Don’t Give All Your Money to Banks and Wonder Why You’re Broke

Live from the headquarters of Ramsey Solutions, it's the Ramsey Show, where we help people Build build wealth do work that they love and create actual amazing relationships rachel cruz number one best-selling author host of the rachel cruz show and smart money happy hour co-host my daughter is my co-host today open phones at 888-825-5225. Cody is in Boston.
Hey, Cody, what's up? Hi, Mr. Ramsey and Mrs.
Cruz. Thanks for having me on.
Sure. I hope the cruise went well.
It did. It was fabulous.
Great. It was good.
We missed you. Hopefully next year.
So I have a question. I'm planning on proposing to my girlfriend here coming up soon.
But back in November, she told me that her father had transferred all of her parents' investments to her so that her sister could get a larger financial aid package. I basically said to not tell me anything more because I think this might be fraud.
She said her dad talked to someone and he said it was all fine. And then a month ago, I went to ask for hand to her parents.
They said yes, but her dad kind of led me into saying that I would be willing to sign a prenup and he doesn't know that I know about the asset transfer. Then last weekend, I brought up the situation saying that I wasn't comfortable combining finances

and signing marriage papers with these assets and putting my name under them.

Again, she tells me their dad said it's above board, but I felt like it was maybe fraud.

I told her that if she went to a lawyer and basically had him call me and said it was a call above board, I'd be fine with it. But I just kind of wanted to get your opinion on this.
Is it fraud or am I just kind of being paranoid about this? I'm not sure if I can make the judgment on whether it's criminal fraud or not, it's definitely morally wrong. Yeah.

Okay. um i'm not sure if i can make the judgment on whether it's criminal fraud or not um it's definitely morally wrong yeah okay the pell grants that they qualify for by posing to be poor people are for poor people right and these people are not poor people correct so i don't know i don't know if it's above board quote unquote or not but it's morally wrong it's like saying um i'm gonna i'm gonna not have act like i don't have a job well now that would be fraud if i have a job and i collect welfare checks uh saying i don't have a job that'd be fraud uh but it'd be like um i'm not gonna um i have the ability to work and make a lot of money but i I refuse to because that way I qualify for free government, whatever.

Right?

Same kind of thing.

Yeah.

And it's just it's morally wrong at a minimum.

It is approaching the criminal side.

And the bigger problem, let's change the word.

It's ethically horrendous.

Correct.

It's ethically ridiculously bad. This guy has no ethics.
Yes. It's ethically ridiculously bad.

This guy has no ethics. Mm-hmm.
Okay. He's willing to lie to the government to get poor people's student assistance.
Right. Pell grants are income and asset-based.
and that's the only thing that quality that's the only thing that in a possible financial aid package

that would come up is the Pell Grant. Okay, nothing else, unless the college had an income-based scholarship program or something, but most of them don't.
So, but yeah, it's ethically wrong. That's what you're saying.
And that's why you got this. That's why you got slime on you and you want to take a shower after you met with him.
Yes. Yeah.
So no, um, full stop. Yeah.
Have her transfer it back. Full stop.
Yeah. Just, yeah.
I'm not going to participate in this. We are going to have a standalone life that does not involve something that I feel like is unethical.
Yes. Yeah, it's really been weighing on me.
So I really appreciate that. Prenup doesn't cover it.
You can't prenup away a lack of ethics. Yeah.
And what's frustrating is she... Yeah, I appreciate that.
Yeah, and what's frustrating, Cody, is she's, you know, in a sense, possibly the one that's going to be punished in the middle of all of this. Cause Cody, you're going to say, no, I can't like, I'm not, I'm not signing a prenup.
I'm not doing this. I can't combine finances right now.
Like this is a sticky situation. I don't feel comfortable attaching my name to all of this.
And so she either has to choose to be between her dad and I mean, yeah, to be a grown up and to say, okay, I have to now think beyond what my dad says is okay and actually start you know having this like problem solving on my own with my future husband with my future husband and deciding that which is going to be a you know a break that's going to be a hard thing for her to do but if she does it then that kudos to her right of like okay this would be a you can be gentle and you can be kind you don't have to accuse him of being a liar like i am or being unethical you can just say you can put it all back on you and just say look i don't feel right about this and i'm not and i can't go forward participating i'm so sorry don't don't don't call her dad names doesn't do any good it's not going to change him okay he's never going to he's never going to say oh wow no my daughter's boyfriend told me i was wrong so now i think i'm wrong the chances of that are zero okay so i mean you know so really it's it's it's your relationship with her that's on the line. I mean, if you guys happen to work through it.

You just say, look, you know, I'm making this up real time. I'm spitballing here, okay? But you could just say something like, you know, I got some counsel because I was confused about this and it bothered me.
Okay? And so take all of the weight of the problem on you and and um and and just say i just can't go forward with this and the count but and here's what i would couch it in all of my understanding of your daughter and i setting up a household is that we are to leave and cleave we We're to leave our parent, our mother and father, and establish our own standalone household. And this does not allow us to do that.
Yes, sir. And I have to be able to do that to have a high quality relationship with your daughter.
And so you guys have got to take these assets back. Prenup doesn't do it.
And I can't, I can't go forward. If we can't have a standalone household, the intertwining of these two households is not, is not healthy.
And I think even before that conversation though, he needs, he, he and her need to be on the same page to even go forward with it. Because if she's like, no, no, I, this is what we're going to do.
My dad says, you know, he would sign a prenup. Sorry, this is it.
And she doesn't budge. And if she says, you're making a call here.
But, dude, let's say she says that and you go, okay, I'm going to cave. I'll sign everything.
We're going to get married. What's the probability you're married 10 years later? Almost zero.
Yeah. So, I i mean from a single argument that then brings up everything no it's not a single argument this is an argument over integrity it's okay to lie to get a program that i don't qualify for what else is she going to be lying about because she thinks it's okay to lie because her dad taught her this? Right.
So, I mean, that's not cool. Yeah, she needs to realize what's going on.
And if she doesn't realize it, that's the hard conversation. And you can't just cave because that condones the whole stupid thing and makes it look like it's okay.
And then extrapolates into other stuff. And 10 years later, you've got an explosion on your hands.
Yeah, it's more of a...

Man, I'm sorry.

That's so painful.

A revelation of character than anything else.

It's so painful.

That's hard.

I mean, if your parents robbed banks for a living

and you think it's okay,

maybe we shouldn't get married.

It's kind of where it lands.

Although that is a criminal act,

this is not a criminal act.

I get it.

I'm being melodramatic.

But still, that's the deal. This is not a criminal act.
I get it. I'm being melodramatic, but still that's the deal.
This is the Ramsey show. Hey, technology has changed a lot in the last 30 years.
Now the hot topic is AI. And I understand that it might seem intimidating, but if you use AI the right way, it's just another tool to help you work smarter and faster like a calculator or a cordless drill.
So if you run a business, you'd better get on board with it before you get left behind. And NetSuite by Oracle offers AI-powered tools that help small businesses improve efficiency and make smarter decisions by bringing all their major business processes into one platform.
That way there's one source of truth for the real-time data you need to take advantage of opportunities. Then you can forecast better, scale more efficiently, and streamline those manual tasks that take too long.
So join the more than 41,000 businesses, including Ramsey Solutions, that rely on NetSuite to help tackle some of their biggest challenges. And right now, you can download the CFO's guide to AI and machine learning at netsuite.com slash Ramsey.
That's free at netsuite.com slash Ramsey. The break, I was talking to some people in the lobby from Phoenix, Dr.
John Deloney, and I'll be in Phoenix on May the 5th doing the money and relationships tour. We're going to be talking about raising great kids, handling money fights the right way, making real friends in the 21st century.
We're going to six cities and it's a weird format. We've never done this before.
We're going to put up about 20 different subjects in an app when you're sitting in the audience before the show starts. You're going to vote on some Dave subjects, some John subjects, and some Dave and John subjects, and that's going to form the format for the night.

