Deporting Mahmoud Khalil

Speaker 1 Lawyers for Mahmoud Khalil faced a judge in a federal courtroom in Manhattan today while outside, protesters demanded his release.

Speaker 1 Khalil is a green card holder who was detained by ICE over the weekend. The Trump administration has lobbed some serious accusations at him.

Speaker 3 Mahmoud Khalil was an individual who was given the privilege of coming to this country to study at one of our nation's finest universities and colleges.

Speaker 3 And he took advantage of that opportunity, of that privilege, by siding with terrorists, Hamas terrorists who have killed innocent men, women, and children.

Speaker 1 But hasn't backed them up with any evidence.

Speaker 1 The attempted deportation has created some unlikely allies here, including conservative pundit Ann Coulter, who tweeted, There's almost no one I don't want to deport, but unless they've committed a crime, isn't this a violation of the First Amendment?

Speaker 1 On Today Explained, can the Trump administration kick out of the country a man who is charged with with no crime and who is here legally? Coming up.

Speaker 6 Every story you love,

Speaker 6 every invention that moves you,

Speaker 6 every idea you wished was yours,

Speaker 6 all began as nothing.

Speaker 6 Just a blank page with a blinking cursor.

Speaker 6 Asking a simple question,

Speaker 6 what do you see?

Speaker 6 Great ideas. Start on Mac.

Speaker 6 Find out more on apple.com/slash Mac.

Speaker 7 Adobe Acrobat Studio, so brand new. Show me all the things PDFs can do.

Speaker 8 Do your work with ease and speed. PDF spaces is all you need.

Speaker 7 Do hours of research in an instant. With key insights from an AI assistant.
Pick a template with a click. Now your preso looks super slick.
Close that deal. Yeah, you won.

Speaker 7 Do that, doing that, did that, done. Now you can do that, do that with Acrobat.

Speaker 10 Now

Speaker 9 This is Today Explain.

Speaker 12 My name is Gabby Delbae. I'm a policy reporter at The Verge, where I cover immigration, privacy, and the tech right.

Speaker 1 Gabby, what happened to Mahmoud Khalil last weekend?

Speaker 12 So on Saturday night, he was arrested by officers from Immigration and Customs Enforcement's Homeland Security Investigations Division in his apartment.

Speaker 12 When the officers asked him to identify himself, they initially said that his student visa had been revoked.

Speaker 12 I believe at that point, he and his wife had called his attorney, and his wife and his attorney were both saying he's not here on a student visa. He has a green card.

Speaker 12 His wife, who's eight months pregnant, got the green card and showed it to the HSI officers. That's the division of ICE that handles homeland security.

Speaker 12 And the officers said, well, the green card has been revoked too, which to be clear, ICE doesn't have the authority to revoke a green card, but they arrested him.

Speaker 12 They took him first, I believe, to a detention center in New York, then transferred him to a different detention center in New Jersey.

Speaker 12 When his wife went to visit him there on Sunday, she was told that he wasn't there.

Speaker 12 And for a while, his wife and his attorney didn't know where he was until it was revealed that he had been transferred to a different ICE detention facility in rural Louisiana.

Speaker 12 And so while he was still detained in New York City, 4.40 a.m. on Sunday, his attorney filed a habeas petition with the Southern District of New York.
So this was before any of the transfers happened.

Speaker 12 And a federal judge on Monday ordered that he not be deported for now and set a court hearing for today.

Speaker 1 Who is this guy?

Speaker 12 Mahmoud Khalil is a recent graduate of Columbia University's School of International and Public Affairs and a very prominent pro-Palestine activist on campus.

Speaker 13 Free, free, free Palestine! Free, free, free Palestine!

Speaker 12 So starting in late 2023, Columbia University had a series of protests on campus where student activists were trying to get the university to divest from military contractors and from certain companies that were based in or do business with the Israeli government.

Speaker 13 We demand divestment. We will not be moved unless by force.

