Still looking
Though first-time unemployment filings barely ticked up last week, continuing claims hit a high not seen since 2021 and nearly 1.9 million Americans are receiving jobless benefits. What gives? A mix of hiring freezes, the time of year and choosy job seekers. Also in this episode: We compare today’s labor market to how things looked just before the pandemic began. Plus, three cities where rents are falling and a visit to a 24-hour diner.
Press play and read along
Transcript
Speaker 1 This Marketplace podcast is supported by Wealth Enhancement, who ask, do you have a blueprint for your money?
Speaker 1 Wealth Enhancement can help you build the right blueprint for investing, retirement, tax, and more.
Speaker 1 With offices nationwide, there's an advisor who's ready to listen and craft a blueprint for your future. Find out more at wealthenhancement.com/slash build.
Speaker 3 This podcast is supported by Odoo. Some say Odoo business management software is like fertilizer for businesses because the simple, efficient software promotes growth.
Speaker 3 Others say Odoo is like a magic beanstalk because it scales with you and is magically affordable.
Speaker 3 And some describe Odoo's programs for manufacturing, accounting, and more as building blocks for creating a custom software suite. So Odoo is fertilizer, magic beanstock building blocks for business.
Speaker 3
Odoo, exactly what businesses need. Sign up at odoo.com.
That's odoo.com.
Speaker 2 We'll go heavy on the labor market today and we'll grab a bite at a 24-hour diner. From American Public Media, this is Marketplace.
Speaker 2
In Los Angeles, I'm Kai Risnoll. It is Thursday today.
This one is the 23rd of January. Good as always to have you along, everybody.
Speaker 2
Thursday mornings bring with metronomic regularity a report on first-time claims for unemployment benefits. It bounces around a lot, that number does.
Volatility is what economists call it.
Speaker 2 So, most of the time, first-time claims don't really rate a mention.
Speaker 2 And today, in fact, those first-time claims barely ticked up just a teeny little bit.
Speaker 2 But continuing claims for unemployment help, that is, people who've been getting benefits for at least a week-rose more than expected, which means almost 1.9 million people right now are receiving unemployment benefits.
Speaker 2 And that is the most we've seen since November of 2021.
Speaker 2 Marketplaces Kelly Wells has more on why and why it matters.
Speaker 6 Some industries saw a fair number of layoffs and hiring freezes in 2024. Allison Stevens is senior director of HR Solutions at Paychecks and says they're partly to blame.
Speaker 7 I think in some pockets, the market might be flooded with qualified candidates.
Speaker 7 And on top of that, Stevens says people might also collect unemployment longer because they're being much more selective with the roles that they're seeking, such as they have decided they must work remotely or they, if they are going to go into an office, it's only going to be within a certain geographical distance from their home.
Speaker 6 Which is actually good for the economy because employees are more likely to stick with and excel at a job if they wait to find one that's best for them. But there's something else going on here.
Speaker 6
It's January. January is always like this.
Michelle Evermore with the Century Foundation specializes in unemployment insurance.
Speaker 8 Every employment insurance agency, if you ask them, will say it's their busiest month.
Speaker 8 The industries that you see decline in January are seasonal, holiday-related, travel-related, retail, and construction and outdoor stuff.
Speaker 6 So there are more unemployed people this week, and people are staying unemployed longer. But Elise Gould with the Economic Policy Institute says she's not worried.
Speaker 7 But when we look at continuing claims as a share of the labor force, it's basically the same as it was pre-COVID.
Speaker 6 She says, sure, it's not as low as it has been in the past three years when the labor market has been really hot.
Speaker 2 But long term?
Speaker 7
I would say that it's been pretty stable over the last couple of years, you know, maybe a little bit of an uptick. But again, layoffs remain low.
Things are still pretty strong.
Speaker 6
And remember, she says, the population is still growing. So we might be seeing more unemployed workers, but we're also seeing more workers in general.
I'm Kayleigh Wells for Marketplace.
Speaker 2 President Trump said something today that deserves a mention. He did a video conference with the World Economic Forum in Davos, and he said lots of things, but this one is right in our wheelhouse.
