43. Arne Duncan Says All Kids Deserve a Chance — and Criminals Deserve a Second One

It's Stock Up September at Whole Foods Market.

Find sales on supplements to power up for busy weeks.

Plus, pack your pantry with pasta, sauce, and more everyday essentials.

Enjoy quick breakfasts for less with 365 by Whole Foods Market seasonal coffee and oatmeal.

Grab ready-to-heat meals that are perfect for the office and save on versatile no antibiotics ever chicken breasts.

Stock up now at Whole Foods Market, in-store and online.

Are you ready to get spicy?

These Doritos Golden Sriracha aren't that spicy.

Sriracha sounds pretty spicy to me.

Um, a little spicy, but also tangy and sweet.

Maybe it's time to turn up the heat.

Or turn it down.

It's time for something that's not too spicy.

Try Dorito's Golden Sriracha.

Spicy.

But not too spicy.

My guest today, Arne Duncan, has played professional basketball, ran the Chicago public schools for over seven years, and was the U.S.

Secretary of Education under Barack Obama.

I suspect you'll be surprised to hear, though, where you'll find him these days.

He's on the streets of Chicago running an organization called Cred that's giving young men who everyone else has given up on the chance to build meaningful lives.

Welcome to People I Mostly Admire with Steve Levitt.

I've known Arnie and admired him for 20 years now.

We first met under difficult circumstances when I discovered there was widespread teacher cheating in the Chicago public schools where Arnie was in charge.

More recently, the last three years, totally by chance, Arnie's been my next-door neighbor.

So compared to my typical interview, I have a much better sense where things might head.

But I do think Arnie is in for some surprises because I have a couple stories about him that I've never told before, and I can't wait to hear his reactions.

So you were Secretary of Education under Barack Obama, and after you left that job, you wrote a memoir entitled How Schools Work.

And the first line of that book is,

Education runs on lies.

And I cannot imagine a Secretary of Education other than you ever saying something like that publicly.

What did you mean by that?

Well, I always try and listen to what people say, Steve, but I always watch what they do.

And when there's a disconnect between what I hear and what I see, what I witness, that's disconcerting.

We all say we value education, but if you look at where we are in the United States relative to other nations, I always break it down, early childhood, K to 12, higher education.

We're top 10 in nothing.

So as much as we would say we value education and care about it, we don't invest, we don't innovate, we don't hold ourselves accountable.

A second example related, obviously, is that we all would say we care about teachers.

If you survey the American public, 99% of us would say teachers are really important, but we don't value them as professionals.

We don't train them as professionals.

We don't compensate them as professionals.

And it's not fair either to our teachers or to our students.

And then the third one, which is a tougher one, is that everybody, everybody would say that we value our children, but we tolerate a level of gun deaths in our country that simply doesn't happen in other nations.

And I hate to say this, it breaks my heart, but I truly believe we value our guns here in the United States more than we value our children.

And there's just a loss of life and a level of living with fear and trauma that our children here in Chicago and the South and West Sides, but unfortunately around the country, live with, that simply doesn't happen to children in other nations.

So I know you had a really unique upbringing because your mom, Sue, ran an after-school program here in Chicago called the Sue Duncan Children's Center.

Could you just talk a little bit about how you spent your afternoons as a consequence of her job when you were growing up as a kid?

Yeah, so we grew up about two blocks from where you and I live now, so I haven't escaped too far and very intentionally stayed in the neighborhood.

My dad was a professor at the University of Chicago for about 40 years in psychology.

And my mother ran an after-school program.

And she started in 1961, literally like 12 blocks from our house at 46 in Greenwood and in those days 47th Street was the invisible barrier between middle class integrated and all black all poor so her program was like just a block on the other side of that I had my friends during the school day at lab school then I had my after-school friends and just seeing the inequities in opportunity that my friends in the afternoon were as smart as talented as hardworking as resilient as my friends during the school day but just wildly fewer set of opportunities, whether it's educationally, whether in terms of safety, whatever it might be.

And just the fundamental unfairness.

People talk about different zip codes.

It's basically the same zip code.

It's a mile and a half, but just a different world.

And that's been the driving force in my life is trying to create opportunities, whether it's here or in Appalachia on Native American reservations, wherever it might be, just trying to take opportunity to where the talent is.

And I always say talent is evenly distributed, opportunity is not.

And that's what she devoted her life to.

And my sister, brother, and I have all tried to follow in her footsteps in various ways.

You can't unsee or can't unfeel something that's such a critical part of you for all your years until you went away to college.

So I know your mom's program, that neighborhood's all African-American, and you and your brother and your sister were the three white kids there.

I'm just curious, what did the kids in her program think of you?

You're this rail, thin, six-foot-five white kid who's better than them at basketball.

What do they make of you?

Well,

I was a late bloomer, so I was 5'3 as a freshman in high school.

She had everyone work in age group cohorts.

And I was part of a group where I was the youngest and the smallest and by far the worst basketball player.

But growing up, having to learn how to compete, trying to learn to be a good teammate, real competitive games.

If you lost, you had to sit out for a long time, so you had to find ways to win.

When I finally grew and got a little bigger, that was helpful.

But I think my identity was very much formed formed when I was small and slow and strawny and trying to just have to be as scrappy as you could to compete and to win and to stay in the court.

Now, you were an academic all-American basketball player at Harvard and you graduated magna cum laude, which is not easy to do.

You played professional basketball in Australia for a handful of years.