Speaker 12 And those protests kind of culminated in the spring of 2024 with an encampment on Columbia University's lawn that the university ended up calling in the NYPD or allowing the NYPD to arrest students.

Speaker 12 The protests didn't end at the end of the academic year and have been ongoing.

Speaker 12 In the spring of 2024, when the encampments had, you know, sprung up and had been there for a while, he actually wasn't prominently involved in the encampments and he spoke at a press conference where he said that he hadn't attended a ton of protests and he hadn't been doing a ton of interviews.

Speaker 12 He wasn't really in the public eye because he at that point was in the US on a student visa.

Speaker 2 And this is why a lot of the Palestinian students here feel very uncomfortable, very, very uncomfortable participating and protesting the genocide of their people.

Speaker 2 That's why we are very grateful for everyone on campus for protesting on our behalf.

Speaker 12 But that wasn't to say he wasn't involved with this movement.

Speaker 12 He was one of the students involved with negotiating with the administration and trying to push the administration to divest while other students were doing like the encampment, the more like on-the-ground stuff.

Speaker 12 He was like in these meetings with the university administration.

Speaker 1 What will happen in court? Has he been charged with anything?

Speaker 12 This is kind of a tricky thing. The judge that sat that hearing is a federal judge in the the Southern District of New York.

Speaker 12 And this is a hearing basically just requesting his release from immigration custody.

Speaker 12 That isn't going to affect the outcome of his immigration case because ultimately an immigration judge is the one who decides whether to order him deported or not.

Speaker 12 These are two different courts, different jurisdictions. So his hearing today was about whether he should remain in ICE custody or be let out.
But it's not about whether he's going to be deported.

Speaker 1 When asked to explain this, what has the Trump administration said?

Speaker 12 So a White House official told the Free Press that he has not been charged with a crime.

Speaker 12 There's no allegation that he's broken the law, but that he poses a threat to the foreign policy and national security interests of the United States.

Speaker 3 Under the Immigration and Nationality Act, the Secretary of State has the right to revoke a green card or a visa for individuals who serve or are adversarial to the foreign policy and national security interests of the United States of America.

Speaker 12 The official White House Instagram and Twitter accounts posted this picture of him saying, Shalom Mahmoud, and Trump himself has said, there will be more.

Speaker 12 In a post on Truth Social, Trump called him a radical foreign pro-Hamas student and said, this is the first arrest of many to come.

Speaker 1 What rights does Mahmoud Khalil have as a green card holder in the U.S.?

Speaker 12 So in most cases, people in deportation proceedings have the right to a hearing before an immigration judge.

Speaker 12 So despite what the government is saying, despite what the White House is saying, he cannot just be deported today or tomorrow or this week.

Speaker 12 He has to go before an immigration judge, and only an immigration judge can decide whether Mahmoud will be deported.

Speaker 1 And what case would the Trump administration have to make in order to get him deported? Like, how does this generally work?

Speaker 12 It works differently depending on what the grounds for deportability are.

Speaker 12 I'm going to give you a kind of unrelated example.

Speaker 12 Like, if he were a green card holder and he had been charged with certain crimes, crimes including what is called crimes of moral turpitude or aggravated felonies, which are not all felonies.

Speaker 12 It's kind of a misnomer. That could then trigger deportation proceedings.

Speaker 12 Or if he were an undocumented immigrant who was in the United States without like legal authorization, that could trigger deportation proceedings.

Speaker 1 This is a really

Speaker 12 unusual case.

Speaker 12 So because deportability is being argued on this foreign policy ground, I believe the administration is going to have to prove that his activities in the United States are in some way a threat to national security or to the U.S.'s foreign policy interests.

Speaker 12 The question is what they're going to point to to prove that. Like, is it going to be his involvement in campus protests? And if so, is there then a First Amendment counterargument?

Speaker 12 Like, will his attorney be able to say he was not doing anything dangerous or anything threatening to national security? He was exercising his First Amendment rights.

