Evil Was Waiting

Speaker 2 the Creator of Homeland, Claire Danes and Matthew Reese star in the new Netflix series The Beast in Me as ruthless rivals whose shared darkness will set them on a collision course with fatal consequences.

Speaker 2 The Beast in Me is a riveting psychological cat-and-mouse story about guilt and justice and doubt, now playing only on Netflix.

Speaker 3 It's time to save. The Firestone Black Friday and Cyber Monday sale is on.
Get 15% off all tires and $40 off a lifetime will alignment when you buy two or more eligible tires.

Speaker 3 Visit FirestoneCompleteAutocare.com for details and more deals.

Speaker 4 He wasn't my biological child, but my heart.

Speaker 4 You can't tell that tire heart.

Speaker 5 I love that boy.

Speaker 4 It's not fair that he was taken from his children or from his family.

Speaker 6 Jesse fell for Vince, a man in uniform, holding the fort during his long deployments.

Speaker 4 My hat goes off to all military wives. It's not easy.

Speaker 8 It's not.

Speaker 9 She was a good mom. She loved the kids.

Speaker 10 Reunited at last, they celebrated.

Speaker 6 Then, on the drive home.

Speaker 4 There was a car there,

Speaker 4 stranded.

Speaker 8 Vince tells his wife that he's going to go check on it.

Speaker 5 I heard two, three poppies.

Speaker 8 He was laying there with what appeared to be several gunshot wounds to the head.

Speaker 6 Her husband, a father of five, dead.

Speaker 6 No one could understand it.

Speaker 9 The type of person that he was, I don't think he ever had an enemy.

Speaker 6 Or did he?

Speaker 5 He said, we are now in debt to dead people.

Speaker 11 We knew that there was another person that needed to be looked at.

Speaker 6 A winding investigation leading deep into the dark.

Speaker 4 This sounds like a love triangle.

Speaker 5 Maybe it was.

Speaker 11 It's horrific.

Speaker 3 Brutal.

Speaker 4 I was like, why?

Speaker 5 Are you kidding me?

Speaker 6 I'm Lester Holt, and this is Dateline.

Speaker 6 Here's Andrea Canning with Evil Was Waiting.

Speaker 4 Hopkinsville, Kentucky. Cornfields, picket fences, and patriotism.

Speaker 4 Just to the south is Fort Campbell, home to more than 13,000 Army soldiers and their families. After facing danger all over the world, soldiers return to a collective sigh of relief.

Speaker 4 After all, bad things aren't supposed to happen here.

Speaker 4 But when one young sergeant returned from a tour in Afghanistan, he had no idea the enemy would be much closer to home. My husband got out and see if some guy needed help.

Speaker 8 Multiple gunshots to his face and head.

Speaker 11 He had only been back from fighting in the war for such a short period of time. It was tragic.

Speaker 5 My heart sunk.

Speaker 4 Sergeant Vincent Goslin Jr., a 28-year-old father of five, had served in the Army for seven years as a quartermaster and mechanic.

Speaker 4 Did Vince ever express to you what it meant to him to serve his country?

Speaker 9 He absolutely loved it.

Speaker 4 Tim Hamilton is Vince's cousin. But as he explains it, they were much more than that.
Were you kind of like a big brother to Vince? Yeah.

Speaker 9 With him, it was, I don't know how we had a bond. He had an outgoing personality.
He had his crazy little grin. You always knew when he was doing something mischievous.

Speaker 4 And Tim recalls the mischief he and Vince got into growing up in a small Michigan town called Cadillac.

Speaker 9 We'd go play in the creeks, go fishing.

Speaker 9 We actually built a raft out of old barrels that we threw in the water and tied sticks to it and

Speaker 9 never floated, but.

Speaker 4 Sounds like Huckleberry Finn.

Speaker 5 Yeah.

Speaker 4 But Vince's childhood story wasn't always so idyllic. Vince's mom left at eight months old, so he was raised with his dad.
I think his dad was married six times. So that was a little tough on him.

Speaker 4 Janet Madison considered herself Vince's surrogate mom. She says growing up he spent a lot of time at her house.
Her son was Vince's best friend.

Speaker 4 He was just like one of the other boys.

Speaker 4 He was always there.

Speaker 4 They did everything together. It seems like you two had quite a connection with you and Vince.
What was that all about?

Speaker 4 I think a lot of it was I never judged him.

Speaker 4 Vince was, you know, he was the purest tattoo kid,

Speaker 4 the droopy pants, the spiked hair, the, you know, and I just treated him just like me and you.

Speaker 4 And then one day, he came to her with some life-changing news. Was he scared finding out he was going to be a dad? He probably was scared, but he was afraid that I would be mad at him.
And

Speaker 4 I wasn't mad at him. Vince had two sons from two relationships by the time he was 18.
But Janet says he only ever saw them as blessings. How was was Vince as a dad? He was awesome.

Speaker 4 He'd change that diaper. He'd clean up that puke.
You know,

Speaker 4 he didn't care. His kids were his world.