Speaker 10 With oil prices going down, I'll demand that interest rates drop immediately, and likewise, they should be dropping all over the world. Interest rates should follow us.
Speaker 2 Central bank independence on monetary policy is kind of a bedrock of stability in this economy, as we talked about a lot before this election. That is item number one.
Speaker 2 Item number two is that a lot of the president's proposed policies are, in and of themselves, inflationary, which, absent political interference, would dictate higher interest rates.
Speaker 2 Traders on Wall Street again seem to have been in a buying mood. We'll have the details when we do the numbers.
Speaker 2 The corporate news of this Thursday comes to us from Detroit, Michigan, the headquarters of the General Motors Corporation, which said today it's going to try and grab a bigger slice of the luxury EV market, specifically with a fancier version of its Cadillac Lyric SUV.
Speaker 2 But when the average price of an EV already tops $50,000, how big a market can there really be for something even pricier? Marketplace's Nancy Marshall Genser's on that one.
Speaker 11 The price of this latest lyric EV starts at nearly $80,000, hardly a bargain. But in the EV world, luxury is in.
Speaker 12 The EV market is lux-heavy.
Speaker 11 Elaine Buckberg is a former chief economist at GM. She says in model year 2024, there were more than 30 EV models that she considers luxury or premium compared to only around 20 cheaper models.
Speaker 11 And she says EV buyers wouldn't necessarily blink at an $80,000 price tag. One reason, Buckberg estimates with a gas price of, say, $3.15 a gallon.
Speaker 12 An EV owner could expect to save about
Speaker 12 $1,000 to $1,200
Speaker 12 per year because it's cheaper to charge at home versus buy gas.
Speaker 11 You You can also get a longer battery range with a higher priced EV. And then there are the early adopters.
Speaker 11 Sean Tucker, lead editor with Kelly Blue Book, says some people will even shell out $100,000 or more for really high-end EVs.
Speaker 13
I think there's a cache sense. These are extremely high technology vehicles and yes, it's the latest thing.
And often when you're shopping in that price range, that's what you're looking for.
Speaker 5 But there are limits.
Speaker 11 Jessica Caldwell is head of insights at Edmonds. She says the market for EVs selling for $100,000 or more is really quite small.
Speaker 14 The $100,000 EV is not going to be, you know, sell like hotcakes. It's just no one can afford it.
Speaker 11 Caldwell estimates that EVs with six-figure price tags are just a fraction of the market, probably less than 1% of all vehicles sold. I'm Nancy Marshall Genser for Marketplace.
Speaker 2 New York City bills itself famously as the city that never sleeps. And for years, the all-night diner was a critical amenity for all those very late-night or very early in the morning New Yorkers.
Speaker 2 Since the pandemic, though, those 24-hour diners have been disappearing as New Yorkers' sleep habits have changed. But those that remain open in the wee small hours do have a story to tell.
Speaker 2 Priya Krishna is a food writer for the New York Times, and she pulled an all-nighter of her own at Kellogg's Diner in Brooklyn. Priya, welcome to the program.
Speaker 14 Thank you so much for having me.
Speaker 2 Tell me why you chose Kellogg's, would you?
Speaker 12 I thought Kellogg's is a really great example of a 24-hour diner in that it has existed for a century.
Speaker 12 It closed during the pandemic, and then it sort of bucked this trend that we've seen of 24-hour establishments either closing or curtailing their hours and reopened as a 24-hour establishment.
Speaker 12 So I thought it perfectly combined old and new.
Speaker 2
And it is by the accounts that you give, it was hopping pretty much the whole time. You were there 8 p.m.
to 8 a.m., right?
Speaker 12 That's correct. Yeah.
Speaker 4 So
Speaker 2
interesting clientele changes through the evening. I did want to touch on a couple of those folks.
First of all,
Speaker 2 you have the regular sort of evening goers who are just out for a good meal and they go to a diner in New York City, which struck me as interesting.
Speaker 12 Yeah, I mean, I think one thing that's really interesting about Kellogg's is it has these two really amazing chefs, Jackie Carnessy and Amanda Perdomo, behind it.
Speaker 12 So, you know, it has a little bit more food cred than your average diner.
