Episode 640: Rodney Alcala: The Dating Game Killer (Part 1)

Hey weirdos, it's Ash. Before we dive into today's twisted tale, let me tell you about the spooky perks of Wondery Plus.
It's like having a skeleton key that unlocks ad-free listening and early access to new episodes. So don't wait, try Wondery Plus today.
You can join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or in Apple Podcasts or Spotify. You're listening to a Morbid Network podcast.
Let Audible expand your life by listening.

Explore over 1 million audiobooks and exclusive Audible. Network Podcast.
finance, investing, and more. Maybe you want to kick a bad habit or start a good one.
Speaking

of, I'm actually listening to The Secret on Audible. I love that title so much.
And 10 out of 10 recommend. The soundscaping is pristine.
Get advice and insight from leading professionals and experts on health, relationship, career, finance, investing, and more. There's so much opportunity to learn and more to imagine when you listen.
Start listening today when you sign up for a free 30-day trial at audible.com slash morbid. When a young woman named Desiree vanishes without a trace, the trail leads to Cat Torres, a charismatic influencer with millions of followers.
But behind the glamorous posts and inspirational quotes, a sinister truth unravels. Binge all episodes of Don't Cross Cat early and ad-free on Wondery+.
Hey, weirdos. I'm Elena.
And I'm Ash. And this is Morbid.
It do be. Sorry, I had to swallow, like, spit before I said that.
Cute. Apologetic I am.
Okay. Okay, Dr.
Seuss. Apologetic I am.
Oh, yeah, yeah. Did you just hear that? I just said yada instead of Yoda.
Oh, gotta go yada baby yada my boy yada my boy yada yada yada yada yada i like that i feel delirious today yeah we didn't get a lot of sleep last night in my house i'm not really sure why like nothing happened that upset anyone to their degree of not being able to sleep just a a restless night. Restless night for everyone.
I hate that. Not for me.
Yeah. It was like mass hysteria in my house.
I don't know what happened. Damn.
I mean, you have kids. That's just like life with children.
That's just every day. I, last night, had a terrifying moment that like nothing became of it.
But it's pretty underwhelming. But I'm trying to, let me'm trying to sleep i'm trying to sleep with the tv off because all my life because science my entire life i have slept with the tv on and it's like not great for you and i do notice a better sleep with it off um so yeah i've been trying to do that but before i went to sleep not last night even the other night i saw this tiktok from the appalach the, and it's, I don't know, like who knows what's real and what's not anymore.
This will do it. This will fucking do it.
Yeah, this will do it. As soon as you said the Appalachian TikTok, I said, uh-oh.
Yeah. Have you ever seen you guys out there? Cause I already talked to Alayna about this.
And I confirmed I have. Have you ever seen those videos where people are like, oh my God, just sitting in my bedroom i see these creatures in my backyard staring at me and it's like these like fucking terrifying almost like dementor but like scarier looking things with like long black hair and like white nightgown sort of or like maybe just like white skin like abyss skin sort of abyss skin abyss skin ayss skin you know i like that just floating and like staring at you like but abyss skin it's just like that but like just staring at you like they're gonna pretty much kill you yeah so i got one of like a couple of those tiktoks and fucking drew it's our it's our cute little thing at night we lay in bed and we scroll tiktok but that was a horrible one to end on.
And then in the middle of the night, I woke up and it was, of course, ready, ready, say it with me, 3 a.m. Oh, 3 a.m.
Sorry. Yeah, that's fine.
I was like pitch black. You're like, we didn't prepare this.
Sorry. Again, I'm tired.
I'm not on point. It was 3 a.m., of course.
And it was pitch black, so you were on the the right thing there and then i just was convinced that there was gonna be those ladies in my room and i got so scared and i woke drew up and i was like give me the clicker i don't blame you on that one now i'm just i was on the treadmill this morning fucking terrified that they were behind me oh man there's like two empty rooms behind me which i don't love when i'm on my treadmill yeah i need to like move it so there's a wall behind me. Yeah.
You don't want empty space. I'm paranoid about Appalachia.
You know, aren't we all? Yeah. I think that's valid.
I think people in Appalachia would tell us we're doing the right thing by being paranoid about it. Let us know.
Because you hear, even if it's like, you know, folklore to me is like folklore to me is like folklore it's very interesting but man it'll get you it'll get you and appalachia is like just lousy with folklore lousy like the whole like if you hear they'll be like if you hear you know a whistle outside you better get inside and it's like and then you'll be like why and they're like can't tell you can't tell you and you're like ah and then they're like that's so much scarier johnny boy here knows why and then you're like johnny boy why and he's like i've been sworn to secrecy he actually just shakes his head because he doesn't even talk anymore yeah that's it his ordeal you're like why don't you talk and he's like i can't talk to tell you. He just shrugs at you.
He zips his mouth and he throws away the key. And here's the thing.
I respect it. I respect it so deeply.
I respect it so hard. But you know where you're not going to find me? Appalachia.
No baby. No baby.
I'm even like freaked out now just that we talked about it. And it's the middle of the day.
Yeah. Anyway, I don't think I'll be sleeping with the TV off anymore.
I mean, you gave. I really tried.
You gave healthy sleeping habits a try and it didn't work out. Oh my God.
Also, just another thing about me. Sorry, I'm really self-serving lately.
Taking it back. You know, whatever.
You know that? Did you talk about that alarm clock on here that we were talking about together or was that a private conversation? I know we had a private conversation about it. We have so many conversations that I'm like, which one was private and which one was on air? It's not private.
It's just she found this really cool alarm clock. Yes.
Can I tell you all about it? Do you mind if I encroach on you? No, I motioned at you. It's your discovery.
So I'm telling you guys, I've been researching sunrise alarm clocks for months and months and months. They just intrigued me, the idea.
The idea is that you are waking up not to like, and like jolting you out of deep sleep. Instead, what sunrise alarm clocks do is they have a warm sunrise effect that happens like a light.
Yeah. And it slowly rises and gets brighter like a sunrise.
And also you can set it to like birds chirping. Which is beautiful.
Or like a bubbling brook or something. You know what I mean? Like something very, just very calm.
Peaceful. And I was intrigued by this idea because it tricks, it basically like makes your circadian rhythm go into like a lighter sleep for a bit.
And it will wake you when out of that lighter sleep so when you wake up you feel more rested because it's a more natural way to wake up exactly and so I was intrigued by it I was reading all this stuff about it and I was like you know what I'm gonna give one a try because I really fucking hate waking up to a jarring alarm and I I was waking up like pissed. So like I immediately like, fuck this.
So I tried it and I got the Philips one. And it was like a Christmas birthday present to myself.
I was like, let's do this. Let's wake up with the goddamn sun.
And so. She's natural.
I'm natural. Guys, it fucking works.
Yeah. And I'm telling you, it is the like most refreshed and calm I have ever woken up in my life.
And I've done it for like almost a week now. It is lovely.
Yeah. You just wake up and you don't know why you're waking up because you don't hear anything.
And then when you do hear something, it's just birds tweeting know what that must be fucking great i wouldn't know yeah i wouldn't know why wouldn't you know i got one yeah and i set it all up last night but my dumb ass didn't realize that i set it up in military time oh i did that too at first how do i change it i can show you how to change it i need you to tell me how to change it because i set it i. I set it.
I don't know why I just said it like that. Leave it in.
I set it and I made it you know 9 p.m because that's the time it was. Yeah.
And then when I woke up at 3 a.m and was like oh god there's an Appalachian woman in my room. It was like 15 o'clock and I was like what? I was so confused.
You're like wait there's an eldritch horror in my world and then you're like it's 15 o'clock what i was like i'm in an alternate universe shit but but at 3 a.m i wasn't gonna i you know i came to after i was like i was, military time. Don't know how to do that.
And I also was like, I'm not fixing this problem at 3 a.m. So I just set my regular stupid alarm on my phone and woke up to like, did it, did it, it was angry.
I can teach you how to take it out of military time. But if you ever need to tell military time, you just subtract two.
So 15 o'clock would be like you take from the five so five three two it's three o'clock oh you know who's told me that's 740 bajillion times drew yeah and every time i come across military time i don't remember that i the only reason i know why to how to use it is when i was taking criminal justice classes they made you do like fake police reports, and they would make you do it in military time. Yeah.
Here's the thing, though. I don't want to do math.
I just want to know what time it is. That was my problem was I looked over and I realized it was military time before I went to bed.
And I was like, oh, I'm not doing math in the middle of the night. So I was like, no, I need to just set that.
I figured out how I'll help you. Yeah.
It's, it's a little bit complicated, but I, you know, I'm looking forward to waking up with the sun. It's worth it.
In my own time. I'm telling you guys, it's very worth it.
It has changed my wake up feelings. I'm excited.
Um, we'll talk, you know, we'll have a private conversation. Yeah.
And maybe we'll forget we had that. Yeah.
We'll get there. We'll have it again.
Um, low key. We can, we can now.
I was putting it off a little bit because we are covering, if you have clicked on this episode, you know that we're covering Rodney Alcala, the dating game killer. Yeah.
I had a very surface knowledge of this case. And when I tell you so surface, it was barely even, I don't know.
I think a lot of people do. Yeah.
Mys yeah so i saw you know that movie and i was like oh cool like that's an interesting case i'd like to cover that so i told dave and dave was like are you sure and i said yeah we should have known then we should have known then it's obviously a case that should be told because these people deserve to have their story told of course it is brutal it is very gruesome uh a lot of these women were unfortunately raped so we're gonna that that's something we're gonna be talking about um so i am gonna break this up i think into three parts yeah um just you know it makes it a little easier to digest and there's a lot parts and there's to cover. Yeah.
So this is going to be part one. Part one, I think, is definitely going to be a little bit shorter than parts two and three.
But it kind of sets the scene. So let's start even somewhat kind of in the middle, I would say.
And a lot of people will know this as the dating game killer case. So that's where we're starting when cheryl bradshaw appeared on the popular game show the dating game in 1978 she was very charmed by bachelor number one rodney alcala and by the end of the episode she had actually chosen to pick him as her date but just minutes after the episode finished taping she actually met met him in person backstage.
And she was immediately uncomfortable.

