The Phantom Killer /// Part 1 /// 887

Speaker 1 Hey there! It's Katie Nolan, host of Casuals, the sports podcast where we don't care how much you know about sports, we're just happy that you're here.

Speaker 1 Every week, I hang out with some of my good friends to discuss the biggest stories across sports and entertainment, but in a way that's like fun and not boring.

Speaker 1 Want to know Sue Bird's favorite Diana Taurasi story, or how heavy the Larry O'Brien trophy is, or even what baseball team is right for you based on your moon sign? We got you.

Speaker 1 Listen to Casuals every Tuesday and Thursday on the SiriusXM app or wherever you get your podcasts.

Speaker 3 Bye!

Speaker 4 Hey, Ryan Reynolds here, wishing you a very happy half-off holiday because right now, Mint Mobile is offering you the gift of 50% off unlimited. To be clear, that's half price, not half the service.

Speaker 4 Mint is still premium unlimited wireless for a great price.

Speaker 2 So that means a

Speaker 3 half day.

Speaker 4 Yeah? Give it a try at mintmobile.com/slash switch.

Speaker 2 Upfront payment of $45 for three-month plan, equivalent to $15 per month required. New customer offer for first three months only.
Speed slow out, 35 gigabytes of networks busy. Taxes and fees extra.

Speaker 3 See Mintmobile.com.

Speaker 3 Welcome to True Crime Garage. Wherever you are, whatever you are doing, thanks for listening.
I'm your host, Nick, and to my immediate left or to my extremely far right, the one, the only, the cap.

Speaker 3 Either way, I'm here in the garage with you. It's good to be seen.
Good to see you. Thanks for listening.
Thanks for telling a friend.

Speaker 3 This week, and once again, we are very happy to be drinking Truth IPA by the awesome folks down at Rheingeist Brewery.

Speaker 3 For some, and especially for the folks at Rheingist Brewery, truth is found in the brilliance of hops. Truth IPA is brewed with a nod to the Pacific.

Speaker 3 Using hops that sizzle with tropical fruit aromas, we have grapefruit, we have mango notes, and a dry finish. ABV 7.2% garage grade 4 and a half bottle caps out of 5.

Speaker 3 And let's give some thanks and praise to our good garage friends for helping us out with this week's show. First up, a shout out to Tanya from Cincinnati.

Speaker 3 And a big, we like your jibby jib jib goes out to Karina in Copenhagen. And here's a cheers to Roxanne, who says she's in the middle of nowhere, Georgia.

Speaker 3 And last but certainly not least, I want to send out a very special Ron Swanson please and thank you to one of my favorite listeners, Janelle from Round Lake.

Speaker 3 And here's another thank you that goes out to all of our great first responders and ER personnel. Everyone we just mentioned went to TrueCrimeGarage.com and helped us out with this week's beer fund.

Speaker 3 And for that, we thank you. Yeah, BWRUN beer run.

Speaker 3 Make sure you check out truecrimegarage.com. And while you're there, sign up on the mailing list.
And Colonel, that's enough of the BSBS.

Speaker 3 All right, everybody, gather around, grab a chair, grab a beer. Let's talk some true crime.

Speaker 3 The devil's wanna get you in your sleep.

Speaker 3 The devil's gonna catch you in your sleep.

Speaker 3 The devil's gonna get you in your sleep.

Speaker 3 The devil's gonna catch you in your sleep.

Speaker 5 This week's true crime story is one that is as scary as any true crime case.

Speaker 5 In fact, in many ways, it is far more scary than any other unsolved murder case that we have covered.

Speaker 5 This true story at its core

Speaker 5 is about double murders committed seemingly at random and in the dead of the night by a phantom killer.

Speaker 5 This is the eerie tale of the Texarkana Moonlight murders,

Speaker 5 a case that resulted in several double homicides and multiple attacks that left a town in fear for decades.

Speaker 5 The murders were committed by a masked gunman.

Speaker 5 The killer remains unidentified to this day.

Speaker 5 Who was the man stalking his prey in the night?

Speaker 3 And will his real identity ever be revealed?

Speaker 5 This is the story of the town that feared Sundown, a series of homicides today referred to as the Tex Arcana Moonlight Murders, committed by the one that they call the Phantom Killer.

Speaker 3 This

Speaker 5 is True Crime Garage.

Speaker 3 The killer,

Speaker 3 known to those of Texarkana and the surrounding towns and cities in both Texas and Arkansas as the Phantom Killer, was responsible for multiple attacks.

Speaker 3 He was never caught, and the case remains one of America's most chilling and haunting mysteries.

Speaker 3 This case is not just incredibly frightening and undeniably chilling, but a truly haunting mystery that has taken hold of many over the decades.

Speaker 3 This is the absolute triple threat of a real life true crime story. It's a slasher film, a ghost story, and a murder mystery all wrapped up into one homicidal maniac with a hooded mask and a gun.

Speaker 3 But with this one, it's not so easy to say when the murders began or when they ended. For us, we will start where most folks do when discussing the Texarkana moonlight murders or the phantom killer.

Speaker 3 We will start on a dark night in Texarkana back in 1946, when, as they say, the Phantom Killer struck for the very first time.

Speaker 3 So let's go to Texarkana, Captain. This is a twin city.
There is Texarkana in the state of Arkansas, and just across the state line, you will find Texarkana in the state of Texas. How cute.
How cute.

Speaker 3 Together, they are the principal cities of the Texarkana metropolitan area. Carlton Stowers, a great writer for the Dallas Observer, called the story the Phantom Menace.

Speaker 3 And as he writes, the enduring legend began not with death, but with a frightening and vicious attack on two young lovers.

Speaker 3 This attack took place on a February night in 1946 when two young romantic partners, 24-year-old Jimmy Hollis and his girlfriend Mary Jean LeRae, age 19, attended a downtown movie.

Speaker 3 After the movie, as sometimes young folks do, they decided to to prolong the evening with a romantic visit to a secluded lane on the edge of town.

