Goldman Sachs' Earnings Woes, X Tests Subscriptions, and Marc Andreesen’s Manifesto

Support for the show comes from Saks Fifth Avenue.

Sacks Fifth Avenue makes it easy to shop for your personal style.

Follow us here, and you can invest in some new arrivals that you'll want to wear again and again, like a relaxed product blazer and Gucci loafers, which can take you from work to the weekend.

Shopping from Saks feels totally customized, from the in-store stylist to a visit to Saks.com, where they can show you things that fit your style and taste.

They'll even let you know when arrivals from your favorite designers are in, or when that Brunello Cachinelli sweater you've been eyeing is back in stock.

So, if you're like me and you need shopping to be personalized and easy, head to Saks Fifth Avenue for the Best Fall Arrivals and Style inspiration.

Thumbtack presents Project Paralysis.

I was cornered.

Sweat gathered above my furrowed brow and my mind was racing.

I wondered who would be left standing when the droplets fell.

Me or the clogged sink.

Drain cleaner and pipe snake clenched in my weary fist, I stepped toward the sink and then...

Wait, why am I stressing?

I have thumbtack.

I can easily search for a top-rated plumber in the Bay Area, read reviews, and compare prices, all on the app.

Thumbtack knows homes.

Download the app today.

You're late.

Actually, when someone says you're late, you're supposed to say you're ugly.

Well, we'd both be right.

Yeah.

Hi, everyone.

This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network.

I'm Kara Swisher.

And I'm Scott Galloway.

How you doing?

My voice is a little better today, don't you think?

Yeah, it actually sounds a lot better.

I know.

Now we're in the hacking cough and sore throat part of the equation of whatever I have.

I don't know what it is.

The good news is, I find that our age, despite I'll say our age generously, because you're much older than me, but coughs tend to hang around for like months.

Do they?

I find they're lingering.

They're lingering.

You just sit there and go

like that.

Definitely.

I could see you wandering around the house coughing late at night.

Do you wander around the house late at night?

Yeah, it's actually one of my favorite things.

I get on.

Me too.

Yeah.

I get, I literally do that.

I wander around and I do things and I have a good time.

Are you a night person?

I am a night person.

I would stay up until 3 a.m.

if I could and sleep till I used to be able to sleep till noon and now I can't because of kids, but I also can't sleep.

Yeah.

I wake up

every morning at six, seven o'clock.

Yeah.

No, I basically, I actually went to sleep at 4 a.m.

last night.

But the nice thing is I get to get up every 90 minutes and pee.

So that's the good news.

That's an old man thing.

That's a prostate thing, right?

It is a prostate thing.

Yeah.

Yeah.

You should wear a diaper, an adult diaper.

You know, it's on its way.

We all come into this world and leave it in diapers.

It's the great equalizer.

That's true.

I think diapers must be comforting.

We're getting Claire off of them almost completely, except for nighttime.

And she's working on nighttime.

And I think she likes it.

Like, I don't know.

I think she likes, you know, the comfort of it or something.

You should try it.

I'll send you a box.

Yeah,

maybe in 20 or 30 years, but yeah, I'm in.

Okay.

I'm in, not yet.

Okay, good.

Cool.

So there's a lot going on.

There's still the ongoing crisis in the Mideast.

Also, Goldman Sachs is earnings woes.

The DJ is no longer.

The side hustle was a distraction, apparently.

X is planned to charge,

will go into effect, I guess.

Google making cuts in its news division, all kinds of things happening.

We still don't have a Speaker of the House.

As we record this on Thursday morning, Representative Jim Jordan has failed to win a second vote for speakership.

He actually lost Republican votes on the second round.

Every House Democrat voted for Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries.

Members of both parties are looking to give interim Speaker Patrick McHenry the authority to run the House until a speaker can be chosen.

I think this is a plot by that little bow-tied man to take over everything.

A lot of it's been drowned out by news from the Mideast, but it's still a circus.

Any thoughts?

I think you summarize it.

It's a circus.

It's a bad look for the Republicans and leadership and America in general.

It's, I think it makes sense.

I

don't, I find Jim Jordan, you know, I just, I have much different political views than his, but I think it's just sort of ridiculous that they would offer up someone to lead the House of Representatives.

At the end of the day, they're lawmakers, and he's never made a law.

I just don't.

So we're going to have...

Yeah, what's he been doing that whole time?

He's been

throwing red meat at his base, getting on TikTok and fundraising.

And

getting re-elected and getting more and more senior appointments.

That's why we need need more churn.

This isn't a career built on achievements.

It's a career built on seniority as built on saying incendiary extremist things that your base loves and gives you more money, which gets you elected Washington's P.P.

He says he's shaken up the system.

He really isn't.

The system remains and he's just loud on the side of it.

A lot of the wrestlers at, I think it's Ohio State,

are coming forward again talking about his behavior, which is also reprehensible, according to them.

I'm going to say you're innocent until proven guilty, but there's a lot of people coming forward talking about how he behaved during that time.

He also bullied a lot of people.

That's what they're alleging.

He's saying he wasn't the bully, but people have been calling offices of congresspeople who voted against him, Republicans, very conservative Republicans, by the way, I might add,

and making death threats and cursing and this and that.

And he's, you know, of course, saying this is terrible, but, you know,

all Rhodes lead of bullying leads Jim Jordan, including around the election denial stuff.

So I don't know.

It's really quite depressing that this is who they think is qualified.

Trevor Burrus: Not only that, I've seen a couple of TikToks of different Republican congresspeople, and a lot of them seem quite reasonable.

A lot of them even seem as if they could reach across the aisle and occasionally work with people to pass bipartisan legislation.

I mean, making him speaker is going to do nothing but decrease the likelihood we're going to get anything done.

Yeah, which may be his point.

I agree.

I was listening to several and I was like, okay, reasonable.

You know, reasonable.

And I then looked up a record.

I'm like, not so reasonable, but that's okay.

It's a policy debate, right?

And she was like, sort of made sense.

There's a lot of them.

It's actually kind of good to get this middle group that's been quiet.

They call them the squishes, I guess.

I don't know.

They're kind of like, screw this.

Fuck this guy.

You know, I'm kind of glad they finally stood up.

My favorite is Ken Buck, who's just, who knows what he's going to say, what's going to drop out of his mouth at any point.

But all he wants Jordan to say is the election wasn't stolen and Jordan won't do it, which is crazy.

But, you know, anyway, we'll see.

But let's get to something that has to do with you because I know you like that.

A number of tech leaders are dropping out of next month's Web Summit conference in Lisbon.

This is after Patty Cosgrave, the co-founder of Web Summit, accused Israel of committing war crimes.

Cosgrave posted that, quote, war crimes are war crimes even when they're committed by allies and should be called out for what they are.

He since issued an apology sort of condemning Hamas and saying he supports Israel's right to defend itself.

But, you know, he was getting into beefs all over the place and kept sort of doubling down on a lot of stuff.

Scott, I'd like you to talk about it.

I would just say a lot of this to me is narcissism on his part.

He has no place here.

I know he can say what he wants, but at some point, especially at a very emotional moment, he might want to sit down.

Just want to sit down and shut up for a minute.

Even if he has opinions, I have opinions too.

So Scott, talk to me about this.

So the last few years, I've been asked to be one of the keynotes at Web Summit, and it's never worked.

Yep.

I've been invited myself, but

I haven't gone in years.

Oh, you had to add that in there, didn't you?

No, I've never seen it.

I was invited before you.

Okay, you were.

No, I've gone.

I've gone.

I have gone.

I've never been.

Anyways, Web Summit is the South by Southwest, if you will, of Europe.

I was really excited about going.