You're going to build the talks.

You're going to build the order of the talk, or not the order,

but you're going to select what you want us to talk about.

It's pretty cool, so pretty interactive.

That's a cool thing.

Louisville, Kentucky is just a couple weeks away, April 21st.

Durham, North Carolina, that's on Monday.

On Wednesday is April 23rd is Durham.

Friday is Atlanta, April 25th. A couple weeks after after that we'll be in phoenix on may 5 for that's a monday fort worth on wednesday may 7 in kansas city on may 9 ramsey solutions.com slash tour or if you're on youtube or podcast click the link in the show notes and you'll get your tickets you don't want to miss this guys it's gonna be a lot of fun and I will have a lot of fun.
The only thing more fun than John and me is Rachel and John. Money and marriage.
Yeah, money and marriage stuff is absolutely fun and hilarious and all that stuff. John, speaking of John, is in San Francisco.
Hi, John. How are you? Hey, I'm doing well.
Thanks so much for taking my call. Sure.
What's up? Yeah. Look, I've just been listening for the last few weeks.
Just a recent listener here, and I really appreciate all the advice you've been giving. I'm trying to balance a couple of things.
So I have sort of two questions. One is related to a really expensive mortgage I have.
I bought a house a few years ago, and I discovered soon enough that it was a bit of a lemon.

Since then, I've been sort of spending all of my time repairing this house and trying to get it up to market value in hopes to, oh, I don't know, rent it or sell it or do something with it that could be profitable. and the second thing is that you know a couple years ago

I also met a lovely lady

and she's just some about last year, I moved in with me and it's been a bit of a struggle trying to have enough time for the relationship, manage the finances as I sort of continue to progress with this very expensive mortgage. How much is your mortgage payment? It's $5,300 a month.
And what is your take-home pay, sir? My take-home is about $7,700 a month. Your mortgage payment is $5,000 and your take home is $7,000.
I don't know how you eat. That's about right.
How do you eat? It's been tricky. Are you running up credit card debt? I don't have any consumer debt.
Is there money somewhere else coming in or going out? How in the world?

That's an impossible budget.

It's pretty tight, yeah.

I've had to do a lot of the house repairs myself.

You're cutting in and out.

Talk directly into your phone.

What did you say?

Oh, I have to keep a pretty tight budget.

That's right.

No, you don't have a budget.

This is impossible.

I've done budgets for 35 years.

Thank you. oh uh i have to keep a pretty tight budget that's right no you don't have a budget this is impossible i've done budgets for 35 years your mortgage is 75 of your take-home pay i don't i don't this is i mean that's not sustainable i'm i'm shocked you've done that for more than 12 months and not caved in i i agree with you you need to sell this house yesterday Do you have a lot of savings john are you feeding are you pulling from savings at all yeah yeah so i have about uh 30 in an emergency and about 80 in stocks and how much are you burning through each month of your savings uh i would say you know maybe uh a thousand maybe 1500 yeah okay now we got it where you can eat now i understand how because it's i mean what you were telling me just wasn't so so basically you're burning up your savings because you bought a house you can't afford sell it yep yep yeah um okay yeah so that that's really it is uh should i should i jump chips.
Yes, Okay. Yeah.
So that's really it. Should I jump ship? Should I keep trying to bring up the value? It's killing you.
It's eating you alive. There's nothing in this home ownership package that is fun.
Everything you've described to me screams anxiety. John, you knew this, right? It's in a high a high value neighborhood it's i guess market here hides them in san francisco higher than your income not to see see the scars and and you know the grass is always greener on the other side so to speak but yeah the grass is always greener over the septic tank yeah yeah exactly well um exactly.
Well, yeah. Sell it, John.
I think it's going to relieve a lot of stress. John, John.
I think your relationship will thrive. Your finances will thrive.
A lot will thrive when you're not stressed. I want you to.
Stress to the max about this. I mean, that's hard.
Here's the thing. That's hard.
Not only is the arithmetic absolutely ridiculous in this because you're burning savings. Thank you for saying arithmetic.
You're saying the mathematics of this. You're saying it's, you know, you're burning through your savings.
So that's principle number one. But what I want you to breathe in also is what this is costing you, the stress level you're carrying around all the time.
When you get rid of this house, you're going to feel like you set down 300 pounds that was on your back. And you've kind of gotten accustomed to carrying around 300 pounds, but when you set it down, you're going to go, I can breathe again.
I didn't realize you could breathe like this. My lungs haven't worked like this since I bought this house.
I mean, you're physically going to feel the release when you get rid of this burden. But you've intellectually and willed your way through this.
You're like a bulldog that got a hold of something and won't let go. But once you let go, you're like, oh, I can let go and I'm free and I can breathe again.
No, dude, there's nothing in this equation that's worth it. It's affecting your health long-term.
It's going to destroy your finances. It's affecting your emotional well-being.
Now you said it's affecting your relationships. So this thing, this house owns you.
And you're going to be singing like, thank God I'm free at last. And you don't even know.
Until you set yourself free, you don't even know how awesome it's going to be. This is a horrible thing for you.
It's not good for John. I want John to have a home.
I just don't want the home to have John. And this one owns you, my son.
It owns you. Let it go.
go are you gonna sing a little Elsa for us a little Frozen let it go who's Elsa it's from Frozen oh okay the granddaughters will teach you that okay soon enough soon enough let it go John we need to cue the granddaughters to sing let it go. That's right.
That's right. You know, it's so common for us.
I'm not qualified for that. As Americans, though, to be so wrapped up in our stuff.
And I would put homes in this, cars in this, credit card debt, all of it. That for the sake of a thing, right? And a house in and of itself, it's a thing that we deteriorate so much of our peace

and our mental margin and our stress.

And like, I mean, so much of it for a thing

and it's not worth it, even a house.

And again, home ownership is something

that like we are all about

and we want you to get it

and have that be part of your long-term financial plan.

But to the point that it's completely robbing you of a life and it's eating away at your relationships and your peace, all of it, it's just a thing. It's not worth it.
It's not worth it. So as Dave and Elsa would say, let it go.
The minimalist, yeah. We can just play their tune right now.
They would love this. Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly.
So yes, we do want you to own a home. You said're new to this stuff but it's much much less home than you own right now and which is hard too john because you're in one of the most expensive real estate areas san francisco yeah and the bay area i mean you're in one of the highest priced tokyo new york and silicon valley i mean uh london these are some of the most expensive pieces of real estate in the world.
And that's where you're choosing to live, making $75,000 a year? Well, that's after taxes. Yeah.
So California, he's probably making $140,000, and they're taking half. Yeah, with their taxes.
That's true. Sorry, John.
Sell it. Please.
No, I'm not sorry. I'm happy for you.
Well, I am. I'm going to set you free.
Now, what you thought was a dream's a nightmare i'm gonna set you free from your nightmare this is the ramsey show statistics show that half of americans don't have enough life insurance or they don't have any at all i don't understand this john why don't people want to take their family? They think they're not going to die or something? Well, I used to be one of those guys. I didn't even think about it.
And one of my buddies said, hey, the only reason to not have life insurance is if you hate your wife and kids. And I immediately went and got term life insurance.
That's a gut punch. For decades, Dave, I've sat across people who've lost a spouse.
They've lost somebody important to them. Me too.
They don't know what to do next. You're going to have a crisis here.
You know, you got two options while you're sitting and talking to a young widow. She's concerned about how she's going to invest all this money properly and not mess this up, or she's concerned how she's going to eat tomorrow.
That's exactly right. These are the two options.
It's saying I love you to your family. Term life insurance.
Jeff Zander and the team at Zander Insurance makes it easy and affordable. I've used them personally for 25 years.
They're the only people I trust. Go to Zander.com or call 800-356-4282.
We've all got people we love and things we've worked hard for that we want to protect. So to keep them safe, I've recommended SimpliSafe Home Security for over 10 years now because they're the best.
You see, traditional security systems only start working after somebody's already broken in, which is too late. But SimpliSafe's active guard outdoor protection can help prevent break-ins before they happen.
And SimpliSafe agents can see and speak to potential intruders to help stop trouble before it makes it to your door. SimpliSafe is 24-7 protection for your home inside and out.
And even though SimpliSafe is the best, it's affordable. Monitoring starts at around a dollar a day.
Your first month is free and they offer a 60-day money-back guarantee. Plus,

