Elon's African roots

Speaker 1 The South African situation is very, very dangerous and very bad for a lot of people.

Speaker 1 There's tremendously bad things going on,

Speaker 1 including the confiscation of property. And worse, much worse than that, you know what I'm talking about.

Speaker 4 You might not know what he's talking about. We got you.

Speaker 4 President Trump says that Afrikaners, white South Africans who decades ago architected a brutal system of segregation laws known as apartheid, are now themselves victims of discrimination after the passage of a law that allows their land to be expropriated without compensation.

Speaker 4 Trump is offering these white South Africans resettlement in the U.S.

Speaker 4 and they are gently turning him down.

Speaker 3 We see our future in Africa.

Speaker 4 But what got Trump interested in South Africa? And is it unelected white South African Vice President Elon Musk? We're going to ask on Today Explained.

Speaker 5 Support for Today Explained comes from BetterHelp. BetterHelp says it's winter and winter is often depressing.

Speaker 5 Instead of getting depressed, BetterHelp wants to encourage you to reach out to someone, perhaps get coffee with an old friend, perhaps write a letter to a family member, perhaps connect with a licensed therapist using BetterHelp.

Speaker 5 This month, don't wait to reach out, says BetterHelp.

Speaker 5 Whether you're checking in on a friend or reaching out to a therapist yourself, BetterHelp makes it easier to take that first step, says BetterHelp.

Speaker 5 You can get 10% off your first month at betterhelp.com/slash explained. That's betterhelp.com/slash explained.

Speaker 6 Adobe Acrobat Studio, so brand new. Show me all the things PDFs can do.
Do your work with ease and speed. PDF spaces is all you need.
Do hours of research in an instant.

Speaker 6 With key insights from an AI assistant. Pick a template with a click.
Now your prezzo looks super slick. Close that deal, yeah, you won.
Do that, doing that, did that, done.

Speaker 6 Now you can do that, do that with Acrobat. Now you can do that, do that with the all-new Acrobat.
It's time to do your best work with the all-new Adobe Acrobat Studio.

Speaker 5 This is Today Explained.

Speaker 4 I'm Noelle King with Chris McGreal. Chris is a reporter for The Guardian who covered South Africa for many years, including the end of apartheid and the start of South Africa's democracy.

Speaker 4 Recently, Chris wrote a piece about the influential white South Africans in President Trump's orbit.

Speaker 3 The argument is being made that Afrikaners

Speaker 3 who were the group that imposed apartheid on South Africa in 1948, the very rigid form of racial segregation, are now victims of the post-apartheid era, that they're being targeted with, as the White House and others characterize it, racist laws, that they're victims of discrimination in the post-apartheid order, and that they are victims of politically targeted violence.

Speaker 3 This is the argument being made.

Speaker 4 What are these so-called racist laws? What's Trump referring to?

Speaker 3 Well, what's upsetting Trump and others is that essentially South Africa has an affirmative action program for the black majority and other minority people of color who were discriminated against and

Speaker 3 left very much at a disadvantage by apartheid. So there's, for instance, a black empowerment legal requirement for businesses.

Speaker 3 There's upliftment in education, in job opportunities, in the civil service. That is now being characterized as discrimination against the white minority.

Speaker 3 Although it's worth bearing in mind that the white minority at the end of a party, which is 30 years ago now,

Speaker 3 30 years later still hangs on to its big houses, its swimming pools, its Mercedes-Benz.

Speaker 4 When does Donald Trump become interested in South Africa and why?

Speaker 3 So there's a group in South Africa which describes itself as an Afrikaner rights group called Afriforum. and the Southern Poverty Law Center has described it as white supremacists in a suit and a tie.

Speaker 3 The leadership of that group came to the United States in 2018 and amongst other things, they appeared on Tucker Carlson's show on Fox News.

Speaker 7 South Africa is a diverse country, but the South African government would like to make it much less diverse.

Speaker 3 They laid out the case that whites were the victims of discrimination in South Africa, but particularly latched onto this issue of the killing of white farmers.

Speaker 8 Basically threatening white farmers that if they do not voluntarily hand over their land to black people, then there would be a violent takeover. So the situation is very dire in South Africa.