I was opening the night, the opening night, and

I have two really close friends in Lisbon, and we were going to make a weekend of it.

I was really excited to go.

Yeah.

And then he does this stuff.

He puts out what most people would label as at a minimum anti-Israel and potentially anti-Semitic comments or commentary on Twitter.

And

so immediately I started getting an email saying, are you going to pull out what are you going to do?

And what's different about the decision process is that I think 10 or 20 years ago, I would have thought, how can I be seen as most awesome and interesting and get into a grievance contest and express my outrage?

And I thought, okay,

how can I be more thoughtful about this?

And I started, I thought, okay, I'm going to call some people who might be able to help me read the label from inside of the bottle, which you can't.

You did.

You called me.

I can't believe it.

I called you.

I called Jonathan Rosenblatt from the Anti-Defamation League.

I called Paul Sagan, who's on my board of directors.

I called Jeffrey Sonnenfeld, although I knew what Jeffrey was going to say.

I called Todd Benson, a few of my friends who I think don't have as much affinity for Israel to get a more balanced view.

And where I was struggling was the following, or the process I went through is when I first heard his comments, I got very upset and thought, that's it, I'm out.

And then kind of the second layer, peeling back the onion, I do have a concern, a very real concern, that corporations, universities, and

gatherings like this

are safe places where we come together and we enjoy what we have in common and our shared beliefs, whether it's at this summit, celebrating Europe, Portugal, entrepreneurship.

digital innovation, capitalism.

There's a lot.

99% of the people who attend this share views on a lot of wonderful things.

And I worry that if everybody just withdraws, if Leslie Wexer and all Jewish alumni and supporters and then ultimately students withdraw from Harvard, do we as Jews just end up at a small number of schools?

Do corporations

are all required eventually to take a political stand on everything, meaning that if you're of a different political view, there's Chick-fil-A, which is one type of political orthodoxy, and there's In-N-Out, which is another.

And slowly but surely, every organization becomes red or blue, pro-Israel, anti-Israel.

And we have even more segregation and less reason to come together and celebrate the things we share.

I really, I have a very real concern that we are

we are finding reasons to segregate from each other, which creates less understanding,

more coarse discourse war.

Can I make one observation?

People did self-select a lot more than you think.

Men, especially.

Say more?

I think people did it without talking about it.

You, you hung out in country clubs you liked, or went to parties you liked with the right people.

And

that's what I mean.

I think people did this.

And, you know, as a woman being left out, I was one of the few at that conference on stage in the beginning early on.

And they tried to change, obviously.

But go ahead.

Universities, corporations, and these types of events are usually generally great ways to bring people from different backgrounds and different viewpoints together to celebrate their shared interests.

Sure.

And

I think that's a wonderful thing.

And I worry that we just continue to segregate.

And then the reality is, I started thinking more and more, and as things have unfolded here, one,

there are different levels of bad.

There are different levels of crime.

I think that the far-right policies that largely indicate the Israeli approach to the occupied territories or Gaza have been wrong.

I think Netanyahu is a criminal.

And I think there's a time to talk about both of those things.

There is a different level of evil, a different threat of DEF CON a million that is represented by terrorism.

And there needs to be a swift and crisp response to the apologists out there, whether it's Elon Musk, whether it's the media, immediately asking everyone to slow down when there's reports of Israeli babies being beheaded.

Let's take a moment.

This hasn't been confirmed.

And then a hospital is destroyed.

And immediately everyone's like, Israel destroys hospital.

If Hamas put down their weapons, there'd largely be peace right now in Gaza.

And I would like to think we could move to something resembling

some sort of reparations or start thinking about the next chapter here.

If Israel puts down their weapons, they're all going to be exterminated.

And the level of both sides here, the thinly veiled anti-Semitism, which is infecting our culture,

I think has to,

I think we have to have a swift and pretty severe response.

Let me ask you, as a devil's advocate, I just want you to put this.

You know, it was interesting.

I was watching CNN last night.

I was noticing

they had had a lot of Israeli families on who have hostages, and they're incredibly brave, given that most of these people have children being held hostage, you know, adult, adult children or older, but, you know, teens or whatever.

And then they just started to bring on a lot of Palestinians who are, whose relatives are suffering there, either stuck in some of these areas, et cetera.

And it was interesting.

It was an interesting,

I obviously was a choice.

I didn't think that was both sidesism.

I thought it was in for, I thought the way they handled it was information.

And I agree on the news stuff because they go too fast, too far, especially around the hospital, around all these things,

whichever

fingers being pointed wherever.

But

there is a time and a place.

I think you're correct in saying that.

And at the moment

that Cosgrove said that, I thought this is just not the moment and not the right message and not you, which was that's what sort of struck me.

Yeah.

And

I think it's important that people have empathy for both sides.

I don't, I mean, this is a layered and nuanced problem,

but

the different level of inhumanity being demonstrated by one side here.

Agree.

And, you know, there's so much going on.

I think young people are conflating

the struggle of the Palestinians with civil rights and have a lot of empathy for them.

And quite frankly, I think the far right in Israel has not draped themselves in glorious and created a real decline in empathy and support for Israel.

And I think they bear some responsibility for that.

But people all around the world in the media and Americans, and especially Jews like myself,

you know, it's one thing to have an opinion.

But if you have a principle, and my principle, I'd like to think, is that terrorism needs to be in uncertain terms

repudiated, it's not a principle unless you're willing to sacrifice for it.

Then it's just an opinion.

opinion.

And so I called a lot of people.

I wanted to be thoughtful about this.

And a lot of his comments, as I read his tweets, I would describe them as he's being an apologist for terrorism.

And he's...

Yeah.

He also is quite like angry and on his high horse.

That was really irritating.

And indignant.

And also, just as a leader,

he's being a terrible leader.

He's putting a lot of

people's economic livelihood in the crosshair of his grandstanding in political beliefs.

That's not what a CEO does.

It's like,

it's not,

does everyone, do the thousands of people who work at Web Summit feel the same way as you?

Because this is how you are representing your organization, whether you like it.

Yeah, there was also the controversy around the Qatar event that he's having.

He's going to Qatar, doing an event there, just to put that in there.

And also,

just on a personal level, I thought about my mom.

My mom was a Jew, and I thought she would be really disappointed if she knew I was going.

And I thought, you know, that that matters to me.

And look, I hope, I hope that there's a lot of other events.

I hope that in an era of social media, I see Twitter as nothing but kerosene that is ready to be poured on our worst instincts.

I agree with you.

And he got caught in that.

And I do believe we need to move to a society, and I hope we teach people this as part of high school, that in an era of social media with network effects, where there's a 24 by 7 camera on your life, that we become slow to judge and quick to forget that's a very good way of putting it who who affected you the most what what pushed you over the edge because you were definitely on the fence when you and i were talking i i have an image of my 80 year old aunt hided

i it's okay scott i get it i get it i think you're making the right decision for yourself i really do i think it's you know people will

will pile on you one way or the other, no matter what you do.

And you have to do what's right for you and what's correct for you and how you feel instinctually, you know, ultimately.

And I appreciate that you

went and called all these people and wanted to talk to people and took a moment rather than got on your own high horse and made a series of declarations, which you did not do.

I thought that was incredibly smart of you to do for yourself.

But you've made the right decision.

Yeah, I think so.

And I hope that we make an effort again to move to forgiveness for people and be a little bit more gracious, whether it's students who say dumb things.

But when it comes to different levels of wrong, there has to be a pretty swift and unequivocal response to terrorism.

Full stop.

I would have to agree with you on that one.

I think you're right.

This has been a really interesting Rorschach test on the whole world on this thing because there's no,

you know, did you, was it night or day?

Did you ever read that book?