there are no long-term contracts or cancellation fees. And right now, you get 50% off a SimpliSafe

system with professional monitoring. So head to simplisafedirect.com to save 50%.
That's

simplisafedirect.com. There's no safe like SimpliSafe.
The Ramsey Show question of the day is brought to you by Y-Refi. You've got a defaulted private student loan, and you can't sleep at night because the thing's riding you down.
See, if you're in default on it, you're not making payments, right? And you're never going to get out, and it's a problem. And this is private.
They can go after you. This is not a student loan with the feds.
And so if you've got that, YReFi can get you out. They'll buy the loan and set up a set of payments that you can pay and show you how to get it paid off and get it out of debt.
It's fabulous. Go to yrefi.com slash Ramsey and you can like sleep at night and get rid of this stupid loan.
The letter yrefy.com slash Ramsey might not be in all states. Today's question comes from Craig in Delaware.
My wife and I are looking to buy a new home. We own our current home outright and are looking to continue that debt-free lifestyle.
We've been paying ourselves a mortgage as a saving technique and have saved a lot of money over the years. Our friends have been telling us not to put so much down, liquid cash down for a new home, but rather take out a mortgage and invest a big chunk of that money instead.
We were thinking that living mortgage-free will give us freedom that we enjoy and allow us to invest with the money that we make going forward. Are we making a mistake by doing this? Craig, no, you are not making a mistake.
You are correct. And this has always been an argument of paying off the mortgage or not, because if you do have a great rate, which if you buy a new home, you won't have a 2% or 3% rate like a lot of people do right now.
But they say, we'll invest that and if you make 10% in the market, you'll make an 8%, 7% spread and you'll make more money in the market than having a paid off home. And that's always kind of been the math that we get cursed by, people would say.
But the truth is. They leave out risk.

Yeah, the risk, the peace of mind,

and then also if you turn around and go back

and invest the mortgage payment, like what he's doing,

and you don't have a paid off home over time,

you're still going to build wealth.

So it's the piece that's not in the Excel sheet of what's key.

Let's go to the proof of what really happens.

Number one, if your broke friends are making fun of your financial plan, you're on track. If your fat friends are making fun of your workout plan, you're on track.
Think about it. These are broke people throwing around financial advice.
It's hilarious. The second thing is this.
Ramsey did, our Ramsey research team did the largest study of millionaires ever done on the continent. We found a couple of things that are key to this.
Number one, we found that 89% of America's millionaires are not millionaires because of inherited money. Nine out of 10.
Okay. Now, once we establish that, then we have to establish the question, if you're doing good critical thought, okay, what made them millionaires if it wasn't inherited money? Well, it was their habits and their decisions around things like this discussion.
So then we go to those millionaires and we say, Okay, how many of you became a millionaire by borrowing all you could on your house so that you could invest your cash? Out of 10,167 millionaires that we asked that question, did you become a millionaire using your broke friend's plan? In other words, how many of them said they used your broke friend's plan, and how many of them said they used your plan? The number that used your broke friend's plan of millionaires that became millionaires on their own, that borrowed all they could on their house to invest the money because the spread is there, the number out of 10,167 that did that is precisely zero. None of them.
So what does that tell us? That your broke friends have a theory that is unproven by data. The data of actual millionaires, people that actually build wealth, not have a theory, not drink too many beers and have a discussion about this, but instead actually freaking do it.
The data, the facts are they work your plan. And they got out of debt and stayed out of debt, and they used the increased cash flow with no debt payments going to the stupid bank to increase and create wealth.
Your most powerful wealth building tool is your income. Don't give it to freaking mortgage companies, Lexus motor credit, Toyota motor credit, MasterCard, student loans, and then wonder why you're broke.
That's what it comes down so no you are exactly right Craig do what you're do your plan and just nod and wink and smile at your broke silly friends you're probably not going to fix them but don't take their advice for sure under any circumstances because the data the facts are that it's wrong and so you know Rachel when know, Rachel, when we first started doing this stuff, I started doing this before you were born. I mean, it feels like you were baby when I started on the microphone.
And I've been asked that question for 30 years. And based on, I would say, well, the borrower's slave to the lender and biblically speaking, you know, and the stress and, you know, the freedom.
And, but now I'm starting to understand as i get further into this and and i actually have millions of millionaires that have been created by the baby steps out there in a did and and the ones we studied were not just ones we created that we didn't create them but not the one that weren't dave millionaires they weren't ramsey millionaires uh but some of them were baby steps millionaires Some of them weren't. But, you know, my theory then was that what would happen is that you would have less physical stress,

anxiety-based disease called blood pressure and heart attacks, right, goes away when you're –

I mean, it largely goes away.

And Deloney pulled this up the other day on some of the research that they've done in the mental health world, that you can track the debt increase, the percentage of our incomes going to debt, and track it like a hockey stick on a graph over the years. And with it, you can follow the increase in anxiety medications, the increase in suicides well technology is the increase in other stuff and phones you can find you find fun and again as soon as the iphone hit it spikes again yeah oh yeah yeah that's all through the books yeah the point was there's a real correlation between debt and your physical health yeah that's the bottom line and so and no one considers talks about that.
Oh, by the way, what's the number one cause of divorce in North America? Money fights and money problems. Guess who has money fights that doesn't have a mortgage? Not many.
Not many. Money fights usually come from like we're broke and we can't afford to buy something.
When you have a mortgage, you can just go get the stupid gun. You can go get and you don't have to fight about it matter of fact you can get one of each you know you don't have to fight about it right and so it's it's the you know relationally physically well and i would say yes that and then just the autonomy of owning your life like so much of the financial space someone else has a say in your life i mean and that and that's everything from you know if you have a boss but especially if you're if your actual income that is yours now has 15 other things that it has to go to because of debts like the autonomy of just being able to make your own decisions all the money comes in all the money goes out only the names are are changed to protect the innocent well that's the stuff that yeah is not an excel sheet right like that that level of bandwidth emotionally as well i mean it's huge it is yeah deloney would call it locus of control bloom was on here with his new book about wealth yesterday and he called it agency yes you lose agents yes you lose the power to make your own decisions yeah yeah i am trapped Oh, here's the other one.
Your career, when you don't have that, you make more money. You know why? Because you might put up with crap.
You don't have to live in a toxic situation to make your bills. But you look up and there's an ethics problem or you are not aligned with leadership because leadership's stupid you can go work somewhere else and people make you know when you are not trapped in a job by your debt you can make moves in your career and people that don't have debt make more money oh and guess what people don't have debt are more generous and guess who guess who ends up with more money? Generous people.
Because they're highly attractive people. Givers are more attractive than takers.
Can we agree? Yeah. If you add value to people's lives, you just carry yourself different.
The whole thing. It's a whole picture.
It's not just I can invest the money and make a little more more on a mutual fund. Oh my God, Kermit the Frog, what is wrong with you? This is the Ramsey Show.
Hey, when you're gazelle intense, you sell so much stuff the kids think they're next. But when you've gotten rid of all you can, save money by switching your cell phone plan to boost Mobile.
It's just $25 a month for unlimited talk, text, and data forever. Boost is a major nationwide network that offers reliable 5G service.
And here's my favorite part, transparent pricing. There's no hidden fees, no contracts, and there's a 30-day money-back guarantee, which no risk go to boostmobile.com slash ramsey to switch today that's boostmobile.com slash ramsey we're gonna try something new that we've not done well anytime in the recent memory uh we may never have done it before it's possible so uh you guys don't know if you've done it.
Well, it's possible I've done a lot of things. No, personalities have.
You did it? This is your first. Yes, welcome.
Oh, I've not done it. Welcome to the segment, Dave.
Oh, okay. So this is something that's happened while I wasn't working.
Yes. So anyway.
It's fun, though. People call and leave voicemails, and so let's play one of them.

