yeah that's a good thing but

Speaker 3 after everything growing up with him in the house it um

Speaker 3 seems like a little bit of justice

Speaker 1 almost three years after Lynn's death the three men charged with her murder finally went on trial and Detective Richard Birdsall and undercover cop Chris Nelson both retired now were there it's always nice to see a case all the way through and see it in you you know, in my opinion, see people get, you know, get

Speaker 7 get what they got coming to them.

Speaker 4 So they gave you a special weird look from the...

Speaker 7 You know, when they walked into court, the only one that looked good that day,

Speaker 7 like rested and fine, was Nick Harvey.

Speaker 7 You could tell he had come to terms with what he'd done.

Speaker 7 He knew he was never going to see the light of day again.

Speaker 7 The other two were really struggling with it. They looked really beat.

Speaker 5 They were so different, the three of them. They were a very unlikely trio of criminals.

Speaker 1 Wendy Thomas Russell, a reporter for the Long Beach Press Telegram at the time, covered all three trials. Nick Harvey's was first.

Speaker 5 I would have to say he was more brawn than brain.

Speaker 5 He, and I don't mean that to be insensitive, but he, this is a guy who took the witness stand in his own defense, and he said

Speaker 5 that he

Speaker 5 aspired to be a hitman. That he.

Speaker 1 He said that on the witness stand. Yes.

Speaker 5 What did you think? I thought, you're not the brightest bulb on the marquee.

Speaker 1 No.

Speaker 5 So he, so he said, you know, he said that he had toyed around with being a hitman, that he had idolized the Hulk as a child, incredible Hulk. And

Speaker 5 he said that he had taken stories just to get bigger

Speaker 5 and

Speaker 5 stronger. And

Speaker 5 it was very hard for the jury to have sympathy for him.

Speaker 1 And they didn't. The jury found him guilty in about 35 minutes.
First-degree murder and burglary. Next was Frank Haramillo.

Speaker 5 He said that he wouldn't have done it had Schochner not threatened his wife and his in-laws.

Speaker 1 So this was... He did it out of fear then?

Speaker 5 Yeah, he said,

Speaker 5 literally, he said on the stand that he had sacrificed his life for his family when we all know that he had sacrificed Lynn Schalkner's life for his pocketbook.

Speaker 1 But that was his defense.

Speaker 5 What was his defense?

Speaker 1 The verdict guilty of first-degree murder. And now it was Fred's turn.

Speaker 5 And the man had aged at least 10 years.

Speaker 2 He looked so frail.

Speaker 1 But this wasn't over just yet. When Fred Schalkner took the witness stand, he told the jury he could explain everything.

Speaker 1 Do toll.

Speaker 5 He was very defiant and completely maintained his innocence.

Speaker 1 Will the jury believe him?

Speaker 3 I had a moment of just sitting there and

Speaker 3 I just started crying. I hugged my family.

Speaker 3 You hold your breath, the world kind of stops.

Speaker 1 A hushed courtroom in Long Beach, California. Fred Schalkner, charged with commissioning the murder of his wife, caught on tape blaming a sloppy hitman, took the stand in his own defense.

Speaker 5 He was very defiant and completely maintained his innocence until the end. I mean, in the face of this overwhelming evidence, he maintained his innocence.

Speaker 1 It was all a tragic misunderstanding, said Fred. He didn't pay for murder, just for a used BMW.
And all those calls to his alleged co-conspirator, El Coupano, Fred said they were wait for it.

Speaker 1 Pocket calls. And they proved nothing.

Speaker 1 The jury had to consider all possibilities naturally, and there was no shortage of nerves among members of Lynn's family.

Speaker 1 Charlie, just 17 years old that day, watched the jury file back in.

Speaker 3 It's law and order and everything right there. You just, you sit there and everyone comes in and just you hold your breath.
The world kind of stops. You don't

Speaker 3 know what the outcome is because they have all the power. Whatever they say is

Speaker 3 either the truth or what is going to be the truth.

Speaker 1 A lot of butterflies in your tummy. Oh, God, yeah.

Speaker 1 He looked at their faces for some sign, waited nervously for justice, for his mother. What was it like to hear the words?

Speaker 3 Emancipating? It was just

Speaker 1 unbelievable.

Speaker 1 The verdict? Guilty of first-degree murder.

Speaker 3 I had a moment of just sitting there and

Speaker 3 I just started crying. I hugged my family.

Speaker 1 You know, it's interesting you say hug my family because somebody who doesn't know the whole story might say, well, you just lost your family,

Speaker 1 but they don't know the whole story.

Speaker 3 Yeah, no, no, they were

Speaker 3 having my mother's side of the family, her two brothers and their family with me.

Speaker 3 It was amazing.

Speaker 3 It was what family should be. They were all there for me.

Speaker 1 The judge allowed Charlie to address his father in court.

Speaker 3 I had this whole like speech prepared of this like vindication of everything but I was so angry, just shaking

Speaker 3 and not really able to get my words out but I managed to say like I'm no longer your son. I can't believe you would do this and just

Speaker 3 you go into where you belong.

Speaker 1 That would be a pretty scary moment. I mean a nervous-making moment for us.

Speaker 3 It was terrifying.

Speaker 3 To know that it was actually going to happen,

Speaker 3 that this was

Speaker 3 the culmination of everything. It was

Speaker 3 a lot of emotion.