I don't think so.

You need to read it.

It's a very short book, so you'll like that.

It's about those.

Does it have pictures?

No, you don't want pictures in this book.

It's about torture and Israel becoming having the people of Israel having just been brutalized.

It's Elie Weisel.

It's night.

There's night and there's day, but you should read both.

And it's about being brutal.

and being brutalized.

And it was really,

it stayed with me.

I read it in college.

I should read it again.

I haven't read it since then.

But

it's about those really difficult moments, which this is.

Scott, you've become a very thoughtful man.

I really appreciate it.

I thought this is where you're going to end up.

I did in the end.

Although I know you want to help those entrepreneurs.

I think that was what was sticking in your craw most of all.

You know, you wanted to be there and sort of give advice and et cetera, et cetera.

Plus, I heard it's just a good time.

It's a good time.

It is.

There's really good prawns in Lisbon.

We'll go to Lisbon together.

How about that?

We'll go there.

We'll go on.

Well, I'm going to to propose now that we bring back code and we have an event at Code in 2024 in Tel Aviv.

Oh,

wow.

Okay, let's talk about it.

Anyway, Google has cut around 40 jobs in its news division.

The spokesman of the company said the cuts were made to streamline and that hundreds of people are still working on a news product.

Reminder, Alphabet cut 6% of its staff this January.

I've never thought news.

I thought it was always a virtue signal for them, at least.

I don't know.

Any thoughts?

I think they figured out what a lot of billionaires and shareholders of Gannett, the New York Times, or the Washington Post have figured out, and that news is a shitty business.

That it is.

I mean, keep in mind, when I was growing up, the news was something that played for 21 minutes every night on CBS, NBC, or ABC.

And it was seen as a social good.

The networks thought, all right, we're just clocking money, selling tang and Chevies during Brady Bunch and the Partridge family.

So we're going to give a little bit of it back and we're going to have 21 minutes of news.

And they started something called Point Counterpoint.

It went 18 minutes of news, three minutes of opinion.

And they noticed that the greatest engagement was in those three minutes.

And then Ted Turner said, people want news 24 hours a day.

And then Rupert Murdoch said, oh, wait, people want 24 hours of news/slash entertainment.

And the whole thing came off the rails.

And unless you were offering entertainment, actual news, the nuance and the depth and the journalism required is a shitty business.

And in addition, when you have algorithms that elevate false content or misinformation and you subject yourself to warranted criticism and you don't want to make the investment because you have margins that are just ungodly and you don't want to reduce those ungodly margins in things like fact-checking and journalism, you just throw up your arms and you say, let's get the hell out of Dodge if Dodge equals news.

And they've just, they've come to the same realization that our economy has come to and that the UK government kind of came to and said to have fact-check reporting we need to charge every household to have the BBC.

Yeah, because news is important, but real news and real journalism is in a profit model, not a good business.

Yeah, I would agree.

I never thought, honestly, I know they think they're serious.

And I remember being at my house once and Larry Page was there and he was talking about how all news is equal to me.

And I wanted to, I literally was like, I'm going to throw a drink in your face.

Like he thought if you give everybody everything, they will figure it out.

And I was like, oh, yeah, yeah.

Yeah, right.

Go to 4chan, Larry.

I remember aye, yi thinking, this is, this guy is just doesn't know me.

And, you know, they, I don't think they value it.

I think everything is, they think a cat video is the same as a, whatever you think of the New York Times this week.

That headline was problematic that they had about the bombing.

I was just like, they don't care.

A cat video is the same as a New York Times article to them.

That's that's my feeling.

It was always my feeling with those people.

And they don't want to, they've taken no responsibility, all of them, and they want no responsibility.

And that's where we are, you know, with these people.

We'll get to that more in a minute.

But let's get to our first big story.

It's been a tough week for Goldman Sachs with the company reporting a 33% decline in profit for the third quarter, though it's slightly better than some analysts expected.

The losses are tied to Goldman selling off pieces of its failed experiment in consumer lending, plus a large drop in revenue in its asset and wealth management division.

In an earnings call, CEO David Solomon attempted to convince investors that the company is headed for future growth, but made it clear that rising interest rates and the war in Ukraine and Israel will present challenges.

He's also said he's going to stop doing his DJ.

DJing, he's called DJ DeSaul.

As he's known, he's played at a number of high-profile events over the years, including Lollapalooza and Sports Illustrated Super Bowl Party.

He stopped DJing after getting criticism.

It created a distraction from his work, according to the Financial Times.

Well, I'd love your thoughts on that.

Well, it's not that complex or interesting, and that is the banks that are largely dependent upon investment banking revenue, that is MA transactions and

the IPO business, which is an amazing business.

There is no higher margin business than getting Twitter, selling Twitter to Elon Musk and collecting 200 million in fees.

But it's lumpy.

And

the

don't like bipolar businesses.

They like steady businesses.

So the business that's driving the most shareholder value is wealth management because it's just a slow build and people typically keep their money with their investment bank.

So Morgan Stanley, who's also much more dependent on investment banking and MA revenue, also had a shitty quarter.

And then the banks that have huge consumer divisions where they take in money and pay you 3% on a CD and loan it out at 7% on a mortgage, the spreads between what they have to pay savers and what they can charge borrowers has grown enormously.

And so they're killing it.

So again, it's more market dynamics and individual

leadership.

Yeah, although this is the eighth quarter in a row where Goldman reported year-over-year profit decline.

The detour into consumer lending seems to be the cause of some of these problems.

Goldman Sachs announced last week that it was offloading Green Sky, the lending platform which it acquired.

It was trying to go all digital.

I recall him talking about this quite a bit, which it acquired in

2022 for $1.7 billion.

They're offloading it.

Coleman's partnership with Apple, the card, which included the Apple card, which I have in savings account, is likely to be on the chopping block.

I bet there was not an uptake to it.

JP Morgan and Wells Fargo are doing pretty well.

JP Morgan reported a 35% jump in third quarter profits from last year, and Wells Fargo had 61% increase, probably reflecting exactly what you're saying.

What is the problem here?

He's got a lot of controversy around him.

Bill Cohen's written about it quite a bit.

He thinks he's not in trouble so far, what I've been reading, but other people do quite a bit.

There's a lot of

spin around this DJ, Saul.

I don't know if that's the biggest deal, although he kind of looked ridiculous in my opinion.

But, you know, whatever, whatever makes him happy.

Well, look, it sucks to be a grown-up.

And David is the CEO of Goldman, which comes with a lot of wonderful things.

You know, people are wanting him at his conferences.

He makes a shit ton of money.

It's an important position.

Yeah.

The DJing had become a distraction, whether it was warranted, whether it was fair, it had become a distraction.

So he made the right decision.

Yeah.

Let me give you the quote.

Let me give you the quote.

David hasn't publicly DJed an event in well over a year.

Music was not a distraction from David's work.

The media attention became a distraction.

That's kind of bullshit because him doing it is a media.

They're creating a media event, the head of Goldman's sect.

So stop it.

Stop it, PR person.

Well, what I would like to say, and I'm 100%

sincere about this, I don't, I'm not friends with David, but I'm friendly with him.

Yeah, me too.

Well, not like you.

I have a big birthday coming up in not this November, but next November, I'll be 50.

Yeah.

And I have taken over, I have rented out this amazing castle in Scotland called the Fife Arms.

And I am issuing a formal, and this is sincere, invitation to David Solomon to show up as DJ Soul and DJ the weekend.

And here's the key.

Okay.

We will lie and tell his investors and his board that we were playing croquet and hunting stags and doing what all good white people do.

Because the thing that I don't understand about any of this shit is would they rather he be playing golf and drinking Pimp's cups?