Speaker 4 Then someone else entered his world, a hometown girl named Jesse Hull. Vince loved Jesse unconditional, and you could see it.
He was happy. He loved her.

Speaker 4 And Janet says he started to settle down, moved in with Jesse's family, and quickly bonded with her dad, a Vietnam vet.

Speaker 4 He was the one who suggested the military might be a good way for Vince to get on the straight and narrow. So Vince joined the army in 2005.
He was 21 years old.

Speaker 4 This is a boy who's gone from baggy pants and spiky hair to now he's going to have the military cut and the uniform.

Speaker 4 I mean, that's like a 180 for Vince. That is a 180.
It's what he needed. You must have been really proud of him for making that stop.
I was always proud of him. I'm still proud of him.

Speaker 4 With Vince's career heading in the right direction, he took another big step and popped the question. Jesse said yes.

Speaker 9 There was a connection between them two that they loved each other to death. You know, they would argue, and I think they actually just argued just so they could make up.

Speaker 4 Well, some people say that's the best part.

Speaker 5 It is.

Speaker 4 After the wedding, kids soon followed for the happy couple. Two girls and a boy.

Speaker 4 As a surgeon in the Army, Vince spent a lot of time overseas, so it was up to Jesse to handle the home front and take care of the kids on her own. It's not easy having a husband who is away.

Speaker 4 It takes someone special to be able to endure that and get through that. Tim says somehow Jesse and Vince made it work.

Speaker 9 When we'd see him and Jesse and them as a family, they looked like a great family.

Speaker 4 By 2012, Vince and Jesse had been married for six years. Despite some bumps, Tim thought life was good for Vince and his family.

Speaker 4 But shortly after returning from Afghanistan, Vince's second tour there, Tim got an unsettling call from him.

Speaker 9 The sound of his voice, it was, if something happens, I wanted you to know what's going on. But he wouldn't tell me anything.

Speaker 4 A few days later, on February 3rd, Vince and Jesse went out to dinner to celebrate his safe return at a place called O'Charlie's.

Speaker 4 They started driving home, back to the base, then turned off the main drag onto this dark and winding road, Fidelio Road, where evil was waiting. I don't know where we are today.

Speaker 4 Coming up.

Speaker 14 A wife's harrowing tale.

Speaker 4 I didn't tell him to say I want my husband and I don't see if some guy needed help.

Speaker 6 Soon after, another driver makes an alarming discovery.

Speaker 10 I stopped and I tried yelling at him to see if he was awake, alert, something.

Speaker 4 It was a moonless February night in Hopkinsville, Kentucky, around 8 p.m., when a frantic call came into 911.

Speaker 12 911.

Speaker 12 Yes.

Speaker 4 I didn't step out of the the side of the road when my husband got out to see if some guy needed help.

Speaker 4 Jesse Goslin told the operator that her husband, Sergeant Vincent Goslin, had been shot when he tried to help a motorist stranded on the side of the road. Jesse was hysterical.

Speaker 16 Listen to me, listen, listen, listen. I can't understand a word you're saying.
You're going to have to calm down and talk to me.

Speaker 4 As she tried to calm down, Jesse told the operator, after being shot, Vince came back to their car, but was unable to get in because a man was pulling him back.

Speaker 4 My husband tried to get in the vehicle.

Speaker 17 He couldn't get in the vehicle.

Speaker 5 He screamed for me to go.

Speaker 4 Jesse says she drove away from the scene as her husband had instructed.

Speaker 4 Minutes later, another 911 call came in.

Speaker 5 The guy that's been killed is dead down the road from my house.

Speaker 4 This is the man who made the call.

Speaker 4 Walter Ferguson said he was getting ready to visit his cousin when he heard the gunshots.

Speaker 10 Living around here, we hear a lot of gunshots, so I didn't think nothing of it. I got in my truck, started to come down the road.

Speaker 10 As soon as I crested the hill, I saw the truck's lights came on and he just bolted off.

Speaker 4 So what did you do when you saw this truck?

Speaker 10 Well, I mean, I went and turned around. And as I came back around, I made sure my high beams were on.
I ended up seeing his body.

Speaker 4 There, on the side of the road, Walter spotted a man lying face down in the dirt.

Speaker 10 So I stopped and I tried yelling at him and talking to him to see if he was awake, alert, something.

Speaker 10 And I started looking for my phone. I didn't have it on me, so I had to end up zooming back to the house to call 911.

Speaker 4 Christian County Detective Ed Stokes raced to the scene.

Speaker 8 We were just notified that there had been a shooting on Fidelio Road and one male possibly deceased.

Speaker 4 Tell us what you see when you arrive here at the scene.

Speaker 8 The first thing that I noticed was

Speaker 8 Sergeant Goslin's body laying here in the gravel with a large amount of blood around the body.

Speaker 4 Could you tell if he had been shot?

Speaker 8 We found what appeared to be gunshot wounds to the head and the shell casings laying near the body inside the crime scene backed up the thought that he was shot.

Speaker 4 You say he was shot in the head?

Speaker 1 Correct.

Speaker 4 And the face?

Speaker 8 Correct.

Speaker 1 Was this personal?