Speaker 3 They stopped off at, according to legend, a lover's lane not far from a neighborhood. In fact, it is stated that the two were parked approximately 300 feet from the last row of city homes.

Speaker 3 Now, in that spot today sits a mall. According to police reports, they had been parked for no more than about 10 minutes when a man, his face hidden beneath a white hood, approached the car.

Speaker 3 This terrified the two, obviously. The victims were caught off guard.
The masked man was pointing a flashlight and pistol at them. The attack occurred in a very dark and seemingly quiet area.

Speaker 3 The day and date, it's Friday night,

Speaker 3 February 22nd, and the time it's just shortly before midnight.

Speaker 3 Jimmy Hollis and Mary Jean Larie are parked on a secluded road just outside of Texarkana, Texas, terrified and alone, and at the mercy now of this masked man with a gun.

Speaker 3 And they're trying to understand exactly what is happening. So neither of them could grasp the reality of the unknown assailant approaching their vehicle in the dark.

Speaker 3 And it was only when the figure got closer that they could tell it was a man, physically fit, menacing, and wearing, as we said, a white cloth mask.

Speaker 3 The record states that the cloth mask resembled a pillowcase with eye holes cut out and a slit for the mouth.

Speaker 3 But because our victims are seated and the aggressor standing, even with the holes for the eyes and the mouth, they could not make out a single detail beyond the mask.

Speaker 3 This is in part due to the shadows and the darkness, of course. The masked man quickly made his way to the driver's side door of the vehicle.

Speaker 3 He's blinding Jimmy Hollis with the beam of his flashlight. Complete boner killer.
Jimmy could hardly see the man at all.

Speaker 3 The attacker is all but a silhouette at this point, but what he could make out very clearly was the barrel of a gun pointed directly at his face.

Speaker 3 So Jimmy tries to tell this guy, the masked man, hey, you've got the wrong guy.

Speaker 3 To which the Phantom responded, I don't want to kill you, fella. so just do what I say.
Now, this masked man captain gave loud, clear, and direct orders.

Speaker 3 He demanded that the two of them get out of their vehicle, and he growled at Jimmy commandingly, telling him to take off your goddamn breeches.

Speaker 3 Then, with Jimmy standing now only in his boxer shorts, The masked man, the Phantom Menace, struck Jimmy in the head fast and ferocious with a solid and likely metallic object.

Speaker 3 Jimmy stepped back, stunned and phased, unassure of what he was hit with and wondering

Speaker 3 what he had said or did to provoke such a violent strike. But before he could sort that out, sort that equation, he was hit once again in the head and this time even harder than the first.

Speaker 3 So instantly, Jimmy,

Speaker 3 everything goes black. His body goes limp.
He collapsed. He didn't even feel his body and his head hit the ground as he fell face first into the pavement.
Right.

Speaker 3 So now, Captain, we have a very bad situation here. The young woman, Mary Jean, just 19 years old.
It's midnight. She's now alone.
Her boyfriend knocked out, lying helpless in the street.

Speaker 3 And now, making his way from the driver's side of the vehicle over to her

Speaker 3 is a man in a mask with a gun. And what he wants and expects of her is unknown.
Right.

Speaker 3 She tries to get in front of it, maybe, if she could just communicate clearly to the man that she might be able to de-escalate this situation, stop the violence, and get the man to spare them and leave so she can get medical help for her boyfriend.

Speaker 3 So she's thinking, I've got to get to Jimmy. She needed to know if he was still breathing.
I would think that she has to be hoping, right, that the man is just an armed robber.

Speaker 3 All he wants is money, with the mask hopefully being some form of confirmation that he gets what he wants and you get what you want, right?

Speaker 3 He gets the money, can't be identified, and you get to keep your life. Well, if you're planning on killing them, there's no need to wear the mask.
The mask is almost a hopeful sign.

Speaker 3 Do you have any thoughts on why he would have Jimmy take his pants off?

Speaker 3 I guess if you're going to rob somebody, hey, just give me your pants and your wallet, and everything's going to be in there as well.

Speaker 3 I think oftentimes, when I've seen when a perpetrator, regardless of what the motive is or what they're attempting to achieve, a lot of times when they're having a victim remove their clothing,

Speaker 3 it is to deter them from fleeing. Right.

Speaker 3 So that could be the situation here.

Speaker 3 I have a lot of thoughts about this killer under the hood here.

Speaker 3 A lot of thoughts that we can get to once we get through the different crimes that are going to take place because this is our first crime scene.

Speaker 3 So right now, in this very scenario, if I'm Mary Jean, I have three goals. One,

Speaker 3 check on Jimmy. Two, distance myself from the man with the gun.

Speaker 3 And three, give him money or prove that we have none and send him on his way hopefully this is just an armed robber with poor targeting skills as these are young folks parked not much reason to assume that they would have a large sum of money on them or even in the vehicle right

Speaker 3 so mary jean makes her way over to jimmy and she tells the gunman

Speaker 3 We don't have any money.

Speaker 3 And by this time, she's so terrified and afraid for her boyfriend that she is crying she even pulls jimmy's wallet out from his his trousers to show the man look there's no money yeah but this phantom menace doesn't make a lot of sense because he says uh what was the quote again did he say i don't want to kill you i don't he says i don't want to hurt you or yeah i don't want to kill you fella so just do what i say right but then but then he just beats him over the head right and in a lot of these reports that you'll read it's jimmy says he doesn't know what he was hit with but we can we have to make the assumption right it's either the butt of the gun or the flashlight the the phantom is could be a lot of things but he doesn't have three hands or three arms and he's holding a flashlight and gun when he approaches the vehicle and when the two step out of the vehicle and let me tell you something that you might not know both of those items would hurt so at this time captain she's showing him look we we don't have any money right he's she's got the wallet and then the attacker, he then hits Mary Jean

Speaker 3 very hard, seemingly with probably the same object. She falls to the ground.
The attacker then orders her to stand up. She believes that the man told her to run, so she does.

