Trump's TikTok Dance

The best cars for the money are Hondas. Save big with 0% financing.

The 25 Accord Civic Passport and Odyssey have been named the best cars for the money by U.S. News and World Report.

Save thousands with 0%, like the 24 Prologue with 0 APR.

To drive the best, ask anyone who owns a Honda and search your local Honda dealer.

See dealer for financing details. Financing on credit approval.
Offer ends 4-30-25. View U.S.
News best cars at cars.usnews.com. The last thing you want to hear when you need your auto insurance most is a robot with countless irrelevant menu options.

Which is why with USAA Auto Insurance, you'll get great service that is easy and reliable all at the touch of a button.

Get a quote today. Restrictions apply.

USAA! Welcome to Pod Save America. I'm Jon Favreau.
And I'm Jane Koston. Jane, so great to have you.
Hello. It's wonderful to be here.
It's good to see you. New York Times and CNN contributor Jane Koston, guest host today.
This is fantastic. It's good to have you back here.
I could not be more excited. So on today's show, we are going to talk about the Republican House just passed a potential TikTok ban that Donald Trump no longer supports.
RFK Jr. has reportedly chosen his running mate, and it could be Aaron Rodgers or Jesse Ventura.
And we're going to talk about whether Republican politicians are too terminally online to win. But first, you might remember that last month, the special counsel who investigated President Biden's handling of classified information concluded in his report that there was insufficient evidence to bring charges, but then swerved out of the way to call Biden, quote, a well-meaning elderly man with poor memory.
Well, House Republicans called Robert Heard to testify yesterday so they could yell at him for not indicting Biden

and generate some content for campaign ads.

Here's an example from Republican Representative Tom Tiffany.

So I want to thank you for the work that you did as far as you could.

But unfortunately, you are part of the Praetorian Guard

that guards the swamp out here in Washington, D.C., protecting the elites. And Joe Biden is part of that company of the elites.
You are part of the guard who defends the swamp. Unfortunately, it was very polite the way he said it.
Just before the hearing, House Democrats released the full transcript of her interview with Biden, which at one point showed the special counsel contradicting his own characterization of Biden's memory.

Let's listen.

I now want to turn you to the transcript and day one, page 47.

You said to President Biden, you have appeared to have a photographic understanding and recall of the House. Did you say that to President Biden? Those words do appear on page 47 of the transcript.
Photographic is what you said. Is that right? That word does appear on page 47 of the transcript.
Never appeared in your report, though. Is that correct? The word photographic? That does not appear in my report.
Attorney Herr Webster's dictionary defines senile as exhibiting a decline of cognitive ability, such as memory associated with old age. Mr.
Herr, based on your report, did you find that the president was senile? I did not. That conclusion does not appear in my report, Congressman.
Democrats also used the hearing to remind everyone that Trump is much worse at both handling classified information and remembering important things. Let's listen.
Unlike President Biden, Trump did not alert the National Archives or DOJ of the documents, nor did he turn over all the classified materials in his possession. He did not agree to sit down for a voluntary interview with the special counsel.
He never consented to a search of his home. On the contrary, Trump suggested that his attorney hide or destroy evidence requested by the FBI and the grand jury.
Trump carefully instructed his aide to move boxes of classified documents to hide them from the FBI. Trump tried to delete incriminating security tape footage from Mar-a-Lago, and he got his attorney to provide a false certification to the FBI saying he had produced all the documents in his possession.
I'd have to get the exact dates for you. I can do that.
Am I correct that you married your current wife in January 2005? I don't know relative to that date. In what years were you the owner of the Paz Hotel? I don't know the years.
James Webb. I don't remember the names.
Don't remember the name. So you don't remember saying you have one of the best members? I don't remember that.
I remember you telling me, but I don't know that I said. Tough that he doesn't remember his anniversary.
I mean... I guess when you've had a couple of wives, it's sort of...
It's not surprising, exactly. I think that, like, at the very 30,000-foot view, it is not ideal that we now have dueling depositions of two presidential candidates and two presidents.
That's not good. I will say, as a side note ever could win anything i would like to win the chance to depose someone deposing someone just sounds super fun just being like did you say this and the person being like apparently i did that sounds great i would go to law school just to depose people that's all i want.
And of course, like when you're getting deposed, you are advised by your lawyers, any good lawyer, to say that you don't recall if you're not absolutely sure. Because otherwise you could have perjury charges slapped on you.
It's another classic example of how the good thing to do doesn't sound good. Right.
If you are arrested, you should not say anything to the police. However, the police, when they do your Dateline episode, will be like, yeah, she lawyered up right away, didn't say anything, which is the right thing to do.
But when you're watching Dateline later, you're going to be like, she killed all those people. And that's what we're watching right now.
Dateline. That is what politics has become.
I'm glad you're here to talk about this, because when we spoke yesterday, you said you hadn't been following every detail of the hearing or the her investigation, which, you know what, makes you just like most voters. So now that you're all read up on everything, what do you think? I think that it is March of an election year and so the relevance of these particular events remain to be seen i know that's not a very satisfying answer but um i've been taking a break from social media uh for lent um which has been great it just also means that i am not plugged it quite literally but i am not plugged in to literally everything that's taking place and so like after going through the transcript of the hearing and reading a bunch of write-ups from actual news outlets my my main takeaway is wow everyone hates each other because you had republicans yelling at her about how he's the praetorian Guard for Biden, which he is not.

And also, I don't know how the Praetorian Guard got involved here.

Me neither.