Speaker 8 It's personal to me

Speaker 8 because

Speaker 8 that person that shot him nine times wanted him dead.

Speaker 4 While Detective Stokes worked the crime scene about a quarter of a mile down the road, deputies were talking to Jesse.

Speaker 8 She was hysterical, crying, almost sometimes where you couldn't even understand what she was saying.

Speaker 4 There's Jesse on her knees, collapsed on the side of the road.

Speaker 4 This was a wife who had clearly been through a traumatic situation.

Speaker 8 She had just watched her husband get shot multiple times, yes.

Speaker 4 Detectives took Jesse back to the station to get her statement. Her stomach, it seemed, couldn't take the horror she'd just witnessed.

Speaker 5 And the Navy's like,

Speaker 5 well, let me go to the garden for you something.

Speaker 4 By now, Christian County Commonwealth's attorney Lynn Pryor had been notified. What did you think when you heard that a soldier from Fort Campbell has been gunned down?

Speaker 4 He's barely been home from his tour of duty.

Speaker 11 At heart, we take a great pride in having Fort Campbell as part of our community. The fact that our soldiers protect us every day and we wanted to make sure that we got justice for him.

Speaker 4 Was Jesse able to describe the person

Speaker 4 who shot her husband?

Speaker 11 She initially described him as a black man and I believe that's pretty basically all the description she was being able to give.

Speaker 4 Jesse also described the killer's car.

Speaker 17 What kind of car?

Speaker 12 A little one, one of the big ones.

Speaker 12 What color was it?

Speaker 4 It wasn't much for police to go on. And to make it even more difficult, the eyewitness, Walter Ferguson, had seen something different.

Speaker 4 Describe the truck that you saw speeding off.

Speaker 10 As he passed me, I could see that it was like a white truck and I saw the 4x4 on it. But that was about as much as I could see on it.

Speaker 4 So the witness had seen a white truck, and Jesse said she saw a reddish-brown car. Investigators had a lot to sort out.

Speaker 4 A murdered soldier, a distraught wife, an unknown motive, and a giant secret about to be discovered.

Speaker 3 Coming up, Jesse reveals a bombshell about her husband.

Speaker 5 He had told me that and about a large quantity of methane findings. He said, We are now in death.
The two bad people.

Speaker 4 If this story checks out, that's pretty serious.

Speaker 12 If we could prove that, yes.

Speaker 14 When Dateline continues.

Speaker 2 Looking to crack the code on your career? Well, maybe it's time to get your degree. Southern New Hampshire University offers over 200 programs you can complete online.

Speaker 2 No set class times means you can do it all on your schedule. And with some of the lowest online tuition rates in the U.S., they make getting your degree affordable, too.

Speaker 2 Get started at SNHU.edu slash dateline. That's snhu.edu slash dateline.

Speaker 1 Most holiday gifts end up in a drawer or the back of your closet or accidentally left at your cousin's house. Not this one.
Mint Mobile is offering unlimited premium wireless for $15 a month.

Speaker 18 That's their best deal of the year, aka a holiday gift you'll actually use every single day.

Speaker 1 Don't get them socks. Get them premium wireless for $15 a month.
Shop Shop Mint Unlimited plans at mintmobile.com slash dateline. That's mintmobile.com slash dateline.
Limited time offer.

Speaker 18 Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for 6 months, or $180 for 12 months.

Speaker 1 Plan required, $15 per month equivalent.

Speaker 18 Taxes and fees extra.

Speaker 1 Initial plan term only.

Speaker 18 Greater than 35 gigabytes may slow when the network is busy.

Speaker 1 Capable device required.

Speaker 18 Availability, speed, and coverage vary.

Speaker 1 See Mintmobile.com.

Speaker 15 If you're a maintenance supervisor at a manufacturing facility and your machinery isn't working right, Granger knows you need to understand what's wrong as soon as possible.

Speaker 15 So when a conveyor motor falters, Granger offers diagnostic tools like calibration kits and multimeters to help you identify and fix the problem.

Speaker 15 With Granger, you can be confident you have everything you need to keep your facility running smoothly. Call 1-800-GRANGER, clickgranger.com, or just stop by.
Granger for the ones who get it done.

Speaker 4 Was this case a top priority? You have an American soldier, gun down, and a shooter on the loose.

Speaker 8 Every detective we had was working this case.

Speaker 4 Did you worry about the safety of others?

Speaker 8 At first, it's always a thought through our mind.

Speaker 8 Is this a, you know, serial killer? Because we have no motive yet. So, yes, it was very important.

Speaker 4 Back at the Christian County Sheriff's Department, 25-year-old Jesse Goslin continued to speak to detectives. She was emotionally and physically distraught.

Speaker 4 And she kept asking about her husband. Jesse still hadn't been told if he was dead or alive.

Speaker 10 Something you heard?

Speaker 5 Really?

Speaker 5 Is there anything needed? No. Okay,

Speaker 5 you just sit there and I'm only a baby.

Speaker 5 I'm only a kid.

Speaker 4 Finally, the detective came back and broke the news about Vince.