Speaker 3 She's running, fleeing from the scene. And now Mary Jean Larie, she spots an old car.
parked off of the road.

Speaker 3 So she runs up to this vehicle, but unfortunately, she finds the car empty. Before she can make her next move, she's caught by the attacker.
He seems even more angry and unsettled than before.

Speaker 3 He says to her, Why are you running?

Speaker 3 When she said that he had told her to do so, he calls her a liar. He then forced her to the ground, down to the ground, and then he sexually assaults her with the barrel.
of the gun.

Speaker 3 Some accounts of this portion of this story say that that assault happened in a wooded area or some nearby woods. After the assault, Mary Jean,

Speaker 3 she flees on foot. We can surmise that the attacker likely is making his getaway at the same time.
Do we have any thoughts on how he got there? Did he walk there? Did he motorcycle car?

Speaker 3 Fall from the sky? I think

Speaker 3 I think the most likely scenario is the empty vehicle that she ran up to was probably his.

Speaker 3 That makes a lot of sense. I think he saw the vehicle.
I picture this a couple of ways because it's reported.

Speaker 3 This story,

Speaker 3 I think, because it's sort of, and forgive me for saying so, because this is a true story. These are real victims here that were terrified and came very close to death.
That's your spoiler alert.

Speaker 3 They both survive.

Speaker 3 Well, that's how we have an account of what happened is they survived. This story is so action-packed

Speaker 3 that I think that we get many different tellings of this story. I think that a lot of it's based in fact.

Speaker 3 But

Speaker 3 one thing that I find

Speaker 3 interesting is that in some of the versions of the story, Keep in mind, we're talking about 1946, so there's been a lot of years, a lot of decades that have passed.

Speaker 3 And that probably plays to why we have slight variance with the different stories here, the different versions.

Speaker 3 Some of those versions include that headlights. Somebody was driving.
A vehicle showed up in the area and that is what spooked. That's what they believe may have spooked the attacker.

Speaker 3 So he may have carried out,

Speaker 3 if his intent was to murder, he may have carried that out that night. But because of the vehicle showing up on the scene, he didn't.

Speaker 3 Other versions of that story leave the vehicle out, the headlights out.

Speaker 3 A lot of the people at the time, Captain, the law enforcement, seemed to be of the belief that either the attacker didn't really want to kill the couple. Right.
Mary Jean, her

Speaker 3 statement and her opinion of the events and what maybe the killer was thinking,

Speaker 3 attacker was thinking,

Speaker 3 was that she thinks that the masked man

Speaker 3 thought that Jimmy was dead. Yeah.

Speaker 3 And in fact, she thought that Jimmy was dead because she said when he hit Jimmy the second time, struck him over the head, he was hit so hard that she thought that the man shot him.

Speaker 3 She thought that the gun went off, that he shot Jimmy in the head. That's brutal.
And he had some severe,

Speaker 3 severe severe skull damage. Yeah.
Head trauma. I mean, it was, it basically cracked his skull open.
And I don't know.

Speaker 3 I think the noise that she heard was a combination of the butt of the gun striking his head and his head popping at the same time.

Speaker 3 But I think it makes these cases more haunting when there's survivors because we get to hear the details of the attacks. You see this in Zodiac and Ted Bundy and

Speaker 3 so many others where there's a survivor, John Wayne Gacy. There's a survivor, and they tell you what happened that was basically leading up to their death.

Speaker 3 And they were lucky to survive. Well, and you bring up an interesting question.
I was glad that you asked about how did the attacker get there? Because they don't see a car, right?

Speaker 3 They never reference a car in their statements that they end up giving to police. We got to keep in mind here, though, when we examine Jimmy Hollis's statement,

Speaker 3 that he,

Speaker 3 while he does

Speaker 3 come to,

Speaker 3 so let me give you the rest of the story and we'll circle back to this. So,

Speaker 3 Mary Jean, she says that she ran, or at least the report says that she ran about a half a mile to a nearby home. I think that that might be

Speaker 3 that distance might be exaggerated because remember we had said earlier that they were only 300 feet or 300 yards, depending on the reports you read, from the last row of city homes.

Speaker 3 So I don't think she had to run half a mile to a nearby home. But we do know that she did run to a home and she pounds on the door.

Speaker 3 She wakes up the folks that live there, and the people there call the authorities. Meanwhile, Jimmy Hollis managed to regain consciousness.

Speaker 3 He's able to get back to his feet or at least kind of pull himself up a bit. And he

Speaker 3 alerted a passing motorist who would also call the police. That's some grit, right?

Speaker 3 True. True grit.
I like the cut of that guy's jib

Speaker 3 to have the grit to pull yourself up like the Undertaker rising up. But he's hurt so badly that once the police we hit, we have the Bowie County Sheriff's Department.
They arrive on the scene.

Speaker 3 The officers there said that Jimmy was in such bad shape that he was going in and out of consciousness. Like he kept, he kept falling out.

Speaker 3 He kept falling out and falling out and coming to and falling out and coming to.

Speaker 3 And so

Speaker 3 I wanted to make sure we included that

Speaker 3 when we are talking about Jimmy's statement. Because how much anybody that's been knocked out or even hit on the head real hard, fainted,

Speaker 3 I think most folks would tell you about the same thing.

Speaker 3 Like, I don't know that I fully trust my memory, or I have, there's, there's black spots, there's blank spots in my memory of what led up to that.

Speaker 3 Mary Jean is going to be able to give us a better idea of what happened.

Speaker 3 But again, she was hit too over the head. So both of these folks are in bad shape.
The police are on the scene.

Speaker 3 The sheriff's department's on the scene, but of course the masked gunman is nowhere to be found.

Speaker 3 Both victims were sent off to the hospital, Mary Jean, for an overnight stay, and Jimmy Hollis was in far worse shape and forced to be hospitalized for an extended stay to recover from multiple skull fractures.