And actually quickly contacted producers of the show to cancel the date immediately.

This is the craziest part to me.

It was just a gut instinct she had.

And it just, I don't know what happened during that conversation.

But something struck her.

And she went with her gut, which you have to applaud.

Thank goodness she did. She called the contestant coordinator Ellen Metzger, I believe is how you say her name, the day after filming.
And she said, Ellen, I can't go out with this guy. There's weird vibes that are coming off of him.
He's very strange. I'm not comfortable.
Is that going to be a problem? Luckily, Ellen was like, nope, it's not going to be an issue at all. You don't have to do anything you don't want to do.
She said, trust your gut girl that's fine now what cheryl bradshaw didn't know at that time was that in canceling the date she had narrowly avoided spending an evening in the company of one of america's most notorious serial killers at the time of his appearance on the dating game in 1978 rodney alcala was already a convicted sexual predator, which just goes to show you,

you know, what work went into vetting people back then.

Yeah, that's what's so horrifying.

Yeah, he had already served time for sexual assault and also had avoided a charge of attempted

murder on a small technicality and was able to be a contestant on this show.

That's unbelievable.

Luckily, times have changed.

Yeah.

This show is sponsored by BetterHelp.

Every January brings you 365 blank pages just waiting to be filled.

In 2025, maybe you're ready for a plot twist.