Speaker 10 He was pronounced dead at the same time.

Speaker 11 I'm really sorry for your loss.

Speaker 4 The tragic news of Vince's murder spread fast throughout the base and to family members. Janet, Vince's surrogate mother, got a call from Jesse's mom.
And she just said,

Speaker 4 Janet,

Speaker 2 there's been an accident.

Speaker 4 Vince has been shot.

Speaker 4 And I was devastated.

Speaker 4 I was like, what?

Speaker 4 What? What do you mean he's been shot? Vince's cousin Tim immediately left his home in Virginia and traveled to Kentucky, still in disbelief.

Speaker 9 How can he survive two times in Afghanistan and come home to be shot by some worthless thug

Speaker 9 that

Speaker 4 didn't even know him? You must have felt so horrible for Jesse and for the kids.

Speaker 9 Absolutely.

Speaker 9 I must have called her at least 50 times,

Speaker 9 trying to figure out what's going on and be there for her and the kids.

Speaker 4 By now, Jesse had left the Christian County Sheriff's Department and headed home.

Speaker 8 She's picked up by a friend, taken back to her house on Fort Campbell.

Speaker 4 The day after the murder, local police and agents from Fort Campbell were canvassing the Goslins neighborhood. This is now a mix of Army investigators and local investigators.
Yes.

Speaker 4 They knocked on the door of Kay and William Ray, the couple who live next door to the Goslins. What they had to say was so compelling, they asked them to immediately come in for an interview.

Speaker 19 You said you had some information about something that Ms. Goslin had told you pertaining to some trouble her husband was in.

Speaker 20 Somehow or another got involved with a drug dealer, at least $20,000 in myth,

Speaker 20 and got jumped and stolen away from him. Well, when that happened, these guys were supposedly after him for the money.

Speaker 4 The Rays explained to the investigators, Jesse had told them about the drug dealers weeks before the murder.

Speaker 19 She seemed worried at all about what was going on.

Speaker 22 She's been on pins and needles ever since this has happened. She's been scared.
She's feared for her life and her children's.

Speaker 19 Okay.

Speaker 19 They ever say who these people were, where these people were from, or never said a word about that right there.

Speaker 4 Later that day, Detective Stokes says K-Ray convinced Jesse she should talk to military investigators, tell them what she told local police. It turned out to be a fateful decision.

Speaker 8 Jesse gets in with the

Speaker 8 friend and they go to CID headquarters.

Speaker 4 With K-Ray sitting next to her for support, Jesse gave a detailed explanation about why she turned down that deserted road.

Speaker 4 She said as they were driving home, she was at the wheel and she started to feel sick. Vince suggested they pull over.

Speaker 5 Then he said, There's a road, turn down it.

Speaker 1 I turned down the road.

Speaker 5 He told me to drive until there was a spot we could pull off.

Speaker 4 She said that's when they saw the vehicle with the hood up, and Vince got out to help. Not long after, she heard gunshots.

Speaker 5 I heard like

Speaker 5 two, maybe three, like

Speaker 5 popping sounds.

Speaker 5 And my husband rounded the edge of the passenger side of the vehicle. He was trying to get in.

Speaker 5 The guy was behind him, pulling him back out.

Speaker 5 He was hit him.

Speaker 5 All my husband could say was, go drive, go get out of here.

Speaker 4 She described a chaotic scene with a random motorist. But then investigators asked her about Vince's involvement with those drug dealers, suggesting perhaps it wasn't so random after all.

Speaker 4 Jesse told them what she knew.

Speaker 5 He had told me that he bought a large quantity of methane filmmaking.

Speaker 5 He said, we are now in debt to people,

Speaker 5 to bad people.

Speaker 5 About $20,000.

Speaker 8 We had to check into his drug usage, if we could find anything out from friends, family, if he was using or even dealing drugs.

Speaker 4 If this story checks out, I mean, that's pretty serious.

Speaker 12 If we could prove that, yes.

Speaker 4 While Jesse did her best to give the investigators leads, police working the case in the field got a new lead of their own, and it sent them in a very different direction.

Speaker 7 Coming up.

Speaker 6 Did Vince's killer threaten Jesse, too?

Speaker 4 She was getting text messages from this man.

Speaker 11 That's what she indicated, yes. And that he would kill her and her children if she didn't comply with what he was telling her to do.

Speaker 4 One day after the murder of Sergeant Vince Goslin, the investigation was unfolding fast. In the field, detectives were gathering evidence and talking to witnesses.

Speaker 4 And at Fort Campbell, the interview rooms were filling up.

Speaker 8 I'm not talking about where she thought Mike had in one of those rooms.

Speaker 4 Jesse Goslin.

Speaker 5 You have drug dealers that are actually you. You never know what the hell's going to happen.

Speaker 4 Jesse had given law enforcement a possible motive for her husband's murder. She said Vince owed money to drug dealers.
A lot of money.

Speaker 19 Do you know where the drug dealers are?

Speaker 5 No, I don't.

Speaker 4 Prosecutor Pryor was getting regular phone updates about all the witness interviews, but to her, Jesse's was the most important.