Speaker 3 Jimmy was hospitalized for several weeks, and he was in and out of a coma during that time. We talked about this part in our coverage back on True Crime Garage episode one,

Speaker 3 The Phantom Killer, that our two victims, Jimmy Hollis and Mary Jean LeRae. I keep saying Larie LeRae.
I've heard it pronounced about three different ways. So I apologize to.

Speaker 3 And we pronounced it five different ways in episode one. We'll put our own spin on it.
Yeah. The two victims, as we said, gave

Speaker 3 what authorities would later say is a slightly different description. Right.
They're giving slightly different descriptions of their attacker. So let's start with what they both agree on.

Speaker 3 They agree that the assailant was

Speaker 3 about six foot tall and thin. So athletic build, six foot tall.
Neither of them had recognized his voice, right? And what they mean by that is it wasn't a voice that they had heard before.

Speaker 3 They couldn't place the voice. It wasn't somebody that they believed that they knew.
And both of them did say, look, we didn't see the face hidden behind the mask.

Speaker 3 Some reports say that they both believe the attacker to be approximately 30 years old. Now, here's the differing accounts, right? We have Mary Jean claim that she could see under the mask.

Speaker 3 And I'm guessing when she says this, that it might be through the eye holes in the mouth, the slit for the mouth.

Speaker 3 And I don't want to go too far down this road because

Speaker 3 the brutality of the attack, but obviously, by our description of the events that took place, she

Speaker 3 would have had a better angle,

Speaker 3 a better vantage point to at a chance of seeing who this guy was.

Speaker 3 She says that she thought the man to be a light-skinned African-American. And Jimmy Hollis says that he thought the attacker was a tan white man or a dark-complected white male.

Speaker 3 Again, it would be hard to tell in the dark.

Speaker 3 And plus, you know how your eyes have to readjust when you see a bright light and then you look into the darkness. And that's part of what Jimmy says, too, here, Captain.

Speaker 3 He says he did say, like, look, this is my opinion. This is what I think that I saw, but conceded that he could not distinguish the features of this man.

Speaker 3 And that for the majority of the time when he was being attacked or was face to face with the attacker, he was blinded by the flashlight.

Speaker 3 Cold mornings, holiday plans, this is when you just want your wardrobe to be simple. Stuff that looks sharp, feels good, and things you'll actually wear.
That's where Quince comes in.

Speaker 3 And the bonus, Quince pieces make great gifts too. This season's lineup is simple but smart and easy with Quince.

Speaker 3 $50 Mongolian cashmere sweaters that feel like an everyday luxury and wool coats that are equal parts stylish and durable. I love Quince.com.

Speaker 3 I go there, I shop there, I get the things that I need to stuff my closet full of great classic styles. that I want to wear.
Just picked up the cotton PK knit over shirt. I love this shirt.

Speaker 3 shirt, it's become my favorite shirt in my closet. I'm looking forward to cold evenings, chilly evenings, so I can put on my new shirt and get out there and have some fun.

Speaker 3 It comes in three different colors. Check out quince.com.
You're going to love the classic styles. Give and get timeless holiday staples that last this season with Quince.

Speaker 3 Go to quince.com/slash garage for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada too.
That's Q-U-I-N-C-E

Speaker 3 dot com slash garage. Free shipping and 365 day returns, quince.com slash garage.

Speaker 7 He's Kenny Main, the funny guy from ESPN.

Speaker 8 Formerly. He's Cooper Manning, the more intelligent and handsome of the Manning brothers.

Speaker 7 And he's Brian Baumgartner. But to me, he'll always be Kevin from the office.

Speaker 9 Yeah, you and everybody else. Together, we're the hosts of the new comedy golf podcast, We Need a Fourth, from Smartless Media and SiriusXM.

Speaker 3 It's like a cold beer after a round.

Speaker 7 You hear the strangest and most bizarre golf stories from our friends, athletes, celebrities, and comedians.

Speaker 8 It's all about how much we love golf and how much we hate golf. New episodes are out every week.
Listen now and subscribe wherever you get your podcast. Could just be anywhere, just on a couch.

Speaker 8 Doesn't matter.

Speaker 10 rediscover skin that looks as vibrant as you feel medicate is a british clinical skincare brand trusted by dermatologists for visible age-defying results without compromise and right now is the best time of the year to try it medicate's 30 off during their black friday sale if you've been curious about retinol start with medicate's crystal retinol night serum it's award-winning ultra gentle and proven to work 11 times faster than traditional retinol smoothing wrinkles brightening dark spots, and firming skin without irritation.

Speaker 10 Or try the fan-favorite liquid peptide serum, clinically proven to smooth fine lines in just seven days.

Speaker 10 And if you want that lifted, deeply hydrated feel, Medicaid's newest innovation, Advanced Pro Collagen Plus Peptide Cream, delivers visibly rejuvenated skin while reducing wrinkles.

Speaker 10 This is the moment to elevate your routine. Medicate's 30% off Black Friday sale is happening now through Tuesday, December 2nd.

Speaker 10 Visit medicate.us, that's M-E-D-I-K-8.us, and save 30% on age-defying skincare.

Speaker 3 Is your home actually safe if you have old-school home security? Traditional security systems respond after someone breaks in. Simply Safe is different.

Speaker 3 With their active guard outdoor protection, you can prevent crimes before they happen. AI-powered cameras detect threats while they are still outside your home and alert real security agents.

Speaker 3 They confront the intruder, letting them know they're being watched on camera and that police are on their way and even sounding a loud siren and triggering a spotlight if needed.

Speaker 3 I love my SimplySafe home security system. When I'm at home, I feel safe and protected because of this system.
And with a quick look-see, I can see what's going on outside of my home.

Speaker 3 It's very easy to use. I always arm the system when I leave, and SimplySafe gives me peace of mind when I am not at home, when I am gone, especially for extended periods of time, like vacations.

Speaker 3 Don't miss out on Simply Safe's biggest sale of the year: 60%

Speaker 3 off.

