A Killing in Cottonwood

Speaker 1 Grand Canyon University is one of the largest universities in the country.

Speaker 1 Praised for its community and impact, GCU integrates a welcoming Christian worldview and open discourse into over 300 online programs.

Speaker 1 Redefine your online education through GCU's industry-driven, academically rigorous programs. In 2024, online students received over $161 million in institutional scholarships.

Speaker 2 Find your purpose.

Speaker 1 Private, Christian, affordable. Discover available scholarships at gcu.edu/slash slash myoffer.

Speaker 3 It's time for Black Friday, Dell Technologies' biggest sale of the year. Enjoy huge savings on select PCs like the Dell 16 Plus featuring Intel Core ultra processors.

Speaker 3 Plus, earn Dell rewards and enjoy many other benefits like free shipping, price match guarantee, and expert support. They also have huge deals on accessories that pair perfectly with your Dell PC.

Speaker 3 and make perfect gifts for everyone on your list. Shop now at dell.com slash deals.

Speaker 5 I put my head on the pillow and two seconds later dad's at the door freaking out.

Speaker 3 Everywhere.

Speaker 4 This is murder by a knife in the middle of the night.

Speaker 3 There were some footprints outside the property, right?

Speaker 2 There was.

Speaker 7 A young lady is going out to make sure her car is locked and sees two gentlemen walking out there.

Speaker 3 People she doesn't know.

Speaker 7 People she doesn't know.

Speaker 7 First law enforcement on the scene sees the car speeding going the other way.

Speaker 8 I'm putting alarms on every door because somebody's out there.

Speaker 9 We have a person who has been in a relationship with a lady in another state.

Speaker 9 I believe Karen confronted him about the affair. That's when he decided, I'm going to get the knife.

Speaker 3 Do you have any idea beyond your own fevered imagination that that's what happened? You don't have a clue.

Speaker 9 What really happened that night? We're still hoping.

Speaker 3 Truth won't prevail.

Speaker 12 We have to have that hope.

Speaker 3 On the afternoon of May 4th, 2012, Casey Duenas walked out onto the field for the start of his very favorite thing, high school baseball, a doubleheader.

Speaker 3 Spring was in its full glory here in Northern California. His senior year was almost done.
This was the place he loved, the game he loved.

Speaker 3 People sometimes talk about having premonitions of things. Did you have anything like that at all?

Speaker 5 It was just another day, just another one of my countless baseball games.

Speaker 5 Countless baseball games.

Speaker 3 Wasn't, of course. Though no one knew it as they wild their way through a golden afternoon.

Speaker 3 Reading, California, with its famous sundial bridge, its parks, its middle America feel,

Speaker 3 is a whole different place, a different life than the California whose reputation blares Technicolor from the Botoxt and TMZ narcissism 600 miles to the south.

Speaker 3 Drive a few minutes from Reading, and you're on the ball diamond in a little place called Cottonwood, here in the shadow of mighty Mount Shasta, an anchor, a constant, just like the people Casey knew would be in the stands.

Speaker 3 So, were they there? Yep. Both were there.

Speaker 11 Both there.

Speaker 3 Always there.

Speaker 5 Always there. Never missing him.

Speaker 3 His parents, Mark and Karen, Dwayne us. Side by side by the dugout, as always.

Speaker 5 No, they were together since they were, what, 17 years old?

Speaker 3 They practically lived in each other's skin.

Speaker 11 exactly

Speaker 3 his mother had brought the chocolate chip cookie she passed out to the players after every game and for which she was justly famous his father had made sure he finished work in time for the opening pitch what kind of parents were they they were the best parents that you could ask for This is Jason, their eldest son, and here the photo of Jason's graduation with his proud parents the day he became a fireman.

Speaker 8 They would do anything anything for us, and they did.

Speaker 3 Mark and Karen were from big Mormon families, high school sweethearts, who married as teenagers and watched their own brood quickly expand. All boys, Jason, Jacob, Tyler, Troy, and Casey.

Speaker 3 Boys bursting with testosterone.

Speaker 8 It was a rowdy house. We had football games inside the house.
We were egged on by our parents, and they loved it.

Speaker 3 Karen was a full-time mom, and once the boys were old enough, taught part-time at nearby Shasta College. For decades, Mark got up at 2 a.m.

Speaker 3 to drive for UPS, just because it freed him to coach his son's teams come afternoon. And to spare his wife middle-of-the-night disruption, Mark slept in a separate bedroom, had for years.

Speaker 8 My dad treated her better than anybody could treat their wife. My mom was the queen.

Speaker 3 They lived simply.

Speaker 11 They lived paycheck to paycheck.

Speaker 3 They never had a lot extra. Son tyler for them it was all about family yeah always

Speaker 3 they all stayed as close as any family could be when jason got married he moved into the house right next door helped celebrate mark and karen's silver wedding anniversary as they all did by 2012 they were grandparents many times over had been married nearly 33 years One thing I always looked up to and loved about their relationship was that they still dated.