Speaker 4 Jesse gave police a key new detail. She said on the night of the murder, one of those drug dealers contacted her.

Speaker 19 Did you have to talk to the drug dealers directly?

Speaker 4 She was getting text messages from this man.

Speaker 11 That's what she indicated, yes. And that he would do harm or kill her and her family, her children, if she didn't comply with what he was telling her to do.

Speaker 4 That's when Jesse admitted she didn't drive down Fidelio Road because she was feeling sick.

Speaker 5 I got a text

Speaker 4 that told me to turn on the road.

Speaker 25 What did the text say?

Speaker 25 Turn on this road or turn on the next road? What did it say exactly?

Speaker 5 Don't even turn on the road after the stop. Like,

Speaker 5 if you deny your whole family is dead.

Speaker 4 She said she felt she had no choice but to go through with what the man said, even though she suspected something bad was about to happen.

Speaker 5 I kind of figured it as we're gonna go down here and hear you address me.

Speaker 4 As Jesse's interview on Fort Campbell headed into its second hour, sheriff's detectives across town were working on tracking down the truck seen leaving the murder scene, figuring if they could find the truck, they would find the killer.

Speaker 26 I heard about three or four shots.

Speaker 4 Walter Ferguson, the witness who had described seeing a white-colored 4x4 truck speeding down the road, gave police more distinctive descriptions about the vehicle.

Speaker 26 The headlights were higher than my hood.

Speaker 26 So they were like in my eyes. Okay, so kind of lifted.

Speaker 14 Was it loud? Was it

Speaker 26 very loud?

Speaker 4 Detectives quickly found neighbors who told them they'd seen a truck just like that many times in the neighborhood. They searched DMV records and found the truck.

Speaker 4 It was registered to a former soldier who had lived on base at Fort Campbell, 24-year-old Jared Long.

Speaker 11 Jared Long was very much a person of interest at that point.

Speaker 4 But he's not on base anymore.

Speaker 11 No.

Speaker 4 Where is he?

Speaker 11 We didn't know.

Speaker 4 So Detective Stokes says law enforcement immediately got busy trying to find him.

Speaker 8 We actually put an attempt to locate out all surrounding states and counties from here to Colorado where he was from. And in fact, he was stopped by a trooper in Colorado.

Speaker 4 He must have really high-tailed it out of Kentucky to get to Colorado that fast. Quick.
When he was pulled over, was he driving a raised white truck?

Speaker 8 He was in a light gray Dodge pickup truck that was lifted with large tires and loud exhaust, matching the description of our witness.

Speaker 4 So you're thinking you might have your man here?

Speaker 6 Yes.

Speaker 4 You might have thought he had his man, but police decided the fact that Jared's truck matched the description of the eyewitness wasn't enough to arrest him.

Speaker 11 They stalled as long as they could, I think, and ultimately had to let him go.

Speaker 4 That's potential evidence driving away. Who knows what's in that truck, what's on his clothes? I mean, you've, it's all, it could all be destroyed.

Speaker 11 That was all evidence, potential evidence that we wanted to get our hands on and had no ability to do so at that time.

Speaker 4 That's tough.

Speaker 11 Very tough.

Speaker 4 But detectives pressed on. And while trying to figure out who Jared Long was and why he would want Vince dead, they uncovered new information about their main witness, Jesse.

Speaker 6 Coming up, Jesse's neighbors revealed that they too had seen Jared's truck outside Jesse's house.

Speaker 23 How often did you see that vehicle there over that period of time while Vincent was deployed?

Speaker 26 Maybe tons of times a week.

Speaker 6 When dateline continues.

Speaker 14 Hey everybody, Ted Danson here to tell you about my podcast with my longtime friend and sometimes co-host Woody Harrelson.

Speaker 14 It's called Where Everybody Knows Your Name and we're back for another season.

Speaker 14 I'm so excited to be joined this season by friends like John Mulaney, David Spade, Sarah Silverman, Ed Helms, and many more. You don't want to miss it.

Speaker 14 Listen to Where Everybody Knows Your Name with me, Ted Danson, and Woody Harrelson sometimes, wherever you get your podcasts.

Speaker 27 Did you know that parents rank financial literacy as the number one most difficult life skill to teach? Meet Greenlight, the debit card and money app for families.

Speaker 27 With Greenlight, you can set up chores, automate allowance, and keep an eye on your kids' spending with real-time notifications.

Speaker 27 Kids learn to earn, save, and spend wisely, and parents can rest easy knowing their kids are learning about money with guardrails in place.

Speaker 27 Sign up for Greenlight today at greenlight.com slash podcast.

Speaker 13 If you're an experienced pet owner, you already know that having a pet is 25% belly rubs, 25% yelling, drop it, and 50% groaning at the bill from every vet visit.

Speaker 13 Which is why Lemonade Pet Insurance is tailor-made for your pet and can save you up to 90% on vet bills.

Speaker 13 It can help cover checkups, emergencies, diagnostics, basically all the stuff that makes your bank account nervous. Claims are filed super easy through the Lemonade app and half get settled instantly.

