A Military Historian’s Omnibus

Speaker 1 What's going on? I'm Arch Manning, Veori athlete and college quarterback. Whether I'm running, training, traveling, or just unlining at home, I love doing it in my core shorts from Veori.

Speaker 1 With a breathable boxer briefliner, they're quick to dry, super versatile, and stand up to even my most intense training sessions. Plus, they come in three inseams and a ton of colors.

Speaker 2 Ready to try a pair?

Speaker 1 Go to Veori.com/slash Arch and get 20% off at checkout. I think you're going to love them as much as I do.
That's vuri.com/slash A-R-C-H and get 20% off your first order. Exclusions apply.

Speaker 1 Visit the website for full terms and conditions. Not only will you receive 20% off your first purchase, but enjoy free shipping on any U.S.
orders over $75 and free returns.

Speaker 3 Have a great day.

Speaker 2 Hello, ladies and gentlemen. Welcome to the Victor Davis Hanson Show.

Speaker 2 Victor is the Martin and Ely Anderson Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution and the Waynamar Shabuski Distinguished Fellow in History at Hillsdale College.

Speaker 2 And he is the possessor of a website, The Blade of Perseus. Its address, VictorHanson.com.
We are recording on Monday, June 9th. This episode will be up on Thursday the 19th.

Speaker 3 Why so long? Well, Victor will be having some surgery.

Speaker 2 We've talked about it on previous podcasts. And we are recording two shows.
This is the second of the two.

Speaker 2 To give Victor a chance to recover from surgery and not have to record podcasts, I did ask the good people from the Victor Davis-Hanson Fan Club on Facebook to submit questions, and many did.

Speaker 2 And I have a bunch of them to toss at Victor today. We're going to start off.
Let's see, what should we start off with? Some thoughts that emanate from one of Victor's great books, The Soul of Battle.

Speaker 2 And we'll get to that when we come back from these important messages.

Speaker 4 This episode is brought to you by Progressive Commercial Insurance. As a business owner, you take a lot of roles: marketer, bookkeeper, CEO.

Speaker 4 But when it comes to small business insurance, Progressive has you covered.

Speaker 4 They offer discounts on commercial auto insurance, customizable coverages that can grow with your business, and reliable protection for whatever comes your way.

Speaker 4 Count on Progressive to handle your insurance while you do, well, everything else. Quote today in as little as eight minutes at progressivecommercial.com.

Speaker 4 Progressive Casualty Insurance Company, coverage provided and serviced by affiliated and third-party insurers. Discounts and coverage selections not available in all states or situations.

Speaker 5 Ever noticed that everyone always wants more of a good thing? More rewards, more savings, more special offers?

Speaker 5 Well, when you become a new member of the Shell Fuel Rewards program, that's exactly what you get. More.

Speaker 5 Join today to save 10 cents per gallon on your first fill, 20 cents on the second, and 30 cents on the third. Then enjoy everyday savings afterwards.
Want more?

Speaker 5 Then head to Shell where members get more. Offer ballot from 421-25 to 1231-26 at participating Shell locations.
Offer must be redeemed within 60 days of registration. Limit 20 gallons.

Speaker 5 Restrictions apply. Visit fuelrewards.com/slash join25 for more information.

Speaker 2 We are back with the Victor Davis-Hansen Show. Victor, here's a question from Paul Puchinow.
And Paul is one of the leaders of the Victor Davis-Hanson fan club.

Speaker 2 He writes: The first book that I read was The Soul of Battle. Does Victor believe that there are any modern day, the last 30 years, quote-unquote armies of liberation and any equivalents of Epim.

Speaker 3 I'm never going to say Epaminondas.

Speaker 2 Thank you, my friend.

Speaker 3 Just call him Epi.

Speaker 2 Epi, that's what you get for a classical education. Sherman or Patton.
Are there any equivalents of Epi, Sherman, or Patton? Thanks from Paul.

Speaker 3 Victor? Yeah,

Speaker 3 the theme of that book was that there were times in history where people engaged in linear marches and they were from more consensual societies than not and were trying to free people who were under the jurisdiction or submission to autocracies.

Speaker 3 And there was kind of a spirit in that army. That was Sherman's march to the sea

Speaker 3 in November to December 1864, Epaminonis' great march

Speaker 3 down to free the Helots. He didn't free

Speaker 3 the Laconian Helots, that would be Alexander, but he freed the

Speaker 3 Messenian Helots in the winter of 369

Speaker 3 and and three

Speaker 3 seventy BC. And then we I also talked about George Patton's I j I referenced that earlier, the march from essentially July 1st all the way to Metz in mid-September.

Speaker 3 And they were can you do that again? Can you form an army really quick? And can you march and kind of be have the moral right on your side and have a spirit de corps? And all I I don't know.

Speaker 3 A lot of it's technological, but today with as we saw with the Ukrainians and drones wiping out all of these targets, I I just saw a statistic, sixty-five percent of infantry losses in the Ukraine war on both sides are from drones.

Speaker 3 I don't know if you could marshal an army without having you'd have to have air superiority a hundred percent or it would be just destroyed as it walked as it went forward. And then

Speaker 3 uh in the postmodern I mean, when you're talking about a liberation of free peoples, I mean we're talking about Western peoples. I don't see anybody in Japan, one 1.3,

Speaker 3 fertility, Korea, 1.2,

Speaker 3 South Korea, Europe, 1.4.

Speaker 3 I don't see a bunch of Europeans say, we're going to go help Ukraine and free them and we're going to march through and that's not going to happen.

Speaker 3 And we tried to do that kind of in that march to, you know, Shakina when we invaded

Speaker 3 Iraq, and the idea was we were going to march all the way to Baghdad. I think it was like 400 miles that we did from the two prongs.

Speaker 3 And we were trying to liberate people. I think a lot of the neoconservatives people said that we were going to be treated as heroes.

Speaker 3 There were people who did treat us as heroes, but that quickly dissolved into a messy counterinsurgency war. So I don't, it's going to be very hard.
I don't think, you know, I just don't.

Speaker 3 It's very hard in the age of drones, sophisticated satellite imagery, nuclear weapons, hypersonic missiles, that a huge column of 100,000 men are going to just, boom, take off unless they they have very good air support, satellite, blocking image.