I am. Or maybe there's a part of your story that you've been wanting to revise.
There's a part of my story that I can't wait to revise. Life isn't about resolutions that fade by February.
It's about picking up the pen and becoming the author of your own life. And guess what? You can think of therapy as your editorial partner, helping you write new chapters and create the meaningful story that you deserve to live.
I've been working so hard in therapy this year. I love therapy.
I'm a big proponent of therapy. If you listen to this ad ever, you know how much I love therapy.
And I genuinely feel like everybody could benefit from it. And I think BetterHelp is a great place to start.
BetterHelp is fully online, making therapy affordable and convenient, serving over 5 million people worldwide. You can access a diverse network of more than 30,000 credentialed therapists working with a wide range of specialties.
You can easily switch therapists anytime at no extra cost. Guys, write your own story with BetterHelp.
Visit betterhelp.com slash morbid today to get 10% off your first month. That's betterhelp.com slash morbid.
All my parents out there, I know that you never want to sacrifice quality for convenience, but listen, so many baby and kids food options today, they just don't meet the mark. But that is why I really love Little Spoon.
They deliver healthy, ready-to-eat meals and snacks that your baby, toddler, or even your big kid will love and that you can actually feel good about. All their products are junk-free, organic where it counts, and thoughtfully sourced.
Peace of mind every parent deserves, and easier mealtime without sacrificing on quality. They have an amazing variety of baby blends, biteables, plates, and so much more.
Elena gets a little spoon for her girls, and I am always out here stealing their little snacks because they are that good. And she's always talking about how good she feels serving them meals that are actually good for them.
And did I mention it all comes right to your door? So flexible, so easy, and everything stores right in the fridge and freezer. You pick the menu and change up what you order every time.
The price is right. The quality is unmatched.
Elena loves it. Her kids love it.

The grandparents even love it.

A huge win-win-win for our family, and it can be for yours. Simplify your kiddo's mealtime with 30% off your first order.
Go to littlespoon.com slash morbid30 and enter our code morbid30 at checkout to get 30% off your first Little Spoon order. After his arrest, though, investigators would learn that by the time he did appear on the game show, he was also a killer.
He had killed many women at that point. In the year that followed, Alcala would go on to murder several other women until he was finally caught and luckily, I'll tell you right at the top, convicted for his crimes.
Thank goodness. Ultimately, he was found guilty of eight murders and various other crimes, but he is suspected of many other murders.
Some people believe as many as a hundred or possibly even more. Jesus.
Yeah. He is vicious.
Luckily, he's dead. Thank goodness.
Sometimes you got to give you that right at the top. Rest in distress.
Rest in distress, you absolute piece of shit. Yep.
So let's dead. Thank goodness.
Sometimes you got to give you that right at the top. Yeah, you got to.
Rest in distress.

Rest in distress, you absolute piece of shit.

Yep.

So let's go back to his, you know, roots, I guess.

Yeah.

Even though we don't want to.

Rodrigo Rodney Alcala Bucor, I believe is how you say his last name.

He was born August 23rd, 1943 in San Antonio, Texas.

He was one of four children born to Ana Maria Gutierrez and Raul Alcala Bucour. By all accounts, the family enjoyed a pretty normal middle class life in San Antonio.
All of the Alcala children attended Catholic school. And Rodney did really well in school.
He worked really hard. He maintained really great grades.
like no warning signs really. None of Rodney's teachers would ever remember him being a problem student.
Actually, on the contrary, they said that he was considered respectful and kind. And they all said that he was among the most intelligent children in the class.
Wow. Crazy.
Now in 1951, Rodney's grandmother did sadly become terminally ill, and she wanted to return to Mexico to live out her final years. So the family packed up everything they owned, and they moved across the border.
Despite the obvious differences, you know, in culture and everything, it seems like life in Mexico was pretty happy for the Alcala family, at least for the first few years. In 1954, when Rodney was just 11, his grandmother, who he had always been really close to, ended up passing away.
And of course, that left a giant hole in the family structure. Yeah, of course.
Her passing was then soon followed by the very abrupt departure of Rodney's father, who just left the family one day and decided to return to the US. Oh.
Like he left them with absolutely nothing. He was the provider of the family.
What the hell? Left them with like nowhere to live, left Anna Maria to figure it all out, and all of those kids were just left without a father. Wow.
And Rodney was 11. Holy shit.
What is interesting though is that obviously I'm sure these experiences were disruptive to him to some degree and especially all the kids but for some reason he seemed pretty unaffected by both of these things his grandmother dying and his father just leaving the family and that's like a little concerning in and of itself yeah definitely you want somebody to be like traumatized by these things no but you want like wholly unaffected is like interesting. Yeah, I feel like you would be concerned.
Yeah. But it was also a very different time.
Yeah. So it kind of went without notice.
After graduating from high school in 1960, Rodney followed his older brother's footsteps and he decided to join the U.S. Army.
So he relocated to boot camp in North Carolina, where he trained as a paratrooper and also took on additional clerical work. In 1962, while he was training in North Carolina, North Carolina, I think that's what happened.
And then I was like, don't do that. While he was training there, his father actually passed away unexpectedly.
Even though, you know, Raul just abandoned the entire family almost 10 years earlier at that point, his passing obviously affected his family pretty deeply. But just like with his grandmother's passing years earlier, Rodney seemed pretty unfazed.
Yeah, something's off. Something's definitely off.
About a year after his father's death is when he really started to exhibit actually unusual behavior. Like, obviously, that's pretty unusual, but it definitely picked up steam.
Throughout his life, he had always been respectful. He followed rules and expectations that had been set for him.
But that all changed one evening in 1963. His mom was at her home in LA making dinner, and Rodney just showed up unexpectedly at her door, which was very strange because he had to have hitchhiked more than 3,000 miles from North Carolina whoa yeah uh which you know was strange in and of itself yeah but even more uncharacteristic was the fact that he just up and left the military base with no permission so he was technically AWOL yeah I was gonna say that's bad thing.
Yeah. So Anna Maria was able to convince her son to turn himself in at the nearest recruitment station.
And there he was evaluated by an army psychiatrist, who at that point determined that Rodney was actually in acute psychological distress and had him admitted to the nearest hospital for psychiatric treatment. Oh, boy.
But this seemed to have come out of nowhere. Yeah.
Initially, he was treated just at a regular hospital in San Francisco, but he was soon transferred to a military facility just outside of Irvine, California. And he was admitted for more long-term inpatient treatment at that point.
Okay. Now, the triggering event for all of this, like essentially his breakdown, remains unclear.

