#580 - Beauty Shop Butcher - Roebuck, South Carolina

Hey, everybody. Just going to take a quick break from the show to tell you a little bit about a delicious dog food, Ollie.
If your dog could talk, they'd want Ollie. They'd ask you for Ollie.
That's what I'm talking about. It's a fresh whole food diet.
It's not just delicious. It can add, like, years to your puppy's life.
Yeah. You want that good, healthy food that's more tail wagging.
And this is. This is real food.
Like, this stuff looks good. I'd eat it.
Yeah. That's how I was like, this looks pretty good.
I might sit down with you on the floor and you could share. It is nice to be able to pop something down on the floor for him that looks like something that you'd put over rice or whatever and eat it yourself.
That's what I mean. It looks great.
All you need to do, you fill out their 30 second quiz that Ollie has for you. They create a customized meal plan based on your puppy's weight and activity level and health info in general there.
You get expert recommendations. Dogs deserve the best, and that means fresh, healthy food.
Head to ollie.com slash STM. Tell them all about your dog and use code STM to get 60% off your welcome kit when you subscribe today.
Plus, they offer a clean bowl guarantee on the first box. So if you're not completely satisfied, you'll get your money back.
That's O-L-L-I-E dot com slash STM and enter code STM to get 60% off your first box. Now back to the show.
Hi, this is Steve Buscemi. You know, the actor.
Well, now I'm an actor and podcast host.

From piece of work entertainment and campsite media

in association with Olive Productions

comes Big Time, an Apple original podcast.

Each episode follows the story of one misfit with big dreams

who isn't afraid to bend a few rules

or take a shortcut to get there.

Well, who steals bees?

I was duped.

I shoot you in the leg. This is Big time.
Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts. Location The Lab.
Quinton only has 24 hours to sell his car. Is that even possible? He goes to Carvana.com.
What is this? A movie trailer? He ignores the doubters, enters his license plate. Wow, that's a great offer.

The car is sold, but will Carvana pick it up in time for...

They'll literally pick it up tomorrow morning.

Done with the dramatics?

Car selling in record time.

Save your time.

Go to Carvana.com and sell your car today.

Pickup fees may apply. Hello, everybody, and welcome back to Small Town Murder Express.

Yay and choo-choo!

Oh, yay indeed, Jimmy. Yay indeed.

My name is James Petrigallo. I'm here with my co-host.
I'm Jimmy Wissman. Thank you, folks, so much for joining us today on another crazy edition of Small Town Murder.
We have a lot today. This is like 10 pounds of murder in a two-pound bag, as usual.
We have a murder that's definitely solved, and then another one that might, we don't know. Yeah, we got a guy that might have done some really bad stuff to way more people than he's been been caught for so we'll talk all about that and more but first head over to shut up and give me murder.com what do you get there you may ask well merchandise obviously but more importantly tickets for live shows right get in there get your tickets for live shows especially the 420 virtual live show takes place on sat, April the 19th, day before 420.
And it'll be available for two weeks after that to buy and watch 100 times or do whatever you want with it for two weeks and have a lot of fun with it. We cannot wait just like a regular live show, except where are they, Jimmy? Right in their living room.
Wherever the hell they want to be. Anywhere with an internet connection in the entire planet Earth is where you can be.
So we're very excited for that. Definitely get your tickets right now just like a regular live show.
We are very excited. Also get your tickets for the regular live shows.
We have our next upper in May. We have St.
Louis in Chicago. St.
Louis sold out. You guys are the best down there.
Chicago, get in there and sell that bad boy out at the Riviera. We're excited.
Shut up and givememurder.com. Get them for the rest of the year, too, because they are going fast.
We have a lot of shows sold out after the summer, so definitely get your tickets right now. Also, get yourself Patreon.
Do yourself a favor. If you like our shows, if you listen to this, you listen to Crime in Sports, you listen to your stupid opinions, and you want more, Patreon's where you get it.

Patreon.com slash Crime in Sports is where you get all the bonus material, anybody $5 a month or above. You get everything, a whole back catalog of hundreds of episodes you've never heard of bonus stuff.
New stuff every other week, one crime in sports, one small town murder, and you get it all. This week is no different.
This week, which you're going to get for crime and sports we are going to talk about more sports songs more athletes singing terrible songs and we even have evil knievel reading poetry which is so all of that and more for small town murder you we're going to talk about lewis carlucci who is known as the as con one or the con man casanova and he had like conning all these women in new y in the eighties. And he was like, the whole city was looking for him and no one knew who he was or how to find him.
Craziest thing ever. We'll talk about that and more.
Patreon.com slash crime in sports. And you get a shout out at the end of the regular show as well.
That said, I think it's time, everybody. Here we go.
Let's do this. I think it's time to sit back.
Let's all clear the lungs. Arms to the sky.
Let's all shout, Shut up and give me murder. Let's do this, everybody.
Okay. Let's go on a trip, shall we? We are going to South Carolina this week.
Okay, fine. This is Roebuck, South Carolina.
R-O-E R-O-E-B-U-C-K. Roebuck.
Yeah, that's a long time. Northwestern South Carolina this is.
This is nowhere near Myrtle Beach or anything like that. This is up toward North Carolina and Tennessee and all that over there.
It is about an hour and a half to Charlotte. That's the closest major city.

So you can tell it's up there more.

About four hours to Nixonville, South Carolina. That's down by Myrtle Beach, actually.

It was our last episode, The Ballad of Bambi, which was crazy.

Definitely a crazy episode.

People living in the yard in a tent and then there's murder.

It's crazy.

This is in Spartanburg County. Population here, 3,482.
It's a small town and it was even smaller back when we're going to talk about it. So it's very small median household income here.
The rest of the country, about 69,000 here, 54,153 lower median home price, 275,500. So it's pretty good.
Not bad on $54,000 a year, that's a tough one. That's a tough one.
History of this town, a little bit of it. It was named for Revolutionary War officer Benjamin Roebuck.
And Roebuck, the town, not the man, is home to the Walnut Grove Plantation, which is a preserved 18th century farmhouse and tourist attraction. Oh, boy.
And one of the daughters of the original owners, Kate Moore, was a scout for General Daniel Morgan during the Battle of Cowpens. A girl was? Yeah.
She was rocking it out. The county was founded in 1785 and named after the Spartan Rifles, which were a Spartan regiment, which was the local militia during the American Revolutionary War.
So they're very much into the Revolutionary War in this part, which is nice because there's a lot of parts of South Carolina that are into a different war. The ship, the USS Spartanburg County is named after Spartanburg County.
So there's that. Reviews of this town.
We've never been there. I don't know anything about Roebuck, South Carolina.
Here's five stars. Roebuck is a small community that's quiet and easy to get around.
It's tight-knit, safe, and serene. I've lived in Roebuck for nine years now, and the most danger I've been in is when a snake poked its nose into the family backyard.

Okay. Okay.
You really can't. No matter how much policing you have, I don't think it's going to help that situation.
And you know, I think. A rural snake.
Given the choice, I think I'd rather have something I can call the police on, depending on how poisonous that snake is. That's what we're talking about, because I have like garter snakes in my house.
They're fine. They don't bother me.
Some snakes. All of my closest friends live in Roebuck as well, and the town has been a key part of growing up for all of us.
The community keeps you grounded, and the people are down to earth. It isn't that far from restaurants of the city making it easy to go to and from.
What city? I have no idea what they're talking about. What do they consider a city? Yeah.
I don't know. What does a restaurant of the city sound and look like? Not sure.
Four stars. I love Roebuck because of the atmosphere.
Everyone feels like family. I love driving down the road and seeing huge fields of corn and wildflowers.
I wish there was a little more to do and more stores and restaurants in Roebuck. But overall, I love living here.
And then it wouldn't be a small town that you love with corn. They put those strip malls in the fields where the corn and the wild flowers used to be, and then you complain about that.
Four stars, small town. That's the first sentence.
We get it. Around five minutes from the pure countryside.
Pure. Pure.
No anything. Raw and uncut.
Uncut. Fucking not stepped on at all.

Yeah. Naturally

cool and comfortable weather. Very

close distance and easy access to

Highway 221. Oh, well

now I'm going to move there. I wasn't

into it before, but now you say

it's close to Highway 221.

That's where everything's happening.