Speaker 8 They would be tortured to death and it would receive very little news coverage, and that's unfortunate.

Speaker 3 Which is totally untrue. But they appeared on Tucker Carlson.

Speaker 3 Trump was watching, this is when he's president in 2018, and he tweets to his then Secretary of State, Mike Pompeo, telling him to watch the situation in South Africa with the whites and how they're being victimized.

Speaker 3 And others pick up on this around the states afterwards, and it starts to gain some momentum.

Speaker 4 In the meantime, President Trump has become very close to Elon Musk, who, of course, is a white South African.

Speaker 4 Do we know whether Elon Musk's ideas about South Africa have influenced Donald Trump at all?

Speaker 3 Well, you'd have to assume they did because there's no real explanation otherwise as to why Trump is so engaged with this issue.

Speaker 3 Why, you know, three weeks into his second term of office, he's suddenly issuing this executive order about one country.

Speaker 3 So one has to imagine that it's Elon Musk, who was born in apartheid South Africa and grew up there, left at 18. But he's not the only one.

Speaker 3 There's a group of white men that all have apartheid South African childhoods in some form or other, known as the PayPal Mafia. They all get to know each other at the top of PayPal.

Speaker 3 They all get rich through PayPal. These include the billionaire libertarian Peter Thiel.
Now, Thiel was born in Germany, but his father took him to South Africa at a young age.

Speaker 3 And then the other kind of two major players are a guy called David Sachs, who is another tech billionaire. He's now Trump's AI and CryptoZAR.

Speaker 3 He was born in Cape Town, although his parents moved to Tennessee when he was five.

Speaker 3 So he did not grow up fully kind of imbued with the apartheid system, although he grew up in the white South African diaspora of the time.

Speaker 4 What would life have been like in the 1980s for a kid like Elon Musk growing up under apartheid?

Speaker 4 What was the deal?

Speaker 3 It separated every aspect of life. So jobs were reserved only for white people.
Interracial marriage and interracial sex was illegal under the Immorality Act. Every aspect of daily life was separate.

Speaker 3 But Musk's teenage years would have been in the huge tumult of South Africa's uprising against apartheid.

Speaker 3 By the mid-80s, you've got a state of emergency, you've got civic society constantly protesting, you've got mass arrests, children incarcerated in their thousands.

Speaker 10 Under the sweeping powers of the state of emergency, an estimated 30,000 people, the majority black, have been detained. Cape Town was under siege.
Police vehicles on every street corner.

Speaker 10 The city overwhelmed with protesters defying the government with marches.

Speaker 11 In a situation of injustice and oppression,

Speaker 11 there can be no neutrality. You have to take sides.
You have to say, am I on the side of justice or am I on the side of injustice?

Speaker 3 The country increasingly ungovernable, the army attempting to keep some kind of order in the townships. So Musk was growing up at this time of incredible turmoil.

Speaker 3 And on the streets of Pretoria, where he went to school, he would have seen the Afrikaner Resistance Movement, which was an openly neo-Nazi group that actually modeled its badge on the swastika and had the same colours as the Nazis and marched up and down the streets doing Hitler salutes.

Speaker 3 Erol Musk, Elon's father, has described his parents-in-law as open neo-Nazis and fascists and supporters, enthusiastic supporters of apartheid.

Speaker 2 They used to support Hitler and all that sort of stuff.

Speaker 3 Now, Errol himself... was a member of something called the Progressive Federal Party, and that really was a small opposition party in parliament opposed to apartheid.

Speaker 12 We never supported apartheid, really, but it was something we inherited from the European countries.

Speaker 3 But leaves the party eventually in the 1980s because it was advocating one person, one vote. In other words, complete equality of democracy.
And he didn't agree with that.

Speaker 3 You know, he was like a lot of white South Africans of that era, particularly English speakers who were doing quite well out of the economics of apartheid, who said that they were against it in principle, but actually didn't do very much to oppose it and certainly benefited from it enormously and so he was the liberal in the family but obviously only up to a point

Speaker 4 so to bring us back to the present day Has Elon Musk said anything about white South Africans and what he believes is happening in that country right now?