And then you came back to Chicago in 1992 in your late 20s and you began working with the Ariel Foundation on the I Have a Dream program.

I think people know that program pretty well that takes a seventh grade class and tries to do whatever it can to have that class succeed and then pay for their college.

So tell me about your time in that program.

I'll just give you a little background on it.

I had played for four years there in Australia and I loved it.

You make good money.

It's a great living.

It's a very seductive lifestyle.

I met my wife, Karen, there.

But all those opportunities I've had, I just felt I owed the city so much.

And so I was looking for an opportunity to come home.

And John Rogers, who runs Aerial Capital and been my best friend and mentor since I was about 10 years old, he was starting to be successful in his money management business.

And rather than buying a second house or a fancy car or a boat or whatever, he wanted to set up a foundation and give back to the community.

And he just knew of our family's involvement in the neighborhoods.

And so he hired my sister and I, Sarah, to come back and set up the I Have a Dream program.

Had he not given me that opportunity, I think it's extraordinarily likely that I would still be living in Australia.

And all this stuff is very personal.

My mother had done an amazing job of getting her young people through high school, but we really struggled on the college front.

And she had many students going to college, but there were many others who just didn't work financially.

And she had a shoestring budget.

She was a volunteer.

The budget for many years and years was like under $5,000 a year was all volunteer run and led.

And just seeing my friends struggle financially and have to drop out of school and not even go, that was extraordinarily painful to watch.

And so there were a couple parts of the iDream program that were appealing to me.

One of John committing to help fund the college tuition of students who could make it that far.

That was just something that would have been amazing for my mother's work all those years where we just didn't have that opportunity.

And the second thing was just the equality of opportunity that we took all 40 children in that class of sixth graders.

And there are many programs that take the top 5%, the top 10%.

I love those programs.

Those are really important.

That just wasn't what my focus was.

What we really wanted to do was prove the children, regardless of where they were.

Many of our students started going into the seventh grade or reading at the third or fourth grade level.

We just wanted to prove what was possible with opportunity and hard work.

And the class ahead of ours, so the class that was in seventh grade when we started in sixth grade, they ended up having a 66 percent dropout rate from high school.

And our class, one year younger, had a 91 percent graduation rate from high school.

So same neighborhood, same school, same building, same socioeconomic challenges, same poverty, same violence, just a very different opportunity.

So those were six extraordinary years, just trying to demonstrate, again, what's possible when opportunity meets talent.

So it's an interesting program because it takes kids who are relatively old.

So it's not starting with super young kids.

And it's small scale and really intensive.

I know the extent to which you and your sister and others would essentially put your life on hold for these 40 kids for six years.

Do you think it's a good use of resources?

It's an unusual model, and we learn a lot from unusual models.

And do you think of it as an answer to a question or more like a demonstration project to show you what's possible in another world?

Yeah, obviously it's always much better to start earlier and to start at kindergarten, start at pre-K, start at birth.

The earlier the intervention, the better it is.

There's never one model that's perfect or not.

And as you said, that one by definition is smaller.

You know, it's hard to scale for a city.

We really tried to extend it as we got working not just with those students, but with their younger brothers and sisters and family members and neighbors.

We had a situation where one of our girls who actually started in a really good spot, she was a high performer, but unfortunately both her parents got caught in the crack epidemic.

And halfway through our first year, she basically lost her parents.

And she was taken in by a neighbor.

So, of course, we took the neighbor's children and worked with them.

And we would pick up all the kids after school.

They'd be with us till six, seven, eight o'clock at night, but obviously going home every night.

So we spent lots of times doing home visits and trying to stabilize home situations.

And we had some fantastic families.

And we had families where there was unfortunately a tremendous amount of domestic violence and abuse and some very tough things going on.

One of our children lived in Robert Taylor homes, and her brother saw a murder and had to go to a witness protection program.

So the work evolved over time.

So then you joined the Chicago Public Schools as the deputy chief of staff to Paul Ballas, who ran the Chicago Public Schools.

So let me tell you a story that I'm pretty sure I've never told you before.

So it's April or May of 2001, and you've been working at CPS for a couple of years by now.

And I got a call from the mayor of Chicago, Mayor Daly, and his people said he'd like to speak with me.

And I said, okay.

And this is years before freakinomics.

I was just some unknown professor.

Like the mayor had never called me.

So I show up at the assigned time his office.

And it's he and I alone in the office, no other aides, no hint what's going on.

He just chats with me about education for at least an hour.

And I'm just answering questions, completely confused.

The only guess I even have is that he's interviewing me to put me on the Chicago school board because I just couldn't make any sense of what was going on otherwise.

And then finally, it's coming to the end of the conversation and he says to me, what do you think of Paul Vallis, who is your boss at Chicago Public Schools?

And I said, I don't know him personally, but he seems pretty good.

And he shakes his head and he says, no.

And he points to the fish tank and he says, he's in the tank.

And I had no idea what he was talking about.

Like, didn't know what he meant.

I said, he's in the tank.

And he said, yeah, Paul Vallas is in the tank.

He's in the tank.

I don't know what to say.

I'm just nodding knowingly as if I know something about what he's talking about.

And finally, he says, so what do you think of Arne Duncan?

And I said, I don't really know Arnie Duncan, but I've literally never heard anyone say a bad word about him.

And the mayor says, I like Arnie Duncan.

I like Arne Duncan.

And then he shows me to the door.