Speaker 3 I'm not saying that technology changes war permanently, but it puts us in cycles of defense versus offense.

Speaker 3 People get gunpowder, then all of a sudden you think, well, body armor is out of the, you're never going to have body armor again. Well, we have body armor today.

Speaker 3 And

Speaker 3 you think we're going to have air, the bomber always gets through. That's what we were told by the British government.

Speaker 3 Why build fighters? It always gets through. You can't stop it.
Well, that wasn't true when you got sophisticated planes and then the bomber didn't get through because

Speaker 3 of fighters and then there was jets and then everybody said fighter, well, you can't have a bomber anymore because these jets are so fast they'll shoot them down. Well, you can have jet bombers.

Speaker 3 They can go faster. It's challenge, response, counter-response, challenge.

Speaker 2 The drone stuff is really.

Speaker 3 You've got to know what cycle you're in, though.

Speaker 3 I think because of the fertility rate, we're going to get, as I understand a lot of the research research now on infantry, it's two things, robotics and body armor, that will protect the person, either through use of a robotic infantryman or new types of ceramics and fabrics that would stop a bullet.

Speaker 3 There are some now that actually will do that.

Speaker 2 But the drones work in killing an infantryman by just exploding, right? And the force, I wonder how

Speaker 2 even how much you cover yourself with some degree of armor can protect the family.

Speaker 3 They said they were I've been reading there's post-traumatic syndrome because there's thousands now of these drone pilots in Ukraine. A lot of them are women.

Speaker 3 And when they have these little things that look like a sparrow hawk or something, and they're chasing somebody through a trench, they have mixed emotions about killing that person.

Speaker 3 But they're killing them in droves.

Speaker 3 And you can jam them. We're learning how to jam them and knock them down and stuff.

Speaker 2 Well, I mentioned General Sherman. Paul had mentioned him in his question, and Sherman comes up again in another question, and this is from,

Speaker 2 this is funny. Hey, Jack, I'm a black dude.
Name is Marcus Burquette. He's from New Haven, Connecticut, near where I live.
Actually, I was earlier today, which is why I'm dressed so. prettily.

Speaker 2 He lives in South Carolina. Huge fan of VDH question.
Just take the second part of this question, Victor.

Speaker 2 The first question is, Victor, can you speak on the Civil War, the Black 54th Regiment from Massachusetts and its commanding officer, Roberts, I believe? He was the colonel.

Speaker 3 That was Glory, right? Glory, right.

Speaker 2 Second question. And can you speak on William Tecumseh Sherman, the Union general? He stood for the law.
He had some favorable views of blacks, but still believed in the supremacy of whites.

Speaker 2 But still, he was an unbelievably great general. Thank you.
And shout out to Sammy Wink. That's from Marcus.

Speaker 3 He was similar to Patton in that he was rhetorical, and what he said didn't match his deeds. In other words, if you look what he said

Speaker 3 in his memoirs, and they're brilliantly written, I think they're even more impressive than Grant's. Memoirs of W.T.
Sherman. He said things like, I'm glad we didn't occupy Mexico.

Speaker 3 I've been down to Mexico. I see what Mexico is like.
I don't want those people in the United States. That was a racist thing to say.
But he was talking about the general poverty.

Speaker 3 And he really detested the white, what he called the cavalier class. He said, we're going to have to kill about 300,000 people in this war, and we've got to wipe out the cavalier.

Speaker 3 He talked about the plantation because he said you can't work with them. They're so wealthy and they're horsemen and they're aristocratic and they think they're so much better.

Speaker 3 He was talking about people like Wade Hampton.

Speaker 3 When you actually looked at him, when you look at the march, he freed blacks from the slaves, probably 20,000 of them as he went through Georgia and the Carolinas later.

Speaker 3 And he created a pioneer corps. And so when we went to the plantation, I'm doing this by memory, but of Hal Cobb, who was governor of Georgia, he freed, I think, 200 slaves.

Speaker 3 And then his wife, Hal Cobb's Cobb's wife, and he said, well, you guys keep calling me a terrorist in the papers. If I'm such a terrorist, why did the governor leave his women folk here?

Speaker 3 Wouldn't I kill them and rape them, my men? But no, I didn't, because you know that I am a humane person, and this army of the West is a humane army.

Speaker 3 And everybody says that we're raping and killing, because they were burning Confederate public railroads and armories and things. They didn't burn small houses.
houses. They did burn plantations.

Speaker 3 Anyway, the point I'm making is that he was criticized because he had had some, General Logan and a few others that were southerners, and these pioneers followed the army.

Speaker 3 And when you read Henry Hitchcock and memoirs of people on that march, they had never seen a black person before. The armies that were this was a northern Midwestern army.

Speaker 3 It wasn't the army of the Potomac at all. It had no very few immigrants in it.
It was Minnesota, Michigan, Wisconsin, Ohio, Indiana, and they were all farmers.

Speaker 3 And that's why they were so different because because when they got down to the South, they actually,

Speaker 3 the South,

Speaker 3 the labor on the plantations was black slaves and then a wealthy aristocratic class, but they knew how to camp better, they knew how to feed themselves, they knew how to farm, they knew exactly how to scrounge, which type.

Speaker 3 So they were very successful and they had never seen black people before, many of them. They talk about it.
And they felt very sympathetic to the way they were being treated.

Speaker 3 And so they allowed them to come along and then they went ahead of the army and they corduroyed what they called corduroyed muddy roads. They put logs down so they could, wagons could go over.

Speaker 3 And there was at one point a lot of them got killed when the Confederates ambushed and people said, well, Sherman let them go.

Speaker 3 But when he got to Georgia, Savannah, and went in the Carolinas, he started to gift African Americans offshore islands. And he said, these are your 40 acres and a mule problem and all that stuff.

Speaker 3 And he didn't have the authority to do that. And he was severely criticized, but he got it.
He insisted on that. And then when he had the march into Washington after Appomattox,

Speaker 3 everybody should read that about that march. We have contemporary descriptions from Europeans about it.
And so they had the Army of the Potomac. It had all brand new uniforms.