Speaker 3 Yes, he's had plenty to say. He's retweeted or commented on tweets that essentially argue that there's either a genocide underway against whites or a genocide coming.

Speaker 3 He recently openly challenged the president of South Africa, Cyril Ramaposo, on Twitter, accusing him of imposing racist discriminatory laws against white people.

Speaker 3 So he's very much taken an adversarial position on this, which I suspect at least goes some way to explain why Trump has done the same.

Speaker 4 One thing we learned during the first Trump administration was that

Speaker 4 Donald Trump and the people close to him often have more than one motive for their beliefs. And some things that might seem ideological are not ideological or less ideological than we might think.

Speaker 4 Does Elon Musk have any other incentive to push Donald Trump to take a stand on this other than thinking white South Africans are being discriminated against?

Speaker 3 Well, as it happens, we watch Musk's commentary on white South Africans ramp up at a time when he was starting to get into conflict with the South African government over Starlink, his satellite business.

Speaker 3 He wanted to get it into South Africa, but part of the present dispensation, kind of compensating for apartheid, is that all foreign businesses investing in South Africa have to have a local black empowerment component.

Speaker 3 In telecoms, which is the area of Starlink, it's 30%. So there has to be 30% 30%

Speaker 3 investment in the local business. And Musk objects to this.
He says he doesn't want anybody else in his business.

Speaker 3 And he's trying and may actually succeed to break down the requirement that he has to have this black empowerment element in his investments in South Africa.

Speaker 3 There are other motives and I think this isn't the only case where you can look and see a financial incentive in some of these decisions that are being made.

Speaker 3 So I guess I would say, you know, read up on South Africa, look at what's really going on rather than just take the word of those who have the power to set policy.

Speaker 4 That was The Guardian's Chris McGreal. Coming up, what do Afrikaners think about President Trump's offer?

Speaker 4 And we're going to dig into the accusation that white farmers' land has been stolen in South Africa.

Speaker 5 Support for Today Explain comes from Indeed. Indeed, says if you're looking to hire, you can give your job posting the best chance to be seen with Indeed-sponsored jobs.

Speaker 5 With sponsored jobs, Indeed, boosts your post so that it is more visible. Their data shows it's effective.

Speaker 5 According to Indeed, sponsored jobs posted posted directly on Indeed are 90% more likely to report a higher than those non-sponsored jobs because you reach a bigger pool of people.

Speaker 5 1.6 million companies sponsor jobs with Indeed. You can spend more time interviewing candidates, less stress, less time, more results now with Indeed sponsored jobs.

Speaker 5 Listeners of this show get a $75 sponsored job credit. To help your job get the premium status it deserves at Indeed.com slash today explained, indeed.com slash today explained.

Speaker 5 Support our show by saying you've heard about Indeed on this podcast, TodayExplained, Indeed.com slash Today Explained. Terms and conditions do apply, guys.
Hiring, do it the right way with Indeed.

Speaker 5 Support for Today Explained comes from ATT. There's nothing worse than needing to make a call and realizing you can't connect says ATT.

Speaker 5 And of course, every wireless provider will claim that they're the best, but ATT says ATT has the goods to back it up. According to Root Metrics, AT ⁇ T earned the best overall network performance.

Speaker 5 While the other guys are busy making claims they can't keep, AT ⁇ T says they're making connections on America's fastest and most reliable wireless network.

Speaker 5 No matter if you're at a concert, a huge sporting event, or just out enjoying nature, you can post when you want to post. Don't post when you're enjoying nature, guys.
Keep it in control.

Speaker 5 Call when you want to call and rest easy knowing that no matter where you go, AT ⁇ T has got you covered. When you compare, there's no comparison.
ATT.

Speaker 5 Based on Root Metrics, United States Root Score Report 1H2025 tested with best commercially available smartphones, smartphones on three national mobile networks across all available network types.

Speaker 5 Your experiences may vary. Root Metrics rankings are not an endorsement of ATT.

Speaker 5 Support for Today Explain comes from Udacity. Udacity says they can help you prepare yourself to be able to use IT.