Speaker 3 Right now, our listeners can save 60% off on a SimplySafe home security system at simply safe.com/slash garage. That's simply safe.com/slash garage.
There's no safe like SimplySafe.

Speaker 3 The devil's only catch you in your sleep.

Speaker 3 All right, we are back. Cheers, mates, tall cans in the air.
And cheers to the people in the back. Talk hands in the air.
And dear God, fix the internet.

Speaker 3 Please, God. That's all we ask of you.
And happy Thanksgiving to everybody out there, too. Please have a wonderful Thanksgiving, a safe Thanksgiving.
It's my favorite long weekend of the year.

Speaker 3 I mean, food, family, friends, football doesn't get any better than that, my friend. So make sure

Speaker 3 you soak it all in and enjoy every second of it.

Speaker 3 This is,

Speaker 3 I always catch myself when I have to say this, Captain. I always go, this is the strange part of the story, but they're true crime stories, Nick.
Every part of it,

Speaker 3 there's strange business strewn throughout these stories, right?

Speaker 3 See, after the Phantom Menace said he didn't want to kill me, and then he hit me really hard with a gun or a flashlight, I would have replied, I thought you said you didn't want to kill me.

Speaker 3 Yeah, and I think that was a clever play on words by that writer,

Speaker 3 Stowers, because he wrote an extensive article for the Dallas Observer on this case. His article came out around the time the Star Wars Phantom Menace movie had come out.

Speaker 3 So I think he was doing a clever play on words there with titling the article.

Speaker 3 But one thing that is regularly reported in this story, regardless of where you get your information from, is that it seems like law enforcement didn't fully believe the couple's account of the events and the attacker.

Speaker 3 In fact, they publicly said that they believed that the couple that was attacked, Jimmy and Mary Jean, knew the identity of the attacker and were covering for him. That's odd.

Speaker 3 Yes, that's a whole lot of crazy right there. So let's try to

Speaker 3 unpack it. Let's try to get into this bundle of crazy and unbundle it.
A guy cracks my skull open, and I'm covering for him.

Speaker 3 Well, okay, so part of this does make sense once we get some more of the facts. Both Jimmy and Mary are married, not to each other.
Ooh.

Speaker 3 So from my understanding.

Speaker 3 Well, from my understanding, they were both well along their way into getting a separation, a legal separation.

Speaker 3 I don't think that they were doing anything behind anyone's back, but that doesn't mean that they wouldn't be upsetting someone or aggravating somebody, maybe to to the point where there would be a threat or even an attack.

Speaker 3 Well, not all separations are amicable. Maybe Jimmy's spouse is upset.
Maybe her spouse is upset. Who knows? I think that that was,

Speaker 3 it would appear to me, Captain, that that is the suspicions of law enforcement at the time, right? They dig into the background of these two and they're like, oh, these two are out fooling around.

Speaker 3 Mary Jean's husband, even though might soon to be the ex-husband, he found them in this car together and he attacked Jimmy.

Speaker 3 And I think part of that thinking too is that Mary Jean's injuries are far less severe than that of Jimmy's. So that probably plays into it a little bit for law enforcement.
And guess what?

Speaker 3 It wouldn't be the first time that a member of law enforcement has been lied to. I firmly believe that both of these two are telling the absolute truth.

Speaker 3 I've looked at this a million ways, and I'm sitting here thinking, like, who cares if it was my ex who attacked my boyfriend? Even more reason to say that I knew who the guy was. Right.

Speaker 3 That's where my mind goes. To me, it's more, I could see if I was law enforcement, I'm talking to these witnesses.
They've just been, and they're not really just witnesses. They're survivors.
Right.

Speaker 3 So

Speaker 3 there would be a part of me that's going, this is a vicious, violent, brutal attack. Is there a possibility they're not saying something?

Speaker 3 Not because they're covering, but because they're afraid that this son of a bitch is going to come back after them and to finish the job.

Speaker 3 Because this attacker that shows up on this lover's lane might not know who these individuals are, but this is not a giant town. It's about 40,000 people back there.
That's not giant.

Speaker 3 No, no, it doesn't matter either. Their names are in every newspaper.
Exactly. You don't have to know who they were when you attacked them.
Their names are in every newspaper. Now,

Speaker 3 I think, though,

Speaker 3 and let's not stay on this too long because we have a lot to get to here in this case.

Speaker 3 But can you imagine if you have, if you are in one room, you're at the hospital with Jimmy interviewing him, and I'm at the hospital and I'm interviewing Mary, we're in separate rooms, I presume.

Speaker 3 And then we meet up after we've talked to both of our victims, our survivors here, And you go, hey, he said the guy's white. And I said, well, she said the guy's black.

Speaker 3 Right then, I feel like our, like the wheels are going to start turning and we're going to start trying to piece this thing together and sort out, well, why do we have that conflict?

Speaker 3 That's a major conflict in your witness statements.

Speaker 3 The reason for that conflict is simply they're terrified, they're afraid, the flashlight's in their faces, and the guy had a freaking hood over his head. But also, you don't know what you don't know.

Speaker 3 That was a lover's lane attack. And as we said, thankfully, Jimmy Hollis, age 25, and his girlfriend, Mary Jean LeRay, 19, parked on a secluded stretch of road after a movie.
They survived.

Speaker 3 Now, in the wake of the traumatic attack, Mary Jean,

Speaker 3 her attempts to sleep are routinely interrupted by horrible nightmares.

Speaker 3 She was afraid, just like you had suspected here, Captain, she was afraid that the Phantom Attacker would seek her out.

Speaker 3 And I saw some reports stating that she left, reports of her leaving Texarkana to go for an extended stay with relatives in the state of Oklahoma. So she left the state.

Speaker 3 Now, just after one month, just one month after Mary and Jimmy were assaulted, the legend of the Phantom Killer began to take its ugly form.