Speaker 3 They were all right off, no offense, Jack, off the boat from Ireland. And I'm just kidding, but there were a lot of immigrants.
The Irish Brigade. It was a revolving army.
They had been wiped out.

Speaker 3 You know, when you're fighting at Antietam and Getty

Speaker 3 and Wilderness in seven days, they were just wiped out more people. But the Army of the West, Sherman was very, he got criticized.
He did not like funnel engagements.

Speaker 3 He only had one, and it didn't go well. So he was outflanking.
He was destroying the wherewithal that fed the armies. But when he marched, he got all these guys.

Speaker 3 He had 60,000 of them, and they were all tan, and they were big and husky farmers, and they had all these black, big guys with them. And he let them march at the front of the army with

Speaker 3 picks and shovels and all of their engineering equipment. And the German ambassador was quoted, saying, Oh my God, I've never seen an army.
This guy could go right through Europe with that army.

Speaker 3 And then everybody was scared of it because they had attacked him. So when he met this Secretary of War, he didn't shake his hand because he'd been attacked.

Speaker 3 And they had sent an embassy down to Savannah to chastise Sherman because they said he hadn't been nice to freed blacks.

Speaker 3 So then they brought in a lot of blacks who had been on the march or knew him when he got to Savannah. And Sherman couldn't talk to them.
And Chase and all these other people, what's his name?

Speaker 3 Stanton, and they started to interview their emissaries interviewed him. And they all said he was a great guy.
They treated him with respect. He gave them land, so they liked him.

Speaker 3 Then after he had this army, people said, oh my gosh, he's got black pioneers, he's got farmers, he's angry at the United States, he's not going going to disband it.

Speaker 3 And he's going to take over Washington. And he's going to destroy the Army of the Potomac.
You can't stop him.

Speaker 3 And he kind of fed that little, he was kind of tweaking them. And then he got to the Bank of the Potomac, and he just, all you guys are going home, we'll see you.
He was a great man. Hallelujah.

Speaker 3 But he was a, he wasn't, and he was, he did not believe, he was a man of his time, so he didn't believe that slaves were the exact equal, but he probably did more for African American slaves than any American general, even more than General Howard, the founder of Howard University.

Speaker 3 But he was very empathetic and he really did not like the way, and his army did not like the way African Americans were treated in the South on the plantations.

Speaker 3 He freed them, he destroyed the plantations. I mean, I don't even want to get into Columbia, South Carolina, what he did.

Speaker 3 But his basic argument was, you started the war, you said that you were military superior, that your chauvinistic culture of cavaliers would destroy our motley immigrant army.

Speaker 3 You had the African African-American slaves. We didn't.
You wanted to fight. Now we're here.
Come out and fight me.

Speaker 3 He was much better equipped. You know, at the end, they had sharps repeating rifles.

Speaker 2 Victor, I have another Civil War-related question, but first.

Speaker 3 Henry, too, I think.

Speaker 2 Henry rifle. I believe Henry still exists.

Speaker 3 Yes, you can buy those beautiful guns.

Speaker 3 I was thinking of getting one the other day.

Speaker 3 Oh, well, to be able to. California's so weird.
It's hard to get ammunition and anything in the mail, you know what I mean? Here. You can't even buy a gas blower.
It's against the law.

Speaker 3 Somebody was so nice, I mentioned that on one of our podcasts, and then I just saw this gas blower show up. Really? It was shipped here.
I don't know how they shipped it. Oh, my gosh.

Speaker 3 And I want to tell the listener, I use your beautiful gas blower.

Speaker 2 That's nice. I should mention my favorite brand of ice cream.
You never know what might show up in my house.

Speaker 3 You mentioned Henry Rifles, and I get a nice 30-30 or 22 or 17.

Speaker 2 I think they were actually made near me here because of a tremendous amount of gun manufacturers in Connecticut.

Speaker 3 I think they're all

Speaker 3 how far are you from the Springfield Armory in Massachusetts? Oh,

Speaker 2 is my pedal on the metal? I could get there in about an hour.

Speaker 3 Is that still there, or did they move?

Speaker 2 I don't believe they're there anymore, but

Speaker 3 we'll verify that.

Speaker 2 I have to read an ad here now, Victor.

Speaker 2 People are right to be frustrated with the cost of health care. Prescription drugs in America cost more than they should and more than almost anywhere else in the world.

Speaker 2 And that's why President Trump's new executive order to lower drug prices is such a big deal. It's smart, long overdue, and puts patients, not corporations, first.

Speaker 2 But while that change is being rolled out, let me tell you about a pharmacy that's not waiting around. Family Pharmacy is stepping up now, offering 20%

Speaker 2 off all medications through June 30th, so you can stock up and stay prepared, whether it's ivermectin, hydroxychloroquine, ethylene, blue, antibiotics, or just your daily prescriptions.

Speaker 2 They've got over 200 essential meds, no insurance needed. They work with licensed drug doctors in all 50 states to get your prescription and ship it.
right to your door.

Speaker 2 So go to allfamilypharmacy.com slash Victor and use the code Victor20. That's V-I-C-T-O-R, the number two, the number zero, to save 20%

Speaker 2 today. This is what healthcare should be, affordable, accessible, and back in your hands.
Again, that's allfamilypharmacy.com Victor.

Speaker 2 Use the code Victor20 and we thank the good people from All Family Pharmacy for sponsoring the Victor Davis Hansome Show. Victor, question here.

Speaker 2 This is from Bill, Bill in New Jersey. Huge fan of Victor.
I listened to all his podcasts and also his other appearances.

Speaker 2 I would like a list of books or a single book, let's just stick with the single book, that would best explain the military and political parts of the Civil War. Is there such a book that combines two?

Speaker 2 Maybe there's the best book on military and the best book on

Speaker 3 the written.

Speaker 3 Well, I would read the primary sources, the memoirs of Grant and Sherman, and

Speaker 3 Alan Guelzo, the great Civil War and Lincoln historians, got a lot of good books on it. Battle Cry of Freedom, you know, by the Princeton historians, great

Speaker 2 McPherson.