Speaker 5 Udacity is an online learning platform. It has courses in AI and tech, generative AI, agentic AI, Python, data science, so much more.

Speaker 5 When you learn with Udacity, according to Udacity, you're not just passively watching videos or reading articles, maybe even books, you're doing practical exercises and projects that prepare you for the job you want.

Speaker 5 That's why they claim 90% of Udacity graduates surveyed say they achieved their enrollment goal. Udacity just launched a master's degree in AI.

Speaker 5 When you have a certification from Udacity, they say recruiters and employers take notice. You can check out Udacity today.
The tech field is always evolving. You should be too.

Speaker 5 You can try Udacity risk-free for seven days. You can head to udacity.com/slash explained.
Use code explained for 40% off your order.

Speaker 5 Once again, udacity.com/slash explained for 40% off. Make sure you use the promo code explained.

Speaker 4 We're back. I'm Noelle King.
This new law that has caused so much controversy in South Africa allows the government, in certain cases, to take white South Africans' land without compensating them.

Speaker 4 It has divided the government and it's being challenged in court. For more on who the Afrikaners are, we call Johnny Steinberg.

Speaker 4 Johnny is an award-winning South African writer, author of many books, including Winnie and Nelson, Nelson, Portrait of a Marriage, and Midlands, which is about the murder of a white South African farmer.

Speaker 4 Johnny, what are Afrikaners?

Speaker 13 Afrikaners are the descendants of the first white people who settled in South Africa. That dates from 1652.

Speaker 13 At the time, Holland was a great imperial power. About a century and a half later, when Holland was in trouble in the Napoleonic Wars, Britain took over the Cape Colony.

Speaker 13 A whole lot of English-speaking white people arrived. And it was the descendants who formed themselves into Afrikaner nationalists, into a nationalist project in the late 19th, early 20th century.

Speaker 13 And I guess it was to stand up against the British and to suppress black people.

Speaker 13 And that project saw its culmination in 1948 when the party of Afrikaner nationalism, the National Party, came to power and instituted apartheid.

Speaker 4 And what was it like? What was apartheid like?

Speaker 13 You know, apartheid is famously one of many brutal regimes in the 20th century.

Speaker 14 The policy of apartheid, literally separateness, has been elevated by the government of South Africa from a mere theory of racial superiority to the law of the land.

Speaker 16 For decades, the National Party enforced racial segregation and violently repressed any dissent. Many died fighting it, some famous,

Speaker 16 others forgotten by all but their families.

Speaker 13 Many millions of people were displaced from their homes. You know, in the political struggle against apartheid, many thousands of people were killed and detained.

Speaker 13 It was a long, bitter, bloody, difficult struggle for democracy, which miraculously ended peacefully in a negotiated settlement in 1994.

Speaker 4 What happened in 1994?

Speaker 13 Well, four years earlier in 1990, the last president of apartheid, F.W. de Klerk, released Nelson Mandela.

Speaker 17 There's Mr. Mandela, Mr.
Nelson Mandela, a free man taking his first steps into a new South Africa.

Speaker 13 He unbanned his party, the ANC,

Speaker 13 and decided that apartheid would end by a negotiated settlement with the people who were once his enemy.

Speaker 10 The eyes of the world are presently focused on all South Africans.

Speaker 10 All of us now have an opportunity

Speaker 10 and the responsibility to prove that we are capable of a peaceful process in creating a new South Africa.

Speaker 13 You know, a lot of people died in those four years. There was a lot of violence.
It It was a complicated process.

Speaker 13 But it was, in the end, a peaceful settlement that both sides agreed to, bringing in democracy in April 1994.

Speaker 18 More than 300 years of white domination ended for good with the swearing in of Nelson Mandela as this African nation's first black president, Sao Harak Meghal.

Speaker 4 So the Afrikaners went from having all of the power and from having this system, apartheid, that basically kept them in power. After the negotiated settlement, what happened to this group?

Speaker 13 It was a pretty gentle settlement on white people. Afrikaans people were about just over half of the white population.

Speaker 13 Most people carried on living their lives pretty much as they were before, to be honest. You know, that's a simple version of the story.

Speaker 13 When you scratch underneath, more complicated things are happening.