On the old Highway 221. Things to do here.
We have the FestiFall. Oh, okay.
FestiFall. Come time travel with us to the back country of South Carolina.
No, thanks. No.
How far? Depends on how far back we're going. How far are we going? We're going to the we going 70s maybe experience life in 1781 during the american revolutionary war with live demonstrations of cannon fire cooking spinning camp life music and more sounds like a 1781 themed joint here which that's the wrong it's the wrong renaissance fair man yeah that's yeah you show up and you're flowing shit dressed like a wizard and they're like the hell are you doing boy what's wrong with you and then children's activities happening all day including candle dipping quill writing tin punching tricorn hats you can't get the kids to stop quill writing that's the thing my.
My kids, the whole growing up, it was just like, well, you stop it with that quill already. Put it down.
Play a video game or something. Get on fucking social media.
Wink asleep in here with all the tin punching. It's constant.
The tin punching, constant candle dipping. We have enough candles, kids.
With your tricorn hats quill writing all over the place. It's enough, damn it.
What's a tricorn hat? I guess it's the corn that has the three different colors in it. Yeah, they make the hats.
How do you make that shit a hat? Who the fuck knows what they're doing down there. Horn books.
I don't know what that is. And sweet bags.
What the fuck is that? Sweet bags. They sound like they're just mad living words together now.
Saturday, also, there will be a bluegrass concert. They don't say who will be there, but they'll be playing bluegrass and they'll be live and in concert.
That said, let's talk about some murder, shall we? Alright, let's do this. Let's start out with a young lady.
Dana Shailene Fowler is how she's born. Dana here.
She's born November 16th, 1967 in Spartanburg, which is nearby. That's the city.
It's the county seat and all that kind of thing. And she's a really, she's an outgoing girl and all this type of thing and grows up to be real pretty too and I'll show you a picture of her here she looks a lot like like married with children era Christina Applegate that's who she looks like very much like that she looks like fun yeah she's a pretty girl so she looks like I said that picture's from like the late 80s, too.
She looks like Christina Applegate.

Yeah, she does.

Big nails and shit, red nails.

In high school, she met a young man and got married as soon as they graduated.

Well, smart move, man.

Yeah, he's like, I'm going to try to lock that down.

But it didn't work out very well.

No?

They had a daughter named Ashley right away.

And then it fell apart after she gave birth.

You know, because they were 19 and had a baby. and that's difficult.
It's not an easy thing. Then she met Paul Michael Satterfield.
He's known as Mike. Mike Satterfield.
He's born in 1962, you know, about five years older. And he, I mean, physically, I don't mean to be shitty to the guy, but.
Oh guy but oh he won god damn this guy looks like a fucking inflated balloon yeah he's a he's a peter griffin he's a very very chunky man let's just say and not like an attract not like a hot guy either you know what i mean not like oh if he was just you know he's he's big but he's a handsome big he's a yeah he looks like a guy no matter what he weighed he wouldn't look very good and he also has an enormous gut that's hanging over his belly he looks like he's probably uh he needs a doctor yeah somebody needs to tell him some things big time so they have a son named brandon and uh owns his own HVAC company. So he's doing heating and air conditioning here.
Now, this goes on for a while, and their marriage is okay for a few years. And then by 1995, though, they start to have some problems.
Dana, when the kids were very young, she stayed home with the kids, and Mike did his business. And Dana would work kind kind of part time here and there to supplement the income but as the kids got school age she decided she wanted to do something with herself so she opened up her own beauty salon great it's a beauty and tanning place that she owns so she does that by 1995 though Dana and Mike are separated here they're talking a divorce, and they have moved out from each other, and it's not going well here for them.

But it's not acrimonious, really.

Really?

I would assume not, because on July 30th, 1995, they're separated, they're living apart, everything like that.

They spend the night of July 30th together with the children, eat dinner, watch TV, and spend the night together on July 30th. So there's definitely like a – they're not, you know, in a heated divorce or anything like that.
They're just – it's not working out. So, by the way, a little about her salon.
It's called Roebuck Beauty and Tanning Salon. Yeah.
And that's where she she has to go the next morning she's got clients and shit coming in and he has to go install fucking vents so he's gotta crawl in somebody's attic he's got i don't think this guy's crawling in anybody's no i don't trust my trusses when they made a crawl space they said nobody like three bills is gonna crawl in here right no that's enough crawl space for everybody right and if they are they'll hire somebody right yeah this dude is not fitting through into your fucking vent i'll tell you that much he's gonna have feet kicking out of it if you try so they get up the next morning scramble to get ready for work and all that kind of thing and they make plans to again have dinner that evening okay so for a divorcing couple the things seem to be going pretty well. They're getting along pretty well.
They're getting along. So this is July 31st, 1995.
And it's down here. And she works a whole day.
He goes to work, does his HVAC. And then he has the kids after work.
And she has her salon. And she has appointments here.
A woman named Patty Taylor arrives at the salon at 6.30 p.m. on July 31st for a hair appointment.
And after she arrives another woman named Diane Harris shows up selling products, a cleaning product to, you know, I'm sure to get dye off of shit or something like that and made a demonstration for her.

She said, let me show you what I'm doing. So she said, sure, she's doing this lady's hair.
They both watched Diane Harris do a demonstration. And then Dana ends up purchasing a bottle of the cleaner from this woman.
Great. And this woman's like going door to door of all the businesses trying to sell them cleaner.
Fuck. I don't know.
So that sounds like a tough job. Yeah.
So she, Dana continues to work on this Patty Taylor's hair until, um, a little before they kind of, she gets there about six 30. They're going in with the hair by seven.
They're really doing it. Cause she's got to wash it and do all that kind of shit.
And then by eight, they finish up with the hair. So during this time, um, you know, she's finishing it up and Dana is sweeping and cleaning up the shop getting ready to close it up for the night Taylor pays her and Dana walks this Patty Taylor to the door and tells Patty Taylor that I have some clothes in the dryer and then I'm going to be right behind you leaving here right now and so this woman said oh you want me to stay until you lock your shop up that way you don't have to sit here by yourself and you know it's dark out and that kind of thing she said no no that's okay she said i'll be right behind you it's only i have five minutes left on the dryer so you know don't you don't have to stand here waiting for me it's five minutes don't worry about it so she said she left the shop at about 8 10 8 15 this patty taylor takes off um now simultaneously to all this going, there is a couple of guys hanging out at a bowling alley nearby.
Just chilling here. David Michael Pace and Jonathan Christian Vick.
And they're both 17 years old, went to high school together. I think David might be a year older than Jonathan, but Jonathan is 17.
Jonathan Christian Vick. And, you know, they became friends in high school and have been friends since then.
Michael Pace or David Michael Pace works at the bowling alley, and Vick would come by a couple times a month on a Friday or Saturday night. You know, 17, cruising the bowling alley for all the chicks.
So he, this particular night, Jonathan Vick comes in to visit his friend at work and he's hanging out at the bowling alley. He's wearing my Vic is where I want to call him Michael Vick, but he's Jonathan Vick.
He's wearing blue jeans and light colored shirt. Vic is talking to his friend Pace about a lady named Dana.
OK, who owns a hair salon. I know her.
And he said that, I'm going to ask her out tonight. Oh, tonight.
He's 17. She's a married 27-year-old woman with two kids.
Who owns her own business. 27-year-old two-time.
Attractive woman. Yeah.
About to be two-time divorcee, though. Yeah.
At 17, you're not scoring that broad. You are absolutely not scoring that broad.
Absolutely have no chance at that shit whatsoever. You may think she...
I'm sure she's nice to you when she cuts your hair, but that doesn't mean she wants to have sex with your teenage ass. So Vic had spoken about Dana to Pace on a couple of occasions telling him like she's hot you know dana that works at the hair salon man she's fine isn't she there's a lot of hot chicks man hot chick over there and she might be the hottest chick in town you know what i mean probably yeah so she said you know this slate she cuts my hair man whoo she's real fine and all that kind of thing.
So at the end, this particular night, Vic tells Pace that Dana was having problems with her husband. That's how small of a town it is.
That some fucking high school kid knows when you're having problems with your husband. I feel like I got an in.
Yeah. She's having problems with her husband.
And he said, I'm going to ask Dana out, and I hope she'll go on a date with me.

Yeah.

Where?

To the bowling alley?

What are you talking about?

What kind of date are you going to take this woman on?

This guy laughed in Vic's face.