Speaker 12 So I think people who had heard of the chefs, had heard heard the food was good, and was sort of treating it like a culinary destination, which I thought was very interesting.
Speaker 2 I will point out here, and I was interested to see that there is a $95 ribeye steak on the menu for this diner. Now, I understand New York City is expensive, but my goodness.
Speaker 12 That was a really divisive one.
Speaker 12 A lot of the diners.
Speaker 4 I wonder why.
Speaker 12 Especially a lot of the diners who had been coming there for 30, 40 years were really shocked to see anything that costs $95 on a diner menu.
Speaker 12 I did ask the server and the server said that I think in her entire tenure as a server at Kellogg's, only three people had ordered it.
Speaker 2 Yeah, well, there you go.
Speaker 2 It was interesting to me that of the people you surveyed through the evening, a couple of them,
Speaker 2 here's one quote, apartments are too small, everyone needs somewhere else to be. And then another woman said, we need a place to go.
Speaker 2 Very much a third destination place, right? You got your home, you got your work, and now the Kellogg's diner, it seems.
Speaker 12 And I think diners have always served that purpose. It was heartwarming to see that the diners still serve that purpose.
Speaker 2 Yeah, the other thing they do, or I guess the other thing they are not, is fast food, right?
Speaker 2 Because a lot of places, and look, I don't go to many all-night diners here in Los Angeles, but I bet fast food places outnumber 24-hour diners by a significant amount.
Speaker 12 They definitely do. And I brought up fast food establishments to these customers asking, you know, why not go to, you know, a McDonald's at 3 o'clock in the morning?
Speaker 12 And a lot of them spoke to this idea of wanting to sit down and have a proper restaurant experience and be served like a hot homemade meal and how diners are really one of the few establishments providing that at 3 o'clock in the morning.
Speaker 2 Yeah. The staff didn't give you any hassle about sitting there for 12 hours, which was kind of cool.
Speaker 12
It was really interesting, and they definitely had no idea who I was. They had no idea I was a restaurant critic.
You know, I was just there with a rotating cast of friends.
Speaker 12 I told my friends to keep ordering because we needed to justify our existence.
Speaker 4 And I hope
Speaker 2 you sat there from 8 to 8, but you had friends come for like a couple hour shifts. Is that the deal?
Speaker 12 Yeah, exactly. I had a spreadsheet, so I had like friends come from 8 to 11.
Speaker 2 Who drew the 2 o'clock in the morning shift? That's what I want to know. Is that like the lowest friend on your totem pole?
Speaker 12 No, I want to shout out my friend Jay, who stayed from 8 p.m. to 8 a.m.
Speaker 4 He never left.
Speaker 2 Did you eat? What'd you eat?
Speaker 12 Gosh, I feel like we covered a good chunk of the menu.
Speaker 12 We had Caesar salad, we had shrimp cocktail, we had the passion fruit pie, which is my favorite thing on the menu, and lots of chocolate mint shakes.
Speaker 2 You are a trained restaurant critic. What'd you think?
Speaker 12 I thought the food was really good. I feel like it was certainly better than a lot of diner food, but it was kind of, it wasn't too fancy.
Speaker 12
And I almost feel like at a diner, the food doesn't need to be anything fancy or super special. It just needs to satisfy and nourish.
And I think the food at Kellogg does just that.
Speaker 2
Right, right. Diners are not necessarily about the food.
Priya Krishna at the New York Times. Priya, thanks a lot.
I appreciate it.
Speaker 12 Yeah, thank you.
Speaker 2 Coming up.
Speaker 4 We like the big open space. We have giant windows that are Arctic grade.
Speaker 2
23 degrees was the high in Fairbanks, Alaska today. First, though, let's do the numbers.
Dow Industrial is up 408 points today, 9 tenths of 1%, 44,565 for the blue chips.
Speaker 2 The NASDAQ added 44 points, two tenths percent, twenty thousand and fifty-three. The SP 500 gained 32 points, about a half percent, 61.18.
Speaker 2 Strong demand for holiday and corporate travel helped Alaska Air beat its fourth quarter profit estimates and predict a smaller than expected loss for this quarter.