Speaker 3 Tyler's wife, Tina.

Speaker 14 After that long, sometimes you can lose that and I never saw them lose that.

Speaker 3 The change does come for everyone and by 2012 in their early 50s Mark and Karen were making some changes. Karen went back to school, nursing school.
This was a plan that they talked about.

Speaker 8 It was the perfect situation. She got to stay home with the kids all growing up.
And now she was ready to start her career. If you think about it, a pretty dang good plan.
He worked his whole life.

Speaker 8 You know, he could start his own business while collecting a pension. And then she would, you know, start her career in nursing.

Speaker 3 Not so easy, of course. Nursing school is a tough thing.
And not just for Karen either. Her brother Joe, wife Jackie.

Speaker 16 Well, her commitments changed.

Speaker 17 Having grandma there when you need her or having mom there when you need her, she's going to have to study.

Speaker 4 And she was struggling with the classes. She felt like she should be doing better.

Speaker 4 But I remember a text that said, I just got back from the ER and got a chance to work with people finally, and I love it. And so she was on her way.
She was really on her way.

Speaker 3 And so, that May the 4th, Casey joined his parents at home after his ball games. Then, it being Friday night, he and a friend went to see a movie, The Avengers.

Speaker 5 That thing started at 9:15

Speaker 4 and

Speaker 5 told my parents everything was fine.

Speaker 3 Do you remember the last thing you said to your mom?

Speaker 5 She handed me a $20 bill and I thanked her and hugged her goodbye.

Speaker 3 It was late when Casey returned and almost immediately fell asleep. And then what do you remember next?

Speaker 5 I literally felt like

Speaker 5 I put my head on the pillow and two seconds later, the door is open.

Speaker 5 Dad's at the door, freaking out.

Speaker 3 And seconds later.

Speaker 3 Now I know your

Speaker 3 The Duenas family was about to discover that a perfectly ordinary evening had ended in horror. She's got blood everywhere.
Everywhere.

Speaker 3 Dad, devastated, but is one horror about to become two. Yeah, I remember him coming in the door and just collapsing.

Speaker 3 It was 12:30 a.m., now May 5th, 2012.

Speaker 3 Casey Duenas, home from a movie and late dinner with friends, opened the front door, unlocked as usual, and moved quietly down the little hallway toward his bedroom.

Speaker 3 Had it not been so late, he might have stopped by his mother's room to say goodnight.

Speaker 3 But the house was dark, everyone asleep, or so it looked to an exhausted Casey, who fell into bed and almost immediately into a deep sleep. And then, 25 minutes later.

Speaker 11 Dad's at the door, freaking out.

Speaker 5 Go next door, go next door, go get Jason. So I'm sobbing to your mom.
Go get Jason, go get Jason, go get Jason.

Speaker 3 Casey did as he was told, running next door to his oldest brother, Jason's house.

Speaker 3 Well, his father, Mark, beside himself, called for an ambulance. Tell me exactly what happened.

Speaker 3 I just came in the room, I heard her, and she's got blood everywhere.

Speaker 3 Everywhere. I don't know.
I can't have it. I have no idea.

Speaker 6 You have no idea what happened?

Speaker 6 You don't know where she's bleeding from? No, I don't. I think there's blood everywhere.
Are you with her now? Yes. Oh, it's in her chest.
I've been dead in her chest.

Speaker 3 And Jason woke up to the horror two ways at once. Fire department alarm.
Brother alarm.

Speaker 8 I was asleep. As a volunteer firefighter, I have a pager.
The pager went off and I could hear Casey coming up the stairs yelling at me in a panic. There's something wrong with mom.

Speaker 8 You got to come next door right now.

Speaker 3 Did you have any sense of what it was?

Speaker 8 I had no idea what I was going to walk into.

Speaker 3 What he walked into was a nightmare beyond dreaming. There was his father in full-blown panic and lying on the floor in the puddle of blood was his mother.

Speaker 3 And the rookie firefighter, for an instant, to his eternal regret, froze.

Speaker 8 If I would have come on that situation now, I would have immediately started CPR. There was a great deal of blood.
So, for somebody to live through that

Speaker 8 much blood, I didn't think it was going to happen. I believe I just missed her last couple of breaths.

Speaker 3 Minutes later, EMTs arrived, and Karen Duenas was pronounced dead. The cause, multiple stab wounds, including a massive gash to her chest.

Speaker 3 Not long after that, the young detective arrived, Logan Stonehouse, a year under his belt as an investigator, but this would be his first big homicide case as lead detective. And lo and behold.

Speaker 16 I didn't know what I was walking into until I saw a picture on the wall and realized whose house I was in.

Speaker 3 You knew these people, right?

Speaker 16 I did. Well, I went to high school with the second oldest son, Jacob.

Speaker 3 And here he found himself looking at the bloody body of Jacob's mother, Karen. The lady everybody loved, the one who brought cookies to all the games at school.
Who could have done this?