Yeah.

That's the right answer, man.

He said, you're out of your fucking mind.

He said, she's older.

You're way too young for her.

You have nothing going on for you. You live with your parents.
what are you gonna do she's she's been fucked by a man she's not gonna want you ever no a fat man she likes men not boys so vick got pissed off at the guy was like hey fuck you i got a shot with her they were arguing at the bowling bowling alley. This guy is like laughing, catching his breath.
And Vic's like, that's bullshit. You don't think, I think she'll go out with me.
I got a shot. I got as good a shot as anybody.
No, you don't. Stupid.
Vic, you're so delusional. You don't even see that you've got a really great friend in front of you.
That's laughing in your face. A good friend laughs in your face when you say dumb shit like that.
So then you don't follow through with it because they laughed in your face.

You're like, oh, trying to save you from embarrassment, man.

Yes.

So that's how it goes.

Then he said he hoped that Dana, he said, I hope she'll say yes to my date.

And then he said he starts graphically describing of what he'd like to do to her, including that he would, quote, bend her over her barber chair and perform sexual acts on her.

I'm sorry. And then he said he starts graphically describing of what he'd like to do to her, including that he would, quote, bend her over her barber chair and perform sexual acts on her.
And we can assume which ones he's talking about. He further then went on to state other sexual conduct he would like to have take place with Dana.
I love how a court document puts that, by the way. This is what I would like to have take place with dana i'd like to have my penis and put it here yeah that is hilarious get whatever's so this goes on this goes on for an hour wow back and forth and this guy's just never he never was like maybe you do have a chance he's like you're out of your fucking mind yeah she's hot i'm sure we'd all like to do that but give me a break here so then vick this guy's work shift ends and vick agrees to give his friend a ride home during the drive he continues to say i'm serious by the way i'm going over there i'm asking her, and she's going to go out with me.
Kept defending himself, and he was mad at pace for laughing at him. Wow.
Such a good friend. He could never be a comedian, this guy.
No. No self-awareness, and then when someone laughs at you, you don't laugh also.
You get mad. Hey, how dare you to say I'm stupid? He should go, I had this dumb thought once and that would be a whole that would be like a three minute bit where I thought I could fuck this hot lady who was 10 years older than me.
So he, Vic dropped Pace off at about 645 or 7 p.m. As Pace exited the vehicle, Vic told him that he was going to go get his haircut right now.
I'm going to go get a haircut from Dana and see what happens.

You're going to walk in at that time of night and expect a haircut? Well, that's what this guy says, too. He says that you're going to, what the fuck? He said, it's kind of late.
By the time you get there, you're still going to get a haircut? And he said, oh, Dana keeps her salon open late, and she knows I'm coming, so she'll be there for me. So the vehicle that pace was dropped off in by Vic was a blue and white Ford Bronco with distinctive saw blade wheels.
And we know exactly what those wheels are. Yeah.
You know, those ones look like louvers almost. Yeah.
So now a week earlier. Okay.
Let's talk about that. A week earlier, there was someone sitting in the chair named Darlene Reeves while Dana was doing her hair at the salon.
Jonathan Vick's mother called Dana and asked Dana to fix Vick's hair. Number one, this is how you know she's not going to fuck you.
Your mom calls and makes your hair appointments. Your mom calls and asks for fixes of your hair appointments.
Which is your mom's not setting up like dates for you here this is not how this is working so um now this woman who was in the chair said that dana was like exasperated by the situation like jesus christ what the fuck and told this after she hung up told the customer customer that I'm not going to accommodate that.

I'm not going to fix his hair.

Fuck this.

You know, they're a pain in the ass.

Now, the saleswoman, Diane Harris here, the one who sold the bottle of cleanser while this was going on.

She, by the way, lived in Charlotte.

She was basically she's part of a they sell like door to door this cleaning supplies. So they just take people to a location and drop off a bunch of salesmen and let them walk around and then drive them an hour 45 back to Charlotte.
Move this shit. Move the product.
Fuck, man. That's brutal.
Like an old vacuum salesman or something. So she said she went to the salon 630 or 640 after giving the demonstration and made a sale with her.
And she said she was scheduled to meet back at her designated spot to be picked up with the other salespeople at 830 p.m. So she was to be the last salesperson picked up before heading back to Charlotte.
After leaving the shop, Diane Harris walked around the area making calls on different houses and businesses, just trying to figure it out, trying to sell some cleaner. So at about 810, she walked through the parking lot of the salon after she had already been there an hour earlier, at which time she saw Dana through the window of the salon and spoke to her.
And she said she appeared to be cleaning and that Dana waved at her as she walked by. Like, oh, you're the cleaning supply lady.
There you go. I think she was using her thing.
So this woman continued to try to sell things before heading back to the pickup spot at 8.30. As she reached the salon parking lot, she noticed that the lights were on, but the blinds were now down.
So she had walked by before, blinds were up waving. Now she walks back.
The blinds are down. At the same time, she hears thumping sounds coming from inside the building.
When she looked around, she observes a man falling out of the salon's window. Oh.
A man falling out of the window. No, no, no.
Open window. Oh, okay.
Falling out. The screen pops out.
The screen's already out. And you see a man climbing out of the window.
No, no, no. Open window.

Oh, okay.

Falling out. The screen pops out.
The screen's already out, and you see a man climbing out of a window. Okay.
Harris, she was like, what the fuck, and got scared and threw all of her shit down and ran. Oh.
She just took off, threw all of her fucking cleaning supplies, everything, just threw it down and left. as she ran around the building in one direction.

She said the man ran around the other direction, and they came face-to-face on the other side of the building like a bad cartoon. Yeah.
So Harris then ran out into the middle of the street and started screaming because she was scared of this guy. That's a wild reaction.
i mean there was no words exchanged yeah so she ran um into a home she just busted into somebody's house yeah ran in slammed the door behind her locks it and tells the residents to call 9-1-1 because dame over here this lady at the beauty shop needs help that's what she says okay so, she said that the man she saw coming out of the window and again at the back of the building was the same man. And he would quote was white and looked crazy.
Well, crazy white boy jumping out the window. That's all I got.
He was wearing a gray or white t-shirt, pair of blue jeans and a pair appeared to be between 20 and 30 years old.

Now, there's a guy named Michael Crook, and he was driving towards Spartanburg at 830 when he observed Diane Harris.

He said he saw a black woman walking and then saw a white male who was bent down and was

looking back toward Dana's salon.

And he was wearing grayish-colored blue jeans and a grayish-colored T-shirt. This is all the same guy.
So the police arrive based on this 911 call. They don't even know what the hell this is.
They don't know if she's being paranoid or what's going on here, but they get there about 8.50. They arrive at the scene here, or the call comes in then, and then they get there about 10 minutes later, 9 o'clock.

A deputy Burnett found the only door

to the establishment is

partially cracked, and a

screen from a window is on the ground

with the window open.

Hey everybody,

just going to take a quick break from the show

and tell you a little bit about our safest

sponsors, Simply Safe.

And everyone has routines that you go through, make you feel good feel good make you feel secure like you have control over the world and a lot of times you don't but you do if you're us and it's on your routine includes arming your simply safe home security system you know that's gonna do well for you so when we're heading out both of us we both have them in our houses our studios lock up for the night. Yeah.
This simple step does more than just protect you. It gives you peace of mind.
You're going to feel good about leaving and then you're going to know it's going to be the same when you get back. You'll sleep more soundly.
I can leave the house with confidence and it's amazing how a push of a button can give you that kind of confidence. And with Simply Safe, we love it.
Like I said, it's in our studios, in our homes.

It's really easy to install, too. You can get

professional installation also, but

if we can put it up, you can put it up.

Put it that way. Visit

SimpliSafe.com slash small

to claim 50% off a

new system with a professional monitoring

plan and get your first month

free. That's SimpliSafe.com

slash small. S-I-M-P-L-I safe.com slash small.
There's no safe like SimpliSafe. And now back to the show.
Hey, everybody, just going to take a quick break from the show to tell you a little bit about a delicious sponsor, Thrive Market. We have both been trying to eat healthy.
Thrive Market is where you go. And that's why we like Th these ingredients and you're like i don't know what that is yeah it's hard to figure out what's good for you and what's not but thrive has it all in one convenient spot they have everything they're a no junk online grocery store that bans over 1 000 harmful ingredients and their team of product researchers like i love a cookie okay i like a cookie i like a cookie.
I like a chocolate chip cookie. I like almonds maybe in it.
They have a delicious alternative I found here that is a gluten-free almond chocolate cookie, and it's delicious. And I'm like a cookie snob, too.
I usually don't like anything that's off. I don't know.
I want sugar and all that. But no, these are delicious, and they're gluten-free, and they're really good.