Speaker 2 Shares climbed just under two and two tenths percent today.
Speaker 2 American Airlines, on the other hand, said its profits for 2025 are not going to meet expectations thanks to the higher prices for jet fuel and a sales strategy that seems to have driven away corporate travelers shares down eight and three quarters of one percent today bond prices were down as well the yield on the 10-year tinot thus rose
Speaker 2 4.64 percent for the 10-year you're listening to marketplace
Speaker 16 Now's the time to start your next adventure behind the wheel of an exciting new Toyota hybrid.
Speaker 16 With the largest lineup of hybrid, plug-in hybrid, and electrified vehicles to choose from, Toyota has the one for you.
Speaker 16 Every new Toyota hybrid hybrid comes with Toyota Care two-year complementary scheduled maintenance, an exclusive hybrid battery warranty, and Toyota's legendary quality and reliability.
Speaker 4 Visit your local Toyota dealer today.
Speaker 16 Toyota, let's go places. See your local Toyota dealer for hybrid battery warranty details.
Speaker 15 Is it time to reimagine your future? The right business skills may make a difference in your career.
Speaker 15 At Capella University, we offer a relevant education that's designed to focus on what you need to know in the business world.
Speaker 15 We'll teach professional skills to help you pursue your goals, like business management, strategic planning, and effective communication. And you can apply these skills right away.
Speaker 15 A different future is closer than you think with Capella University.
Speaker 4 Learn more at capella.edu.
Speaker 17 You've finally broken loose from work. Three friends, one tea time,
Speaker 17 and then the text. Honey, there's water in the basement.
Speaker 17
Not exactly how you pictured your Saturday. That's when you call us, Cincinnati Insurance.
We always answer the call because real protection means showing up, even when things are in the rough.
Speaker 17 Cincinnati Insurance. Let us make your bad day better.
Speaker 17 Find an agent at CINFIN.com.
Speaker 19 Here for the Lowe's early Black Friday deals? You're right on time for some of our biggest savings.
Speaker 19 We're talking up to 50% off select major appliances, plus up to an extra 25% off when you bundle select major appliances holiday lights going up soon select ladders are up to 50 off right now get black friday prices without the black friday crowds lows we help you save valid through 1119 selection varies by location select locations only while supplies last see lowe's.com for more details
Speaker 2 this is marketplace i'm kai rizdahl february 2020 going on five years ago now was the last gasp of full-month data that we had for the pre-pandemic economy and things were going pretty well.
Speaker 2 The labor market was on a roll, adding jobs at a healthy clip. Unemployment was at 3.5%.
Speaker 2 By April of 2020, of course, the pandemic in full swing. 22 million jobs had disappeared, and unemployment peaked that month just shy of 15%.
Speaker 2 And it seemed, at least for a bit there, if we're being honest, that things might never get back to normal in this labor market. But they did.
Speaker 2 As you know, we're now well ahead job-wise of where we were in the before times.
Speaker 2 But it's not like nothing's changed. Here's Marketplace's Mitchell Harmon.
Speaker 5 There are now about 7 million more jobs in the U.S. economy than in February 2020.
Speaker 5 But there'd be 11 million more if we'd kept adding jobs at the same pace as we did in the five years before the pandemic. So we've fallen behind the pre-pandemic trend, right?
Speaker 5 Not exactly, says Harvard economist Jason Fuhrman.
Speaker 20 Right now, we have 3.5 million more jobs than the Congressional Budget Office had been expecting for this point in time prior to COVID.
Speaker 5 Here's how the math works. In the five years before the pandemic, unemployment fell from 5.5% to 3.5%.
Speaker 5 But no one expected the economy to keep adding jobs at the same rip-roaring pace over the next five years, which would have meant unemployment falling to like 1.5%,
Speaker 5 which economists will tell you pretty much can't happen. What did happen despite the pandemic is job creation surged ahead of expectations.
Speaker 20 One big reason, says Fuhrman, there's been a huge flow of immigrants into the country.
Speaker 5 Filling open jobs, generating new ones. The pandemic also brought big changes in how we work, says Jane Oates at Working Nation.