My name is Jared.

I have been looking into the baby steps, and I know one of the things is to sell everything quickly as you can get yourself out of debt, which I do totally understand. I have about $16,000 saved up, and I also do have debt, and I was wondering,

like, why does it feel better to have that safety net of the 16 then pay off the amount of debt even though I totally understand numbers wise that the debt is costing me more than the savings is keeping me in savings. Thank you.
Appreciate your time. Yeah, that's a good question.
It does feel better to have the $16,000 and have the debt because you have the illusion of security. You have the illusion that you're safe.
And it's an illusion because over a 20-year period of time, you're not safe because you're broke and in debt. But you've got this sense that in the moment, if something happened, because it's true.
If you had a $5,000 car engine blow up and you've only got $1,000, you're not safe. But what you also don't realize is that because you're carrying all this debt, you're not that's right yeah but your emotions because you're a saver jared uh tell you that uh as a saver i'm safer if i have savings then but but if you were looking at the other way and said oh the debt scares me more than the illusion of the savings yeah then you're going to pay it off until then you're going to sit to sit there in that.
So yeah, we always teach to just pay down to $1,000 and start your baby steps. Baby step one's $1,000.
Anything above that that's not retirement goes at your debts in baby step two, listing them smallest to largest and attacking them in that order. Yeah.
And what's interesting is usually with especially savers, so I get this, Jared, on this end, that again, you don't feel the risk of the debt but if something were to happen there's other people coming to knock on your door and that doesn't feel safe either right so like if you're not able to pay these things it's scarier to have your you know your financial piece if you will in other people's hands and in other people's situations and so being free from all of that by being out of debt and then building back the emergency fund actually gives you a level of deeper security. But I don't think people think about that as much.
You know, the difference is you haven't experienced the risk. So like with me, it's a no-brainer because I have been foreclosed on.
I have been sued. I have had people take money out of my account that sued me and won before we went broke, before we filed bankruptcy.
We were in the process of two and a half years of fighting that. We were foreclosed on multiple times.
We were scared several times that they were going to repo our car that night, walk out in the driveway, and it's anybody's guess if it's going to be there. Then you start to go oh wait a minute i don't feel safe right forever for the rest of my life i don't feel safe with that and so that it's an that's what i mean by it's an illusion i've got that benefit of that experience because whatever sense i had that that was okay was completely stripped away by the extreme experience we went through.
Okay, play the next one, James. We had a question about tithing.
Is tithing specifically supposed to be used for the church? Or if we are in a church that is currently declining, is it okay for our tithe to be donated to Christian organizations such as a pro-life organization or something of that sort? I just wanted to kind of find out what you believe is a biblically sound answer to that question. Thank you.
Good question. Well, I studied the Bible through the lens of an evangelical Christian, which means someone who believes the Bible, on instructional things like this, literally.
Evangelicals for the last 500 years have taught and backed it up biblically that the tithe goes to the local church, a tenth of your income. Tithe, the word in Hebrew, means tenth.
Doesn't mean 5%. If you want to give 5%, that's fine.
The tithe is not a salvation issue. You're not going to – God doesn't love tithers more than non-tithers.
Tithers don't automatically get into heaven. That's not what this is.
It's a baseline instruction from your heavenly father that teaches us to give to our faith community 10% of our income first. And the model is the Old Testament storehouse.
And the Old Testament storehouse took care of the widows and the orphans and the Levites. The Levites were the pastors.
And so the preachers get paid well, not overly paid. The minister of music, the children's minister gets paid well,

but not overly paid. They never get overly paid.
And the bills get paid, and we keep the lights on in the house of worship with the first tenth of our income. Anything other than that tenth is an offering, and it can go anywhere.
So it's tithes and offerings. Then I would just say that if you're uncomfortable giving your money to the church because it's in decline, I'm uncomfortable trusting the spiritual welfare of my family.
I'm more worried about that than I am the money. Yeah, but if it's just a sweet church that there's not a lot of givers and they're like, well, we're not going to be able to keep it open.
But they're bible teachers do you mean like there is i don't know there's a part of me that i'm like what if it is a great church and they're just it's not in decline but what if the all the people who know and we don't know where seth lives right i do not i do not know the church but and they so all that to say we've worked with 50 000 churches in america We love churches we love pastors that's not the question but the question usually if there's a decline givers you say your church is too much in decline to give to i worry that it's too much in decline to trust your spiritual health of your family too um that would bother me that's the answer i mean i if i can't trust them with my money i don't need to trust them with my family no so it's not a it's not that they're doing anything immoral but i didn't i wasn't talking about immoral but if you say i can't trust them with my money i'm just saying they're not doing well because maybe they don't have a lot of givers i don't know i always hate making that statement i'll be honest churches here's the thing churches that do well don't have a shortage of givers oh's a strong statement no they don't it's an accurate i'm not i'm not okay we'll argue about it that's fine i don't know i don't know you'll be wrong it's okay and then i'll find the stat and bring it on next time i'm on there this is the father good good luck with that good luck with that rick is in new Orleans. Hey, Rick, welcome to the Ramsey Show.
Hey, how's it going? Better than I deserve. What's up? Yeah, I just had a question on how I should start preparing to possibly take over a business from my boss.
He's going to give it to you or sell it to you? Sell it. Okay.
So how is that going to happen? Currently uh currently with current discussions with them we're looking at a possible owner finance okay all right make it a percentage of net profit a large percentage of net profit until he's paid out in about two or three years don't take a set payment for 20 years that'll get you in trouble that's thing one is, um, then if there's no profit, he doesn't get money until there's profit again and you don't go out of business and he can't sue you. That's my point.
So, um, thing two is then, uh, how long have you been working there? Five years. Okay.
And how many people work there? Um, it's seasonal. So we have, yearly we have six people working there um seasonally we have upwards of 28 okay are you the senior guy uh yes for how long um actually um there's me and one other person in our maintenance department.
Okay, well, you need to be the senior guy immediately. The person that would also be me is not interested.
No, that wasn't what I said. They all need to be reporting to you as step one before the transaction occurs.
he needs to set you in the president's seat while he's the CEO,

and you walk in that, and he shows you every detail of every part of the business that he's running for at least a year, and then the transaction occurs.

Not he tosses your keys and goes, I hope you can figure this out.

That's not a good plan.