Yeah. And but then you had Democrats yelling at her that he had smeared Biden by referring to him as elderly and talking about his memory issues.
I was very entertained because part of the transcript shows that Biden does remember going to Mongolia and having an awesome time bow hunting, which sounds super fun. He apparently Biden excels at archery.
Which, how is that not? That's my takeaway. Archery is hard.
From a trip to Mongolia 13 years ago, and he's remembering hitting the target. I don't even want to know why that story came up by the way no uh he wanted to talk about cars and uh he wanted to talk about how hot his wife is so i was like yeah joe biden elderly wife guy who remembers elderly wife guy things that checks out um but i think like the main you know it was interesting how rather than ask questions that could show like why, why didn't charges result from this? Why did this not appear in the ultimate report that you gave? Like, you know, getting actual answers.
Everyone involved decided this is a televised hearing. We must do televised hearing things and yell at each other and yell at him.
This former special counsel who did not ask for any of this. He's just there and he was yelled at.
But I think that it was interesting because a couple of write-ups I saw were like, this could have election ramifications. And I'm thinking back to, do you remember four years ago? Do you remember what was taking place roughly four years ago? Oh, I think we were home for quite a while.
Yeah, we were home for quite a while. Some stuff was happening.
I believe we are now just over the anniversary of when Rudy Gobert caused the entire NBA to shut down, which I will never move on from the fact that as far as I'm concerned, it's all Rudy Gobert's fault. But we have no idea what is going to happen in between now and November.
It is not ideal that Biden is in the situation. This report is not good.
This hearing was not good. But whether it will be relevant to people voting in November, which is, I don't, it's a while from now.
A lot can happen.

You can have an entire global pandemic between now and then.

I would prefer we didn't.

That happened four years ago.

I was like, all right, goodbye, everybody.

Taking my social media break for Lent.

And I came back and we were in the midst of a global pandemic. So I'm really trying not to like instigate that again.

Yeah, please.

I'm doing my very best.

But I will just say, like, I don't know how relevant this is going to be.

I don't know how relevant this is going to be i don't know what's going to be at top of mind for voters especially because the opposition candidate also has apparently memory issues or and a deposition and a host of legal issues a couple depositions at at this point. Yeah, exactly.
He's been deposed a bunch of times. Exactly.
And also had a whole classified document scandal and his classified documents were kept in various places in Mar-a-Lago and now there are interviews with former Mar-a-Lago staffers saying like, yeah, we just moved stuff around and it seemed weird. Like, that's not good.
But again, I don't know what it will mean for people voting in November. Yeah.
I mean, my takeaway is if you are truly concerned about Joe Biden's memory or cognitive abilities, I would urge you to read or at least skim. It is 159 pages, the full transcript of the interview.
It paints a much different portrait of Biden than her report in which the special counsel very clearly cherry picked, exaggerated and editorialized in a way that absolutely wasn't necessary in order to explain why he chose not to bring charges. Just one example in the report.
Her says Biden, quote, did not remember even within several years when his son Bo died. Of course, what actually happened is that Biden was telling a story to her about why he started thinking about running for president in 2017, 2018, which involved a promise to his dying son.
Biden said, what month did Bo die? Oh my God, May 30th. And then a White House lawyer interrupted to say 2015.
And Biden said, was it 2015 he died? The lawyer said yes. And Biden said it was 2015.
So like, it's not like her was completely lying. But when you say he did not remember even within several years when his son Bo died, you wouldn't know from that that he immediately knew what date it was and just had to be corrected on the year as he was telling a very, very long story about why he ran for president.
Yeah, exactly. And especially because I think if anyone has experienced tragedy, sometimes you remember every aspect of it like it happened.
It is still taking place. And sometimes little things fade away away like you might remember like i remember where i was when i found out that this person had passed away i can tell you everything about it i could tell you what the weather looked like but what year not sure like might need a moment and so like that was a moment in which i think that and i think representative raskin also made the point that like, there seemed to be, I mean, Republicans getting really upset about document handling seemed a little bit of a, I'm giving a side eye.
I'm aware that side eye is not ideal for a podcast format. But I do think that there is a sense about being like, this hearing was not about documents.
This hearing was about Biden should be charged with crimes and removed from the White House. And you know who should take his place in the White House? Donald Trump, another person with documents issues who actually has been charged with crimes.
Yeah. And by the way, if you don't think that Biden is going to be charged, which none of them really think because Robert Hur said he's not going to be.
And now it doesn't look like they're going to impeach him because they haven't found any evidence that warrants impeachment. And Ken Buck just retired.
So now they barely even have a House majority, let alone enough people to impeach him. So in case that's not going to happen, Biden's old.
Biden's old and he's senile, even though Robert Hur just said he wasn't senile. But anyway, that's what they were trying to push.
I don't think they successfully, I don't think they successfully advanced the storyline about Biden's age in this hearing. Right, exactly.
Because that's, I mean, politics so much is about storylines and about introducing ideas into the media zeitgeist. I am a part of the media zeitgeist.
I do zeitgeisty on occasion and there is an idea of like if we talk a lot about how biden is old then the media will have to report that he is old and then they'll have to do like roundtable discussions about how old is joe biden he's so old that he might remember truman i don't know and like that's the point but I do think that the challenge is that like Trump is also old.