Speaker 13 One of the things happening is that crime rates absolutely soared in the late apartheid and early post-apartheid era.

Speaker 13 And white people became victims of crimes in ways that they didn't know under apartheid, which was very frightening.

Speaker 13 I mean another thing happening, and this is about the land, this is not about all white people or all Afrikaans people, but is about farmers.

Speaker 13 A policy of land redress was introduced in the mid-1990s. And to explain what happened, it's necessary to go back to 1913 when a law was passed disallowing black ownership of land in South Africa.

Speaker 13 Many, many people displaced from their land in the decades after that. By the early 1970s, several million people had been displaced from their land.

Speaker 13 And

Speaker 13 a policy of redress was set in place in the mid-1990s. And among other things, it allowed people who could show that they had had their land taken away from them after 1913 to get it back.

Speaker 13 But not by confiscating land, not by taking it away from those who owned it, but by buying it back at market prices. So that was the core of the land reform scheme, just stated at its most simple.

Speaker 4 So in the mid-1990s, there's this process of land reform, and it's now 30 years later. Is that process still underway?

Speaker 13 It is underway. And,

Speaker 13 you know, I think many white people's grievances about that process are less about the policies themselves and the way that they've been implemented.

Speaker 13 Black and white South Africans are both enormously, enormously frustrated with South Africa's government for its levels of inefficiency and its corruption.

Speaker 13 And very often, anger at that melds with angle of the substance and the content of policy. You know, a fair amount of land has been redistributed.

Speaker 13 It has not been a particularly successful or particularly well-managed process. It has left both poor black people and white landholders and others dissatisfied.

Speaker 13 So a lot has to do with the corruption and the inefficiencies of the process itself.

Speaker 4 President Trump doesn't always speak with a great deal of accuracy.

Speaker 4 When he talks about South Africa now, as he has been doing recently, he will say things like, the land of white South Africans is being stolen.

Speaker 4 Is this an idea that Donald Trump just came up with himself, or is this idea prevalent in South Africa also?

Speaker 13 Well, if you look at South Africans' response to Donald Trump saying that, nobody has agreed with him.

Speaker 13 You know, land has not been stolen from anybody in South Africa since 1994. A lot of land has been bought at market prices and redistributed, but not stolen.

Speaker 13 As for where these ideas come from, you know, there have been South African organizations that have lobbied Trump very, very vocally, very persistently for a number of years on matters of land redistribution, but also on matters of crime, of the extent to which people who live in rural South Africa are vulnerable.

Speaker 13 And many white farmers have been victims of very violent crime.

Speaker 13 And Trump has heard about all of that from a very vocal, very articulate lobby that says that violent crime against farmers is not coincidental, that it's organized, that there's something behind it, it's an attempt to push them off the land.

Speaker 13 He has been told that by pretty extreme forces in South African society, not mainstream ones.

Speaker 4 Could you dig in a bit more on violence against white farmers? What does that mean? What does that look like?

Speaker 13 So farmers generally live in remote areas. They're far from rapid response.
They're far from police. There are a lot of guns in South Africa.
There are a lot of unemployed young men in South Africa.

Speaker 13 A lot of people making a living from crime. You know, people enter a remote property and hold up the people at gunpoints to take their possessions, sometimes kill them.

Speaker 13 Sometimes there's a terrible level of brutality in South African predatory predatory crime.

Speaker 19 In the last 10-20 years in this area I can name 20-30

Speaker 19 attacks, murders

Speaker 19 on farmers. We were busy having breakfast and they just walk around

Speaker 19 with a shotgun, two pistols and a stick and they said

Speaker 19 we are going to kill you today.

Speaker 9 Some of them they have that past ideology of saying no the farmers took our land for free and when they go there they take out the anger on them.

Speaker 10 So you think there is a racial

Speaker 9 there is that

Speaker 9 a racial element in it as well.

Speaker 13 Levels of violence in South Africa are extreme. You know in a country of 62, 63 million people there are 20,000 murders a year.
That is breathtaking. It's a violent place

Speaker 13 and it's absolutely understandable and natural that the white farming community would feel under siege, would feel vulnerable, would feel scared.