Speaker 3 The detective took a look around the house. He and fellow officers fanned out around the neighborhood.
There were some footprints outside the property, right?

Speaker 16 There was. There's a wood fence that surrounds that piece of the property, and there's a back gate back there, and there was a little trail that led out to a canal area.

Speaker 3 And the first patrolman on the scene told them he had seen a car speeding away as he raced toward the Duena's house. Neighbors reported seeing two strangers nearby that evening.

Speaker 3 And here, in this crime scene video taken the next day, a screen on the window in Karen's bedroom that looked suspiciously like it had been cut open. Had intruders entered here?

Speaker 3 Was anything disturbed around the house?

Speaker 16 No, actually, the bedroom was pretty much intact. There wasn't drawers taken open like someone had burglarized the place.

Speaker 3 Also, even though the screen appeared to be cut, it didn't look like anybody had actually gone in that way.

Speaker 3 And so, the detective had some questions for the only man known to be in the house all evening. The husband, of course, Mark Duenas.

Speaker 3 What was his story of what happened that night?

Speaker 16 He told us that he had been up with Karen. They were watching a movie.
And then once Karen went to bed, he tried to stay up a little bit longer to watch a Giants game.

Speaker 16 He was falling asleep during it, so he decided to go to sleep himself.

Speaker 3 Mark in his room. Karen already down the hall, he said, in hers.

Speaker 3 The detective took Mark to the major crimes unit, where Mark, who'd been awake more than 24 hours by now, finished the story himself.

Speaker 18 I'm in my room asleep.

Speaker 13 I hear

Speaker 18 crazy noise.

Speaker 18 And

Speaker 18 you hear a cat sound like. It wasn't cats.
It was

Speaker 3 a weird scream.

Speaker 18 No, I just heard some weird screaming types.

Speaker 3 And then what did you do from there?

Speaker 18 I ran, I got up and I, because I didn't want those, whatever was going on to wake up my wife, because I'm sensitive like that.

Speaker 18 And I went to the door by the kitchen, opened it up, and looked out there. I didn't see any cats.
Shut it. Walked down the hallway, looked under, the lights were on.
So I figured she's up.

Speaker 3 Opened the door, and that's when i found her the detectives questioned mark for more than three hours had him changed so they could keep his shorts and t-shirt for testing then sent him home to his children yeah i remember him coming in the door and just collapsing

Speaker 14 on the floor we weren't really worried about him because he kept saying like his his heart like and so we thought maybe he was having a heart attack i mean he was

Speaker 15 he was a mess

Speaker 3 as the duenus family planned a funeral their big extended family, including Karen's brother Joe and wife Jackie, descended on Cottonwood.

Speaker 17 I've never seen a person more broken.

Speaker 3 What was your perception of how he took it?

Speaker 4 He's taken incredibly hard. He still does.

Speaker 3 And along with unbearable grief for the family came anxiety.

Speaker 8 I live next door. I'm worried for my family.
I'm putting alarms on every door because somebody's out there.

Speaker 3 But the police did not seem to think that. In fact, within a day or two, one of the detectives announced no need to worry about some unknown killer stalking the town.

Speaker 3 Now, why would he say that?

Speaker 3 Investigators were about to hear a strange tale from Karen's husband.

Speaker 18 It scares me when I think about it.

Speaker 3 But what did his story mean?

Speaker 12 Hey, weirdos, I'm Elena Elena and I'm Ash, and we are the hosts of Morbid Podcast. Each week we dive into the dark and fascinating world of true crime, spooky history, and the unexplained.

Speaker 12 From infamous killers and unsolved mysteries to haunted places and strange legends, we cover it all with research, empathy, humor, and a few creative expletives.

Speaker 12 It's smart, it's spooky, and it's just the right amount of weird. Two new episodes drop every week, and there's even a bonus once a month.
Find us wherever you listen to podcasts. Yay! Woo! Aye!

Speaker 20 If you're a smoker or dipper ready to make a change, you really only need one good reason.

Speaker 21 But with Zen nicotine pouches, you'll discover many good reasons.

Speaker 23 Zinn is America's number one nicotine pouch brand.

Speaker 24 Plus, Zen offers a robust rewards program.

Speaker 25 There are lots of options when it comes to nicotine satisfaction, but there's only one Zen.

Speaker 26 Check out Zen.com slash find to find Zen at a store near you.

Speaker 27 Warning, this product contains nicotine. Nicotine is an addictive chemical.

Speaker 28 If you're an experienced pet owner, you already know that having a pet is 25% belly rubs, 25% yelling, drop it, and 50% groaning at the bill from every vet visit, which is why Lemonade Pet Insurance is tailor-made for your pet and can save you up to 90% on vet bills.

Speaker 28 It can help cover checkups, emergencies, diagnostics, basically all the stuff that makes your bank account nervous. Claims are filed super easy through the Lemonade app and half get settled instantly.