I'm aware that's the point. But I do think that the challenge is that like, Trump is also old, I'm aware that that is not a discussion that we have all the time.
I think that a couple of people, I think McKay Coppins, who's a great writer for the Atlantic, has made the point that like, so much of Trump's weirdness is baked in with American voters and with, you know, kind of the media that like, if you just keep saying like weird things Trump says, there's a certain moment. There's a sports writer, he owns the ringer, Bill Simmons, he came up with this thing years ago called the Mike Tyson zone, which is that like Mike Tyson, if you if you hear that Mike Tyson did anything, like Mike Tyson jumped off the Eiffel Tower, you'd be like, yeah, probably.
Like there is a certain zone. And like Donald Trump is within the Mike Tyson zone of like, if I heard, if you told me that Donald Trump went on a long rant about the Netflix revival of Gilmore Girls and how terrible it was, I'd be like, yeah, that 100% checks out.
Not a surprise at all. Nope, nope, nope.
I'm like, now I i'm gonna incept myself into believing that this happened but like there it it this hearing was an effort to put this conversation about biden's age back into media spaces and make the media talk about it and i think that the media will continue to talk about biden's age because I do think it is relevant for obvious reasons.

Namely, he is elderly.

Actuarial tables are actuarial tables for a reason.

But I also think that on this particular issue of the documents issue, I don't think that they got what they wanted out of it.

It's the same way that the Biden impeachment didn't go anywhere.

Like you can you can bring a horse to water, but you cannot make it into a document scandal, as the saying says. I think part of their problem is that the hearing came, you know, several days after a State of the Union where Biden appeared feisty, was a joyful warrior.
And, you know, my take on the State of the Union is it's not going to be a game changer since State of the Unions often aren't game changers. They usually don't lead to any change in approval ratings or bumps in the polls.
But I do think it was a blueprint for Biden for the campaign. Like if he is like that out on the campaign trail or when we see him in public from now until November, he's going to be a lot better off.
But what did you think? Yeah, I think that how the State of the Union is perceived is always it's always challenging because you are asking people who already have a perception of the person giving the State of the Union. Like you cannot bring in people who have literally never heard of Joe Biden be like, watch this speech.
How do you think this guy did? Like, that's not how this works. And I do think like how his I don't think it's going to have any impact on polling.
But I do think that Republicans keep setting the expectations for Joe Biden on the floor. We saw this in 2020.
And we have seen this over and over again, that joe b supposed to be barely alive. He is supposed to be unable to do literally anything.
And then he will do anything. He will appear to be a member of the human race in good standing.
And then Republicans are like, well, he was loud. He was very loud.
And he seemed annoyed. He seemed annoyed.
And like, at a certain point, like maybe set your expectations for Joe Biden like slightly above comatose. Like I think that that is the challenge here.
Like if you have baked in this idea that Joe Biden is senile and then Joe Biden does things that make it obvious that he is not senile, I think that you are ignoring, if you're a Republican, things that are actually things you could go after Joe Biden on. You could go after Joe Biden on any number of subjects.
You could go after the withdrawal from Afghanistan or any any number of actual policy issues this is me trying to make this election about policy while it will not be about policy i know that i know that but like i think that it just it's so easy it's so easy to just be like oh he's old and can't do anything. Whereas Donald Trump, not old, not weird, is this vital person like a Ben Garrison comic.
And it keeps not working and they keep doing it over and over and over again. I remember during the, in the early months of the 2012 reelect, the Romney people sort of tried out a line on Obama that was, you know, he's a he's a decent man who was a historic president.
And we're so glad that he made history, but he just hasn't been able to turn the economy around. And we need someone new we were we were much more afraid of that line of attack than we were what they ended up with by the end which is like you know he did Benghazi and because once again the Republicans let like the fringe take over the messaging and it's just not as it's not the people had doubts about Obama but they didn't believe that he was some uh evil whatever that they painted him out to be and that is the same thing that the republicans are doing with biden right and i think that that's something um you know 2012 like mit romney wanted to talk about like the economy or like very specific issues that i think were tethered to actual policies upon which you could actually criticize barack obama whose actual polling numbers were not like that great in 2011 2012 due to any number of things and the gop media base was like no benghazi slash orly tates slash something extremely It's strange.
Like, oh, I've've never I will never forget about Orly Tates. You can't take that away from me.
But like, it is interesting how I mean, this is I mean, it's a it's a cultural discussion. His Biden's age is an easier conversation to have that everyone makes sense of when talking about withdrawing from Afghanistan gets complicated because a lot of people wanted to withdraw from afghanistan and everyone was always going to be mad at the person who actually did people could be mad about the economy or about bidenomics or about inflation but like all of that is a little challenging to talk about but like he's old that's easy yeah and yeah he's's senile.
That's something that people kind of understand.

It just happens that it keeps not necessarily being true.

Right.

Yeah.

And the truth is he's a well-meaning elderly man who can remember just with

mind numbing detail,

all kinds of stories from his 81 years on this earth, and will

tell those stories to you, like, ad nauseum.

Yeah, yeah.

Like, and I have been, it is, the Joe Biden in that transcript is like the Joe Biden,

anyone who knows Joe Biden, who has been in meetings with Joe Biden, who has talked to

Joe Biden, like, we have all heard those kind of stories where he has a, the mental acuity,

he is sharp, right?

And he remembers a lot.

He goes on at length.

Right.

And he tells these stories.

And some of the stories are a little kooky, might make you roll your eyes time to time.

But the guy is sharp.

He is really sharp.

The best cars for the money are Hondas. Save big with 0% financing.
The 25 Accord Civic Passport and Odyssey have been named the best cars for the money by U.S. News and World Report.
Save thousands with 0%, like the 24 Prologue with 0 APR. To drive the best, ask anyone who owns a Honda and search your local Honda dealer.
See dealer for financing details. Financing on credit approval.
Offer ends 4-30-25. View U.S.
News Best Cars at cars.usnews.com. This wasn't the adventure I had in mind when you said, let's rent a car in Italy.
Relax. GPS says we're on track.
Wait, does that sign say Switzerland? No, no, no. We should be near Sicily.
Routing. Want to actually enjoy your next trip? One that's completely mapped out? With Colette's small group explorations, you can.
Our experts handle every detail, from great food to unique stays and local connections. Start your next adventure today.
Visit GoColette.com. That's GoCollette.com.