All right, Dave, you have some strong opinions. Possibly, yeah.
I think so. Okay, because you really prefer credit unions over big banks.
So why is that? Well, credit unions, for one thing, are non-profit, which means that the members, the customers own the credit union. So any profits that the credit union makes goes back into customer pricing.
So you get better interest rate on savings, cheaper checking, and so on, that kind of thing. But what's more important than that, though, is the fact that the customer is the owner changes the spirit on the credit union.
So I find very few credit unions that aren't very customer centric. Yes.
Well, and I think we have found one that is incredible, and that's Fairwinds. They are an incredible credit union that is really out with the heart to help the customer.
You know, that's why we're partnering with them, because they've got a scope to be able to handle the Ramsey audience, and they're the right kind of people with the right kind of values. And they've done a really, really good job with customer service.
And the deals that they're offering, the Ramsey tribe is incredible. Yeah, absolutely.
And you're right. Their customer service is unbelievable.
Winston and I just signed up and we got an account. And I'm not kidding.
It took less than five minutes. It was so user-friendly.
The step-by-step approach was unbelievable. And then the next day, my phone rings, and it says Fairwinds on my phone.
So I answered it and talked to someone there. And they said, yeah, they give calls to every new customer.
And so, again, they just really care about your experience. And I so, so appreciate that.
So, again, you guys, I know it can be a pain to switch banks or to open up new accounts, but Fairwinds, again, they make it so easy. Plus, anything that you can do at a traditional branch, you can do with them at fairwinds.org or on their app.
And you'll have free access to over 33,000 ATMs. Hey, you guys know how much I hate banks in general.
And so for me to do this is a big deal. Talk to our friends at Fairwinds and check out the combined checking and savings bundle that they created just for the Ramsey tribe.
You guys, it's incredible. Yeah, you guys, it's so easy to join Fairwinds no matter where you live.
So go to fairwinds.org slash Ramsey to learn more. That's F-A-I-R-W-I-N-D-S dot org slash Ramsey.
Live from the headquarters of Ramsey Solutions, it's the Ramsey Show, where we help people build wealth, do work that they love, and create actual amazing relationships. Rachel Cruz, Ramsey personality, number one best-selling author, host of The Rachel Cruz Show, and co-host of Smart Money Happy Hour on the Ramsey Network.
My daughter is my co-host. Thank you for joining us.
888-825-5225. John is in Indianapolis.
Hi, John. Welcome to the show.
Hi, Dave. Hi, Rachel.
Hello, hello. How are you guys today? Better than you deserve.
Don't say it. Better than you deserve.
You're right. You got it, John.
Yes. I'm so glad it's both of you today.
My father approached my wife and I about moving in with him. I'm one of eight siblings, and it's a home that is now, as siblings are growing up, getting more quiet than he's used to.

And I have four kids of my own.

And he's one of these really old guys who was born in 1960.

And he said that he would love for us to inherit his house at some point and be able to fill it up with our kids.

And I don't know the best way of approaching that with my siblings, who are many scattered throughout the country and want to make sure that we do right by everybody there with the value of the home meaning if it goes to you guys correct yeah yeah um is he how's his health he is in good health he just retired last month uh he was a he was a doctor his whole career and has imparted really good financial wisdom on us throughout our lives and so he's just lonely is what it sounds like and he just wants you guys around it's in your in your town yes it is okay that's good um well i mean the obvious thing is it's his house and if he wants to deed it to you in return for you all living there to have him keep him company or whatever we want to call this, that's his choice. Okay? The right way to do that is to make sure that this is all talked about with the brothers and sisters.
Okay. The wrong way to do it is to hide it from somebody, and then they discover later that you own the house that they thought they owned an eighth of at his death, and that would make everybody angry, right? Yes.
So these things sprung on you later is how people get mad at the reading of the will when they discover that the house is

no longer in the estate. Is there any merit if we were to sell our house and just using that equity as essentially a down payment into this house? I'm sorry, I thought he was giving it to you.
Well, that's what I'm trying to figure out.

Would I buy it from him or could I? into this house. I'm sorry.
I thought he was giving it to you. Well, that's what I'm trying

to figure out. How would I buy it from him or could I buy it from him or is he giving it to me or basically eliminate the questions from the siblings is trying to buy it from him that way.
Oh, yeah. I mean, if you pay market value, if you don't pay market value, then.
which I can't pay

I can't pay

market value

for that home

so

then the siblings

are going to have an opinion. Okay.
Agreed? Yes. I mean, because.
Unless they all just. And, you know, if I'm the sibling, I'm going to go, hey, more power to you.
You're taking care of dad. Yes, that's what I was going to say.
Have at it. Do you have good relationship with them? Because they relationship with them because they may say john like thank you thank you john and wife and kids and taking care of dad like yeah i mean if dave called us and was like please come live with us and denise denise was like i'll do it great job denise would be the one yeah rachel's like nah no i'm.
I'm kidding. I would take care of you.
No, seriously, you have to clear it with the siblings, and everybody has to be okay with whatever the deal is. Okay, there's a couple of ways to structure the deal.
One thing you could do is he just deeds you the house now, and you leave him with no protection, and you just own the house. Another thing you could do is he deeds you the house now, and you could give him a life estate, which means as long as he lives, he's allowed to live in that house.
And you can't sell it until he dies unless he signs off on that and releases that, okay? That's the second thing. The downside of him deeding it to you now uh he's only 64 so i mean he could live 30 years this is a long time for you to not ever sell this house or not ever move that would be and we're okay with that i I'm not okay with you being trapped.

Okay.

Okay, because things change.

And sometimes they change tragically.

Sometimes they change from prosperous.

Okay.

Let's pretend that something happened and you at work had a breakthrough and started a business and And all of a sudden you had had a complete change of net worth. And you wanted to build a house twice this size because you had the money.
30 years? That could happen. That's prosperous.
Okay. And, you know, that's why I always laugh when someone says my forever home.
Or your wife's family gets ill and you guys want to be close to them

and you want to move out of state or something.

You know what I mean?

Like anything can happen in 30 years.

Well, God forbid something happened to you or your wife before he dies.

And then you got to, you know, and then you're deciding, okay,

here's a really weird one.

What if you died in a car wreck and she's stuck there?

She said if I died in a car wreck, she's stuck there she said if i died in the car wreck she'd sell our house and move in before before the funeral that's her my father and her get along so well today that way today today that's where you live together but yeah um i i'm sorry i'm serious i don't want you to do something that doesn't have an exit path if you need to get off off the exit ramp, you need a place to get off. I hope you don't.
I hope it plays through the way you want it to play through. But you're not against the idea.
The idea is fine. Give yourself a release valve.
Yes, that's right. That's right.
If the pressure's on, give yourself a release valve and let everyone know what the release valve is and give yourself a way out of this thing. Dad's been in the nursing home with early onset for eight years, and all your kids move to another city, and your grandkids are all now in another city.
You can't sell the house. You're stuck with it.
That's not okay. Life is going to happen.
That's all the people that call this show is life happened to them, over and over and over and over so no you just don't want to get there so what would you do then you would deed it not deed it to john right now i'm trying to what's what's confusing me what i don't know i don't know how to protect dad and protect john and let give john a release valve that's what's bothering me i can't figure out how to do that so you got got to think through that though. If you can get that, if you can solve for that, you're okay.
The last thing you got to solve for is if they deed it to you now, your basis in this house becomes what he paid for it. Versus if you receive it at his death, your basis is market value.
And if you sell it, you got no capital gain or you know, you got no gain. If this house is worth 600,000 bucks you're married filing jointly and his basis is close to zero um and you're married filing jointly can do a 500,000 write-off you now have capital gains on a house because it was deeded to you oh and by the way he needs to work on the unified estate tax credit so you got some estate tax planning to do if he's going to deed you the house now if he's not going to deed you the house now, that might be a way to do it.
Maybe you don't own it. Maybe you just bank your equity and you live there.
And if you needed the exit, you still have no rent because you take care of him. And then if you need to leave, you can leave.
That might be even cleaner. And if he dies, it comes to you.
You're deeded're due to it out of your estate your portion well or the whole thing and the spout the siblings are okay with that

i might be okay with that one that might give that might be a way for you to get out if you

get i just don't want you to get stuck they call here all the time stuck this is a ramsey show

let me tell you the god's gonna cut you it's holy week in jerusalem and the city is restless

This is the first time I was going to be able to get this. Let me tell you the God's gonna cut you down.
It's Holy Week in Jerusalem, and the city is restless. The people of Israel welcome Jesus as King, His followers ready for revolution.
But instead of taking the throne, Jesus turns the tables. Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees! How will you escape being condemned to hell? Experience Holy Week like never before.
What have you done? Now in theaters, The Chosen, Last Supper. Get your tickets now.
If you own a small business and you like The Ramsey Show, then you're going to love the Entree Leadership Podcast. Almost 200,000 listeners tune in every Monday to hear me take calls from real business leaders and give tactical advice based on my 30 years of experience leading.
This is not a podcast about business theory. It's real insight from a practitioner who actually does this stuff.
Find it anywhere you listen to podcasts, or if you're listening on YouTube or podcasts now, just click the link in the description. From the Ramsey Network app, Isaiah steps in it.
You keep saying to invest $100 a month beginning at age 30 and you'll be worth $5 million at 70 years old. That's the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard because the life expectancy of a white male is 72 and for a black male it's 68 that means most people will never leave to live to see five million dollars help me make sense of this advice well you don't really want me to make sense of this advice because you think it's ridiculous so um let's start with your belligerency to start with the um but the answer to your question is, number one, you have all of your numbers wrong.