Speaker 12 So, will the administration then argue that he was doing something beyond speech is what we should be looking out for?

Speaker 12 As far as I know, he is not accused of any acts of violence, of like the occupations, any of that.

Speaker 12 In fact, I emailed the NYPD asking if he had any kind of like charges or if he had been arrested in connection with any of those events, and I didn't receive a response, but when I was covering these protests last spring, there was no mention of him as one of the people who had been arrested.

Speaker 1 There were many students involved in these protests on college campuses and many students all across the country. Do we know why this one student was singled out?

Speaker 12 I think there are a few different reasons why he was singled out. One of them is that he's an easier target than a lot of other students.
His name is out there. His information is out there.

Speaker 12 The government knows that he's not a U.S. citizen.

Speaker 12 There was a report in the foreword that some pro-Israel activists had met with members of Congress, including Ted Cruz and John Fetterman, and had personally named Mahmoud as like someone that the government should be looking at.

Speaker 12 And there are also a number of organizations that both before and since Trump's re-election have kind of dedicated themselves to naming and shaming what they say are students on campus who are either promoting anti-Semitism or in some cases promoting terrorism.

Speaker 12 One of these organizations, Canary Mission, makes these kind of dossiers of pro-Palestine activists on college campuses across America.

Speaker 14 Canary Mission's simple interface allows you to easily explore profiles of radical individuals and organizations. It is your duty to ensure that today's radicals are not tomorrow's employees.

Speaker 12 Another more recent one is the Heritage Foundation's Project Esther, which has kind of tried to weaponize the Canary mission model to encourage retaliation against these students.

Speaker 15 Students that are engaged in pro-terrorist activities should be deported.

Speaker 15 The United States federal government itself should embark on a mission to deport such visiting students that are expressing support for Hamas and other terrorist entities.

Speaker 12 And then there's another group, Betar,

Speaker 12 which claims it made lists of students who are in the U.S.

Speaker 12 on visas or otherwise non-citizens, and also claims that it showed that list to immigration authorities and has encouraged that these students be arrested and removed from the country.

Speaker 1 President Trump said on Truth Social the following, we know there are more students at Columbia and other universities across the country who have engaged in pro-terrorist, anti-Semitic, anti-American activity, and the Trump administration will not tolerate it.

Speaker 1 It sounds like a threat. There will be more of this.
Should we expect more of this?

Speaker 12 We should absolutely expect more of this.

Speaker 12 Just days before Mahmoud was arrested, Axios reported that the State Department under Marco Rubio was using AI to identify students who were in the U.S.

Speaker 12 on visas, who had either been arrested at pro-Palestine

Speaker 12 on campus or off campus, or who had posted like anti-Israel content on social media.

Speaker 12 It claimed that there were no visas that were revoked under the Biden administration, which was proof that they were not taking this seriously, and that this new administration would be taking this seriously.

Speaker 12 Reuters and the AAP have also reported that ICE has been looking for at least one other student on campus.

Speaker 1 Let me ask you, lastly.

Speaker 1 What does this tell us about how President Trump and his administration are thinking about deportations, about how to do them, about how to utilize them, about who to target for deportation?

Speaker 12 So when Trump was on the campaign trail, he promised mass deportations.

Speaker 12 And since then, you know, we have seen an increase in immigration enforcement.

Speaker 12 But despite what Trump says, despite what other White House officials say, you can't just instantly deport most non-citizens.

Speaker 12 Because that process is often slow and bureaucratic.

Speaker 12 The Trump administration is kind of relying on these shock and awe tactics, you know, sending people to Guantanamo, high-profile arrests of activists, sending migrants to Panama, these videos of Chris Yinome wearing bulletproof vests to arrest migrants in New York City.

Speaker 12 They're kind of relying on the public not realizing that an immigration arrest, while it may be the first step in a deportation, there's still a process that they have to adhere to.