Speaker 1 I'll see your way of saying goodbye to him. Yeah.

Speaker 1 Yeah.

Speaker 1 Through all of this, Fred Schochner maintained his innocence. In fact, even before his trial began, Fred did carry out a threat he uttered right after the murder.

Speaker 1 He launched a lawsuit against the Long Beach Police Department for not protecting his wife, Lynn.

Speaker 1 He

Speaker 5 went to the city and filed a claim, which is a precursor to a lawsuit against the city of Long Beach,

Speaker 5 blaming the Long Beach Police Department for not preventing the murder of his wife because they had not, you know, followed through, followed proper procedure.

Speaker 1 Wait a minute, it's their fault because they didn't prevent me from killing my wife.

Speaker 5 That's right, exactly. Yeah.

Speaker 1 The claim was rejected. But now, on the day of his sentencing, he tried the same argument again.

Speaker 5 What spark? That was the, yes, that was the judge's response, too. He called it sophistry, and he called him a disgusting human being, and he did not mince words.

Speaker 1 Fred was sentenced to life without parole. They all were.
In a few sentences, what you think the motive in this murder was? Money.

Speaker 1 Well, in one word, apparently.

Speaker 9 For whatever reason,

Speaker 6 three or four million was not enough for Manfred Schochner. He wanted six or eight.

Speaker 1 Even from prison, Fred Schachner fought to keep it all for himself, fought his own son, his own blood, tried to prevent Charlie from getting a share of the Schochner estate.

Speaker 1 And though Charlie was eventually granted some of the money, Fred kept millions for himself, though how he'd managed to spend it in prison was unclear.

Speaker 1 We wrote letters to all three of them, Nick Harvey, Frank Harromeo, and Fred Schochner, asking to hear from them what happened.

Speaker 1 Fred wrote back and said he was convicted on highly skeptical circumstantial evidence and that there should have been more than enough to prove my innocence.

Speaker 1 Nick, now in his 30s, called us. He has matured in prison, he said, was mad at the world back then, but has found God now.

Speaker 1 But listen to this. Though he takes full responsibility for what he did, he's also been nursing a strange and very lonely conspiracy theory.
I've always believed the police were involved.

Speaker 1 You mean that they intentionally sent her back there? To be killed? Yes.

Speaker 1 You don't still believe that, though?

Speaker 1 Look, I'm not a big believer in coincidence, especially in situations like this.

Speaker 1 Lots of time to think in prison about things like that, but also about Charlie.

Speaker 1 Oh, uh,

Speaker 1 young Charlie.

Speaker 1 He, um,

Speaker 1 what I did to Charlie

Speaker 1 is haunts me every day.

Speaker 1 Yeah.

Speaker 1 You know, I took so much from him.

Speaker 1 But whether Nick knew it or not, Charlie was in the very capable hands of his uncle Mark, who received a commission from his worried sister Lynn before she was murdered.

Speaker 1 If anything happens to me, take care of my son.

Speaker 1 And he did.

Speaker 1 How do you feel about that boy? Love him.

Speaker 1 Yeah.

Speaker 1 Yeah, this one's going to be tough.

Speaker 1 I always look back at that moment as

Speaker 1 the greatest gift I ever received from the man

Speaker 1 who I

Speaker 1 still hate more than any person I've ever known.

Speaker 1 And

Speaker 1 my wife and I didn't have children of our own. Now I've got the best son in the world.

Speaker 3 Well, it's been great.

Speaker 3 Mark and Susan are just

Speaker 1 great.

Speaker 3 I love them so much.

Speaker 1 And so in a sad, strange way, out of unimaginable evil and loss, came love.

Speaker 1 A real family. An unexpected blessing.

Speaker 1 What's he done for you personally? How do you appreciate?

Speaker 1 Having him in your life.

Speaker 1 It's like getting another life.

Speaker 1 Like somebody opening a door and say, here's a second chance.

Speaker 1 Got a reason to get up in the morning.

Speaker 1 Damn straight.

Speaker 1 A reason to live.

Speaker 1 Run out of the flame. Mark and Susan are now his mom and dad.
He has taken their last name.

Speaker 1 And Charlie has more than survived. He is thriving.

Speaker 3 I'm going somewhere and I'm going fast.

Speaker 1 He got his master's and landed his dream job in theme park design. And he has learned, in spite of everything, that rarest of lessons, to accept and move on.

Speaker 3 I mean, I know it happened,

Speaker 3 and I know it's influencing me. but it's not defining me.

Speaker 1 But there is one thing that defines him. His mother's character.
And that follows him everywhere.

Speaker 3 My mother was just ethereal. She holds a very special place.
She's

Speaker 3 just everything that you think of as good, everything that you think of as kind, everything that is

Speaker 3 just great about people.

Speaker 3 That's what she embodied.

Speaker 1 And

Speaker 1 I'm gonna carry that with me.

Speaker 10 This time of year, many are checking off their holiday gift lists. But identity thieves have lists too, and your personal information might be on them.
Protect your identity with Life Lock.

Speaker 10 LifeLock monitors millions of data points every second and alerts you to threats you could miss. If your identity is stolen, LifeLock will fix it, guaranteed, or your money back.

Speaker 10 Save up to 40% your first year at lifelock.com/slash dateline. Terms apply.