Hannity presents, in the red corner, the undisputed, undefeated Weed Whacker Guy.

Champion of hurling grass and pollen everywhere.

And in the blue corner, the challenger, Extra Strength Hannity.

Eye drops and work all day to prevent the release of histamines that cause itchy, allergy eyes. And the winner, by knockout, is Hannity! Hannity, bring it on! So the House is on a real tear this week on the heels of that very successful special counsel hearing.
They just passed a bill 352 to 65 that would ban TikTok from all U.S. app stores unless ByteDance, the Chinese company that owns the social media platform, agrees to sell TikTok to an American-based owner within 165 days.
The legislation passed overwhelmingly bipartisan support. It also has support from President Biden.
This is all based on assessments from the intelligence community and the FBI that TikTok poses a threat to national security. They believe the Chinese government will use or is using the app to spy on American users, spread propaganda, and interfere in our elections.
The bill may or may not pass the Senate. We don't know yet.
But it does have one brand new opponent, Donald Trump, who tried to ban TikTok when he was president, but just changed his mind recently after a fierce lobbying campaign by people with financial ties to TikTok, including a billionaire donor and Kellyanne Conway. Imagine that.
All right. Before we get to the Trump of it all, what do you think of the ban or the potential ban? So I think that there's, in a normal, objective conversation about this, I think that the ban, that is not really a ban, to be clear.
If if we go back to 2020 there's another app that's very popular and occasionally lightly controversial that has this exact same issue grinder which some of you might be extremely familiar with and some of you were like what's grinder and but you're also lying you know what it is so grinder in 2020 owned by a Chinese company kunlun the u.s forces the sale of grinder

uh to san vicente acquisition because of security concerns and people are still grinding is that what i'm not gonna ask someone will email me to tell me what the verb is when you still grinding Still grinded.

Got the episode title.

I'm leaving that there.

So there is. verb is when you still grinding still grinding got the episode title i uh i'm i'm leaving that there so there there are examples for this this is not no more tiktok ever this is sell it to an american subsidiary sell it to an american company which is i think it seems to me a reasonable ask if you would like to continue having TikTok in the United States.
Like it's a thing that you can do. But then it's not about objectively what TikTok actually is.
It is about what TikTok means. If you're former Vice President Mike Pence, you believe it is digital fentanyl, fentanyl, um i don't entirely understand what that means or what mike pence thinks fentanyl is but that's neither that's neither here nor there uh if you are rand paul you believe that this is all deeply unfair there are obviously a lot of libertarians with like i think on many, I agree with them with regard to attempting to ban TikTok or limit TikTok for like some of the arguments against TikTok that I've seen from Republicans seem to literally be like, it's poisoning our children with liberal nonsense.
Like the idea that in China, TikTok is like, ah, they watch orchestra performances.

But in America, they watch pornography on TikTok.

Like that's no, that sounds stupid. If you have actual security concerns.
TikTok is like, ah, they watch orchestra performances. But in America, they watch pornography on TikTok.

Like, that's no, that sounds stupid.

If you have actual security concerns with regard to the ownership of TikTok, that is

different from TikTok is bad.

Ban TikTok.

No more TikTok for anyone.

Those are two different things.

So I think that how people are thinking about this app is actually how people are thinking about tech and this type of tech. On the one hand, you have people who I think are a smidgen too enthusiastic about it.
Some of them are being paid to be enthusiastic. Our good friend of the Bowling Green Massacre, Kellyanne Conway.
Some people, you know, there have been a host of TikTok influencers who have been on Capitol Hill to talk to people. I don't know if you may have seen, others may have seen, TikTok has had a big ad campaign in the United States to being like, you know, I'm able to support my family.
I'm educating toddlers. I'm making soap.
Like, I'm the nicest person in the entire world. And I'm on TikTok.
um nothing bad could happen here which i'm like fine but i think that the conversation is less about what tiktok is and more about what tiktok means yeah which is about a social media platform that is confusing and loud and sometimes filled with really bad stuff and sometimes filled with really good stuff. And it is currently seemingly out of control.
And a lot of people don't like that. And a lot of people don't like that.
Other people don't like that. Yeah.
I mean, look, my view on this is that most social media platforms as currently designed do more harm than good. That's my own bias here.
I think that functional democracies require a shared reality and social media is not in the shared reality business, traps us in different realities where we only see and hear now what we want to, even if it's not true, makes rational debate impossible, makes it very easy to ignore what's going on in the world altogether. I think TikTok is maybe one of the worst of all the platforms because the algorithm is more determinative, right? There's very little choice involved.
You're just being fed video after video based on your own interests. But what if I really want to watch a llama hopping to party up by DMX? That's my right.
I have the right to watch a llama hop to party up by DMX. Don't take that away from me.
That's what I'm saying. It's like, so all that aside, like I'm not, like I said, I'm not a fan of Twitter, even though I use it and I'm addicted to it.
I also spent an hour on TikTok. And then where did the hour go? Right.
So, like, but you're right. If you want to if you want to do that, great.
But operating in a country where the government is actively hostile to U.S. interests and looking for ways to spy on us, not good.
I don't think we would have accepted during the height of the Cold War the Soviet Union owning NBC. Right.
That's something that would have been a problem for people. Right, exactly.
And like, I think that it's difficult for people to separate all of these pieces.