Speaker 3 James McPherson. Yeah.
It's

Speaker 3 wonderful. And then Shelby Foote's the best written,

Speaker 3 the southern

Speaker 3 agrarian writer. It's a brilliant book on the Civil War.

Speaker 3 The Star of the Star of the World. John Keegan, I knew him really well.
And he had written the. He gave me a big break.
He wrote the introduction to the Western Way of War.

Speaker 3 Everything he wrote was wonderful. The World War II book, the World War I book, of course, The Face of Battle, Price of Admiralty, all those.
But his book on the Civil War was his weakest.

Speaker 3 I think it was because I don't know why he was not in good health and he was writing very quickly.

Speaker 2 Who's your friend that you see every

Speaker 2 friend? I put that in quotes that you see occasional summer at a certain place who did this PBS series on the Civil War.

Speaker 2 The documentary.

Speaker 2 Ken Burns.

Speaker 3 Ken Burns.

Speaker 2 Oh, thank you.

Speaker 3 Yeah, I told. I mean, we don't agree politically, obviously.

Speaker 2 I guess I was asking, though, what did you think of did you see?

Speaker 3 He was brilliant. I said that to him once.

Speaker 3 I wasn't a big fan of his later work, but I said to him two things. And I wasn't trying to be obsequious because he's been, I don't know if he's fond of me or not.

Speaker 3 But I said to him, that was a brilliant piece of cinematography. It was.

Speaker 3 There was something about the time, you know, people said it wouldn't work unless you have, you know, move film clips and all that, and they couldn't have that in the Civil War.

Speaker 3 But all of those, all those still frames, and then they had those great people narrating. Shelby Foote was one of them.
And then they had the music, and he he was really, he really nailed it.

Speaker 3 And I asked him, I said, I don't think people on your side of the political spectrum would let you do that again.

Speaker 3 And he said, what do you mean? And I said, because you had a tragic view of it.

Speaker 3 You were lucky that the South is that these were very brave people, very capable people, very honorable people in many cases. And they were enlisting for a bad cause, slavery.

Speaker 3 Yet you not only brought that out, but you kind of pointed out indirectly that the majority, and this is debatable, it's one of the biggest debates in Civil War history, what percentage of the South owned slaves?

Speaker 3 Was it 4%? Was it 5%?

Speaker 3 You can define it by household versus person, etc. But basically, the vast majorities of Southerners did not own slaves, maybe 90%.

Speaker 3 And they suffered because of that in the sense that their society, I mean, they suffered because of slavery, was bifurcated, medieval.

Speaker 3 There was not a vibrant, agrarian, industrial worker class to the same degree there was in the North because they had to pay wage labor.

Speaker 3 Three generations. Slavery really hurt the South, Southern economy.
I really like Eugene Genovese, you know. Yeah.

Speaker 3 And he was the great Marxist historian, but later in life he became very conservative and he wrote about slavery.

Speaker 2 Did you know him?

Speaker 3 I knew him. I did.
I knew him.

Speaker 2 Was he from Brooklyn?

Speaker 3 Was he from New York? Yeah. He was an Italian guy with a chain smoker.
And I knew him when he had transitioned from a Marxist historian to a U.S., and he was Elizabeth Fox Genovese with his wife.

Speaker 3 She was brilliant, and her father had been a really brilliant geographer, geographical historian. I like both of them.
They both died. They passed on.
He was a creator of the Historical Society.

Speaker 3 It was kind of an effort to give a reasonable alternative to the American Historical Association. They'd been taken over by leftists.
Yeah.

Speaker 2 Well.

Speaker 2 What we call parallel polis, right? To offset the...

Speaker 2 Hey, Victor, we have some more questions to get your wonderful take on, and we're going to get to one on the Iraq war when we return from these important messages.

Speaker 6 You know, they say it's not what you say, but how you say it. And when it comes to making an impact, nothing speaks louder than your actions.

Speaker 6 For those who lead by example, who adapt and overcome, there's a vehicle that matches your drive: The Range Rover Sport. The Range Rover Sport is a perfect blend of power, poise, and performance.

Speaker 6 With its assertive stance and refined driving experience, it's designed to make a statement.

Speaker 6 Want to elevate your drive, activate noise cancellation and cabin air purification for a pure, unadulterated drive, and with terrain response, you're ready to take on challenging landscapes with confidence.

Speaker 6 Plus, choose from a range of powerful engines, including a plug-in hybrid option. Ready to make your Explore Range Rover Sport at range Rover.com slash US slash sport.

Speaker 3 Oh, the car from Carvana's here.

Speaker 4 Well, will you look at that? It's exactly what I ordered. Like, precisely.
It would be crazy if there were any catches.

Speaker 3 But there aren't, right?

Speaker 2 Right.

Speaker 5 Because that's how car buying should be. With Carvana, you get the car you want.

Speaker 4 Choose delivery or pickup and a week to love it or return it. Buy your car today with Carvana.
Delivery or pickup fees may apply. Limitations and exclusions may apply.

Speaker 4 See our seven-day return policy at Carvana.com.

Speaker 2 We are back with the Victor Davis-Hansen Show recording on Monday the 9th. This is the Victor's Recovering episode, one of the two.

Speaker 2 This is the second that we're recorded, and this will be up on Thursday, June 19th.

Speaker 2 By the way, on Thursday, June 19th, by then I will be a senior citizen, Victor, so I'm looking forward to being a citizen. What a senior

Speaker 2 65.

Speaker 3 I will be. Oh my gosh, you look like you're 55.

Speaker 2 Well, I am what I am. I'm going to get my senior discounts.

Speaker 3 I had a nice letter.

Speaker 3 A very nice woman said, you don't look like Skeletor.

Speaker 3 So you know what I did?

Speaker 3 What? From on the website behind the paywall, when I'm answering questions, I'm going to put the picture of my bike accident and show you how Skeletor was formed.

Speaker 3 I'm going to show you how Skeletor was formed.

Speaker 2 You sent me,

Speaker 2 first of all, that you would even send that to me. You would do a selfie of yourself looking so banged up and then send it.
It was a really shocking picture. But don't you'll scare children.
And

Speaker 3 what?

Speaker 3 You'll scare people with that.