Speaker 21 Since COVID, we've seen fully remote, hybrid, and everything in between, except some of the mandatory frontline work, construction, manufacturing.
Speaker 5 About one in four employees were working from home or a remote location sometime in December, including this guy.
Speaker 22
My name is Jer Doyle. I am the country manager in the U.S.
for Manpower Group.
Speaker 5 Doyle started working at the Global Staffing and Recruitment Agency in 2020.
Speaker 22 I lived and breathed the whole roller coaster that we've had. I interviewed remotely, onboarded remotely, based here in Florida, even though HQ is in Milwaukee.
Speaker 5 Doyle sees employees continuing to demand more flexibility in where and and what hours they work.
Speaker 5 There was a downside to remote work early on, especially for working mothers, says Jasmine Tucker at the National Women's Law Center. She had a one-and-a-half-year-old at home when the pandemic hit.
Speaker 12 It felt so long ago five years ago, but when we were all here with little kids, virtual learning with bigger kids, it was a really stressful time.
Speaker 5 She says five years later, it still is.
Speaker 12
We only just saw in 2024 the child care sector recover the jobs that it had lost. Look at population growth.
There's no way pre-pandemic child care workforce levels are going to be meeting the demand.
Speaker 5 The pandemic also shook up the labor market, untethering people from their previous jobs and careers. Job quitting and salary offers initially surged as employers scrambled to staff up again.
Speaker 5 Five years on, the job churn has calmed way down, says Jane Oates at Working Nation.
Speaker 21
People are not quitting. They seem very content in their jobs or nervous to leave.
And employers are not laying off.
Speaker 5 Because they still face a skills shortage, says Jared Doyle. And to retain employees, they're trying to prevent worker burnout.
Speaker 22 Mental health support, work-life balance, workplace inclusivity has been huge.
Speaker 5 Five years after the pandemic disrupted pretty much everything, University of Michigan economist Betsy Stevenson takes a broad view of where we are now.
Speaker 8 It actually gives me a lot of hope for the future.
Speaker 9 The American labor market has always been very well suited
Speaker 9 to having people reinvent themselves, upskill, reskill, change skills, find a new path, and become more productive. We ended up with the most dynamic labor market among developed countries.
Speaker 9 We've seen real wage growth, GDP growth, high labor force participation.
Speaker 5 The kind of economic dynamism that Stevenson says characterized the U.S.
Speaker 5 back in the 20th century, but hadn't been much in evidence in the 21st until the pandemic came along and shocked us into reinventing our economy. I'm Mitchell Hartman for Marketplace.
Speaker 2
It'll cost you on average $1,965 a month for the typical rental in this economy right now. That's across the entire pool of rental units nationwide.
So, of course, your mileage may vary.
Speaker 2 Point is, though, that that's up a relatively reasonable 3.4% over the past year, so says a report out this week from Zillow.
Speaker 2 And while rents are rising in most parts of the country, a couple of three cities are bucking that trend and offering some economic insights, as Daniel Ackerman explains.
Speaker 24 Denver, San Antonio, and Austin were the only metro areas where rents fell last year. What's so special about those places?
Speaker 23 In some sense, there's nothing special about them.
Speaker 24 Aniban Vasu is CEO of Sage Policy Group. He says in recent years, a number of cities in the South and West saw huge growth along with rising housing costs.
Speaker 24 Vasu says apartment builders saw the demand and got to work.
Speaker 23 But even in a good market, the market can become saturated. There can be overbuilding.
Speaker 23 And so when all of that capital flew into those markets to develop new properties, all of a sudden there weren't enough tenants.
Speaker 24 Across the country, rents are still rising, but at a slower rate than before the pandemic.
Speaker 24 Denver, San Antonio, and Austin just happen to be the cities where rent growth has gone negative, says Igor Popoff, chief economist at Apartment List.
Speaker 25 Rents are not falling in those places because they're becoming less popular.
Speaker 24 Popoff says people moving there now have more options, including a bunch of shiny new apartment buildings.
Speaker 25 The projects that started back in the really high rental demand, low interest rate environment of a couple years ago, those are finally hitting the market now.
Speaker 25 And it's a very different market than when they broke ground.