So it's hard to make a cogent argument when you have your numbers all wrong. We have never said $100 a month from $30 to $70 is $5 million.

It's not.

It's $1,176,000.

And that would be true of 20 to 60 or 25 to 65, any 40-year period of time you wanted to pick. And so you could align that with, okay, start when you get out of high school, saving $100 a month at 18, and at 58, you would have $1 million, not $5 million.
I never said that. $1,176,000.
Also, the average life expectancy of a white male is not 72 years old. I don't know where you're getting your data, but the national vital statistics system at the national center for health sciences says in 2023, the average male death age is 75.8 years, 76 years period.
Uh Average female is 81 years old when they die. Now, that includes infant mortality and teenage death, which we can all agree that most teenagers are not saving and most infants are not saving.
So once you make it to age 65, my age, and you're healthy, well, not even healthy, once you make it to age 65, on average, you will live another 18 years. So the average 65-year-old has a death, all males, 76 years, okay? Add 18 to that, it's going to be 86, 92 years old i'm sitting here at 64 the average is that i make it to 92 once you make it to 65 okay so so all your numbers are wrong to start with isaiah but at the core of your belligerency and claiming our process is ridiculous is the idea that somehow you're supposed to get rich in 10 minutes or that somehow you're entitled to something or that i'm angry because i don't feel like it's possible for me and you even throw the race card in there because color of skin hasn't got anything to do with your ability to build wealth.
Skin pigmentation doesn't cause wealth building one way or another.

It doesn't.

And so, you know, you just got to throw that in there, though, to go ahead and try to create some kind of social justice argument that's bullcrap here.

So the truth is that anyone who saves $100, but by the way, almost no one saves, like I would say really close to zero people save $100 for 40 years a month. Like I haven't saved $100.
I've saved a lot more than that. Rachel hasn't saved $100.
She wants to save a lot more than that. Right.
So just the idea of the investment calculation saying it's an example.'s an example saying if you'll save money you can build wealth that's what the example says but you're like oh well no one can get there because they're all going to be dead it's like oh geez son roll up your sleeves live on less than you make get out of debt deny yourself a little bit of pleasure because you're acting like a four-year-old here and stay out a happy hour and go put some money in the bank quit smoking so much pot seriously and so uh honestly this is ridiculous no i mean the belligerence on this is victim-based okay it's victim-based this is the most ridiculous thing i've ever heard it is not the most ridiculous thing i ever heard. What's ridiculous is your argument because you don't know anything about the numbers that you presented.
They were all wrong. That's what's ridiculous.
So what's ridiculous is you've used some twisted version and inaccurate numbers to justify your victim existence. That's ridiculous.
So you're not a victim of anything but your bad thinking. That's only victimization so the truth is is that the you know 89 of america's millionaires are first generation rich go get you some boy it's your turn roll up your sleeve quit your whining be a victor not a victim and quit trying to figure out some way that if the whole thing stacked against me the little man can't get ahead i grew up with people my whole life saying the little man can't get ahead you're always gonna have a car payment we're stuck these numbers only work for people that aren't like us people that are different than me people that are my race my color my neighborhood my educational background my history of my family people like me can't.
Oh, shut up. Was Eeyore your spirit animal? Come on, man.
That's ridiculous. I'm the little man.
I started with nothing, and I was a millionaire twice. I'm so stupid I had to do it twice.
I got a Ph.D. in DUMB, and I had to do it twice.
So this victimized, and it's just seeping in these words right here. It's just running off this page.
And I'm not going to tell you. It is not, it's hopelessness that you're spreading.
You are a hope stealer when you tell people that they can't make it. And that pisses me off because I spend my life giving people hope.
And you can do this in America right now. It is the best place, the best economy, the best situation in human history for the little man to get ahead.
If at any time you wanted to drop into any society in human history and you wanted to start from nothing and build wealth, this is the place ever any time it's better than 30 years ago it's better than 60 years ago it's better than the roman empire it's better than anywhere you want to drop your little butt and think you can't get ahead little man can't get ahead i promise you freaking carl marx isn't going to help the little man get ahead. He helps the big man get ahead.

That's who gets him ahead.

And so your broke college professor that's teaching you communist technique has got to stop it.

This is crazy, y'all.

So if you want to win, you can go win.

We'll help you.

We'll show you how.

But we are not going to participate in this is the most ridiculous.

It means people will never see their money. They're going to die before they get their money.
Oh, that's just dumb. It's just ignorant.
So hope I wasn't unclear. Nope.
That's why I wrote million. That's why we did.
I was not going to do another book in this space. That's why I did Baby Steps Millionaire.
What's the stat of people that come legally into America,

they end up winning?

Four times more likely.

Four times more likely because they come and they're like,

you know, the generation.

If you come here from another country under the law,

legally, not illegally,

you are four times more likely to become a millionaire

than someone born here who believes crap like this.

Like the deck stacked against the little man. You just can't do it.
You're going to die. You can die before you get your money.
Oh, brother. So, no, do the stuff, man.
Do the stuff. Live on less than you make.
Get out of debt. Get your butt on a budget and act like a grown-up and stop your whining, and you can go almost anything in this country it's going to be hard but it's easier than being broke and mediocre and at the end of the story you get to win this way the other way at the end of the story you just die broke and wondering what you i don't want to work in mcdonald's at retirement unless it's the one i own in st thomas you know seriously you can do this stuff it is and you don't want to work in McDonald's at retirement unless it's the one I own in St.
Thomas. You know, seriously.
You can do this stuff. And you don't have to be – I'm not extraordinary.
I'm far from extraordinary. But I've had extraordinary results following God's ways of handling money, having hope in my life, having a sense of abundance instead of a sense of scarcity.
And going and apply – if you plant corn, the most magical thing happens corn grows and if you plant more corn more corn grows so if you plant a hundred bucks you'll get this if you plant a thousand bucks you'll get 10 times as much and and you know most of you're making so much money 100 bucks you waste driving past some fast food restaurant or starbucks you just drive past they take 100 bucks100 from you, and you haven't even got your food yet. Man, this is so doable, y'all.
It's so doable. And I'm not going.
You can get pissed at me if you want to start another Reddit page on Dave Ramsey. Have at it.
I don't give a crap. Just stack it up there.
You know what? Because you're wrong. The proof is in.

The social proof is out.

Ten million, millions and millions and millions of people are doing this stuff.

And it's not.

So if you're not doing it, you're just wrong.

It's not even harder than that.

You're just wrong.

This is The Ramsey Show.

Hey, you guys. Health insurance costs are only moving one way, and that way isn't down.
And if higher costs aren't enough, the wait times to see your doctor are longer, and it's harder than ever to get anything approved through the bureaucracy. So if you feel like the system is working against you, try a biblically-based alternative to health insurance, Christian Healthcare Ministries.
CHM is a health cost-sharing ministry that's helped hundreds of thousands of families like yours take care of over $11 billion in medical bills since 1981. And CHM has also helped them stay true to their values and avoid miles of red tape.

And CHM support goes far beyond meeting financial needs.

They'll also help meet spiritual needs.

Members become part of a family who will pray with them and for them

when they experience a medical event.

So listen, y'all, there's no better way

to take care of healthcare costs.

CHM programs start as low as $98 a month.