Outstanding. Try them out.
You can find better options way easily with Thrive Market's Healthy Swap Scanner. You can scan a product, and it instantly recommends cleaner alternatives.
That's great. So if you know you like this, but this isn't good for you, let's find a better alternative.
Are you ready to make the switch? Go to thrivemarket.com slash smalltownmurder for 30% off your first order plus a free $60 gift. That's T-H-R-I-V-E market.com slash smalltownmurder.
Thrivemarket.com slash smalltownmurder. Okay.
I was like, okay, this is strange. The lights are all off in the shop.
So he took, he went in and took a flashlight, which was good. He didn't touch anything.
Yeah. Yeah.
Decent police work, um, shined his flashlight into a common all around the shop. And then he got to the bathroom laundry room, which is a combination room here.
Fucking shines the flashlight and he finds Dana in there.

Okay.

Not okay.

She has a strap around her neck.

Oh, boy.

From a duffel bag.

And is hanging from the hot water heater with her feet two inches off the ground.

Oh, no.

Yeah, not good.

She's covered in cuts and bruises. Her face and hair are covered in blood.
Yeah. This is not good.
She's dead. That's a terrible way to find anybody.
He said her clothes were pulled away from her body. Her head was, quote, dramatically cocked to one side based on her hanging thing.
Oh, God, Jesus. Oh, man, it's fucking horrible.
Hanging from a strap around her neck, which was connected to the hot water heater. It appeared to have been that she had been strangled with a duffel bag strap and was left hanging from that.
Like we said, bruises all over her, an inch or two off the ground, blood in her hair on her face, bruises and cuts on her face, and her tongue appeared to protrude from her mouth. Fuck, man.
A white T-shirt on the top of her body was covered in blood that she was wearing and she was naked from the, uh, from the waist down with her pants on her left ankle. Oh, for Christ's sake.
Yeah. It's, it's fucking horrifying, man.
The investigation of the scene reveals all the blood was contained in the bathroom where she was found. So there's not like a,unk of blood out in the salon area or anything like that.
The room showed evidence that a struggle had certainly taken place in there. There's blood on walls.
It looks like, yeah, this wasn't easy. Her pocketbook, wallet, and checkbook are all in the salon.
Not robbery. As well as the business cash book and checkbox, cash box and checkbook, and the wallet and cash box together contained over $200 in cash.
So if you're looking to rob a place, that's not the shit you leave. I don't think they just stole some new cleaning product and took off here.
So the wounds here, the pathologist performs an autopsy on Dana and noted that she had a deep abrasion on her forehead, as well as other superficial abrasions and numerous contusions about her head, neck, upper chest, elbows, arm, wrist, knees and ankle. This like she fucking was pushed out of a car like that's those are a lot of wounds to fuck, man.
Her hyoid bone appeared appeared fractured indicating that she'd probably been strangled or at least had significant pressure around her neck at some point here um they said that uh could have been caused by a ligature or manual strangulation the pathologist believed that she was probably strangled manually as well as with use of a ligature examination of her brain also revealed extensive hemorrhaging caused by blunt force trauma. And she was sexually assaulted as well.
So the violence of the attack made the cops think this and the fact that nobody stole anything makes them really think this is personal as shit. Like this, even if it's just somebody off the street that comes in to try to rape somebody, they probably grabbed 200 bucks on the way out to, you know what I mean? I don't think it would be outside of their moral like spectrum to be able to steal money is after you've raped and killed.
So they, obviously they said, this seems like it's gotta be somebody that knows her. That's very angry at her.
So a state agent, the SLED agent here, what's the state investigative thing? They an agent here, an expert in the area of DNA and serology or serology said that she processed the crime scene for fluids. She examined the body and noticed that there was possible semen in the victim's pubic region here.
So remembering that she had seen this when she processed the scene, she later tested the evidence from a rape kit which contained pubic hair combings hoping to find semen. The sample tested positive for semen.
okay and they were able able to develop a DNA profile from this semen sample that they have. So they have a DNA profile.
So now it's just matching whatever. So they're talking to witnesses here trying to figure something else out.
They have a guy named Jerry Mills who said he knew about the shop and knew where it was and it was in the same area of where he worked. He said he drove by the area around 5 or 5.30 on that afternoon and didn't notice anything out of the ordinary.
However, just before dusk, he drove back through and observed a Ford Bronco parked in a place where his employer did not allow parking because it was by his job. And he said none of his coworkers drove a vehicle like that.
So that was somebody else. He pulled up closer to the car to check it out, but no one was around the vehicle.
He was going to tell them, hey, you're not allowed to park here. He described the Bronco as a late 80s car, blue with white or light cream colored top with, quote, nice rims on the tires that did not look like factory rims and may have been like a razor type of rim, he said.
Or saw blade. You never know.
Blade. So they interviewed Diane Harris, the saleswoman here.
She nervously explained that she came face to face, heard the thumping sound, found someone on the ground in front of an open window. She said, quote, I seen a man come out of that window with his shirt pulled up like he had fell.
She said she ran to the left. He ran to the right.
And then she said they came face to face. She said she saw him for a split second.
She said, quote, he looked crazy over and over again. He looked crazy.
He looked crazy. That's all she would say.
He was white with brown hair, wearing a light colored T-shirt and jeans. And that's when she ran to a nearby trailer to call 911.
So she was all fucked up about it, but she also gives a lot of details to create a composite sketch, and we'll get to that in a minute. First person they have to really talk to is Mike, is the husband.
They're in the middle of a divorce. So dead lady, middle of a divorce.
We're chit-chatting with you.

Doesn't match this lady's description, but we're going to talk about it. He said he first learned something was wrong about 9 p.m.
when a fellow church member of his called to say that officers were all around his wife's beauty salon. What's going on? So he got in his car, went to the salon, and the deputies wouldn't let him inside, wouldn't tell him anything that was going on.
Then they talked to him, and he downplayed the stories that their marriage was in trouble. He said, we were just together last night.
We're going to have dinner tonight. This is crazy.
I don't know what you're talking about. And so they were saying, they were thinking maybe he hired somebody to do this.
Sure. He obviously couldn't have done it himself just based on popping out of that window, which would have been physically impossible for literally he couldn't fit through that window it's a trailer window he would have probably taken the whole wall down with him if he tried to fucking climb out of that thing so that's what they're wondering so they said shit there's a lot of questions here he supplies a solid alibi for himself he's home with the kids who are old enough to say we didn't leave and dad was here all night.
Because her daughter Ashley's eight at that point. So she's one there.
And he passes a polygraph test as well. That's good.
Okay. So they clear him as a suspect.
He's got an alibi polygraph test. They haven't been like fighting over the divorce or anything.
So they't know now let's go back to jonathan christian vick here remember this guy um well pace his friend he said the next time he saw him was a few days later in a pool hall he ran into vick and he stated that vick walked up and bumped into him in a serious manner vick then told pace if i tell anybody he would kill me and he said what the about what what are you talking about and vick said that pace he said you know or you'll find out oh so a couple of days or to a few weeks after the incident we don't know a few days or a week or something after this pool hall deal pace realized what vick did not want him to discuss was when he saw a report on the news that described a vehicle similar to Vic's and showed a sketch that resembles Vic as well. That we'll show you in a second here.
So the detectives then turned their attention to the witness reports of seeing a white and blue vehicle in the area, which he drives. So they looked all around Roebuck for the vehicle and turned up a possible match.
Marianne Vick, one of Dana's customers and Jonathan's mother, has a similar car. So they said the Vick vehicle wasn't, the one witness said the Vick vehicle wasn't a perfect match with the one he'd seen though, which people have terrible memories when it comes to cars, colors, especially at dusk.
You have no idea what color a car is at dusk. No one does.
Yeah, but that thing seems like it sticks out a bit. It sticks out a bit.
But he said it's sort of like it, but it's a small town. There isn't another one that's kind of like it, but the rims are different.
It's not like that here. It's the only one.
And a Bronco looks like a Blazer as much as it looks like like a Dodge Ram charger. They all make the same thing.
They're all similar. And at dusk, you have no idea what color or what model it is.
Who the hell knows? So, you know, well, we all know a Bronco after the OJ shit. But not the 80s ones.
Anyone can pick out Bronco had taillights after that, but besides that. A 92, or was it a 94? I don't know.
Was it a 92? Is or a 90 Bronco I think he had a 93 the one that 93 the one that OJ had was a 93 yeah and you can't find him now no no they burned them all exploded no I mean people keep them no I know I'm kidding it's crazy so they ended up they're awaiting the results of the rape kit and all that kind of thing. They spend months interviewing all of Dana's customers.
All of their, I mean, basically everybody in town is interviewed over this. There's nobody getting away from this.
If you're not like an old lady who didn't go to her salon, you're getting questioned. So three months after the murder, David Michael Pace anonymously calls the cops and says, Jonathan Vick, and hangs up, basically.
Anonymous call. You're looking for this guy.
So that is wild. Then it was on a TV show that he saw the murder, so he contacted law enforcement for a second time, again anonymously, giving this person's name, which doesn't help.
It's hard to get. It's really hard to get like any kind of warrant based on an anonymous tip.
That's the problem. There's no no nothing to attribute it to.
It could be somebody's enemy going. It's them.
And then you go arrest them. That's great.
Girlfriend that hates her husband or boyfriend. Who knows anything.
Yeah. Yeah.
How many people people called and said i think my boyfriend's ted bundy so many fucking thousands literally thousands of people called yeah so on a third occasion during an unrelated bowling alley