Speaker 3 Jimmy Hollis warned police, saying, quote, if you don't find him, he's going to kill someone, end quote. And unfortunately, Jimmy was right.

Speaker 3 Carlton Stowers writes in part, more than a half century later, that event is looked back on as the precursor of a nightmare that would long terrorize this quiet East Texas railroad center.

Speaker 3 In the weeks following the attack on Hollis and LeRae, Five murders would occur in its rural shadows, prompting one of the most intense manhunts in the state's history.

Speaker 3 Twice on moonlit nights, an unknown assailant interrupted young lovers, leaving them brutalized and dead. On another evening, a farmer sitting in his living room was shot through a nearby window.

Speaker 3 So let's go to March 24th. This is March 24th, 1946.

Speaker 3 The Phantom killed for the first time.

Speaker 3 We have a heavy rain that was falling early that Sunday morning when a motorist nearing the Texarkana city limits noticed an Oldsmobile sedan parked on a dirt lane near U.S. Highway 67.

Speaker 3 So

Speaker 3 thinking that someone was just stuck in the mud, this vehicle stuck in the mud, the driver slowed and got close enough to see that two people were in the vehicle.

Speaker 3 And it looked as if they might be asleep. So again, the date was March 24th, 1946.
And on this day, Richard Griffin,

Speaker 3 29, and Pollyanne Moore, 17, were found dead in Griffin's car,

Speaker 3 parked on another lover's lane. Griffin, his body lay awkwardly slumped between the seats, pockets turned out as if robbed.

Speaker 3 Polly Ann Moore lay in the back seat, but investigators suspected that she had been killed outside. So they actually suspect that both were probably killed outside of the vehicle.

Speaker 3 And then placed back into the vehicle. That the killer managed to place them back into the vehicle.
That takes some strength. Both had been shot in the head with a.32 caliber Colt pistol,

Speaker 3 and this would end up being the same weapon that would be used in a later attack.

Speaker 3 The Phantom. had escalated from assault to murder, and now fear was spreading faster in Texarkana than the ink in the headlines.
And again, it goes back to the idea in the first attack.

Speaker 3 If these two attacks are, in fact, connected, committed by the same attacker,

Speaker 3 what was his intent in the first attack? Was it his intent to commit double homicide? Because that's the result here. A little background here, Captain.

Speaker 3 Richard Griffin was recently discharged from the Navy. Pollyanne Moore, a 17-year-old employee at the Red River Arsenal, has said they're both found dead.

Speaker 3 The way that they're positioned in the vehicle, I apologize, but it's reported all over the shop, especially with Richard Griffin's body. Some of the reports state that he's in the front seat.

Speaker 3 Some state that he's

Speaker 3 between the seats, and then others state that he's in the back seat. But with

Speaker 3 Pollyanne Moore, every account I could find, she's in the back seat.

Speaker 3 Griffin had been shot twice in the head, and some of this might be a bit repetitive, but it adds some context to the double murder scene and fleshes it out a bit.

Speaker 3 This says Moore's body lay face down on a blanket in the back seat.

Speaker 3 Her open purse beside her, a ring signifying that she had recently graduated from Atlanta High School, which is it's in Texas, is still on her finger.

Speaker 3 Investigators noted a pool of blood about 20 feet away from the vehicle. So investigators concluded that she had likely been killed there and her body placed back inside the car.

Speaker 3 And then, again, some reports state that they believe both were killed outside of the vehicle and placed back

Speaker 3 inside of the car. I wonder if the placement of the victims in the car matter.

Speaker 3 And what I mean by that is, like I said, to put a victim back into the car, that would take some strength.

Speaker 3 But if you're trying to set a scene or trying to stage the scene in some manner, you'd think that you'd put both of the victims back into the front seat.

Speaker 3 So that makes me wonder, did he just open up whatever door that they were closest to? And then, again, that would make me question how strong this individual was.

Speaker 3 I don't know how the vehicle was positioned in relation to the road, that the motorist that eventually finds them, because it may,

Speaker 3 the strategy there, Captain, might lie in the idea of if I'm going to take the time to put place them back in the vehicle, I'm doing that for very, for a very strong purpose, right?

Speaker 3 I'm not just doing that just for the fun of it. I think it may have been an attempt to conceal the bodies and delay discovery of the bodies.

Speaker 3 And if how many times do we drive down a road and we see a vehicle that's just sitting off to the side of the road and nobody's in it? We just keep driving. I think in this scenario.

Speaker 3 Yeah, in this scenario, I think that

Speaker 3 the gentleman that approached the vehicle only did so because he assumed due to the rain that was falling that they were stuck in the mud he was just attempting to help some people

Speaker 3 and then when he gets close realizes oh there's people in here they look like they're sleeping wait a second no they're not they've been shot and they're dead aside from several shell casings from a 32 caliber pistol located near the murder scene investigators found little evidence They had stated that the heavy rainfall that continued throughout the day that the bodies were found had washed away footprints that they were hoping to find, shoe prints that they were hoping to find, and tire tread as well.

Speaker 3 And it made it all but impossible, they said, to locate any fingerprints on the exterior, on the exterior of the vehicle. But how do we know it's the same person? Well, that's a great question.

Speaker 3 I don't think that we can 100% say that it is. Because again, it goes back to intent.
What was the intent of the first attacker? Was he spooked?

Speaker 3 Was he scared by the car that was passing by, as some of the reports say, and then he flees the scene?

Speaker 3 And who's to say what he would have done had he not been spooked? Or did he just leave, like some of the reports state? Because some of the reports don't have a mention of the vehicle.

Speaker 3 But also, it seems like there was a lot of violence going on in this town anyways.

Speaker 3 Like...

Speaker 3 Like what? I think when we first covered this, it seems like this sleepy, know-nothing town. It seems like there was criminal activity happening.
It wasn't like this was like Mayberry.

Speaker 3 Yeah, I don't see any

Speaker 3 look, this would be certainly be an uptick in violent activity, especially of an extreme nature. And we don't know if it's the same attacker.