Speaker 3 I know it. And I

Speaker 2 want to get one of those stickers.

Speaker 2 They stick,

Speaker 2 you know, not with glue, but to the back of your car. I want to get some VDH image that we can send to our listeners and viewers.

Speaker 2 And even one of those ovals you see on the back of the car that have three three initials. I'm going to do VDH.
We're going to do that. No, mom, mommy.

Speaker 3 That's Lordy Lou. Lordy.

Speaker 2 What that was your, just see your bike, your front of your bike snapped off, and there you were.

Speaker 3 That was my fault. It had a hairline crack in the fork, and it was made out of carbon.
Yeah.

Speaker 3 And the next thing I knew, I woke up, and my two, my bottom and the upper lip, were not connected to each other. I mean, here, they were just.

Speaker 3 And I have

Speaker 2 you have a rugged handsomeness from that. Okay, let's now.
Let's ask this a question from John, who happens to be a friend and he happens to live in Milford, Connecticut.

Speaker 2 John asked a number of questions, but I got to pick one. Victor, when did you decide the Iraq war was a mistake?

Speaker 3 I supported it because of 9-11. And I don't know if I would have fully had I, I did believe that he had WMD.
I'm half believing that a lot of the WMD that he had, he shipped out.

Speaker 3 The other thing thing about the Iraq war was

Speaker 3 they had been, since the incomplete first Gulf War and the no-fly zones and all, they had, remember, they had destroyed the Marsh Arabs. They had committed genocide against them.

Speaker 3 They were persecuting Shia. Not that we should get into anybody's business in a cost-to-benefit analysis, but at that time, there were all of these.

Speaker 3 I was talking to Christopher Hitchens a lot, and he had written a lot that while Saddam Hussein was not an instigator of 9-11, he was aware of it.

Speaker 3 He had been, put it this way, some of the worst terrorists in the world that had killed Americans were residing in his regime, Abu Nadal and other people.

Speaker 3 I once wrote an article about all the reasons why you would like to go in there, but why didn't that's not the question? The question is, why did I change?

Speaker 3 I thought, first of all, and a cost of benefit. Remember, Donald Trump at this time was telling everybody he wanted to impeach.
He was for the war initially, and then he quickly got disillusioned.

Speaker 3 My criticism was it was everybody was saying it was my brilliant war and you screwed up. It's your peace.

Speaker 3 In other words, a lot of the neoconservatives, Richard Pearl, Bill Christo, all of them, had been hammering since 1998. Remember the project for a new American century under Clinton?

Speaker 3 If you go back and read that, I thought it was Robert Kagan, they were all asking for a premature, a preemptive attack on, forget about 9-11.

Speaker 3 They wanted to go in there and remove him and then democratize the area. I never believed in any of that.
But after 9-11, I thought we should at least take him out and leave.

Speaker 3 But as the surge started, and then we had the insurrection, and then Petraeus wanted the surge 2006, I thought, if you're for the war, then you have to be for the war.

Speaker 3 As Matthew Ridgway once reportedly said, there's only one thing worse than a bad war, and that's losing it. So I thought, if you lose this war, it's going to be catastrophic.

Speaker 3 So

Speaker 3 when the surge started, that was the worst of all, 2006 and 2007. That's when, if you look at the casualty figures, that was the area.

Speaker 3 So in 2006, I went with a group on Black Hawks. I was in bedded.
And I flew around, and you know, you see these kids right next to you sitting out of the Blackhawk with a 50-caliber machine gun.

Speaker 3 You talk to them. And then back at the base, I talked to people.
But more importantly, the next year I was in bedded with H.R.

Speaker 3 McMaster and he was on a mission for Petraeus to chronicle the Arab rebellion, the sons of Saddam and all those people who he flipped. Remember, they were joining us.

Speaker 3 And that's what won, they had the war won. And I noticed something very quickly that

Speaker 3 we said we were nation building, but we weren't really. That was just what we said.
Stanley McChrystal and most people were killing al-Qaeda, ISIS,

Speaker 3 Saddamites. That's what broke the back of the resistance and allowed there to be peace.
So in the time Obama was elected, 2009, when he took office, there were more people in the U.S.

Speaker 3 military per month being killed by accidents than in Iraq. It was pretty much quiet.
Then he pulled out, as you remember, and ISIS came in. And then Trump fixed that.

Speaker 3 But my point is, why did I change? Because I got over there twice. And I went with our friend Rich Lowry once.
He was in bed.

Speaker 3 We had a rocket that went right at us, almost killed us. It skipped.

Speaker 3 Anyway, I started talking to all these kids, and I would see all this wealth there. I mean, wealth in the sense of Humvees for a line forever, tanks, just an incredible amount of material.

Speaker 3 And you talk to all these kids, and then they would ask you, they said, why are we over here? Do we want to win or are we not? Are we going to win or not? I want to know, Mr.

Speaker 3 Hansen, are you here to say to me we're going to win? Because I don't winning.

Speaker 2 What did winning mean?

Speaker 3 What winning meant was to destroy the opposition and leave it calm.

Speaker 3 And then supposedly they had been told we were going to get a constitutional government like Egypt or not a constitutional, but something like Jordan or Egypt or something like that.

Speaker 3 So that it wouldn't be,

Speaker 3 you know, it would not be a host of terrorists. It wouldn't do all that.
And I couldn't answer that.

Speaker 3 So I thought to myself, if you're supporting this war, you have to go over there at least and see what it's like and what these kids are doing. So I did it twice.
And I had really bad kidney stones.

Speaker 3 I remember that. I stayed one year at the Palace of Saddam.
I interviewed David Petraeus, who I thought was very heroic. He was flying all over Iraq in very dangerous areas.

Speaker 3 There was no safe area there. I was at the airport when a rocket almost got us.
I was in the green zone when they would send in a mortar anywhere.

Speaker 3 So when they said that, I saw that they said, well,

Speaker 3 J.D. Vance was just a Marine reporter and he wasn't in a combat.
He was just, there was no safe places. They could kill you anywhere there.

Speaker 3 But I just got to the point when when I came back that I thought you either have to win the war or you've got to get out or you've got to tell everybody what you're doing because you're sending all these poor kids that are 18, 19 from working classes.

