105 - What Happened at the Smithwick House

Hey hey, Jeffrey Kraner from welcome to Night Vale here.

Apart from Night Vale, we make other podcasts.

If you're already a big Night Vale fan, check out Good Morning Night Vale, where cast members Meg Bashwiner, Symphony Sanders, and Hal Lublin break down each and every episode.

Or if you're looking for more weird fiction, there's Within the Wires, an immersive fiction podcast written by me and novelist Janina Mathewson.

Each season is a standalone tale told in the guise of found audio.

Finally, maybe you like horror movies or are scared of horror movies but are horror curious, check out Random Number Generator Horror Podcast Number 9, where me and the voice of Night Vale Cecil Baldwin talk about a randomly drawn horror film.

We have new episodes every single week.

So that's Good Morning Nightvale Within the Wires and Random Horror 9.

Go to nightvalepresents.com for more or get those podcasts wherever you get your podcasts.

Say hello to the next generation of Zendesk AI agents, built to deliver resolutions for everyone.

Loved by over 10,000 companies, Zendesk AI agents easily deploy in minutes to resolve 30% of interactions instantly.

That's the Zendesk AI Effect.

Find out more at Zendesk.com.

If you could press a button, that would give you a great deal of money.

But it would cause someone you don't know in a distant part of the world to die, then you would have a good model for how our current economy works.

Welcome to Night Vale.

To start off,

the story that everyone is talking about.

about.

In the interest of the common good, I feel I must report to you what happened at the Smithwick house.

Mr.

and Mrs.

Smithwick lived in a neat two-story home on Butterfield Lane.

They had two small children, Lisa and Jake.

Their lives were mostly normal.

Mr.

Smithwick was a gloomy man.

He had an anger inside of him.

He hadn't used this anger to do anything, but Mrs.

Smithwick could smell it, and the children could smell it.

They were always very careful around Mr.

Smithwick.

Sometimes it would be a day, just any day, and they would turn to find him looking at them with a blank stare, and they would feel as though teetering on the edge of something wild and final.

And then they would look again, and it would just be stolid Mr.

Smithwick going about his day.

Even the neighbors could smell it.

There was always something dark hanging over the Smithwick house.

They never consciously thought, but always felt.

And because of this, they stayed away.

Mrs.

Smithwick was often lonely since few neighbors would talk to her.

Mr.

Smithwick was never lonely.

He did not have the capacity for loneliness.

One day, Mrs.

Smithwick discovered she was pregnant.

An accident.

And how would they care for a third child?

But they would.

There would be no choice.

Dutifully, Mr.

Smithwick began to prepare a nursery in what had previously been a guest room.

He moved out the furniture that had only ever been used for guests once, a visit from a cousin three Thanksgivings before, never repeated.

He was in the process of painting the room a soothing green when he first saw the hole in the wall opposite the door.

He called in the other members of the family because the hole was so truly odd, perfectly square, and opening onto a tunnel that was also square.

The tunnel's sides were a cool, damp concrete leading away into darkness.

On the other side of the wall was the outside of the house, but the hole seemed to lead somewhere very distant, although it was too dark to see.

A soft breeze came from the hole.

It was too small to enter, only about a foot on each side, so the family stood in the unfinished nursery.

looking at the hole.

Mr.

Smithwick thought he could hear from far in in the distance of its depths, a soft humming.

More soon, but first.

As many of you probably heard, two weeks ago I was arrested after my explanation of the secret hierarchy of

angels.

I was dragged in front of the city council and informed I would be sent through a lengthy re-education and brain reconditioning program before I would be allowed back on the air.

But then I got city council chatting about how station management is doing.

Their relationship is on a little bit of an icy patch again, and I see station management on a daily basis, so it was pretty easy to draw the council into a series of questions about what management's mood has been like and how many hapless employees of the station have been lured to the management's office.

and relieved of their life energy.

And finally, the council forgot what they had called me in to punish me about and let me go.

And so, here I am, speaking to you once again.

Ooh, by the way, there is a difference between a rough patch and an icy patch in a relationship.

A rough patch is where there is a great deal of arguing and disagreement, a jostle to both parties' lives.

An icy patch is where, outwardly, all seems to be smooth, but there is no actual connection made.

Simple sentiments sentiments skitter off in unintended directions, and both parties feel like they're lurching without control towards destinations they had not foreseen.

The angels, meanwhile, continue to fight for a legal acknowledgement of their existence.

They have been protesting outside City Hall, blocking the entrance.