trip here yeah he uh he ran into a cop and informed an officer pace does that he might know who was

responsible for dana's murder and gave the officer a name but wouldn't give the officer his name

Thank you. and informed an officer, Pace does, that he might know who was responsible for Dana's murder and gave the officer a name but wouldn't give the officer his name.

Again, anonymous.

He's like, listen, check this guy out.

That's all I'm going to say.

So that doesn't really work.

So the composite sketch here, she did a couple of different composite sketches

on two different occasions a month after the murder, and then two years later,

she was asked

to identify the man from a six-person photo lineup but pick different men and both of them so she's not a big help here uh here is the sketch by the way okay it's not the husband we fucking know that no that's his lip is very interesting but that could just be trying to be artistic yeah yeah, we don't know. But it looks like a 30s man.
Yeah. Kind of hardened.
Yeah, hardened, square jaw. Yeah, mean looking.
Yeah. Stern, I would say.
So the 1996 here, Aaron Popkin purchases a 1998 blue and white Ford Bronco with sawblade wheels from the Vick family. Really? Yes.
He said he met with Jonathan Vick at Jonathan's job after seeing an ad for the car. But when Popkin offered to loan Vick one of his cars while his mechanic kept the Bronco for inspection, he said, I'm going to take it and have a guy look at it.
You can use my car while we do that. Vic told Popkin that he was suspicious that Popkin might actually be a police

officer, So no. This guy's like, what are you talking about? I'm just trying to buy your Bronco.
Do you want to sell the car or not, man? And even if I was a cop, I want to buy a Bronco. Who cares? I'm just buying it.
Vic is very suspicious, so they worked out an alternate arrangement for inspection of the car.

Weird.

1997, this case is on Unsolved Mysteries now.

Okay.

So it gets national attention here.

Yeah.

That brings in the FBI and John Douglas, actual mind hunter himself here, John Douglas.

He does a workup and does a profile on this and says that he thinks that the killer is probably an average guy nothing special about him he said the person responsible is not a ghoulish individual that you would, you know, blood dripping off his teeth not that kind of guy, he's a guy you would see every day doing normal things he spent more than 25 hours, John Douglas did reviewing the case and found the killer was probably waiting until darkness to enter the hair and tanning salon to do this, but it's not a guy that you would expect, basically. So a year goes by.
A couple years go by, obviously. Then they get a potential tip.
A tip from an inmate who said his cellmate, Russell Quinn, carries a picture of Dana Satterfield around with him in jail and said he was involved in the crime. What? That's not normal at all.
Now, police know that cellmate shit can be bad. But when Harris, then Harris, the saleswoman, identified a mugshot of Quinn from a photo array as the man she saw jump from the shop window.
Okay. So now they're like, okay, but this is also like the third person she's picked out of a lineup that's a different person.
So that's not helpful. But he's got a picture of her for real? Got a picture of her.
They go, there's a real easy way to find out. Yeah.
Open that mouth, chief. I don't know if they did blood back then or what.
Swipe it up. They did the DNA.

Not a match.

Why would he do that?

Not a match.

The prosecutor said science doesn't lie.

Back to square one.

Like nothing we could do with that.

He's just a lunatic.

He can admit to it all day and night.

Doesn't matter.

He didn't do it.

So lucky they have DNA.

20 years earlier, they'd have just convicted him of murder.

It would have been done. That's it.
There's no anything. So 2005 comes around.
Yes, I said that right. 2005, 10 years later.
Now, Dana's daughter is now 18 years old. Ashley is her name.
She's now 18 years old. Looks a lot like her mom, too.
A blonde and all that kind of thing. Yeah.
She goes to get an oil change for her car simple you know normal thing just living her life you know not looking for her mother's murderer at this point in time she's living her life it's 10 years ago well guess who works at the gas station or at the service station where she does it is michael pace remember him our buddy there yeah he works and and Ashley comes in. He sees Ashley and learned that she was Dana's daughter and felt horrible.
He saw her and was like, oh, this poor girl's never, she lost her mom when she was a kid. He feels terrible.
So he contacts the cops again, this time actually giving him his identity and the reasons why he thinks they should look into Jonathan Vick. So now the cops are like, OK, now we have a real person with corroboration of something.
Now we can get a warrant here and enough information to force Vick to submit a DNA sample because you have to get a warrant. Someone doesn't want to do that.
So he does this. They interview, first of all, while they're waiting for the DNA, they interview Vic's former girlfriend who spoke of his violence.
That's not good. She also said that he'd threatened her as they drove past Dana's shop one time.
What? I don't know what that means. I will fucking hang you from a hot water heater like that hairstylist.

That is crazy that that's what happened to her and then they didn't get somebody right now.

No.

That would fuck me up every day until they caught him. Yeah.

So at the same time, in the last 10 years, he had joined the Marines.

He's had several jobs.

He assaulted both male and female fellow Marines while he was in the Corps and was punished on two separate occasions for convictions on articles of assault and eventually received a general discharge. It couldn't even take four years of this place.
Let's part ways type of deal. Yeah.
My God. His former supervisor called him a pathological liar with a violent temper, saying he would bait female Marines and bait is in quotes.

That's what he that's his words he would bait female marines through flattery for dates and then change his behavior once they got out he would be mean to them and hit them and shit um one said quote i had one that came this is the sergeant major here i had one that came to me and she said, Sergeant Major Smith, there's something wrong with him. We went out and he's a whole different person.
He's like Dr. Jekyll and Mr.
Hyde. So they were like, interesting.
So they get a written statement from Pace, so they have everything, now they're just waiting on the DNA sample here, and they get that in and the DNA sample matches his profile from the semen sample found at the scene. They said it's the probability of randomly selecting an unrelated individual having the DNA profile matching the semen was about one in 900 million.
So it's either him or some guy in Sri Lanka. We don't know.
One of the two. could pick which one but there's only i mean that means there's only seven other people on the planet that could have done that could have done it yeah and they probably don't aren't anywhere near roebuck south carolina on the planet on the planet probably not in roebuck south carolina driving a fucking bronco that fits everybody's shit and also who talked about how bad he wanted to fuck the victim either.
Yeah. And if it was somebody else, the odds of those two people being in the same town of Roebuck, South Carolina.
Unbelievable. Way higher.
What are those odds? Is anybody out there good at math? Let's figure that shit out. Wow.
So October 24th, 2005, he is arrested uh hauled him in here by then he's a married man with a baby oh no has a history of arrests for both domestic violence and vandalism outside of the military as well as in the military uh history of antagonizing co-workers and being fired. Oh, and then there's one other thing.

In 2002, his girlfriend disappeared and was never solved and she was never found.

He has a woman in his life that disappeared and we don't know where she is.

His fiance disappeared.

What?

Yes.