Speaker 3 And the people who are sending them are from the intellectual elite classes. It just bothered me.

Speaker 3 And, you know, I tried to do a lot of stuff. I drove a T-34 tank for about, I went out, it was just like Wild West.
Somebody said, you want to go out to the Iraqi army and see how they're training?

Speaker 3 I did. I I walked out there and they said, Eric, take a AK-47.
So I started shooting it. And then the guy said, this is better than your guns.
And I said, no, an M4 is much better.

Speaker 3 So he took the AK-47 and he threw it in the dirt. He took all the sand and poured it on.
He jumped on it and he had me jump on it. He said, now shoot it.
And it shot.

Speaker 3 And then he did that to another, an American M16 derivative, M4 whatever, and it didn't shoot. He said, which would you rather have? I don't know how to shoot very.

Speaker 3 I mean, I used to shoot shotguns pretty well, but I didn't, didn't, it was hard to shoot. In other words, it was very inaccurate.

Speaker 3 And then I got in the tank, and we had, my grandfather had a D4 from World War II or D2 with the little things like this when I was a kid. So I was able to drive it a little bit.

Speaker 3 And then I saw people. Well, the weird thing about it was you were in Iraq, and all of a sudden I said, I know you.
You're from the Monterey Postgraduate School. Yes, I know you.

Speaker 3 You were in the military history working group. You, I know you too.
And then Chris Gibson, who's a wonderful guy, he's a congressman for three terms, and

Speaker 3 he just texts me and said, I hear you're here. I'll be there in a second.
And all of a sudden, I turn around and he gets off a black hawk with an M16 and says, hell, how are you? It was just.

Speaker 3 And then I remember one day a person said, would you like to get on

Speaker 3 a flight into Balad Air Base and see the hospital? I said, yes. So we're going there.

Speaker 3 I think I told you that. And we kind of did a slow thing where they pushed a type of scanner, X-ray scanner, on a pallet off, but they didn't quite stop, right?

Speaker 3 And it wasn't a C 17, it was a C one thirty five. Oh, it was a cargo over there? Yeah, cargo.

Speaker 3 We were in a cargo thing, so he said, when we slow down, you jump off with a scanner and you can watch the Hawaii so I did with another guy.

Speaker 3 And then I get into the the hangars, they had Soviet hangars and everything, you know, and a guy goes, You look tired, and you can hear like people attacking the base and he said, what do you want do you like a Hage-Doss with almonds or do you like it without almonds I said I went with almonds and then somebody came do you want an oat latte or do you want this and they had this and then you know I went into the surgery center and there it was just horrific it was so it was so weird you know yeah

Speaker 3 and anyway it was a colossal effort of the best of Americans and I just came back thinking you can't oppose this unless you get them all out.

Speaker 3 If they're there, whoever's making the decision, you've got to support them. But I'm not sure if they should be there.

Speaker 3 Because from my point after I went over there and coming up, that's why I went over there because I was getting to the point where I don't think this whole country is worth one dead American.

Speaker 3 I was so mad.

Speaker 3 And

Speaker 3 there were a lot of nice Iraqis, but I just didn't see you take some kid that's working in an auto shop in Indiana at minimum wage and then you put him in a black hawk and he has to fly around and get shot at all the time for what?

Speaker 3 And then these people who dreamed all this up. And then I kind of felt guilty that I had been part of the people who supported the war and hadn't been over there.

Speaker 3 But in defense, a lot of the people that I now disagree with, they were very brave. Max Boot was a big hawk, but he went over there and he was embedded.

Speaker 3 Mark Stein went over there very early, and didn't he drive across Syria in a rental car? I think he did.

Speaker 3 Yeah, Mark Stein did. He did.
So there was a lot of people there. I saw a Hoover fellow there.
It was just,

Speaker 3 it was, but it was not going to work.

Speaker 2 It was well, especially the nation-building aspect of it.

Speaker 3 You talked to people and it was

Speaker 3 not going to work. People are people.
Their culture is culture. I didn't go to Afghanistan because that was considered the good war.
Remember, we won that supposedly until the withdrawal.

Speaker 3 And the Iraq was the bad war, but I always thought Afghanistan would be harder for a variety of reasons.

Speaker 2 Well, Victor, I have a question about

Speaker 3 what else?

Speaker 2 Oh, about warfare and horses but first I want to take a moment for our sponsor Open Phone. OpenPhone is the number one business phone system that streamlines and scales your customer communications.

Speaker 2 It works through an app on your phone or your computer. So no more carrying two phones or using a landline.

Speaker 2 With Open Phone your team can share one number and collaborate on customer calls and texts like a shared inbox.

Speaker 2 That way, any teammate can pick up right where the last person left off, keeping response times faster than ever.

Speaker 2 OpenPhone is a no-brainer and see why over 50,000 businesses trust OpenPhone to manage their businesses, calls, and texts.

Speaker 2 OpenPhone is offering our listeners 20% off your first six months at openphone.com slash Victor. That's O-P-E-N-P-H-O-N-E dot com slash Victor.

Speaker 2 And if you have existing phone numbers with another service, OpenPhone will port them over at no extra charge.

Speaker 2 Open phone, no missed calls, no missed customers, and we thank the good people at Open Phone for sponsoring the Victor Davis-Hansen show.

Speaker 2 Victor, really interesting question from Charla, Charla Gibson, who writes, I'd love to hear a lecture.

Speaker 2 No lectures, Victor, just five minutes, on how horses changed warfare in ancient Greece, specifically how Philip and Alexander incorporated horses in their campaigns to great success.

Speaker 2 That's from Charla. Victor.

Speaker 3 No horse in the world. Yeah, that was Frank Adcock in a little short book called The Greek and Macedonian Art of War.

Speaker 3 It was written, it's beautifully written.

Speaker 3 It's a little essay that he wrote, but it was this, the status quo said that horses would not be prominent in the ancient world because they could not attack infantry because they didn't have stirrups.

Speaker 3 And I think John Keegan wrote about that too. I think that's been modified now.