Speaker 28 Get a quote at lemonade.com/slash pet, and they'll help cover the VET bill for whatever your pet swallowed after you y'all drop it.

Speaker 3 They measured time in units of pain in Little Cottonwood, California, during the surreal minutes and hours and days after Karen Duenas was murdered. The best way I can explain my mom

Speaker 11 is

Speaker 11 she was pure of heart is the best way to

Speaker 11 say it.

Speaker 3 The whole big family, Karen's family as well as Mark's, parents, brothers, sisters, gathered to support each other and mourn. and struggle with the question that hung in the air.
Who did this?

Speaker 3 But the word on the street was there there was no question at all.

Speaker 4 We immediately heard rumors, outlandish rumors. You're just going, I don't know where you're getting this.

Speaker 3 The boys heard them too. Rumors that detectives knew the killer was Mark,

Speaker 3 to which the family said.

Speaker 5 It's ridiculous. I know there's no way possible he could have done it.

Speaker 8 My parents were best friends from as long as I could remember.

Speaker 3 But if that was true, then why would detectives be so suspicious of a man married to his high school sweetheart for almost 33 years, a man without so much as a traffic ticket on his record, let alone a violent act?

Speaker 3 Well, it's true that when wives are murdered, husbands are frequently implicated, and Mark did discover the body. But there was another reason.

Speaker 3 Just minutes after Mark sat down to talk to those detectives, he volunteered information that sounded to them like a motive for murder.

Speaker 18 It's what was going on in our life,

Speaker 18 and it scared me when I think about it.

Speaker 3 It was an odd little story. One day at work toward the end of 2010, said Mark, a UPS co-worker asked him if he'd ever gone on Facebook.
No, said Mark, he hadn't.

Speaker 3 Well, asked the colleague, haven't you ever wondered what happened to people you used to know? Facebook might tell you.

Speaker 3 And Mark thought about it and said, well, there was this girl he used to talk to back in high school. Wasn't a real girlfriend or anything, but he was curious about whatever happened to her.

Speaker 3 So sure enough, the colleague found the woman on Facebook. And pretty soon, she and Mark were texting and talking on the phone, catching up.

Speaker 18 Always talked and we visited, you know, we kind of got carried away with a little texting here and there.

Speaker 3 Carried away?

Speaker 3 Well, that may be a little strong in this age of sexting and lurid electronic dalliances. They did talk and text, yes, for several months.
Even said, I love you a time or two.

Speaker 3 But was it some kind of affair? Well, judge for yourself.

Speaker 18 Was there ever any pictures sent or anything like that, or was it always just... There's pictures of

Speaker 16 just

Speaker 18 maybe

Speaker 18 me or her, you know, just little innocent,

Speaker 18 you know, we're not into any of that nasty porn none of that right it was just what do you look like now you know it's

Speaker 18 she'd send a picture of her of her and she goes your turn she does a quilter she took a picture of her quilt showed it to me right stuff so this innocent stuff she took had a picture of her and her grandkid and she and

Speaker 18 stuff like that

Speaker 3 and Not once did they try to see each other.

Speaker 3 In fact, when an opportunity came up, they decided, no, it wouldn't be be fair to their respective spouses in more than three decades, or their kids, or grandkids. So they didn't.

Speaker 3 But as Mark told the detectives, Karen found out what he'd been doing when she went through a phone bill and it hurt her feelings. So he promised to stop.

Speaker 3 Except he didn't.

Speaker 16 Mark went and bought a secret phone to continue that communication that Karen wasn't aware of.

Speaker 3 It was the woman who put a stop to it, and she sent Karen this letter, postmarked just a little less than three months before the murder, asking for forgiveness, promising it would never happen again.

Speaker 3 Karen told a couple of her kids about it all. She was pretty upset for a while.
How important was that?

Speaker 16 I would definitely say everything together showed that

Speaker 16 Karen was not happy in their relationship.

Speaker 3 Mark told them otherwise, that it was a happy marriage, the texting thing just a blip.

Speaker 3 But the detectives didn't believe it, so they confronted Mark.

Speaker 16 When did you find out that Karen was going to leave you, Mark?

Speaker 5 Leave me?

Speaker 8 She's never going to leave me.

Speaker 8 Never going to leave me.

Speaker 3 Honestly. In fact, investigators believed it all backed up what they suspected from that very first night.
Here, just hours after the murder, when they first accused Mark of killing her.

Speaker 18 I didn't do it.

Speaker 3 And I mean,

Speaker 13 it's crazy.

Speaker 3 It's just like, OJ, we need to be out there finding the real killers, right?

Speaker 3 LAPD, they didn't have to go find the real killers.

Speaker 18 I know you're doing your job, but I would never lay a hand on my wife. I did not hurt her.
I did not kill her. I walked in and found her in her condition.

Speaker 3 Mark's family, by the way, said he told them all about that texting relationship. They said, didn't seem like such a big deal.

Speaker 14 It sounds to me that it was just them confiding in each other about their marriages and their families and, you know, just an outlet.