Okay.

Since then, he's lived.

I'm going to give you a guess of two states he lived in in the last 10 years.

Could that be Florida and Ohio?

Nope, nope.

You're close.

Yeah.

It's obvious.

You're sitting in it.

We're sitting in it.

He lived in New York?

Arizona.

Oh.

I'm at your house.

What are you talking about?

Do you know whose house we're at right now?

Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ.
Where did he live here? I don't know. He was in the military, so wherever they moved him there.
Oh, my God. James, I could be right on the fucking street.
That's what I mean. He was right here.
So, yeah, he ended up in Florida and Arizona were the two places he lived, which seemed to fit in perfectly. Florida too, huh? Yeah, Florida and Arizona.
One of Vic's cellmates at a local detention center, Steve Vaughn, was housed in a cell with Vic for approximately eight or nine weeks starting in February 2006. They discussed their pending charges.
One night, this Vaughn guy got what he called a bad phone call from his wife and was upset. I assume when you're in prison, it's probably a few of those going on.
I bet you get a lot of bad phone calls. Oh, man.
You don't even want to be married if you're in prison because those are horrible phone calls. You feel awful, I'm sure.
She's yelling at you. Nothing's good.
That's got to be a mind fuck every day if you're a... Oh, brutal.
You're married? Brutal. Are you kidding? So in discussing the call with Vic, Vaughn asked him whether there was anything in his life or uh or a day in his life that he would take back if he could he's like anything you would ever take back in your life and vick said it would be the day he went over to dana's beauty shop vick told this guy that he drove his vehicle over there but parked across the road because dana was married and he didn want her husband to see him or his vehicle.
Even though he gets his hair cut there. He further indicated he exited the building through a window because he was scared.
He said that he recalled having a conversation with Dana but he blacked out and doesn't recall anything else that happened while in the shop. That's what he said.
Now, there's a lot of details in there that only this person, like where he parked and all that kind of shit. So, by the way, he wants Bond.
He wants to get out. What? Yeah, yeah.
He says that his whole family, they're all trying to get him out. They say he needs to be free and at home with his six-month-old daughter.
Let's keep him away from her probably forever, okay? And the mother of her. They said, well, he can't, if you don't let him out, then he can't fulfill his dream and become a minister.
Okay. All righty.
Hey, everybody. Just going to take a quick break from the show and tell you a little bit more about our stylish and fashionable friends over at Quince.
Elevating your style. That used to be a real expensive thing.
You want to change your look. It's so hard to do.
It's expensive. But with Quince, this is the way you can do it the right way.
You can get high-end, versatile pieces at a price that we can all actually afford and actually want to pay. And now I can upgrade my style, getting nice, real good luxury items and essentials that sync up with what I want and what I want to pay.
It's perfect. And Quince has all the must-haves like Mongolian cashmere sweaters from $50.
Come on, that's ridiculous. Iconic 100% leather jackets and comfortable pants for every occasion, which I got a leather jacket and Jimmy got comfortable pants.
That's exactly what we did. It's great stuff.

So you, too, should do this.

Indulge in affordable luxury.

Go to quince.com slash smalltownmurder for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns.

That's quince.com slash smalltownmurder to get free shipping and 365-day returns.

quince.com slash smalltownmur now back to the show this show small town murder is sponsored by better health we're huge proponents of therapy because everybody needs it too and it's independence is very glorified it's easy to forget that we're all better when we have a little support system behind us. And therapy can be a great source of support for any area of your life when it's time to shift the focus here from doing it all on your own to maybe it's a little better if we ask for some help here or there.
It doesn't hurt and there's nothing wrong with it. And we've benefited greatly from therapy.
Just talking to Jimmy about something he wanted to talk to his therapist about this week. So, I mean, you can't beat it.
Makes therapy affordable and convenient, actually, which is a big barrier to a lot of people. Serves over 5 million people worldwide.
You access a diverse network of more than 30,000 credentialed therapists with a wide range of specialties. And you can easily switch therapists at any time for no extra cost.
Build your support system with BetterHelp. Visit BetterHelp.com slash SmallTownMurder today to get 10% off your first month.
That's BetterHelp, H-E-L-P dot com slash SmallTownMurder. Now back to the show.
Let's get real for a minute about smelling good. With Suave launching their new men's deodorant line, you've got even less reason to overpay.
They're bringing the same powerful protection as premium brands without the premium. We'll see you next time.
of serious sweat and odor protection. Suave is all about cutting the nonsense and delivering what works.
No gimmicks, no fancy marketing tricks, just solid protection and great scents that keep you fresh all day long. Stop overpaying for basics.
Cut the BS out of your routine with Suave. Available now at your local store.
One relative said she just wanted to cook him his favorite meals again. Isn't that nice? Oh, my God.
That is fucking unbelievable. About 30 members of Satterfield's family presented letters to the judge protesting his release, and the judge went, we're going to go with that.
We're going to go with you, suspected rapist murderer. Yeah.
So April 30th, 2006, waiting on his trial. He's incarcerated and waiting on trial.
And apparently he, Vic, draped his feet out of a food hatch of the cell door, you know, a little door that they put the food through. And then became belligerent when the jailer asked him to please remove his feet so they could put the food through.
So he blocks this when Officer Derek Jefferson Green opened the hatch to give him his food at the Spartanburg County Detention Center. Then Corporal Albert Alvin Jennings Jr.
opened the cell door in order to stop Vic from blocking the hatch. They said Jennings and Vic then became involved in an altercation in which Vic yelled, quote, I'm going to kill you and your fucking family, which obviously he I don't know how he's going to get to the family from prison.
Probably not. So when the officers opened the door, he continued his aggressive behavior, made the verbal threats.
They sprayed him with a quick burst of pepper spray, and he continued fighting and fighting until they contained him. And he was charged with assaulting local correctional employees and threatening the life of a public official.
Wow, that's big. So the other young lady who's missing, Heather Rena Sellers, S-E-L-L-A-R-S.
Vic is a suspect in the 2002 disappearance of then 20-year-old Heather Sellers, who was his former fiancé and the last person to have seen her anywhere. Sellers grandmother, Norma Jean Swan, told deputies she dropped Sellers off at work at the Waffle House at Highway 9 in the I-85.
Jesus, that's depressing, man. Can you imagine? Fuck.
At about 2 p.m. to work second shift at the Waffle House that sits on two fucking interstates.

Oh, God. September 24th,

2002, and the family never heard

from her again.

So the mother told investigators

or the grandmother told investigators

that Sellers had a small bag of clothes

and intended to spend the night with an aunt.

A report said that she left her

aunt's house with Vic.

She had gone to her

aunt's house. Mom dropped her off.
She did her

Thank you. and intended to spend the night with an aunt.
A report said that she left her aunt's house with Vic. Oh? She had gone to her aunt's house.
Mom dropped her off. She did her shift.
Then she went to her aunt's house and left with Vic. Witnesses said they went to the Rainbow Lounge and then to Cocktails and Dreams, which is the fucking name of the movie in the terrible Tom Cruise movie, Cocktail.
That's the bar that they were opening. Cocktails and Dreams.
Yeah. They had like a pink logo.
Yeah. It's the shittiest movie and the dumbest idea for anything.
And that's what they did. And dreams.
And dreams. Because it was his dream to have his own place.
So cocktails and dreams. And he wrote it on a cocktail napkin.
Fucking awful movie. But Elizabeth Shue was in it and she was cute at the time so why not anyway um they said that uh uh um witnesses said shortly after she disappeared uh when they talked and were kind of canvassing the area they said that uh that heather was on drugs at the time and had also not picked up her paycheck at the waffle house uh.
Yeah, I guess they said that they went to two local bars. A photograph of Fick is posted with the case summary as well in the thing.
Like, here's our only suspect, basically. Her last paycheck was for $81, by the way.
Oh, man. So they had broken off their engagement two weeks earlier, but we're still seeing each other.

They did find Heather Sellers car at the bottom of a river,

but her body was never found at the bottom of a river.

Yeah.

She's not alive.

Let's say no.

No.

So she,

she's,

that's just a mystery.

So trial for Dana's murder,

November,

2006.