Speaker 13 Get a quote at lemonade.com/slash pet, and they'll help cover the vet bill for whatever your pet swallowed after you yelled, drop it.

Speaker 4 At Fort Campbell, Jesse Goslin was talking to a military investigator, giving possible clues about her husband's killer.

Speaker 4 Meanwhile, Detective Stokes and others from the Christian County Sheriff's Department thought they were onto something.

Speaker 4 They believed they'd located the truck from the crime scene and knew the name of the driver, Jared Long.

Speaker 4 Now, they needed to know why he would be involved in Vince's murder.

Speaker 8 Our units, detectives, along with the CID agents from Fort Campbell, did a neighborhood canvas on post.

Speaker 4 And what they discovered was a bombshell. Neighbors said they'd seen Jared's truck not just in the area but parked in Jesse's driveway.
K. Ray lived next door.

Speaker 22 I would see him driving the truck with her and the three kids. I would see her driving the truck with the three kids.

Speaker 4 And what she said next really got the investigators attention.

Speaker 23 How often on a weekly basis would you see that vehicle there over that period of time while Vincent was deployed?

Speaker 26 Maybe two or three times a week.

Speaker 4 As you looked deeper into this potential relationship between Jared and Jesse,

Speaker 4 how serious was it?

Speaker 8 From what we could gather, they lived together on base. And if Sergeant Goslin came home for any reason, then Jared Long would leave for a couple of days while he was here.

Speaker 4 It was stunning. Stokes was now convinced Jesse was not the devoted Army wife she seemed to be.
Instead, she was at the center of a deadly love triangle. Both men in love with Jesse.

Speaker 8 Correct.

Speaker 4 Jesse in love with

Speaker 4 one man?

Speaker 8 I believe so.

Speaker 4 To the detective, evidence that Jared and Jesse were a couple was piling up. Like when police ran the plates of the car Jesse was driving the night of the murder.

Speaker 8 They came back to Jesse Goslin and Jared Long.

Speaker 4 They owned a car together. By now, police had had enough of Jesse's shifting stories and confronted her with what they knew.

Speaker 15 Jesse, we know there wasn't a black guy.

Speaker 3 Yeah, there was Lyris.

Speaker 24 We know that his truck was there.

Speaker 15 Everything that witnesses said has been true.

Speaker 5 No.

Speaker 3 Yeah,

Speaker 15 very true.

Speaker 21 No.

Speaker 4 He told her they knew all about her romantic relationship with Jared. Jesse admitted she and Jared hung out together, but continued to deny there was anything sexual between them.

Speaker 8 She said they were friends and he stayed there on the couch, and that was it.

Speaker 4 Jesse did admit she and Vince were going through a tough time, but she claimed they were working things out.

Speaker 5 I've always reassured Vince that I'm not just gonna walk away from you.

Speaker 5 I'm not that person. I'm not gonna

Speaker 5 leave you. We were planning on doing marriage counseling.
He actually called Friday before we left.

Speaker 4 And besides, she said Vince knew all about Jared.

Speaker 5 Vince knew that he had been staying at the house.

Speaker 4 But investigators didn't believe her. More than three hours into Jesse's interview, after repeatedly denying she and Jared had a romantic relationship.

Speaker 5 Because we did not have sex.

Speaker 4 Jesse finally changed her story.

Speaker 5 There was times when I was drawing, yes, I'm sure we had sex. I knew that Jared loved me.
Right. And I know he loves my kids.

Speaker 26 Okay.

Speaker 11 He saw him non-cons.

Speaker 4 When investigators told prosecutor Lynn Pryor that Jesse had admitted to having a romantic relationship with Jared, she knew this was a big moment.

Speaker 11 They were planning a life together.

Speaker 4 That could be a motive.

Speaker 11 Absolutely a motive. Because who was in their way of being together for the rest of their life? Her husband.

Speaker 4 And Jesse had another possible motive. As a military wife, she would receive a big payout from her husband's life insurance policy.
$450,000.

Speaker 11 She certainly certainly could have benefited greatly from the death of her husband.

Speaker 4 Before Jesse's eight-hour interview was over, she had admitted to seeing Jared the day before the murder.

Speaker 5 He wanted me at the motel while he was in town. I said, fine.

Speaker 5 We had lunch and talked and needed to have sex.

Speaker 4 But it wasn't the sex investigators were interested in. Jesse had one more story to tell.

Speaker 4 She claimed that Jared had talked to the drug dealers, and if he roughed up Vince, somehow that would satisfy them. Then she said Jared told her what her job would be.

Speaker 5 And he told me, you need to meet me on this road.

Speaker 5 You need to pull down to the shoulder rig, pull off.

Speaker 5 I'm going to say husband's straight.

Speaker 4 But the prosecutor and detectives weren't buying it. Instead, without realizing it, Jesse had finally given them what they needed.
Why is there now enough to arrest her?

Speaker 11 Because she's admitted her part in getting Vincent to the location where he was ultimately killed. In Kentucky, being an accomplice to murder is the same as actually committing the murder.