So I leave the office and I go back to campus and I meet up with my co-author, Brian Jacob, who was an expert on the Chicago Public Schools.

And I said to him, I'm going to make two really crazy predictions.

The first one is that I'm going to be named to the Chicago School Board shortly.

And the second one is that Paul Vallis is going to get fired and Arnie Duncan is going to take over as the head of the Chicago Public Schools.

And he laughs out loud and he says, the first one is crazy.

but at least within the realm of plausibility.

But there's no way in the world that Arne Arne Duncan could ever be named the next head of the Chicago Public Schools.

And two months later, Paul Vallas got fired and you were named the head of the Chicago Public Schools.

Does that fit with your account of what happened?

That's a crazy story.

You've never told me that.

You've been holding out all these years.

That's more than 20 years ago at this point.

I learned a tremendous amount from Paul.

And to be clear, Paul wasn't fired.

Paul actually ran for governor.

So he ended up resigning to run for governor.

You said that means it was in April.

I think it was in July.

So it was just a couple months after that that the mayor mayor appointed me.

And he took a lot of risks.

I was 36 at that point.

A lot of people probably questioned his sanity, and he probably questioned his own sanity more than once.

Those meetings in his office could be intimidating, as you knew.

And there were a few times.

I went home and told my wife, I might get fired tomorrow.

And she's like, okay, we'll figure it out.

But I came into Chicago Public Schools in 1998.

So we worked with those dreamers in the I have a dream program from 92 to 98, sixth grade through 12th grade.

And during that time, we actually started our own small public school, Aerial Community Academy, in the neighborhood.

That was going to serve 400, but the Chicago public schools had 400,000.

And there's something about the math of that and the scale that made me challenge myself and think it's easy to do smaller scale projects on the outside.

It's easy to throw stones and critique.

It's a very different thing to go into the system.

So when our kids graduated and went to college, we thought about starting another I have a dream program.

We thought about starting another public school.

But I said, let me try and go in and see whether I can have impact.

So how scared were you going from one school, 400 kids to 400,000 kids?

I mean, were you petrified?

I wasn't petrified.

I had two and a half years of an apprenticeship, traveling across the city with Paul, visiting lots and lots of schools, meeting with staff, and I had a real good sense of who was really committed within CPS to making a difference in kids' lives and challenging the status quo and who was maybe a little bit more comfortable or complacent or whatever.

So you're never fully prepared for anything like that.

But I definitely felt that I had seen enough and knew enough folks and had a good enough sense for our schools to do it.

And there are definitely some strategies and tactics that are applicable everywhere.

But for me, just growing up in Chicago, growing up playing basketball all over the south and west sides, knowing so many of the communities and families, I'm a big relationship guy.

Relationships are just critical to me.

And I just felt that was a huge advantage.

I never could have done what I did in another city.

I just felt I totally had had home court advantage working here in Chicago.

Honestly, just being so passionate about the city and the families and the communities, that gave me a lot of comfort walking into a job like that.

So that's when I got to know you.

I reached out to you more or less out of the blue, putting you into a terrible situation because I had been working on the academic project looking at cheating in the Chicago public schools, and I had found some pretty compelling statistical evidence that maybe 5% of all the teachers in the Chicago public schools were cheating on standardized tests, on the high-stake standardized test by changing student answers.

And I felt really bad for you because I was creating this public relations nightmare because here you are taking over the schools, and one of the first headlines that's going to come out is that it's rampant with cheating.

So I just went to you not expecting anything, but trying to give you the heads up so you wouldn't be totally caught off guard.

And I showed you the data, the evidence, and I would say your reaction to that conversation surprised me about as much as any reaction I've ever gotten in any meeting I've ever held.

Do you remember what you said when I showed you all that data?

I don't remember exactly what I said, but it's just interesting or different perspectives.

Like you can say you put me in a terrible situation.

I actually thought you were a godsend.

I knew that there was some cheating.

And again, 5% is too much and it is a lot, but that meant 90, 95% of people were doing things the right way.

And the big thing, Steve, that I wanted to do was I had to create credibility.

I had to create trust and I wanted to hold myself accountable for results, but I wanted people to believe them.

And I honestly had a lot of confidence that we could get better as a system.

But because of Chicago Public Schools' history of cheating and scandal, I think there wasn't a lot of faith from the public.

And you came to me very early on.

I think it was in that first year.

And what it did for me is that you had this extraordinary capability and insight that we did not have within CPS.

So if we could set a baseline that we would not tolerate cheating, that we were going to do things the right way and hold ourselves accountable for results, then that would create a much higher level of credibility and integrity in the community.

So yeah, we had to deal with some tough issues for a short amount of time, but I wanted people to understand that we were going to do things the right way for the right reasons.

And you actually gave me just an extraordinary opportunity, again, not to talk about that, but to actually try and live that and demonstrate those values.

I think that you don't realize that your reaction was not the typical reaction of people in this situation, people who would be defensive and try and cover up.

But what really struck me about what you said, the first one was, this hurts the kids.

And I won't let anybody hurt my kids.

I think that might be an exact quote.

And the second thing you said was, you just tell me what you need me to do and I'll do it.

And I said, how would you feel if I took a bunch of resources and we retested classrooms?

And you said, sure, how many do you need?

I named some number.

And I said, and I'd also like not just to retest the classrooms I think are cheating, but I'd like to be able to retest a whole bunch of other classrooms that weren't.

You're like, okay, good.