Speaker 1 That was The Verges Gabby Del Valle. Coming up, President Trump promised mass deportations, not just high-profile ones.

Speaker 6 How's that going?

Speaker 4 Support for Today Explain comes from Indeed. Indeed says if you're looking to hire, you can give your job posting the best chance to be seen with Indeed sponsored jobs.

Speaker 4 With sponsored jobs, Indeed, boost your post so that it is more visible. Their data shows it's effective.

Speaker 4 According to Indeed, sponsored jobs posted directly on Indeed are 90% more likely to report a hire than those non-sponsored jobs because you reach a bigger pool of people.

Speaker 4 1.6 million companies sponsor jobs with Indeed. You can spend more time interviewing candidates, less stress, less time, more results now with Indeed sponsored jobs.

Speaker 4 Listeners of this show get a $75 sponsored job credit to help your job get the premium status it deserves at indeed.com slash today explained, indeed.com slash today explained.

Speaker 4 Support our show by saying you've heard about Indeed on this podcast, TodayExplained, Indeed.com slash TodayExplained. Terms and conditions do apply, guys.
Hiring. Do it the right way with Indeed.

Speaker 4 Support for Today Explained comes from Wondery and their new podcast, Lawless Planet.

Speaker 4 It unfolds almost like a true crime podcast, I've been asked to tell you, but it is about the global climate crisis, complex stories wide-ranging happening in every corner of the planet.

Speaker 4 On Lawless Planet, the new podcast from Wondery, you will hear stories from the depths of the Amazon to small-town America.

Speaker 4 Host Zach Goldbaum takes you around the world to see investigate stories of conflict, corruption, resistance.

Speaker 4 and highlights activists risking their lives for their beliefs, corporations shaping the planet's future, and the everyday people affected along the way.

Speaker 4 Each episode takes you inside the global struggle for our planet's future, mysterious crimes, those high-stakes operations, those billion-dollar controversies that you do know so well.

Speaker 4 To reveal what's truly at stake, you can follow Lawless Planet on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to new episodes early and ad-free.

Speaker 4 Right now, by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify.

Speaker 4 Support for Today Explained comes from Chime. What's What's Chime? Chime is different.
Chime is a financial technology company that wants you to embrace each and every dollar.

Speaker 4 When you set up direct deposit with QIIME, you can get access to fee-free features like overdraft protection, or they say you can get paid up to two days early and even more.

Speaker 4 Speaking of no fees, Chime says that when you open a checking account with them, there are no monthly fees and no maintenance fees.

Speaker 4 And with qualifying direct deposits, you can be eligible for free overdraft up to $200 on debit card purchases and cash withdrawals. Not to mention, although I will, $47,000 fee-free ATMs.

Speaker 4 You can work on your financial goals through Chime Today. You can open an account in two minutes at chime.com/slash explain.
That's chime.com/slash explain. Chime feels like progress.

Speaker 10 Chime is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services and debit card provided by the Bankor Bank NA or Stripe Bank NA, members FDIC.

Speaker 10 Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply. Timing depends on submission payment file.
Fees apply at out of network ATMs, bank ranking, and number of ATMs, according to U.S.

Speaker 10 News and World Report 2023. Chime checking account required.

Speaker 4 You're listening to Today Explained.

Speaker 8 My full name is Colleen Putzel-Kavanaugh, and I'm an associate policy analyst at the Migration Policy Institute.

Speaker 1 It's been just under two months, Colleen, since President Trump took office. On the campaign trail, he promised mass deportations.
We heard this again and again and again.

Speaker 17 We will use all necessary state, local, federal, and military resources to carry out the largest domestic deportation operation in American history.

Speaker 18 Gotta do it.

Speaker 17 Gotta do it.

Speaker 1 How is he doing with that campaign promise?

Speaker 8 Right now, we don't have the current numbers of deportations from the government, but we do know that the Trump administration is quite frustrated with where deportations are at.

Speaker 8 We have some inferences that show that the deportations have not kept pace with what the Trump administration had hoped.