Now this has made life extremely difficult for City Hall employees.

The employees are unable to get inside the building, but since angels do not legally exist, these employees are also unable to accurately describe the reason for their absence from work.

And the angels have called on all unions, including the steelworkers union, the taxi drivers union, the tree, shrub, and moss union, to join them in a general strike until the denial of their basic identity is finally purged from the books of law.

And now your Children's Fun Fact Science Quarter.

Today we will look at birthstones.

If you were born in January, your birthstone is the garnet.

If you were born in February, your birthstone is also the garnet.

You have to fight with January to see who gets to have the garnet.

Whoever wins gets to be born.

That's how birth works.

If you were born in March, your birthstone is, that's right, the garnet.

This is going to be a brutal battle for that stone.

If you were born in April, your birthstone is flat and gray and sits next to a pond.

It is dusty and warm in the sunshine, and if you put it against your cheek, it would feel like taking a long walk on a nice day.

If you were born in May, your birthstone is cemented into the wall of a rich person's indoor shower.

This stall has several different shower heads and built-in surround sound speakers and your stone is near near where the person's butt usually goes.

I'm sorry to have to inform you of this.

June, your birthstone is this one that I have in my hand.

If you want it back, then you'll need to listen very carefully and do everything

I say.

July, you don't have a birthstone.

You have a birth rock.

It's in a park in San Diego, and children sit on it to tie their shoes.

August, your birthstone is in space, A shard broken off of an asteroid that is spinning away from the sun.

Thousands of years from now, your birthstone will leave the solar system.

September, your birthstone was swallowed by a little boy who is very sorry about having swallowed a stone.

Swallowing a stone is uncomfortable and dangerous.

A lesson that little boy is learning now.

October, your birthstone was buried by by drifting soil thousands of years ago.

It will never again be uncovered.

November, your birthstone is falling from a great height.

Soon it will land.

I hope it will not land on anyone, but then life has no guarantees.

December, your birthstone is a dump truck.

You may correctly notice that this isn't a type of stone, but you may also correctly notice that at least you didn't get stuck fighting over a garnet.

This has been the Children's Fun Fact Science Corner.

And now back to what happened at the Smithwick house.

A few days after the discovery of the hole, Mrs.

Smithwick disappeared.

She did not pack any of her clothes.

There was no sign of violence.

She was just gone.

The children, Lisa and Jake, did not cry.

They were too shocked to cry.

They realized, without realizing, that they had passed through a threshold that there would be no way to ever return.

Mr.

Smithwick called the police, who investigated thoroughly.

He tried to tell them about the hole, still in the wall of the unfinished nursery upstairs, but they were uninterested in that.

They wanted to know where he had been last night and if he could prove it.

He had been with the children.

They said so as well.

The police didn't like it.

But they couldn't find evidence of a crime, let alone evidence that any specific person had done a crime.

And so, they left.

Mr.

Smithwick took the children to school on his way to work.

He made dinner that night.

He felt as though he should be searching for his wife, but something in him did not seem to find that urgent.

Instead, he went into the nursery, painted a green,

he now found overbearing.

The hole was where it had been before.

He listened closely.

Yes,

still the humming from deep in the darkness.

He bent over and looked, but in the depth of its perfectly square tunnel he could see only shadow.

Then

there was a gurgle, and movement coming toward him, and he stumbled backwards, and a stream of clean, fresh water began to pour from the hole.

And now,

traffic.

I have never seen snow in person.

And yet, I can taste it.

I know its bite, but I have never felt it.

We go places.

We never go.

We achieve what we do not achieve.

This is the power of imagination.

Is imagination a blessing or a prison?

Would I be more driven to seek out snow if I could not imagine snow?

If I could not project in my stomach what a ride down a hill might feel like, would I be compelled to seek out a slope and a sled?

Does imagining make me less likely to act?

Here Here is what I think.

Imagination might hold us back, but the exchange is worth it.

By imagining, I can experience things that not only haven't happened, but couldn't happen.

For instance, I will imagine an event now.

A

creature with a long

forehead and

wide golden eyes on the planet

Zardaz.

In a galaxy that is not even visible from our galaxy, this creature who is named Ersdon is on trial for the crime of having viewed the sacred animal.

Tom,

pet of the Queen of Zardaz.

When asked to defend themself, Erzdon looked over the assembled citizens of Zardaz,

all six of them.

It is an inhospitable planet, and their population is very low.

Have we not all,

at one time or another,

viewed Tom, the sacred animal?

Have we not all?