It's like any hearing you have on these issues with regards to the Chinese Communist Party or the Chinese government obviously turns into rabid Sinophobia, which no one needs.

But there is an actual security concern here.

There is a security concern that has been raised by many people of both parties. People who I do not think are completely insane.
I think that that is worth hearing, especially because if TikTok is owned by an American company, then you can continue to watch. Keep TikTok.
Whatever. Yeah, you can keep on tick tocking or inventing tick tock dances and please just don't film your tick tock in public because you look insane what is also of interest to me is that donald trump on this particular issue who as you mentioned wanted to ban tick to TikTok in 2020.
Donald Trump occasionally is accused,

or given the, accused is too negative a term,

he is admired for his ability

to do three, four, five-dimensional chess

on any number of issues.

But Donald Trump is actually

the most easily influenced person in the history of time. Ever.
Ever. At any time.
And on this particular issue, he has been effectively influenced because there is a person that he hates. That person's name is Mark Zuckerberg.
That person runs Facebook and a host of other entities. For years, Donald Trump has hated Mark Zuckerberg, hated him a lot.
And so the brilliant people who are paid millions of dollars to do this very thing go to Donald Trump and are like, hey, you know what Facebook hates? TikTok. You know what your supporters love? TikTok.
And, you know, your supporters are free on TikTok. David Urban, who's a lobbyist, long-time advisor to Trump, I believe he ran the Pennsylvania campaign in 2016 for Trump, said that the app could be a campaign tool.
You've got Kellyanne Conway, who's being paid by Club for Growth tiktok which is a a circle that i really want to put a pin in to have a conversation about later because club for growth doing this is weird to me as someone who's been following conservative politics for a long time yeah but so and then you know i think most importantly you have um jeff yas who owns about 15 of bite dance he's the biggest donor to club for growth and thus kellyan conway and so all of a sudden donald trump again most easily influenced person in the history of time like there are there are eight-year-old boys who are less easily influenced than donald trump actually eight-year-old boys are really hard to convince of a lot of different things. Not Donald Trump.
So Donald Trump now is like, TikTok, eh, whatever. But in comparison to the evil Mark Zuckerberg, we got to keep TikTok.
I mean, it also goes to show people like, Donald Trump will abandon his position on literally any issue. He will screw over literally anyone, his own family, if it will help him politically or if he thinks it will help him politically.
That is the only thing he cares about is Donald Trump. So I'm tough on China.
It doesn't matter if it's going to if if coming out against the TikTok ban is going to help him politically, whether it's whatever the issue is, he will abandon it in a second if it's going to help him politically. And I do think, having said what I just did about TikTok, that there is a good case to be made that a TikTok ban that it well, if this legislation is signed into law and ByteDance doesn't sell and TikTok is then banned in the United States and President Biden has signed that into law and Donald Trump is out there opposing the ban, I think there's a very good case to be made that this will politically benefit Donald Trump, especially with a group of voters, young voters who Joe Biden has been struggling with compared to how he did in 2020.
And so, like, all that said, I'm like the political strategist in me. I'm like, yeah, I might wait until after the election to do anything about this legislation.
Right. Which I think that that that seemed to have been the path that was attempted four years ago.
But I will also say a couple of things. One, the TikTok audience is older than anyone thinks it is.
The TikTok audience is actually generally people around my age because um the deeply elderly people in our uh me in our 30s we are ancient we we we are struggling well-meaning millennials and i will also say that um in other countries where this has been attempted people basically tiktok basically just did what it has already done in its days which is that it became

instagram reels like instagram reels are essentially repurposed tiktoks there are thousands i don't actually have tiktok but because of instagram i feel like i do and so it's not as it like tiktok has broken contain tiktok like the people who are on tiktok do not stay there they are also posting their content on YouTube.

But like the content is there.

The users are there.

Um,

yeah. Like the people who are on TikTok do not stay there.
They are also posting their content on YouTube. But like the content is there.
The users are there. Like you can't really attempting to limit.
We are now in a point of like kind of social media amalgamation in which people who are on one platform don't just stay there. Their content doesn't just stay there.
It crosses over. But I do think I mean, if I if I'm ByteDance, I just sell.
I just sell. I do it like Grindr.
I just sell to an American company for whatever skillions of dollars. But I guess the Chinese government has a say here, right? If ByteDance is allowed to sell.
And they have previously said that they will not allow a sale, which if you weren't worried about Chinese government influence on TikTok before, the fact that they have been very opposed to a sale should raise some red flags, people. Yeah, it's just, I mean, that does seem...
We're not letting go of this company. And also, by the way, the Chinese government that does not allow any American social media platforms to operate in their country.
Yes, and also has tight limits on their social media platforms, as has been found out 90 bazillion times over the last five years. But I think like I am not sure what the political ramifications would be.
I will say that the polling indicates, and again, polling is just a photograph in time. It does not tell you how anyone will actually react to anything.
The polling indicates that most Americans are in support of a ban on TikTok. Now, why that is, we need to ask most Americans, and neither of us have that kind of time.
But like, how people think about this particular issue might be a little more complicated. I mean, yes, I am fully convinced that House members have had been diluted with calls from young people, which I will say it's it's kind of funny to me that people are like, why aren't young people more politically active? And then young people get politically active and then call their representative about an issue that matters to them.
And people like, whoa, stop it. Stop it.
Go away. They're doing the thing they're supposed to do.
All right, before we go to break, and in case you missed it, the Cricket Store just launched a no trespassing collection inspired by states where abortion is under attack. A portion of the proceeds will go to Vote Save America's Fuck Bans Fund, which currently supports abortion rights organizations across Arizona, Nevada, and Florida.
Head to crooket.com slash store to shop now.