Speaker 11 According to three sources familiar with discussions at Immigration and Customs Enforcement, ICE, and at the White House, President Trump is said to be angry that more people aren't being deported.

Speaker 17 It is, you know, too low when he's angry over the ICE numbers.

Speaker 12 His borders are Tom Homan. We've heard that he is unhappy and has made his unhappiness known to the men and women of ICE that they want to get arrests and deportations of migrants higher.

Speaker 8 It's a type of infrastructure that can't be built overnight.

Speaker 8 And so right now, the deportations are just not keeping pace with what the Trump administration had hoped to reach that goal of $1 million per year.

Speaker 19 All illegal entry will immediately be halted and we will begin the process of returning millions and millions of criminal aliens back to the places from which they came.

Speaker 1 Now, in the meantime, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, is more transparent, perhaps, than I think a lot of people realize. They do have a color-coded spreadsheet online.

Speaker 1 It shows us all of the detention data from this year. What does that spreadsheet tell us about detentions, if not deportations, since Donald Trump took office?

Speaker 8 These spreadsheets from ICE offer us really concrete information about ICE detention, and then they also allow us to make some really great inferences into what might be happening with deportations, especially when we don't have that data.

Speaker 8 And so, since Trump took office, we can see that the average number of people in detention has gone up.

Speaker 8 So, in December, that last full month of the Biden administration, there are about 39,000 people in detention.

Speaker 8 And then in February, the first full month of the Trump administration, there were about 42,500. So a small increase, but an increase nonetheless.

Speaker 8 And then we can also see that more of the people who are in ICE detention right now are coming from ICE arrests rather than arrests conducted by Customs and Border Protection, which would typically be those arrested on the border.

Speaker 8 Under this administration, we are seeing an increase in arrests. And so the interior arrests that are happening by ICE are higher than under the Biden administration.

Speaker 8 What's much different about this administration versus the Biden administration and when Biden came into office is that the border looked a lot different.

Speaker 14 President Biden taking executive action this afternoon that will restrict asylum processing along the U.S.-Mexico border.

Speaker 16 President Biden announcing new steps to tackle the crisis at the border, expanding rules on who will be turned back.

Speaker 8 And under the Biden administration, the majority of the shares of people who were being deported were actually coming from through the border.

Speaker 8 So it wasn't that ICE stopped interior arrests altogether, but it was that those arrests were happening at a far slower rate than they are currently.

Speaker 8 But also, the Trump administration came into a border that was much slower and much less busy than the Biden administration inherited.

Speaker 8 And so those two differences have somewhat skewed the numbers in that now the Trump administration is focusing more on the interior, but those deportations are a lot harder to carry out than when people have just recently crossed the border.

Speaker 1 So I wonder what we should make of this dynamic.

Speaker 1 The numbers of deportations are falling short of what Trump promised, but his administration is making a lot of news with these very high-profile cases.

Speaker 20 A student connected to pro-Palestinian protests last year has been detained by ICE.

Speaker 21 Striking scenes from the windows of this Panama hotel confined inside migrant men, women and children deported from the U.S. by the Trump administration.

Speaker 19 We have 30,000 beds in Guantanamo to detain the worst criminal, illegal aliens threatening the American people. Some of them are so bad we don't even trust the countries to hold them.

Speaker 1 What do you think we should take from that?

Speaker 8 So having this large kind of public relations campaign around the arrests that are happening, the deportations that are being carried out, the previous use of military planes, for example.

Speaker 18 We shot this video from a dirt ridge outside Fort Bliss in El Paso, Texas.

Speaker 18 We could see about 80 men, women, and children, recent arrivals in the U.S., stepping off buses and stepping on to military transport jets.

Speaker 8 Sending military to the border.

Speaker 5 Thousands of troops have been deployed to the border with Mexico.

Speaker 8 These are all part of a larger campaign to basically meet two critical needs of the Trump administration.