Speaker 3 Her youngest son, Casey, had explained why there had been some tension between his parents a few months before the murder.

Speaker 5 There was a good span where

Speaker 5 they didn't get along, but

Speaker 5 it was a while before.

Speaker 3 Yeah.

Speaker 3 And they seem to be back together again.

Speaker 5 They seem better than ever.

Speaker 3 And those claims by investigators about a pending divorce?

Speaker 3 Not a chance, said the boys.

Speaker 8 They never were going to give up. They taught us that.
I'm sure a little bit of trust was lost.

Speaker 8 You know, if someone keeps something from you, but, you know, it was something they worked on and they got over.

Speaker 3 All that grief-infected summer, a cloud darkened over the Duanus family.

Speaker 5 When Casey graduated from high school in June, I remember walking to where we'd be seated and just seeing, you know, dudes, my dad, along with other family members. But, you know, of course, there was

Speaker 5 one spot missing.

Speaker 3 And five months went by that way, as if those early police suspicions had faded away.

Speaker 3 But of course, we know better, don't we?

Speaker 3 Mark Buenas is in for a bitter shock.

Speaker 5 He was upset. Like, are you kidding me?

Speaker 3 And what his family did next would surprise everyone. That sort of thing hardly ever happens.
Yeah, like never.

Speaker 3 It was evening in Cottonwood, California, October 5th, 2012, five months to the day after the murder of Karen Duenas. Her widower Mark and their son Casey were watching TV.

Speaker 3 There was a knock at the door.

Speaker 3 And when Mark saw the detectives...

Speaker 5 He was upset.

Speaker 3 Couldn't believe it.

Speaker 5 Like, are you kidding me?

Speaker 3 They were not. Detectives had suspected Mark all along, and now they had a warrant for his arrest.
Mark Duenas was charged with first-degree murder, held on a million-dollar bail to await trial.

Speaker 8 To see him in that situation is surreal. Man, you hope the system works because

Speaker 8 there's an innocent man up there having to go through this.

Speaker 3 The whole extended clan, including Karen's family, told anybody who would listen that the police made a huge mistake.

Speaker 3 I've never heard him call anybody a name. I've never, he just isn't that type of guy.

Speaker 14 I can't think of one time where he raised his voice to anybody.

Speaker 3 That family support was what persuaded an attorney 600 miles away in Southern California to take the case. Ron Powell is his name.

Speaker 7 At first, I'm not thinking, I want to go up there. But, you know, when I saw her family saying, well, can you help us, that type of stuff, and us meant, Mark.
That's when I started to think, you know.

Speaker 3 The victim's family wants the accused represented by you because they believe he's innocent? Correct. It's sort of a once-in-a-while thing.
Hardly ever happens. Yeah, like never.

Speaker 3 But 14 months after the murder, when Mark went on trial, the family, his, Karen's, and theirs, filled the galleries every day to support him.

Speaker 17 You are there because you know that person.

Speaker 3 The judge allowed cameras in court, but no audio. So we can't play you the testimony of that woman from Idaho and decided to conceal her identity.

Speaker 3 That's the one he texted and phoned but hadn't seen in more than three decades. Still, it was to be with her, said the state, that Mark killed his wife.
And on the stand.

Speaker 16 At one point, she said Mark had mentioned that if they were meant to be together, something bad would have to happen.

Speaker 3 The woman didn't seem to know what Mark meant by that, but the prosecution claimed he meant he'd have to kill Karen.

Speaker 3 Not just so he could be with the Idaho woman, but so that he wouldn't have to share his pension with Karen, his wife of 33 years.

Speaker 3 Anyway, said the state, Karen must have been angry at Mark and might have told him that night she intended to leave him. She wanted a divorce.

Speaker 16 The facts of the case showed that something happened that night between Mark and Karen, whether that be

Speaker 16 her discussing divorce or whatever the case may be,

Speaker 16 and he became upset and murdered Karen.

Speaker 3 The prosecution based that theory around a story told by some teenagers two or three blocks away, who said they heard a scream between 10 and 11 p.m.

Speaker 3 The pathologist testified Karen could have been killed as early as 10.30 or as late as 2.30 a.m.

Speaker 3 But the state said it must have been 10.30, after which Mark must have washed his clothes, slashed the screen to make it look like an intruder came in, then went to bed and waited for son Casey to come home from the movie.

Speaker 16 One of the theories that we did have was that he wanted Casey to find Karen.

Speaker 3 He's sleeping peacefully. Is that the idea? Correct.
Having covered his tracks. Correct.

Speaker 3 Except, of course, Casey didn't discover the body. So, said the state, about 1 a.m., Mark had to make the 911 call himself.

Speaker 3 And when detectives went back and listened to that call, they heard what sounded to them like an incriminating mistake.

Speaker 3 911, your emergency.

Speaker 6 I gotta have my wife's shit and go everywhere.

Speaker 3 What did he say?