Speaker 3 We have this couple that was attacked, but they were both ending marriages, which was a way bigger deal back then.

Speaker 3 So that could incite violence towards the two individuals that were attacked. And then these two individuals,

Speaker 3 we don't know who they were connected to either. And

Speaker 3 who in their life did they possibly upset to incite violence against them? Well, of course. And that's how any good detective would look at any scene.
You don't go in there going, hey,

Speaker 3 this,

Speaker 3 you don't arrive on the scene going, hey, this attack is probably connected to the one that the call that I got a month earlier right

Speaker 3 and but

Speaker 3 but it's very similar oh it's it's extremely similar and like you said it's not a major road but it's uh

Speaker 3 it's a it's a more traveled road than the leverage lane attack oh absolutely and this is near so this is near US Highway 67

Speaker 3 when the where the vehicle was spotted now

Speaker 3 if you look at U.S. Highway 67 on a map, especially an old map, this is kind of heading out of town.
So it's look at it like it's the opposite of the first attack.

Speaker 3 And what I mean is not the opposite of how things went down. It's opposite in where that it falls on a map.
So

Speaker 3 if you have the edge of town, this is the opposite edge of town.

Speaker 3 Both on the edge of town, both of them in these lover lanes as reported.

Speaker 3 But one thing too, and I want to kind of point this out, and I know this might be difficult for some folks to wrap their heads around with the regarding the statement from police

Speaker 3 about,

Speaker 3 oh, we don't fully believe their story from the survivor story from the first attack.

Speaker 3 I have a suspicion that that not only has to do with their marital status, that would make the most sense.

Speaker 3 But what also would make sense to me is if you're saying, hey, you got to keep in mind, this is 1946.

Speaker 3 All right. That has to be in your mind the entire time you examine and examine this case.
It's 1946. Newsflash, it was a different world back then.
Segregation was alive and in most cities.

Speaker 3 And Texarkana was no different.

Speaker 3 And I think that it would have been wise because one thing that gets lost in the sauce in true crime stories is that the purpose of law enforcement the police is to protect and serve what is the first part of that protect protect their their number one job is not to solve crimes yes that's what they do that's but if you can protect and set up every scenario where a crime is never committed you don't have to solve the crime you don't have to solve the crime right so their number one job is actually public protection to protect the public and keep everybody in the public safe preventing anything from happening my number one job is public erection.

Speaker 3 But if you are keeping that in mind at all times, that my number one job is to protect the masses, it's beneficial to that goal that maybe, hey, I don't jump out in front of the public and go, guess what?

Speaker 3 1946, Tex Arcana, a black guy attacked two young white people in a parked car. That's not going to go very well.
That's not going to, that's going to create other problems.

Speaker 3 And further, I don't think that this guy was african-american at all if in fact all these attacks and murders are connected well colonel let's get into the third crime the third in the series here captain is on sunday april 14th 1946 we have paul martin he's 16 years old he was found dead on north park road shot four times His date from the previous night was Betty Joe Booker, age 15.

Speaker 3 She's discovered nearly two miles away, shot twice in the head and chest. She was actually shot in the heart and in the head.
Betty Jo had been playing saxophone at a local dance the night before.

Speaker 3 So her plan here, Captain, was she was going to go to this dance and perform, play the saxophone,

Speaker 3 and Paul was going to meet her at the dance and he was to be her ride home. So this obviously happened as planned.

Speaker 3 However, before the young couple could get to their destination someone the phantom had intercepted them attacking

Speaker 3 killing them shooting them both they discover paul martin's body so his body's found around 6 30 a.m that morning yeah what we do know is betty joe booker Her parents did report her missing and they were out actively looking for their daughter that morning.

Speaker 3 And it was during that time that somebody else found Paul Martin's body. You have to picture this.
He's essentially laying on the side of the road. So he's found around 6:30 a.m.

Speaker 3 lying on the side of the northern edge of North Park Road. Police say,

Speaker 3 the investigators say, we found a bunch of blood on the other side of the road by a fence.

Speaker 3 And our victim here has been shot four times. Once in the back, once in in the hand, the right hand,

Speaker 3 once in the back of the neck,

Speaker 3 and then through the nose, through the center of the face. So chances are he's not moving after being shot.
So he's possibly moved by the killer? Well,

Speaker 3 that's interesting to ponder here because I think we could have

Speaker 3 a couple of different scenarios. So we get that description of there being blood on the road by a fence on the other side of the road.

Speaker 3 but what i think we're not getting is the full description of the scene because i think a couple things could have happened here either i think the the shot i want to know with the hand if they were able to determine what position they think the hand was in when he was shot so what i mean by that is you say he shot four times you tell me the locations of these four shots but a hand is one of those

Speaker 3 appendages that you could you could be you could place it up as kind of to block yourself to shield yourself

Speaker 3 Could the shot to the face have simply was he trying to cover his face and he was shot in the hand through the hand? I want to know: was that a through and through shot with the hand?

Speaker 3 We don't get that description, but what we do get is that he's also shot in the back and the back of the neck. So it could be he's facing his attacker when he's first shot.

Speaker 3 The attacker thinks he's dead, and then now my victim starts to move and I plug two in the back. Another scenario is he's gunned down from behind,

Speaker 3 shoots him in the face just for good measure. And then after the killer left the scene,

Speaker 3 this young man somehow had the strength to try to pull himself to safety and he kind of dragged himself across the street. I think either could play out.

Speaker 3 And I think without more information, we don't know exactly what happened. The strange part of this particular double homicide is the locations of the bodies, right?

Speaker 3 So, in the last scene, we are told that police have a lot of reasons to believe that the two victims were killed outside of the car and then placed into the car for whatever reason. Right.

Speaker 3 So, victims were moved. You know what?

Speaker 3 Think about this, though. What does our attacker do in the first case? He

Speaker 3 commands the two folks that are in the vehicle to get out of the vehicle. Yeah.