That sounds great.

And in the end, we managed to bring down a bunch of cheaters and get them out of the classroom, especially cheaters who were not good teachers at all on top of that, and get the cheating way down.

So really, from my perspective, it was.

an amazing success.

The other thing you did that I thought was so simple and brilliant, which is you just held a press conference and you said something like, so there's this egghead professor at the University of Chicago and he's got some algorithm I don't really understand and he thinks there's cheating and I'm not going to let there be cheating in the Chicago public schools.

And so I put my foot down today and I'm going to cooperate with him fully and we're going to get rid of the cheaters.

And then

the reporters called up parents and said, what do you think of cheating in Chicago public schools?

And they say, we don't want cheating in the schools.

And then they called up the teachers union.

And the teachers union even said, we don't want cheating in the schools.

So instead of the headline being Chicago schools overrun with cheating, the headline is Arne Duncan puts his foot down against cheating.

And it was a huge win.

I don't think of you as being very political, but somehow I think your own authenticity actually backs its way into being better than even the most strategic politician could ever be.

I guess I don't think politically.

Sometimes it serves me well.

Sometimes that really hurts me.

But I just think in life, the truth will set you free.

And your point, when folks cheated, what they basically did is take children who were below grade level and said they were above grade level.

When that happens and they get denied services they need like summer school to actually help them catch up.

So I think that's one of the most insidious things we can do is to lie to kids and families and say they're on track to be successful and they're not.

You're ultimately setting them up for tremendous failure and heartbreak when they graduate from high school and aren't ready to be successful in college and don't have those skills.

And yes, it's maybe a little painful short term.

And we had to let some teachers go.

It was interesting, Steve.

Almost nobody contested.

We thought they would have some lawsuits.

Basically, teachers just resigned.

Your evidence, for better or worse, was overwhelming.

I'm sure we didn't fire every teacher that cheated, but it was enough to send a message and to try and bring that down going forward.

You're listening to People I Mostly Admire with Steve Levitt and his conversation with former Secretary of Education, Arnie Duncan.

After this break, they'll return to talk about Arnie's latest work aimed at reducing gun violence in Chicago.

I'm Dr.

Sarah Rahal, the founder and CEO of Armra.

I developed Armor Colostrum because I know your body was designed to thrive.

It's your natural state, your birthright, and you can reclaim it.

Colostrum is the first nutrition we receive in life with every essential nutrient our bodies need.

It's nature's original blueprint for health.

After a devastating health crisis almost took my life, I made it my mission to harness this power.

Using proprietary technology, Armour captures over 400 bioactive nutrients in every scoop, delivering over 1,000 benefits that transform your health at its foundation.

Whether for gut health, metabolism, skin, hair, immunity, mood, energy, fitness, or recovery, I invite you to join this collective revival of health and discover radical transformation for yourself.

Visit armor.com, that's A-R-M-R-A.com, and enter code CULTURE30 for 30% off your first subscription order.

The statement has not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration.

This product is not intended to diagnose, treat care, or prevent any disease.

I choose to work where everyone can see how busy I am.

I choose pedal power.

I choose the freshest of beats.

I choose to never burrito and drive.

Whatever you choose, choose transit and do your part to spare the air.

These days you've got two choices, buying a new car or making the one you've got run like new.

That's why we have thousands of ASE certified technicians to help you get more out of your car.

Firestone Complete Auto Care.

Book now at FirestoneAuto.com

People I Mostly Admire is sponsored by Mint Mobile.

From new shoes to new supplies, the back-to-school season comes with a lot of expenses.

Your wireless bill shouldn't be one of them.

Ditch overpriced wireless and switch to Mint Mobile, where you can get the coverage and speed you're used to, but for way less money.

For a limited time, time, Mint Mobile is offering three months of unlimited premium wireless service for $15 a month.

Because this school year, your budget deserves a break.

Get this new customer offer and your three-month unlimited wireless plan for just $15 a month at mintmobile.com slash admire.

That's mintmobile.com slash admire.

Upfront payment of $45 required, equivalent to $15 a month.

Limited time, new customer offer for first three months only.

Speeds may slow above 35 gigabytes on unlimited plan.

Taxes and fees extra?

See Mint Mobile for details.

Department of Rejected Dreams, if you had a dream rejected, IKEA can make it possible.

So I always dreamed of having a man cave, but the wife doesn't like it.

What if I called it a woman cave?

Okay, so let's not do that, but add some relaxing lighting and a comfy IKEA Hofberg Ottoman, and now it's a cozy retreat.

Nice, a cozy retreat.

Man, cozy retreat.

Sir, okay.

Find your big dreams, small dreams, and cozy retreat dreams in store online at IKEA.us.

Dream the possibilities.

Hey, Morgan, what do you have for me today?

Hey, Steve.

So, Julia H wrote in to tell us that after listening to your interview with Sendel Molinaten, she resigned from her job.

She'd been afraid of change for six years, but your conversation actually inspired her to take the plunge.

How does it feel to know that the things you say might inspire people to make bold decisions that could affect the course of their lives?

So in this case, it feels great because that's exactly why I started this podcast is because I felt like the research I was doing and the ideas I was seeing around me were having no impact on people.

And in this particular case, I am about 99.8%

sure that making a change is almost always the right thing to do when you're on the fence.

So I feel great when people make those kind of changes.

Now, I also just say stuff off the top of my head that I haven't thought about very hard and that's probably wrong.