Speaker 3 But the point I'm making is that people who owned horses were aristocrats because if you take an acre of land in the ancient world, it will produce two cows or three cows or 15 sheep or goats,

Speaker 3 or it will produce grain and barley or olive oil. But if you have pasture, it'll only be like one horse, not even one horse.

Speaker 3 So people who had horses, they were either the wealthy cavalry class, the hippes, we call them, in classical Athens, or they were people from the vast plains of Thessaly and Macedonia.

Speaker 3 So the Macedonians had great rolling pasture, and they were kind of a monarchy pre-civilizational. They didn't have a city-state system like the South.

Speaker 3 And they were the first then to do a couple of things. They started to arm

Speaker 3 the rider and the horse with pads and sometimes with copper, I mean bronze protection.

Speaker 3 And then they started to use the companion cavalry had the infantry had something called a sarissa that can be anywhere from 14 to 22 feet in the hellenistic period because i don't know how i've tried to do that and it looks like a bow and arrow a boat

Speaker 3 but

Speaker 3 um

Speaker 3 anyway they they had horses with sarissas that are about 12 feet pikes and they had armored horses and they had big horses and they were the first to what we would call make shock cavalry what does that mean i mean typically when alexander or philip's army approached a classical greek army of hoplites that were just as good, citizen soldiers for the most part, they were mercenaries and paid soldiers, professionals.

Speaker 3 They would target an area on the line and then bombard it with arrows, with javelins, slings, etc., and cause chaos.

Speaker 3 And then they would send in the companion cavalry, about 2,500 on each wing, led by Alexander

Speaker 3 and his father, but mostly by Alexander.

Speaker 3 And then he would break through that disorganized mass and and he would, they could stab people that had armor on and blast through and then get in behind the enemy army.

Speaker 3 And that was the classical tactic. So that was the first time that horses played that role.
But mostly infantry was the primary

Speaker 3 because they were yeoman infantry, they were small farmers, etc. And they were the majority of the middle classes were infantry.

Speaker 3 And Rome had very, they had always had to get auxiliary cavalry from pre-civilizational people.

Speaker 3 So people that had horses in the ancient world, at least until the late empire, they were considered weird or pre-civilizational or not sophisticated.

Speaker 3 In other words, there's land inequality, big barons that had enough money and pasturage to support horses, which were very expensive.

Speaker 3 But they were very valuable. So, when Rome came in, they were an army of infantry that was just unstoppable, the legions, but they needed horses when they started to see diverse horse people.

Speaker 3 And what they did is they recruited them from the Germans, the Gauls, the Dacians, etc. They were auxiliary troops.

Speaker 3 And then, just to finish, the Byzantines then who were dealing with the Iranians, the Parthians, the people on the east, they developed something called

Speaker 3 cataphracts or cataphractoi. These were heavily armed.
I mean, they had a big Arab horse, and they had metal armor on the horse and on the rider with lances, and

Speaker 3 they could go through almost anything. And that was the Byzantines' secret weapon, or special weapon, or shock weapon that made them very

Speaker 3 formidable.

Speaker 2 Mentioning Byzantine, the Byzantium of the Empire, that will be the subject of our next and final question. And I will ask that of Victor when we come back from these final important messages.

Speaker 4 She's made up her mind to live pretty smart.

Speaker 3 Learns her budget responsibly right from the start.

Speaker 3 She spends a little less in boots, more into savings, keeps her blood pressure low, and credit score raises. She's gotten right out of her life.

Speaker 3 She tracks her cash flow on a spreadsheet at night.

Speaker 7 Boring money moves make kind of lame songs, but they sound pretty sweet to your wallet. BNC Bank, brilliantly boring since 1865.

Speaker 2 we're back with the Victor Davis-Hansen Show. It's Monday, June 9th.
This episode is up on Thursday, the 19th.

Speaker 2 I forget, Victor, if I did say you have a website, The Blade of Perseus, and it costs $65 a year to subscribe, $6.50 a month, if you want to do it monthly.

Speaker 2 And you would want to do that because you're a fan of Victor's writing. And twice a week, Victor writes an exclusive article for The Blade of Perseus, and once a week, he does an exclusive video.

Speaker 2 And there's so much more there. So do check that out and do subscribe.
Also, if you're on X, Victor's Handle is at V D Hansen. We mentioned again the Victor Davis Hansen Fan Club on Facebook.

Speaker 2 You should check that out. And Victor is on Facebook, VDH's Morning Cup.
And as for me, I write the Center for Civil Society's newsletter, Civil Thoughts.

Speaker 2 And you can go to civilthoughts.com and sign up. And every Friday, it'll come in your inbox, and it's got 14 recommended readings.
I know you will like it. CivilThoughts.com.

Speaker 2 Victor, our final question is simple, but it's from Brian Bagley. Why is the Byzantine Empire mostly ignored by history? The defeat of the Byzantine Empire changed European history.

Speaker 2 Is he right with that?

Speaker 3 Yeah, I think part of it is that we

Speaker 3 that the locus of civilization

Speaker 3 after the discovery of the New World in 1453

Speaker 3 and the end of the Byzantine Empire and the rise of

Speaker 3 the Ottoman Empire, we now associate Western civilization with an area that was backward in classical antiquities.

Speaker 3 Britain, Holland, the Netherlands, France, Spain had ports on the west, and they developed a very sophisticated trade to get around the Ottomans.

Speaker 3 That meant the old Silk Routes were blocked by Muslims. So they said, we're going to get to China or Africa along the African coast.
And then the idea that the world was round, we're going to go west.

Speaker 3 That's why we get the word Indian, right? Because they thought they were in India.

Speaker 3 So that wealth changed from the New World, and in terms of history, people say, well, the history of the West is the Western Roman Empire. And it really wasn't.

Speaker 3 If you look at where the scientific development was occurring in the Empire, and we also say it's because the Republic started, Roman society started in the West, in Italy.

Speaker 3 But by the time of the Empire, if you look at

Speaker 3 documents talking about imperial income, income, it's all from Egypt or from Syria or from Iraq or what's Asia Minor. And so the town, the cities like Alexandria, Pergamum, Tyre,

Speaker 3 were just so Thessaloniki. They were so much, and Constantinople, they were so much wealthier than Rome was at this time.
I'm talking about 400, 350.