But even at that time, there were allegations of sexual misconduct on his part.

So I don't know if he did something.

And I don't know that he necessarily would have regretted it.

Yeah.

Maybe it was just overwhelming to have done something awful for the first time.

Who knows?

But after months of treatment, it became clear that he would no longer be able to keep up with his responsibilities in the military. So in February of 1964, he was given a medical discharge.
And at that point, a diagnosis of antisocial personality disorder listed as chronic slash severe. Wow.
So this is like well-documented. Super well- well documented.
The crazy thing about this case is that there are so many things that are well documented, but he just flies under the radar. And ends up on the dating game.
Ends up on the dating game, is able to get off of things on like a weird technicality, just. Very strange.
Yeah, it's very odd. After being released from the hospital, though,

he returned to his mother's house in Los Angeles,

and he just started taking courses at California State University.

Like, nothing ever happened.

Okay, pal.

Given his past success in school and his IQ,

which was reported to be around 140,

which is actually right about where the genius category starts.

Huh.

So he was exceedingly intelligent.

Yeah, I mean, it sounds like he hasn't had any trouble in that area. No, not at all.
He had no trouble with his coursework, and after that he transferred to UCLA, where he ended up graduating with a bachelor's degree in 1968. Now free of academic obligations, he embarked on the next phase of his life, where he had a lot more free time.
I think that's where things went really wrong. In between being released from the hospital and getting his degree, though, Rodney did attack one of his first documented victims, Morgan Rowan.
Fortunately, she was able to escape him not once, but twice. Yes.
In 1965, she was hanging out in the parking lot of a teen nightclub with some friends, and that's when she first saw Rodney. Nothing seemed off about him in that moment.
In fact, she actually thought he was pretty attractive, thought he was charismatic. So sorry, how old was he around this time? I think he's like early 20s, probably 22 at this point.
And he's in a teen nightclub. Yeah, he's outside of a teen nightclub.
Very Rodney. Just a grown-ass man outside a teen nightclub.
Nothing nefarious about that. Yep, I'm not worried at all at this point.
No. Just kidding, I'm very worried.
So worried you should be. So he and Morgan kept making eye contact, and eventually they're two, it seems like maybe he was with a group and she was with a group, and then they kind of like became one group.
Yeah. And they all started chatting.
Eventually, the two of them split off from this big group and they made their way into an alley near the club. Okay.
Everything very quickly turned once Rodney got Morgan away from this group. He immediately got very rough with her.
Ew. He hit her head against the wall.
Oh. Immediately knocking her unconscious.
Luckily, before anything could escalate any further, she did come to to and was able to scream which then alerted the owner of the nightclub and his wife who came running out to help her but in the shuffle of all that he was able to run away like get out of dodge before anybody even saw him what a piece of shit yeah so fucking crazy she morgan runs into rodney again three years later in the summer of 1968 at this point. I hate this.
This was during her going away party. She and her family were actually going to be moving from California to New York.
So, her friends decided to take her out for one last celebration altogether on the Sunset Strip. There was a big group of people, and while they were out, Rodney happened to join the group by by chance because he's living around that area and morgan said she immediately felt creeped out she was very nervous she and her friend sat in a car waiting to head wherever they were going next rodney ended up slipping in behind the wheel and was like oh all right i'll give you guys a ride to wherever you're going next nope i don't know if it was like a situation where maybe somebody was drinking so he was designated but he hopped behind the wheel and he was like oh why don't we all head to my house like i've got some weed we can all smoke together and of course every nobody else knows what happened so they're like yeah sure sounds good and it's the time period remember it's the time period it's like these are like kind of like hippie people you know everybody's laid back everybody's laid back exactly it was california dude yeah hollywood so once there with everybody smoking and kind of distracted he took the opportunity to get morgan alone and ended up bringing her into his bedroom it sounds like forcibly and i'm just gonna kind of do an overview of this just because the details of a lot of this is very intense like in most of these cases so i'm just kind of gonna give like an overview yeah he did physically and sexually assault her and actually pulled a knife on her during the attack her friends at a certain point probably heard something and also realized that she was gone for too long so they started pounding on rodney's closed and locked door to try to help her.
But it actually took one of her friends breaking Rodney's bedroom window and entering that way for Morgan to escape a second time. Oh my god.
So she escaped him twice. And it was like she had to go through a lot to escape him.
Yeah, she was assaulted in a big way. Like awful.
He's very, very aggressive. He's super aggressive.
Oh, that's awful. Now, she didn't end up reporting this attack because her family was leaving for New York the next day.
She was overall just too scared. And like we were saying, these are kind of like hippie people.
She was saying she didn't feel like she was going to be believed. I was going to say, and they'd probably just be like, well, you went to the house, like especially in that time.
I mean, they would do that now, but back then even more so, they'd be like, well, you went to the house and you were smoking weed and you were and like you know i mean it would all be hurtful it would be very much you put yourself in this situation what do you want us to do she didn't and even like you should never that should never be the case no don't be but sadly she she was terrified after this she said she slept in bed with her parents after this she was horrified once they moved to new york and then she later learned you know a lot of different crimes that he committed and carried a lot of guilt for not reporting him yeah which it's like girl that is not on you he is the monster no now this next attack is on a young girl who's eight years old so again it's it's brutal and and I'm just going to give you an overview of it. Thank you.
So just three weeks later, a little past 8 a.m. on the morning of September 25th, 1968, eight-year-old Tali Shapiro left her family's temporary home at the Chateau Marmont and just started making her way to school.
She's eight. Eight years old, like a tiny babe.