Speaker 8 To one, show the base of people that are supportive of this that they are doing what they promised. They are intending to increase arrests and increase deportations.

Speaker 8 Whether or not the numbers are adding up, the intent is there.

Speaker 8 One of the very first actions by the Trump administration was to rescind something called the Sensitive Locations Memo, which did not allow ICE to go into schools.

Speaker 9 The Department of Homeland Security tossed out a policy that limited where immigration authorities can make arrests.

Speaker 9 Now, federal agents can detain migrants at sensitive locations, including schools and churches.

Speaker 8 And so it certainly created a bit of a chilling effect.

Speaker 22 Today, federal agents detained and arrested people in Denver and the neighboring city of Aurora, Colorado, breaking down doors and questioning people.

Speaker 23 Multiple communities across Chicago are feeling the impacts of what ICE is calling targeted operations.

Speaker 8 That can mean that people just aren't going to go to work, or they might not go to a doctor's appointment or they might not send their kids to school that day.

Speaker 24 I have calls from school teachers and parents who are afraid to send their children to school. It's already scaring people.

Speaker 1 My guess would be that the Trump administration at some point will start to take flack because the number of deportations that it promised is not matching the reality.

Speaker 1 Are you seeing new strategies by this administration to kind of get deportation numbers up?

Speaker 8 Part of the deportation system is also the detention system. The Trump administration has made a lot of efforts to essentially bend the U.S.

Speaker 8 government towards trying to increase the resources across detentions and deportation.

Speaker 8 And so that means that they're deputizing all different areas of the government, including ones that had never been working on immigration before, but also calling agents from the Department of State, from DEA, from ATF, from U.S.

Speaker 8 Marshals, and asking people to be reallocated to work on immigration enforcement. And we're also seeing that they are targeting certain areas that work with immigrants.

Speaker 8 So, for example, the Trump administration has launched several investigations into so-called sanctuary cities, which has resulted in a litany of different lawsuits.

Speaker 20 Sanctuary City mayors from Boston, New York City, Denver, and Chicago were taken to task by House Republicans for their dangerous policies during this contentious hearing.

Speaker 25 That is actually what is undermining safety in our communities.

Speaker 8 We're also seeing that the Trump administration is trying to compel states and localities to use their own law enforcement agencies to also carry out immigration enforcement.

Speaker 8 So, the Texas National Guard has signed a memorandum of understanding with DHS so that Texas National Guard can now

Speaker 8 kind of carry out the functions of an immigration enforcement officer where they previously couldn't.

Speaker 8 So, there's a lot of different areas in which they're trying to sort of bend various aspects of both the U.S.

Speaker 8 government but also state resources, all towards this singular goal of carrying out mass deportations.

Speaker 1 Colleen Putzel-Kavanaugh of the Migration Policy Institute. Today's show was produced by Avishai Artsi and Gabrielle Burbay.
Amina El Sadi is our editor.

Speaker 1 Laura Bullard and Amanda Llewellyn check the facts. And Patrick Boyd and Andrea Kristen's daughter are our engineers.
I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained.

Speaker 6 Support for this show comes from one password. If you're an IT or security pro, managing devices, identities, and applications can feel overwhelming and risky.

Speaker 6 Trelica by OnePassword helps conquer SaaS sprawl and shadow IT by discovering every app your team uses, managed or not. Take the first step to better security for your team.

Speaker 6 Learn more at onepassword.com/slash podcast offer. That's onepassword.com/slash podcast offer.
All lowercase.

Speaker 6 support for this show comes from OnePassword. If you're an IT or security pro, managing devices, identities, and applications can feel overwhelming and risky.

Speaker 6 Trellica by OnePassword helps conquer SaaS sprawl and shadow IT by discovering every app your team uses, managed or not. Take the first step to better security for your team.

Speaker 6 Learn more at onepassword.com/slash podcastoffer. That's one password.com/slash podcast offer.
All lowercase.