Yeah, fair point.

Fair point.

It's like, come on.

It's his time.

It causes attention.

It does.

Well, you're right.

And per my previous comments, when anything you're doing, it sucks to be a grown-up.

Whether it's fair or not, when anything you're doing as CEO is distracting from your mission to create shareholder value and add value back to your stakeholders, then, okay, if all of a sudden everyone was obsessed and joking about his kayaking, then fine, you need to give up kayaking.

Yeah.

So I think they got this right.

What should he do instead?

I don't know him that well.

Whatever makes him happy.

Pickleball.

Pickleball.

Oh, God.

He can play pickleball.

I don't know.

Yeah.

You're having a party.

Are you inviting me to that party?

Let's focus on the party.

You know, Karen, I meant to tell you, we only have room for 100 people and you came in at 1.02.

So I apologize.

If we have cancellations, you're welcome.

But we only had 100 spaces.

Of course, you're going to be there.

I expect you to be there.

I've already RSVP'd yes for you.

Oh, okay.

Good.

You better tell me when it is because I have a busy lady.

No, of course I would come to your party.

I would give a great toast to you.

I would give.

a great toast.

Well,

what's going to return this to other people?

Jamie Dimon's doing great.

You know, I see why Wallace Fargo.

By the way, Solomon was appointed the CE job in 2018.

He took a nearly 30% pay cut in 2022, a result of the firm's performance.

I think he's more in trouble from the other partners who get, who can get a little testy with this kind of stuff.

I think the word is that he fired a lot of people, or people aren't making as much money, and people just don't like the guy internally.

And so there's a lot of people going on background and shitposting him.

But if you look at who matters, and that is the board, really,

they just put an ally of his on the board.

And if you look at the stock performance relative to his peers,

he's done just fine.

I mean, he's the stock,

the, it's pretty simple here.

When you're JP Morgan or Citi or Wells Fargo, who you could argue are or are not, or Bank of Energy, well managed, when you used to take money in and have to pay people 1% and you could loan it out at 2,

okay, and then all of a sudden you can take in money and pay.

pay four and loan it out at six, you double your margins.

Well, you got more.

Well, he did have the Apple card.

He had the Apple card.

I actually think think that stuff,

the way they handled their foreign consumer banking and the way they got out, I would argue that, look, no one likes failure.

We don't embrace failure.

That's bullshit, but we tolerate it.

But they tried to get into consumer banking.

It didn't work.

And they performed what they did that big companies usually don't do is they performed infanticide.

They said, this isn't working.

Let's get out.

Yeah, interesting.

Why didn't it work?

Do you think?

Just not their business.

The honest answer is I don't know why it didn't work.

Yeah.

I don't know.

Yeah.

Interesting.

I bet nobody had an Apple savings account.

I didn't.

It's not something I would, I like my, I use my Apple card every now and then.

I don't use it as much, though.

That's for sure.

I never use the Apple card.

I use Apple Pay four or five times a day.

Exactly.

That's because that's why.

Hello.

That's why.

You know what the most valuable, I'm sorry, the most valuable real estate in the world, hands down, is the real estate in your wallet.

Yeah.

It keeps getting smaller.

And my wallet keeps getting smaller and smaller and smaller.

And now that real estate has almost gone away.

Yeah.

It's like, I use my wallet as much as I go into an office now because everything's on my phone.

I agree.

I agree.

I didn't have my, I left my wallet somewhere the other day.

And I'm like, oh, no problem.

Who cares?

It didn't matter.

Everything was on my phone.

As long as I have my phone.

Yeah, exactly.

My phone would be more problematic.

Anyway, DJ Soul, we're so excited to see you in Scotland.

Where in Scotland is this?

It's about an hour's drive out of Edinburgh.

Yeah.

Oh, good.

Perfect.

I went to a wedding up in Scotland like that.

That was wonderful.

It was really beautiful.

Yeah, it is.

It's one of the most...

Is there going to be kilts?

Are you going to be wearing a kilt?

Mandatory.

Mandatory.

I'm bringing a kilt.

Now we'll have a fitting.

Yeah.

Oh, good.

A fitting.

I'm going to go to Edinburgh and get myself a whole outfit.

That's what I'm going to do.

Because they have stores where you can outfit yourself, you know.

They do.

They do.

I'm going.

I'm getting a little jacket, getting a little hat, the whole thing.

I'm going to get a little dog,

probably a thing of whispers.

A little dog.

That's a little much.

That's a little much.

I'm going to do the whole thing.

Are you going to do that?

I'll bring my dog.

Anyway.

I'm going to care my dogs.

Yeah.

Okay.

And I'm getting a little dog, one of those little ones, those little Scottish-y-looking dogs.

All right.

Scott, let's go on a quick break.

We come back.

We'll talk about X's payment plan going into effect for some users and take a listener mail question about a tech manifesto.

Support for this show comes from Robinhood.

Wouldn't it be great to manage your portfolio on one platform?

With Robinhood, not only can you trade individual stocks and ETFs, you can also seamlessly buy and sell crypto at low costs.

Trade all in one place.

Get started now on Robinhood.

Trading crypto involves significant risk.

Crypto trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Crypto LLC.

Robinhood Crypto is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services.

Crypto held through Robinhood Crypto is not FDIC insured or SIPIC protected.

Investing involves risk, including loss of principal.

Securities trading is offered through an account with Robinhood Financial LLC, member SIPIC, a registered broker dealer.

Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn.

From talking about sports, discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them.

But it's not just person to person, it's the same connection that's needed in business.

And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing, finding the right people, making the right connections.

But instead of spending hours and hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals.

According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys.

You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company role, seniority skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place.

So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads.

LinkedIn will even give you $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself.

Just go to linkedin.com/slash pivot pod.

That's linkedin.com/slash pivot pod.

Terms and conditions apply.

Only on LinkedIn ads.

Scott, we're back with our second big story: the state of affairs at the social platform, formerly known as Twitter.

X announced this week that it had started testing the quote not a bot subscription plan in the Philippines and New Zealand.

Under the plan, new users will pay a dollar a year to post content, like, reply, repost, and bookmark.

Elon sent in a post: it's the only way to fight bots without blocking real users.

This won't stop bots completely, but it'll be a thousand X harder to manipulate the platform.

I honestly would prefer bots to some real users, I'll be honest with you.

So it's finally happening.

X said in a statement that the move is not intended to be a profit driver.

New X users who do not pay the dollar a year fee will only be allowed to read only actions.

I don't know if it's expanding or anything else.

So what do you think?

So

strategically, theoretically, I think this is a good idea.

I think that this should clear out.

I mean, it was similar.

It reminded me of Bill Gates' idea 20 years ago to try and reduce spam.

Remember your email box used to be just incredibly clean, and then all of a sudden it turned into just something you couldn't even wade through the sewage of the spam.

And he said, if you charged everyone one cent to send an email,

his idea was with

Microsoft Mail, whatever it was,

they were going to charge you one cent.

And he said, and we'll give the one center.

We'll give the one cent away.

So I think this is a good idea.

The problem is, is that they have had so many

different

confusing pricing mechanisms and products and new strategies that I don't think people really understand it, see the value in it.

He'll get criticism for it.

So, I don't, it's the right idea.

It's all about the rollout, but I think it is an efficient, elegant way to potentially reduce the number of bots on the platform.

Well, they've thought about it at Twitter for years.

They've thought about doing this exact thing, and there are all kinds of reasons why they didn't.

And Bill Gates never did charge that one cent, by the way.

It never happened.

But,

but, and people have been trying to fix email forever and just sort of gave up on it kind of and just like deal with it.

And they've tried to increase, you know, blocking.