Ersdan asks.

It turns out they have not all.

No one has ever seen Tom before, not even the queen, and the queen is annoyed at this, and Erzdon is tossed off a cliff.

And the population of Zardaz

is now five.

What would our lives be without the ability to imagine nonsense like that?

Anyway, there's a patch of falling snow on Route 800 that scientists cannot explain, given that the rest of the region is currently in the usual early spring heat wave.

I have never seen snow in person, but can imagine exactly what that snow looks like, and so

feel no urge to go check it out

this has been

traffic

more on what happened at the smithwick house

the children were gone they had not attended school in days and mr smithwick could not say where they were he expressed utter confusion The police did not believe this and arrested him.

He sat quietly in his cell, and when they were forced to let him go because there was no evidence of his involvement, he quietly went home.

The neighbors avoided him, but they had always avoided him.

The police left a car outside his house indefinitely.

He went about his days as he always had.

He made breakfast.

He went to work.

He made dinner.

He went to bed.

His wife and children were missing.

He did not look for them.

Instead, he went each evening into the nursery, where the hideous green paint on the wall now seemed an act of violence upon him.

And he sat cross-legged on the floor, looking at the hole.

The air coming from within it was cold, like air from a cave.

One evening, after several weeks of this, he stood and reached his arm into the hole.

He felt something

soft brush his fingers.

He cried out and tried to grasp it.

It felt like the faintest touch of a hand.

He stretched his arm as far as it would go and found a finger.

Hold.

He pulled it.

What he had felt in the tunnel moved easily with his pull.

To his astonishment, his arm emerged holding the branch of a tree several feet long, covered in leaves the same shade as the wall.

He sat back down.

He did not try to reach into the hole again.

Soon, the rest of what happened at the Smithwick house, but now

the weather.

You cannot cage me, I revolt

You cannot contain me, I hold I am not caught because what I got, got you can't hold, holderness

The wildness was obvious.

From the moment you saw me, you should have known in the dirty snow, holding my own.

You cannot cage me, I revolt.

You cannot contain me, I hope.

I am not caught because what I got, got, you can't hold, hope.

I wouldn't dare me, so don't.

You cannot will me, I won't.

I am not caught because what I got, got, you can't hold, hold, hold.

hope, hope.

I can't help pinching an audience.

This naughtiness is glorious.

You love me

because of this.

This wildness is tenderness.

With every bite of my teeth, I'm showing you best how I love you back without bitterness.

You cannot cage me, I revolt.

You cannot contain me, I won't.

I am not caught because what I got, got, you can't hold, hope.

I wouldn't dare me, so don't.

You cannot will me, I revolt.

I am not caught.

Cause what I got, got you can't hold, hold.

You cannot cage me.

I wouldn't dare me.

So you cannot contain me.

I cannot will me.

I'm caught.

Cause what I got.

Cause you can't hold, hold, hold.

Hey, it's Jeffrey Kraner with a word from our sponsor.

You're on a desert island, but not a deserted island.

Someone else is there.

Something else is there.

In the water, surrounding you lurks a mythical beast with two large eyes and many long arms.

You're just now hearing of this beast, but you're not afraid because you don't plan to swim.

Though that water looks nice, you're good at talking yourself into things, and soon you are in the sea, frolicking and splashing.

You even squeal, thinking you're all alone.

But you forgot what I just said.

You're not alone.

Something wraps itself around you.

It lifts you high in the air, waving you about at dizzying heights.

You look down and see the mythical kraken.

You start to scream, but in its other tentacles are bottles of kraken black spiced rum and kraken gold spiced rum.

I love kraken rum, you say.

It's bold, smooth, and made with a blend of spices.

You high-five the beast as it sets you back down on the island, along with the bottles of kraken rum.

It winks and tells you kraken rum is ideal for Halloween cocktails and disappears back into the dark, briny depths.

Visit the official sponsor of Welcome to Night Vale, Kraken Rum.com to release the Kraken this Halloween.

Copyright 2025, Kraken Rum Company, Kraken Rum.com.

Like the deepest sea, the Kraken should be treated with great respect and responsibility.

You chose to hit play on this podcast today.

Smart Choice.

Progressive loves to help people make smart choices.

That's why they offer a tool called Auto Quote Explorer that allows you to compare your progressive car insurance quote with rates from other companies.

So you save time on the research and can enjoy savings when you choose the best rate for you.

Give it a try after this episode at progressive.com.

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates.

Not available in all states or situations.

Prices vary based on how you buy.