Unbeknownst to her parents,

since they moved to the hotel a few months earlier,

Tali had been getting up early and actually walking to her elementary school instead of taking the bus like she was supposed to. It was probably just a fun adventure for her.
She obviously didn't know any better. And different time.
Very different time. you sign up for something you forget about it after the trial period ends and then you're charged month after month after month after month my god the subscriptions are there but you're not using them in fact i just learned that 85 of people have at least one paid subscription going unused each month i probably probably had about 472, but thanks to Rocket Money, now I can see all my subscriptions in one place and cancel the ones that I'm not using anymore, and now I'm saving more money.
Rocket Money is a personal finance app that helps you find and cancel your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending, and helps lower your bills so that you can grow with your savings. Rocket Money will even try to negotiate to lower your bills for you.
They'll automatically scan your bills and find opportunities to save, and then you can ask them to negotiate for you, and they'll deal with customer service so you don't have to. I hate talking on the phone, but apparently people at Rocket Money don't because they call the people for you, and they negotiate to lower your bills, and I love them for that.
Rocket Money has over 5 million users and has saved a total of $500

million, whoa, in canceled subscriptions, saving members up to $740 a year when using all of the

app's premium features. Cancel your unwanted subscriptions and reach your financial goals

faster with Rocket Money. Go to rocketmoney.com slash morbid today.
That's rocketmoney.com slash morbid. Rocketmoney.com slash morbid.
Everyone has that friend who seems kind of perfect. For Patty, that friend was Desiree.
Until one day, I texted her and she was not getting the text. So I went to Instagram.
She has no Instagram anymore. And Facebook, no Facebook anymore.
Desiree was gone. And there was one person who knew the answer.
I am a spiritual person, a magical person, a witch. A gorgeous Brazilian influencer called Cat Torres, but who was hiding a secret.
From Wondery, based on my smash hit podcast from Brazil, comes a new series, Don't Cross

Cat, about a search that led me to a mystery in a Texas suburb.

I'm calling to check on the two missing Brazilian girls.

Maybe get some undercover crew there.

The family are freaking out.

They are lost.

I'm Chico Felitti.

You can listen to Don't Cross Cat on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. As she walked to school that morning, though, a car pulled up beside her and she heard the driver say, come on in, I'll give you a ride to school.
No. But her parents had advised her many, many times that she was not supposed to talk to strangers.
They instilled that in her so she declined the offer and was like i'm not supposed to talk to you like leave me alone but rodney because it's rodney told her i'm not a stranger i know your parents oh my god fuck this guy yeah obviously he did not know tolly's parents but he had seen her and her parents at the chateau marmont because he had also been living there recently. I hate this so much.
To convince her even more to come with him, he was like, you know what? I actually have a beautiful photo to show you. Like it won't take any time at all.
No. In 1968, Los Angeles and California in general had yet to undergo the very dark transformation brought about by the Manson family murders.
So while she knew she wasn't supposed to talk to strangers, Tali Shapiro didn't really get why she wasn't supposed to. The man in the car seemed nice enough and he knew her parents and even lived in the same hotel as they did.
Plus he said he had a beautiful picture to show her and she's eight years old. Yeah of course like she's a baby.
She's a literal baby. I that's a baby.
Yeah, so she didn't see anything wrong with getting in his car and going back to his apartment with him and then getting on her way to school. She was already early, remember, because she woke up early to walk.
As he was sitting at a red light across the street, hero of the fucking century Good Samaritan, Donald Haynes, watched the curious exchange between this man in the car and the little girl on the sidewalk and even though he couldn't hear what was being said he didn't know what the relationship was between them something about this this whole scene just made him very uncomfortable he said it was something about the way the girl tried to keep walking and the way the car seemed to follow along slowly trying to keep her attention oh that makes me upset it caught his. It caught his eye, and he was just like, I don't know, something's real off about this.
But his focus was broken when the light turned green, and the car behind him honked, which, of course, he has to go forward. But as he started to drive away, he watched as the little girl got into the car.
And later, he would describe feeling in that moment as a kind of sixth sense or he said going off one's rocker.

Whatever the case, this feeling prompted him to turn his car around and look for the man in that car to see where he was going. Oh, this is an amazing man.
Like truly good Samaritan of the century. We need more people like him.
It's like what we were saying last episode. Yes.
See something. Say something.
See something. He did something.
Yeah.

So it took him a few minutes, but he soon spotted the vehicle again and actually started following Alcala, Alcala's car a few paces behind and trailed him all the way back to the parking lot at Chateau Marmont. From his vehicle, he watched as Alcala and Tali got out of the car and started walking towards one of the apartments with the little girl following just a few steps behind.
Meanwhile, her parents live in the Chateau Marmont right now. Yes, she is living there.
He's bringing her back to where she lives. Yes.
So that's why she's like, there's nothing wrong with this. He knows my parents.
He's a neighbor. And obviously the fact that they both lived in the same place added to the fact that she was or added to the, you know of i know your parents yeah of course so not wanting to wait any longer and fully aware that he could be very wrong about what he thought was happening haynes was like i don't care he drove to a nearby payphone and called the police what a badass truly he told the dispatcher you might think i'm a little screwy but i just witnessed something that doesn't look right i think a man just lured a little girl into his car and now he and the look he and the girl went into his apartment together and they sent a cruiser good which is actually pretty that's for that time period because nobody believed anybody back then but thank that's actually shocking it is so minutes later a police cruiser pulled up alongside the payphone and haynes pointed out the apartment that the man had walked into.
And the officer, Chris Camacho, I believe it is, thanked Haynes, walked over to the apartment door and knocked on the door hard and fast. Again, I'm not going to go into all the details here.
They're available elsewhere if you want them. But when the officer was able to make his way in, it was a horrible horrible scene he ultimately found tallie laying in a large pool of blood coming from her head it was clear that she had been sexually assaulted and there was a metal bar across her throat that was effectively suffocating her oh my god he is a fucking monster he's a monster she's eight she is a babe i can't oh i can't even like my so officer camacho grabbed a towel from the kitchen counter so as not to disturb any of the evidence and carefully lifted the bar off of her throat and then checked for a pulse she was pale she was badly injured but tolly was still alive holy shit in the meantime the occupant asshole piece of shit garbage human