Speaker 3 I killed my wife, the state claims. Then, a sound they say is a well-known barnyard expletive.
Listen again.

Speaker 3 I killed my wife's shit and go away everywhere.

Speaker 3 An unintended confession caught on tape. Or so said the prosecution.

Speaker 3 So he got it all together and all planned, and then he blew it on the 911 call. I believe so.

Speaker 16 I'm sure if you just killed your wife, you'd be pretty stressed on the inside, which would make some things come out that you didn't mean to have come out.

Speaker 3 But to the defense, it was quite simply bunk.

Speaker 7 I've listened to it, I don't know, a hundred times now. I don't hear that.

Speaker 3 Defense Attorney Ron Powell told the jury Mark found his wife just after someone attacked her and told 911 this.

Speaker 6 911, your emergency. I gotta sell my wife's shit.

Speaker 3 I'm going everywhere.

Speaker 3 I found my wife. And then that sound the state claims was an extra, the defense said was reading the word sick.

Speaker 3 So, I found my wife sick.

Speaker 3 Listen again.

Speaker 6 I gotta cover my wife's shit. I'm going everywhere.

Speaker 7 Do you think if they heard it that clear that this guy says I killed my wife and he's the only one home, do you just think they're arresting this guy? If that had happened, what are they waiting for?

Speaker 7 They didn't arrest him until four months later.

Speaker 3 And meanwhile, said the defense, police failed to follow up on plenty of evidence that in a town plagued by drug-related crime, intruders intent on theft could certainly have been surprised by Karen, then killed her, then fled.

Speaker 3 There was an unidentified car parked nearby, time of the murder, another car seen speeding away from the neighborhood as the cops raced to the Duena's house.

Speaker 3 The two strangers seen in the neighborhood, and a trail of footprints leading away from the Duena's backyard. And as for those screams heard by teenagers a couple of blocks away.

Speaker 7 The entire block where Mark lives hears nothing. The woman next door sleeps with her window open, hears nothing.
The person on the other side of the house is Jason Duenas, who has his window open.

Speaker 7 He hears nothing.

Speaker 3 The defense put on a witness who said Karen told her the very week of the murder that she and Mark were making plans for a bright future together.

Speaker 3 And the idea that Mark would kill Karen so he could pursue a happily married woman from Idaho he hadn't seen in more than 30 years was simply ridiculous, said the defense.

Speaker 7 It sounds like a great motive when you look at it

Speaker 7 from a distance, but then when you get to it, it sounds like puppy love.

Speaker 3 The defense rested its case in a matter of hours. When I went to the jury, how did you feel about it?

Speaker 7 I was pretty confident. You could see in the jury's face that they weren't buying this.

Speaker 3 Then something... Odd happened.
The day the jury went out, a female juror overslept. And rather than delay the case, the judge replaced her with an alternate.

Speaker 3 And yes, on such tiny wheels, fates turn.

Speaker 3 Jurors get the case and aren't impressed.

Speaker 10 I thought the Sheriff's Department did a terrible job, an investable job. Terrible job.

Speaker 30 Hey, this is Jeff Lewis from Radio Andy. Live and uncensored.
Catch me talking with my friends about my latest obsessions, relationship issues, and bodily ailments.

Speaker 30 With that kind of drama that seems to follow me, you never know what's going to happen.

Speaker 29 You can listen to Jeff Lewis Live at home or anywhere you are. Download the SiriusXXTEM app for over 425 channels of ad-free music, sports, entertainment, and more.

Speaker 29 Subscribe now and get three months free. Offer details apply.

Speaker 20 If you're a smoker or dipper ready to make a change, you really only need one good good reason.

Speaker 22 But with Zen nicotine pouches, you'll discover many good reasons.

Speaker 23 Zinn is America's number one nicotine pouch brand.

Speaker 24 Plus, Zen offers a robust rewards program.

Speaker 25 There are lots of options when it comes to nicotine satisfaction, but there's only one Zen.

Speaker 26 Check out Zinn.com slash find to find Zen at a store near you.

Speaker 27 Warning, this product contains nicotine. Nicotine is an addictive chemical.

Speaker 15 Just got a new puppy or kitten.

Speaker 3 Congrats!

Speaker 15 But also, yikes! Between crates, crates, beds, toys, treats, and those first few vet visits, you've probably already dropped a small fortune, which is where Lemonade Pet Insurance comes in.

Speaker 15 It helps cover vet costs so you can focus on what's best for your new pet. The coverage is customizable, signup is quick and easy, and your claims are handled in as little as three seconds.

Speaker 15 Pro tip: LemonAid offers a package specifically for puppies and kittens. Get a quote at lemonade.com/slash pet.
Your future self will thank you. Your pet won't.
They don't know what insurance is.

Speaker 3 The jury in the Duenas murder case was a little unusual, not just because of that last-minute switch of jurors, but because several of them had spent careers dealing with the justice system, and they certainly knew what was at stake.

Speaker 9 This is something that we all had to take very serious.