Also, in case you missed it, our Pod Save America and Love It or Leave It 2024 tour dates were just announced, and the Friends of the Pod pre-sale is happening now. So if you want access to the best seats in the house before everyone else, subscribe at crooket.com slash friends to get the exclusive code.
And name the best cars for the money by U.S. News and World Report.
Save thousands with 0%, like the 24 Prologue with zero APR. To drive the best, ask anyone who owns a Honda and search your local Honda dealer.
See dealer for financing details. Financing on credit approval.
Offer ends 4-30-25. View U.S.
News Best Cars at cars.usnews.com. This wasn't the adventure I had in mind when you said, let's rent a car in Italy.
Relax. GPS says we're on track.

Wait, does that sign say Switzerland?

No, no, no.

We should be near Sicily.

Routing.

Ugh.

Want to actually enjoy your next trip?

One that's completely mapped out?

With Colette's small group explorations, you can.

Our experts handle every detail, from great food to unique stays and local connections.

Start your next adventure today.

Visit gocolette.com. That's gocollette.com.
From great food to unique stays and local connections. Start your next adventure today.

Visit GoCollette.com.

That's GoCollette.com.

Auto insurance can all seem the same until it comes time to use it.

So don't get stuck paying more for less coverage.

Switch to USAA Auto Insurance and you could start saving money in no time.

Get a quote today.

Restrictions apply.

USAA! Alright, so here's a New York Times headline that made me throw my phone. Aaron Rodgers and Jesse Ventura top RFK Jr.'s list for running mate.
What a world! Apparently, Kennedy has approached the New York Jets quarterback and the former professional wrestler about joining his independent ticket as vice president and quote, both men have welcomed the overtures. Two people familiar with the discussion said the Washington Post then followed up with the report that Kennedy has, in fact, selected his running mate and will announce his choice within two weeks.
Kennedy's currently only on the ballot in four states, though his super Pack says he has enough signatures to qualify in Georgia and Arizona as well. Like Kennedy,

Rodgers, Kennedy's currently only on the ballot in four states Though his super PAC says he has enough signatures To qualify in Georgia and Arizona As well Like Kennedy, Rogers and Ventura Both conspiracy theory guys Rogers spreads misinformation about COVID Ventura thinks the government Did 9-11 Gonna be tough to choose between them, huh? Apparently Discovery Channel host Mike Rowe and Tony Robbins Yes Yes, that Tony Robbins are also in the mix.

What do you think, Jane?

I'm about to say words that I have never said before,

but all credit to former Representative Tulsi Gabbard,

who has apparently stopped having discussions about becoming vice president.

Too crazy for Tulsi. As had Senator Rand Paul, which makes sense,

because the idea of Randul being anyone's vice president

just seems um unlikely unworkable on a lot of things um with respect that is due jesse ventura did serve as governor the great state of minnesota that that is a real thing that happened many of us were there. Aaron