motherfucker of the apartment had slipped out of the bedroom window and camacho didn't want to leave tolly alone so he ended up just staying in the apartment and waiting for the ambulance while officers and detectives then spread across the entire neighborhood looking for this creep oh tolly remained in a coma for over a month at a nearby hospital. Holy shit.
But after months of rehabilitation, she was able to return to school and actually lived a pretty normal life. I am so glad to hear that.
Yeah. When she recovered from all of her physical injuries, the Shapiro family actually moved to Puerto Vallarta, Mexico, hoping that a new environment would help her healing process.
And the last thing she remembered was entering the apartment. But she said everything that happened after that was and always would be a blank.
Oh, she doesn't remember. I am so glad.
I hope that never comes back to her. Never, ever, ever.
I hope she never, that never resurfaces. Ever.
When we say he's a monster, he's worse. Oh, he's worse than that.
I have no words. I mean, she's one of his, what we believe to be one of his first victims but it's like that's where you start your criminal

activities what a disgusting piece of shit like a pig he's awful i can't i can't even linger on it too long years later though morgan and tally connected over their shared experiences through letters and they actually even appeared on the show i survived a serial killer oh shit i think in either 2021 or 2022 oh wow yeah and uh Morgan said she like felt this like like protectiveness over Tali and that's what connected them and uh she even said like she was sorry to Tali that she didn't report what happened to her she was like if I had done that maybe it wouldn't have happened to you but Tali was like no it's not you's not you. It's him that did this.
Yeah. They became friends.

Oh, I love that.

I know.

I'm so glad something good came out of that.

I know.

I wanted to tell you guys that.

Because I'm like, oh.

Because, again, it's going to get rough.

Yeah.

So we've got to have those little glimmers there.

Los Angeles police detective Steve Hodel, whose name you might recognize.

I sure do.

He's George Hodel, one of the prime suspects in the Black Dahlia's case's son.

He was assigned to this case and immediately set out learning everything he could about the suspect, Rodney Alcala. Because remember, they know his name.
This is his apartment. He's renting this apartment.
That's blowing my mind. Yeah.
Like, that's blowing my mind. Like, how this went any further.
It was like 8.30 in the morning, too. And this girl's just, it's a weekday.
This girl's on her way to school. On her way to school.
Like you would never expect something that horrible to happen right then. On her way to school.
Mm-hmm. Like Jesus.
Now to his surprise, no one at Chateau Marmont seemed to know anything about Alcala personally, but they all described him as a quiet person and not a troublemaker. I wouldn't go that far.
Yeah, I know. That impression was echoed by his former classmates and professors at UCLA when Steve Hodel talked to them.
One faculty member told Hodel that Alcala, quote, wouldn't harm a fly. Again, I wouldn't go that far.
It's like, yeah, we have evidence that he did hurt much more than a fly, an eight-year-old little girl. Yeah um sexually assaulted an eight-year-old so do you want to you want to suck that one back into your mouth essentially tried to kill her so i hate that shit yeah i do hate that shit don't say that don't say that when you just heard that this man might be a child rapist don't say he wouldn't hurt a fly exactly because that's not true we can only hope that whoever said that didn't know what he was well that of.
Well, that's, I know it's like the impression of somebody.

Like I, how many times you hear about something happening and you hear the people be like,

holy shit, I never would have expected that.

But it's like, just, you know, be careful of the words that come out of your mouth during those times.

Agreed.

More important than what his peers and neighbors thought of him, though, was the fact that none of them had seen him recently.

In fact, Hodel could have searched all over California and he never would have found rodney alcala because by then rodney alcala was thousands of miles away as steve hodell was making the rounds of the ucla campus to learn about his suspect rodney alcala now calling himself john berger walked into the admissions office at new york university and applied for a spot in the undergraduate film program at the School of Fine Arts. Wow.
What a weird next move. You know what I think I'll do? I think I'll take a film class after, you know, terrorizing people in California and a small child.
So that sounds good. Yeah.
Yeah. Despite the highly competitive nature of the program, actually at the time time one of the instructors was the then acclaimed roman polanski and the fact that the semester had already started alcala was admitted wow like he's a charmer wow he's a charmer yeah that just goes to show you that right there that's a competitive school at the time roman polanski was like a very...
Prominent name. Prominent name, exactly.
And they're like, yeah, you can take this class. Wow.
What? Damn. Once again, though, he impressed his professors, his peers, who found him to be charismatic, like I just said, and a highly motivated student.
He's like John Wayne Gacy. Yes.
Like, you know, he's got that kind of like... He can turn it on, but when it's off, it's all the way off.
He's got that smarmy charm. Smarmy charm.
Yep. Admissions chairperson Arlie Mock said of Alcala, there was a quiet determinism that seemed to pervade everything he did.
Outside of class, it appeared that he was similarly successful. He dated casually.
Oh. Can you fucking imagine? Can you imagine looking back? Absolutely not.
Because you'd have no way of knowing. No, you'd never know.
That's the thing. Again, he's so charismatic.
I mean, somebody just said he wouldn't hurt a fly. He obviously is not showcasing his aggression outside of these things.
I mean, again, going back to the beginning of the episode, he was the bachelor who won the dating game, won the date. The amount of women who must be like, holy shit.
Yeah. I can't even imagine imagine he made friends with fellow students he was working on group projects with people wow he even managed to make some money as a commercial photographer at that time in every sense he seemed an ordinary but particularly driven student and nobody suspected there was anything dark about him at all that's so scary it.
It's horrifying. That is so scary.
Yeah. On the evening of June 12th, 1971, on the other side of Manhattan, though, Friends had been trying unsuccessfully to reach Cornelia Michelle Crilly all afternoon.
23-year-old, she went by Michael Crilly, as she was known to Friends, had recently moved out of her parents' home in Bayside, Queens, and found her own apartment in an Upper East Side neighborhood that is sometimes called, and it's a quote, girl ghetto or Mecca for maidens. It was very affordable at the time, and young people were all moving over there.
Okay. It's kind of like if you're from Boston, like the Brookline, Somerville area.
Yeah, that makes sense. Crilly had spent that spring at the Transworld Airlines campus in Kansas, training to be a flight attendant.
And she had just come back to New York. She was super excited to start her career.
So excited to have an apartment of her own was just setting out in the world. According to her boyfriend, Leon Bornstein, Michael was funny, vivacious, had a jaunt in her step and she had a real joie de vivre.
She was also gorgeous, he said.