Google's tried very hard, et cetera.

Um, I think it comes down to the fact that nobody wants to give this guy any money.

And even if it's a dollar and giving him your credit card is a, is a little,

I said, I don't know.

I don't think I want to pay for this.

And I, and, and, and it was, I can't really block people I hate.

Um, I get, I can't do comments because people who are commenting are not bots.

They are actual people that are really rude.

And I don't trust him with my credit card.

I got so much response of, I don't trust him with my credit card.

I don't want this guy to have my credit card.

It was really interesting.

That was the response more than anything else.

Let's take a listen to what ex-CEO Linda Yaccarino said when asked about the plan by Julia Borston at Code a few weeks ago, which was her last and perhaps last interview as CEO of X because she's dropped out of a number of them.

Elon Musk just announced a new monthly fee for users.

Yep.

And my question for you is, do you want to start charging all users of X, as he said?

And how many users do you think you will lose as a result?

Can you repeat?

Elon Musk announced you're moving to an entirely subscription-based service.

Nothing free about using X.

Did he say we were moving to it specifically or is thinking about it?

He said that's the plan.

Yeah.

So did he he consult you before he announced that we talk about everything

oh god listening to that again i have a stomachache she didn't answer obviously terrible oh god doesn't it give you a stomachache listening to it um can you repeat yeah no that's what i do this morning

my i'm with my 13 year old and his mother called and started asking me a series of pointed questions like you know did he eat last night yeah and i would say could you repeat

and she doesn't get the joke.

She's like, what do you mean?

Did he have dinner?

I'm like, could you repeat?

Can you repeat?

Can you repeat?

Oh, good God.

Well, she doesn't, it's obviously not dialed into this one.

She hasn't dialed in.

What do they say?

She's not read in.

She's not read into this, or maybe she is now, I guess.

Anyway, we're approaching the one-year mark of his acquisition of Twitter.

A new report shows usage is on the decline, according to data from similar web.

I think this will lead to more decline.

I'll be on, I'm not paying for it.

According to data on similar web, X's global website, traffic was down by 14% year over year.

In September, U.S.

traffic was down by 19%.

That's a big drop.

In July, Yaccarino claimed the usage was at an all-time high.

It's just, I don't know what to say.

Traffic to Elon's profile page was up 96% year over year because he hasn't directed there.

I don't know if you'll see that.

trend continue

because I mean I have to tell you threads is getting better.

It is.

You like it more?

You like it?

I'm enjoying it.

I'm enjoying it.

There was a flood of people after this Israeli Hamas thing.

I bet.

I do miss Twitter.

I miss the rawness and the viscosity of things being thrown at you and

a lot of really wonderful information would bubble up, but it wasn't worth it.

It got to the point where the amount of vitriol and venom and sewage and also just back to the notion of having principles, it's like, okay,

I love what you said.

I'm not going to paint paint this guy's fucking fence.

Yeah.

And I would argue that a very,

you know, for a lot of people in a creative mental health move is to get off of, get off of Twitter.

I have lost some stuff.

I don't get the DOPA hits.

I don't get feedback on everything I do in as granular a way.

I think I, gosh, I get a lot of feedback on threats now.

It's really interesting and it's all helpful.

It's much more positive.

It's much more, or I wouldn't even say positive, constructive.

It's constructive.

What's interesting is like, I'm thinking someone like Ian Bremer, who I read on Twitter, is now putting it over there, the same thing.

And I like it over there.

Like I see him.

I'm seeing a lot of people that I like to see, you know?

And the only thing I'm not doing is the Jim Jordan stuff is faster over on Twitter.

So

that's where I'm going for that.

Right.

And then I go right back over for the regular life.

So in that regard, and fast news stuff, but for the news about

what's going on in Israel, absolutely not Twitter.

It's so full of crap.

And let me talk about that.

Companies like Meta and TikTok have said they're trying to moderate this content.

It's still a mess.

Twitter is impossible.

There was

so much bad information.

It was hard to sort through and find the good stuff.

Eventually I did for say the bombing at the hospital.

Even though Amos has been banned from most social media platforms, their content is still showing up in violent videos and political messages.

The messaging app Telegram seems to be where particularly violent and extreme content is getting posted.

There's little, if any, moderation.

We talked about the EU taking action last week here in the U.S.

U.S.

Senator Michael Bennett is calling on ex-Meta, TikTok and Alphabet to explain what they're doing to

address it.

Some people think you should let it on there and then use community notes.

Some people think you should

take it down.

I think it's almost impossible to do it given the thing.

It's really problematic, I have to say.

This war has shown this very clearly.

Well, a lot is coming to light here.

One,

the flaw in social media about how, again,

it just absolutely turbocharges our worst instincts.

And also, what it's reflecting in our society is that when I was growing up, It just was, America was just incredibly pro-Israel.

And I think a combination of poor policy that's been overzealous from the right wing in Israel, I think a leadership right now that is trying to disassemble their democracy in order to avoid their own corruption charges.

I think an incorrect conflation

of the

struggles that many minority groups have faced in America with the struggles that the Palestinians face.

I don't think the two are equivalent.

I think it's much more nuanced than that.

Has resulted in a dramatic

schism or chasm between how the alumni of universities and older Americans feel about Israel versus younger ones.

And that's just been

thrown in our face.

And also,

you know, the fact, I also don't like the fact that

we're so dependent.

I mean, quite frankly,

I give money to my alma mater's, but I don't like how dependent on universities that are supposed to be,

they're supposed to encourage people to be provocative.

But the leadership there, I kind of agree with the University of Chicago.

We're just neutral.

We don't make these statements.

We support free speech.

I think that's the right advice for Morse corporations.

If you're Microsoft and you have people in Tel Aviv, I think you need to say something.

If you're an organization like Disney that has a really vibrant LGBTQ community driving your business and you get this shit from DeSantis, I think you have to say something.

But for the most part, be careful.

When you start taking political positions to Virtue Signal, then you're going to be expected to have a position on everything.

Yeah, everything.

Yeah.

But in this case, you're not on Twitter, but I have to tell you, it's impossible to get good information about this, except on

Jim Jordan.

There's a couple of reporters who are very good, and that's it.

That's all I look at.

I'm so particular because now I can't, I cannot wade through the crap.

on Twitter.

And I'm not using threads for news really yet.

I could.

I certainly could.

And I've seen, I've, one thing it has delivered to me is stories I didn't know I wanted to read, like all these interesting, sort of what artifact is also doing.

Like, oh, I didn't know about that.

That's interesting.

And I like that.

I find that helpful.

But you're, you know, it's, I just don't think they ever had an intention.

I don't think they, as I said, they want responsibility.

And I don't think they're taking responsibility.

They just are just like, whatever.

And they're trying all kinds of little tools, again, from community notes to actually taking the stuff down.

And none of it's effective because they don't have an intent to make it effective it's going to be very anytime there's a crisis like this that that where all of a sudden people's appetite for news and information grows exponentially i mean i'm just glued to my phone right now i'm just yeah yeah but there's usually a reshuffling of the deck right the first iraq war was where cnn kind of really became super important yeah remember the stud scud or the scud scud stud i imagine there was an event where twitter saw a step change up.

I don't know if it was a great thing.

The Arab Spring.

Was it the Arab Spring?

Oh, yeah, that's absolutely right.

It'll be really interesting to see when the dust settles here

which platform, which, you know, how which platforms accelerated or decelerated and why.

I would say none of them.

But things are getting, the reporting is actually getting better and better from these areas and people are figuring it out, which is great.

I have to say, media, I know you were very critical, but they're figuring it out in a way.

And initially, as always, it sucks.

But they're being much more thoughtful.

And I'm so glad for really good media and all kinds of experts like Ian.