Rogers. Hang on, I need

to gather

myself. So, in January,

now, many of us were there Aaron Rodgers I need I need to gather myself so in January now this is I I started out writing about the NFL and college football that is my first love my true passion and um a quote went around a bunch yesterday um the absolutely fantastic uh ESPN commentator reporter Mina Kimes shared it as to a host of other people so in january aaron rogers jets quarterback who played two plays for the jets before tearing his achilles he's he told pat mcafee on espn because uh aaron rogers had time to call into pat mcafee anytime he wants and he said it's he it. He said the Jets need to eliminate distractions, which it's a real guy in hot dog costume asking, we're all trying to find who did this.
Aaron Rodgers, I want to talk at the very micro about the football of it all, because this is a rare opportunity in which I can do this though i figured yeah yeah so he has a job he has a job that for what 30 31 other starting quarterbacks and like a ton of other people is an all-encompassing job being an n NFL quarterback is extraordinarily high pressure. Very difficult.
People are mad at you all the time. You are working all the time.
Aaron Rodgers came over from the Packers. If you watched Hard Knocks this year, which was excellent, Aaron Rodgers came across as a nice, interesting person with a lot of strange views, but he didn't really talk talk about those and he seemed kind of like oh you know he was going to make the team better and he was doing a lot with like team camaraderie and people got along and then he gets hurt and in in normal peopleville it would have been like you know you would have just seen a lot of like hashtag grind set posts on instagram as he like works his way back from an achilles chair which is like the fact you can do that now, like an Achilles chair in football or in sports in general used to just be like, well, that's your that's done.
He was even hinting in December that like, oh, I could make a return when that was never going to happen. But he just likes to hear himself talk.
Being an NFL quarterback is a full time profession. Like if you're an NFL quarterback, that's all you do.
Bengals quarterback, Joe Burrow, has been recovering from a hand issue. That's all he does.
He goes to physical therapy and recovers from his hand issue. He's not like, while we're here, I'm going to enter the seminary and become a priest in my spare time.
Not a lot of opportunities for part-time work when you're an nfl quarterback and do you know what's also a full-time job i don't know if you've heard this being a vice presidential candidate being a vice presidential candidate which just just to really uh circle things up here the election i that is going to take place is in November. You know what else is taking place in November? That's actually way cooler and better, and I like more than elections.
Football! Football is taking place then! The fact that I saw that headline in the New York Times, and for just a second, I was this isn't like some of like one of those like weird you remember like early 2000s like internet scam stuff that was like political scams where it's like oh you know we fake the cover of a magazine and it's supposed to talk about how this is actually all about climate change or something like that like for a second i was like wow this is a really involved fake. But no.
I did a double take as well. I did a double take as well.
It's a real thing. It's a real thing.
And unfortunately, I keep going back and forth on how seriously to take RFK Jr.'s candidacy because he is not quite a serious person, has proved himself to be, nor is Aaron Rodgers in his spreading COVID misinformation and random conspiracies about Jimmy Kimmel and Jeffrey Epstein that turned out, of course, not to be true. So, like, Aaron Rodgers, not a serious person at this point, nor is jesse ventura at this point or arguably ever a lot of the other people on this list as well and yet but i actually i i want to i want to jump in here for a second aaron rogers is not a serious person this is something like the conspiracy stuff he does conspiracy stuff in the way that like it's interesting because it's the one way in which i think aaron rogers is a very identifiable american because he does conspiracy stuff for fun like this is this is interesting and entertaining for him like it's like the guy you work with where you have had approximately one beer with him and we're like that will never happen again because he just randomly started being like so how do you think they fake the moon landing and you're like oh no it's this person um he is like every time i mean and he always has that plausible deniability about being like i'm just you know i'm just thinking out loud trying to think outside the system but like he does have and should stay within his actual job his actual job at which he is let's remember very good at multiple mvps he's won a super bowl he has been very successful and he just happens to have this sideline of saying things that are fucking insane rfk jr is actually a very serious person which is why he is concern, because he very seriously says and does the things that he says and does.
Like, yeah, this is not a sideline. He is a former environmental attorney who has been spreading vaccine misinformation for years, not because it is fun for him.
It actually seems like it's not fun for him at all he is very serious about this he really really believes it this is not like a being contrarian thing or trying to think outside the matrix he is absolutely 100 convinced of it that is not good and i think um to i i i'm guessing what you're thinking of like how you know what are what role rfk will play in the election i think that the challenge is going to be that each party believes that he is going to be a problem at best for their opposition at worst for them and so for instance there's been talk about rfk Libertarian Party ticket. I don't think that is going to happen because I will say this for the Libertarian Party.
RFK is a very non-Libertarian person. Very non.
Like, the adjacent, it's not, it's, he, the ways in which he wants to wield the government on a host of issues, ranging from environmental issues which let's keep in mind that is where he started out like yeah not very libertarian um now that he could still attempt to run on that ticket but i don't think that the lp will permit that i do think that rfk can thread this very particular needle of being someone that appeals to people who are conservative on social issues, but fairly liberal on economic issues with regard to the welfare state, with regard to social security. You know, when you have conservative influencers and pundits saying like, why should anyone retire? Retirement will kill you.
Just work forever, as Ben Shapiro implied, I believe, yesterday. A candidate who is talking a lot about the need to build up the welfare state while espousing the same kind of anti-corporate, anti-quote unquote, big pharma attitudes that used to be something that like lefties talked about in the early 2000s like when you you have a candidate who can appeal to people who think of themselves as being conservatives while also sounding like somebody who would be at the wta protests in 1999 like that's an interesting through line yeah however i will also say like i think that i think that that's the concern also for biden like you have someone who can who sounds this particular way who can you know thread that particular needle that i think that is a that is a populace that neither party is reaching out to or understands that is not to say that like everyone should be aiming themselves at the vaccine skeptical conservative voter like that's you know that's not that big a population and also vaccines are cool and good but like i understand why both parties are concerned about this and i think like it is this list of potential candidates really speaks to the I'm not socially conservative I'm like the kind of the

like the kind of the, like the, the political middle that in political muddly middle of people who are also vaccine skeptical and really like state power, but also don't want to be told what to do, which is a large swath of people. Like, I think that I understand this list of people as being representative of that when you get Tulsi and Rand and Aaron Rodgers.
I get why people are worried. I get that.
It's anti-establishment, countercultural, and low trust at a time when people do not have a lot of faith in institutions and are pretty cranky. So yeah, that's like a toxic mix.
Kennedy's campaign also has like an extremely online feel to it. Heavy on conspiracy, grievance, fringe, weird.
DeSantis campaign was also very online. Didn't work out so well for him.
You wrote a piece that you and I talked about before on the 2020 Trump campaign being too online. And it does seem like the terminally online reactionary manosphere is the real driving energy in at least some segment of Republican politics right now.
I know you've been thinking and writing about this. What's your sense of what that's all about and sort of why it's bubbling up right now? Yeah, I think that first, I think it's helpful to explain what I mean by extremely or terminally online which is something john you you understand um very well being extremely online is not just being on the internet it is believing firmly and acting as if events that take place online matter to everyone offline um and the 2020 campaign was a great example of this because Donald Trump would

routinely go on the stump and talk about things that online conservatives were talking about all the time to audiences in like Iowa or Nebraska who were like, what in the fuck are you talking about? He went on the stump or would tweet at the time and would talk about how we need to repeal section 230 the communications decency act of 1997 now i love section 230 the communications act of 1997 uh that has to do with uh that you know how basically it says that like if you post something on facebook facebook is not liable for the thing you post if you post a comment on a, the person who runs that website, whether it's InfoWars or a recipe website with two long descriptions at the top that you have to scroll all the way through, they are not liable for that. That's awesome.
I love it. Donald Trump does not.
A lot of people do not. Most people don't know what it is or care.
And I think that the online-ification of the right, which I think that has been ramped up by the fact that X is now a, what I would argue to be a conservative, not conservative, like William F. Buckley conservative, but like a right-leaning social media outlet.
is, you know,

it's still incredibly popular with online conservatives and the people who care

what they think.