The night before, he was trying to get a hold of Michael by the phone,

and after several unsuccessful attempts, he finally went over to her apartment and tried the door, but it was locked.

So concerned for her safety, he called the police,

and an officer was able to access the apartment through a window just off the fire escape. Hey, weirdos.
I'm Lindsey Graham from the podcast American History Tellers. And if you're still reeling from Ash and Elena's episode on the Boston molasses disaster and you want to dive even deeper, you're in luck.
My show doesn't usually venture too far into the spooky or creepy, but we've dedicated two full episodes to uncovering fascinating details about this bizarre molasses catastrophe. From the company's negligence to the victim's harrowing stories, we explore how this strange event reshaped industrial safety laws and left an indelible mark on Boston's history.
And the Boston Molasses Disaster is just one of many fascinating stories waiting for you on American History Tellers. We take you to the events, the times, and the people that shaped our nation and show you how our history affected them, their families, and affects you today.
Follow American History Tellers on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. Wondery Plus subscribers can listen to both American History Tellers and Morbid early and ad-free.
Start your free trial in the Wondery app, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify today. Curley was still in the process of moving in, so the apartment was pretty much empty.
But in the bedroom, lying on the floor, they found Michael Curley curly's partially clothed body a stocking tied tightly around her neck to the investigators her apartment had all the hallmarks of a targeted murder nothing was missing there was a small amount of cash and other valuables right in plain sight there was no sign of a break-in and no sign of a struggle elsewhere in the apartment and it was obvious that she had been the victim of a violent sexual assault this is very brutal i just want to give you a heads up her shirt had been stuffed into her mouth and there was saliva and bite marks on both of her breasts there were also signs of serious trauma to the rest of her body and it was very clear that she had been raped i can't imagine what she went through no one of the officers asked the and this is horrible one of the officers asked leon her boyfriend to come into the bedroom to identify her which is fucking insane that is beyond like we were talking i for the blackout ripper i forget the time period but it was way it was it was during World War II, wasn't it? Yeah. It was like during the 1930s, 40s.
It was literally, and they were being sensitive to make sure family members didn't see these scenes. They did everything they could and made sure that nobody saw the scenes.
These officers pulled him in and was like, can you tell us, is this her? What the fuck? Wild. Who would ever bring, especially like their boyfriend or significant other, any loved one of any kind, to see them in that position? Yeah.
That will ruin you for the rest of your life. I don't know how you ever recover from seeing someone you love in that position i would never recover you don't you even take great i don't that doesn't make any fucking sense to me because i've done plenty of viewings when i worked at the morgue we went to great lengths to make sure there was nothing upsetting about like nothing beyond seeing your loved one of course dead but like we would go to great lengths to make sure there was nothing seen that was beyond what they were already going to see exactly so like i just can't like my brain doesn't wrap around that sometimes especially back then the nypd is very similar to the lapd i was gonna say that you just sit here like question mark question that's a that's a state of dumb that I I didn't know people existed you have to assume that that was like a and you have to almost hope even that that was a rookie who was just real fucking dumb in that moment you I mean lose your fucking job at that point like you've just ruined someone for the rest of their lives.
Years later, he said it was a terrible scene.

Michael's mouth was wide open because rigor mortis had set in and the killer had put something in her mouth to prevent her from screaming. I couldn't even tell it was Michael.
She was so disfigured. Yeah, I can't.
The fact that they had that guy do that is so messed up. So messed up.
Wow. but detectives learned from leon that earlier that day michael had been looking for somebody who could help her move two heavy beds and other furniture up to her apartment and since some of the furniture appeared to have been moved in by the time she was killed they theorized that whoever helped her move was probably the same person who killed her but leon rejected that theory he said michael would have had to have recognized him or known him before she would have let anybody inside.

But the coroner took swabs of the saliva and a bite mark impression.

But otherwise, the body was absent of any other physical evidence that could help identify their killer.

Meanwhile, executives at TWA authorized a $5,000 reward for any information leading to an arrest.

And a few days later, the Professional Airlines Stewardess uh upped that reward by a thousand dollars wow and despite the offer of of the reward though the case quickly went cold wow a few days later michael curley's funeral was held in queens and was attended by nearly 1500 people holy this girl was so beloved wow after the murder of michael curley rodney alcala needed to get out of the city obviously so in early july he applied for a position as an arts camp counselor at a children's summer camp in new hampshire no no what the fuck stop what the fuck but he was using an alias he was using the name johnger, so they wouldn't have known any better. But at the same time, investigators in California still had not given up the search for Tally Shapiro's attacker.
And by then, Alcala had actually been added to the FBI's list of most wanted fugitives. And here he is just on the East Coast.
Yep. His face and description appearing on wanted posters in federal buildings pretty much everywhere in the u.s wow now and this is crazy the amount of times he just like just by chance somebody sees something in these cases there's it's wild in august two girls from the camp they walked a short distance to the post office just to mail some letters back home it was meant to be a pretty quick trip actually but by the time they reached the post office it started to rain heavily so they were like let's just wait inside until the rain lets up because we don't want to get soaked on the way back to camp yeah so they just wandered around the post office it was a pretty small building they were looking at the governmental notices on the wall and eventually their eyes settled on the bulletin board of all the wanted criminals and one of the faces looked very familiar.
According to the notice the man's name was Rodney Alcala and he was wanted for assault of a child in California but he looked remarkably similar to their very popular camp counselor John. Oh my god.
Yeah. Can you imagine? No.
I cannot. To be a parent and to later learn that Rodney Alcala your child's camp counselor i'd never let my kids do anything again never i feel like you're actually we actually live in the house and we never leave yeah we actually have um like a bomb shelter a bunker we're gonna live there sound good never leaving bye so the girls dismissed the notice as merely a coincidence after all john berger saidger said he'd come from New York where he'd lived his entire life.