So learn more today and join at chministries.org slash budget. That's chministries.org slash budget.
Hey guys, good news. Pre-sale is on now for my new book, Build a Business You Love.
If you're a business owner, you know running a business is hard. That's why I wrote this book, to share what we learned over the last 30 years so business owners can grow your business faster with fewer mistakes.
Pre-order your copy today and you'll get access to over $350 in bonus items only at RamseySolutions.com slash store. RamseySolutions.com slash store.
Pre-order today. Roberts in Denver.
Hi, Robert. How are you? I'm good.
How are you, Dave and Rachel? Better than we deserve. How can we help today? Thanks for taking my call.
Um, I found you guys in 2020. Um, and after paying off all my debt, I'm now on baby step six.
Um, I've been dating the same woman for four and a half years. Um, she's absolutely amazing.
I love her to death. Um, the one thing we struggle with is money and we pretty much see it kind of opposite.
Um, we're getting to a point in our relationship where, you know, we're heavily discussing marriage and what all that looks like. And we're kind of in a spot where, you know, I try to help her as much as possible and as much as she wants me to, I guess, to set up budgets and stuff like that.
And it just never works out. Um, you know, she, she always goes way over budget or whatever.
And, um, if we were to get married, like she, you know, she would sell her house and move in with me and, and the profits from that would pay off all of her debts. She has about 65,000 in debts.
Um, so, so it's not really like a concern from that aspect it's more just um i guess i'm scared to move forward with someone that i've never seen can stay within a budget um you know and and i'm worried that it's the number one reason people get a divorce i'm worried about becoming a statistic because we fight about money all the time can she not can i ask this robert is she not being able to stay into the in is she not able to stay on budget because the budget's not realistic for what she's set up or is it that she truly spends more than she makes and she's just says that's that's just how it is yeah she just spends more than she makes i mean she she she brings in more money than i do honestly what does she spend it on and what's she doing shopping vacations like what's like yeah yeah so like in in her every dollar you know she's got a food category that's that's supposed to be six hundred dollars last month she spent eleven hundred and then like her shopping you know it's supposed to be i think four hundred dollars and that includes even like unnecessary fun purchases that you know everyone has to have but instead she spent like 900 um you know she wants to she's a mom of two she wants to get a mommy makeover um and so like in her head she's justifying well if i can pay off these two debts that's payments equal what the mommy makeover payments will make then i can can do it. But she's never once made like that extra debt payment to even pay those debts down.
She just, she's more of like a, you know, you got to spend the money that you make to have fun kind of thing than I am. It's interesting to me that you started doing this stuff in 2020 and you've been dating her four and a half years so you started you met her about the same time so she's watched you adopt all of these things correct the more the more you got engaged the more you got engaged with the stuff that we teach, she's watched it.
She's had a front-row seat for the whole thing. So I was debt-free by the time I met her.
I started January 1st as a New Year's resolution, and I met her December 4th. So within that year, I was out of debt.
So she never really saw me aggressively attack debt, but I still live the lifestyle. Like I still budget every month.
I still, you know, so she's seen that lifestyle and where it's gotten me. And she just, she just, she doesn't have like the mental mind.
Like I see things in numbers and statistics. I'm a spreadsheet complete opposite but yeah i don't i'm not asking her to be a nerd i am asking her to quit being immature and just buying stuff she can't afford and uh i just deserve it i just want to get it and so i'm just going to get it i mean she doesn't tell herself no ever the category breaches you talked about the purchase breaches you talked about those are all i just look at it and i'm going to do it anyway like that like she's in there's a sense of entitlement or immaturity or something there that's bothering me in this i can't tell what it is exactly so what would we do in this situation you guys have got to resolve this before you go forward not necessarily she has to become the nerd that you are or she has to stay on a budget, but whatever the core issue is that she's struggling with here, immaturity, entitlement, just because you can't just, she's not acting like an adult in the sense that you can't just spend 900 bucks when you say I'm going to spend 400.
Yeah, that's where I was trying to figure out with that's weird is yeah is she not budgeting correctly because there are some people that are like oh i'm gonna make well then change the budget that's what i'm saying but this sounds like it's above that it's like that she probably she could live within the numbers that she sets correct like she that or that she has to mathematically she makes enough money to pay to do it right she just chooses not to have any boundaries for herself yeah and that's what i'm hearing so what would i do i if i were in your shoes i would say look we have to resolve this and get aligned on it to go forward because it's not gonna we're gonna have you're gonna you're gonna have a long life because you're gonna treat you're gonna think i'm just picking on you all the time and i don't want to be the bad guy in this all the time. And it's a value standpoint.
I'm not going to sign up for the bad guy role. Yeah.
And it's not, again, we've said it twice in the call, but I think this is important for couples to hear. You're not trying to form her into you, right? No.
Because I'm the free spirit. As you're speaking, I'm like, oh my gosh, that would so be me if I wasn't doing the Ramsey plan.
I am. I'm just a spender.
Emotions. I'm like, yep, we're going to have fun.
We're going to enjoy. But having to learn a value system of boundaries, a value system of living below your means, a value system that stuff is not going to make me happy.
There's a contentment issue there as well. Like all of these things are values where I still month to month spend more than Winston, my husband, because I am more of a spender than he is, but it's in the budget.
So from again, that winston doesn't spend any money he doesn't spend a lot but it's like the idea is again it's the values that we agree upon not the personality trait necessarily but if we can't have boundaries and limits to our money and we keep going over and over and over and over that's a problem then there's an issue there you know and even with debt i would say debt's a value system that if you are if you are uncomfortable with living with debt, that it gives you stress, the risk of it, it's not worth it. I want the autonomy.
And she's completely okay with it. And it's totally fine to live by my means.
And I'll live on credit cards and just try to pay the minimum balance every month or the minimum payment. Then again, there's a value system there that will be really excruciating to walk along life with.
And this is your partner, right? When you get into a marriage, this is the person that you're going to make all these decisions with, and that should be fun, and it should be enjoyable. This is someone that you don't want to constantly be picking apart and adding stress to the relationship, and that's what these big issues, money is one of them, but you could throw in in-laws you could throw in parenting i mean right there's all these other issues but with money specifically yeah like you would tell the kids no and she won't you know that that's yeah that causes yeah that ruffles feathers that's how that's going to translate so here's what i would do i would schedule a pre-marriage counseling session and i would sit down with a counselor and tell the counselor on the phone before you meet with them uh with her present that the account the pre-marriage counseling session will have failed if you can't help us get aligned on these subjects your job as a pre-marriage counseling is you have to give the counselor instructions, okay? I am not moving forward in this marriage unless we can get aligned on these things.
And so your job is to guide us through that. If you think your job is to make me okay with her being off the rails one way and me being off the rails the other way, I'm not going to be okay with that, that you failed as as a counselor because sometimes counselors will do that you get it's all okay because they don't think they don't see it the way that we're so you need to give the counselor will dig in and understand a good one yeah but you know the root of it because so much of of who we are in our existence the good the bad the ugly comes out on how we handle money and so there's there's things in there right and i would say for extreme family of origin yeah and extreme savers right there's a level of hoarding and control issues that come from people that are some people call this show and they're so anal and you're just like oh my god chill you're okay but they're they're so wound up on that side and that's unhealthy but then being on the other far side where she is that's unhealthy and so so tell me get into that place give the counselor some instructions and the instructions are you are to help us get aligned if you can't help us get aligned then we're either going to call it or you failed in your counseling you we are not leaving your office with you saying oh it's okay that's not an okay thing for the counselor to think because sometimes pre-marriage counseling is a bit of a rubber stamp and you don't want that's what i want you i want them digging in on this i want you to dig onto this and y'all find out what's what's driving these things and that way you don't turn ramsey into a cuss word in your new household this is the ramsey show are you sick and tired of being sick and tired you can take control of your money and your relationships, and it starts with just one night.
Join me and Dr. John Deloney live in a city near you on the Money and Relationships Tour.
We're covering the real-life stuff that matters so you can break the cycles that have left you stuck. It's coming up fast, so get your tickets for Louisville, Durham, Atlanta, Phoenix, Fort Worth, or Kansas City at RamseySolutions.com slash tour today.
If you're a business owner, you know running a small business is hard. If you've ever become self-employed like I have, you figure out pretty quickly that your boss is tough.
Your boss is a slave driver. And yeah, self-employed is tough.
It's hard. Running your own deal is hard.
We've got a new book called Build a Business You Love, where we unpack the entree leadership system. It doesn't make running a business easy, but it makes it easier because it's a clear path to walk through the five stages of business.
It's like the baby steps for small business. Not money, but how to grow your business, how to deal with team members differently as you go through the five stages, how to deal with profit differently as you go through the five stages, and so on.
If you pre-order right now for $29.99, you can get over $350 in bonus items, instant access to the Entree Leadership Hiring Playbook, the e-book, and the enhanced audio book. Pre-order today at RamseySolutions.com slash store, or if you're on YouTube or podcast, click the link in the description.
Seth is in Virginia Beach. Hi, Seth.
How are you? Hey, Dave and Rachel. How are you all? Better than we deserve.
What's up? All right so I'm uh 27 years old and I'm married with three kids and me and my wife have been on baby steps four five and six for the past few years and I'm currently in the military and we live in military housing so we're renting we're trying to figure out the best way to kind of save for a down payment on a house since we move every three years we're not we're not trying to jump on buying a house right away, but if the opportunity presents itself, then we would like to maybe be in a place where we can do so. So over the past few years, we've saved about $25,000.
Good for you. Yeah.
So also while saving for retirement and kids college. Which branch are you in the Navy? I'm in the Marine Corps.
Marine Corps. Thank you for your service.
All right, very cool. Yeah, thank you.
And your question was what now? So we're trying to figure out the best coach to saving up for a down payment on a house. My wife's taking some time off work to stay home with the kids, with the birth of our kids, but she's a nurse, and she's going to be starting a job here in the fall as a school nurse.
And we were thinking, like, potentially going back to babysat 3B and just pausing retirement in kids' college to just back up cash for a year. We were still going to know if that would maybe be the right move with, you know, still trying to invest steadily for retirement.
That's fine. the first thing popped into my head was i'm under the impression a school nurse does not make near what a nurse makes correct so she used to work like in a hospital on the floor so why would you take a job that pays less when you're trying to hit a financial goal so because of with our three kids the schedule is a lot easier with kids.