Speaker 3 Here are three members of the jury. This one is a retired chief probation officer and former cop.
He was surprised by the case, he said, and not in a good way.

Speaker 10 I thought the sheriff's department did a terrible job.

Speaker 3 Terrible job.

Speaker 10 Terrible job in their investigation.

Speaker 3 In fact, the jurors we spoke to said that feeling was pervasive in the jury room. And the 911 call that prosecutors claimed was a confession, the jury couldn't decide what, he said.

Speaker 9 We listened to it many, many, many times.

Speaker 10 20 times at least.

Speaker 12 Yes, yeah.

Speaker 3 Still couldn't tell right. No.

Speaker 3 The jury took vote after vote, 10 to 2 for acquittal at one point. But one juror in particular was adamant about his guilty vote.
Which one?

Speaker 3 The alternate who replaced the woman who'd overslept.

Speaker 7 That juror said

Speaker 10 he's guilty and he's going to have to prove that he's not guilty. And I'm not going to change my mind.
I'm going to hang this jury.

Speaker 3 The judge declared a mistrial.

Speaker 3 What was that like? It was heartbreaking. We thought my dad would be home that day.

Speaker 3 Afterwards, Mark and Karen's extended family publicly pleaded, do not retry Mark. Let it go.

Speaker 21 You see these people?

Speaker 21 This is love.

Speaker 17 This is belief in this human being. This is a snot question in our hearts.
Please listen to us and know we love this man.

Speaker 3 So, was it over? Oh no, not even close. Instead, Shasta County's DA assigned a new prosecutor to the case, Stephanie Bridget.

Speaker 3 Something to know about Miss Bridget.

Speaker 3 Up to this moment, she had never lost a case, not one. Her secret?

Speaker 3 Preparation, she said. She is very thorough.

Speaker 3 By the time you finished reading through it in your preparation, what did you think?

Speaker 9 I didn't have any doubt that Mark was the one that killed his wife.

Speaker 3 One big change at trial number two, the very first words out of the prosecutor's mouth were the state's version of that 911 call. I killed my wife.
Blood everywhere.

Speaker 3 No jury, she declared, could doubt the content of that call. You did say your hurricanes were.

Speaker 3 And prosecutors offered yet another possibly damning statement from Mark himself during his first of three tape-recorded interviews with detectives, which, again, he he willingly submitted to without the presence of an attorney.

Speaker 18 That's the only cut I saw.

Speaker 3 In his very first interview, claimed to state, Mark slipped and made an admission while describing the wound he said he found on Karen's chest.

Speaker 18 Like the guy knew what he was doing or something. Because the way he cut her,

Speaker 18 that's the only cut I saw and there was tons of blood. But there was none there coming out when I...

Speaker 18 Whoever did it, I don't.

Speaker 3 What was that again

Speaker 3 listen carefully

Speaker 18 but there was none there coming out when I

Speaker 18 whoever did it I don't

Speaker 3 when I found her or when I did it

Speaker 3 no way to know what he might have said but the state claimed it amounted to another quasi-confession The second prosecutor also presented evidence the first prosecutor chose not to use.

Speaker 3 Testimony, for example, from a criminalist who examined the clothes Mark wore that night and who found Karen's blood, though not visible to the naked eye, all over.

Speaker 9 There was a big area on the front of his shirt that covered all the way down. There was blood on the back of the shirt.

Speaker 9 There was blood all across the waistband, down the sides, different spots throughout the shorts, even blood on the inside of the boxer shorts.

Speaker 3 Which you don't think he could have gotten there with this by touching with his hands, like removing, changing, adjusting?

Speaker 9 absolutely not

Speaker 9 not in all those locations

Speaker 3 the prosecutor claimed mark must have washed off some but not all the blood after the stabbing had a shower in his clothes or something and then she claimed she'd found the murder weapon or what could be the murder weapon a knife found in the wrong slot in the kitchen butcher block Mind you, there was no blood on it, but its handle was bearing a substance identified as either animal fat or some kind of cleaner.

Speaker 9 What it tells us is that he had something in the home available to him that could have caused that murder.

Speaker 3 So, means, motive, opportunity for premeditated murder.

Speaker 3 But would a second set of jurors agree?

Speaker 3 They would want evidence. But just how much was there?

Speaker 3 Do you have any idea that that's what happened?

Speaker 11 You don't have a clue.

Speaker 3 November 2013. A chilly autumn wind played around the corners of that big courthouse in the middle of Reading.

Speaker 3 And inside Defense Attorney Ron Powell fretted that he had been shorn of a certain advantage because now the prosecution knew his case and besides, had added these new wrinkles, the blood on Mark's clothes and the knife in the kitchen butcher block.

Speaker 7 Remember, this is a retrial now. They felt this time that they needed to show a possibility of a knife.
They never said this was the knife. They're just showing this knife could have done it.

Speaker 3 In fact, said Powell, the new evidence was no more persuasive than the old. No blood but animal fat found on the knife and some sort of soap?