Speaker 13 But it's another thing to say that there's an organized plot against them, that this is a

Speaker 13 manifestation of a deeper attempt to throw them off their land.

Speaker 13 You know, if you look at who is killed in South Africa, if you look at per capita murder rates, those most vulnerable to being killed are unemployed young black men.

Speaker 13 And that's not for a moment to say that white farmers should not feel afraid and should not take action to defend themselves. But the idea that they're especially victimized is untenable.

Speaker 4 And so responding to this, President Trump has made this offer to help resettle resettle Afrikaners in the United States. Have any of them said, yeah, we'd like to go? What's the response there?

Speaker 13 People are pretty bewildered by the offer, you know, including the people who've been lobbying Trump. Nobody has taken them up on it.

Speaker 13 The head of Agri-South Africa is pretty mainstream, perhaps a center-right organization, said, we're farming here and we're farming successfully.

Speaker 12 We don't see large-scale land grabs in South Africa. What we see is at this stage

Speaker 12 still very reasonable as is any country in the world.

Speaker 13 You know the day after Trump made that announcement I was on a flight from Johannesburg to London and boarding the plane it was full of white South Africans who were joking about it saying well let's divert our flights to New York let's go and live in America.

Speaker 13 It was really an object of fun.

Speaker 4 So if Afrikaners are not interested in coming to the United States and Many of them, as you've laid out, will say, look, the politics in this country are messy, but it's not like a genocide is being committed committed against us, which is another rumor that we've talked about.

Speaker 4 Why do you think President Trump is making this offer? Do you have any sense of what is really behind this?

Speaker 13 Well, I think it's because it's easy for him, because there's no downside. He gets to perform a very powerful and entertaining anti-DEI performance in front of the world.

Speaker 13 He also potentially gets a

Speaker 13 middle-sized country to change its foreign policy or certainly be under enormous pressure to do that. So South Africa becomes an exemplar.

Speaker 13 It becomes a lesson to the world in what American power under Trump might mean. It causes others to move with caution.

Speaker 13 I think what Donald Trump is doing has shaken up South Africa and has sharpened divisions.

Speaker 13 Because although nobody thinks that there's genocide taking place, although nobody thinks that white land is being confiscated en masse, you know, there are powerful forces in South Africa which would like to use what Trump is saying to further their own legitimate agendas, which is to contest the government's policies of racial redress, to contest its policies of land reform.

Speaker 13 And this strengthens their hand. And it's natural that they would do that.

Speaker 13 So I think that matters that are contentious in South Africa, matters that are highly, highly disputed, have become more contentious, more volatile.

Speaker 13 You know, they're forces in South Africa which are using what Trump has done to open up space for their agenda. But that's kind of expected.
Of course, they're going to do that.

Speaker 13 And in a democratic country, why shouldn't they?

Speaker 4 Johnny Steinberg. He teaches at Yale.
His latest book is Winnie and Nelson, Portrait of a Marriage. He's also the author of Midlands.
Avishai Artsi and Travis Larchuk produced our show today.

Speaker 4 They were edited by Miranda Kennedy and Jolie Myers, fact-checked by Laura Bullard, and mixed by Patrick Boyd and Andrea Kristen's daughter. I'm Noelle King.
It's Today Explained.

Speaker 15 Support for this show comes from OnePassword. If you're an IT or security pro, managing devices, identities, and applications can feel overwhelming and risky.

Speaker 15 Trellica by OnePassword helps conquer SaaS sprawl and shadow IT by discovering every app your team uses, managed or not. Take the first step to better security for your team.

Speaker 15 Learn more at onepassword.com slash podcastoffer. That's onepassword.com slash podcastoffer.
All lowercase.

Speaker 15 Support for this show comes from OnePassword. If you're an IT or security pro, managing devices, identities, and applications can feel overwhelming and risky.

Speaker 15 Trellica by OnePassword helps conquer SaaS sprawl and shadow IT by discovering every app your team uses, managed or not. Take the first step to better security for your team.

Speaker 15 Learn more at onepassword.com/slash podcast offer. That's onepassword.com/slash podcast offer.
All lowercase.