Mr.

Smithwick no longer went to work.

He did not make breakfast or dinner.

He did not sleep.

He sat in the nursery and looked at the hole.

From deep in the tunnel, he heard humming.

The neighbors noticed that he didn't go out anymore and they assumed the worst about this.

They confirmed with each other that there had been something heavy and strange about the man.

They agreed that this had all been a matter of time.

Time did not matter to Mr.

Smithwick anymore.

He didn't notice if it was day or if it was night.

Inside the tunnel leading away from the unfinished nursery, it was always the same.

dark and cool.

When no one had seen Mr.

Smithwick for several days, the police in the car outside decided to investigate.

Earlier this week, they searched the house, but there was no trace of Mr.

Smithwick.

All of his things were still there, and there was no sign of violence.

He was just gone.

One of the police officers wandered into the nursery.

where the green paint on the walls resembled a person turning ill.

It did not appear that anyone had been in the room for days.

There was no hole in the wall.

Evidence was searched for, and evidence was not found.

The Smithwick house stands empty, with all of the family's things still inside, furniture and clothing, even the food.

rotting in the refrigerator.

The neighbors still shake their heads and say that this just goes to show,

although none of them understand what it went to show.

And that

is what happened at the Smithwick house.

If there is anything to be learned from this,

I

refuse to learn it.

Carlos has called into the station to let me know that he's thinking quinoables for dinner.

Also to remind me that the Dancing on the Stars finale is tonight, and also to say that what happened at the Smithwick house happened a long time ago, and he has no idea how it happened again.

And I told him that this is definitely the first time anything like this happened in Nightvale.

I mean,

I would have remembered something this weird happening in our quiet little town.

But he insisted that he studied the Smithwick case already almost four years ago.

He doesn't understand how the whole incident could have repeated exactly as it happened before.

Reality doesn't allow for that, he said.

Well,

I suppose there's no accounting for reality.

Stay tuned next for a look back at your life, featuring the most embarrassing moments and biggest failures, hosted by your own brain.

If you missed this showing, don't worry.

It plays on a nightly repeat.

Good night, Night Vale.

Good night.

Welcome to Night Vale is a production of Night Vale Presents.

It is written by Joseph Fink and Jeffrey Kraner and produced by Joseph Fink.

The voice of Night Vale is Cecil Baldwin.

Original music by Disparition.

All of it can be found at disparition.info or at disparition.bandcamp.com.

This episode's weather was You Cannot by Erin McYone from her newest EP.

Find out more at erinmcyone.com.

That's M-C-K-E-O-W-N.

And see her on tour with Welcome to Night Vale this month all over the US plus Montreal and Toronto.

Comments, questions, email us at info at welcometonightvale.com or follow us on Twitter at nightvale radio or learn more about birds that live in your area.

Check out welcome to nightvale.com for more information on this show and our live shows, which we are doing right now.

Check them out.

And while you're there, consider clicking the donate link.

Artists like paying bills and eating.

Today's proverb: you are what you eat.

That's very confusing phrasing.

Let me simplify: you consume your own flesh.

Much clearer.

I'm Amy Nicholson, the film critic for the LA Times.

And I'm Paul Scheer, an actor, writer, and director.

You might know me from the League Veep or my non-eligible for Academy Award role in Twisters.

We love movies, and we come at them from different perspectives.

Yeah, like Amy thinks that, you know, Joe Pesci was miscast in Goodfellas, and I don't.

He's too old.

Let's not forget that Paul thinks that Dune 2 is overrated.

It is.

Anyway, despite this, we come together to host Unschooled, a podcast where we talk about good movies, critical hits, fan favorites, must-sees, and in case you missed them.

We're talking Parasite the Home Alone, From Greece to the Dark Knight.

We've done deep dives on popcorn flicks.

We've talked about why Independence Day deserves a second look.

And we've talked about horror movies, some that you've never even heard of, like Kanja and Hess.

So if you love movies like we do, come along on our cinematic adventure.

Listen to Unschooled wherever you get your podcast.

And don't forget to hit the follow button.

Are you squeamish about horror movies, but kind of want to know what happens?

Or are you a horror lover who likes thoughtful conversation about your favorite genre?

Join me, Jeffrey Kraner, and my friend from Welcome to Nightville, Cecil Baldwin, for our weekly podcast, Random Number Generator Horror Podcast Number Nine, where we watch and discuss horror movies in a random order.

Find, here's the short version, Random Horror Nine wherever you get your podcasts.

Boo.