It means that you spend a lot of time fixated by issues and talking about

issues and hyping yourself up about issues that only matter to other members of the online right or the online left that hates the online right. And I think you saw this over and over again in 2022, where you had a midterm election where Biden did that speech about how this is about democracy.
This is about fighting against the forces that would end democracy democracy and the online right and like the super online left make fun of him and talk about how he looked like hitler and how it was scary and this is actually going to be a red wave because you're transing our kids and noms for liberty and libs of tiktok and blah blah blah blah and then you might recall there was no red wave that's the problem with this which is like this online right-wing activism has now like infected and taken over a lot of the party i mean it's the problem for them i think for i think if for democratic strategists it's to like lift up these examples right and it's not by the way these aren't just like online influencers. The Speaker of the House, Mike Johnson, he monitors his grown son's porn consumption.
He thinks there are dinosaurs on the Ark, on Noah's Ark. The guy that they're running for governor in North Carolina thinks Black Panther was a Jewish plot to scam black people.
You know, like they're all mad. A bunch of them are mad about recreational sex, but they also like ban, they want to ban all abortion, no exceptions, ban IVF, ban gay marriage, ban books, ban no fault divorce.
They want to replace it with covenant marriage. But they're also very mad that women aren't sexy anymore.
Like there are all these like AI things where it's just like showing like, here's what the ideal woman looks like. And also all of these ideal women happen to have 11 children and amazing breasts.
think they think they think that sydney sweeney's breasts are a victory against wokeism that's the that's i am so sorry sydney sweeney i am so sorry this is all so weird it is so weird but that is the energy of the party and a lot of republican politicians are just like they have bought this now yeah yeah and like you see i mean the host of defections coming from like people in Congress because like this is the onlineification of the right is happening in Congress too. Where you have people who are like the online nature.
And I will say also that this is a problem. This was a problem for Democrats as well because everybody has their weirdos you keep locked in the political closet.
That's a thing you have you gotta keep them locked in you got like in 2020 you had a host of people who were talking about how rioting was great and how this is awesome and then you know you had a lot of people looking at actual voting numbers from including like from working-class African-Americans who were like no it's not not cool at all and joe biden notably won the democratic primary out of what 85 people how many people ran for president among democrats in 2020 i believe it was 85 people and he is and to his credit he is very not online, like absolutely 100 percent not online.

I know he now has a TikTok now, but like that is run by nice people who are like 25 years

old.

That's fine.

This is a person who like in the State of the Union was like, I was born during the

Second World War.

I don't remember it, but I think about it a lot.

And I'm like, yeah, you do.

Of course you do.

But like that is something that is adjacent to reality and I think for the online right the challenge is that they are not adjacent to reality and then reality will take place and they are so put off by reality they retreat even more into the loving inverse of the online right but this is why i think that um republicans have been very good especially over the last couple years of like picking out like you said sort of the craziest anecdotes on the far left and highlighting them right and i do think that if for us to do that to them we don't have to pick some random conservative activist online or someone here they're like there's plenty of politicians that they're running for national office that are doing all these cpac is it cpac partying with literal nazis it's like actual nazis and then they're like no we weren't and then it's like no it actually there's jared taylor like yeah actual actual real nazis of potomac or whatever so i think it's a i do think it's like, no, it actually, there's Jared Taylor. Like, yeah, actual, actual real Nazis of Potomac or whatever.
So I think it's a, I do think it's going to be a big issue, a big issue to harp on in the fall for Democrats. Like again, because it's not just going to be about Trump.
It's going to be like, look at all these freaks they nominated, all these weirdos. Yeah.
Well, so Jane, thank you so much so much for joining Pod Save America. This was a lot of fun.
Thank you so much for having me anytime. You know, if Aaron Rodgers does get this VP spot, you gotta bring me back.
We'll bring you back. Oh no, we're gonna have a whole episode on that.
We're gonna have content for weeks if that happens. All right, everyone, we will be back with another episode Friday morning.
Take care. Bye, Jane to get ad free episodes exclusive content and more consider joining our friends of the pod subscription community at crooked.com slash friends and if you're already doom scrolling don't forget to follow us at pod save America on Instagram Twitter and YouTube for access to full episodes bonus content and more plus if you're as opinionated as we are, consider dropping us a review.
Pod Save America is a Crooked Media production. Our show is produced by Olivia Martinez and David Toledo.
Our associate producers are Saul Rubin and Farrah Safari. Kira Joachim is our senior producer.
Reid Cherlin is our executive producer. The show is mixed and edited by Andrew Chadwick.
Jordan Cantor is our sound engineer with audio support from Kyle Seglin

and Charlotte Landis. Writing support

by Hallie Kiefer. Madeline Herringer

is our head of news and programming. Matt

DeGroat is our head of production. Andy

Taft is our executive assistant. Thanks to

our digital team, Elijah Cohn, Haley

Jones, Mia Kelman, David Tolles,

Kirill Pellaviv and Molly Lobel. and Odyssey have been named the best cars for the money by U.S.
News and World Report. Save thousands with 0%, like the 24 Prologue with zero APR.
To drive the best, ask anyone who owns a Honda and search your local Honda dealer. See dealer for financing details.
Financing on credit approval. Offer ends 4-30-25.
View U.S. News best cars at cars.usnews.com.
This wasn't the adventure I had in mind when you said, let's rent a car in Italy. Relax.
GPS says we're on track. Wait, does that sign say Switzerland? No, no, no.
We should be near Sicily. Routing.
Want to actually enjoy your next trip? One that's completely mapped out? With Colette's small group explorations, you can. Our experts handle every detail, from great food to unique stays and local connections.
Start your next adventure today.

Visit GoCollette.com.

That's GoCollette.com.