I would be a little nervous if people jumped too quickly at those kind of ideas.

I agree.

I mean, you do give great advice a lot of the time, but I also think you're a little flippant sometimes with the things you say.

So I worry about our audience.

I don't think our problem is the audience following too much of my advice.

That's never been my problem in life is that people listen to me too much.

But on the other hand, sure, some of the things I say are a little bit crazy, but I think everybody needs a little bit more crazy injected into their life.

And if you're listening to this podcast, it's probably because you want things a little different.

So I'm definitely not going to stop saying crazy things, no matter how much you try to get me to do it.

On a whole, I agree with you.

I think change is a good thing.

Thanks, Julia H, for writing in.

Good luck with the new job.

If you have questions for us, please write in.

The address is pima at freakonomics.com.

That's p-i-m-a at freakonomics.com.

And Steve and I both read every question.

And Julia, if things go badly, I'll take all the blame.

In case you're wondering, I never did get nominated for the Chicago School Board.

Unlike Arnie, I think I failed my interview with the mayor.

In the second half of our discussion, I have a couple last things I want to discuss regarding education, but what I most want to talk about is his new organization.

It's called Create Real Economic Destiny, or CRED for short.

He co-founded it with Laureen Paul Jobs.

It's tough work with tough young men, and Arnie is right in the middle of it.

So the next thing you're 44 years old and you become Secretary of Education.

Fun job or not a fun job?

I loved it.

But honestly, Steve, I probably wouldn't have gone for anybody else but President Obama.

I had led the Chicago public schools for seven and a half years.

There's tremendous turnover in those jobs.

They average 10 years, about two, two and a half years.

And it was sort of crazy.

When I started running CPS, I was, by definition, the rookie.

And by the time I left, I was the longest serving big city.

public school superintendent in the country.

And so I wanted to do at least 10 years, but it's clearly a once-in-a-lifetime situation when someone who's a good friend and more importantly, someone who I've done a lot of education work with when President Obama was in the Illinois legislature and then became our senator, I knew his heart for education.

I knew his commitment.

I'd grown up playing basketball with Michelle Obama's older brother, Craig.

He was a good friend and super amazing family.

But neither one of their parents had gone to college.

They were both first-generation college goers.

And I knew what he was willing to do to fight for kids.

So I had no aspiration to be Secretary of Education.

Had President Obama said come to the White House and help take out the garbage for me, I would have done that quite happily.

So obviously, Arnie, both in the Chicago public schools and as Secretary of Education, you operated under enormous constraints, whether it's teacher unions or politics or the fact that schools have more or less been run the same way for 100 years.

But I wonder if you've thought at all, if we really just threw everything out and we started completely from scratch, You and me were given free rein to redesign everything in the American schools from the bottom up.

What would be your most radical changes?

What would you just like completely overhaul?

There's so many things you'd like to do, but just a couple that aren't impossible.

And frankly, I always say this stuff is really much more a matter of political will and courage.

This is not.

putting a man on Mars.

This is not finding a cure for cancer.

It's just do we really value the lives and the academic and social potential of all of our kids?

So a couple things.

One, I would have universal access to pre-K.

I'd make sure our babies have a chance to enter kindergarten ready to be successful academically, socially, emotionally.

Obviously, access to technology and the pandemic brought this home.

Devices, broadband, Wi-Fi, children should be able to learn anything they want, anytime, anywhere, 24-7.

Learning should not be confined to a physical school building.

And we got to make that as ubiquitous in our country as access to water or electricity.

Thinking very differently about teacher talent, and we all know great teachers, great principals make an extraordinary difference in kids' lives.

If we systematically, Steve, identified our hardest working, our most successful teachers and principals and placed them in our most underserved communities, if we had the courage to do that and the will to do that, the difference that would make in the lives of our students would be extraordinary.

And then the final thing is just really giving every child what they need.

And it's not a radical concept.

So here in Chicago, we served tens of thousands of children three meals a day.

And we had a couple thousand children who we very discreetly sent home with backpacks full of food on Fridays because we worried about them not eating over the weekend.

What's been constant education is time and the variable has been learning.

And I just want to flip that construct on its head.

I want the constant to be learning and the variable to be time.

So some students might need school six hours a day.

Some students might need school eight or 10 or 12 hours a day, Saturdays, Sundays, weekends, 11, 12 months out of the year.

It's funny, when I went away to college, I met a bunch of students who had gone to boarding schools out east.

I really didn't know what boarding schools were, but I always say what works well in our country for the wealthy probably works pretty well for the poor.

And one thing I wasn't able to do here in Chicago that I thought a lot about was trying to start some boarding schools for children where home might not be the safest place for them to be.

And so just giving to every student what they need, the goal is not equal.

That's actually the problem.

The goal is equity.

And whether it's more meals, whether it's eyeglasses, whether it's more time, whether it's the best teachers, whether it's access to extracurriculars, if we could meet every child where they are and help them grow, those would be game-changing things for our nation's children and families.

I'm absolutely convinced would take education in our country to an entirely different level.

So that all makes a lot of sense.

Although I'm surprised that you didn't talk about what we teach because Knowing a lot about you, I know that you're focused very much on the trauma that kids are facing.

And I think it's really a mistake in our schools that we don't make mental health and teaching kids about how to manage their own life like on par with geometry.

What do you think of that as a concept?

No, that's hugely important.

Sorry, I bucketed that and what students need.

So I always talk about physical, social, and emotional health.