The kids are at school.

Instead of working at a 12-hour shift.

Yes.

And so, like I said, we're not trying to jump on like buying a house.

How old are your children?

There are five, two, and then about to be one.

The school nurse doesn't have anything to do with a two- or one-year-old. Correct.
They would have to be in daycare. But our oldest is in kindergarten.
Okay. So the schedule thing is bogus.
It's not true. Well, she'd have summers.
I mean. It's not.
Well, I mean, you can take summers off whenever you want. I mean, you can go three twelves and be done for the week and make three times more than she's going to make while the other two kids sit in daycare so that it's not logical anyway um i think that's a bad choice uh anyway back to your question you're not in a hurry so you can do whatever you want to do and you've done a great job so far with your money.

But I, you know i'm a huge fan of nurses because it gives you the potential to earn a lot of money and work a very very flexible schedule and do a lot of different kinds of things uh and i think you're not getting good use of that opportunity with what we're talking about. But, okay, back to it.
Now, the – I wouldn't pause Baby Step 4. I would keep investing.
You can pause the kids' college, though. If you guys were putting in a certain amount of money every single year for them.
You had a one-year-old and a two-year-old. Yeah, if you want to pause that to save up some extra money.
Well, or just drop it down to 50 bucks or something. I wouldn't stop it i'd drop it way down okay and you use that i really wouldn't because you're not on a uh a tight schedule to buy you don't have an urgency to buy and so i don't want to build up a down payment over here in a high yield savings account while i'm missing out on good mutual fund returns over in my retirement accounts no i'm going to leave that at 15.
Now, if you want to turn up the urgency and you say, okay, in 24 months, we're going to buy a house. If you want to shut it down for that, that's okay.
But just in general, I'm going to just want to build a slush fund so someday I can buy a house. No, I would not do that.
And then I want to add one more thing before I let you go. Like you said, you guys move every three years, and it's going to be a very unusual market that you can buy a house and sell it quickly and make money on it in three years.
Okay, so here's how – I mean, I'll teach you how to do it. I talk to military guys and gals all the time.
I love what you guys do, and thank you for protecting our country. The thing you do when you get ready at your next stop and you think, okay, we got the money, let's buy a house.
What you want to do is you want to look at two different statistics with the local real estate agent. Just go get one of your Ramsey trusted real estate pros off the website at the ELP site, okay, on our website, and ask them two things.
Number one, in the area I'm looking in, within a five-mile radius of the houses I'm looking in in that area, what is the average DOM days on the market? And if it's an average of 27 days, well, you've got a hot market and you'll be able to sell the house. If it's an average of 270 days, that's nine months.
You're going to be stuck with this thing when you move next time. And it's going to end up a rental property in another city.
Bad idea. Okay.
So days on the market. The second thing you want to look for is average appreciation rates in that five mile radius.
For the last five years, four years, what have the houses gone up in this area? If they've gone up 2 a year in three years that's six percent you're going to lose money when you sell this house with commissions and closing costs right okay and but if they go up 10 a year that's going up 30 you're going to make money i will tell you that you will find these two numbers are uh will only appear together

and give you the right answer in other words if you see high appreciation rates you're probably

going to see short days on the market and if you see long days on the market you're probably going

to see low appreciation rates so a low appreciate and so what happens is if the town is a military

only town and the military is the economy you've got a bazillion houses on the market all the time

to What happens is if the town is a military-only town and the military is the economy, you've got a bazillion houses on the market all the time because the people are moving in and out all the time. There's always a glut in the market.
You don't see a lot of appreciation. It's very hard to sell.
You're going to get burned. But if you're in a metro area like you are right now, Virginia Beach is a vibrant economy, separate and apart from the military, heavily influenced by the military, but separate and apart from the military.
It's got its own economy. So that could be one of the markets right there that you could make money on.
San Diego would be a market you could make money on and get in and out if you're military. But if you're in the middle of whatever cornfield and it's all military, you're going to get stuck with the house, dude.
So be careful with careful with that we do talk about renting a lot for families just rent just rent if you're in a market if you're going into the cornfield market or whether if it's not a vibrant market for whatever reason um and you're gonna get stuck at your you're much better off financially to rent for that three-year period of time and your stress levels are way down because if you're buying're buying and you've got to move in, fix up, and you're selling, you've got to move out, fix up. And it's a lot more stress to be an owner than it is to be a renter on the short-term basis.
So that's what we're looking for. So good question, man.
Thank you. And again, thank you for serving your country.
Last thing I'll throw out because I've got just a second is don't use the va loan the va loans suck the veterans administration was formed to be a blessing to veterans and to active duty and they may be in some areas but in the real estate world they're not va loan is more expensive than an fha loan the interest rates are higher and the fees are higher but veterans do it and active duty do it because I can get nothing down. It's one of my benefits.
Well, nothing down is not actually a benefit. It's causing you to buy something you can't afford.
And so don't do the VA. Don't do it.
Do it. You know, do a, do a traditional conventional Fannie Mae mortgage.
Don't do an FHA either. It's the cheapest.
Fannie Mae is the cheapest. a standard conventional mortgage is much cheaper than either one of the the two government programs well there's a shock

and so um you know don't don't fall for that either for those of you that are out there

military so we've done a bazillion hours of work with the military folks and love them and try to

help them any way we can. So thank you guys.
We'll be right back.