Speaker 4 That grieving wife, hysterical by the side of the road, getting sick in front of police, was charged with her husband's murder.

Speaker 21 Let me see your hands. Now step out of the truck.

Speaker 4 As for Jared Long, because of Jesse's admission that she and Jared had a plan to harm Vince, police now had enough to arrest him too. They tracked him down again, this time near his home in Colorado.

Speaker 8 They did a felony stop, called him out, made him go prone on the ground, and placed him in cuffs.

Speaker 5 Jared continued his search warrant on

Speaker 5 credit.

Speaker 4 They had a warrant to search his truck this time.

Speaker 8 Colorado authorities were able to obtain a search warrant for Mr. Long's truck.

Speaker 11 They found a shell casing that ultimately was matched to the shell casings found at our murder scene.

Speaker 11 And they swabbed the truck, which eventually led to evidence that indicated gunshot residue had been left in several places around his vehicle.

Speaker 21 Did I ask you to take that seat over there? Yes, sir.

Speaker 4 Colorado police brought Jared in for questioning. Unlike Jesse, he didn't hesitate to talk about his romantic relationship with her.

Speaker 20 We hooked up a while back.

Speaker 21 It was sometime around September.

Speaker 21 And

Speaker 21 we started going out. The next thing I knew,

Speaker 21 we were living together. I knew she was married.
I knew it was horrible.

Speaker 4 He also admitted to being in Kentucky on the day of the murder. But he says he left before dark.

Speaker 21 When do you think he left?

Speaker 21 About 5.30.

Speaker 4 What he didn't know was Jesse had already pointed the finger at him.

Speaker 21 She has spoken with the detectives and she has told them about the plan that you guys have.

Speaker 21 Excuse me.

Speaker 21 But she puts her and Vince and you at the scene. And the witness puts you and your truck at the scene.

Speaker 21 But you need to help us out at this point, Jared, and explain to us what happened there. I believe at this point I need to say stop and I believe I need a lawyer.

Speaker 21 because this has gone well beyond what I'm capable of.

Speaker 4 They now had two suspects in custody. And as for that drug dealer story, Detective Stokes says that was just a hoax Jesse cooked up to throw off police.

Speaker 4 And she told the story to several people, including her neighbors, the Rays, who unwittingly corroborated her story.

Speaker 4 Did you ever find any evidence that Vince was involved in some type of drug deal gone bad? No. That men were out to get him and his family.

Speaker 8 No, we did not. We couldn't find anything that would take us there other than her story.

Speaker 4 Janet, Vince's surrogate mom, was horrified when she learned that Jesse, the woman who had seemed so good for Vince, was now implicated in his murder. I was devastated.

Speaker 4 I was like, why is she arrested? Did you think she was capable of killing Vince?

Speaker 4 Never.

Speaker 12 Why?

Speaker 4 There's divorce. Why wouldn't she just get a divorce?

Speaker 8 Do you swear to affirm that the statement you've given is true to the best?

Speaker 4 But even with Jesse's story and the evidence against Jared, the case was far from closed. An unexpected twist was about to put the whole investigation into a tailspin.

Speaker 4 Did you worry that one or both of them could get away with murder?

Speaker 6 Coming up, prosecutors face a major setback.

Speaker 4 I was livid.

Speaker 6 Is their case about to collapse?

Speaker 4 I was devastated all over again.

Speaker 4 Prosecutor Lynn Pryor already felt she had a solid case against Jared Long. And after his arrest, police found even more evidence in his truck.

Speaker 11 There was one spot of blood that belonged to Vincent Goslin. on the backpack of Jared Long.

Speaker 4 This is bingo right here.

Speaker 11 This is more evidence than I've had in most of the murder cases I've prosecuted.

Speaker 4 How do you explain the victim's blood on your backpack when you're hundreds of miles away?

Speaker 11 You can't,

Speaker 11 unless you're the person that killed him.

Speaker 4 But Pryor knew the case against Jesse wasn't as airtight.

Speaker 11 It was very much a circumstantial case because there was no physical evidence implicating her.

Speaker 4 Did you worry that that wouldn't be enough to get a conviction?

Speaker 11 Somewhat, yes. Jared Long was not willing to give us anything to help out with regard to implicating Jesse,

Speaker 11 but we knew that

Speaker 11 it was her involvement that got Jared to where Vincent was killed.

Speaker 4 How are you going to prove that?

Speaker 11 With her own words.

Speaker 4 But then entered defense attorney Mark Bryant. He represented Jared Long, and he had a plan that could benefit Jesse, too.
His strategy was to get Jesse's interview with police thrown out.

Speaker 4 And how would he do that?

Speaker 24 Mrs. Goslin had told the the local police department that she didn't want to talk, that she wanted a lawyer.

Speaker 5 I wanted a story and I want to know where my husband is.

Speaker 24 And so under the law, you have to break up any questioning. And they did.
And they sent her back home to Fort Campbell.

Speaker 4 But you might remember after that, her friend convinced Jesse to go speak to the military police on base.

Speaker 24 Jesse Goslin spent eight hours with the police. After that very day, she said she wasn't going to talk without a lawyer.
So it's just a different police agency.