Speaker 24
For one thing, it's more competitive for landlords. Emily Blair is executive vice president at the Austin Apartment Association.
She says some owners are offering concessions.
Speaker 26 Maybe a floor plan upgrade or a couple of months free.
Speaker 26 So when you see a lot more supply, it does increase renters' ability to have more choices in housing and increases their affordability options as well.
Speaker 24 And with more new units set to come online this year, Blair expects the concessions to continue. I'm Daniel Ackerman for Marketplace.
Speaker 2 I think we mentioned last week that housing starts were up at the end of last year, more ground being broken for more new homes. That's kind of interesting because the cost to build is way up.
Speaker 2 Construction materials will set you back 40% or more now than they did in 2020, and the average rate on a 30-year mortgage is still around 7%.
Speaker 2 Of course, you could just build yourself to keep costs down. Here's today's installment of our series, Adventures in Housing.
Speaker 4
My name is Justine Schmidt, and I live in Fairbanks, Alaska. I've lived here about six years.
It's a lovely, cold place.
Speaker 4 Me and my partner, Josh,
Speaker 4 saw this property up for sale on a bike ride once, and we were like, you know, that's a great spot. It's at the end of a dead-end road.
Speaker 4 It like goes right up against against state land that there's a bunch of trails on.
Speaker 4 It was pandemic time, so we had a bunch of you know pent-up energy and had saved some money, you know. So we were like, this is a great idea.
Speaker 16 We
Speaker 4 built and designed and did the whole thing from the ground up, starting with cutting down all the trees
Speaker 4 and stacking all the firewood that we're still using.
Speaker 4 We started in 2021
Speaker 4 and we moved in last fall.
Speaker 4 So there's a fun thing about living in Alaska, especially we're outside of like the town of Fairbanks, right? There's very little regulation.
Speaker 4 So there's a lot of people kind of like us who have almost no experience in construction and are like, you know what, I can do this.
Speaker 4
And that means a couple things. One, that you can kind of build what you want, which is really cool.
And then the second thing is there's a lot of houses that end up for sale that are really weird.
Speaker 4 We built basically a large box. We have no like indoor walls and like doors,
Speaker 4
which we're fine with because it's just the two of us. We like the big open space.
We have giant windows that are Arctic grade
Speaker 4 and the walls are super thick.
Speaker 4 A little less than $200,000 is how much this house costs us to build, which,
Speaker 4 you know, housing prices are different all over the place, but we definitely could not have gotten this house on the market for that much money.
Speaker 4 You know, I think a lot of people would come into this house and it is not like a normal house, right? It's all open,
Speaker 4 but it is like exactly what we wanted.
Speaker 4 I think we both feel very like connected to our house, like it's a little baby that we had, you know.
Speaker 4 It's our child.
Speaker 2
Justine Schmidt, just outside Fairbanks, Alaska. Tell us about your adventure in housing.
Would you do it yourself, giant big box, or professionally built with all the bells and whistles?
Speaker 2 We want to know. You can reach us at marketplace.org.
Speaker 2 This final note on the way out today, consider it a public service announcement for those of you who use public computers from time to time.
Speaker 2 Starting next month, Microsoft says it's automatically going to keep you logged into your account unless you sign out. You can see how this could go wrong, right?
Speaker 2
Log out, people. Just log out.
Get used to doing it. Computer hygiene.
It matters.
Speaker 2 John Buckley, John Gordon, Noya Carr, Diantha Parker, Amanda Peacher, and Stephanie Seek are the marketplace editing staff. Amir Babawe is the managing editor and I'm Kai Rizdahl.
Speaker 2 We will see you tomorrow, everybody.
Speaker 2 This is Apm.
Speaker 17 You've finally broken loose from work.
Speaker 4 Three friends, one tea time,
Speaker 17 and then the text. Honey, there's water in the basement.
Speaker 17
Not exactly how you pictured your Saturday. That's when you call us, Cincinnati Insurance.
We always answer the call because real protection means showing up, even when things are in the rough.
Speaker 17 Cincinnati Insurance, let us make your bad day better.
Speaker 17 Find an agent at CINFIN.com.