Speaker 3 How about somebody used a knife to cut a steak and then washed it? Could you wipe all the DNA off a knife you put it in the dishwasher?

Speaker 7 Good question. I've learned now after this trial that blood will never leave clothes, but it'll go right off a knife.

Speaker 3 As for the blood on Mark's clothes, of course there was blood, said the defense. He handled her body.
And police didn't see the blood at first because his shirt was red and his shorts were black.

Speaker 3 And then there was the new prosecutor's insistence that Karen was very unhappy in her marriage and wanted a divorce. Was it true?

Speaker 7 No, there's nothing to support it. There's no facts to support it.
There's no evidence to support it.

Speaker 3 This was the issue that went right to the heart of the prosecutor's case and her contention that the state had developed a clear idea of just what happened the night Karen was murdered.

Speaker 9 I believe that most likely Karen confronted him with information that she she had about the affair he was having with the lady in Idaho. She probably said that was it.
She wasn't going to have it.

Speaker 9 She was going to get a divorce. That's when he decided, I'm going to get the knife.
I'm going to go in there.

Speaker 3 Do you have any idea beyond your own fevered imagination that that's what happened? You don't have a clue.

Speaker 9 Well, you know, all the evidence presents, it points to that. So yes, I think that I do have that.

Speaker 3 How does all the evidence point to that?

Speaker 9 We have a person who has been in a relationship with a lady in another state.

Speaker 3 Let me stop you for a minute.

Speaker 3 First of all, you said affair. Now you're saying being in a relationship.
He was doing what millions upon millions of Americans have been doing since Facebook came along.

Speaker 3 They hadn't seen each other for 30 years.

Speaker 3 You can't really call that an affair, can you?

Speaker 9 Here's the big difference. It becomes an affair and crosses the line when you don't tell your spouse about it.

Speaker 3 You believe that he was obsessed with this woman.

Speaker 9 I believe that he wanted a lot more out of that relationship than she did.

Speaker 3 Was it pure fiction or what was it? I mean, what else could it be?

Speaker 7 I mean,

Speaker 7 I know she's got a law degree. I never saw a psychology degree.

Speaker 3 For Mark and Karen's sons, the prosecutor's psychoanalysis of their mother amounted to an insult.

Speaker 8 The DA said things about my mom that were untrue. Do they know my mom better than I know my mom? Better than any of us? They act like they do.

Speaker 8 There's no evidence.

Speaker 3 What do you say to people whose reaction is, well, you know, of course they're going to feel that way. This is his family.
They've just lost their mother. They don't want to lose their father too.

Speaker 8 Life is so much harder protecting my dad. We would be moved on.
We would know what happened if we thought that was the truth. But we all know with our hearts that's not what happened.

Speaker 3 The jury in the first trial had been hopelessly deadlocked, came so close to acquitting Mark and sending him home to his family.

Speaker 3 The second jury was back in less than than a day, and their verdict was written on family faces in the gallery's first row.

Speaker 7 I still hear the sounds of the boys right behind Mark, the crying.

Speaker 23 I still hear that.

Speaker 23 It was very tough.

Speaker 3 Guilty of first-degree murder. You're sick.

Speaker 9 I felt like throwing up, to be honest.

Speaker 14 I was sick.

Speaker 9 I feel bad for the family members because the family members and they're not going to be happy with the verdict.

Speaker 9 But at the end of the day, it's Karen who was killed and Karen who that verdict was for.

Speaker 3 What would you say to them, this big extended family out there that doesn't think it got justice at all?

Speaker 9 Well, I would tell them that I'm confident that the right person was convicted.

Speaker 3 Mark Duenas is serving a sentence of 25 years to life. Courts have so far rejected his appeals.
And his family will go on believing what they have always believed.

Speaker 3 That late at night on May 4th, 2012, unknown intruders, probably drug addicts intent on theft, burst in, were surprised by Karen, killed her, and then realizing what they had done, ran away without taking a thing.

Speaker 3 Jason no longer lives right next door to the home he grew up in. In fact, the family sold the home, the place it happened.
The memories. and upkeep too much to bear.

Speaker 5 I mean, it was always, oh, we live in Cottonwood, small town, nothing happens here.

Speaker 8 And then the worst you can imagine happened.

Speaker 3 Casey and his brother Troy no longer play baseball for the local college.

Speaker 3 The days when they looked toward the bleachers where their parents always sat side by side are gone forever.

Speaker 20 If you're a smoker or dipper ready to make a change, you really only need one good reason.

Speaker 21 But with Zen nicotine pouches, you'll discover many good reasons.

Speaker 23 Zen is America's number one nicotine pouch brand.

Speaker 24 Plus, Zen offers a robust rewards program.

Speaker 25 There are lots of options when it comes to nicotine satisfaction, but there's only one Zen.

Speaker 26 Check out Zen.com slash find to find Zen at a store near you.

Speaker 27 Warning, this product contains nicotine. Nicotine is an addictive chemical.