Speaker 4 Bryant argued in front of a circuit judge. Since Jesse had already asked for a lawyer, the military police should never have questioned her.
The judge agreed.

Speaker 24 He made a decision that that confession that she made implicating our client should be set aside because the law enforcement agency for the military police should have followed the same rules that the earlier police department in Christian County had followed during that day.

Speaker 4 Jesse Goslin's statement was thrown out.

Speaker 4 The news hit Vince's family hard. Hearing the news that Vince was killed was horrible.

Speaker 4 But what the justice system did was unfair. When they threw that out of court, I was devastated all over again.
And we thought that she was going to walk away.

Speaker 4 We thought that they were going to get away with it. But Prosecutor Pryor wasn't going down without a fight.
She filed a motion with the Kentucky Court of Appeals.

Speaker 4 Jesse and Jared, meanwhile, were out and about relatively free. How did you feel about both Jesse and Jared being out on house arrest with just ankle bracelets? I was livid.

Speaker 11 I argued to the best of my ability to the judge about why someone that was charged with such a heinous murder should be out on an ankle monitor.

Speaker 11 And none of the arguments that I made were convincing to the judge.

Speaker 4 Then Then everyone waited and waited. Four long years went by before the appeals court finally reached a decision and sided with the prosecution.

Speaker 4 What's that moment like when you get word that it's been overturned and that the statement will be allowed?

Speaker 11 I was very much relieved.

Speaker 4 Pryor considered her options and concluded that of the two, Jared deserved the harshest punishment.

Speaker 11 Jared Long was the one who pulled the trigger nine times. Jared Long was the one who took the life of Vincent Goslin.

Speaker 11 So we wanted to make sure he received the maximum punishment that he could for this crime.

Speaker 4 To do that, the prosecutor needed not only Jesse's videotaped statement, she needed Jesse to tell a jury the whole story that she and Jared planned to murder Vince.

Speaker 11 We needed her testimony about the reasons why they planned to kill Vincent and the way that they planned it out.

Speaker 4 So the prosecutor made an offer. If Jesse pleaded guilty to complicity to murder and would testify against Jared, she would recommend a sentence of 22 and a half years behind bars.

Speaker 4 She agreed to this plea deal?

Speaker 11 She did after long talks and very heated discussions.

Speaker 4 The prosecutor had a deal. That means the woman who had played the victim, betrayed her husband and lover, will be eligible for parole in 2031.

Speaker 4 Some people think the sentence is too light.

Speaker 11 I don't disagree with that, that the sentence was too light.

Speaker 11 But after discussions with law enforcement, with family members, we determined that it was worth it to have her to be able to say in her own words

Speaker 11 what happened and why.

Speaker 4 A different prosecutor then took over the case against Jared Long, Commonwealth Attorney Mark Blankenship.

Speaker 4 And as he looked over the case, he came to to a different conclusion about who was most responsible.

Speaker 28 I felt that the mastermind of the crime was Jesse. She didn't pull the trigger, but without her, this doesn't happen.

Speaker 28 What bothered me was that the bar got set at 22 years for the mastermind of the crime.

Speaker 4 So Blankenship did what he thought he had to, to be fair, and offered Jared a deal too. 30 years in prison for pleading guilty to first-degree murder.
Jared agreed.

Speaker 4 Jared, at times, is sort of being portrayed as this kind of victim, a little bit of Jesse, that she was the mastermind. But Vince was shot nine times in the head and the face.

Speaker 4 I mean, you cannot discount that for anything. No, it bothers me.

Speaker 28 He should have gotten more than 30 years.

Speaker 4 Tim, Vince's cousin, was torn about Jared's punishment.

Speaker 9 Jesse, she should have got more time than he did.

Speaker 9 Because she manipulated him.

Speaker 4 Is that the Jesse you knew? This master manipulator?

Speaker 9 Obviously, she must have been manipulating us because

Speaker 9 I would have never pegged her.

Speaker 4 I believe that she should do life.

Speaker 4 As for Janet, the woman who stepped in as Vince's mother, it's hard for her to describe the pain she feels. She watched her surrogate son go from a tough kid to a tough soldier.

Speaker 4 He became a good and honorable man, only to have it all needlessly taken away. He wasn't my biological child, but my heart, you can't tell that to my heart.

Speaker 5 I love that boy,

Speaker 4 and it's not fair that he was taken from his children or from his family.

Speaker 4 He had so much potential.

Speaker 4 He had gone so far.

Speaker 6 That's all for now.

Speaker 3 I'm Lester Holt.

Speaker 6 Thanks for joining us.

Speaker 18 This time of year, many are checking off their holiday gift lists. But identity thieves have lists too, and your personal information might be on them.

Speaker 6 Protect your identity with Life Lock.

Speaker 18 LifeLock monitors millions of data points every second and alerts you to threats you could miss. If your identity is stolen, LifeLock will fix it, guaranteed, or your money back.

Speaker 18 Save up to 40% your first year at lifelock.com/slash dateline.

Speaker 1 Terms apply.