And he definitely didn't seem like somebody who would hurt a child.

He was good to them at that camp.

But still, the resemblance was uncanny.

So when they got back to camp, they did mention the poster to the camp director.

Good.

Who was like, you know what?

I'm going to go check that out just to be sure.

Because I actually give a shit about the safety of children.

I love that.

At the post office, the camp director stared at the wanted poster for several minutes just sat there in awe reading and rereading the information on rodney alcala none of the details matched what he had been told about john berger but he simply could not ignore the fact that that man in the photo was pretty much identical to the counselor he'd hired just one month earlier and he has a very like um he's got a distinct face yeah it's not like he's i'm trying to think of like how to describe it because it's not like he's like you know uh like somebody that you're like oh like how could you ever like you know even like they look like everybody else he's just got something he's got very, it's very like cheekbones. He's very reminiscent of Richard Ramirez.
He is very reminiscent. Or he has like very like pronounced cheekbones.
He's got like, you know, his eyes are like a certain way. So I understand because like a lot of guys around that time, like same haircut, same kind of thing going on.
Yeah. So you'd be like yeah i don't know it kind of so the fact that they are so so sure like this has got to be that you know he's got to have some something something about him i think it's his eyes there's something in it they're dead they and they're scary they're yeah like there's something evil in those eyes it feels like something is like brimming in those eyes and i think it's because a lot of the pictures obviously you see are after his arrest so he just let his facade go completely but you can also see how somebody would be like oh that guy's harmless you see him on the dating game have you ever seen the clips i actually i can't even watch them the clips are horrifying i've seen a couple but because you get why people are didn't think twice about him.
Again, he is super charismatic. He's very much like in the vein of Ted Bundy that way.
I was literally just thinking that. And I think it's the intelligence level.
They know, and they study other people, and they see what makes people tick when they talk to others. And what makes people a people.
They literally just try to kind of duplicate and imitate what they see. And it works because they're highly intelligent.
So the director asked the woman at the counter in the post office if he could use the phone after standing there for several minutes, just going back and forth in his head. He was like, I got to report this just in case.
Good for him. So he dialed the number on the poster and he was immediately connected with the regional branch of the FBI.
Oh, shit. Can you imagine just a camp counselor from fucking New Hampshire? And he's just like, oh, hey.
He's like, hi, I'm terrified. Yeah, hi.
The agent on the phone took all the details that the director could remember about John off the top of his head. You know, John Berger, the camp counselor.
Yeah. And then instructed the man to return to the camp and act as normal as he could he was like you just have to go back to the camp and act like nothing is wrong but he emphasized do not leave him alone with any of the young female campers or any female campers at all oh shit make sure act as normal as you can but you gotta make sure he's not alone with would be, hearing that...
How do you act normal after knowing that he is possibly wanted in California for the assault of a child? But thank goodness this guy went this far, because I'm glad people intervened here. Yeah, it's wild.
It seems like this is a case that's very different from a lot of cases we see. That's the thing, exactly.
Now, he didn't have to keep up the facade too long because the next morning, a group of FBI agents arrived at the camp and took Alcala into custody without incident. Oh, wow.
After comparing his fingerprints with those on file, they knew that they had the right person and they called Steve Hodel in Los Angeles, who immediately booked a flight to Boston so he could personally bring Alcala back to California to stand trial. He was like, fuck this guy.
I'm bringing you in. Hodel arrived at the local police precinct early on the morning of August 12th, where he was introduced to Alcala.
And as they waited for the extradition paperwork to be completed, Hodel asked Alcala, why? Why did you attack a little child? And in response, Alcala looked expressionless at Hodel and said, I don't want to talk about rod alcala and what he did oh please that's it please and that is where we're going to end for part one god yeah uh we're gonna talk about you know his arrest a conviction and his eventual release in part two so get ready for that um and then so part there's gonna be a little break between part one and part two because we have you know listener tales which you'll need as a little palate cleanser you are gonna need that yeah so part two will be coming out next monday we'll do a little listener tales video in between then so definitely tune in for that it will be kind of like a pre-palate cleanser i guess yeah also kind of a post and again you'll you have a lot more after that coming so yeah yeah so uh stay tuned we hope you keep listening and we hope you keep it weird but not so weird as any of this and guys i know i don't have to tell you that no certainly not yeah Do keep it as weird as all these good Samaritans

that were actually called people.

Keep it that fucking weird.

Keep it real weird like that.

Alright, bye.

Bye.

Bye. Thank you.
If you like Morbid, you can listen early and ad-free right now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts. Prime members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music.
Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey at wondery.com slash survey. Hey, weirdos.
I'm Mike Corey. And like you, I'm drawn to true crime, creepy history, and all things spooky.
If you particularly enjoyed Ash and Elena's coverage of the USS Indianapolis, where 900 sailors battled rough seas, sharks, dehydration, and madness in the open ocean, you need to check out my podcast, Against the Odds. We dive deep into this survival story across four full episodes, revealing details you haven't heard yet.
Each week on Against the Odds, we put you in the shoes of real survivors, from the Thai cave rescue to Somali pirate hostages to the Donner Party. These aren't just headlines.
They're incredible stories of human endurance.

Follow Against the Odds on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts.

Wondery Plus subscribers can listen to both Against the Odds and Morbid early and ad-free.