And I go back to my mother's program that every single day when students walked into her program at 2.30 or 3 o'clock, she fed them.

And what she always said is it's hard to concentrate if your stomach's grumbling.

And so for me, the foundation of the education house, to your point, Steve, Steve, is making sure students physically, socially, emotionally are in a good place, that they're not being bullied, that they're not living in fear, that you're helping them work through their trauma.

And if that foundation is strong, then let's talk about rigor and AP calculus and biology and physics and where you're going to college.

But if that foundation is weak, if there are cracks in it, then that house is very unstable.

And so that is the basis, that is literally the foundation of an academic house that's going to be successful.

So, there's one particular moment that is burned into my memory from your years running the Chicago Public Schools.

Chicago was in the national headlines then, as now, because of a flurry of homicides that had taken the lives of some young people.

And you were interviewed on a news show, and the host asked you a series of typical questions,

but your answers were raw with pain.

And it was clear that you were spending your days and nights grieving in the living rooms with the parents of the kids who had died.

And you cared in a way like these were your own kids.

What was that like for you?

Yeah, well, it's obviously the reason I do what I do now.

And there's so much that I'm proud of during those seven and a half years.

And we could talk all day on another show about rising graduation rates and test scores and more students going to college and lots of money for college scholarships.

So much I'm proud of.

But on my watch, Steve, during my seven and a half years, on average, and this is a staggering number, we had a child killed every two weeks due to gun violence.

It's just an overwhelming number.

And thank God, never in one of our schools, but on the bus going home, walking to the corner store.

Starkisha Reed killed at 7.30 on a weekday morning in her living room, getting ready to go to school, shot by an AK-47 from 100 yards away.

And my wife and I had two young kids at that time, and getting to know those families after they had just lost their son or daughter and going to those homes and going to those funerals and going to classrooms where there was an empty desk and a class of just traumatized kids trying to talk to them and trying to make some sense of the senseless, that was by far the hardest part of my job.

Nothing came close.

And everything that's supposed to be hard, you know, academic achievement, operations, budgets, labor management, I don't say any of that was easy, but all that was wildly easier than dealing with the loss of our our children.

And quite honestly, it got hard over time.

It did not get easier.

I just know, I don't think, I know we as adults, we as educators, we as parents, we as leaders, we failed to keep our kids safe.

And I'm still friends with many of those parents who lost their children while I was at CPS.

I just can't imagine, I can't imagine that pain.

I can't imagine that heartbreak as a parent.

And I just know we as a city have to do so much better to allow our children to grow up free of fear and trauma.

And that is the reason why I do the work I do today.

So it's not at all surprising that after being Secretary of Education, where you could have done just about anything you wanted, you came back to Chicago and you dedicated yourself to reducing violence, starting an organization called Chicago Cred.

Can you describe what Cred does?

It's important for your listeners to understand I'm doing exactly what I want.

There's nothing I'd rather do.

There are five pillars to our work today, Steve.

First is a street outreach team.

These are guys who have tremendous credibility in the street with connections to all the different cliques all the different gangs and they're working to stem conflicts they're putting in place non-aggression agreements and peace treaties but they're also our recruiters they're bringing guys into our program guys and women and then when people come into our programming we have a life coach for every single man and woman and we always say experience can be the best teacher it just doesn't have to be your experience And unfortunately, many of our life coaches are folks that served 20, 30 years in jail who gave a lot of time away, but they've come out and dedicated themselves to giving back to the community and having their experience stand in the place of our young guys, learning from them.

We have an amazing clinical team, and I can't overstate the amount of trauma.

We have 17 folks on our clinical team now, and as much as we're doing, I know we're not doing nearly enough.

And there's a saying that hurt people hurt people.

but the converse is also true that healed people help to heal people, help to heal their families, help to heal their community.

And as our men heal and seeing their transformation, it is just absolutely stunning.

We have an education team.

We've had lots of guys get high school diplomas.

It's just an unbelievable high point, incredibly moving to see guys who 28, 29, 30, some of whom never actually made it to high school, to see them graduate and see the pride and joy they have and their family members have.

It's unbelievable.

It's unbelievable.

And then we have a jobs team.

And our goal is after guys work of us for nine months, 12 months, 15 months, whatever it is, we spin them off into the legal economy.

I can't ask the guys to put the guns down if we don't have something else for them to do.

And I say all the time, these are men.

They're not boys.

They're going to to make a living, they're going to eat, they're going to take care of their kids, it's up to us, whether that's in the illegal economy or in the legal economy.

Very naively, when our family moved to D.C.

in 2009, I really thought Chicago was a rock bottom.

I thought it couldn't get worse.

And unfortunately, for a whole bunch of reasons, in the seven years we were in D.C., things got a lot worse here.

And the epiphanies I had just from many, many conversations

were if you want to stop shooting, you have to work with shooters.

You have to work in the crisis space.

You have to intervene there.

And almost nobody's winning here, Steve.

Nobody's getting rich on the streets.

It's a myth that everyone's making a lot of money selling drugs.

You understand that so much better than most, that a lot of folks are risking their lives for nothing.

So what your team is doing is trying to find the most at-risk young men and women.

You can find the ones who have been shooting at others, been being shot at.

And you take them into this structure and you try to give them a path forward where there isn't a path.

And it's an intensive program that you're running.

By my calculations, you're spending about $33,000 a year per person in this program.

You're mass about right.

The cost is pretty variable.