You know who I think has done a great job?

I think CNN's done a great job.

Yeah, I have to agree.

But I do think, and all kinds of experts.

I like Belling Cat.

I like, I thought BBC Verify has been very good.

So, you know, they're getting their act together and they care about it.

But the social media companies don't give a fuck.

So just don't expect any good behavior from them.

Well, it's a shitty business.

I mean, to a certain extent, they're uber capitalists.

They're like, we're not here to cat videos.

The people that go there aren't on a mission to make the world better.

They're in a, they're on a mission to create economic security for themselves.

And I think that's fine.

I get it.

But be clear.

Yeah, cat videos.

Go watch your cat videos.

That's what you need to do.

By the way, there's some very good cat videos on threats.

Okay, Scott, let's pivot to a listener question.

You've got, you've got.

I can't believe I'm going to be a mailman.

You've got mail.

All right.

This question comes from a listener, Tim McGrath, who has some questions about a blog that tech entrepreneur Mark Andreessen put out this week that has a lot of people talking.

I'll just give a quick context.

He likes to put out these things.

One of his most famous ones where he said software is eating the world, which was kind of a good, was actually a very good post.

This is not the same, I would say, but I'll read the question.

Karen Scott would love to hear your thoughts and commentary on Mark Andreessen's Techno Optimus manifesto.

The title starts problematically.

Anyway, obviously, it's self-serving, and I'd love to hear what you think.

I'm a bit offended that he starts off with lies and also sets the tone.

There will be no real introspection in this piece about the role of technology in society or the ways to mitigate its evils.

It reeks of libertarianism and tech bronze, but the real question is: why?

Why does it come out now?

What is spending that precipitated this?

It would be awesome to include an interview with Mark to talk about it.

I'd love to hear how Mark thinks.

I'll start.

He's not speaking to me.

He blocked me.

We used to talk all the time.

he's really turned in a way that he turned before elon turned i'll tell you in a really unpleasant way uh i thought this piece was terrible i thought it was a straw man for everyone who hates ai is is evils essentially so uh i thought it was a terrible terrible piece i think he's doing it because he's not being relevant right now and he wants he's making a bid for relevancy

i don't know scott what do you think i don't know mark andreessen um i've never met him.

I'm not that familiar with his work.

I was trying to find something that he had written and I found it on Twitter and I found out that he had proactively blocked me.

So I think someone managing a social media account has decided that I'm anti-Andreessen Horowitz Witter.

I'm a co-investor with Andreessen in a company,

but I've never met the guy.

I find that this,

I personally find it distasteful and I'm grouping him maybe unfairly into a group of tech entrepreneurs that have a lack of appreciation appreciation for the blessings they got by virtue of being born in America or building their businesses in America.

And I find that they leverage American, almost every major tech company has been built on the back of the greatest venture capitalist in history, and that's the U.S.

government, and middle-class taxpayers who are the limited partners who invested in GPS, technology, or internet, or DARPA, or subsidies for vaccines.

And the moment they have theirs, they decide that they want out,

that they want, they start endorsing this weird form of libertarianism

and i find it just very disappointing that the people who should be the most patriotic oftentimes end up being the least patriotic and a lot of what i've seen from mark feels very um

yeah i think he was the first person to start getting funny that's that's what i noticed let me tell you what i wrote on threads i also put it on twitter typical boneheaded straw man setup that everyone but the fine minds of the tech elite hate the future most of us are both excited and wary wary given the cost so far about tech.

And that is how adults behave.

Literally, these deep wounds, these people suffer in childhood, keep expressing themselves in the most nonsensical of ways, in which they are always the aggrieved victims and deeply misunderstood, even though they are geniuses.

The real story, we completely get you.

I also added that, you know, someone, you don't hear Tim Cook doing this, right?

They just make their stuff.

And when they have a problem, they tell you, et cetera, et cetera.

And they they just literally can't stop talking like this.

They can't stop being aggrieved.

You do not hear this from the adults of tech.

You just don't.

And the idea that

you can think AI is great and at the same time say, oh, there might be some problems is offensive to this guy.

You know, especially when he just had a whole...

little flirtation with crypto that wasn't didn't go very well is particularly galling i find it and then lastly lastly, let me read this one: the thing.

Our enemy is the ivory tower, the know-it-all, credentialed expert worldview, indulging in abstract theories, luxury beliefs, social engineering, disconnected from the real world, delusional, unelected, and unaccountable, playing God with everyone else's life with total insulation from consequences.

Honestly, he's literally talking about himself.

And this look in the mirror, dude.

Look in the mirror.

I read that and I thought, oh my God, he's describing him and all his friends who have gone down this sad highway they're down right now.

And that was, that drove me nuts because they're the ones that are unaccountable and insulated more than anyone.

And the real world, these people, I've seen their world.

They don't live in the real world.

They just don't.

The periods over the last two years that have made me...

I have wonderful relationships with my venture capitalists now.

I've only worked with, I've worked repeatedly with General Catalyst.

They're good people, always trying to do the right thing.

I've had just great relationships in the last 10 years with a small number of venture capitalists.

Where I see some of the, I don't want to call it West Coast, East Coast, but I think when the story on Silicon Valley and venture capital is written, the things the last two years I think are really damaging and will be really damning

in retrospect will be one, I think a lot of them who had financial stakes in cryptocurrency companies were fomenting, catalyzing, and rooting for an implosion amongst regional banks and a decline or potentially even a collapse in our banking system, thinking they could make a lot of money because Bitcoin and their crypto alternative financial vehicles would skyrocket in value.

I also think we're going to find that a lot of these VCs, and I don't know if this is true of Andreessen or anyone else, would invest in quote-unquote a project.

They'd put $10, $20, $50 million into a project, a technology project that ultimately minted a coin that could provide, had underlying technology that would facilitate micropayments on Twitter or something that had absolutely no use case and no adoption whatsoever.

But because XYZ,

famous venture capital firm, was doing it, everyone, they were tapping into what is the ultimate FOMO across middle-class investors.

And they said, well, oh, the cum rocket crypto coin is going to replace the dollar.

And these guys are on CNBC talking about it.

So I'm going to invest in it.

And the shit coin would go from, they invest $30 million at an $80 million valuation.

It goes to $800 million.

And because there's no SEC mandating the disclosure of their sales, I think we're going to find out the next day they sold everything.

The coin goes back to one cent from 50 cents.

And everyone goes, oh, these guys got burned.

No, they didn't.

They made a shit ton of money.

I believe there are a lot of venture capital firms that are nothing but an efficient vehicle or transfer of wealth from middle-class investors to the 0.1% in these firms who leverage their brand, leverage a CNBC that is hungry for carnival barkers, and the FOMO of middle-class investors that want to participate in the next Google or Amazon.

I think these people have lost more money of middle-class investors than they've made.

I would agree.

That's the thing.

That's the thing.

I was sitting in these meetings listening listening to them talk about this.

That's crypto.

I was like, I don't know.

You don't believe in the future.

I was like, fuck you.

You know, let me read you another report thing that's coming out from

Satcha Nadella.

They're talking,

it's their own manifesto, I guess, their annual report.

This is from the CEO of Microsoft.

Now, look, Microsoft has all kinds of issues, but let me hear, let me, let me listen to how an adult speaks about this issue.

As we pursue our opportunity, we're also working to ensure technology helps us solve problems, not create new ones.

To do this, we want to focus on four enduring commitments that are central to our mission, that take on an even greater importance in this new era.

For us, these commitments are more than just words.

They're a guide to help make us decisions across everything we do as we design and develop products, shape businesses and policies, help our customers thrive, build partnerships, and more, always asking ourselves critical questions to ensure our actions are aligned with them.