Now, because he committed the crime when he was 17, he's not eligible for the death penalty. Okay.
Because we can try him as an adult still, right? Oh, yeah, absolutely. But he can't get the death penalty.
That's not one thing. So it's a four-day trial.
Not very long. Defense opening here a little bit.
The lead defense attorney said that, yes, Dana Satterfield was brutally murdered and that a pubic hair was found on her body, though. And that pubic hair does not match Vic.
The problem is also there was a struggle in the bathroom. This all happened in the bathroom.
Forget it. So how many pubes are in there? Yeah.
It's a bathroom. Murdered in a barbershop's floor.
She was. She was.
That's the other thing. The amount of hairs, it may not have been a pube.
You don't know. She was dragged across the floor, too.
So they said there's tons of different hair all over. She had like 15 people's hair on her.
I'm sure she did. Yeah.
So they said that didn't belong to Vic. And they said that that's crazy, and they said no test can show when the semen made contact with her body as well.
So telling the jury, you keep an open mind. So their theory is he came in, said, yo, what's up? You want to fix my hair? And she was like, not till I fuck you.
And then they went in the back, and he gave her the fucking business. And then he was like, peace out, lady.
And then while she was sitting there in the afterglow, some other guy came in and strangled her. Somebody that is just popping pubes.
While she still had a fucking, yeah. While she still had her pants around her ankle, he came in and then raped her and dropped pubes everywhere.
But didn't come. Because only that guy came.
Okay. Yeah.
They said DNA analysis cannot put a time frame on when it got there. Like she was cutting hair all night with sperm in her pubes.
We got no evidence that she's ever had sex with him willingly. None.
And his friend laughed at him when he even suggested it was a possibility. So not happening.
Fuck. So a customer said that she was a customer, Reeves here.
She was a customer and a friend of Dana and that she was in the salon to have her haircut on July 25th, the week before, on Tuesday. When this Reeves was in the chair, that's when she also got another call from Vic's mother.
Dana gets a call from Vic's mother, Marianne.ne now reeves who also knows marianne vick and had talked to her on the phone before knew it was marianne on the phone because dana was behind reeves when the phone call came and she recognized marianne's voice that's how small of a town this is i know that's marianne impersonating marianne marianne around no jay more doesn't know her no fucking no no shit. Where's Rich Little when this is going on? So Reeves was asked why Marianne was calling, and then there was an objection in the middle of all that.
The trial court overruled the objection, and she testified this, quote, she wanted Dana to look at Vic's hair that, you know, I don't know if he put something in it or had someone something. But she told her that it wouldn't take but about 10 minutes of her time.
And Marianne could not, excuse me, Dana could not do it that day. And it stated to Marianne that she was not able to do it.
But if she would call her back, you know, it's been a time frame. So I don't know if she said come there the next day or to call her back or what.
So when asked about what she remembered about the conversation, she stated the conversation was to call back and she would take a look at it. But she could not do it that day.
She said, I just heard a voice. And when Dana hung up, she obviously Marianne hung up on her because there was no goodbye.
And the victim, Dana, turned around to me and she just took a breath and said, Mary Ann Vick, like you all know she's a pain in the ass. Yeah.
So they objected again and all this type of thing. And Reeves stated that Dana told her that it was Mary Ann Vick, at which point Reeves told Dana that she knew because she recognized the voice.
When Dana asked Reeves, ifves if Reeves knew them, Reeves told her she did.

And then she said, Dana said to me, she said, well, I won't do that anymore. She said, that's the last time that the last time he was here, that was the case, that 10 minutes of your time.
And it took her an hour and a half and she doesn't have time to do this. Yeah.
Now, they also deny a state motion to preclude defense attorneys from introducing evidence that Mike Satterfield's fingerprints were found on the water heater where the body was found. It's her business, right? Well, Mike Satterfield testified in court that he installed the water heater two months before his wife's death.
So my fingerprints are going to be honest. I installed a water heater in my wife's business.
I'm an HVAC guy. It's probably on the heater and the air conditioner also, I would bet.
It's things I do. Yeah.
And also another witness had told jurors that the man he saw crouch down near the crime scene was way too small to have been Mike Satterfield because Mike, you'd see from space. He's a giant fucking fat guy.
I'm not trying to be a dick. This saves him in this.
He's not a man. If you say, oh, yeah, six foot average build, whatever could be anybody.
It's not Mike. That's one person.
It's not. If you saw Mike first thing out of your mouth to be big guy, big belly, enormous man, big fat guy.
So he was home with his children as well. And they don't think that he hired a teenager to go rape and kill his wife when he's trying to get with her.
So the testimony and evidence altogether shows that Vic had a sexual desire to be with Dana and intended to visit her on the night of the murder. Vic threatened to kill the witness who could provide this information.
He said, I'll kill you. A person matching the description of Vic was seen exiting the salon before she was beaten, before her body was found.
A car similar to him in make, model, color with distinctive rims was found around there. He confided to a cellmate, all of the details, everything, and his DNA matched the semen found on her to the tune of one in 900 million.
That's crazy. A lot of evidence here.
The closings, prosecutors said this. I want you to speak the truth in a voice so loud that it will be heard in years to come.
It's eight female jurors and four male jurors, by the way. And I want you to speak the truth so it bounds back through the halls of history to a beauty shop in Roebuck and a young mother hanging by a strap.
I want this courtroom to be full of justice when you come back. Okay, that's the silliest thing I've ever heard a person say.
I want this courtroom to be full of a feeling or of justice. You don't get a more nebulous term than justice.
To say I'd like it to be full of it is a weird thing to say. say then he said Jonathan Vick is a danger to our community and he doesn't ever deserve to see the light of day so the defense said come on well you know you know the defense said please look past the emotion and look at the evidence and then forget that also you'd have to say and then also forget all of that and then just said that vick's fingerprints were not found at the crime scene and that dna tests showed a pubic hair found on dana's lower body did not belong to vick they said clearly what happened to her was tragic but convicting the wrong person doesn't serve any purpose you just got a point you don't want to convict the wrong, you never want to convict the wrong person.
But I think we're okay.

I think we got this one.

And the jury really thinks so because it took them less than 20 minutes of deliberation to come out with a verdict.

I mean, that's not, they didn't even get a drink of water.

No.

They sat down.

Nobody has to pee.

They sat down.

They always do a straw poll at first just to see where we stand.

They sat down.

Straw poll.

All right, then.

We're done. Let's go home.
Peace peace out that's it she he is found guilty on all counts murder criminal sexual conduct and kidnapping as well oh so um the prosecutor said later on that's the jury's way of sending a message it's less than the time it's less than the time it takes to watch a sitcom That's how reprehensible we think you are. An episode of Friends lasts longer than this.
Fuck you. We didn't even get to the soup Nazi.
Didn't even get there. So, sentencing here.
The prosecutor said, only by his good fortune, only by his good fortune was he 17 at the time he committed it, or else we would be at the start of the death penalty-seeking phase. Vic's wife, Caroline, pleads with the judge prior to sentencing for the minimum sentence, noting that she and her husband have a young daughter at home.
She said, I know he didn't do this. I know he didn't, sobbing and crying.
You're a single mom, lady. Wow, you are fucked.

Vic says this. He steps up and says, I got something to say.
Quote, she did not get justice today. She will not as long as I sit behind bars.
Is that right? Wow. So the judge says, let's make that a good long time.
You, sir, may fuck off life with parole. Okay.
Okay. Okay, so his parole eligibility date starts October 24th, 2035.
Is that right? That is when he's eligible for 20 years, I guess. Huh? Yeah.
Now, okay. He is sentenced there.
Now, Heather Sellers family is there as well. Okay.
Cause they, they believe they just have their laser. I'm surprised if one of her brothers didn't murder this guy already or something.
Like, how the fuck do you let this guy walk around? He left a woman hanging from a hot water heater just a few years before. Oh, yeah.
This is his jam here. So Seller's grandmother attended the court.
She's the one who dropped her off at the Waffle House, Norma Jean, throughout the week and smiled as the verdict was announced. She later stood outside the courtrooms alongside Cora Kent, her granddaughter's friend, the murdered woman's friend or missing woman's friend, who was also Vic's ex-girlfriend as well.
He, man. Kent said that justice was served.
She said they should have given him the chair, though. It's an eye for I'm in for an eye for an eye.
As the Vic family left, Vic's younger brother then threatened her. What? This lady and said, quote, you'll get yours.
And Vic's mother began to proclaim her son's innocence and officers hurried the Vic family away from the property. You know, before they got attacked by the entire town and murdered in the street.
Well, they all got strung up. Fuck.
So Mike, he's out there. His reaction here, he's outside hugging his kids, and he said he took the denial of the crime in stride, saying it doesn't matter what he says.
The evidence points to him. He said, though, that he thought, he said, I don't know, maybe in his own mind he thinks he's innocent.