For some guys, it's actually a lot higher.

Some guys, it's lower.

But every homicide costs our city $1.4 million.

A bed at Cook County Jail is about $60,000 per year.

And that cost for us is basically a one-year cost.

And after that, folks have spun off to legal economy and are productive citizens.

And we've had folks like Bank Consulting do big pro bono studies and talk about a 19 to 1 ROI for the kind of work we're doing.

So again, take out the tragedy, take out the heartbreak, take out the loss to human potential, just on the hard numbers, the economics, I can make a pretty compelling case that this is the best investment we can make.

And five years into this work, I am clearer than ever that this is a huge part of the answer.

And my frustration and my sense of urgency is our unwillingness to take to scale what we know works.

We're doing the vast majority of this with private philanthropic dollars, which is fine, but you can't scale enough.

And so getting the city to do more, the state starting to do more, the county, hopefully the federal government, then we can touch enough folks.

That's the next step.

I know you're a big believer in data.

What do the numbers say about the impact you're having with CRED?

We have two metrics, Steve.

It's pretty simple and pretty stark.

It's homicides and shootings.

So we started this work in 2016.

2016 was a horrific year in terms of violence here in the city, as you know.

2017, 2018, 2019, we saw double-digit reductions in violence each year.

So things were very much going in the right direction.

And then last year killed us, 2020, with the pandemic, with the aftermath of George Floyd's murder.

That was the worst six or eight weeks of our work here.

We had a staff member killed.

We had three of our young men killed.

We had a 20-month-old son of one of our men killed in a car seat going to Langemat with his mother.

And so last year, violence was up about 50% here in the city.

We were able to get those numbers down.

And as tough as things are, we still have a chance this year to hit our goal of a 20% reduction.

If you look at the cred-specific data and Northwestern studying this, it's showing about a 58% reduction in victimization for folks in our program.

We track every shooting, we track every homicide.

We have put in place a number of non-aggression agreements and peace treaties between different groups.

And just having that kind of street intel, I just, again, so many crazy stories, but I was out Saturday night with our street outreach team and there had been an incident early before I got there with a gun at a gas station and they had helped to diffuse that situation.

And one of our street outreach workers called a guy and didn't hear back from him and said, I bet he's been shot.

And lo and behold, we paced together in about an hour that the people at the gas station went and shot him.

Thank goodness he survived.

But just the level of intelligence, the level of detail that we have of the different groups and the different conflicts and who's at peace, who's at war.

It is unbelievable what our team is doing every single day.

Is it lack of money that keeps you from scaling or is it something deeper?

Well, it is, yes, a lack of money, but it is deeper.

It's understanding that people who have witnessed terrible things, who have had terrible things happen to them, who maybe have done terrible things, that there is a possibility of redemption.

And we've worked with over 500 men, Steve.

And again, this may sound crazy to your audience, but there's not a single guy we've worked with that I think is a bad person.

You know, one of our guys told me his earliest memory was of his father shooting heroin.

That's his earliest childhood memory.

And another young man in our first cohort, who was honestly a pretty big shooter, he said, Arnie, I grew up in a household full of guns, and I wish we would have had toys, but we had guns.

And I just thought about my childhood.

Both my parents are educators.

We grew up in a household full of books.

And guess what?

Me, my sister, and my brother all went into education.

That was our family business.

His family business was guns and shooting.

He became a shooter.

It doesn't make me a better person.

It doesn't make him a worse person.

People see the world, I think, far too often as white and black.

This is the grayest world I've ever been in, Steve.

Who's a hero?

Who's a villain?

Who's the good guy?

Who's the bad guy?

Is the hero of the guy in the street?

Is the policeman, the hero, the villain?

It is unbelievably complicated.

And people have to be comfortable with the tremendous amount of things that are confusing, that are uncomfortable.

But that's the only way we're going to get to a safer city and give our children their childhoods back and allow them to grow up free of fear and trauma, which is all we're trying to do.

That's all I'm trying to do.

So speaking of redemption, a friend of yours in high school named Benji Wilson was shot and killed.

And his shooter, Billy Moore, actually works works with you today.

How did that come about?

Benji Wilson was a friend who I grew up playing basketball with.

ESPN did a 30 for 30 special on him.

And there's a clip of him playing in the schoolyards right at the very start of that.

I happened to be in that clip.

And he wasn't just the best basketball player as a senior in Chicago.

He was literally the number one basketball player in the nation.

And he was killed in 1984.

And I was a sophomore in college.

I still remember where I was when I got that call in my dorm that he had been killed.

And to say that was shattering is a tremendous understatement.

We had always really believed that we as ball players, that we had a pass, that we were allowed free passage in and out of neighborhoods and had a sense of safety.

And that just absolutely went away with Benji's death.

So when ESPN did that story, they interviewed Billy Moore, who had killed him.

And he's interviewed at the end of it.

And I actually, I couldn't even watch it.

And just

didn't want to hear him.

And Billy committed that murder when he was 16.

He served 20 years and got out.

And very symbolically, I met Billy on a peace march.

And we had a mutual friend.

And he said, do you know who Billy Moore is?

And I said, yeah, I know exactly who Billy Moore is.

And he said, he'd like to talk to you.

Would you be willing to meet him?

I can't say I wanted to, but I said, sure.

So we walked and talked and just heard his story and heard what he had been through.

And he walked me through in immense detail what had happened.

And I just got a sense for his heart and what he was doing.