And then he has a series of stuff that just explains it in pretty plain English.

It's not just virtue signaling here about their commitments and different things like that.

Whether they reach them, I don't know, but he's actually not defensive.

He's not angry.

He understands that there's, you can have two ideas in your head at the same time.

And he doesn't have to create a punch your face, you know, in the nose thing.

And these are the people at the forefront of it, right?

Which is why I'm a little.

feeling a little better.

I don't think this is a virtue signal at all from Sachinadell.

I think he's an adult.

And let me just say, Mark Andreessen is a great mind.

He is.

I've spent a lot of time with him over the years.

He's also totally juvenile in his need to always top people.

And it's really disappointing that someone who has such great, has such a great mind has to stoop to this.

Just like we were talking at the beginning of this with Patty Cosgrove, maybe sit down, fella.

Just sit down.

stop talking for just a minute because what you're saying is almost complete nonsense.

Thank you.

Yeah.

I mean, we'll see.

I don't, I don't, like I said, I don't know the man.

And I think I have a tendency because I had such a bad experience with henter capitalists on the West Coast to stereotype them.

But it is disappointing that people who have been given so much

just want to credit their creativity and their grit and never acknowledge the market or the country.

It's a fatal flaw for them.

I have to say it is.

And it's actually what my book's about.

It's their fatal flaw.

And they don't like people.

I think that's ultimately except themselves.

And they literally have to constantly pat themselves on the back.

Their arms must be exhausted from it.

Anyway, if you've got a question of your own you'd like answered, send it our way.

Go to nymag.com/slash pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PITOT.

And by the way, Mark Andreessen, come on and talk to me.

Come on.

You used to talk all the time.

Are you scared?

Are you fucking scared?

What's the deal?

Give me a break.

I thought you were smarter than me.

You always used to tell me that.

But just please don't be whining.

Please don't whine.

Anyway, that's my invitation, which you will not take because you,

you know, can't take a lesbian like this lesbian.

I'm just trying.

You invited DJ Saul to Scotland.

Let's invite Mark to Scotland.

Mark, come to Scotland and we'll do it from there.

But these people aren't as tough as me.

I mean, I can handle anything here.

I've flown Spirit Air.

Okay, all right.

I can handle anything.

All right.

All right.

You keep talking about, you keep talking about how gay you are.

I'm not gay, but 20 bucks is 20 bucks.

I'm talking about how lesbian.

That's good.

That's good.

The penis joke slips in there, so to speak.

Anyway, let's go on a quick break.

We'll be back for wins and fails.

Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start?

Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to.

Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin?

or what that clunking sound from your dryer is?

With thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro.

You just have to hire one.

You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app.

Download today.

This month on Explain It To Me, we're talking about all things wellness.

We spend nearly $2 trillion on things that are supposed to make us well.

Collagen smoothies and cold plunges, Pilates classes, and fitness trackers.

But what does it actually mean to be well?

Why do we want that so badly?

And is all this money really making us healthier and and happier?

That's this month on Explain It To Me, presented by Pureleaf.

Okay, Scott, let's hear some wins and fails.

I shall go first.

Women in sports, if you're going to believe, I'm going to talk about this.

GM Kim Ng of the Miami Marlins walked away from her job this week after the organization tried to hire someone over her.

This was after one of the team's most successful seasons since 2003.

Meanwhile, over at the WNBA, the Orlando Mercury got a new head coach, Nate Tibbetts.

As sports economist Dave Berry points out on Twitter, the highest paid coach in WNBA history is a white male with no head coaching experience in the WNBA or MNBA.

Oh my God, really?

Come on.

That's all I have to say.

That's my fail.

And then my win is: I would like to pay tribute to Suzanne Summers, who I really loved her on television.

I thought she was great.

Even those three companies, if you watch it right now, now, you really have to be like, oh my God, oh my God, every time they say something.

Still, at the time,

she sort of did this dumb blonde thing.

She wasn't dumb at all.

She created the Thigh Master.

People were jokingly calling her a Thai con, but did a lot of businesses.

Very smart.

People who knew her, I knew a lot of people wrote me when I mentioned it on threads.

Was a lovely person.

Someone said she was a great cook, a great mother, great friend.

I don't think she got her due.

She was, you know, she was a lot more than people in the way they looked at her.

But I really am sad she died of cancer.

Seems like a really good person.

And I really, she gave a lot of, a lot of,

just, it made me happy at least.

She made me happy and she deserves a lot more credit.

Yeah, I mean, I've always thought that whenever anyone accuses me of being a sexist, I'm like, if you knew what I was raised on, specifically iDream of Genie and Three's Company, you would think I'm fucking Alan Alda in terms of where I've come from.

I mean, do you remember how homophobic Three's Company was?

Oh, homophobic, date rapey.

If you go, I went back and looked at one after she died and I'm like, oh my God.

Like even a right-wing people would be like, hey, that's a lot.

Like, you know, like, how can I.

How can I drug someone to have sex with them?

But I agree, it was highly homophobic.

What Scott's talking about is the principal character who was living with two women in

an apartment, and he had to pretend he was gay in order to live there.

I don't know why that was the case, but that was the case because the landlord didn't want to.

Because Don Knotts wouldn't let Mr.

Lee.

No, no, it was Mr.

Roper at the beginning.

Oh, Mr.

Roper.

And then it was Don Knotts.

Norman Fell.

Norman Fell.

Yeah.

So anyway, it was, go watch it again.

You'll be like, oh,

I can't believe I watched this.

Like, anyway, go ahead.

It was nostalgic because these things are markers of time, right?

And you realize, wow, it's the mortality rate is 100%.

And it takes you back to a time, and you miss that time.

And you also probably get a little bit worried about your own mortality.

But so now it's just, it's just Joyce DeWitt.

Joyce DeWitt.

Joyce DeWitt.

Who was always ignored compared to the other two?

Yeah, rest in peace, Suzanne Summers.

My

when

is

President Joe Biden?

When my father is sort of a man's man, and I remember a couple of times, a few times

when

like I remember when we were in the garage once and the car wouldn't start and we were trying to figure out and I kept just like turning it and trying to turn it over.

And my dad just kind of came out to the garage hearing us trying to start the car and like threw up the front, front hood and put on a pair of gloves and looked around, went and grabbed a wrench.

My father was an airplane mechanic on an aircraft carrier for the Royal Navy and just like, didn't even say anything, just like, I got this and fixed the car.

And I thought, wow, dad, like age and experience kind of matter.

And I saw Joe Biden or the President Biden on

Air Force One coming back from the Middle East, answering questions.

And I thought, well, first off, there's just no getting around it.

He looks very old.

And that's a bad thing.

And we talk a lot about it.

I probably talk too much about it.

But I felt like I was watching my dad.

throw up the hood of the car and be like, I got this.

I think he is providing comfort.

And I think he's going to, I think this period of crisis in the Middle East, you just get the feeling these decades of public service, foreign policy, relationship building.

He, in a very equivocal voice, or non-equivocal voice, is like, I got this.

I know what to do here.

And I do think he's providing comfort.

I think

the SS

Gerald Ford carrier strike groups and the second carrier strike group that have shown up.

I don't think people realize how important it is that those are there keeping the peace.

He is the only guy that can,

in my view, he is sort of

providing a lot of comfort.

And it's pretty obvious in this situation that his age is a feature, not a bug.

And I remember seeing him on the plane and thinking, he just looks like a guy who knows how to fix an engine.

And he,

so my win is I did think, wow, this guy, it's actually good to have someone with this level of foreign policy experience.

He did look old, but you know what?

He pulled it off absolutely perfectly.

He flew his old ass over to Israel.