He said, I don't know what people's heads do. Either way, he did it.
So I don't care. Basically, he said, maybe it'll be a better.
He said now it'll he thinks maybe hopefully the future will be better. He said, maybe it'll be a better holiday as this is coming up on the holiday season.
He said the holidays will never be the same, but at least we got some closure. Ashley's 20 at this point

the daughter and she said that

she was glad Vic wouldn't be able to hurt anybody else while in jail and said that, quote, he can lie to himself all he wants. Her brother Brandon, who was 17 at this point, he said he got what he deserved.
Dana's mother said that it was a smack in the face to hear Vic vic deny his guilt but added that she was surprised he said anything she said at least we've put this person away for life where he can't hurt anyone else we wanted him where he could not hurt anybody or control anybody else now he goes to court for his his fucking problems with the prison guards there you can't threaten to kill people in jail so he goes to court for that, he is found guilty of threatening the life of a public official and assault on a correctional officer in a two-day jury trial. They sentence him to, you, sir, may fuck off three more years in prison because of that.
Even if he gets parole in 2035, he then has to go serve that. so that's going to be on top of it also he has he's a fuck up though he's not going to get paroled if he does it's not going to be for a long time because he has been in the special management unit which is 23 hour a day lockdown for at that for 1.6 months after a punishment for attacking a fellow inmate then He's transferred.
He has all sorts of infractions. Oh, he's a pain in the ass right now.
That's crazy.

He's transferred. He has all sorts of infractions.
Oh, he's a pain in the ass right in the bar. It's crazy.
He appeals the case very quickly here. He maintains that testimony related in detail the substance of what that, what that, the phone call, he's saying that phone call, the substance of that phone call that that woman overheard the mother wanting Dana to fix Michael's hair.

Or not Michael, Jonathan's hair.

Recognizing her voice.

Recognizing her voice and saying that because they're saying it was hearsay that she said that this person told her it was Marianne.

They said that doesn't fucking matter.

It doesn't matter. Explain your jizz, sir.
That's's the point your jizz is not where it shouldn't be i know where all my jizz is you know what i'm saying i know we're all that i can catalog on dead women nope there's no i can tell you where it is and it's nowhere out there it's not there's not a hair salon on earth where my jizz can be found and that's that's important here yeah so they ended up taking a couple of his points on the appeal but it doesn't matter because his sentence stands and everything stands. So he's kind of shit out of luck there.
Guilt was conclusively proven such that any error in admission of evidence would be harmless. D-N-fucking-A.
He still denies it. He still continues to maintain an unknown assailant did the whole thing and fucking everything so then he wants a new trial as well he's got to have a new trial he said his personal research on the topic led him to believe the sample could have been contaminated the DNA sample yeah he did his own research from jail where you have the best Internet access and access to top experts.
He said that led him to on a topic to believe that the DNA sample could have been contaminated and said he was under the impression that another DNA expert was going to testify for the defense. And so, you know, he said, but I didn't ever get that.
He said, I felt there was no way to get a fair trial in this town with all the media exposure. I was looking forward to a day in court.
I was looking forward to my day of standing up here and telling the world, Hey, I didn't do this. He never testified by the way.
He could have was more than welcome to do that. I'm not this monster.
These people think are trying to make me out to be in the media. I was looking forward to that.
I felt that was important for people to hear my own from my own mouth. No one was defending me at the time.
I was the only person to defend myself in the media and in court. Wow.
You're jizz. Now, Ashley, she went on to have two children of her own and she became a victim advocate for the Spartanburg County Sheriff's Office.
And she said that she makes herself available at all hours for victims in case someone needs to talk. She attends bond hearings with them also against the people and encourages them to draft impact statements and read them at sentencing hearings.
She also started a jailhouse program to make inmates aware of the effects that their crimes have on victims' families. She said, quote, you just don't get over it.
You learn how to live with it. So this is kind of my way of living with it.
And she also operates her own photography business as well there. Now, the Heather Sellers case.
Okay. They said that any other crimes that might involve Vic, they're investigating him for all sorts of shit.
He's considered a person of interest in her disappearance. I would say more than that.
In 2006, authorities found blood stains and blonde hair in an abandoned vehicle registered to Vic. They believed the blood and hair may be from sellers, but the samples were broken down and couldn't get good DNA on it.
Yeah. They said if he's involved in anything else, we're never going to quit looking.
We do not believe he is squeaky clean. We don't believe he's as squeaky clean as his lawyers and his mama believe.
He's an evil, evil person. Now, he was considered a possible suspect in the disappearance of another person, one of Sellers' fellow Waffle House employees, Michelle Whitaker, who disappeared in August 2002, around the same time Sellers did.
But turns out in 2008 when the cops were investigating it, they found her alive. She was alive.
She had left on her own and just wasn't aware anyone was looking for. She's so, she's so inconsequential that it didn't even, she like, it never came up.
This town sucks so bad. People leave.
They leave. Nobody knows.
So he's at the Ridgeland, um, whatever correctional facility or whatever right now just says Ridgeland. Um, and, uh, yeah, parole 10, 24, 20, 35.
He's eligible for parole. He's had loss of privileges a bunch of times, you know, cell phones and fighting and all this type of shit.
Dana is buried at the Heritage Memorial Gardens in Roebuck there. And this has been on a bunch of different TV shows, everything from forensic files to unsolved mysteries to Paula Zahn to all this shit.
He really that he's just gonna do his time and get out he's never getting out right I fucking hope not as a murderer you can't get out I really really hope not because he's dangerous that's a dangerous fucking man so there you go there is Roebuck South Carolina gotta go to the end quick here if you like the show get on whatever app you're listening on and please give give us five stars. It helps so fucking much, and we don't understand why.
Follow us on social media at SmallTownMurder on Instagram, SmallTownPod on Facebook. Definitely head over to ShutUpAndGiveMeMurder.com.
Tickets for the 420 virtual goddamn live show. Can't wait.
Anywhere in the world with an internet connection, just like a live show. The pictures, the story.
We're in costumes. Jimmy's going to be forced to do bong hits.
It takes place Saturday, April 19th, and it's available for two weeks after that. Get your tickets.
Also, get your tickets for Chicago in May. Get them right now for the rest of the year as well.
Shut up and givememurder.com, patreon.com slash crime in sports. All the bonus material that you could possibly handle.
Hundreds of back episodes immediately subscription anybody five dollars a month or above and you get new ones every other week this week crime in sports we are going to talk about more sports songs chris weber rapping and a bunch of other terrible shit and then for small town murder the con one the con man casanova lewis carlucci who is just some like tubby guinea guy and fucking in uh new york in the 80s who was scamming a bunch of women and they couldn't find him. And it was why the whole city was looking for him.
It was crazy. Talk about that.
That is patreon.com slash crime in sports to get a shout out at the end of the regular show. Yep.
Want to follow us on social media? Super easy to do that. Shut up and give me murder dot com.
Drop down menus coming out of your ass. Get in there, everybody.

And until next week, everybody,

it's been our pleasure.

Bye. If you like small town murder, you can listen early and ad free now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts.
Prime members can listen early and ad free on Amazon Music. Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey at Wondery dotcom slash survey.
In the early hours of December 4th, 2024, CEO Brian Thompson stepped out onto the streets of Midtown Manhattan. This assailant pulls out a weapon and starts firing at him.
We're talking about the CEO of the biggest private health insurance corporation in the world. And the suspect.
He has been identified as Luigi

Nicholas Mangione. Became one of the most divisive figures in modern criminal history.
I was targeted,

premeditated, and meant to sow terror. I'm Jesse Weber, host of Luigi, produced by Law and Crime

and Twist. This is more than a true crime investigation.
We explore a uniquely American

moment that could change the country forever.

He's awoken the people to a true issue.

Finally, maybe this would lead rich and powerful people to acknowledge the barbaric nature of our

healthcare system. Listen to Law & Crimes Luigi exclusively on Wondery Plus.
You can join Wondery

Plus on the Wondery app, Spotify, or Apple Podcasts.