Speaker 3 So then the Western Empire collapsed sometime in the 470s, but we forget that the Eastern Empire did not. And it existed for a thousand years

Speaker 3 because it didn't have a lot of religious schisms. It didn't have Manichaeanism or

Speaker 3 the liberist or et cetera, et cetera. Augustine was trying to do was solidify and unify

Speaker 3 what would become the Catholic Church. But Orthodoxy did not have as many challenges.
And it united the Byzantines and the government in a way that was not true of the West.

Speaker 3 And it had much more defensible borders. It got got to the Tigris and Euphrates.
It had the Hellespont from marauding people trying to get in.

Speaker 3 The walls of Constantinople were the most impressive in the world. The Theodesian walls, built around 440, 470, they were impenetrable.

Speaker 3 And then the Golden Horn and the Sea of Marmora, you couldn't get into Constantinople. And so this lasted for a thousand years, and it was a very sophisticated, brilliant society.

Speaker 3 I mean, Haggia Sophia by Justinian, it was the biggest church in the world for a thousand years until the cathedral, I think, at Seville.

Speaker 3 And it had the Justinian Law Co., the brilliant effort of Belisarus to try to unite the fallen West and bring it back.

Speaker 3 He almost pulled it off, and I think he would have if they had not had the Great Plague

Speaker 3 that wiped out a fourth of the Byzantine population. So my point is that why do we have a bad name? Why don't we give it credit? Because it did what the West couldn't do.

Speaker 3 And the answer is that as it survived and its heyday was the 5th century, 6th century, century, 7th, 8th, 9th, 10th, we got this wonderful reputation of it. And then the West caught up with it.

Speaker 3 And if you go today to Greece or somebody, they will tell you that Greece or Bulgaria or the West, the Orthodox countries were wealthier in antiquity.

Speaker 3 And the only reason that Western Europeans dominate the EU was because the Eastern Catholic Orthodox saved them from Ottomanism.

Speaker 3 We were enslaved for 400 years so you people in Italy could have the Renaissance. That's what they'll tell you.

Speaker 3 Or they'll tell you all of the great thinkers from Constantinople that had the majority of manuscripts that kept classical wisdom alive

Speaker 3 after the First Crusade or right before, I mean, the Fourth Crusade, where the Franks destroyed Constantinople and had to be, you know, rebuilt. That was Western Catholics, did that.
And

Speaker 3 they will tell you that after the during the fall of Constantinople, that all the great minds brought their scientific inquiry to Western Europe, and that prompted the Renaissance.

Speaker 3 But I think what happens is that the discovery of the New World and the fights of the East with Ottomanism kind of warped our appreciation.

Speaker 3 We said, well, Western Europe was always wealthier, and today it's wealthier. And it's no, it wasn't always wealthier.
The East was the bulwark of Western civilization from 500 AD to 1500, maybe.

Speaker 3 You know, Black Tuesday, May 29th,

Speaker 3 1453, that was the end of it. I wrote about that in the end of everything.
It was very tragic. The other thing, very quickly, is the word Byzantine is really not an ancient world.

Speaker 3 There's a city called Byzantium, and that's the one that Constantine the Great built on top of when he made Constantinople the city of Constantine.

Speaker 3 But it had been a very strategically located place, but the word, they never used the word Byzantium for Byzantine people. They were

Speaker 3 Hellenes. And what did the people of Byzantium for a thousand years call themselves? Romaioi.
Romans. Roman.
They were the true Romans.

Speaker 3 They thought that everybody had died in the West or had been conquered. They were the Romans.
So why do we call them Byzantines? It was 19th-century German scholarship who started to write about them.

Speaker 3 And they said, well, they're not Romans because the West fell, even though they call themselves Romaioi.

Speaker 3 But they were Greek speakers, so what's a good Greek word for the area that will, you know, they weren't Romans really. It was kind of a chauvinistic attack on them.

Speaker 3 So they started using the word Byzantine, which had been used very rarely by the Byzantines themselves. Once in a while, you'll see

Speaker 3 primary sources what they'll call it, the people of

Speaker 3 Byzantium, but it was not a word for the imperial civilization. It was Romaioi, Romans.
And the other thing, very quickly, is Gibbon.

Speaker 3 If you read Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, the last last chapters are devoted to

Speaker 3 Byzantium. And he was heavily influenced by sensationalist primary sources like Procopius, Secret History, and Theodora, all of the nudity, pornography, decadence, the hippodrome, and the Nica riots.

Speaker 3 And then he coined the idea that it was a decadent, pale imitation of the Western Empire. And he coined the idea, Gibbon did, that the church was, the Eastern Church was backward and superstitious.

Speaker 3 It had no experience with the Enlightenment or much less the Protestant Reformation. It had never had a counter-reformation.
It was just a ossified, solidified, calcified church.

Speaker 3 And he gave us the idea of

Speaker 3 Byzantine as a pejorative word in English, as something that's heavily bureaucratic and inefficient, which wasn't true at all.

Speaker 3 So Gibbon really prejudiced us, I think, against the Byzantines and the fact that it wasn't in Western scholarship. Most people in the Renaissance knew Latin, but they did not know Greek.

Speaker 3 So they did not have experience with Byzantine authors unless they had been translated.

Speaker 2 I am so glad. I forget who asked the question that they asked it because I was fascinated.

Speaker 2 Victor, we're doing these truncated shows because you've got things to do, like get your health back together. So we're going to conclude the podcast with that great answer.

Speaker 2 I want to thank everyone from the Victor Davis-Hansen Fan Club on Facebook who sent us questions. Couldn't get to answer them all.

Speaker 2 It's a possibility later this year, Victor might be gone for a week or so doing this or that, and we will store these questions, reserve them for that opportunity. Victor, you've been terrific.

Speaker 2 Thanks for all the wisdom you shared. Thank you, people, for listening, watching, for commenting on the show on YouTube, Rumble, Apple, wherever, Victor's own website.
God bless. Thanks so much.

Speaker 2 And we'll be back soon with another episode of the Victor Davis Hansen Show. Bye-bye.

Speaker 3 Thank you, everybody, for listening and viewing.