Yeah, 100%.

Conducted the meetings, did a great job.

He got over there.

You know, when someone asked him about Jim Jordan, who must be like a lot of the attention would be on Jordan and the Republicans right now, if not.

And he was like, I ache for him.

It was very funny.

Let me say the best thing he said there was when he said, justice must be done.

But I caution this.

While you feel the rage, don't be consumed by it.

After 9-11, we were enraged in the United States.

While we sought justice and got justice, we also made mistakes.

What an incredibly wise and reasonable thing to say.

He also got the border open to bring in aid, like totally effective.

Like, you know,

a lot of people are like,

he's been there.

He's fixed an engine before.

He got the border open.

That's exactly why he should have been there.

That was the goal of that, I think.

It wasn't to just pat Netanyahu in the back.

You know, he said he was going to be a tough, tough on him.

He was there to get the border open.

He was there to get shit done that needed to be done, that was decent and human at this point, which is what absolutely had to be done.

So I don't care if he's old.

He gets shit done.

You know, gets shit done.

And

I don't even like to imagine.

Trump on his way over there, just making it all about him.

And oh, God, anyways.

You're listening to him.

It's all about him.

This never would have happened if I were running the place.

Yeah.

Anyways,

that's my win: the president seems to know how to fix this car and has been doing it for a long time.

My fail is: I think that leaders don't recognize what it means.

A key component of fiduciary is that if people grant you with a leadership position, you're supposed to represent their interests, not your own.

And I just think it's, I think it's everywhere.

I think,

I mean, going from the profound to the meaningful to the not very meaningful, I think that

Hamas is not interested in advancing.

They want to put civilians in harm's way.

They want to kill, have their own civilians killed as a means of creating empathy and sympathy.

I think Netanyahu is trying to dismantle democracy.

to insulate himself from corruption charges.

These people, there's nothing resembling leadership here.

I think when Patty Cosgrove grandstands in this weird,

his narcissism has overridden his obligation to his employees.

And he is going to cost a lot of people, create a lot of economic harm totally needlessly.

You know, it sucks to be a grown-up.

When you bring together 13,000 people and build a great organization, you may want to lay off Twitter regarding your own political manifesto the the week before, you know, the month before your event.

It's like, how are you serving as a fiduciary and leader?

And we just see this everywhere that people don't want to be fiduciaries.

They don't want to stand back and say, okay, for a moment,

most moments.

It's got to be, it can't be about me.

It's like, and I'll use this.

I remember when I was running L2,

there was a luxury brand that had unpaid interns, including those from Stern.

And I got all angry and upset about it and said, we're going to resign this client because I went and spoke to him and said, you got to actually pay people.

Most kids don't have parents who can put themselves through Chanel

and that all you're doing is deciding only rich kids can come to work for you.

And I said, we're going to resign this client.

And then I called someone on my board and they said, Scott, you're kind of grandstanding.

And unless you do a survey of all your employees and decide that this is more important to them than their economic livelihoods, you know, you need to be a grown-up here.

You need to be a fiduciary for your employees.

And this feels like grandstanding.

And they were right.

And, you know, there's just bigger fish to fry, including ensuring that this company did well and that the employees did well.

And I think there's so much grandstanding, so much

just lack of fiduciary responsibility, lack of responsibility as a fiduciary.

So

a tremendous lack of leadership and an inability to see to be a leader to means be a fiduciary.

And you're representing other people's

interests.

Yeah, that's true.

And you're also representing yourself.

I can't tell you how many times this week I started, I've been tweeting so much less, like by a factor of 100, I'd say.

I have stopped and closed it when I thought about tweeting something.

And I just didn't.

I was like, not my say.

I do do have something to say, but I think I'll just tell a friend, right?

And it was really interesting.

I have stopped myself at least a dozen times this week because I was like, why do I need to say this?

100%.

And the stuff I say, I really care about, right?

The stuff I do, like this Andreessen thing, which again, I think is fucking nonsense.

I know something about it.

I will speak out, but there's some stuff like this congresswoman just retired and she's such a terrible person.

And she was like going on, I was like, she was like blaming everybody.

I was like, you, you know, I wanted to tweet something like you or put on threads,

you know, pot meat kettle.

And I thought, you know, no, she doesn't deserve my time or my attention.

And why am I doing this?

This diminishes me, not her necessarily.

So anyway,

I agree with you.

I think you're 100% right.

I think about it a lot more.

Well, Elizabeth Spears said something,

and I'm going to paraphrase here, but in a column.

Yeah, Yeah, but the opening line was like, I don't have to post about my outrage.

Neither do you.

You know, it's just, we all feel like this obligation.

And these, we live in an environment where these algorithms and these social media platforms have an incentive to convince you that you have an obligation and a right as a DJ.

or a personal trainer to let us know how you feel about the conflict in the middle of the world.

Yes, it's true.

The pushback on that, just so you know, and I really like that column, is,

you know, a white lady has the comfort not to have to speak out, you know, but, you know,

Muslims or people

or Palestinians have to.

And I'm like, you should, you really should.

But it doesn't prevent you.

I think she was talking about a different, like, she does not feel uniquely qualified to.

If it affects you personally, if you have real passion, if you have real domain expertise, then have at it.

I would argue about 99%

of the exhaust we're exposed to online,

people don't check any of those boxes.

They're all looking for affirmation from strangers or feel a need to go on and

it's not even virtue signaling.

It's very strange how these platforms and the reward systems and our inability to to update our need for DOPA from when we were on the savannah has resulted in we've gone from the gutenberg era we've gone into the network economy era where it's no longer reading information in isolation and being thoughtful about it and then communicating with it in more thoughtful mediums to oh i've got to i've got to communicate how i feel on everything

and the more emboldened i am the more strident i am the more coarse i am the more reward I will get from the algorithm and other people.

I think you're spot on.

I think people should speak if it's something they know about or they're passionate about.

I have talked down so many people from ledges this past two weeks, week or so.

Like, all I say is say nothing, say nothing.

You know, I know you can say something.

It's your First Amendment right, but maybe take the First Amendment and put it on the shelf for just a week or something like because it's not going to be good for you.

And that's what I'm thinking about.

An excellent piece of advice, Scott Galloway.

And again, thank you for sharing that about what your web.

I appreciate your advice.

I really wasn't, I really struggled with it.

Yeah, you did.

It wasn't 90-10 for me.

It was more like

70 or 80, 30 or 20, but it's still.

And I don't think it's because you wanted to start around the stage, though.

I do think you like that.

And I do think you like having prawns and liquor in Lisbon, too.

But I do think you cared about the entrepreneurs there, you know,

meeting and greeting and stuff like that.

I think you enjoy that mix.

So

I'm sorry you're not going.

And they, they are, it will be lesser for it.

It will be lesser for it.

Go on.

Okay, Scott, that's the show.

We'll be back on Tuesday with more Pivot.

Can you read us out?

Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman, Zoe Marcus, and Taylor Griffin.

Ernie Intertot engineered this episode.

Thanks also to Drew Burrows, Meal Severo, and Gaddy McBain.

Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts.

Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine of Ox Media.

We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.

My colleague and friend Jonathan Haidt, who was kind enough to call me at at literally 1 a.m.

last night, had something that really struck with me, and that is in this era, we need to be slow to judgment and quick to forgive.

Starting a business can seem like a daunting task, unless you have a partner like Shopify.

They have the tools you need to start and grow your business.

From designing a website to marketing to selling and beyond, Shopify can help with everything you need.

There's a reason millions of companies like Mattel, Heinz, and Allbirds continue to trust and use them.

With Shopify on your side, turn your big business idea into

sign up for your $1 per month trial at shopify.com/slash special offer.