Speaker 3 In the second attack, whether connected or not, what happens? The victims are believed to have been killed outside of the car and then placed back in.

Speaker 3 Now, the blanket, with there being a blanket, that throws a whole other wrinkle on it because I kept examining this and going, well, no shit. He commanded them to get out of the car.

Speaker 3 decided to shoot them outside of the car and then places them back in the vehicle for whatever reason.

Speaker 3 But the blanket being involved, I wonder if in the second scene, if the attacker arrives on the scene and finds them outside of the car, he didn't have to command them to get out.

Speaker 3 They're out on a blanket fooling around. Yeah, because some cards are hard to fool around in.
But not blankets, my friend.

Speaker 3 You get on that blanket. It's easy to touch the bathing suit areas.

Speaker 3 It's a magic carpet ride.

Speaker 3 So he places them back in the car to conceal the bodies. This is a completely different scene.

Speaker 3 We have a victim lying on the side of the road, and then we have the other victim who's found a great distance away. A mile and a half to two miles, depending on what reports you read.

Speaker 3 But also, the victim, Paul Martin, his vehicle's found in a completely different location. Was the girl sexually assaulted?

Speaker 3 Well, try to follow me on this. So, the young couple's driving home.

Speaker 3 We know that what we do know that happened is Paul Martin successfully picked up Betty Joe Booker at the dance, and we can assume that they were en route to either go park somewhere but being as late as it was they might have been en route to to go home and decided I'm guessing they probably stopped for a bit and that's when the killer encountered them

Speaker 3 so Paul Martin's body is found around 630 a.m. Later that morning we have Betty Joe Booker's body is found by a second search party.

Speaker 3 This is just just before noon, so at 11.30 a.m., approximately two miles from where Martin's body was found. And her body, it's reported, was behind a tree.
She's lying on her back, fully clothed.

Speaker 3 And in fact, the killer had put her coat, or at least buttoned the coat up that she was wearing. She had been shot twice, once in the chest, once in the face, as we said, heart and face.

Speaker 3 Paul Martin's car was found about three miles away from Betty Joe Booker's body and a mile and a half away from Paul Martin's body.

Speaker 3 The vehicle was parked outside of Spring Lake Park with the keys still in the ignition.

Speaker 3 I've tried to make heads or tails of this. The best I could come up with is

Speaker 3 today,

Speaker 3 and I'm assuming it's very similar back in 1946, that park is surrounded by neighborhoods.

Speaker 3 Would it be so easy for me to drop the vehicle there and walk

Speaker 3 to my home? Police said that they couldn't figure out who was shot first, who was killed first.

Speaker 3 They did say this is the one where we do get confirmation when we have no survivor that there was a sexual assault.

Speaker 3 Investigators did openly say that they believe that Betty Joe Bookler had been sexually assaulted. I say that because in the second case, in the first double homicide, they

Speaker 3 weren't real

Speaker 3 open about if a rape had occurred. Now, that might be that they do not know.
So the first double homicide, they're not firm on their statements of if a sexual assault had occurred in that one.

Speaker 3 Now, that could be for multiple reasons. As I was saying, it could be because either they don't know, they can't confirm it 100%,

Speaker 3 or two, it's simply holdback information

Speaker 3 that they don't want to put that out there in case they have to interrogate someone or they get a confession but this movement with the vehicle and the bodies here

Speaker 3 we don't see this in the other scenes i've heard people come up with great and i want to be clear here i think a lot of the theories i've heard on why the bodies were found where they were found and the vehicle found elsewhere i've heard great theories on that i've heard heard theories to suggest that maybe he was hunting, that the killer was hunting and wanted to hunt Betty Joe Booker down.

Speaker 3 Like in the first attack, where Mary Jean believed that she was told to run, and then the guy tracks her down. But I don't know that Booker ran this distance.

Speaker 3 I think whatever happened to Paul Martin happened first.

Speaker 3 Just like telling Jimmy Hollis to take off his goddamn breeches.

Speaker 3 I think that the attacker took out Paul Martin first, either killing him or believing that he left him dead, and then he was going to do whatever he was going to do to the female victim.

Speaker 3 Well, you have to eliminate the threat first,

Speaker 3 but also

Speaker 3 all these old cases of Lover's Lane.

Speaker 3 And maybe there's just not as many Lovers Lane anymore, but or maybe there's just so much. Now the kids are smoking dope.

Speaker 3 Well, they're smoking dope and, you know, jerking on the floor. They're parking.

Speaker 3 No, they're parking to smoke.

Speaker 3 But no, I think you're onto something here.

Speaker 3 Especially with the first attack, if you're aware of these lover's lanes or this particular lover's lane and you're looking for some kind of sexually motivated homicide or attack,

Speaker 3 and you're hoping to find a young woman to victimize. Well, you're going to go there.
I mean, that's one of the

Speaker 3 place where you will go, you know what? Probably on a Friday or Saturday night, I might be able to find someone. And that's another thing that's interesting about this case with the Phantom Killer.

Speaker 3 All of these attacks take place on a weekend, be it a Friday night, Saturday, Sunday. They all take place on a weekend.

Speaker 3 The devils only get you in your sleep.

Speaker 3 The devil's only catch you in your sleep. I want to thank everybody for joining us here in the garage.
Stick around for part two. And until then, be good, be kind, and don't.

Speaker 1 Hey there, it's Katie Nolan, host of Casuals, the sports podcast where we don't care how much you know about sports, we're just happy that you're here.

Speaker 1 Every week, I hang out with some of my good friends to discuss the biggest stories across sports and entertainment, but in a way that's like fun and not boring.

Speaker 1 Want to know Sue Bird's favorite Diana Taurasi story? Or how heavy the Larry O'Brien trophy is? Or even what baseball team is right for you based on your moon sign? We got you.

Speaker 1 Listen to Casuals every Tuesday and Thursday on the SiriusXM app or wherever you get your podcasts.

Speaker 3 Bye!