And And he eventually came to work with us at Cred, and he now leads all of our alumni work.

But he is one of the most extraordinary men I know.

And I don't say this lightly.

I would take a bullet for him tomorrow, and I know he would do the same for me.

Very tragically, his own son was killed, was shot 16 times at Foster Park, which is a place where I played basketball for 30 plus years.

And what Billy says that I believe, and it still blows me away, is that if the young man who killed his son came into our program, that he would take him under his wing and mentor him and try and teach him that he can't ask for forgiveness and redemption if he can't give it.

And just what I've learned about humanity and forgiveness from Billy, I can't begin to put in words.

And we can't succeed in this work.

We can't begin to get where we need to as a city if we don't have the talents and passion and expertise and heart and lived experience of folks like Billy Moore helping to lead us and leading our young men where we need to go.

And I can tell you unequivocally that he is saving lives every single day in this work.

Let me end with something more trivial, which is basketball.

You won the national three-on-three basketball championship in 2014.

You're almost 50 years old and you were secretary of education.

And that's a big deal tournament full of college superstar athletes and stuff like that.

Did you sell your soul to the devil for that win?

Or what's the story behind that?

No, that was so fun.

So we've played for years, three-on-three tournaments, and we actually won nine or ten national championships.

That's always been my stress relief and just a tremendous amount of fun.

But that was an absolute highlight was going to the Olympic Training Center there in Colorado and winning that national championship.

And we're supposed to go to Russia to compete for the international championship.

And because of the politics and because of our Secretary of Education, I couldn't go.

So I'll regret that to the day I die.

But I have a group of guys that we work out 7.30 every morning.

That's my stress release.

This work, it absolutely takes a toll on me emotionally.

I don't want to hide from that or shy from that.

And just getting out there and breaking the sweat every morning and having that camaraderie, that really helps to keep me going.

I still love to play.

I'm slower than ever, but I feel so lucky to be able to still do it.

And I'm going to do it as long as I can.

When Arnie's family bought the house next door to me, the first thing they did was to rip out their backyard and turn it into a giant basketball court.

My wife was not happy.

For the first year Arnie lived there, his son used to court a lot, but I didn't see Arnie shooting baskets once over that entire time.

I figured maybe after his three-on-three championship, he'd hung up his sneakers.

But then one day, I looked out the window and it was Arnie out there on the court.

I watched his first shot.

Swish.

I watched his second shot.

Swish.

He made the first 10 shots I saw.

And these were not easy shots.

Next thing I know, he's up to 20 straight baskets without a miss.

And then it was 30 straight.

I had other things to do, but how could I walk away from a performance like that?

Soon it was 40 straight.

And I would say at least 30 of those 40 shots had touched nothing but net.

Finally, shot 58 rattled around the rim and bounced out.

The streak was over at 57.

At least I understood now why Arnie never practiced.

Now, was it a fluke?

Maybe.

It was another six months before I saw Arnie dig the court, and I vowed again to watch him shoot until he missed.

He made his first shot, he made his second shot, but this time, he missed after only 23 consecutive baskets.

But you know, everyone's entitled to an occasional off day.

Thanks for listening, and we'll be back next week.

People I Mostly Admire is part of the Freakonomics Radio Network, which also includes Freakonomics Radio, No Stupid Questions, and Freakonomics MD.

This show is produced by Freakonomics Radio and Stitcher.

Morgan Levy is our producer and Jasmine Klinger is our engineer.

Our staff also includes Stephen Dubner, Allison Creglow, Greg Ripon, Joel Joel Meyer, Tricia Bovita, Eleanor Osborne, Emma Terrell, Lyric Bautich, and Jacob Clementi.

Theme music composed by Luis Guerra.

To listen ad-free, subscribe to Stitcher Premium.

We can be reached at Pima at freakonomics.com.

That's P-I-M-A at freakonomics.com.

Thanks for listening.

The true story is that at one point at the White House, Brock came up to me and said, Arnie, you motherfouled me too much.

I didn't know what to say.

Like, I'm sorry, Mr.

President.

The Freeconomics Radio Network, the hidden side of everything.

Stitcher.

I choose to work where everyone can see how busy I am.

I choose pedal palette.

I choose the freshest of beats.

I choose to never burrito and drive.

Whatever you choose, choose transit and do your part to spare the air.

Hi there, it's Andy Richter, and I'm here to tell you about my podcast, The Three Questions with Andy Richter.

Each week, I invite friends, comedians, actors, and musicians to discuss these three questions.

Where do you come from?

Where are you going?

And what have you learned?

New episodes are out every Tuesday with guests like Julie Bo and Ted Danson, Tig Nataro, Will Arnett, Phoebe Bridgers, and more.

You can also tune in for my weekly Andy Richter Call-In Show episodes where me and a special guest invite callers to weigh in on topics like dating disasters, bad teachers, and lots more.

Listen to the three questions with Andy Richter wherever you get your podcasts.

When a cold has you down, it's the little comforts that lift you up.

A warm blanket, a cup of tea, and a tissue that actually feels good on your skin.

Infused with aloe, Kleenex Cooling Plus Aloe provides a hint of cooling freshness to help your skin feel restored.

So whether your skin is feeling dry, chafed, or irritated, you're only one wipe away from helping it feel relieved.

The next time you have a cold, get a hint of instant cooling relief with new Kleenex Cooling Plus Aloe.

For whatever happens next, grab Kleenex.